Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Critiques not just the topic of the movie, but how the
director treats that topic.
Why the critical essay?
It can improve critical thinking skills
It can help understand the complexities of the field
It can allow participation in discussions about your
field
A critical essay is a composition that offers an analysis,
interpretation, and/or evaluation of a text.
Remember:
Critique TREATMENT, not topic.
Critique THEME, not subject
Example: Extra-Judicial Killings
Additionally…
What do you know about the topic?
What else have you read about the topic?
What other perspectives are there regarding the topic?
Why is the topic important?
What is the writer’s position on the
topic?
Who is the writer?
Does he have affiliations? Motivations? Biases? Ulterior
Motives?
What is his/her tone?
Is he approving? Distrustful? Sarcastic?
What are his/her main points?
Make sure you know them, point by point.
How does she explain them?
Is her position clear? Logical? Believable?
How does she support them?
Does she give evidence? Are they credible?
What’s your position?
Are you convinced with what the writer said? Do you
agree? Why or why not?
Once we have considered the writer’s position, we can
proceed to the critical essay.
A critical essay is an analysis of a text such as a book, film,
article, or painting. The goal of this type of paper is to offer
a text or an interpretation of some aspect of a text or to
situate the text in a broader context.
For example, a critical analysis of a book might focus on the
tone of the text to determine how that tone influences the
meaning of the text overall.
Or, a critical analysis of a film might focus on the
significance of a recurring symbol in the film. Regardless, a
critical essay should include an argumentative thesis about
the text and plenty of textual evidence sources to help
support your interpretation of the text
Steps in writing a critical essay
Perform a critical reading of your source(s). A
critical essay assignment asks you to evaluate a book,
an article, a movie, a painting, or some other type of
text.
In order to perform a critical analysis of any text, you
need to become very familiar with the primary text.
Get to know the text inside and out by reading and
rereading it. If you have been asked to write about a
visual text like a film or piece of art, watch the film
multiple times or view the painting from various
angles and distances.
Take notes as you read your text. Taking notes as you
read will help your to remember important aspects of the
text, and it will also help you to think critically about the
text. Keep some key questions in mind as you read and
attempt to answer those questions through your notes.
What is the text about?
What are the main ideas?
What is puzzling about the text?
What is the purpose of this text?
Does the text accomplish its purpose? If not, why not? Is
so, how so?[
Review your notes to identify patterns and problems.
After you have finished reading and taking notes on your
text, look over your notes to determine what patterns are
present in the text and what problems stand out to you. Try
to identify a solution to one of the problems you have
identified. For example, you may notice that Frankenstein's
monster is often more likable than Doctor Frankenstein,
and make an educated guess about why this is.
Your solution to the problem should help you to develop a
focus for your essay, but keep in mind that you do not need
to have a solid argument about your text at this point. As
you continue to think about the text, you will move closer
to a focus and a thesis for your critical analysis essay.
Find appropriate secondary sources if required. If you are
required to use sources for your critical essay, you will need to do
some research. See your assignment guidelines or ask your
instructor if you have questions about what types of sources are
appropriate for this assignment.
Books, articles from scholarly journals, magazine articles,
newspaper articles, and trustworthy websites are some sources
that you might consider using.
Use your library’s databases rather than a general internet search.
University libraries subscribe to many databases. These
databases provide you with free access to articles and other
resources that you cannot usually gain access to by using a search
engine.
Evaluate your sources to determine their
credibility. It is important to use only trustworthy
sources in an academic essay, otherwise you will
damage your own credibility as an author. Using the
library’s databases will also help to ensure that you are
getting plenty of trustworthy sources for your paper.
Develop your tentative thesis or main idea Once
you have developed your ideas about your primary
source and read your primary sources, you should be
ready to write a thesis statement. Effective thesis
statements express the main focus of a paper and state
an arguable claim. You may find it helpful to use a
multi-sentence thesis statement, where the first
sentence offers the general idea and the second
sentence refines it to a more specific idea
Begin your essay with an engaging sentence that
gets right into your topic. Your introduction should
immediately begin discussing your topic. Think about
what you will discuss in your essay to help you
determine what you should include in your
introduction. Keep in mind that your introduction
should identify the main idea of your critical essay and
act as a preview to your essay.
Provide background information to help guide
your readers. Providing adequate background
information or context will help to guide your readers
through your essay. Think about what your readers will
need to know in order to understand the rest of your
essay and provide this information in your first
paragraph. This information will vary depending on
the type of text you have been asked to write about
Use your body paragraphs to discuss specific
components of your text. Rather than trying to talk
about multiple aspects of your text in a single paragraph,
make sure that each body paragraph focuses on a single
aspect of your text. Your discussion of each of these aspects
should contribute to proving your thesis.
For each body paragraph, you should do the following:
Provide a claim at the beginning of the paragraph.
Support your claim with at least one example from your
primary source(s).
Support your claim with at least one example from your
secondary sources.
Develop a conclusion for your essay. Your conclusion should
emphasize what you have attempted to show your readers about
your text. `Before you write your conclusion, spend some time
reflecting on what you have written so far and try to determine
the best way to end your essay. There are several good options for
ending an academic essay that might help you decide how to
format your conclusion. For example, you might: Summarize and
review your main ideas about the text.
Explain how the topic affects the reader.
Explain how your narrow topic applies to a broader theme or
observation.
Call the reader to action or further exploration on the topic.
Present new questions that your essay introduced.
Example Critical Essay: Analysis of
Babycakes
Analysis of BABYCAKES by Neil Gaiman
This story opens with the line, ‘A few years back all the animals went away.’ And
this sets you up with everything you need to know.
No one knows how or why the animals vanished; they just weren’t around
anymore. Someone points out that life shouldn’t change just because the
animals have gone. There is no reason to change eating habits, or stop product
testing.
So babies replace animals. They’re eaten, ‘Baby flesh is tender and succulent.’
Their skin is flayed and worn, ‘Baby leather is soft and comfortable.’ They are
tested on, and everything goes back to normal. Until… ‘Yesterday, all the babies
were gone.’
Example Critical Essay: Analysis of
Babycakes
I think this story is a great narration on humanity, with
an excellent first line that sucks you in immediately.
It’s especially relevant now considering the
controversial Palm Oil industry. With only 6,000
orang-utans left in the world, this story is scarily
familiar.
This story makes you think. The thoughts it conjures
towards the end last longer than the 500-odd words it
takes to tell. Humans treat animals like tools or
ingredients for their own satisfaction. But when does it
go too far? As the author writes, ‘Babies can’t talk.
They can hardly move. A baby is not a rational,
thinking creature.’ If this is true for animals, how long
before we can shift the thinking onto babies?
I would hope that the target audience is the thinking
person. Neil Gaiman wrote it for a publication to
benefit PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of
Animals). It is quite disturbing, and as someone who
wears leather and eats meat it doesn't come across as
preachy. It makes you step back and think about
things. I hope it does anyway.
Example Critical Essay: Analysis of
Babycakes
Tension is successfully created with the way the author
writes. He puts important lines in their own
paragraphs – and there are many of them.
This short story is perfect for what it is, and what it was
written for.
Sample of Satire
Satire is a genre of literature, and sometimes graphic
and performing arts, in which vices, follies, abuses,
and shortcomings are held up to ridicule, ideally with
the intent of shaming individuals, corporations,
government or society itself, into improvement.
Although satire is usually meant to be humorous, its
greater purpose is often constructive social criticism,
using wit to draw attention to both particular and
wider issues in society.
A feature of satire is strong irony or sarcasm; but
parody, burlesque, exaggeration, juxtaposition,
comparison, analogy, and double entendre are all
frequently used in satirical speech and writing. This
"militant" irony or sarcasm often professes to approve
of (or at least accept as natural) the very things the
satirist wishes to attack.
Satire is nowadays found in many artistic forms of
expression, including literature, plays, commentary,
television shows, and media such as lyrics.
Laughter is not an essential component of satire; in
fact there are types of satire that are not meant to be
"funny" at all. Conversely, not all humour, even on
such topics as politics, religion or art is necessarily
"satirical", even when it uses the satirical tools of irony,
parody, and burlesque.