Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Qualitative
Data
Analysis
2017
Marketing & Strategy
Marketing Communications & Advertising
Schedule Group 1 PR & Corporate Communications
Quantitative Research
in-lab test methods
2-5 BS1021 starts
Schedule Group 2 Marketing & Brand Management
Close immersion in
the subject
Assessment closely follows learning
Lectures followed by workshops
Exercises and puzzles
Heavy emphasis on practice / application
Learning by doing
Study the technique, then apply it
Don’t be afraid of getting it wrong….
Structure of the slides and
agenda for the sessions
Positivist vs interpretivist
Deduction / induction
* http://quoteinvestigator.com/2010/05/26/everything-counts-einstein/
Q. What is qualitative research
A.
What it is and what it is not is
by no means straightforward
(Bryman & Bell, 2011)
“When you move into your own home, you’re alone. There is no bustle of
people around the house. I miss having someone to chat to when I get home. I
put the TV or some music so there’s some background noise, the silence
makes me feel so alone. Sometimes I will be sat watching trash TV and thinking
I should be out doing something rather than watching this rubbish.
I read a lot but sometimes I am too tired and just want to veg out. But it’s been
good to move out of mum and dad’s as its not healthy to rely on them as they
won’t last forever.
I wanted to become independent and make my own decisions. It’s good they
still are there when I need them. It’s good to have some distance as when I was
at home I was arguing a lot with my dad and that was what made me decide it
was time to go”
To sum up – qualitative analysis is...
Stages of data
analysis
Stages of qualitative analysis
Data
assembly
• Based on Miles and Data
collection
Huberman (1994)
Conclusion
Data drawing Data
display and preparation
verification
Data
reduction
• Transcription hints
– Don’t tidy-up the language. Punctuation is likely to be important.
– Highlight key excerpts; include comments for later analysis
– Add the time at intervals
– Use generous margins for manual coding
– Put interviewer name/questions in different font/colour
Data Data Data Data Conclusion/
collection preparation reduction display Verification
Some useful examples shown in Verdinelli and Scagnoli (2013) – see StudySpace
Category Sub-category Conceptual label
Health related
Basic needs
Pornography
Alcohol
Tobacco
Armaments
People Gambling
Animals As food
As clothing
3rd World
People Employment
Pollution
Investment Process Environment Efficient use of materials
screened by: Sustainable materials
Openness
Political donations
Philosophy Community relations
Charitable donations
Repressive regimes
Data Data Data Data Conclusion/
collection preparation reduction display Verification
• Conclusion drawing
– Intertwined with the data display stage – an iterative process
– The researcher seeks to find patterns and associations in the
data and to interpret the meanings underlying these
– The aim is to use this understanding to draw conclusions about
what is ‘going on’ in the data and offer explanations that answer
the research question – how or why did the phenomena take the
form it did?
• “No ready-made solutions available for integrating the data
….the literature does not tell us much about this analytic stage,
probably because this phase of the investigation is unique ...and
bound to the specific research project.” (Boeije, 2010)
Focus on Data
Reduction stage –
Open and Axial
coding
Stages of qualitative analysis
Data
assembly
• Based on Miles and Data
collection
Huberman (1994)
Conclusion
Data drawing Data
display and preparation
verification
Data
reduction
Phase At the beginning of the project Halfway through End of the project
Activities Reading and re-reading (close Retrieve and compare fragments Determine core concept(s)
reading); asking questions assigned to a certain code; and their relationships; write
about the data; comparing the determine relationships; add, up findings in relation to
data; assigning codes to data refine and check ideas with literature; draw conclusions
fragments newly added data
Starting Raw data Codes developed during open All of the research material
point coding
Results List of codes (the coding Categories and sub-categories Coherent story that clarifies
frame); memos are described and distinctions relationships between
between them are made concepts and provides
answers to the research
question(s)
Validation Saturation, i.e. no new codes Saturation, i.e. the definition of Saturation, i.e. new data fit
are needed the categories is clear the model
Typically you will have some codes in mind (deductive) and will also
be looking for other ideas that arise from the data (inductive)
Coding is more than just writing down words in the margin – it is
where ‘doing’ and ‘thinking’ converge
When coding, ask yourself questions:
What is going on here?
What is this about?
What is the problem?
What are people doing?
What is the person saying, or trying to say?
What else can they mean?
What kind of experience is represented here?
Constant comparison – guides the
process of coding and analysis
Each time you select a passage of text for coding, you should compare it
with all the passages you have already coded that way, both within and
between cases
Ensures that your coding is consistent and allows you to consider whether
the coding is appropriate (fits well enough) or whether different codes are
needed
Helps to avoid definitional drift, where the use of a code shifts as analysis
progresses and later coding represents a different concept from that used at
the start
Usually a sign that there is a need for a new code – the coded text can be split
between the existing and the new codes.
Constant comparison also involves looking for variations and differences
across cases, settings or factors which affect the phenomena that are being
studied, e.g. the influence of age and gender.
Applying new codes
A code book (coding scheme; code frame; code list) is a list of all
the codes you have constructed, including a short definition of each
and a locator (where the code can be found in the text)
As you code, check against the list to see if an existing code can be
used, or whether a new code needs to be developed
Eventually you will have a very long list!
Emerging need to order and categorise the codes
Missing codes – do the existing codes suggest others that you have not
yet used?
Start to think about the relationship between codes, e.g. are some
codes also linked to others? Can some codes be seen as dimensions
or parts of others?
Open coding Axial coding Selective coding
Segmenting the data Segmenting the data and starting Reassembling the data
the process of reassembling
Purpose Exploration of the data; Describe and delineate Determining important
covering the data with codes; categories; determine relevance categories and possibly a
getting familiar with the data of categories; increase level of core category; formulate
conceptual abstraction theoretical model;
reassemble data; answer the
research question(s)
Phase At the beginning of the project Halfway through End of the project
Activities Reading and re-reading (close Retrieve and compare fragments Determine core concept(s)
reading); asking questions assigned to a certain code; and their relationships; write
about the data; comparing the determine relationships; add, up findings in relation to
data; assigning codes to data refine and check ideas with literature; draw conclusions
fragments newly added data
Starting Raw data Codes developed during open All of the research material
point coding
Results List of codes (the coding Categories and sub-categories Coherent story that clarifies
frame); memos are described and distinctions relationships between
between them are made concepts and provides
answers to the research
question(s)
Validation Saturation, i.e. no new codes Saturation, i.e. the definition of Saturation, i.e. new data fit
are needed the categories is clear the model
Phase At the beginning of the project Halfway through End of the project
Activities Reading and re-reading (close Retrieve and compare fragments Determine core concept(s)
reading); asking questions assigned to a certain code; and their relationships; write
about the data; comparing the determine relationships; add, up findings in relation to
data; assigning codes to data refine and check ideas with literature; draw conclusions
fragments newly added data
Starting Raw data Codes developed during open All of the research material
point coding
Results List of codes (the coding Categories and sub-categories Coherent story that clarifies
frame); memos are described and distinctions relationships between
between them are made concepts and provides
answers to the research
question(s)
Validation Saturation, i.e. no new codes Saturation, i.e. the definition of Saturation, i.e. new data fit
are needed the categories is clear the model
Verification of
the data
(for reference only)
Data Data Data Data Conclusion/
collection preparation reduction display Verification
Guidance on coding:
http://onlineqda.hud.ac.uk/Intro_QDA/how_what_to_code.php
Coding exercises on Online QDA
Exercise A: Amanda - http://onlineqda.hud.ac.uk/amanda.php
Exercise B: Karen - http://onlineqda.hud.ac.uk/karen.php
Stages of coding: http://onlineqda.hud.ac.uk/movies/Coding/index.php#whatscodingfor
Further reading
Further reading
Boeije, H. (2010), Analysis in qualitative research, 1st edition, Sage, especially
Chapter 6 Doing Qualitative Analysis
Bryman, A. and Bell, E. (2011) Business research methods, Oxford University Press,
especially Chapter 9 on Content Analysis and Chapters 13-20 on Qualitative
Research & Analysis
Charmaz, K. (2014), Constructing Grounded Theory, 2nd Edition, Sage
Strauss, A. and Corbin, J. (1998) Basics of Qualitative Research. Grounded Theory
Procedures and Techniques, 2nd edition, Newbury Park, CA: Sage
Ritchie, J. and Lewis, J. (2003) Chapter 10: Generalising from qualitative research, in
Ritchie, J. and Lewis, J.(Eds.) Qualitative Research Practice: A Guide for Social
Science Students and Researchers, London:Sage
Ryan, G.W. and Bernard, H.R. (2003) 'Techniques to Identify Themes', Field Methods,
15(1): 85-109.
Saldaña, J. (2009), The coding manual for qualitative researchers, London:Sage