Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Ex-Hague prosecutor
Alleges Organ Trafficking in Kosovo
13 April 2008
The Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Kosovo reacted on Friday to a letter from Human
Rights Watch where they were asked to investigate the allegations in Carla Del Pontes book
about alleged organ trafficking in the aftermath of the Kosovo war.
Nekibe Kelmendi, currently Minister of Justice and a reputable Kosovar lawyer, told journalists
in Prishtina that allegation about organ trafficking immediately after the war are pure
fabrications made by Del Ponte or perhaps Serbia herself
Kelmendi stresses that she has met with Carla Del Ponte four times and she never mentioned
these allegations to her. If she knew of such cases then she should be charged with withholding
evidence and hiding these crimes, Kelmendi said. Former Chief Prosecutor of Criminal
Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), Carla Del Ponte, published a book in Italian in the
beginning of this month. Many weeks before the book reached Italian bookshops, it was
available for Serbian journalists who chose to publish selective excerpts that mainly dealt with
Kosovo and the Kosovo Liberation Army.
In the book called The Hunt: Me and War Criminals, Carla Del Ponte claims she had received
information saying Kosovo Albanians were involved in organ trafficking. According to Serb
media, the information provided to Del Ponte alleged three hundred Serbs where kidnapped in
Kosovo and then transported to a remote town in Albania where their organs were removed and
sold to wealthy patients around the world. Del Ponte writes that her subordinates gave up this
case because further investigation could not be implemented.
The allegations have already been sharply denied by former Kosovar and Albanian
officials. Ahmet Isufi, a former KLA commander and now deputy leader of the political
party Alliance for the Future of Kosovo, told journalists that no such crimes were carried
out and that he believed these undocumented allegations were nothing more than political.
He was also quoted as saying:
"The case Del Ponte, if we can speak in the softest terms,
is a case that needs psychiatric treatment"
Earlier this week Swiss authorities decided to stop the promotion of the book and ordered Del
Ponte to return as soon as possible to Argentina where she is Swiss ambassador. Swiss officials
said Del Ponte had included within her book information which an official of the Swiss
government should not be allowed to state publicly.
The allegations have caused fierce reactions among Albanians in both Kosovo and Albania.
Most of the reactions emphasize that Albania does not have any hospital where organ
transplantation can be implemented. They also cannot believe that this could have been kept
secret when the information provided suggests tens or even hundreds of people were involved in
this operation.
A commentator from Tirana writes:
"This madness coming from Del Ponte shocks us. The anti-Albanian hate this woman
has been cultivating puts in doubt her independence and objectivity as Chief Persecutor
when it comes to investigating crimes committed in Kosovo"
Commentators are unanimous that Del Ponte used these undocumented allegations as a
gimmick to sell the book, and they all agree that this is going to be used by Serbs to enforce
the victim mentality promoted by current prime minister of Serbia, Vojislav Kostunica.
It is also claimed that Del Ponte, with these undocumented, sensational allegations, wanted
to shift focus from her failures as Chief Prosecutor to the Kosovo Albanians. During her
time at the ICTY, Carla Del Ponte did not manage to bring to justice Serb war criminals
Radovan Karadzic and Ratko Mladic, believed to be the masterminds behind the
Srebrenica massacre where 8 000 Bosnia boys and men were massacred.
The book has also attracted attention in Del Pontes native country, Switzerland. In its Thursday
edition, Neue Zrcher Zeitung reports about the source of these allegations. According to this
Swiss influential newspaper, the allegations are most likely based on an inquiry conducted by a
team of journalists back in 1999. The newspaper claims to know who these journalists are. When
the journalists could not advance further their investigation, they gave up but at the same time
informed ICTY.
Pandeli Majko, Albanian Prime Minister during the Kosovo war, reacted with disbelief while
talking to the newspaper and explained that he never had information about something like this
happening after the war.
The newspaper criticizes Del Ponte for publishing these unproven allegations and goes on with
saying that Del Ponte has created a Frankenstein myth that will circulate in the Balkans for a
long time.
There is scepticism about the accuracy of these claims also among experts on the Balkans
and the ICTY.
Mirko Klarin, an authority on the tribunal and Balkan war crimes at the Institute for War
and Peace Reporting, described Del Ponte's allegations
"as irresponsible and appalling.
...This is more journalistic than prosecutorial.
She shouldn't put rumours in her book".
Serb human rights activist, Natasa Kandic, says
"allegations of organ-smuggling are rumours
I talked to [Del Ponte] many times,
she never told me about this" said Kandic to Daily Telegraph.
http://newkosovareport.com/20080413864/Society/Ex-Hague-prosecutor-alleges-organ-trafficking-in-
Kosovo.html
Natashino "shuskanje" [rumors]
"Nata!a Kandi" had sent the Office of the
Prosecutor a published report indicating that 593
personsSerbs, Montenegrins, Roma, and Slavic
Muslimshad either disappeared or were abducted
after June 12, 1999, the day the NATO-led
international peacekeeping force, KFOR, deployed in
Kosovo, and were still missing on December 31,
2000.
Several aspects of these disappearances were strange, and
suggested that they were not simply acts of post-conflict
vengeance. Most of the disappearances had taken place in
districts where there had been no large-scale violence by
Serbian forces against Kosovo Albanians during the NATO air
campaign.
Dozens of Yugoslav Army soldiers had also
disappeared during the bombing and
contemporaneous fighting against the KLA.
Additionally, more than 1,500 Albanians disappeared
after the KLA had taken them into custody during
the bombing; and more than three hundred Albanians
had disappeared in the second half of 1999 and in
2000" []
Carla Del Ponte [p.204] "Madame Prosecutor
[confrontations with Humanitys Worst criminals and the Culture of impunity]"
by Carla Del Ponte, Chuck Sudetic [2011]
[ili na 3coj strani poglavlja "Confronting Kosovo - 1999 to 2007",
u posebnom PDF-u koji vam shaljem]
From: dr <nula.nemostersterster@gmail.com>
Subject: "Allegations of organ-smuggling are rumours" Serb human rights activist, Natasa Kandic
Date: July 27, 2014 11:23:00 PM GMT+02:00
Probe urged
into 'missing Serbs'
Human Rights Watch has called for an investigation into claims
that ethnic Albanians in Kosovo Abducted and Killed
Serbs, and may have Sold Their Organs.
The claims involve about 400 Serbs who went missing
after the war in 1999.
The rights group says new information has come to light, some of it in a book by former UN war
crimes prosecutor Carla Del Ponte.
But Albanian PM Sali Berisha said the claims were like "an Agatha Christie novel" and had been
investigated.
Kosovo's assembly is due to convene in the coming weeks to discuss whether to sue Ms Del
Ponte for allegedly tarnishing the image of Kosovo.
'Organs removed'
Ms Del Ponte said in her book that she had learned from "credible journalists" that organs were being
sold.
She said the sources had told her that between 100 and 300 mostly Serb civilians
were taken from Kosovo into Albania, where "doctors extracted the captives' "doctors extracted the captives'
internal organs". internal organs".
At the time UN and Nato forces were being deployed to Kosovo as the war between Serbian forces and
separatists was ending.
Human Rights Watch (HRW) said it had reviewed investigations carried out at
the time, and that it believed the allegations that Serbs were abducted were
"serious and credible".
Fred Abrahams, senior emergencies researcher with HRW, called on Kosovo and Albania to "show their
commitment to justice and the rule of law by conducting proper investigations".
He added that the particular Allegations of Organ Trafficking were "suggestive "suggestive
but far from complete" but far from complete".
But Mr Berisha said:
"There has been a clear investigation by both national and international "There has been a clear investigation by both national and international
prosecutors and they have found no evidence." prosecutors and they have found no evidence."
He added:
"Carla Del Ponte never presented an official request to my government on the "Carla Del Ponte never presented an official request to my government on the
matter" matter"
Story from BBC NEWS:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/2/hi/europe/7384679.stm
Published: 2008/05/06
Madame Prosecutor
[confrontations with Humanitys Worst criminals and the Culture of impunity]
by Carla Del Ponte, Chuck Sudetic [2011]
Carla Del Ponte won international recognition as Switzerland's attorney general when she
pursued cases against the Sicilian mafia. In 1999, she answered the United Nations' call to
become the chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia
and for Rwanda. In her new role, Del Ponte confronted genocide and crimes against humanity
head-on, struggling to bring to justice the highest-ranking individuals responsible for massive
acts of violence in Rwanda, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, and Kosovo.
These tribunals have been unprecedented.
They operate along the edge of the divide between national sovereignty and international
responsibility, in the gray zone between the judicial and the political, a largely unexplored realm
for prosecutors and judges. It is a realm whose native inhabitantspolitical leaders and
diplomats, soldiers and spiesassume that they can commit the big crime without being held
culpable. It is a realm crisscrossed by what Del Ponte calls the muro di gomma"the wall of
rubber"a metaphor referring to the tactics government officials use to hide their unwillingness
to confront the culture of impunity that has allowed persons responsible for acts of
unspeakable, wholesale violence to escape accountability.
Madame Prosecutor is Del Ponte's courageous and startling memoir of her eight years spent
striving to serve justice.