Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
MUHAMMAD WASIE
FASIH BUTT
WAHI—Two Types
Action
Approval
HADITH & SUNNAH
Means: every narration related Means: model behavior of
to the prophet (sallahu alaihe prophet (sallahu alaihe
wasallam) wasallam)
Hades may be abrogated, e.g.: SUNNAH don’t contain any
praying towards the BAITUL
abrogated HADITH.
MAQDAS( bukhari:399)
The narration can be regarding
urgency arrived. e.g. relaxing SUNNAH is applicable for
while standing(bukhari:224) all times
Narration may be confine to the
prophet (sallahu alaihe Ummati can follow every
wasallam) only. e.g. nine wives
SUNNAH
Authority Of SUNNAH
Proficiency in the Arabic language alone cannot help us
grasp the meaning of the Qur’an. Remember, the shaba
(raziallahu anhum), who spoke fluent Arabic, always
turned to the Blessed Prophet (sallahu alaihe wasallam) to
understand the deeper meanings of the Qur’an. Event of
Hazrat ADI BIN HATIM (raziallahu anhu) related to ayat
of sehri.
If we know the Qur’an and its place, it is only because the
Blessed Prophet (sallahu alaihe wasallam) said, “This is the
Qur’an; it is the word of Allah” If we were to reject this
hadīth then the whole foundation of Islam collapses.
Authority Of SUNNAH(cont’d)
Allah says to the Prophet (sallahu alaihe wasallam)
• “And We have sent unto you the message, that you may
explain clearly to men what is sent for them.”(16:44)
• This ayah proves that the fundamental role of prophet
(sallahu alaihe wasallam) is to reveal the meaning of the
Qur’an, which means that the Qur’an cannot be
understood without the prophet (sallahu alaihe wasallam).
Following ayah points towards an event, which could not
be understand without SUNNAH.
• “And (He relented) towards the three whose matter was
deferred” (al tauba:118)
Arguments Against
The Preservation Of Hadith
John Esposito notes that "Modern
Western scholarship has seriously
questioned the Preservation Of the
hadith", maintaining that "the bulk of
traditions attributed to the Prophet
Muhammad were actually written much
later.”(The Oxford History of Islam, edited by John L.
Esposito,pp:685)
2-Hasan
1-Sahih
through an through an
unbroken chain of unbroken chain of
narrators all of narrators all of
whom are of sound whom are of sound
character and character but weak
memory. Such a memory. This
hadith should not hadith should not
clash with a more clash with a more
reliable report and reliable report and
must not suffer must not suffer
from any other from any other
hidden defect hidden defect
3-Dai’f 4-Mawdu
Which cannot gain the status of • Fabricated and wrongly
hasan because it lacks one or more
elements of a hasan hadith. ascribed to Prophet
• if the narrator is not of sound
Muhammad
memory and sound character, • Example: "Seek
• or if there is a hidden fault in the knowledge even you have
narrative
• or if the chain of narrators is
to go to China.“
broken
• Da‘if Ahadith are acceptable in
fadai’il (general good deeds),
Leanings
1. Dha‘īf( weak) is also HADITH, denying every
Dha‘īf( weak) HADITH will lead to denial of all
HADITH itself.
2. weakness of HADITH can be compensated by other
supports, so should not blame any jurisprudence
without complete study.
3. Authenticity check must be done before forwarding
any HADITH., since forwarding fake HADITH is a
great sin
Compilers of Sihah Sittah
Sahih Bukhari—Muhammad bin Ismail Bukhari [194-256 A.H]
7,000 approx. out of 600,000
Sahih Muslim—Muslim bin Hajjaj [204-264 A.H]
12,000 approx. out of 300,000
Sunan Abu Dawood—Sulaiman bin Shoaib [202-275 A.H]
5000 approx. out 500,000
Sunan Tirmizi—Muhammad bin Esa [209-279 A.H]
4,000 approx.
Sunan Nasai—Ahmed bin Shoaib [210-303 A.H]
5,500 approx.
Sunan Ibne Majah—Muhammad bin Yazid [209-273]
4,000 approx.
Do BUKHĀRY And MUSLIM Contain
All The Authentic HADITHs?
It is like saying that “instead of following the whole
Qur’an; let’s just follow the twenty fourth chapter.”
there are many authentic HADITHs besides the
HADITHs of BUKHĀRY and MUSLIM.
Imam BUKHĀRY himself wrote: “I have only put
authentic HADITHs in my book, but also left many
authentic HADITHs for fear of the book becoming too
drawn-out.”(Siyar I‘lam al-Nubala, 12/402)
One must remain alert about the attacks on Hadith by
orientalists, secularists or Islamophobes