COMPARISON OF UTILIZATION OF MATERNAL
SERVICES BY MOTHERS OF ICDS AND NON-ICDS
AREAS IN URBAN SLUMS OF LUCKNOW
Madhu Agarwal
ABSTRACT
Objective: To study the differences in the extent of utilization of maternal services by
the mothers of the ICDS and the non-ICDS areas. Also, to suggest appropriate
strategies for the improvement of available services in both the areas.
Subject and Methods: A sample consisting of 400 households was covered from the Aliganj
ICDS Project (urban) and the non-ICDS slum areas in the neighbourhood of the ICDS Project of
Lucknow district of Uttar Pradesh, having the youngest child withia the age group of a year. Data
obtained was statistically analysed by adopting percentage analysis.
Observations: In the ICDS are, around 79 percent of the mothers had taken special care in
the form of extra food, tonics, extra rest, less hours of work during advanced pregnancy, as
‘compared to around 60 percent mothers in the non-ICDS area. A large proportion of the mothers
had home deliveries, in both the areas {ICDS-59.0 percent, non-ICDS-73.4 percent), but more
deliveries took place in the institutions, in the ICDS as compared fo the non-ICDS area. Largely,
non-institutional deliveries were attended by the untrained personnel, including the traditional
birth attendants, family members or neighbours (ICDS-31 percent, non-ICDS-50.7 percent).
However, higher percentage of mothers in the non-ICDS area received postnatal care by
untrained staff as compared to their counterparts in the ICDS area. Thirty-five percent of children
in the ICDS and 24 percent in the non-ICDS area were fully vaccinated.
Conclusion: it shows that although the level of utilisation of maternal services was by and
Jarge low in-both the areas, but it was slightly better in the ICDS area as compared to the non-
ICDS area. Thus, there is a need for involvement of the community and a strengthened network
of the health services in the urban areas. There is also essential need to strengthen the
knowledge of mothers about the need of antenatal, neonatal and prenatal care in both the areas.
In addition better linkage are to be developed between the AWW, community and health siatf.
Key words: Tetanus Toxoid, iron and Folic Acid, antenatal checkups, traditional bisth
attendants, Anganwadi Worker.
1. 41/110, Society Park, Narahi, Lucknow-226 001
Index Medicus (IMSEAR), INSDOC, NCI Current Content, Database of Alcohol & Drug Abuse, National
Database in TB & Alled Diseases, IndMED, Entered in WHO CD ROM for South East Asia.Madhu Agrawal Comparison of utilization of maternal services by mothers of ICDS & non-ICDS areas
INTRODUCTION {
Heaith of the females is an important factor in determining the overall health of the society.
Malnourished women are more likely to give birth to weaker babies, leading to higher Infant Mortality
Rate. Infant mortality is a sensitive indicator of the quality of maternal and child health services
provided by a country.
During the past two decades, Infant Mortality Rate has improved i.e., IMR has come down
from114 in 1981 to 66 in 2001 (SRS-2003). However, IMR has been stagnating since 1993. The
causes of high rates of infant mortality especially, neonatal mortality are linked to untimely
pregnancies, low birth-rate, pre-term birth, unsafe delivery, neonatal tetanus, high fertility rates, etc,
Pregnancy and childbirth are the leading causes maternal mortality. Majority of the maternal deaths in
pregnancy are due to anaemia, malnutrition, improper birth spacing and common complications of
pregnancy.
Maternity mortality and, the complications related to the pregnancy, are very high in india ie.,
407 women deaths out of 1,00,000 live births (SRS 1998) NFHS-I! results in the State of Uttar
Pradesh show that although almost two, in every five currently married women reported, atleast one
reproductive health problem. This could be symptomatic of a more serious reproductive tract infection.
Three-quarter of these women bear the problem silently without consulting a doctor. These findings
highlight the need to educate women regarding the symptoms and consequences of reproductive
health problems. There is an urgent need to expand counselling and reproductive health services in
both rural and urban areas.
Over the years, Government and non-government organisations have made concerted efforts
to improve the health of women and children. The National Health Policy adopted by the Government
of India in 1982, recognized the high rates of mortality affecting women and children and the extent of
malnutrition and diseases among these groups. It proposed the adoption of a comprehensive primary
healthcare approach, which emphasizes preventive health, improved health awareness and
involvement of the community in all aspects of health-care.
Today, Integrated Child Development Services (ICDS) Scheme is one of the world's largest
and the most unique outreach programme for the care of young children in matters of health, nutrition,
care of pregnant women and lactation. Awareness of mothers regarding the services provided under
the scheme, accessibility and utilization constitute an important strategy in the ICDS Scheme.
Indian J. Prev. Soc. Med Vol. 35 No.3L 4 128 Juby.-Dec., 2004poe FN
HPL a agate ve
Madhu Agrawal Comparison of utilization of maternal services by mothers of ICDS & non-ICDS areas **
However, few researchers have reported that the utilization of health services by the mothers from the
lower socio-economic communities was slightly better in the ICDS areas, as compared to the non-
ICDS areas".
The ICDS Scheme is now poised for a wider expansion. Considering the magnitude of
foreseen expansion, it has become imperative to assess and compare the status of utilization of
maternal services by the mothers in the ICDS Projects vis-a-vis, mothers in the non-ICDS areas. Tus
would go a long way in identifying operational problems in utilizing services by the beneficiaries.
Appropriate strategy could accordingly be suggested for improving the health services. Against this
background, this study was undertaken to compare the extent of utilization of maternal services by
mothers of the ICDS and the non-ICDS areas. The study also, suggested strategies for the
improvement of available health services.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
The present study was carried out in Lucknow district, which is located in the central region of
Uttar Pradesh. From the Lucknow district, Aliganj ICDS Project (urban) that was sanctioned during tie
year 1979, was selected as it is one of the oldest urban blocks in the district. Since, there was no jre-
project information available in the ICDS Project area, so it became imperative to select a non-ICDS
area for the purpose of comparison. A non-iCDS area where, the ICDS was not in operation was
selected in the neighbourhood of the ICDS Project, to compare and study the impact. sites
A two-stage sampling design was adopted. Selection of slums in the first stage and
households in these selected slums in the second stage. Ten slums having Anganwadi centres from
the Aliganj (CDS Project were selected. From each sector, two-three centres were taken randomly in
the ICDS area. Purposive sampling was done to select the households as the study required only
such families which had at least one child aged less than 12 months of age. From each slum, 20
mothers were contacted who had male/female child upto 12 months of age for eliciting ihe
information. A sample consisting of 200 households from the Aliganj ICDS Project and another 200
households from the non-CDS area was taken. In this area also, 200 households from 10 siums
scattered in the different comers of Lucknow city were contacted for data collection. in all, 400
mothers belonging to 20 slums from the ICDS Project and the non-ICDS area, were studied from
different localities of Lucknow city.
Indian J. Prev. Soc. Med Vol 35 No.3L4 129 Suly.Dec., 2004