Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Unit 1
Enabling Objectives
Students should be able to:
Discuss dust explosions
and fires as a significant
safety problem that may
affect them;
Explain how these events
occur and how they may
have catastrophic Metal
Dust
consequences to employees themselves Collector
-
and to the die casting plant; and, Exploded
Identify the materials used in die casting and
Collapsed
that may cause dust explosions and/or fires
and how they may be prevented or reduced
in severity if they occur.
This presentation is based on
“Combustible Dust in Industry. . .” - OSHA
Safety and Health Information Bulletin (SHIB 07-31-
2005) (download at
http://www.osha.gov/dts/shib/index.html )
NFPA 484
“Standard for Combustible Metals”, 2009 Ed.
(on-line free viewing at
http://www.nfpa.org/aboutthecodes/list_of_codes_and_
standards.asp )
Combustible
Dust
Explosions
Background
This section describes a series of horrific dust
explosions that have occurred recently.
• The US Chemical Safety and Accident
Investigation Board (CSB) and OSHA have
identified these explosions as representative
of a national safety problem.
• The list includes a spectacular metal dust
explosion and fire in Indiana that killed one
and injured one employee.
Background
Organic Dust Fires and Explosions:
– Massachusetts
(3 killed, 9 injured)
– North Carolina
(6 killed, 38 injured)
– Kentucky
(7 killed, 37 injured
Metal Dust Fire and Explosion: Indiana
(1 killed,1 injured)
Recent Sugar Dust Explosion
Common Causal Factors
• Housekeeping to
control dust
accumulations
unacceptable;
• Ventilation system
design flaws;
• Lack of Hazard
Assessment;
• Lack of explosion
prevention and
mitigation.
Phenol
formaldehyde resin
polyethylene dust
Imperial Sugar Company
Port Wentworth GA
Explosion and Fire
February 7, 2008
14 Deaths and Numerous serious injuries
US Chemical Safety and
Hazard Investigation Board Photo
US Chemical Safety and
Hazard Investigation Board Photo
US Chemical Safety and
Hazard Investigation Board Photo
US Chemical Safety and
Hazard Investigation Board Photo
US Chemical Safety and
Hazard Investigation Board Photo
US Chemical
Safety Board
– Found a pattern
of catastrophic
dust explosions
– Recommended
that OSHA take
action
– MSDS sheets
often fail to
provide dust
explosion
information
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR Occupational Safety and Health Administration
SUBJECT:
Combustible Dust National Emphasis Program
Some event
disturbs the
settled dust
into a cloud
Dust cloud is
ignited and
Adapted from CSB
explodes
Dust explosion in
equipment
Dust
collector
venting
flame jet
Dustexplosion
Dust explosioninin
equipment
equipment
Dust
Collector
With dispersal
and ignition of 2 kg dust
by the flame jet
Dust explosions
An initial (primary)
explosion in
• processing equipment or
in an area where fugitive dust
has accumulated:
– may shake loose more
accumulated dust; or,
– damage a containment system (such
as a duct, vessel, or collector).
• The additional dust dispersed into the air
may cause one or more secondary
explosions.
• These can be far more destructive
than a primary explosion.
Primary deflagration inside process equipment
Carefully identify:
• Materials that can be
combustible when finely divided;
• Processes which use, consume,
or produce combustible dusts;
• Open areas where combustible
dusts may build up;
• Hidden areas where
combustible dusts may
accumulate;
• Means by which dust may be
dispersed in the air; and
• Potential ignition sources.
Dust Combustibility
See
The primary factor in an Explosives
regulations
assessment of these
hazards is whether the
dust is in fact
combustible.
Determine if a dust cloud
will:
– Detonate
– Deflagrate
– Present a fire hazard
– Or will Not burn or
ignite
Testing may be necessary
Dust Combustibility
See
A detonation is a combustion Explosives
event that burns faster than regulations
the speed of sound:
• Not common in industry;
• Not generally the
problem in an industrial dust
explosion.
A deflagration is a combustion
event that burns slower than
the speed of sound:
• A pushing force;
• The mechanism of destruction in most
combustible dust explosions.
Dust Combustibility
Concentration 1000X
Dust Combustibility
25 watt light bulb probably can not be
seen through six feet of a mixture of
combustible dust in air > Minimum
Explosible Concentration What
bulb
?
2 meters
40 g/m3 concentration of
comb. dust suspended in air
25 watts
Glass Glass
What is wrong here?
Dust Combustibility
Information sources
– Best to rely on “As used” test data
– Chemical supplier test data
– MSDS sheets Variables
– Published tables • Particle size,
• Shape
• Changes in the material
produced by process
equipment.
• Many others
Dust from Die Casting Alloys
Produced
Chips
Dust
Resulting in
Facility Analysis Components
Dust Combustibility
Practice Quiz
1. The primary factor in an assessment of a material’s dust
explosion hazard is to:
A. Determine whether the dust is in fact combustible
B. Measure the size of the particles
C. Determine if the dust will pass through a #40 USG
screen
D. None of the above
2. A deflagration is a combustion event that:
A. Burns at a rate slower than the speed of
sound
B. Provides a “pushing force”
C. Is the mechanism of destruction in most industrial
dust explosions.
D. All of the above
Facility Analysis Components
Dust Combustibility
Practice Quiz
Dust Layer
Class II Group E Metal Dust Areas
Plan/Top
Elevation/Side
View
View
Dust Source
HAZ LOC
Dust Control
NFPA 484
• Locate relief valves away
from dust hazard areas; and
• Develop and implement a
hazardous dust
– inspection,
– testing,
– housekeeping, and
– control program
(Written with
established frequency and
methods).
Dust Control
• OSHA discusses
housekeeping in detail.
• Inspection program
provides insight on how
they interpret housekeeping
• The program is listed on
the web at
http://www.osha.gov/pls/osh
aweb/owadisp.show_docum
ent?p_table=DIRECTIVES&
p_id=3830
OSHA NEP on Housekeeping
• Clean immediately
whenever a dust layer of
1/32-inch thickness
accumulates (the thickness
of a paper clip wire)
– over a surface area of at
least 5% of the floor area
of the facility or any given
room. 2
– Not to exceed 1,000 ft
Taking a
sample in a
dusty area
OSHA NEP on Housekeeping
Include:
– Overhead beams, joists,
ducts,
– The tops of equipment,
and other surfaces
– Even vertical surfaces if
they are dusty
Rough calculations may show
– surface area of bar joists is approximately 5% of
the floor area and
– the equivalent surface area for steel beams can
be as high as 10%.
Areas to observe for dust > 1/32
Inch
• Structural
members
• Conduit and
pipe racks
• Cable trays
• Floors
• Above ceiling
• Equipment
(leaks around
dust collectors
and ductwork.)
Other Hazard Analysis Considerations
Dust Control
Practice Quiz
Blast barrier
Flame
Automatic, fast- front
acting isolation diverter
valve
Electric Air
Pneumatic
initiator
actuator
Roof Line
Pressurized Gate
reservoir
Damage Control
Isolation of Equipment
Automatic
fast acting
valve
Damage Control
Airflow control valves
Diverter valves are to seal mechanically
and close all other directions from air or
material leakage
Flame
front
Hinged Diverter
Positive shut
device valve
off flap
Normal flow
of material
Damage Control
• Deflagration venting of
a building, room, or
area;
Damage Control
Deflagration venting is
required for rooms or
buildings containing a dust
explosion hazard . Blast barrier
Vent
Vent closures: wall
–Must be directed toward a
restricted area;
–Closure must not be a Explosion
missile hazard; hazard
–Blast pressure and fireball building
must not impinge on
Blast resistant
unrestricted personnel construction
pathways.
Damage Control
NFPA 654 (7.1.2)
Explosion
protection system
requirements
NFPA 69, Standard
on Explosion
Prevention
Suppression
Explosion
Total
Ignition
Suppression
Systems); Begins
Detected
Suppression
Continues
0 Mil/Sec
30
20 Mil/sec
Mil/Sec
50
40 Mil/Sec
Fire ball expands at 30 feet per second
Pressure wave expands at 1100 feet per second
Damage Control
Damage Control
Deflagration
Explosion protection pressure
– NFPA 654 (7.1.2) detectors
Mechanical
isolation
valve
Dust collector
suppression system
Deflagration
suppression
device
Damage Control
In general dry dust collectors greater
than 8 cubic feet in volume located must
be located outside.
• Outside
location
• Engineered
3 containment
>8 ft
• Venting to
outside
• Suppression
Damage Control
OSHA has fined facilities
where
• Dry dust collectors
– located inside the
Outside wall
building (some
exceptions) and/or
– dust collectors returning
air back inside the
building
• Ductwork
– not grounded
– not constructed of metal
Damage Control
Ducts must be designed to maintain
sufficient velocity to ensure the transport of
both coarse and fine particles?
E.G.: Ontario Fire Code (5.10.1.10) requires
velocity to exceed 1068 meters/minute
Dust 18m/sec
flowing 3560
ft/min
>1068 meters/minute
Dust
built
up
<1068 meters/minute
Facility Analysis Components