Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
• Published version:
‘love’
Problems with meanings of
verbal signs
1. Polysemy
2. Circularity
3. Liquidity
Polysemy
house
1. a building which people, usually one family, live in
Metonymy:
WORDS STAND FOR LINGUISTIC EXPRESSIONS
COMMUNICATION IS
SENDING
It is hard to get that idea across to him.
I gave you that idea.
Your reasons came through to us.
Fling/sling/throw mud at someone.
Hurl curses at someone.
THOUGHTS (IDEAS) ARE
MATERIAL OBJECTS
When you have a good idea try to capture it
immediately in words.
It is difficult to reconstruct his thoughts.
Your thoughts will leak out anyway.
His ideas are a disorderly heap.
MINDS ARE CONTAINERS
His mind is full of ideas.
How can one be so empty-headed?
Go in through one ear and go out through
another.
WORDS ARE CONTAINERS
Words stand for linguistics expressions
It’s difficult to put my ideas into words.
The meaning is right there in the words.
You can’t simply stuff ideas into a sentence.
This text is without meaning.
Some metalinguistic concepts
E C W
E= entity
C= concept (thought)
W= word (linguistic expression)
Entity = an element of anything that IS in
whatever reality (physical and/or mental)
Semiotics and semantics
• Semiotics (semiology, semasiology) deals
with all possible elements and relations
between these elements in E, C and W
(”meaning” tout court).
• Semantics, more specifically, focuses on C
and W (”linguistic meaning”).
Ontological differences
Entities – any conceivable domain
Concepts – mental domain
Words – language/speech domain (mental
and physical)
Notational conventions
<dog> as an entity (real or imagined)
”dog” as a concept
‘dog’ as a word (linguistic expression)
dog/dogs as words (linguistic forms)
:dog/dogs: as words used in an actual speech
act
Concepts: three kinds of sets
Finite
Nondenumerably infinite
Denumerably infinite
Finite sets
Formal (synthetic) concepts – products of
human mind. Examples: geometrical
figures; mathematical constructs; logical
relations.
Delimited by definitions
Denumerably infinite sets
Categories of (analytic) concepts ”abstracted”
through human experience.
Examples: all concepts based on repeated experience
generalised as categories, such as common nouns
and noun phrases as well as verbs in any language.