Sei sulla pagina 1di 339

HUMAN RESOURCE

MANAGEMENT
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost
Main Questions

 What is Human Resource Management (HRM)?

 Which Megatrends determine future challenges


in HRM?

 What are key fields of action in HRM?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 2


Innovation

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 3


From manual work to knowledge work

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

1900 17 83

1930 30 70

1970 49 51

2000 62 38

2020 75 25

knowledge work manual work

Source: Zukunftsinstitut (2008)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 4


Demographic Changes in Germany

50%

40% 25-34 35-49

50-64 65+
30%

20%

10%

0%
2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035

-10%

-20%

-30%

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 5


Globalization
German global Trade

Source: Statistisches Bundesamt: www.destatis.de

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 6


Web 2.0 – User-generated Content

Web 1.0 Web 2.0

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 7


Value Change

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 8


Megatrends determine future Challenges in HRM

 Acquire the right talents


Innovation
 Give the right rewards
 Support lifelong learning
Demography  Leverage employee potential
 Support diversity
Competitive
Globalization  Build successors Advantage
 Retain and share knowledge
 Shape attractive working conditions
Web 2.0
 Manage strategic changes
 Use latest technologies
Value Change
 Retain the best talents

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 9


Human Resource Management (HRM)

All planned and controlled activities of an


organization to build and maintain the
relation between employees and the
organization in order to meet both business
objectives and employee expectations

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 10


Key Terms

Human Resource Management - Innovation - Demographic


Changes - Knowledge Work - Value Change - Web 2.0 -
Globalization

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 11


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 12


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 13


Main Questions

 How are company strategy and HR strategy


related?

 As part of an HR strategy which company


functions should be of the highest priority?

 How to plan quantitative workforce demand on


both strategic and operational level?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 14


Strategic Priorities

Innovation Brand Price Design Quality

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 15


Company Strategy – HR Strategy

Company Strategy Employees HR Strategy

Strategic Challenges Competencies Key Functions

Strategic Priorities Motivation Recruiting

Business Objectives Commitment Development

Competitive Values Communication


Advantages
Availabilty Layoffs
Company Vision

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 16


Which function is of the highest Importance?

Management

Core Functions

Sales/
Product Prod.- Production/ Key Service/
Mgmt
R&D Design
Planning Engineering
Marketing
Account Support
Mgmt

Supportive Functions

Human Public
Quality Controlling/ Facility/
Mgmt
IT Accounting
Resource
Security
Relations/ Purchase Logistics
Mgmt Comm.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 17


Key- and Bottleneck-Functions

Low

Talent
Availability

High
Low Strategic High
Relevance

Source: Trost, A. (2012). Talent Relationship Management. Personalgewinnung in


Zeiten des Fachkräftemangels. Heidelberg: Springer.
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 18
Added Value in Key Functions and other
Functions

Added
Value

Key Functions  In key functions there


is an exponential
relationship between
performance and
added value
Mean
 Added value in key
Others functions is higher
compared to other
functions

Performance

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 19


Age Structure Analysis

600

500
Manager

Employees
400

Number 300

200

100

0
20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70

Age

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 20


Factors determining Workforce Demand

Senior

Promotion
Hiring out Losses
From outside Retirement,
Promotion Turnover
Professional in

Junior

Growth

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 21


Strategic Workforce Planning

2013 2014 2015 2016

Employees 120 128 132 140

Demand 18 23 28 29

Internal Availability 15 12 8 7

External Demand 3 11 20 22

Risk

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 22


Quantitative Workforce Planning Methods

 Leading Indicators
Determine the ratio between Performance and required
numbers of employees based on programmatic
assumptions (e.g. professors/students, nurses/patients).
 Trend Analysis
Applying statistical models that predict labour demand for
the future, given objective statistics from the previous
years
 Task Analysis
Tasks are identified and quantified in terms of
appearance and workload
 Conclusion by Analogy
Determine workforce requirements according to those of
similar organizational units or companies

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 23


Operational Workforce Planning
Revenue # Sales Revenue/ # Other Total #
Year # Mgr
(T€) Reps FTE* (T€) FTE of FTE
2004 6.000 30 200 9 39 6
2005 6.480 35 185 11 46 7
2006 6.998 37 189 12 49 7
2007 7.558 37 204 12 49 7
2008 8.163 36 227 13 49 7
2009 8.816 43 205 14 57 8
2010 9.521 46 207 13 59 8
2011 10.283 55 187 15 70 10
2012 11.106 58 191 17 75 11
2013 11.994 60 200 18 78 11

2014 12.954 65 20 85 12
Demand 5 2 1

Average annual Revenue Growth 8%


Average Revenue/Sales Rep (T€) 200
Average Relation Other Ees/Sales Reps 0,31
Span of Control 7 * FTE: Full Time Equivalent

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 24


Workforce Planning using Task Analysis
Example Italian Restaurant

Duration/
Assumptions # Tasks # Duration (h)
Task (Min)
Core Tasks 28
Guests/Day 200 Prepare Table 1/Table 67 2 2
Guests/Table 3 Take order 1/Table 67 3 3
Tables/Day 67 Prepare Pizza 1/Guest 200 4 13
Hours/Day 15 Billing 1/Table 67 3 3
Chat 1/Table 67 2 2
Drinks/Guest 2 Prepare Drinks 400 0,5 3
Additional Tasks 10
Breaks 5% 1
Administration 10% 3
Misc. 20% 6
Total 38
Working
8 Workforce Demand (FTE) 4,7
Hours/Day

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 25


Key Terms

Strategic Priority - Strategy - Business-HR-Strategy Linkage


- HR Strategy - Value Chain - Key Function - Bottleneck
Function - Age Structure Analysis - Workforce Demand -
Strategic Workforce Planning - Operational Workforce
Planning - Planning with leading Indicators - Task Analysis

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 26


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisitio
n Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 27


Main Questions

 What does the traditional approach in recruiting


look like?

 How is a company able to position and present


itself as an attractive place to work through
building an employer brand?

 Which active search strategies help companies


to find and approach passive candidates?

 How can companies retain promising and


talented candidates?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 28


Internal versus external Hiring

Internal Hiring External Hiring

 Lower risk  New perspectives/ideas


 Short Time-to-Fill  Lower training efforts
 Lower costs  Competitor insights
+  Internal competition  More options
 Faster integration
 Development opportunities

 Less options  Higher costs


 Higher training costs  More integration efforts
−  Disappointed colleagues  Higher recruiting risks
 Conflicts among managers  Higher turnover

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 29


Job Ads

 Employee Value
Proposition
 Job
 Job-ID
 Location
 Social Media
 Tasks and
Responsibilities
 Requirements,
Education,
Competencies
 Attractive aspects
 Application
 Send-to-friend

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 30


Contingent Workforce

Contract
Employment Worker Performance
Contract

Salary Direction

Agreement

Supplier Client
Fee

According: Holtbrügge, D. (2004). Personalmanagement. Heidelberg: Springer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 31


Career Fairs

 Direct and immediate


contact to potential
candiates
 Immediate pre-
selection and job
offering
 Direct Competition
with other employers
 Limited focus on
specific target groups
 Limited contact to
passive seekers
 Lower quality
candidates
 Additional information
services

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 32


Executive Search

 Usually executive positions will be filled through the


(secret) help of executive search consultants

 Leading executive search agencies are Egon Zehnder


International, Heiddrick & Struggle, Russel Reynolds,
Korn/Ferry, Kienbaum

 The overall fee is 33% of the candidate‘s future total


target annual salary which is billed independently of
the success of the search (retained search)

 There is a difference between active search based on


research and ad-based search

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 33


Executive Search Process

Determine Requirements
related to Position to be Interview Candidates
filled

Identify Target Check References of


Companies most suitable
(Consider off-limits) Candidates

Negotiate job-related
Candidate Search and Conditions (e.g. Salary,
direct Approach Sign-on Bonus)

Present profiles of three Coach new Executive


possibly suitable during first 100 Days of
Candidates Employment

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 34


Talent Relationship Management

Employee
Target Group Active Candidate
Value
Definition Sourcing Retention
Proposition

Positive
Selection &
Candidate
Recruiting
Experience

Source: Trost, A. (2012). Talent Relationship Management. Personalgewinnung in


Zeiten des Fachkräftemangels. Heidelberg: Springer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 35


Employer Image as a competitive Advantage

- X%

- X%

- X%

- X%
- X%

Awareness Company Employer Job Application Retention


Image Image Appeal

Branding Personnel Marketing/


Relationship Management

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 36


Which Promise?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 37


Product Brand versus Employer Attributes

Product Employer

Function Prize Company Tasks

Prestige Quality Products Offers

Inno- Values People


Design
vation

According: Corporate Leadership Council (1999). The


Employment Brand. Washington: The Corporate Executive
Board.
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 38
Building an Employer Brand

Target Group Definition

Operation Analysis
Creative Formats, Rules Employer Image,
& Processes, Validation, Target Group Preferences,
Campagnes Employer Stengths,
Labour Competition

Strategy
Employee Value
Proposition (EVP),
Media strategy

Source: Trost, A. (Hrsg.) (2009). Employer Branding. Arbeitgeber positionieren und


präsentieren. Köln: Luchterhand.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 39


Potential Employee Value Propositions

Offers Tasks Company People Values Purpose

Compensation Attractive tasks Products/ People‘s Company Environment &


& projects Services Personality culture Climate
Benefits
International Technology Qualification Leadership Social
Career work leader level of quality responsibility
opportunities workforce
Innovation Market leader Famous leader Health of
Work-Life- Collaboration others
Balance Impact Success Trust &
Diversity Respect Quality of live
Location
Work flexibility
Public
reputation

Security

Customers

Source: Trost, A. (Hrsg.) (2009). Employer Branding. Arbeitgeber positionieren und


präsentieren. Köln: Luchterhand.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 40


An historical Example

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 41


To the point

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 42


Defining the Employee Value Proposition

Employer Target Group Competitors‘ EVP


Employee Value
Strengths Preferences Strengths Proposition

A A A

B B B

C C C

D D

E E E

authentic relevant different

Source: Trost, A. (Hrsg.) (2009). Employer Branding. Arbeitgeber positionieren und


präsentieren. Köln: Luchterhand.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 43


Focus on Opportunies, Chances, Perspectives

* Grades are not everything. Your talent also matters!

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 44


From EVP to specific Messages

EVP

Strengths

Evidence & Stories

Target group specific messages

Source: Trost, A. (2012). Talent Relationship Management. Personalgewinnung in


Zeiten des Fachkräftemangels. Heidelberg: Springer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 45


Media Channels

N:N
Facebook

Internet-Forums,
Communities

Twitter
Blogs

YouTube
Career
fairs
Workshop

Personal Company- Career-


Conversation presentation Website 1.0 Print

1:1 1:N

Source: Trost, A. (2012). Talent Relationship Management. Personalgewinnung in


Zeiten des Fachkräftemangels. Heidelberg: Springer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 46


Active- passive- and non-seeking Candidates

 Read job ads, visit career


fairs, apply actively
Active
Seeker

 Have a job, are open for new


Passive opportunities, observe the
Candidates market but don‘t visit career
fairs

 Are not interested in a new job


Non-Seeker opportunity by any means, are
happy with their situation, new
in their current position, close
to retirement, ...

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 47


Active and passive Ways of Talent Sourcing
High
Guerilla
Recruiting
Competitive
Poach the Intelligence
Recruiter

Tribal Talent
Recruiting Scouting

Social
Competitiveness Community
Recruiting Employee
Referrals

Executive Campus
Search Recruiting

Career
Fairs Networks
Job Ad

Low
Low Line Engagement High
Source: Trost, A. (2012). Talent Relationship Management. Personalgewinnung in
Zeiten des Fachkräftemangels. Heidelberg: Springer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 48


Campus Recruiting

Target Universities Relationship Building Marketing Activities

Criteria definition, Building social Measures to get in touch,


prioritization of relationships to students, evaluate and retain
universities/faculties and professors, with faculties students with high level
selection and student of talent and motivation
organizations

Partnering between employer and target


university

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 49


Campus Recruiting Roles

Student
Ambassador

Top-Manager HR

Students

Manager/
Employees Professors

Career
Center

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 50


Campus Recruiting Measures

High
Internships Theses

Presentations/ Scholar-
lectures ships

Benefit* Case-Study-
Workshops Company
Inhouse Sponsorship
Days

University
Days Theses
Award

Posters

Low

Low Effort High

* Based on numbers of applications

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 51


Social Networks

 „A-Player know A-Player“

 „The Strength of weak ties“

 Growing usage of employee


referral programs

 Referrals are seen as highly


credible

 Growing social media usage

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 52


Employee Referral Programs

 Employees refer to
potential candidates
(friends, former
colleagues etc.)
Recommended
 Company gets in Person
touch with
recommended person
Hiring
Referral
 Once the
recommended person
gets hired the Company
Employee
employee who
referred to him/her
gains a bonus Bonus

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 53


Social Community Recruiting

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 54


Guerilla Recruiting

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 55


Candidate Segmentation

Very
High
A

Candidate B
Potential

C
Medium/
High
Low Relevance to High
Key-/Bottleneck Function

Source: Trost, A. (2012). Talent Relationship Management. Personalgewinnung in


Zeiten des Fachkräftemangels. Heidelberg: Springer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 56


Candidate Retention Measures

C B (C) A (B, C)
1:1 Regular Conversation with
line representatives
Invitation to Breakfast
company events with the CEO
Intensity Greeting Weekend- Job-Offers
cards workshops
Social Holiday Theses
Media Jobs

Access to Company Personal


Intranet magazine gifts
Information about vacant positions
1:N
Newsletter

Priority

Source: Trost, A. (2012). Talent Relationship Management. Personalgewinnung in


Zeiten des Fachkräftemangels. Heidelberg: Springer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 57


Internship Program

Employee

Company keeps
Talent relationship to former
Formal Assessment Pool intern

Responsibility for a small


project of relevance for
Project Work
the company/business
function

Transactional work on a
daily basis in one or more
Regular Internship
business functions

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 58


Candidate Retention Cycle

Talent-Pool
Nomination

Operation Planning

Documentation

Job-Offer Recruiting

Source: Trost, A. (2012). Talent Relationship Management. Personalgewinnung in


Zeiten des Fachkräftemangels. Heidelberg: Springer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 59


Positive Candidate Experience

Speed Transparency Appreciation

The company‘s reaction The candidate is always The candidate is treated


on incoming applications clear about current with full respect. The
and throughout the entire status. He/she company consequently
recruiting process is understands why certain demonstrates its interest
faster than thoses of the selection instruments are in those candidates it
competitors used and gets wants to hire.
appropriate feedback

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 60


Key Terms

Internal versus external Hiring - Job Posting/Add - Career


Website - Contingent Workforce - Career Fair - Public
Jobboard - Executive Search - Off-Limit - Talent Shortage -
Talent Relationship Management (TRM) - Employer Image -
Brand - Product versus Employer Brand - Employee Value
Proposition - Employer Positioning - Employer's Strengths
- Labor Competition - Target Group Preferences - Active
Seeker - Passive Seeker - Active Sourcing - Social
Community Recruiting - Referral Program - Guerilla
Recruiting - Campus Recruiting - Internship Program -
Talent Pool - Candidate Retention - Candidate Experience

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 61


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidat
e Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 62


Main Questions

 During a company‘s recruiting process how are


the most suitable candidates selected and which
risks need to be controlled?

 How can a company determine a candidate‘s


future performance? Which selection criteria are
typically used?

 What are the most commonly used selection


methods?

 How can you determine the quality of a selection


method in terms of objectivity, reliability and
validity?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 63


Recruiting Risks

High

False Right
Negative Positive

Actual
Performance

Right False
Negative Positive

Low

Low Predicted High


Performance

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 64


Job – Position – Employee

Position Job Employee

Responsibilities

e.g. teacher, butcher,


manager, sales
representative

Job Family

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 65


Job Architecture

Joblevel Chief Marketing Officer

Executive
Head of Accounting
Upper
Management Research Manager

Department Head

Team Lead Sales


Representative
Senior Research
Assistant
Junior
Marketing R&D Production Sales Admin HR

Job Family

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 66


Content and Purpose of Job Analysis

Critical Selection
Requirements
Incidents Criteria

Job
Description
Employee
Magic Attractive
Value
Moments Aspects
Proposition

Job Analysis

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 67


Critical Incident Technique
Example: Waiter in a Restaurant

Critical Incidents Requirements

 Restaurant is crowded and  Friendliness


guests become impatient
 Speed
 Guests complain about inedible
dishes  Resilience

 A drunken group of guests with  Knowledge


no money in their pockets
 Direction
 A guest wants to learn more
 Coolness
about minor details of a
specific wine  Diplomacy
 The cook is sick and his deputy  Empathy
is out of his depth

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 68


Limitations of Job Analysis

 Job-related aspects change


over time
 Jobs need to be identified and
classified (job architecture)
 It might be the employee who
defines his/her job (dejobbing)
 Job descriptions may increase
bureaucracy
 Job descriptions support the
„this-is-not-my-job“ mindset

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 69


Relevant Candidate Dimensions

Knowledge Personality

Interests Motivation

Expectations Competence

Attitudes Talents

Contacts Age, Gender,


Look?
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 70
... and how they might be judged

Education Appearance

Interview Motivation
Letter

Reason to
CV
Apply

Private Former
Engagement Development

References Photo,
Appearance
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 71
Candidate 1

 Engineer

 Intelligent

 Teamplayer

 Confident

 Result-oriented

 Ambitious

 Creative

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 72


Candidate 2

 Engineer

 Intelligent

 Teamplayer

 Confident

 Result-oriented

 Ambitious

 Creative

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 73


Social Judgement Biases

 First Impression  Stereotyping


The tendency for a The tendency to
perceiver to rely on early generalize about people
cues or first impressions. in a social category
 Recency Effect  Contrast-Effect
The tendency for a The tendency to judge
perceiver to rely on upward or downward
recent cues or last because of a comparison
impressions. with another candidate
who was recently judged
 Projection
The tendency for  Halo-Effect
perceivers to attribute The tendency to provide
their own thoughts, similar ratings across
priorities and feelings to different dimensions
others based on an overall
judgement

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 74


Recruiting-Funnel

Application 10:1 2:1 5:1 2:1 3:2 Hiring

Pre-Selection Personal Accepted


Interview Job-offer
Telephone- Assessment
Interview/ Center
Test

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 75


Selection-Process

Results
Criteria definition
consolidation

Appropriate tools
Decision
and methods

Communicating the
Usage
decision

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 76


Selection Methods – Overview

Method Spread Effort Objectivity Validity

Resume

Cognitive
Ability Test
Physical
Ability Test

Personality Test

Biographical
Questionnaire
Personal
Interview
Assessment
Center

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 77


Selection Method – Overview

Method Spread Effort Objectivity Validity

Reference Check

Background
Investigation

„Google“

Heuristics

Physiological
Tests

Graphology

Games/Simulation
s

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 78


Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI)

Favorite World Extraversion Introversion

Information Sensing INtuition

Decision Thinking Feeling

Structure Judging Perceiving

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 79


D2

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 80


Intelligence
Select the option that best fits the pattern of For each question determine the number
the previous images that best fits the pattern of the previous
numbers

1. 1, 3, 6, ?
2. 3, 5, 8, 13, 21, ?
3. 3, 6, 18, 108, ?
4. 4, 1, -3, -4, ?
5. 95, 36, 15, ?
6. 6, 13, 29, 63, ?
7. 1, 1, 2, 6, ?
8. 12, 33, 55, ?
9. 99, 86, 73, ?
10. 2, 5, 8, 35, ?
11. 4, 16, 49, ?
12. 73, 61, 56, 62, ?
13. 1588, 1820, 2148, 2204, 2284, ?
14. 923, 937, 963, ?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 81


Intelligence

There is scientific evidence, that people who earn


more money are often not as happy than those who
earn less money.

Please create as much theses supporting this


finding as possible.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 82


Intellingence Score Distribution

Frequency

Mean:
100

Standard-Deviation:
15

85 100 115 Test-Score (IQ)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 83


Projective Tests

Thematic Apperception Test Rorschach-Test

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 84


Online-Tests

 Advantages
– Global access/availability
– Low operating costs
– Opportunity for adaptive
item presentation
– Automatic/immediate
analysis and reporting
– Opportunity to track
response time

 Disadvantages
– Limited control over test
situation and subject
behaviour
– Limited opportunities to
professionally support
interpretation of results
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 85
Advantages of Psychometric Test Methods

 High objectivity due to limited impact of test operator


 High comparability across candidates due to
standardized test conditions
 Limited costs per test usage
 Test can be used as modules complementing other
selection measures
 Tests require minimal infrastructures and can be used
in almost every situation
 Tests can be exposed even online at any time and at
many locations
 Analysis is very simple (e.g. score is equal to the
amount of correctly-answered items)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 86


Interview Structure

Tension

Informal
Talk
Questions
about the
applicant

Open
Questions

Next Steps
Company/Jo
b
Presentation

Time

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 87


What both sides want to know in an Interview

Applicant Employer

 Why am I invited?  Why are you here?

 What can your company  What can you do for us?


offer me?
 What kind of person are
 What kind of employer are you?
you?
 What distinguishes you from
 What distinguishes your others who have the same
company from others? skills?

 Can I afford to work at your  Can we afford you?


company?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 88


Interview Questions to assess Competencies

 Strategic Thinking
How does the work you are currently doing affect your
organization‘s ability to meet its mission and goals? Do you
think your work is important? If yes, why? If no, why not?
 Planning
Describe a time when things didn’t turn out as you had planned.
What did you do to analyze the situation and how did you
address the issue?
 Interpersonal Relations
Give an example of a situation where the group of people you
worked with on a regular basis had a serious conflict. What was
the conflict about? How were you involved in the conflict? What
was the outcome?
 Communication
Tell me about a time when you really had to pay attention to
what someone else was saying, actively seeking to understand
their message? How did this challenge affect the manner in
which you portray important messages to others?
Source: Corporate Leadership Council (2004): Interview Questions to Assess Competencies
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 89
Combined Interviews

Interview 1 Interview 2 Interview 3 Panel-


Criteria
HR Manager Techn. Exp. interview

Teamability

Technical Skills

Motivation

Leadership

Mobility

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 90


Assessment Center

Candidates
× Assessors
× Criteria
× Methods
× Situations

6-15 Well-trained Intelligence, Tests, In-tray,


candidates psychologists social group- presentation,
and competence, exercises, Role play,
managers mobility Interviews, ...
... ...

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 91


Assessment Center Setting

Participants

Assessor Facilitator

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 92


Assessment Center Exercises

Dynamic

Role play
Meet
Introduction (role not
Employees
defined)

Role play
In-Tray Case Studies
(role defined)

Group
Psychometric Business
problem
Tests Simulation
solving

Standard

Individual Group

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 93


Assessment Center Architecture

Group Intelligence
Criteria Introduction
Exercise
In-Tray
test
Interview

Leadership

Communication

Intelligence

Mobility

Intercultural
Sensitivity

Organization

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 94


Judgement Scheme
Example Introduction

Nr. Criteria Points Commends

1 Speaks loud and clear 3 mumbles

2 Keeps eye contact 6 sometimes

3 To the point 1

4 Body expression 3 overdone

5 Structure 7 Uses flipchart

6 Stays in time 5 3 Minuts

7 Uses Time 2 Speeds up

Total 27

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 95


Advantages of Assessment Centers

 High objectivity, reliability and validity through


multiple methods, exercises, criteria, assessors

 Comparability of candidates within and across


assessment Centre cycles

 Reflection of future duties and responsibilities

 Limited risk of social desirable behaviour

 High transparency of requirements in the eyes of


the participants

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 96


Correlation

 Correlation reflects r = 0,5 r=0

linear relationship Y Y
between two
variables (X and Y)

 It can vary between


-1 and +1
X X
 Is used to determine r = 0,9 r = -0,5
validity, reliability
Y Y
and objectivity

X X

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 97


Validity

 Validity describes the extent to which results of


an assessment method relate to what it is
supposed to measure

Person Test Criterion


1 78 72

(e.E. Performance)
2 67 68

Criterion
3 44 51

n 89 83

r Prediction (e.E. Test-Score)

Criterion-Validty

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 98


Reliability and Objectivity

 Reliability  Objectivity
The extent to which a predictor Multiple rater independently
repeatedly produces the same produce the same results in
results over time terms of execution, analysis
and interpretation

Person 1. Test 2. Test Person Assessor 1 Assessor 2


1 78 72 1 78 72
2 67 68 2 67 68
3 44 51 3 44 51
… …
n 89 83 n 89 83

r r

Test Retest Reliability Interrater-Reliability

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 99


Key Terms

Candidate Selection - Hiring Risk - Job versus Position -


Job Architecture - Job Family - Job Analysis - Critical
Incident Technique - Job Description - Dejobbing - This-is-
not-my-Job-Mindest - Applicant - Stereotyping - Primacy
Effect - Halo-Effect - Recruiting Funnel - Pre-Selection -
Biografic Questionnaire - Reference Check - Background
Investigation - Graphology - Heuristics - Resumé -
Personality - Personality Test - Social Desirability - Myers-
Briggs Type Indicator - Ability Test - Intelligence Test -
Standard Deviation - Projective Tests - Online Testing -
Adaptive Item Presentation - Job Interview - Assessment
Center - In-Tray Test - Role Play - Correlation - Validity -
Reliability - Objectivity

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 100


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensatio
Selection n & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 101


Main Questions

 What is equity?

 Which components make up total reward and


based on which factors are these components
determined?

 Under which conditions does money impact


motivation for performance?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 102


Equity

Reward
 Distributive Equity
A One‘s performance
reward relation
compared to others

Equity  Procedural Equity


Do procedures to
determine compensation
B
lead to fair results?

Performance/
Contribution to company success

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 103


Factors determining Compensation

Strategic
Responsibility Performance
Relevance

Company
Qualification Market
Success

Civil
Cost of Living Tenure
Status

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 104


Total Reward

Total Reward

Total Compensation Non-financial


Reward

Base Pay Variable Pay Benefits

Individual/ Organisation
Group

Salary Piece Rate Profit Insurances Appreciation


Sharing
One-time Contacts
Wages Bonus Stock
Ownership Pension
Target Bonus Privileges
Stock
Commission Options Services Title

According: Holtbrügge, D. (2004). Personalmanagement. Heidelberg: Springer.


Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 105
Development of a Base Pay System

Job Analysis

Job Evaluation Pay Survey

Pay Policies Pay Structures

Job
Individual Pay
Appointment

Implementation,
Communication,
Monitoring

According: Mathis & Jackson: Human Resource Management. South-Western.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 106


Compensable Factors – Hay System

Functional Expertise 8

Knowledge Managerial Skills 7

Human Relation 3

Environment 8
Problem Solving
Challenge 5

Freedom to act 8

Accountability Impact on end results 4

Magnitude Dyn.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 107


Job Evaluation
Example Consulting Company

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 108


Market Line

Market Pay
Average Salaries in the Market
 Benchmark jobs are Jobs
at other companies with
Benchmark-Jobs Market similar duties,
Line requirements etc.

 Market line represents


relationship between job
value and market pay

 Computing market line


by using statistical
regression analysis

Job Value

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 109


Base Pay Structure

Job Grade
Based on Job Value Market Line

5 A

4 B

Pay Rate (€)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 110


Opportunities and Threats of Job Evaluation and
Base Pay Structures

Opportunities Threats

 Common foundation for  Significant bureaucracy


compensation-related during implementation
decisions
 Acceptance of all
 Job-related distributive and stakeholders involved
procedural equity
 Requires clear job definitions
 Transparency of
compensation-related  Reduces flexibility of
decisions compensation-related
decisions
 Active elaboration of job
values and contribution to  May reduce innovation and
company‘s success employee engagement

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 111


Compensation of Business Graduates
in Germany

Entry-Level (Graduates) Professional Experience

Median

50%

Source: Personalmarkt, 2006

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 112


One-Time Bonuses

 A one-time bonus is a one-time payment that


does not become part of the employee‘s base
pay

 Can be used to reward employees for


contributing new ideas, coping with critical
challenges, acquiring new skills

 Bonuses usually recognize performance of both


the employer and the company

 Bonuses provide great flexibility in rewarding


valued behaviours at particular situations

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 113


Employee Recognition System

 Every employee can acknowledge special


performance of his/her colleagues with a gift

 Based on his/her own budget (% of base pay)

 To operate the system there is an internal kind of


gift-plattform in the intranet

 The value of gifts totally received by an employee


can serve as a basis for performance appraisal

 It‘s a rarely used approach but its popularity


increases

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 114


Piece-Rate System and Commission

Piece-Rate System Commission

Daily Wage Salary

variable variable

fix fix

Daily Performance Revenue

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 115


Target Bonus

 Employee and supervisor Target Bonus


(%)
agree on both individual
targets and relation between
target achievement and target 140
B
bonus
120
 Employees can choose from A
different options reflecting
100
different risk preferences

 Primarily used for managers 80


and senior employees
60

60 80 100 120 140


Target Achievement (%)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 116


Objective Setting Scheme

Point Achieve- Point Value ×


Objective Value ment Achievement

Organize CEBIT Fair attendance.


Generate 100 leads + follow-up 10 130% 13

Successfully integrate 3 new hired


colleagues by end of the year 10 90% 9

New corporate website relaunch. 400


clicks per day by end of the year 25 105% 26

Σ 45 48

Σ 100% 107.2%

Target Bonus in € 5.000 5.361

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 117


Does Money motivate? The Candle-Problem

1 2 3

Dan Pink: The puzzle of motivation


http://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pink_on_motivation.html

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 118


Pay for Organizational Performance

 Profit Sharing
Proportions of organizational profits are distributed
among employees according to their base pay

 Employee Stock Ownership


Giving employees stock ownership of the organization or
the right to acquire stocks at a price below market.
Employees must keep stocks for a specific period of time

 Employee Stock Options


The right to buy (exercise) a certain number of stocks at a
specific price

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 119


Employee Stock Options
Example

Stock price

13€

10€ Option

6€

4€

0 Time t

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 120


Types of Benefits

 Security  Financial
– Unemployment – Interest-free building loan
compensation – Company credits
– Life insurance – Financial counselling
– Disability insurance
– Early retirement options  Offerings
– Disability retirement benefits – Company car
– Pension Plans – Private cell phone, laptop
usage
 Health – Free lunch
– Health Care Insurance – Cafeteria and food services
– Sabbatical – Child Care; Company
– Free tennis courts, fitness Kindergarten
centre usage – Cost advantages for
– Medical care company products
– Psychiatric counselling – Company accommodation

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 121


Deferred Compensation
Tax-deductible Pension

Cash Pension

Employer Employee Employer Employee

Compensation 1.000.000 € 1.000.000 € 1.000.000 € 1.000.000 €

Social Security + 200.000 € - 210.000 €

Pay Tax - 290.000 €

Result 1.200.000 € 500.000 € 1.000.000 € 1.000.000 €

Benefit 200.000 € 500.000 €

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 122


Reasons why Companies offer Benefits

 Benefits protect employees and their dependents


from financial risks associated with illness,
disability, and unemployment
 Most benefits are not taxed. For this reason, they
might represent a more valuable reward to
employees than an equivalent cash payment
 Benefits may contribute to attracting, motivating
and retaining human resources
 Some benefits add value to the employee without
additional costs for the employer. As such,
benefits might serve as substitutes for financial
compensation
 Some benefits are required by law

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 123


Flexible Benefits (Cafeteria System)

 Flexible Benefit Plan


A plan that allows employees to select the benefits they
prefer from groups of benefits established by the employer

 Reasons for using “Flex Plans”


– Perceived value of benefits depend on employees’ age,
family status etc.
– By tailoring the right benefit package employees gain
maximum value without additional costs on employer’s side
– Flex plan increases employees awareness of the costs and
value of benefits offered

 Problems with Flexible Plans


– Inappropriate benefits package choices
– Adverse use of specific benefits by higher-risk employees
– Administrative and communication efforts
– Benefit requests are hard to predict

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 124


Key Terms

Equity - Factors Driving Individual Compensation - Total


Reward - (Non-)Monetary Rewards - (Non-)Financial
Rewards - Total Compensation - Job Evaluation -
Compensable Factor - Point Method - Benchmark
Study/Pay Survey - Benchmark Job - Market Line - Pay
Structure - Pay Range - Pay Grade - Median - Piecework -
Commission - Bonuses - Target Bonus - Intrinsic versus
extrinsic Motivation - Profit Sharing - Employee Stock
Ownership - Employee Stock Option - Benefits - Deferred
Compensation - Flexible Benefits

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 125


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 126


Main Questions

 What can be learned through training?

 In which coporate fields are training courses


typically used?

 How can a training-event be designed and


devloped in order to meet predefined learning
objectives?

 How to ensure employees transfer what they


have learned during training into real life?

 How do modern media and working conditions


influence the way people learn in a company?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 127


What can be learned how?

Training
Knowledge

Competence

Talent Develop
Experience

Intelligence

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 128


Corporate Fields where Training Courses are used

Unique Training Needs

Training as part of a Customized training


large-scale change addressing special
initiative development needs for
E.g. IT-implementation, teams and individuals
cultural change E.g. sales training

Planned,
strategically Demanded
decided

Regular training for Training for employees


specific target groups offered on demand at
E.g. newly-appointed high volume
managers, new hires E.g. group conflict training

Standard Training Needs

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 129


Content of a typical Training Catalogue

Office Business
Languages Accounting Labor Law
Packages Administration

Leading Conflict Coping with Doing


Communication
People management Stress Interviews

Project Working Facilitation/Pr Time Sales


management techniques esentation management technique

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 130


Increasing Productivity through Employee
Onboarding

Productivity
With Onboarding

Benefit

Without Onboarding

First Weeks in a new Job

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 131


Training Course Development

 Target Group
Needs Analysis  Learning Needs
 Relevant situations

 Content and learning objectives


Design  Methods and media
 Costs und budgets

 Trainer
Operation  Duration, Schedule
 Infrastructure

 Evaluation
Evaluation  Optimization

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 132


You don‘t know what you don‘t know

Knowing Explicit
Conscious incompetence Capabilities

Unconscious Unconscious Implicit


Incompetence Competence

Weak Strong
Capabilities Capabilities

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 133


Needs Assessment Methods

 Structured interviews  Critical Incidents


on individual or group Techniques
level
 Participated or non-
 Self-administered participated observation
assessment tools
(e.g. tests)  Off-site needs
assessment workshops
 Ratings from peers,
supervisors,  Professional auditing by
subordinates (external) experts

 Shadowing, diaries,

 Coaching

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 134


Training Approaches

Along the Job


Assistance
Substitute

Into the Job On the Job Out of the Job


Education Job Rotation Outplacement,
New Hire Integration Coaching; Mentoring Retirement
Trainee Programs Project Work

Near the Job


Task Forces
Work Groups

Off the Job


Congresses
Outdoor-Training
Off-side-Training

According: Holtbrügge, D. (2004). Personalmanagement. Heidelberg: Springer.


Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 135
Advantages of „On-the-job“ versus „Off-the-job“ -
Training

On-the-Job Off-the-Job

 Natural and job-related  Expertise and experience of


training conductor
 Lower costs of development
measure  Professional learning
environment
 Immediate application of
newly acquired knowledge  Focus on training, limited
job-related disruptions
 Immediate Feedback
 Networking among
 Opportunity to monitor participants out of different
development advances functions and countries
 Motivation to learn

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 136


Training Methods

Dynamic

Group work
Coaching with indiv. Role Play
presentation

Facilitated
Exercises for Case Studies
group
Individuals in Groups
discussion

Business
Literature Presentation
Simulation

Standard Blended Learning


Individual Group

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 137


Course Schedule
Example: Project Management Course

Day # Time Topic Objective Method Material


1 1 9am Introduction Understand the Presentation Course Handout
attributes of a project Slides 1-8
and the key challenges
to manage projects
2 10am Critical Factors Understand which Group Flip-Chart
factors drive success of Discussion & Pin Board
projects in the
participants' business
context
3 11am Break
4 11:30am Project Planning Participants become Presentation Course Handout
familiar with gant-chart Slides 9-16
technique to schedule a
project
7 1pm Lunch
6 1-2pm Project Planning Participants learn how to Group Work Case Study 1;
Excercice apply gant-chart Pin Board
technique

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 138


Levels of Training Evaluation
according to Kirkpatrick

What are the immediate


Reaction reactions of the participants Questionnaire
after the training?

Have the participants


Tests,
Learning acquired knowledge as it was
Examination
intended?

Did the training lead to


Observation,
Behaviour changing behavior at the
Evaluation
participant‘s daily work?

Did the training impact


Performance
Results achievements of
Indicators
organizational goals?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 139


Learning Transfer

Participants
 Cognitive abilities
 Learning-motivation
 Readiness to learn

Training
 Training Quality
Trainer, Media, Structure,
Methods, Material, Environment Learning Transfer
 Relevance of content

Work Environment
 Support by
colleagues/manager
 Opportunity to apply
 Feedback

According: Baldwin, T.T., & Ford, K.J. (1988). Transfer of training: A review and
directions for future research. Personnel Psychology, 41, 63-105.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 140


Formal versus informal Learning

 Formal Learning
20%
Learning in an institutionalized
context, dedicated to learn (e. g.
courses, training-programs)
80%
 Informal Learning
80% Learning happens self-
organized and often as a
positive side-effect of daily work
20%

Budget Effect

Source: Cross, J. (2006). Informal Learning: Rediscovering the Natural Pathways That Inspire
Innovation and Performance. San Francisco/CA: John Wiley.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 141


Managers as Teachers

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 142


Learning on Demand

Expert Forums Wiki, Blogs

YouTube
Tutorials
Communities
Peers of Practice Literature

Off-the-Job iTunes U
Training
Conferences
Direct
Manager

Simulations Yellow
Pages

Yammer
Social Expert
Education Podcasts Communites

Micro-Blogging
Source: Trost, A. & Jenewein, T.
(Hrsg., 2011). Personalentwicklung
2.0. Köln: Wolters Kluwer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 143


YouTube Tutorials

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 144


Communities of Practice

 Group of employees with similar professional


interests, background or duties

 Informally organized meetings during working-


hours

 Exchange of best practices and ideas to


autonomously chosen topics

 Exist independently of organization and


hierarchies – results will not be reported to
management

 Engagement of external speakers and experts

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 145


Principals of informal Learning

 Learning content is easily produced, shared and


found via Web 2.0 (e.g. YouTube)

 Flexible and problem-related usage of content


(„Learning-on-Demand“ instead of „Learning-
just-in-case“)

 Learning from others (peers) through Social


Media und Communities of Practice

 Room and infrastructures allow self-directed


learning and knowledge exchange

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 146


Knowledge Management Challenges

Knowledge
Knowledge Retention Knowledge Transfer
Identification

How can the employees‘ How can a company and How can the knowledge of
knowledge be retained its employees know what one employee be
inside the company even the (other) employees transferred to another
when employees leave it? know? employee?

?
! ! ! !

A A A B C A B

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 147


Collect-Approach via Knowledge Database

!
Search for
Expertise ?
Document

Document

Knowledge
Database

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 148


Connect-Approach via Yellow Pages, Wikis, ...

! Personal
exchange

?
Reference to
expertice
Search for
experts

Yellow Pages,
Wikis, Forums ...

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 149


Key Terms

Training & Development - Knowledge versus Competence -


Strandard Training Catalogue - New Hire Onboarding -
Training Needs Analysis - Off-the-Job Training - On-the-
Job-Training - Blended Learning - Training Evaluation -
Learning Transfer - Formal versus informal Learning -
Learning on Demand - YouTube Tutorial - Communities of
Practice - Wiki - Podcast - Mobile Learning - Knowledge
Management - Collect- versus Connect-Approach -
Knowledge Database - Yellow Pages

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 150


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 151


Main Questions

 How can companies ensure that they have


successors ready for key positions at any time?

 Which methods and criteria are typically used to


identify talent inside a companies?

 What are required conditions for employees to


leverage their talent as part of their long-term
career?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 152


Leadership-Development at McDonalds
German Perspective

Global Leadership
Global Development Program
GLDP Senior Executives

European Leadership
Europe ELDP Development Program
Top-Executives

Operations
West ODP Development Program
Senior Superiors

Young Leaders
Germany YLDP Development Program
Junior Management Talents

Restaurant Manager-
RMDC Development Center
Restaurant Management

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 153


Classic Approach of Talent Development

Succession Performance
Planning Management

Stretch Role Talent Review


Assignment

Competency
Model

Training Potential
Off-the-Job Assessment

Source: Trost, A. & Jenewein, T.


(Hrsg., 2011). Personalentwicklung
2.0. Köln: Wolters Kluwer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 154


Competence

Learned ability to successfully solve


Competence problems or cope with given
challenges
Action-related knowledge acquired
Experience through repeated solution of practical
problems
Cognitive understanding of aspects
Knowledge and how they relate to each other

Cognitive and physical abilities


Predisposition determined through genetiv
predispositions (DNA)
Stable predisposition to demonstrate
Personality similar behavioral patterns in similar
situations

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 155


ABB Leadership Competency Model

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 156


Development Needs Identification

Job Position Employee


Senior Specialist Senior Specialist CRM Garth McGrath

1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
Creativity Creativity Creativity

Teamwork Teamwork Teamwork

Presentation Presentation Presentation

Project Mgmt Project Mgmt Project Mgmt

Mobility Mobility Mobility

SAP R/3 SAP R/3

English English

Development Needs

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 157


Limitations of Competency Model Usage

 Depending on a given situation a


competence might be a strength or a
weakness – what matters is the right
balance
 Having a certain competence does not
necessarily mean that the person in
question actually uses it
 Similar challenges can be met through
different sets of competencies (internal
compensation)
 It matters how competencies are given in an
entire team. Not everybody must have same
competencies (external Compensation)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 158


Performance Management Cycle

Superior Objectives  In an annual cycle employee


and their immediate supervisor
agree on objectives both in
terms of performance and
Performance Objective development
Appraisal Setting
 Individual objectives derive
from superior objectives

 In a backwards perspective
achievements/performance of
the employee will be reviewed

 The annual meeting between


employee and supervisor is
called „appraisal interview“

Mid-Year Review

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 159


Purpose of Performance Management

 Cascading strategic objectives from upper


hierarchical level to the bottom line

 Alignment and focus of individual and team


performance with overall target

 Clarity about mutual expectations within an employee-


manager relationship

 Continuous learning and constant improvement of


performance through feedback and target-oriented
people development

 Foundation for numerous key processes in human


resource management such as compensation, people
development, succession planning (horizontal
integration)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 160


Performance Management Form

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 161


Behaviorally anchored Rating Scale (BARS)
Example Teamwork

Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Level 4

Contributes willingly towards Takes responsibility for Builds support and Builds highly productive
the accomplishment of team activities that stretch enthusiasm for the teams from highly diverse
goals of one’s own team, beyond own functional accomplishment of team disciplines, cultures or
doing his or her share of the area. goals. organizations.
work.
Solicits the input of team Uses the agendas and Creates commitment to and
Demonstrates respect for members and encourages perspectives of others to enthusiasm for the
the opinions and ideas of their participation. establish mutually accomplishment of
others. beneficial objectives. challenging objectives across
Ensures participation of diverse teams.
Does not remain silent or others who are affected Takes responsibility for the
withhold differing opinions in by plans or actions. accomplishment of team Masterfully integrates people
team settings. goals. and resources to achieve
Puts team’s agenda and high levels of synergy.
Is willing to accept the good of the whole Removes obstacles that
compromises to progress ahead of personal needs. get in the way of team Resolves dysfunctional
toward the achievement of success. conflict within or among
group goals. Finds areas of agreement teams to ensure business
when working with Gives recognition and success.
Follows through on conflicting individuals or credit to people who have
commitments made to other groups. contributed to team
team members. success.
Helps others to solve
Keeps people informed and work problems and Takes specific steps to
up to date. achieve team objectives. keep morale and levels of
performance high during
times of intense work
pressure.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 162


Overall Performance Ranking Scale

Rating Definition
Exceptional performance rarely achieved. Marked by precedent-setting results beyond the scope of the
5.0 position. Demonstrates the highest standards of performance excellence relative to individuals with
comparable levels of responsibility
Consistently exceeds all position requirements and expectations. Accomplishements are highly valued
4.5 and may be well beyond the scope of the position. Demonstrates higher standards of performance
excellence relative to individuals with comparable levels of responsibility.
Consistently exceeds most position requirements and expectations. Accomplishements are often
4.0 noteworthy. Overall performance is consistently above levels of quality and quantity relative to
individuals with comparable levels of responsibility.
Exceeds some position requirements and expectations. Successfully accomplishes all objectives.
3.5 Overall performance matches levels of quality and quantity relative to individuals with comparable levels
of responsibility.
Meets position requirements and expectations. Accomplishes most or all objectives. Some aspects of
3.0 overall performance may require additional development or improvement to match levels of quality and
quantity relative to individuals with comparable levels of responsibility.
Falls below performance standards and expectations of the job. Demonstrates one or more performance
2.5 deficiencies that hinder acceptable performance relative to individuals with comparable levels of
responsibility

Does not meet minimum requirements in critical aspects of the job and has numerous performance
1.0-2.0 deficiencies that prevent success at Microsoft.

Source: Bartlett, C. A. (2001). Microsoft. Competing on Talent (A). Harvard Business School.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 163


What if ...

 employee and manager talk  there is already a natural


about relevant aspects on a relationship between manager
daily basis anyhow? and employee built on trust
and respect?
 employee and manager don‘t
usually talk to each other  at daily work the manager has
throughout the year? limited insights into
employee‘s performance?
 problems should have been
adressed once they occurred?  The manager has limited
understanding of the
 the suppervisor struggles with
employee‘s professional
giving honest feedback?
work?
 superior objectives are not as
 objectives dynamically
clear as they should be?
change in the course of a
 the benefits of the appraisal yearly period?
interview are nor seen by
 the employee doesn‘t fully
either the employee or the
trust his/her manager?
manager?
 the manager primarily acts Recommended: Trost, A. (2011). Wozu noch
Mitarbeitergespräche?
like a coach and not like a http://www.harvardbusinessmanager.de/blogs/artikel
judge? /a-809396.html

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 164


Performance – simplified

Freedom
allow × Capability
can × Motivation
want

 Time, Budget  Knowledge  Added Value


 Tools  Experience  Challenge
 Material  Predisposition  Appreciation
 Colleagues  Health  Self-Actualization
 Organization  Resilience  Purpose
 Autonomy

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 165


Learning-Curve

Performance Level

Maximum

Potential

Age

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 166


Potential Criteria

Performance

In the past did the


employee demonstrate an
extraordinary growth in
his/her ability to meet
challenges?

Motivation

Personality Is the employee eager


and hungry to take over
Based on his/her more responsibility
character will the relevant to the entire
employee have a chance organization?
to be seen as a role
model by others?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 167


Performance Potential Grid

A1 A2
High Plan next move Apply multiple
Provide extra development and
C1 coaching retention measures
Performance
Improvement
Measures A3
Potential Identify next
development
opportunity
B
Keep in Place
Low C2
Manage Out

Low Performance High

Source: Michaels. E, Handfield-Jones, H., & Axelrod, B. (2001). The War for
Talent. Boston/Mass.: Harvard Business School Press.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 168


Talent Review Structure

L1
Leadership Team

L2
HR Business Partner

L3

L4
High Potential

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 169


360-Degree-Feedback

 A focus person is evaluated


from different perspectives
Direct
(outside perception)
Supervisor
 A focus person evaluates
him/herself (self perception)
 Evaluation happens
anonymously, in written by
Peers Focus-
Customers using standardized and
person
structured methods (e.g.
questionnaire)
 The focus person gets a
personal report to be
discussed with his/her direct
Subordinate
supervisor or a coach
 Purpose is to determine a
focus person‘s development
needs

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 170


Careers as Managers versus Expert

 More responsibility for people


and budgets

 Career moves up the


hierarchical ladder

 More task complexity

 Deepen professional
knowledge within a narrowly-
defined field

 No responsibility for people

 Internal consultant for top-level


executives

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 171


Dual Career Path/Ladders

Management Expert

Executive Fellow

 Comparable salary based


Senior
Division Head
Consultant
on a corresponding base
pay structure

 Comparable value of
Department Head Consultant privileges (e.g. company
car)

 Active involvement in
Teamlead Junior Expert decision processes on
comparable level

 Comparable social
Employee without leadership responsibilies acknowledgement (e.g.
title)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 172


A Study about what matters in long-term
Development

Job Assignments
1 Promote high performers quickly
2 Build skills to boost career prospects
3 Fast rotation and advancement
4 Roles with P&L responsibility
5 Special project opportunities
6 On-the-job training

Coaching Feedback
7 Told my strengths and weaknesses
8 360°feedback
9 Candid, insightful feedback
10 Informal coaching from boss

Mentoring
11 Great mentor
12 Great senior role models
13 Mentoring advice on development

Training
14 Traditional classroom training

Source: Michaels, E; Handfield-Jones, H; Axelrod, B. 2001,


The war for talent, Boston, Harvard Business School Press.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 173


People who develop their Talent ...

 trully love what they do  got the opportunity to do


what they can do best
 know their real potential
 trust in a strong mentor
 have a vision about their
future position  are lucky
 jump into cold water  prefer to work with thoses
who compensate their
 actively build strong
weaknesses
networks
 get trained
 sell themselves
 showed early successes
 are disciplined – most of
the time  are well known
 prefer to work with A-
player

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 174


Talent Development Measures

Through Experience From Others Through Training

 Challenging  Mentoring  Off-the-Job-


tasks/projects Training
(Stretch Jobs)  Career Coaching
 Being a Trainer
 Job Rotation  360-Degree-
Feedback  Literature
 Internal Talent
Markets  Learn Forums

 Action Learning  Action Learning

70% 20% 10%

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 175


Mentoring

Benefits for the Mentor

 Building future supporter

 Learning from the bottom-line

 Professional insights across borders

 Appreciation

Benefits for the Mentee

 Access to networks and roles

 Professional feedback

 Confidence
Trust Commitment
 Role Model

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 176


Career Coaching

What are your talents?

„ „
What are your biggest
Who could support your future
strengths and
career development?


weaknesses?

„ „ What do you really


like to do?
What could be you
Which working
next, realistic career-
conditions are
move?
important to you?

„ To achieve your goals, „


which additional What is your ultimate
experience could help? career goal?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 177


Stretch Jobs

Stretch Jobs HiPo

Which job is What can be Who fits


appropriate? learned? the job?

 Acceptable  Professionally  Mobility


turnover risk (Finance, HR, Marketing,
Sales,…)  Career
 Visibility preferences
 Intercultural
 Social and Sensitivity  Development
professional needs
 Leadership,
variety
Management  Private Situation
 Responsibility
 Strategy  Mentor
 Pressure
 Languages

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 178


Action Learning

Definition of strategic
... On top management level. Projects work for
learning projects &
sponsors
diverse teams and as good learning opportunities

Schedule, logistics, information about the


Identification and
program and its structure, professional
preparation of participant
preparation

Combination of training, workshops, project work


Program operation
and mentoring

... by experts, active involvement of responsible


Project evaluation
line representatives and external consultants

... once project ideas are seen as promising and


Follow-up/
doable. Relevant functions take over
project implementation
responsibility

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 179


Action Learning – Program Operation

Mentoring

Project Project Project


Training & Workshop

Training & Workshop

Training & Workshop

Training & Workshop

Final Presentation
Kickoff

Project Project Project

Project Project Project

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 180


Internal Talent-Market

Talents Jobs & Projects Rules

Experiences Requirements Notice Period


Projects Challenges Roles and views
Expectations Objectives Compensation
Preferences Conditions
References

HR Consultant

Source: Trost, A. & Frosch, M. (2011). Interne Talentmärkte. In A. Trost & T.


Jenewein (Hrsg.) Personalentwicklung 2.0, S. 283-301. Köln: Wolters Kluwer.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 181


Key Terms

Leadership Development - Talentmanagement -


Competence - Competency Model - Job Profile -
Performance Management - Cascading - Objective Setting -
Performance Appraisal - Behaviorally Anchored Rating
Scale - Talent Review - Learning Curve - Potential - Talent -
Performance Potential Grid - 360-Degree-Feedback - Dual
Career Ladder - Career Path - Mentoring - Coaching -
Career Counselling - Stretch Job - Action Learning -
Internal Talent Market

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 182


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 183


Main Questions

 What characterizes modern work and what will


be the future of work?

 In this particular context how do work-life-


balance and working hours matter?

 Can employee surveys help to improve working


conditions?

 How can a company strategically strengthen its


employer attractiveness?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 184


Traditional Worktime Recording

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 185


76% of all good Ideas are generated outside the
original Workspace

Vacation, Travel Spare time,


13% Sport 9%
Misc. 1%
At
Workplace 4%
In interesting Nature,
Meetings 6% hiking 28%

In boring
Meetings 10%

Breaks 3%
At home,
watching TV,
Using creativity
Hobby, etc. 14%
techniques 1%
Business travel/
Way to office 11%
Source: Füglistaller, KMU-Magazin Nr.7/2005

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 186


Flexible Working Structures

Flexible
Working Hours

Flexible
Locations

Flexible Organization

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 187


Dimensions of a Working Hours Model

Distribution
Time

08-09 Volume

09-10

10-11

11-12

12-01
Duration/
Position
02-03

03-04
04-05
Flexibility
05-06

06-07

Mo Tu We Th Fr

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 188


Relevant Factors determine Working Hours Model

Industry/
Country

Labour
Law

Job Requirements

Working
Individual Employees,
Hours Preferences Values
Model
Leadership
Culture

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 189


Working Hours Approaches

high
Trust-based Working Hours

Flexible Annual
Working Time
Flextime Job-Sharing

Working Time
Autonomy Flexible weekly Early
Working Hours Retirement

Part-Time German Long-Term


Work Kurzarbeit Accounts

Fixed Working Hours


low
Day .. Week.. Month .. Year .. Life

Timely Reference

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 190



Work-Life-Balance

Imagine life as a game in which you are


juggling five balls in the air. They are Work,
Family, Health, Friends and Spirit and you’re
keeping all of these in the air. You will soon
understand that Work is a rubber ball. If you
drop it, it will bounce back. But the other four
balls — Family, Health, Friends and Spirit – are
made of glass. If you drop one of these; they
will be irrevocably scuffed, marked, nicked,
damaged or even shattered. They will never be
the same. You must understand that and strive
for it. Work efficiently during office hours and
leave on time. Give the required time to your
family, friends and have proper rest. Value has
a value only if its value is valued.

Brian G. Dyson
Former CEO of Coca Cola

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 191


Individual Life Plans

10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Age

Learning Work Private

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 192


Phases of Life

Learn Grow Decide Lead Share

First
Growing Management Leading Coaching,
professional
Work

responsibility, responsibility, organizations, Mentoring,


experiences,
career, talent autonomy, new experience, close to
occupational
development orientation networks retirements
orientation

Family, divorce, Prosperity, Autonomy,


Private

Marriage,
Single, relation, own home, grown-up health,
familiy planning,
autonomy, party purchasing children, aging prosperity,
kids
power parents „Handicap“

Succession Coaching,
Onboarding,
Talent Flexible working planning, mentoring,
HRM

trainee
development, hours, change health
programs,
... ... management, management,
..
... ...

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 193


Home Office (Telework)

Pros Cons

 Reduced cost to the  Limited separation of


company private life and work
 Tax advantages for the  Limited social, informal
employee* connection to colleagues
 Worktime flexibility  Risk of private
 Work-Life-Balance disruptions
 Higher productivity at  Availability might not be
individual tasks transparent

* Depending on local tax law

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 194


Distance and Communication

Face-to-face
Communication

often

never
low Distance long

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 195


Spaces and Structures relate to each other

Source: DEGW
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 196
Non-territorial Workspace, Hoteling,
Rooms to concentrate or communicate

Source: DEGW
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 197
Survey Feedback & Organization Development

Planning

Implementation
Survey

Action
Planning
Analysis

Feedback

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 198


Conduct of a traditional Employee Survey

Project Planning & Feedback/Commun


Setup ication

Analysis &
Prestudy Action Planning
Reporting

Survey Survey
Implementation
Development Administration

Prior
Evaluation
Communication

Preparation Survey Follow-Up

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 199


Survey Development

Topics

Indicator

Questions

Adjustment

Pretest

Operation & Evaluation

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 200


Q12 (Gallup)

1. I know what is expected of 7. At work, my opinions seem


me at work to count
2. I have the materials and 8. The mission/purpose of my
equipment I need to do my company makes me feel my
work right job is important
3. At work, I have the 9. My associates (fellow
opportunity to do what I do employees) are committed to
best every day doing quality work
4. In the last seven days, I have 10. I have a best friend at work
received recognition and
praise for doing good work 11. In the last six months,
someone at work has talked
5. My supervisor, or someone to me about my progress
at work, seems to care about
me as a person 12. This last year, I have had
opportunities at work to learn
6. There is someone at work and grow
who encourages my
development

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 201


A Typical Way to Present Results

Frequencies (%)

I have the materials and equipment I need to strongly partly- dis- strongly
N Average agree
do my work right agree partly agree disagree
1 2 3 4 5

Sales Germany 35 35 36 36 29
29 45 2,92 12 23 36 19 10

Global Sales 48 28 24
48 28 24 287 2,63 19 29 28 18 6
Organization

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 202


Survey Results (Example)
1 1,5 2 2,5 3 3,5 4 4,5 5

1,7
Tasks and Duties 1,6
2
Work Environment 1,5 Region South-West

2,3 Germany
Empowerment 2,6
1,4
Colleagues 1,6

Direct Supervisor 2,3  Region South-West (32


2,1
Employees) is part of
2,8
Communication 2,8
Germany (186 Employees)

Work Flexibility 2,5  1 = Best possible result


2,4
5 = worst possible result
2
Work-Life-Balance 1,8

Compensation 3,1
3,2
2,5
Benefits
2,6

Commitment 1,7
1,8
2,8
Career Development
2,2

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 203


Ways to interpret Survey Results

Absolut Relative Longitudinal Target

Comparing items Comparing results Comparing results Comparing results


based on the with internal and with thoses of with targets set in
absolute results external previous surveys advance to the
Benchmarks survey

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 204


Follow-up Process

 All employees get all results of the survey even


when results are negative

 Feedback of results follows a top-down approach


from to top-management to every single team

 All teams get their own results compared to the


results of the superior organisational units

 All units on all levels are encouraged to work with


their results and come up with related action plans

 Issues which lay beyond an organizational unit‘s


responsibility will be passed on to the unit on the
next level

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 205


Shortcomings of traditional Employee Survey
Approaches

 Surveys are isolated events not integrated into


regular leadership processes

 Not every topic is relevant for everybody on every


hierarchy level

 Objectives are defined after the survey has been


conducted based on survey results. But, surveys
can‘t change priorities

 Required budgets for improvement activities are


not defined. Therefore planned actions lead to
minimal impact

 Comparison with benchmarks means taking


the mediocre as standard

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 206


Relevance of Results depend on Targets

Survey Potential Target

Potential Target Survey

According: Trost, A. & Hagmeister, A. (2005). Mitarbeiterbefragung als Instrument


strategischer Unternehmensführung. In W. Bungard & I. Jöns (Hrsg.),
Feedbackinstrumente im Unternehmen (S. 197-208). Wiesbaden: Gabler.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 207


Positioning different Feedback Instruments

Instrument Who What Why For whom

Traditional Employees,
Improvement,
Employee Survey All Employees Job Satisfaction Manager,
Involvement
(Survey Feedback) Management

Status
Theme-oriented Selected
Selected topics Monitoring, Management
Employee Survey Employees
Feedback

Strategy Monitoring
Random
Pulse Survey commitment, strategy Management
Sample
capabilities execution

Manager,
360-Degree- Employees, Development
Management Management
Feedback, Manager,
behavior,
Management Peers,
competence
Evaluation Customers Selection Management, HR

Internal Customer Internal Service Internal Service


Service quality
Survey Customers improvement Provider

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 208


Traditional Employee Survey versus Pulse Survey

Traditional
Pulse Survey
Employee Survey

Content  Factors driving employees‘  Content is relevant to the


satisfaction and company‘s competitive
performance position
Customer  Employees, Manager,  Management
Management
Follow-Up  Units on all levels are  Results are natural part of top-
encouraged to work with management agenda and
results and draw conclusions decision making

Objectives  Objectives are set after the  Objectives are set in advance
survey of the survey
Cycle  Every 1-5 years  1-12 times/year

Participants  All employees  Random Sample


High-Potentials

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 209


Employer A

„ As a key component of our employer-of-choice strategy,


we communicate to potential employees that this is a
great place to work. We offer a positive work climate,
rich career-opportunities and competitive benefit-
packages. We are proud that we have won a number of
awards and rank high in most of currently existing
employer-rankings. As a result, our applications are up
and turnover is down across the firm.“

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 210


Employer B

„ The last thing we want to be is an „employer of choice“.


All that does is dramatically increase the number of
unqualified or marginal applicants, which increase both
the probability of selection errors and cost-per-hire. Our
strategy is to hire choice employees or to seek the
market-place by having them self-selected even before
they apply. We want all applicants to understand that
this is a demanding, high-performing organization. To
achieve this, we try to communicate in every possible
interaction that this is a place that values talent and
exceptional effort. For those employees, we provide
exceptional rewards and career opportunities. We
cannot be everything to everyone, and we do not want
to be.“

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 211


Improving Employer Attractiveness

Target Group Competitors‘ Areas to


Potential
Preferences strengths improve

A A

B B B

C C

D D D

E E E

realistic relevant special

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 212


Key Terms

Worktime Recording - Flexible Working Structures -


Working Hours Model - Working Time Autonomy - Trust-
Based Working Hours - Flextime - Part-time Work - German
Kurzarbeit - Long-term Accounts - Job-Sharing - Work-Life-
Balance - Homeoffice (Telework) - Age-oriented Personnel
Policy - Hoteling - Non-territorial Workspace - Employee
Survey - Survey Feedback - Organizational Development -
Gallup's Q12 - Follow-up Processes - Pulse Survey -
Employer Attractiveness

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 213


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention

Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 214


Main Questions

 What is relevant and voluntary turnover and what


are related turnover costs?

 How can the risk of voluntary turnover be


estimated?

 How and why do employees leave voluntarily?

 What are major components of a retention


strategy?

 Which measures help to effectively retain talent?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 215


Common Views

 People who join for money leave for money


 People join companies and leave bosses
 You don‘t need to care about retention if you do
well with all the rest
 Employees are free, which is fine
 At the end of the day retention is all about
leadership
 Losing an employee leads to costs 1-2 times of
his/her annual salary
 The strongest are the first to leave the company
 Happy employees prefer to stay
 To a certain extent turnover is good

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 216


Turnover

 Turnover  Involuntary Turnover


The process in which Turnover initiated by the
employees leave the organization (often among
organization and have to be people who would prefer to
replaced stay)

 Voluntary Turnover  Early Turnover


Turnover initiated by Voluntary Turnover during
employees against the wish the first few weeks/months
of the company of employment

 Turnover Rate
Number of Employees leaving the Company in a Year
 100%
Number of Employees at Midyear

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 217


Turnover-Performance-Relation

Turnover

Average

Low Middle High

Performance

According to: William and Livingstone (1994). Another look at the


relationship between performacne and voluntary turnover.
Academy of Management Journal, 37, 269-298.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 218


Differentiated Turnover Rate

High Performer/
High-Potentials ?

Others

Key
Non-Key-Functions
Functions

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 219


Turnover Cost
Training
Onboarding
Hiring
Visible („Direct“) Cost Selection
Marketing
Vacancy Lost
Separation Productivity of
Other Employees
Learning
Curve of
Hidden („Indirect“) Cost Lost New Hire
Productivity of
Other Employees
Lost
Productivity of
Lost Vacant Position
Productivity of
Other Employees
Lost
Productivity
of Incumbant

Pre-Departure Vacancy Introduction

Employee Leaves New Employee New Employee


Hired Fully Effective
Source: Corporate Leadership Council (1998). Employee Retention. Washington: The Corporate Executive Board.
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 220
Fictitious Cost Estimation

Annual Salary
60.000 € Assumptions
of an employee

Cost per Hire 6.000 € 10% of annual salary

Onboarding (off-the-job) 12.000 € 20% of annual salary

Loss of Motivation 50% less performance in the last 3


7.500 €
(former employee) months of employment

Productivity Losses 10% less performance of 5 colleagues


10.000 €
(colleagues) (similar salary) during 4 months

Performance deficit 50% less performance in the first 6


15.000 €
(new employee) months of employment

No value creation for 2 months due to


Opportunity Costs 10.000 €
vacant position

Σ 60.500 €

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 221


Turnover Cost

Tunover cost ranges as a percentage of annual salary


0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450

Entry Level
Service/Production Workers
Skilled Hourly Range
Clerical/Administrative
Professional
Technical
Engineers
Specialists
Supervisor/Team Leader
Middle Managers

Source: Managing Talent Retention: An ROI Approach


by Jack J. Phillips and Lisa Edwards (2008)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 222


Individual Risk Analysis

major
Keneth Keith Carlson Garth McGrath

Mark Myer John Shark

Kelley Clark
Impact Tom Scott Rock Stewart

Paul Paulson Susan Power

Linda Anderson
Russ Rothen

Pete Peters
Paul Cummings
minimal

possible Likelihood likely


of Turnover

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 223


Individual Indicator of Intention to Leave

 Sudden performance drop

 Frequent short-term absence

 Reduced social interaction and isolation

 Frequent complaints

 Glorify other companies

 Reduced willingness to take over responsibility

 Pessimism about future perspective

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 224


Top-Management View on Retention

Source: The Economist Intelligence Unit 2008


(Responses of 1.000 executives around the
globe). The original question was: Which of the
following factors are most likely to hinder your
company’s ability to retain talented employees
over the next three years? Select up to three
(Answers in %)
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 225
Marienthal. The Sociography of an Unemployed
Community. Jahoda (1933)

Source: Archiv für die Geschichte der Soziologie in Österreich

Source: Jahoda, M., Lazarsfeld, P. F, Zeisel, H. (1933). Die Arbeitslosen von Marienthal. Ein
soziographischer Versuch über die Wirkungen langandauernder Arbeitslosigkeit. Hirzel.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 226


The Psychological Contract

Employer provides Employee provides

 Salary  Performance
 Benefits  Creativity
 Social contacts  Capabilities
 Tasks  Knowledge
 Training  Talent
 Image  Energy
 Identity  Time
 Security  Health
 Values  Social Networks
 Perspective  Customers

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 227


Relative Job Evaluation

better Relevance
Copmany Image
Perspective
high
Location
W-L-B
middle
Difference
alternative Job Tasks
compared to
current Job Salary
low

Boss
Peers
Security
similar/
worse
low Certainty high
of Value of alternative Jobs

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 228


Rational Decison Making

Value (V)

Vchange

Vact Valt Intention to Leave


= Valt – Vact - Vchange

Current Alternative Cost of Intention


Job Job Change to Leave

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 229


Turnover Decision Style

high
Solution Strategy

Elaboration

low Escape Job-Hopping

current future
Situation Situation

Driver

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 230


Exit-Interview
Example: Intel

 What was the main reason that you decided  Pay


to leave?  Benefits
 Is your new position in a different line of work  Location
than the one you where in while at Intel?
 Working Conditions
 How would you characterize your new
 Job Security
employer?
 Would you say your new employer is better  Career Opportunities
than Intel, about the same as Intel, or not as  Product Quality
good as Intel in terms of:  Co-workers
 How would you descibe your relationship with
 Company Leadership
your manager while you where at Intel?
 Company Image
 How would you describe your experience with
Intel?
 If a friend approached you and told you
he/she was looking for a similar position at
Intel, how likely would you be recommend
Intel?
 Any other comments about Intel or you new
position?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 231


Multiple Regression Analysis

Salary X1

W/L-Balance X2

Perspective X3

Intention
Peers X4 Y
to Leave
Training X5

Tasks X6

Security X7

Y = β0 + β1X1 + β2X2 + β3X3 + β4X4 + β5X5 + β6X6 + β7X7 + ε

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 232


Components of a Retention Strategy

 What is the relevant internal target group?


Target Group E.g. particular Units, Jobs, Countries, (Key) Functions,
High-Potentials, Managers

 What are related turnover costs?


Problem General and differentiated? Which kinds of costs are
generated?

 Why do employees leave the company?


Causes What are the internal and external factors and reasons for
leaving?

 Anticipating turnover and related impact


Risks How big is the likelihood of employees leaving the company
and what are related consequences?

 How can employees be retained?


Measures Which options are there to effectively retain employees?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 233


Where is the Problem?

Employees with a strong intention to leave

Employees without intention to leave

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 234


Levels of a Retention Strategy

Causes Risks Measures

Employee Survey Improving Employer


Differentiated Attractiveness
Organization Exit-Interview
Turnover Rate E.g. Internal Talent Market,
Regression Analysis Flexible Working Hours

Development,
Management Current and previous Selection, Coaching,
Manager
Evaluation Turnover Rate Replacement,
Objective Setting

Performance Individual Risk New projects, new


Management, Analysis, Performance tasks and colleagues,
Employee
Turnover Decision Management salary adjustmenet,
Styles Intention to Leave more flexibility

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 235


Key Terms

Turnover Rate (differentiated) - Voluntary versus


involuntary Turnover - Visible/hidden Turnover Costs -
Opportunity Costs - Individual Turnover Risk - Turnover
Risk Analysis - Intention to leave - Relative Job Evaluation -
Marienthal-Study - Psychological Contract - Turnover
Decision Styles - Job-Hobbing - Exit Interview - Multiple
Regression Analysis - Employee Commitment - Retention
Management

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 236


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 237


Main Questions

 What is meant by a change and what are major


types of changes in organizations?

 Why and how do changes often lead to


dysfunctional human reactions?

 How can employees be led throgh changes by


applying change management measures?

 Which conditions are required to effectively


manage change?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 238


Types of Changes in Organizationen

Re- Re- Mergers & Strategy Cultural


structuring engineering Acquisition Change Change

Changing Changing Changing the Changing Changing


organizational processes, the identities of priorities, values,
structures and way work is organizations ultimate attitudes and
reporting lines done direction and behavior
purposes

+ =

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 239


Organizational Structure
based on Functions of Products

Executive Executive
Board Board

Marketing Production Sales PC Printer

PC Printer PC Printer PC Printer M P S M P S

Functions Products

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 240


Two Leadership Cultures

We want our people to behave People need structure and


like adults. That‘s why we treat guidance. That‘s why our leaders
them that way. Each employee is will never stop telling our
responsible for what he/she employees as clearly as possible
decides. We believe in our what‘s expected from them.
people‘s own initiative to Control is better than trust.
contribute to our company‘s Organizations need rules. And
success -- everybody at his/her rules always need somebody
place. We do everything to avoid who takes care for them. Nobody
static structures, order or control. wants to suffer from corporate
We simply don‘t need it. chaos.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 241


Human Response to disruptive Changes

Emotional
Response Anger
Acceptance
active

Bargaining

Stability

Denial Testing

Immobilization
Depression
passive

Time

According to: Kübler-Ross: On Death and Dying (1967)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 242


Resistance

 Resistance is a natural human reaction to


disruptive events (fear of losing control)
 Change is seen by different people differently
according to their individual frames of reference
 Resistant employees are often seen as non-
rationally thinking troublemakers
 Resistance of informal opinion leaders are of
greater power than those of formal leaders
 There is always a mixture of overt and hidden
resistance. Overt resistance should be a valuable
aspect of any change process
 Active involvement is propably the best way to
deal with resistance

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 243


Reactions to positive Changes, for which the
individual is responsible

Pessimism

Level of Tolerance

Informed Pessimism
Hopeful Realism
Checking
Out (?)

Informed Optimism

Uninformed
Optimism (Naivité) Completion

Time

Source: Conner, D. R. (2006). Managing at the Speed of Change. Random House

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 244


Why Transformation Efforts Fail
John Kotter, 1995

1. Establishing a Sense 5. Empowering broad-


of Urgency based Action

2. Creating the Guiding 6. Generating


Coalition Short-Term Wins

3. Developing a Vision 7. Consolidating Gains &


and Strategy Producing More Change

4. Communicating the 8. Anchoring New


Change Vision Approaches in the
Culture

Source: Kotter, J. (1995). Leading Change: Why transformation efforts


fail. Harvard Business Review. March-April 1995, pp. 61-67.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 245


Sources of Complacency

Too much happy talk


from senior
Human nature, with its management A kill-the-messenger-
capacity for denial, of-bad-news, low-
especially if people are confrontation culture
already busy or stressed

The absence of a Too many


major and visible visible
Complacency resources
crisis

Organizational structures
Low overall that focus employees on
performance narrow functional goals
standards
Internal measurement
A lack of sufficient systems that focus on
performance feedback the wrong performance
from external sources indexes

According: Kotter. J. (1996): Leading Change. Harvard Business School Press

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 246


Change Management Framework

Environment Action Fields


Initialization

Sponsorship/ Change
Commitment Scope, Objectives Analysis
& Vision

Program
Setup & Communication
organization
Principles

Planning & Training &


Design Support
Control

HRM Change
Involvement
Integration

Stabilization

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 247


Dilemmas require Guiding Principles

Prevent
We don't do losses We avoid too
things by much noise
halves
Addressing
80/20: Focus on problems
what really
matters Avoid
additional
costs
We take along
all people Speed matters

We avoid any Quality: doing


irritation things right
We endure
pain

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 248


Change Analysis

Situation Situation Chances/F Training


Target Group Risks
before after ears Needs

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 249


Stakeholder-Analysis
„Pain-Power-Analysis“

strong
✔D ✖ Opponent
✖ ✔ A
✖ B
✔ Supporter

✖  Promoter

Power  Influencer

 Decider

✔  Multiplier
✖C ✔
weak  Patient
less Impact much
„Pain“

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 250


Top Management Sponsorship/Commitment

Level of Support
Commitment

Investment
Sponsorship/
Commitment
Convincement

Acceptance
Acceptance
Understanding

Listening Attention

Time
No Idea
Ignorance
According: Conner, D. R. (2006). Managing at the Speed of Change. Random House

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 251


Roles
Program Organization Target Group

Sponsor

Steering Group SB

CA FK

MA
MA
Project Team Project Lead

CA FK

SB
Change
Agent

CA
Consulting
Team Project Lead
SB

Partner SB

Sounding Board

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 252


Roles in a Change Program 1/2

 Sponsors
– Have the power to sanction and legitimize change and
to make decisions about change
– Create an environment that enables change to be
made on time and within budget
– The sponsors make up the steering group

 Change Agents
– Responsible for making the change happen on an
operational local level
– They directly deal with employees and managers,
who are impacted by the change (targets)

 Target
– The group who must actually change attitudes and
behaviour

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 253


Roles in a Change Program 2/2

 Project Team
– Operationally drives the entire change program
– The project team is led by the project leader, who is
responsible for the overall success of the program
– The project team reports to the steering group

 Sounding Board
– Key-players with a good sense of the company‘s culture and
the actual mindset of the employees
– Provide feedback to the project team about acceptance and
resistance on side of the target

 External Advisors
– Give advice to the project team from a neutral standpoint

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 254


Corporate Communication Channels and
Activities

Available Media

 Employee Newspaper  Intranet, Social Media


 E-Mail Newsletter (with forums and
(Meassage from the CEO) chatrooms)
 Intranet  Department Meetings
One-direction

(with F&Qs)
 Individual employee

Interactive
 Town Hall Meeting meetings

 Broschures  Open Space Events


 Posters  „Ask-the-CEO“-Meetings
 Videos, webcasts  Workshops, Conferences
 PPT-Presentations  Hotline
 Social Media

New Media

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 255


Dimensions of a Communication Plan

 When to inform?  What will be the


content, main
 Who will inform, send message?
the message (CEO,
Manager, Project  Why is it relevant?
Leader)? What should be
achieved with the
 How will be informed, message?
which media will be
used?  Whom to inform,
which target group?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 256


Communication Plan
Example

When Who How What Why Whom

Invitation to All
March 1 CEO Mail Manager Meeting
Save the Date
Managers

All Dept. Objectives of Announcement All


March 12 Managers Change Open Space Employees
Meeting

Project Agenda, Open Clarity about All


March 18 Intranet Space Schedule Open Space Employees
Lead

Manager role at Manager All


March 20 CEO Mail Open Space Briefing Managers

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 257


Communication Dilemma

Early
Communication ? Late
Communication

High
Need for Information
and Planning

Knowledge,
Certainty

Low

Time, Progress

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 258


Involvement Strategies

high Active Role


in the
Project

Individual
Focus
Measures
Groups/Works
hops
Intensity
Sounding
Board
Open Space

Social
Media
Employee
Survey
low
limited Reach broad

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 259


Open Space – Impressions

Haniel/Metro 2009
MLP 2012
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 260
The Idea Factory
Brainstore

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 261


Key Terms

Change - Change Management - Re-enigneering -


Restructuring - Product- versus functionoriented Organization
- Merger & Acquisition - Culture Change - Leadership Culture -
Strategic Change - Change Curve - Resistance (overt/hidden) -
Locus of Control - Informal Thought/Opinion Leader -
Uninformed optimism - Sense of Urgency - Quick (Short-term)
Win - Vision - Change Analysis - Change Management Principle
- Stakeholder - Stakeholder Analysis - Management
Sponsorship - Sponsor - Steering Committee - Change Agent -
Sounding Board - Communication - Communication Dilemma -
Communication Strategy - Training - Stakeholder Involvement -
Focus Group - Open Space Event

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 262


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 263


Main Questions

 What are central and local responsibilities in an


international HR organization?

 How are responsibilities of an HR department


changing?

 What are major roles/areas in a modern HR


organization?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 264


Global Organization

Headquarter

Regional Headquarter

Subsidiary

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 265


Variety of International Organizations

International Multinational

Headquarter as ethnocentric, Local differentiation as


strategic and cultural center. guiding principle. Subsidiaries
Resources are transferred from act autonomously in order to
Headquarter to local units. meet local need.

Global Transnational

The world is seen as one single For all relevant processes the
market. Operations are right balance between local
controlled centrally from the differentiation and global
corporate office in order to integration is achieved .
achieve global integration.

Source: Bartlett, C.A. & Ghoshal, S. (2002). Managing Across Borders. Harvard Business School Press.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 266


Balance in a transnational Approach

global
Employer Branding
Career
website
Executive HR-IT
Compensation
Employee
Referral
Program
Global
Integration Talent Campus
management Recruiting

Office Candidate
Training Selection
Training

local
Local Differentiation

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 267


From traditional to future HR

Strategy

Consulting

Support

Administration

Traditional HR Future HR

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 268


The 4 Ps of HR

Critical role in helping to


Player develop any business
strategy

HR professionals helping the business


Partner lines solve their human issues

The protectors of company


Police policies and procedures

The politest people in the


Polite company

Source: Les Hayman (2010). http://leshayman.wordpress.com/2010/08/26/hr-polite-to-police-to-partner-to-player/

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 269


The Dave Ulrich HR Role Model

Strategy

Strategic Partner Change Agent


Defining and Creating a renewed
executing strategy organization
Processes

People
Administrative Employee Champion
Expert
Increasing employee
Building an efficient commitment and
infrastructure capability

Operation
Source: Ulrich, D (1997(: Human Resource Champions.
Harvard Business School Press.
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 270
HR Business Partner Responsibilities
 Provide HR consultation, policy interpretation,
and strategic planning to all levels of client
organization.
 Manage HR projects and program
implementation for Public Policy, Law, &
Security and Strategy, Development, &
Planning organizations.
 Responsible for providing Human Resources
support in the areas of ethics, compliance,
EEO, compensation planning, performance

* management, talent management, headcount


management, leadership development,
staffing, absence management, employee
relations, and labor relations.
 Ability to influence without direct authority.
 Provide analysis of data and monitor HR
results through key metrics. Develop and
communicate status of key initiatives with HR
reports.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 271


Managing Queries

Intranet
Q&A
Call-Center,
Virtual HR Service HR Expert,
Assistent Center HR Business HR Director
(shared) Partner
ESS
Hotline
Yellow
Page

70 % 20 % 5% 5%
100% 30 % 10 % 5% 0%

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 272


Decentralized Recruiting Organization

HR Application
Marketing management

Definition of Target
Profile Preselection Application
Unit
A Data Base
Introduction Assessment

Job Offer Job Offer


Preparation Negotiation
Applicant
HR Application
Marketing management

Definition of Target
Preselection
Profile Unit Application
B Data Base
Introduction Assessment

Job Offer Job Offer


Preparation Negotiation

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 273


Selecting Tasks to be handled by a Shared
Service Center

close
Assessment
Introduction

Job Offer
Negotiation

Job Offer
Close to
Preparation Preselection
Applicant

Application
management Definition of
HR Target Profile
Marketing

far
high Standardization low

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 274


Integrated Recruiting Organization with
centralized e-Recruiting Technology

Definition of Target
Profile Unit
A
Introduction Assessment

Job Offer Negotiation HR Application


marketing management

Pre-
Shared
Applicant e-Recruiting Recruiting
Selection
Center

Job Offer
Preparation
Definition of Target
Profile Unit
B
Introduction Assessment

Job Offer Negotiation

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 275


Three Pillar Model of modern HR-Organization

Central Coordination

HR Business Partner Center of Expertise


Customers
near to business company wide

Individual support of
Dealing with complex HR-
Managers managers on HR-
related Issues
related topics

Shared Service Center


IT
company wide

Employees Hotline
Delivery of standardized and regularly
Applicants ESS demanded services to all employees with
high volume (e.g. payroll)
MSS

Partner-/Supplier Management

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 276


Outsourcing, Onshoring, Offshoring

multi-client
Offshore
Outsourcing
Scope of Service Delivery

single-client

Onshore
Outsourcing
internal

Shared
Onshoring Service Offshoring
Center

near/ close far


home
Cultural/regional Distance

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 277


Prioritizing Tasks to be outsourced

high Strategic
Employer Branding
Performance
Relevance
(EVP)
Management

Trainee- high
Programs
Top-Management
Placements
Specificity of middle
Expatriation
Requirements Recruiting for
Exit-
Interviews Non-Key Functions low

Payroll Onboarding

MS Office Trainings

Pension

low
less Internal Competence more
compared to external service provider

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 278


Reasons why Companies outsource

Focus Quality Costs Flexibility

Focus on company‘s External service Leveraging Demand for services


core competencies providers are long- economies of scale, depends on actual
and on ultimate term experts in their competition against needs
purpose of the field and compete other service
organization against other service providers, purchasing
providers power of client

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 279


Key Terms

Global Integration - Local Differentiation - Global HR


Organization - International HR Organization - Multinational
HR Organization - Transnational HR Organization - HR
Target Role Model - HR Business Partner - Virtual Assistant
- Shared Service Center - Center of Expertise - Three Pillar
Model of modern HR Organization - Outsourcing -
Onshoring - Offshoring

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 280


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 281


Main Questions

 What are major IT-solutions in HR?

 What is the difference between expert-systems


and user-systems?

 What are major functionalities of HR IT-solutions


in fields like recruiting or learning?

 What are future trends in HR-IT?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 282


HR-Software Provider

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 283


The Solution of Workday

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 284


Expert-System

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 285


Typical Solutions of Expert- and User-Systems

Administration Value Creation


Standardized processing Creative usage
Automatization Personal judgements
Reliable results Fuzzy output

Employees*  Master Data  Skill-Maintenance


Rare usage Maintenance  360-Degree-Feedback
Event-triggered  Leave Request  Performance Appr.
No training efforts  Course Booking  Application
 Time Record  Online-Training

Experts (HR)  Payroll  Intern Talent Pools


Frequent usage  Pre-Selection  Succession Planning
Limited to intense
 Training Admin.  Talent Review
training efforts
 Internal Mobility  Course Development
 Interview planning  Job Posting
* Employees, Manager, Applicants etc.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 286


Screenshot „Abwesenheitsmitteilung“

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 287


Roles and Activities as Part of a Recruiting-
Process ...
Applicant

Application
Recruiter

Pre- Work
Job Posting Interview
Selection Contract
Manager

Vacancy Pre-
Selection Onboarding
Request Selection
Systems
Related

Organisations Online- Competence Payroll


Management Jobboard Management

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 288


... and how they appear on the Screen

Cornerstone

SuccessFactors

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 289


Learning Management System (e-Learning)

Learner Portal LMS CMS External


personalized & Learning Management Content Management Content
intranet-based System System

Qualifications Training Learning Literature


Administration Content Databases
Generation
Role
Learning
Strategies Relevant
Embedding Websites
external
Personalized
Profile-Matching Content
Training Offers
Communities of
Formal Practice
Tests & Standards
Learning History Certificates

Authorization
Analytics
Collaboration

Authorization & Company


Tests Accounting Information

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 290


Hype Cycle for Human Capital Management
Software (Gartner, 2012)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 291


Trends

Bring your
Social Mobile Cloud Big Data
own Device

Employees use Solutions support Data usage and IT Resources Smart usage of
their private and collaboration and maintenance such as software, mostly
most preferred communication at anywhere at storage space that unstructurred, fast
devices and work anytime. are delivered as a changing data of
systems at work services over a very high volume
(e.g. Handy, Laptop, Interfaces to Availability of network (internet)
Mail-Systems) Social Media systems on
Plattforms (e.g. smartphones and
LinkedIn, Xing) tablets.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 292


Key Terms

HR Information System - User-System - Expert System -


Usability - Employee Self Service (ESS) - Administration
versus Value Creation - e-Recruiting - Learning
Management System (LMS) - Mobile HR - Gartner Hype
Cycle - Bring your own Device - Cloud Computing - Big
Data

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 293


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 294


Main Questions

 How are both the role of the users and the


markets affected by Web 2.0 and social media?

 What are practical examples of social media


usage in the field of HRM?

 How can social media be implemented and what


are different types of social media usage?

 What are relevant conditions for effective social


media implementation and usage?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 295


From Web 1.0 to Web 2.0

Web 1.0 Web 2.0

www....com www....com

Publisher Content Consumer Content Prosumer

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 296


Social Media

www....com

A A

B B

C C

User profiles, Content & Relations

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 297


Google PageRank versus Social Bookmarks

 The more links refer to a


D C A website the higher is its
Google PageRank
 The Google-Algorithm
F
takes into account the
PageRank of the
E B referring sites

Social Bookmarking. The relative importance of a


website depends on the number of people who like it.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 298


Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 299
Forrester‘s seven overlapping Levels of
Social Technology Participation

2013

Source: http://empowered.forrester.com/tool_consumer.html

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 300


Cluetrain Manifesto (1999)
Selected Theses (10 of 95)

 Markets are conversations  We are waking up and linking


to each other. We are
 In both internetworked
watching. But we are not
markets and among
waiting
intranetworked employees,
people are speaking to each  But first, they must belong to
other in a powerful new way a community
 Companies can now  Markets do not want to talk to
communicate with their flacks and hucksters. They
markets directly. If they blow want to participate in the
it, it could be their last chance conversations going on
behind the corporate firewall
 To speak with a human voice,
companies must share the  You're too busy "doing
concerns of their business" to answer our
communities. email? Oh gosh, sorry, gee,
we'll come back later. Maybe.
 We know some people from
your company. They're pretty  There are no secrets ...
cool online ...
Source: Rick Levine, Christopher Locke, Doc Searls: Das Cluetrain Manifest. Econ Verlag 2002
Siehe auch: www.cluetrain.com/

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 301


Social Media are faster and more targeted than
any traditional Media

Journalist Editor Medium


Incident

Journalist Interview Draft Article Reader

Time

Incident

Victim Tweet Follower Follower‘

Time

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 302


Democratization of
Human Resource Management?

 Employers are evaluated by  Employees and candidates


current and former decide what‘s good or bad
employees and applicants
 Teacher and learner become
 User share image-videos and the same -- users produce
job ads – the good and the and share knowledge content
bad ones
 Users who share similar
 Everybody can act as a interests communicate,
headhunter – and earn collaborate and learn in
money virtual communities
 Candidates are present in the  Current and former
web and passively wait for employees evaluate each
employers to approach them other
 Interviewers, future  People share their thoughts
colleagues and managers are about strategic corporate
googled by candidates changes

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 303


Social Media/Web 2.0 in Talent Acquisition
Employer Outside Career Job- Inter- Talent Candidate
Branding View Infos Posting action Search Retention

Blogs

Forums

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 304


Social Media Roadmap

Check &
Targets Listen Do it
Develop

Target group Involve and Definition & action Constantly check


definition (whom understand target on Social Media effects of social
to reach) group Activities media activities
Setting social Consider internal Defining a social Set priorities and
media objectives conditions media policy develop selected
(what to achieve) social media
activities

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 305


Cases

Four trainess in a regional bank regularly post


events and informal affairs on Facebook. To
plan their activities they run a weekly editorial
meeting. By doing so, the trainees try to reach
pupils and raise the pupil's interest in an
apprenticeship at the bank. Moreover they
already build some relations to future
potential trainees (Fans). The four trainess
received an iPhone for free, which they can
even use for private purposes. They defined a
social media policy by their own with
supervision from the bank.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 306


Cases

In an internationally operating accounting firm all employees were


encouraged to produce videos about their company. All videos
were then posted on an internal plattform where all employees
were asked to vote for the best ones, which then were presented
on YouTube. The ultimate objective of this initiative was to present
an authentic picture of the company to the outside world and to
attract potential candidates.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 307


Cases

Employees of an internationally operating company in the


telecommunication industry gave HR access to their LinkedIn-
profiles. Once there is an attractive applicant, his/her relation to
current employees is checked and -- if possible -- HR tries to seek
internal references. The ones who deliver references are then
asked to name further candidates in his/her social network who
might fit to the profile in question just as you would do in an
employee referral program.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 308


Cases

A german provider of financial software


got rid of the regular employee survey.
They ask their employees to rate the
company on kununu* instead. Each
quarter, all comments, traffic-indicators
and results are reported and discussed
by the executive board.

* www.kununu.com. Glassdoor is a similar website on an


international basis (www.glassdoor.com)

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 309


Cases

On a simple, internal platform all employees of an internationally


operating company in the computer gaming industry are
encouraged to assign up to ten points to colleagues they
successfully worked with. The amount of points an employee gets
by the end of the year determines his/her variable pay.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 310


Cases

A german gymn-franchiser runs an employee manual in the form


of an internal wiki. This manual describes how to deal with typical
daily problems. All employees are free to include new rules, edit
existing ones and make comments. At the end the consensus
among the employees always decides upon what's valid or not.
Only what's currently written in the manual counts. The executive
board is not empowered to impact the content of this wiki. Once
the executive board intents to change something they must bring
in their succestions just like every employee can do.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 311


Cases

In a midsize insurance company employees


are encouraged to post succestions on an
internal plattform. All employees have the
same budget of 500 Euros which they can
assign to suggestions they prefer. The one
who brought in a suggestion always gets 10%
of the total budget assigned to his/her idea.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 312


Cases

At a globally leading car manufacturer 200 exclusively selected


employees write blogs about their daily work-life. These
employees are absolutely free in what they write and how they
write. The intention is to provide authentic and appealing insights
into the daily life of this company and to attract potential
candidates. The traffic of all blog entries is constantly tracked,
which enables the company to communicate a real-time ranking-
list of all entries and bloggers. As a result all bloggers compete
against each other in reaching the top of the list.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 313


Cases

At a globally leading provider of HR-software both employees and


clients are encouraged to post product proposals on a dedicated
plattform, which in turn are commented and evaluated by
employees and clients. A core product planning committee then
prioritizes all proposals by taking into account all evaluations and
comments on a regular basis. Decisions are always
communicated on the same platform. Those clients, who are
engaged the most are invited to an annual client roundtable.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 314


Social Network Analysis

Nodes –
Relations – Density – Centrality –
Cliques – Cluster (Community) – Stars

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 315


Ways of Social Media Usage

Uncontrolled passive Central Delegated


Communication Communication Communication

Some employees actively Social media is seen as just Internal target group
use social media and another channel to centrally representatives are
possibly communicate work- communicate official privileged to communicate
related content content in a one-to-many work-related content within
direction clearly defined borders

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 316


Ways of Social Media Usage

Peripheral Peripheral Strategic


Communication Connection Connection

All employees communicate Employees are encouraged Internal and external


about daily informal affairs to network both internally networks are strategically
and events within clearly and externally and to built and used
defined borders (rules) communicate informal and
work-related content

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 317


Conditions determine the Type of Social Media
Usage

 To what degree does the executive board impact


social media usage inside the company?

 Which chances and risks are seen by the


executive board related to social media usage?

 Is the company culture driven by openness and


trust?

 Is there a natural affinity and activity towards


social media among the employees and the
company‘s social environment?

 Are there any real opportunities related to social


media usage?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 318


Typical Content of Social Media Policies

 Do not communicate any sensitive,


business-related information

 Everyone is legally responsible for his/her


comments

 Conflicts among employees should be


resolved off-line

 If a member of the media contacts you


contact our public relation department

 Respect copyrights

 Be authentic and always demonstrate


respect, trust and honesty

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 319


Key Terms

Web 2.0 - Prosumer - Social Media - Enterprise 2.0 - Google


PageRank - Social Bookmark - Forrester's Level - Cluetrain
Manifesto - Democratization - Shitstorm - Career Fanpage
(Facebook) - Kununu - Blog - LinkedIn/Xing - Tweet/Retweet
- Twitter - Social Media Roadmap - Wiki - Social Network
Analysis - Node - Relation - Density - Centrality - Clique -
Cluster (Community) - Star - Ways of Social Media Usage -
Social Media Policy

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 320


HRM Landscape

HR-
Strategy &
Planning

Talent
Development

Change
Management
Learning
Talent
Acquisition Work
Retention
Candidate Compensation
Selection & Benefits

HR Social HR
HR-IT
Organization Media Controlling

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 321


Main Questions

 Why and how are indicator systems used in HR


and what are typical examples?

 How are indicators defined and implemented?

 What is the added value of employees and how


can it be estimated?

 Is it possible to estimate the ROI of large-scale


investments in Human Resource Management?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 322


Control Loop

Target

Corrective Target/Actual
Actions Deviation

Causes
Analysis

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 323


Selected Indicators in HRM

HR Marketing & Recruiting Training & Development Retention

 Employer ranking  Days of training/employee  Turnover rate


 Number of applications  High-Potential rate (general, differentiated)

 Cost per hire  Average time on current  Tenure

 Time to fill level (HiPos)  Employee commitment

 Early turnover (during  Internal placement rate  Reasons for leaving


probation period)  Trainee rate

Workforce/Organization Compensation & Benefits Performance & Productivity

 Average age  Labor costs/total costs  Revenue/employee


 Female/male ratio  Labor costs/employee  Human Capital Value
 Women in leadership  Tariff employees (%) Added (HCVA)
positions (%)  Compensation structure  Human Capital ROI
 Span of control  Sick leaves/employee
 Temporary contracts (%)  Bradford Factor (SxSxD)
 Accidents/1000 employees

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 324


Cost per Hire
What‘s in, what‘s out?

 Advertising costs  Opportunity costs related


to involved line employees
 Candidate travel costs
 Costs of recruiting
 Executive search retainer infrastructure (e.g.
and contingency fee e-Recruiting)
 Selection tools and  Referral bonuses
measures
 HR Marketing events
 Salary of employees
involved in recruiting  Sign-on-bonuses
 Costs for facilities of the  Relocation costs
recruiting organization
 Onboarding costs
 Market Research

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 325


Time to Fill

Workforce Start HR Signed Job End of


Demand Marketing/ Offer Onboarding
Search

Vacancy Selection First Day End of


at Work Probation
Period

?
?
Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 326
Relevant Indicator Dimensions

What?
Which indicator will be used?

For whom? Why?


Who is the customer To which objective does
of the indicator? the indicator relate?

How?
Which sources and methods are
used to calculate the indicator?

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 327


Balanced Scorecard

Financials
Targets KPI

Customer Processes
Targets KPI Targets KPI
Vision &
Strategy

People
Targets KPI

Source: Robert Kaplan and David Norton, “Strategic


Learning and the Balanced Scorecard, 1996

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 328


Implementing an Indicator System
Example: Turnover Early Warning

Definition of Scope/Objectives Analysis Method Definition

Definition of client, objectives Systematic analysis of turnover Definition of methods and tools
and functions causes and possible early to track/measure turnover
Setting budgets, timeline and indicators drivers and predictors
project structure Develpment of a model to Defining ways to analyse and
Approach definition explain and predict turnover report data and results
behavior
Meeting with client/steering group Interviews with managers, former Workshop with experts, clients
and project lead employees, experts and HR managers

Evaluation Operation Implementation

Checking validity and Tracking data and report to Development and


acceptance clients implementation of indicator
Defining fields for Data usage and related actions system and related technical
improvements infrastructure
Identification and training of
impacted employees (clients)
Validation study interviews with
client, user tracking

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 329


Calculating the ROI of HR-related Investments

What‘s the Problem?

What are the costs related


to the problem?

What‘s the solution?

How much does the


solution cost?

Which improvements might be


achieved through the solution?

ROI

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 330


Example

10 HiPos (20%) leave the company every year voluntarily


Problem
(average annual salary: 120.000 €)

200%* × 10 × 120.000 € = 2.400.000 €


Costs
(* Cost per turnover as a percentage of annual salary)

Solution All HiPos get a company car

50 × 10.000 €* = 500.000 €
Solution Costs
(* annual costs per company car)

Turnover reduction by 25% lead to reduced turnover


Improvements
costs of 600.000 €

ROI ROI = (600.000 € - 500.000 €)/500.000 € × 100% = 20%

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 331


Human Capital Value Added

Non-Human
Capital Value Creation
Total Costs - Labor
Costs
Products
Revenue

Human Capital
Labor Costs

Human Capital
Value Added = Revenue – (Total Costs – Labor Costs)

Source: Jac Fitz-Enz (2000). The ROI of Human Capital. Amacon.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 332


Value Added and Rentabiliy*

Döner Shop Design Office


1 FTE 1 FTE

Human
40

Revenue Human Revenue


220 180 220
Non-
Human
160
Non-
Human
20
Human Capital 220-160 220-20
= 60 = 200
Value Added/FTE 1 1

Human Capital 220-160 220-20


= 1,50 = 1,11
ROI (Rentability) 40 180
* in 1.000 €

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 333


HCVA/Employee* in german DAX30-Companies
(2007)

Addidas 70 Metro 26

Allianz 136 RWE 132

Bayer 94 SAP 163

Daimler 97 Siemens 70

Henkel 69 TUI 29

Hypo Real Estate 556 Volkswagen 23

* In 1.000 €

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 334


Performance Indicators
Example

Company Performance

Revenue 200.000 k€ Revenue/FTE 100 k€


Employees 2.000 FTE Profit/FTE 10.000 €
Total Costs 180.000 k€ HCVA 160.000 k€
Labor Costs 140.000 k€ HCVA/FTE 80 k€
Work days/Year 220 HCROI 114 %

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 335


Added Value in Key Functions
compared to other Functions

Added Value

1 2 3 Key Functions

0,5 1 1,5 Other Functions

C B A
Performance

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 336


Differentiated Added Value Calculation

C 10% B 70% A 20%


Key FTE 20 FTE 140 FTE 40
Functions Factor 1 Factor 2 Factor 3
Per employee (1.000 €): Per employee (1.000 €): Per employee (1.000 €):
10% HCVA 69 HCVA 139 HCVA 208
Labor Costs 80 Labor Costs 100 Labor Costs 120
Benefit - 11 Benefit 39 Benefit 88
Others FTE 180 FTE 1.260 FTE 360
Factor 0,5 Factor 1 Factor 1,5
Per employee (1.000 €): Per employee (1.000 €): Per employee (1.000 €):
90%
HCVA 35 HCVA 69 HCVA 104
Labor Costs 60 Labor Costs 70 Labor Costs 90
Benefit -25 Benefit -1 Benefit 14

Source: Trost, A. & von Bothmer, L. (2010). Lohnende Rechenspiele In


Personalwirtschaft 07/2010 S. 22-24.

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 337


Four simple Business Cases

 To hire an A-Player in a key function one day faster


than before: 536 €/day

 To hire an A-Player instead of a B-Player into a key


function: 49.000 €/year

 To increase productivity of all (1.260) B-Players in


non-key functions by 1%: 869.400 €/year

 To convert a C-Player into a B-Player in a non-key


function: 15.000 €/year

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 338


Key Terms

Control Loop - HR Controlling - Indicator System -


Employer Ranking - Time to fill - Cost per Hire - Early
Turnover - Trainee Rate - Span of Control - Bradford Factor
- Indicator Dimensions - Balanced Scorecard - Return on
Investment (ROI) - Human Capital Value Added - Human
Capital ROI

Prof. Dr. Armin Trost Human Resource Management www.armintrost.de 339

Potrebbero piacerti anche