Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Journey Mapping
Expanded toolkit
DIAGNOSTIC QUESTIONS
BUILDING UNDERSTANDING
THROUGHOUT A PROJECT
Engage Identify
Customer Develop Carry out Identify Plan
hearts ways to
Experienc initial gap ways to actions, Design
and improve Put
e custome analysis improve based on and
minds of efficiency together
mapping r insight – where experienc a clear impleme Use this tool to
staff / cut the
does the e (cross knowledg nt an
Clearly current silos)
costs
e of
business
entirely help identify the
without case, sell
Mapping define system without
damagin numbers new type of journey
differ damagin the
the the of people system mapping that
g project
System current from the g affected, using
system ideal? efficiency
customer
and
internally.
quantifie could help you at
s
quantifie d under- Measure different points in
Measurin Impleme
d costs of standing progress a the lifecycle of a
g the nt the
acting or from on an
Experienc not
plan
mapping project.
ongoing
e acting basis
Different types of mapping build a picture as a project moves on. Customer
experience mapping brings the story to life and delivers insight. A comparison
with the existing process can identify where improvements can be made. This
can be quantified to make business decisions, and success can be judged by
measuring and tracking on an ongoing basis.
LEVEL OF INTEREST
Develop Design a
Map Implement
Stakeholder Stakeholder
Stakeholders and monitor
insight strategy
SMART OBJECTIVES
SOURCES OF UNDERSTANDING
Environmental
Political
Databases
This helps you to
Economic Syndicated Data think of all the
Technical places you might
Social Studies think about when
Social looking to learn
Surveys more about your
Legislative issue. All of these
can help you
Consultation Sessions better understand
Focus Groups
your customer’s
Meeting Real People journey.
Quantitative Studies
Intermediary Feedback
Segmentation Studies
Behaviour & Attitude
People Observation
Interviews Listening-in
Think deeply about what sub- Quant costs are based on 5 variables: 1. Think deeply about what sub-
number of people in the sample. 2.
groups you want to analyse and Questionnaire length/ time. 3. Interviews groups you want to analyse and
make sure the sample size will achieved per hour 4. Method: On-line make sure the sample size will
[cheaper], phone, or face-to-face [most
deliver a statistically significant costly]. Ask for these to be spelt out 5. deliver a statistically significant
result for each sub-group Whether we provide lists – if so less time is result for each sub-group
needed for screening the customer sample.
IN-HOUSE OR AGENCY?
In-House Agency
In House
Establish
research
Select Identify
need
and insights
and
choose
brief and Use this tool when
agency Draw up actions
approac into
you are working
h Specify
Design Heart with an agency to
sample, Monitor guide the
question
method, or other
cost
-naire
output
sequence of
Analyse events and help
formats
data
Conduct
(statistic
Produce decide where
fieldwor data
k
al
tables
responsibilities
modellin lie.
g)
Agency
• What you would need to tell someone who knew nothing about this in order
Subject
for them to understand what you’re talking about?
Objectives,
• As laid down when you set Customer • As laid down when you
scope and
out your maps segment set out your maps
journey type
• What’s the overall challenge (as defined at the start of the project)?
What issues • Where do you believe the problems lie (based on your initial qualitative
are you mapping)?
looking to • Why are you doing this research – what are the key triggers (policy change, Use this tool when
resolve? customer dissatisfaction, operational issues, cost issues etc)? you are working
• What are the specific issues you need to address?
with an outside
• What critical questions do you need the research to answer? agency to help
• What exactly will you do with the results? brief them on your
Why is this • What benefits will result, to you and to the customer, if your project is project. You can
important? successful?
• How might the customer experience be improved?
also use it to brief
• Are there any mandatory requirements that you have to deliver on? an in-house
• Identify the journey steps and moments of truth as you currently understand research team.
them
• What budget is available for this work?
Practicalities • When do you need the results?
• Are there any immovable deadlines?
• Are there any issues that might cause problems or delays?
• In what format would you like the results to be delivered?
SEGMENTATION DEFINITION
Segmentation is . . .
“The sub-dividing of people with distinctive shared needs
and characteristics into reachable groups based on 3
dimensions - who they are, what they do, how they think
and feel”
Hold a scoping work Develop the Research Brief: Find the best segment Share, spread results;
session: User needs solution & number: get segmentation used:
Why we’re segmenting Produce brief and tender Integrate data sets Share segmentation with
What we want to do better Commission research Apply statistical everyone who can use it-
as a result Detailed method
techniques allocate resources to
Any stakeholder views on Specify sample/special
Make solution actionable priority segments
segmentation groups
Questionnaire design Identify ‘discriminating Apply to policy, delivery
What key departments need
variables’ and comms
1 3 5 7
Leverage
Project Specify Inspiration This tool explains
Segmentati
Definition Research al Analysis the steps taken in
on
a full, bespoke
segmentation
study.
2 6 8
‘Know 4 Segment Track &
what we Fieldwork
Immersion Monitor
know’
3. BASED ON HOW
1. BASED ON WHAT 2. BASED ON WHO
PEOPLE THINK AND
PEOPLE DO PEOPLE ARE
FEEL
Behaviour/ ‘mode’ Socio-demographic Attitudes
Use & Behaviour, e.g. Demographics, e.g. Needs, Benefits, Motivations, e.g.
Frequency Need convenience, need reliability, need
Place Gender
support etc.
Time Ethnicity Beliefs, desires, wants
Occasion
Extent of use e.g. heavy, light
Family Deep-seated drivers e.g. love, belonging,
Persistency e.g. loyal Age and life stage praise, security
Channels used for contact Household type/ composition Loves & hates
segment
customers.
4. A COMBINATION
OF MANY FACTORS
Multi-factorial
3. BASED ON HOW
1. BASED ON WHAT 2. BASED ON WHO
PEOPLE THINK AND
PEOPLE DO PEOPLE ARE
FEEL
Behaviour/ ‘mode’ Socio-demographic Attitudes
Use & Behaviour, e.g. Needs, Benefits, Motivations, e.g.
Frequency Need convenience, need reliability, need
Place Turnover of business support etc.
Time Beliefs, desires, wants
Occasion Number of employees Loves & hates
Extent of use e.g. heavy, light Market sector Attitudes & Beliefs, e.g.
Persistency e.g. loyal
Area of business activity In general
Activities, e.g. Government specific e.g. to our brands,
Membership of trade bodies Level of profitability services Use this tool as a
Lobbying activities Geographical location To value and money
How profits are distributed
Number of sites/locations Influencers e.g. quick guide to
Media Consumption e.g.
Where most info comes from Private or limited Authority figures, e.g. police, tax
inspectors some of the
Community influences
common factors
Internet and digital usage
How information is processed Key shareholders
Access to media Media
you can use to
segment
customers.
4. A COMBINATION
OF MANY FACTORS
Multi-factorial
Rational or functional needs. and What drives and triggers action? Barriers help bring the
emotional or hidden needs? Who to doing? History, place of doing? How customer to life.
experience ‘most’ & ‘least’? Why the frequently? Signals of things working? Work with a team
differences? to build a picture
of your customer,
PASSION POINTS BELIEFS AND ATTITUDES focusing on what
In this area, loves and hates? Thoughts, beliefs, attitudes to this? really defines this
What pleases? What disappoints? What makes them feel good? Bad? particular group.
“Must haves’’? Key words and Why?
language people use? Reasons for doing or not doing?
Place, time How much Where they When & Who they Who
& how they info they get it from- where do/ don’t delivers
get info want Media used they’re most listen to & for them?
receptive? respect
Listen in at
Call Centres
Observe People
people from a videoing or
distance web cam
Some thoughts on
Shadow your Read how you might get
customers letters or closer to your
during an e-mails from target customers.
average day people
• Trawling existing research • Brief research department as for • Treat as standard research project
• Utilising front line staff / any research project • Remit to agreed specification
knowledgeable managers • They will recruit specified • Agree number and scope of
• Examining call centre data / customers who can be interviewed research
customer complaint data or followed through a journey • Attend agency brief and
• Questioning stakeholders • Any (briefed) staff member can be subsequent debrief of results. Use this tool when
• Role playing involved in the interviewing process
thinking
PRO’S PRO’S PRO’S specifically about
• Harness existing expertise • First hand feedback from • New thinking customer
• Quick, cheap, easy to implement customers • Agency provide the resource closeness
• Engaging, involves staff • Truly engage those who need to • Independence, objectivity, research, to help
• Strong ownership implement credibility
• All benefits of DIY • Honed skills, approaches and
decide whether to
techniques do it yourself or
via an agency.
CON’S CON’S CON’S
• Less robust / objective • Slightly more expensive • Cost
• We don’t know what we don’t • Takes a bit longer • Timing
know • Need skills and confidence • Lack of engagement (esp. front
• Less credible internally line staff)
• Abdicates responsibility
Can combine…
QUESTIONING SKILLS
LISTENING SKILLS
Preparing the next question and Countering with verbal thrusts of your
Rehearsing missing the present answer Duelling own
Objectives,
Customer
scope &
segment
journey type
Moments
of truth
Use this tool to
Key journey
Key Journey record the
stepsSteps thoughts, feelings
and actions of a
customer at every
stage in their
journey, recording
Actions,
feelings, all the key
thoughts and information from
reactions at research you have
each step
carried out.
Touchpoints
HEART MONITOR
Objectives,
Customer
scope &
segment
journey type
Moments
of truth
Use this tool to
Key journey
Key Journey record the highs
stepsSteps
and lows of the
customer
experience
throughout their
Ups and journey, to
downs of express it in a
the visual way that
customer
experienc clearly identifies
e problem areas.
Levers for
solution
hunting
Step 1: Now you have carried out your in-depth mapping event, review
Confirm the the work of the set-up phase to confirm type of journey (with start
journey and and end points) and customer segments
customer Ensure definitions of these are clear and that everyone has a
common understanding of them
Step 2: Start by noting down all the journey steps people go through. It’s
useful to put these on Post-it notes so they can be moved around
Use this tool to
Identify key guide you through
journey steps
Arrange these in chronological order and challenge to make sure
you’ve got the sequence right. Ideally you want to map around 6- all the steps in
10 key journey steps building your
Ensure you’re clear which channels people use at each step
customer
For each step, and taking the customer’s viewpoint, write experience map.
Step 3:
down what they do and how they think and feel
Actions, Write this in the everyday language customers use – put it in their Full details are
feelings, own actual words where possible given in
thoughts and Say what people’s emotions are and how strongly they’re felt
reactions
“Customer Journey
Use emotive words – they help bring people to life
Mapping:
Step 4: Again, for each step in the journey, write down what the Guidance for
Touchpoints touchpoints are. A touchpoint is a point in the process where you Practitioners”.
have some sort of interaction with the customer
Think about physical interactions (e.g. buildings), human contact
(face to face or remote) and communications
Step 5: Now, looking at the whole journey, identify the moments of truth
Moments of These are the key points in the journey where customers may
truth pause and evaluate the experience, or make a crucial decision
Aim to be discriminating here – don’t be tempted to label every
step as a moment of truth!
1.Preparation is vital
This is not a play it by ear kind of thing. The format
Pre-work for you may be loose but the thinking has to be very light.
Sort every detail out in advance, from toilets to tea
breaks, stimulus to stationary
Clarify specific objectives and deliverables 2.Think it through stage by stage
Look at the workshop from start to finish. Consider
Identify participants who will help deliver how you’ll break the ice, get people involved, build
these momentum, sustain it. Think about what success
looks like at every stage in the day
Decide whether to use professional 3.Brief pre-work and incentivise delivery
facilitation or do this yourself Maximise the time you have during the session by
getting participants to prepare before the event.
Set data, locate venue and plan logistics Provide an incentive to encourage participation and
send out reminders/expectations
Invite participants and inform other
stakeholders
4.Be prepared for energy drops and silence This tool gives
Be ready with ideas, anecdotes and techniques to
keep us the pace and momentum
some general
Plan agenda, inputs and specific outputs
5.You’re on show workshop tips and
Send out pre-work to participants How you look and act will have a direct impact on hints that are
how the workshop participants respond. Prepare for
useful for
Pre-work for this, look and act to get the response you want
whatever type of
6.Understand why they’re there
participants An escape from the office? For a genuine learning workshop you
experience? To be politically correct? Bear this in
mind, but also let them know why you want them
might be running.
Could involve one or more of the following: there
Review all materials relating to core 7.Send In The Clowns…
We are more likely to input when we are relaxed, and
customer segments humour can go a long way to helping that happen.
Create customer pen-portraits It’s not about a floor show, but keep it light and fun
8.Back To Reality
Confirm the journey to be mapped, Ensure everyone stays connected with the objective,
including start and end points to understand the journeys our customers take and
the experience they go through. We’re talking reality
Identify key channels of interaction and here, not what it could or should be
communication 9.Relinquish Control
Have the courage to let things go, hand over the
Take part in customer closeness activity to reins during the day and allow participants to take
build extra understanding control over the direction of the event if appropriate
10.Homeward Bound
Send everyone off on a high, review progress, give
© Oxford Strategic Marketing thanks, involve in next stages
EXPERIENCE MAPPING: WORKSHOP
AGENDA
End-to-
Objectives
end Customer
/
system segment
scope
definition
Agency Step 3c
Critical Critical
incident incident
MAPPING DEPENDENCIES
The simplest kind, Where two parties Where two parties Where one party can
where one party are involved in repeat the same change the process
depends on another activities at the handover on a by opting out.
completing a task same time, and both number of
before they can must finish before occasions.
begin their activity. the next step can
take place.
Use this tool to
understand the
type of
dependencies that
are recognised in
system mapping,
Assemble and how and when
Look at cake Plan food for
ingredients for
Bake cake cake
recipes the day to use them.
OUTLINE AGENDA
For a full day workshop
Introduction and ice breaker 15 mins
Setting the context 30 mins
Project background and system mapping principles
Objectives for today
Is the route through the system clear to customers? Are there points
where they’re unsure where to go next? Use this tool when
Complexity Are they having to do the same thing more than once?
Are they clear where responsibility lies at each step in the process?
you are building a
Are badly-designed forms or other materials causing delays? system map to
look at where
How long does the whole process take now?
problems arise or
How long does each step take? where there are
Time
taken
Are people satisfied with the overall timespan and with time taken for opportunities to
individual steps?
Where do delays occur and why?
improve a system
or process. It is
one of four such
Where and when are people coming into this system? Are they coming
in at the right points?
lists (slides 56 to
Accessibility Once in the system, is signposting clear? 59). There are
Does the customer see consistent branding? corresponding
Are you offering appropriate channels?
checklists looking
at specific actions
What’s pleasant/unpleasant about the experience now (customer that might be
Nature of experience mapping can help here if you don’t know) taken (slides 65 to
experience What are the real turn-off points? 68).
Where are you losing people?
What’s the direct cost to government at each step in the process? Use this tool when
Where are costs particularly high? you are building a
Overt system map to
Are some channels especially expensive?
costs look at where
Are there avoidable contacts?
Are some customers particularly costly? problems arise or
where there are
opportunities to
improve a system
or process. It is
one of four such
Where might there be hidden costs associated, for example, with lists (slides 56 to
Hidden
costs
reworking, partner costs or costs not directly incurred by your 59). There are
department? corresponding
checklists looking
at specific actions
that might be
taken (slides 65 to
68).
Where are high costs adversely affecting the level of service delivered
Impact to the customer?
of costs
Where are you incurring cost that’s failing to deliver any value to
customers?
Are you making assumptions about the way things should be done Use this tool when
based on what’s always gone before?
Assumptions you are building a
Are steps really adding value?
Are decision-points really necessary? system map to
look at where
problems arise or
What parts of the system have been around for a long time without where there are
review or overhaul? opportunities to
Inertia Where have steps proliferated because something’s been tacked on to
an old system rather than rethinking the whole thing? improve a system
or process. It is
one of four such
lists (slides 56 to
Where are the touchpoints with other government systems or
Perspective processes? Have you reflected all of these? 59). There are
Do you understand the impact on the customer? corresponding
checklists looking
at specific actions
that might be
Are there points where you’re delivering the same service to everyone,
although not everyone needs the full process? taken (slides 65 to
Choices Do you know what the cost/benefit balance is for different customer 68).
types?
HEART MONITOR
Objectives,
Customer
scope &
segment
journey type
Moments
of truth
Key journey
Key Journey
stepsSteps
Use this tool to
plot quantitative
Great
+100
data on how
customers think
and feel at each
Customer step of the
Satisfacti journey, based on
on Rating research
information.
-100
Poor
Levers for
solution
hunting
Your research study should provide you with a list of the factors that
will result in an improved customer experience, but it may be quite
long. You need to uncover the key drivers, those we call the moments
of truth.
Key Driver Analysis uses statistical modeling to isolate these
important factors. You’ll need to get experts involved in this bit. The
output can be presented in a user-friendly format that can
communicate the findings and the necessary actions to all staff,
whatever their prior knowledge or experience.
Use this tool when
you reach Step 3
You can bring the moments of truth to life by exploring them further in the process of
through qualitative research. This can also examine the issues in constructing a
more detail to get to the route cause of the dissatisfaction. For
example, customers may be unhappy with the Call Centre response,
heart monitor to
but it may be the connection process rather than the staff dialogue help you plot
that is driving concern. moments of truth.
Verbatim comments from customers can also illustrate the findings in
a more powerful way than charts or numbers. They can get to the
‘heart of the matter’, key for this kind of measurement.
Are there particular steps (and particular customer groups) you should
focus on?
Make it How can you minimise the number of contacts you require customers
cheaper to make?
How can you use channels more effectively to manage costs for the
customer?
CHECKLIST 2:
IMPROVING EFFICIENCY
Use this tool when
Which steps cause most delays and/or are the priorities to be speeded you have built
up? your map or maps
Save time How can you clear bottlenecks?
Where can you combine or eliminate steps to speed up the process? to look at where
Can tasks be automated? Which ones? there are
How can you eliminate repeated steps? opportunities to
Can you link systems to avoid multiple data entry? take action. It is
Remove Can you put in failsafe procedures to avoid the need for double-
duplication checking? one of four such
How can you ensure paper records don’t simply duplicate electronic lists (slides 65 to
ones? 68). These
Can you remove any steps to smooth out ‘dog legs’ & make a simple
path through?
checklists
Reduce correspond to the
Is all the data you collect really needed? Who uses it and how?
complexity What’s the simplest route from start to finish? Can you apply this to
earlier ones that
everyone? If so, how?
were focused on
Can you put in failsafe mechanisms to prevent errors occurring? the initial
Reduce
What would help reduce errors? Better staff training? Simpler forms? identification of
More help?
errors Could you reduce errors by putting sanctions in place if correct problems and
procedures aren’t followed? opportunities.
(slides 56 to 59).
How might you better clarify/formalise responsibilities?
Clarify How can you clearly specify ownership of customers, data, decisions?
responsibilities How can you work more closely with other departments or agencies to
ensure smooth ‘baton-changes’?
TAKING ACTION
Actual
Identify most appropriate times and ways to deliver
A literal, physical journey;
information & messages
e.g. prisoners being taken
Improve the environment at key points
from court to prison
Train staff to recognise and respond to moments of truth
Transactional
Establish new channels so that customers can access Plan and
Going through a process with
government more easily and efficiently (re)allocat
fixed steps, e.g. applying for
Look for ways of reducing journey times
free school meals e Use this tool to
Remove duplication from the process resources
to focus
help your thinking
Experiential Build staff engagement and empathy for customers on areas about potential
An ongoing experience of a Encourage cross-silo working to deliver a consistent of actions. Can you
service or linked services, customer experience greatest
e.g. using the Health Service
Find ways increase patient engagement through improved
need
learn anything
communication from the sort of
Plan resources around times of peak demand
Set examples given
Emotional Identify priority customer groups who need most help performa
A ‘mental’ journey that is Train staff to know when to intervene and when to stand nce
here?
experienced over time e.g. back
going through a separation indicators
Change systems to reduce demand on customers at times and
and making arrangements for
children of greatest emotional stress standards
Establish ongoing communication channels with low cost to so that
Relationship Building
The development of a serve change
relationship with government Identify times when customers will and won’t welcome over time
over time; e.g. a business contact from you can be
customer working Segment customers according to the stage they’ve reached measured
government to grow a in their relationship with you
business Link systems to reduce need for multiple contacts from the
Rite of Passage
A major life change or customer
lifestage event that can cut Focus resource on ‘baton-change’ points where customers
across many parts of can be lost
government, e.g. Train staff so they understand their role vis a vis that of
bereavement other departments
ongoing) between different
Cost Time cost types of action
People cost
that you might
Other resource
Level of risk take.
Low
Step 1 Step 3
Now score each idea against each criteria (so for
Open the spreadsheet by double idea A fill in cells C3 to C15). The maximum score
clicking twice on the table on the for each idea against a criteria would by 100% of
bottom right and then maximising its weighting – so if the weighting was 20 an idea
it. This will take you into Excel so that was perfect in that respect would score 20, an
that you can work on the sheet (you idea that failed completely in that respect would
need to be in Powerpoint ‘normal score 0. Score each idea against all criteria. Try
view’ to do this). Look at the not to give similar marks to everything – by giving This tool can be
criteria for assessing potential a wide range of marks you’ll see clearer used where you
benefit of each idea (cells A3 to A8) differences between the idea. Enter the numbers
and decide whether these are
have qualified
into the spreadsheet and this will automatically data, to help
relevant to you, or whether you plot the results. Click on the ‘bubble chart’ or ‘bar
would like to change these. You chart’ tabs at the bottom of the page for charts assess the
don’t have to have 5 criteria – showing the results. potential of your
anything up to 6 is fine. Type in any different action
new or different criteria. Do the
same for cost (cells A10 to A15).
ideas and decide
which ones to take
forward.
Step 2
Now decide, for ‘potential benefit’
how important each criteria is. In
cells B3 to B8, allocate a weighting
to your criteria so the total adds up
to 100. So, if you had five criteria
and they were all equally important
you would give them all a weighting
of 20. But if one criterion were as
important as everything else
combined, you’d give it a weighting
of 50. Go through the same process
for cost (cells B10 to B15).
© Oxford Strategic Marketing
EVALUATION CHECKLIST
EVALUATION CHECKLIST