Cook's Illustrated

Homemade Mayo That Keeps

If you’ve eaten homemade mayonnaise, you know that its custardy richness and delicate tang are clean and clear in a way the commercial stuff just isn’t. It lights up anything it touches—from egg or potato salad to lobster rolls to boiled artichokes to green goddess dressing—and is the only condiment worth slathering onto a BLT or high-summer tomato sandwich. It’s the preparation President Calvin Coolidge waxed nostalgic about (his Aunt Mary’s, specifically) to the Spokesman-Review and one that fascinated—and often stymied—Julia Child. British food writer Elizabeth David urged her readers to make “plenty of it” when hosting guests, since “this beautiful golden ointment-like sauce is really the pivot and raison d’être of the whole affair.”

Homemade mayo lights up anything it touches—from egg or potato salad to a BLT.

There are practical perks, too: Making a batch takes minutes, most of the work can be done in a food processor, and there’s a good chance you have all the ingredients (eggs,

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from Cook's Illustrated

Cook's Illustrated8 min read
The Fruit-Lover’s Cream Cake
This is the story of two cakes that have long been beloved in East Asian baking traditions—and how I merged those traditions into an airy, downy-soft, cream- and fruit-festooned marvel that’s perfect for any celebration. The first is one many will im
Cook's Illustrated5 min read
The Cool Comfort of Sesame Noodles
Every twirl of liang mian manages to be both refreshing and hearty. The cold, lightly chewy noodles coated in a dark, earthy majiang (sesame paste) sauce are edged with satisfying sweetness, heat, and tang. In China and Taiwan, the chilled, glossy st
Cook's Illustrated4 min read
No-Commitment Refrigerator Preserves
Refrigerator jams and jellies are gateway preserves: quick, easy, attractive ways to bottle up peak-season produce at its best. The formulas are basic (fruit, sugar, lemon juice); the batches are typically small, so there’s no need to invest in bushe

Related