Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
16 de Junho (Segunda-feira)
16 de Junho (Segunda-feira)
17 de Junho (Tera-feira)
17 de Junho (Tera-feira)
18 de Junho (Quarta-feira)
18 de Junho (Quarta-feira)
Philosophy
Strategy
Initiative
What is the Cost of Power Quality?
Flexible
Reliable
Comprehensive
Identify
Responsibility and
Solutions
Information , Regulation,
and Industry Interaction
Implement Solutions
and Assess
Performance
Analysis and Simulation
Tools and Proced.
Education and
Information Periodic Reporting
Programs Monitoring and Perform.
Assessment System.
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Process
Facilities Equipment
Utility Supplied Electrical
Power Distribution
System
Support
Equipment
PQ Check List
Approach
Problem Definition Why is PQ important?
Philosophy Responsibilities What needs to be done? By whom?
Flexibility to allow for different system characteristics
PQ Check List
Voltage Sag
Overall
Susceptibility Weak Link
Percentage
Ranking
EMO Circuit:
1 Pilot Relay (33%) and Main Contactor 47%
(14%)
DC Power Supplies:
2 19%
PC (7%), Contoller (7%), I/O (5%)
3 Phase Power Supplies:
3 12%
Magnetron (5%), RF (5%), Ion (2%)
4 Vacuum Pumps 12%
5 Turbo Pumps 7%
6 AC Inverter Drives 2%
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
PQ Check List
Disturbance Data
All Semiconductor Sites
110%
100%
Percent of Nominal Voltage
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
1 10 100 1000
Duration (cycles)
CBEMA CURVE
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Definitions
IEC Power Quality Standards
SC 77A/WG 2: Voltage fluctuations and other low-frequency disturbances
SC 77A/WG 8: Electromagnetic interference related to the network frequency
SC 77A/WG 9: Power Quality measurement methods
SC 77A/PT 61000-3-1: Electromagnetic Compatibility (EMC) - Part 3-1: Limits -
Overview of emission standards and guides. Technical Report
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Definitions
Other PQ Standards
UIE: International Union for Electricity Applications
CENELEC: European Committee for Electrotechnical Standardization
UNIPEDE: International Union of Producers and Distributors of Electrical Energy
ANSI: American National Standards Institute
ANSI C62: Guides and standards on surge protection
ANSI C84.1: Voltage ratings for equipment and power systems
ANSI C57.110: Transformer derating for supplying non-linear loads
CIGRE: International Council on Large Electric Systems
CIRED: International Conference on Electricity Distribution
CBEMA / ITIC curve
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
IEEE STD 142-1991, IEEE Recommended Practice for Grounding of Industrial and
Commercial Power Systems. (Green Book)
IEEE STD 446-1995, IEEE Recommended Practice for Emergency and Standby Power Systems
for Industrial and Commercial Applications. (Orange Book).
IEEE STD 141-1993, IEEE Recommended Practice for Electric Power Distribution for
Industrial Plants. (Red Book).
IEEE C62.22-1991, IEEE Guide for the Application of Metal-Oxide Surge Arresters for
Alternating-Current Systems.
IEC Publications are available from IEC Sales Department, Case Postale 131, 3 rue de Varembe,
CH 1211, Geneve 20, Switzerland/Suisse. IEC publications are also available in the United
States from the Sales Department, American National Standards Institute, 11 West 42nd Street,
13th Floor, New York, NY 10036. Telephone: (212) 642-4900.
IEEE publications are available from the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers,
Service Center, 445 Hoes Lane, Post Office Box 1331, Piscataway, NJ 08855-1331, USA.
Telephone: (212) 705-7900.
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
ANSI publications are available from the Sales Department, American National Standards
Institute, 11 West 42nd Street, 13th Floor, New York, NY 10036, USA. Telephone: (212) 642-
4900.
Federal Information Processing Standards (FIPS) documents are available from the National
Technical Information Services (NITS), United States Department of Commerce, 5285 Port
Royal Road, Springfield, VA 22161. Telephone: (703) 487-4650.
UIE publications are available from the Union Internationale de Electrothermie, Tour
Atlantiquee F - 92 0A0 Paris Ladefense Cedex 06 France. Telephone: 011 331 41 26 56 48,
Fax: 011 331 41 26 56 49.
Basic Measuring Instruments publications are available from BMI -- Order Administration,
3250 Jay Street, Santa Clara, CA 95054. Telephone: 1-800-876-5355.
Dranetz Technologies publications are available from Dranetz Technologies Incorporated, 1000
New Durham Road, Edison, NJ 08818. Telephone: (908) 287-3580.
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
<>
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Scrap
Restart costs
Labor PQ Level
PowerQuality ( A B C )dPd $
A - Electric parameters
B - Economic Parameters
C - Structure of the Sector
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Intangible Costs
Increased Business Risk
Lost Business Opportunity
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Types of Disturbance
Impulses
Distortions, etc.
Level of Quality
B
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
C
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
A B B C C
Financial Analysis
Net Benefit
Payback
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Integrated Macroeconomic/Financial Analysis
Power quality will have to be regulated. As deregulation takes over the industry, the
temptation to let the level of service and investment in the system deteriorate is obvious.
Regulators will want to prevent this be requiring some basic level of quality and reliability.
Indices are being developed and standardized to facilitate the characterizing of power
quality levels on the system. EPRI completed a 2 year monitoring project to provide
benchmark indices describing power quality levels on distribution systems in the United
States. The Europeans have already started the process with the Euronorms (EN50160)
that define levels of power quality that can be expected in a number of important
categories (harmonics, flicker, regulation, unbalance, disturbances).
Utilities will have to report power quality performance statistics and make sure that the
performance does not significantly deteriorate over time. The regulations governing power
quality will be part of the overall regulations for operating the distribution part of the
electricity supply business (often called the lines company). This will require more system
monitoring and analytical tools to predict performance as part of the system design
process.
The regulations will only address a base level of power quality and will be evaluated on a
system-wide basis.
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Deregulation
Deregulation will not mean the end of power quality evaluations as an important
function within the electric utility industry. On the contrary, power quality is only
increasing in importance as competition becomes the standard and utilities look for new
ways to service their customer base.
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
New T&D Technologies
TL
HVDC
SVC
TL TL Substation
Generation
FACTS
DL
Excitation
DL
Alternate Sources
Load Load Load
1 2 3
Customer B
Home Automation
UPS Load Load Load
Motor Drives 1 2 3
Customer A
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
T&D Technologies
Power System Value Chain
Environmental
Maintainability
Availability
Safety
Efficiency
Reliability
Performance
Price
Power Quality
Energy Communication
Power
INPUTS Generation Delivery Conversion Processing OUTPUTS
Light / Motion
Utility User
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Different Levels of Action
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Development of PQ Standards and Specifications
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Evaluation Procedure
09:40 09:55 Sesso de Abertura
Challenges
Distribution and Power Quality Strategic - EPRI Roadmap - Difficult Challenges
-Breve Introduo
-Gerao Distribuda
-Fontes e Aspectos Probabilsticos
-Instrumentao
-ndices Harmnicos
-Normas / Recomendaes
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Tenso x Corrente
Limits (V or I ?)
Harmnicos x Transitrios
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Modelagem (Sources)
-Current injection model.
-Frequency- or time-domain
Norton equivalent circuit model.
-Time- or frequency-domain
device model used with frequency-
domain network model.
-Time-domain model.
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Sensitivity Analysis
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Modelagem (System and Loads)
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Modelagem (Solution)
Breve Introduo
Modelagem (Solution)
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos
Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
THD
V
THD
1.2%V
0.8%
0.4%
An Inevitable Reality
0.0%
2/2 2/3 2/4 2/5 2/6 2/7 2/8
The causes of variations are the continuous changes in system configurations, linear
load demands and operating modes of non linear loads
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Time-dependent Limits
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Im(V5) Im(V23)
Re(V5) Re(V23)
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
0.4
fX
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
X
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Time ranges involved (hours, day, etc.)
Multimodal patterns
The time factor is completely lost and the same pdf can correspond to
different time varying harmonics, with consequent different thermal responses
of electrical components
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Conditional probability density functions
Example: pdf of the 5th Harmonic Voltage given that its amplitude is
greater than or equal to 6%
2 f*V5 4.5
fV5
4
3.5
1.5
3
2.5
1
2
1.5
0.5 1
0.5
0 0
V6%V5
V5 V6% V5 V5
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Statistical Measures
average value m
standard deviation s
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Harmonic pdfs with the same PC95% and MAX can cause different effects
x0.95 x0.95
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Summation Laws
I h k hjI hj
j h = summation exponent
dependent on harmonic order
U h h U hjh
j
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Summation Laws
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Harmonic Impedances
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Time-Varying Nature of Harmonics
Time-Dependent Limits
Up to now the studies on harmonic effects mainly (but not only) refer to
static distortions
Studies are needed on harmonic effects when time-varying distortion is
applied
THDV
TH
1.2%
DV
0.8%
0.4%
Equipment
0.0%
2/2 2/3 2/4 2/5 2/6 2/7 2/8
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Proposition For IEEE 519
IEEE 519-1992 introduced the concept of probability distribution plots to characterise
variations in harmonic levels.
A reasonable method of using these types of plots to evaluate harmonic levels would be
to compare the steady state harmonic limits with the measured harmonic level that is not
exceeded 95% of the time (the 95% probability point). This is consistent with the
evaluation of compatibility levels in IEC standards.
In order to further develop this topic the IEEE Probabilistic Aspect of Harmonics Task
Force is preparing a proposal for the Std. 519 in which the time-varying nature of
harmonics voltages are considered in the establishment of the limits.
Any limits on the short duration harmonic levels should be based on the possible
impacts of these harmonic levels. Effects such as metering error and equipment ageing
are the accumulated result of harmonic levels over time. Other effects include the
sensitive electronics to short burst of high harmonic levels or certain types of waveform
distortions.
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Proposition For IEEE 519
The continuous limits could be taken as, for example, the 95% probability
limit.
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos - Proposition For IEEE 519
THDV
THDV
1.2%
0.8%
0.4%
0.0%
2/2 2/3 2/4 2/5 2/6 2/7 2/8
50 100.00%
S i te 1 0 9 2 T H D H i s to g r a m C o u nt = 305
M i n im u m = 0.739
45 J une 19 - J une 26, 1992 90.00%
M a x im u m = 1 .9 4 9
R a n ge = 1 .2 1 1
40 M ean = 1.4 0 6 80.00%
M e d ia n = 1 .4 8 9
S t a n d a rd D e vi a t i o n = 0 .3 1 8
35 S t a n d a rd E rr o r = 0 .0 1 8 2 70.00%
V a ri a n c e = 0.101
S k ewnes s = -0 . 5 2 1
30 K u rt o s i s = -0 . 7 7 7
60.00%
Frequency
25 50.00%
20 40.00%
15 30.00%
10 20.00%
5 10.00%
0 0.00%
0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9
TH D B in s (% )
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos
Breve Introduo
Aspectos Probabilsticos
Drawing of cumulative distribution (Ttotal) and the maximum duration and maximum duration of
individual burst (Tmaximum) for a harmonic measurement. The curve also includes a conceptual limit
for short term harmonic levels.
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Monitorao and Instrumentao
Breve Introduo
Monitorao and Instrumentao
Breve Introduo
Monitorao and Instrumentao
Transmission
Cust om er
Monitoring
Syst em
Substation
Monitoring
Sys tem
Cust om er
Monitoring
Syst em Power Quality/
Energy
Information Service
Internet/
Data Collection Data Collection
World Wide Web
Local Network
Monitoring
Database
Corporate Power Quality/
Intranet Reliability
Database Management/ Performance and
Local Data Analy sis Data Analysis
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Disturbance magnitude
Voltage regulation
Equipment immunity test levels
Unbalance
Compatibility level
Flicker
Utility planning levels
Harmonics
Assessed level
time
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
The concept of compatibility levels
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Monitoring to improve operations & reliability
Fault location
Capacitor bank performance assessment
Voltage regulator performance assessment
DG performance assessment
Cable fault identifier
Arrester failure identifier
Transformer loading assessment
This is where the real financial return for
system monitoring comes in
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
400 100
200 80
0 60
Voltage ( V)
Voltage (%)
-200 40
-400 20
-600 0
0.00 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0 2 4 6 8 10
Time ( s) Harmonic Component
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
Breve Introduo
ndices Harmnicos
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
ndices Harmnicos
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
ndices Harmnicos
U k Uref k
RTL k max 0,
Uref k
Uk - measured or calculated harmonic voltage
Uref - harmonic voltage limit (standard or particular equipment)
k - harmonic order
8
8 8
8
6
6
RT Lk 4
RT Lk 4
2
2
0 0
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 0 0
0 0.05 0.1
2 k 13
0 Uk .1
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
The Blood Pressure Analogy
50
HDD RTLk
2
k 2
Exponent = 2 or 4 ?
k = 50 or less ?
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
0
a b c d e f g RTL
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
Harmonic Distortion Diagnostic Index Applying Fuzzy Logic Comparisons
Alternative Approach Individual Harmonics (Vh)
Equipment Malfunction
Fuzzy - Color Code Criteria
No Problem
Normal
Below
Normal
Below
a
Caution
NormalOver
b
Heating
Possible Problems
c
d
Very
Hot
Imminent Problems
1
e
0
A B C D E F G RTL
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
Example 1
U k Uref k 2
2 0
0.04
0.001 0.01 0.03
3 0.5
0.015 0.01
0.001 0.01 4 0
0.03 0.01 5 2 Uk
0.001 0.01 6 0 0.02
0.015 0.01 RTL 7 0.5 Urefk
0.001 0.01 8 0
0.009 ( VTHD Vthd )
THDD max 0
0.01 9 0
0.001
3
0.01 10 0 Vthd
0.02 0.01 11 1 110 0
0.001 0.01 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
12 0
0.015 0.01 13 0.5 2 k 13
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
Example 1
13 13
VHDD RTLk2 VTHD
2
U k 100
k 2
k 2
THDD max 0
( VTHD Vthd )
Vthd
THDD 0 Vthd=5%
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
Example 2
U k Uref k 2
2 0
0.001 0.01 0.02
3 0
0.01 0.01
0.001 0.01 4 0
0.0 0.01 5 0 Uk
0.001 0.01 6 0
0.01
0.01 0.01 RTL 7 0 Urefk
0.001 0.01 8 0
0.01 0.01 9 0
0.001 0.01 10 0
0.01 0.01 11 0 0 0
0.001 0.01 12 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
0.01 0.01 13 0 2 k 13
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
Example 2
13
13
VHDD RTLk2 VTHD
2
U k 100
k 2 k 2
THDD max 0
( VTHD Vthd )
Vthd
THDD 0 Vthd=5%
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
Example 3
U k Uref k 2
2 0 0.05
0.001 0.01 0.04
3 0
0.001 0.01
4 0 Uk
0.001 0.01
5 1
0.02 0.01 Urefk 0.02
0.001 0.01 6 0
RTL 7 1
0.02 0.01
0.001 0.01 8 0 3
110 0
0.001 0.01 9 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
0.001 0.01 10 0 2 k 13
0.05 0.01 11 4
0.001 0.01 12 0
0.04 0.01 13 3
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
Example 3
13
13
VHDD RTLk 2 VTHD
k 2
2
U k 100
k 2
THDD max 0
( VTHD Vthd )
Vthd
If HDD = 0 No
If THDD = 0
If HDD = 0 Possible
If THDD > 0
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - ndices Harmnicos
Compatibility vs Absolute Measure
Current Distortion
Limits (in % of IL) for
General Transmission
Systems (>161,000 V)
Voltage
Distortion Limits
(in % of V1)
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
1. Modeling of network components such as overhead lines, cables, transformers, etc. (The
analyst has some flexibility in selecting the level of detail needed; sensitivity studies
should be considered to determine which degrees of detail can be avoided in any particular
study.)
2. Modeling of various nonlinear loads including predefined models and the capability for
user-defined models based on measured or typical data. (It is left to the analyst to determine
what degree of sophistication is required, especially if time-domain simulation techniques
are to be used.)
3. Modeling of power factor correction capacitors should be built in to any software
being considered. (The representation of the equivalent capacitance is the most important
requirement; other details are somewhat insignificant for limit compliance evaluations.)
4. Modeling of utility system equivalents should be straightforward. (In an advanced study,
the analyst should consider the capability to represent the frequency dependence of network
equivalents.)
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo
ndices Harmnicos
10:00 12:15 Harmnicos
Breve Introduo - Normas / Recomendaes
IEEE P1547.1 Standard for Conformance Tests Procedures for Equipment Interconnecting
Distributed Resources with Electric Power Systems
Scope This standard specifies the type, production, and commissioning tests that shall be performed to
demonstrate that the interconnection functions and equipment of a distributed resource (DR) conform to
IEEE Standard P1547.
Purpose
Interconnection equipment that connects distributed resources (DR) to an electric power system (EPS)
must meet the requirements specified in IEEE Standard P1547. These test procedures must provide both
repeatable results, independent of test location, and flexibility to accommodate a variety of DR
technologies
Contratos e Seguros
Harmonic Distortion.
IEEE 519-1992 describes the responsibility between the customer and the
distribution system supplier in controlling harmonic distortion levels. The
distribution company is responsible for the voltage distortion and the customer is
responsible for harmonic currents being created by nonlinear loads within the
facility.
Contratos e Seguros
16:00 - 16:25 - Coffee Break
16:30 - 17:30 Debates Mesa Redonda
Quiz
Quiz
Quiz
Voltage sags are typically characterized by the minimum rms voltage and the
duration of the sag.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
- Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
- Instrumentao
Faults on Own
Faults on Circuit
Transmission 23%
System
31%
Faults on Parallel
Circuits
46%
Example of the breakdown of voltage sag performance at an end user location illustrating the
relative causes of voltage sags between the transmission system and the distribution system.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
What is SARFI?
SARFI is an acronym for System Average RMS Variation Frequency Index. It
is a power quality index that provides a count or rate of voltage sags, swells,
and/or interruptions for a system. The size of the system is scalable: it can be
defined as a single monitoring location, a single customer service, a feeder, a
substation, groups of substations, or for an entire power delivery system. There
are two types of SARFI indices. SARFIx and SARFICURVE.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
SARFIx
SARFIx corresponds to a count or rate of voltage sags, swell and/or interruptions below a
voltage threshold. For example, SARFI90 considers voltage sags and interruptions that are
below 0.90 per unit, or 90% of a system base voltage. SARFI70 considers voltage sags and
interruptions that are below 0.70 per unit, or 70% of a system base voltage. And SARFI110
considers voltage swells that are above 1.1 per unit, or 110% of a system base voltage. The
SARFIx indices are meant to assess short-duration rms variation events only, meaning that
only those events with durations less than 60 seconds are included in its computation.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
SARFICURVE
SARFICURVE corresponds to a rate of voltage sags below an equipment compatibility
curve. For example SARFICBEMA considers voltage sags and interruptions that are
below the lower CBEMA curve. SARFIITIC considers voltage sags and interruptions
that are below the lower ITIC curve. Lastly, SARFISEMI considers voltage sags and
interruptions that are below the lower SEMI curve. These curves do not limit the
duration of an rms variation event to 60 seconds; therefore, the SARFICBEMA,
SARFIITIC, and SARFISEMI are valid for events with durations greater than cycle.
http://www.pqview.com/indices/sarfi.pdf
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
440-500 kV
220-230 kV
110-138 kV
69 kV
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Events per 100 mile / Year
70
60 Distribution
Number of Events per Year
Transmission
50
40
30
20
10
0
Interruptions < 50% < 60% < 70% < 80% < 90%
Minimum Sag Voltage
Example of summarizing voltage sag performance at typical SARFI threshold values.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo - Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
500
450
400
350
Count
300
250
200
150
100 90 to 100
50 60 to 70
0
30 to 60 cyc
20 to 30 cyc
30 to 40
10 to 20 cyc
6 to 10 cyc
5 cyc
M agnitude
4 cyc
0 to 10
3 cyc
2 cyc
1 cyc
Duration
Example of characterizing voltage sag performance using a three dimensional chart showing the count
of events with magnitude and duration.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo - Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
Example of characterizing voltage sag events by summarizing magnitude and duration of events with
respect to equipment sensitivity (ITIC curve).
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
What about calculation of expected performance vs. measured performance? Our results dont seem to
match the measurements.
It is theoretically possible to calculate voltage sag performance from a historical database of the system
faults. Electrotek has done this for a number of customers.
Dis turbanc e s at UNIFI
25
20
Events 1 5
Per
Year 1 0
0
3 8 kV 1 1 0 kV 2 2 0 kV Total
Fault Location
Consider the following rms variation event summary table, which was hypothetically
measured at a single site:
List of RMS Variation Events Measured at a Single Monitoring Site
The count of voltage sags and interruptions that would be included in the SARFI90 is 8,
as there were 8 voltage sags and interruptions measured at this location that were had a
minimum voltage below 0.9 per unit (90 percent) and between cycle and 60 seconds
in duration. This can be expressed as a rate of 3.93 events per 30 days. This is computed
by dividing the 8 events by the 92 days between July-01-1997 and Oct-01-1997, and
then multiplying by 30 to normalized to events per 30 days.
SARFIX Rates Computed from previous table
SARFI90 8 2.61
SARFI70 6 1.96
SARFI50 5 1.63
SARFI10 3 0.98
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
- Breve Introduo
- Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
- Instrumentao
Brazilian System ? ? ?
Discuss
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo - Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
Comparison of UI Substation's SARFI 70 performance of the last 12 months vs. their 3 year average
16
Number of times when Substation's Bus Voltage was less
14
than 70% of Nominal per 365 days
12
10
0
NG NI A K
AY SS RE T L . 1 2 N E T S . A B W
SI EE NU
M
RE HO ES RN
E
EL ST ER ER VO ENU AVE
N
W
N
OC
K
IA
C
ET LL ST O NT RD RD NE
S SO R R DW G W O W E V V IL O N I P K A R I A I S
O N C A N S M H N I I V H T N N C F E M A B S
CR A H B OA CO ST EL T N JU R R M A H D O IN SA AP AT D B E
AS BR EA AW ND
IA IL
L
IL
L
IX RT OL QU QU TR OO GR
N GS H I M M M O E
W
W N
I N P CO
A LL
SARFI70 from Distribution Events 3 years average SARFI70 from Trasmission Events 3 years average
Substation Name
SARFI70 from Distribution Events during the last four Quarters SARFI70 from Trasmission Events during the last four Quarters
Example of comparing voltage sag performance at different substations. The chart shows the breakdown of
events caused by transmission faults vs. distribution faults and compares the three year average performance
with the last years performance for each substation.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
Basically, the flicker meter is designed so that an output value of Pst = 1.0 represents
the flicker severity where 50% of observers can detect the light variations from a 40
watt incandescent bulb. EN 50160 specifies that the Plt should be less than 1.0 for
95% of the samples over a one week period. This is a worst case limit and the
planning levels for utilities should be more strict than this.
Input Volltage
Adaptor
Demodulator Statistical
with Weighting evaluation
Smoothing
squaring Filters of
multiplier flicker level
RMS Meter
(optional)
The role of unit 1 is to receive the input voltage and to generate the internal
reference level. Thus, the flicker measurements can be made independently from
the network voltage and the results will be given in percentage.
The role of the 2nd unit is to separate the voltage change causing flicker from the 50
Hz signal using a squaring demodulation.
The 3rd unit consists of two filters and optionally a range selector. The first filter
eliminates the DC component of the demodulator output and the double of the
fundamental frequency. The second one forms the transfer function of the
flickermeter, which is an answer to the modulating fluctuation (the filter simulates the
frequency response of the human visual system to the fluctuating luminaire of a bulb
caused by a sinusoidal modulation of the fundamental frequency voltage). The
transfer function of the 3rd unit is given as follows:
The 4th part consists of a squaring multiplier, and a first order low-pass filter. The
simulation of the human perception of flicker through the lamp, eye and brain is done
by the combination of units 2,3 and 4. So, the output of the 4th unit represents the
instantaneous perception of flicker. The 5th unit has a microprocessor, which does
the online evaluation of the flicker levels, enabling the direct calculation of the
important evaluation results. Based on the output of the 4th unit the off-line evaluation
of the data is also possible.
Because of the random nature the measured flicker value could change within a wide
interval and in a non-predictable way.
The following steps have to be made in order to generate the function.
- first, the actual values of measured flicker levels at the output of the 4th unit have to
be classified,
-when the observation period is over, calculate the cumulative probability function.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
The length of the observation period is 1 and 10 min. Based on the cumulative
probability
function the following algorithm is defined by the standard:
Pst = (K1P1 + K2P2 + .... + KnPn)^1/2
where Pst is the magnitude of the short-time flicker to be calculated, while K1 to Kn
are weighting factors and P1, P2 ..... Pn are the levels belonging to a certain
exceeding of the cumulative probability function. In the algorithm developed by IEC
there is given 5 breaking points as follows:
P0,1 the level which is exceeded only by 0,1% of the observation period
P1 the level which is exceeded only by 1% of the observation period
P3 the level which is exceeded only by 3% of the observation period
The related K factors are:
K0,1 for the 0.1% level = 0,0314 K1 for the 1% level = 0,0525 K3 for the 3% level =
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
The error of the measuring method should remain always under 5%. In
practice, tests have confirmed that the above method gives correct results for
different network disturbances. The method was developed so that people feel
flicker disturbing for Pst = 1.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
The short-time flicker value with its 10-min duration is appropriate for the
measurement of the single disturbing sources but there is a need to measure
more complex disturbing sources like a group of and loads with longer and
variable time cycles. The long-time flicker-level values have to be calculated for
every 2 hours of each day of the observation period, using 12 pieces of
consecutive 10-min Pst values, originating from the given 2 hour interval,
according to the following definition
where Psti is the 10 min value calculated every 10 minutes. According to the
standards the long-time values calculated in this way - among normal
operational conditions, during any period of a week - Plt, should be 1, during
95% of the time interval.
This is equivalent with the statement that the value corresponding to the 95%
value of the CPF function is Plt 1.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo
-Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
Tables 1 and 2 summarize recommended limits for the supply system as a function of the
voltage level being evaluated. The limits take into account transfer factors that estimate the
attenuation of flicker from one voltage level to another.
2
95% or 99%of 10-minute Pst values
1.5
Pst
1
0.5
0
00h00 24h00
Figure illustrates the procedure for performing the assessment using the
statistical values over a one week period.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo - Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
Responsibilities
The concept of ranges for the flicker limits has been suggested rather than fixed limits. Flicker
impacts are very dependent on system characteristics, load characteristics, and customer
characteristics. Therefore, adjusting the flicker limits for specific circumstances is attractive.
However, this also introduces ambiguity to the evaluation procedure.
In general, three different flicker ranges would be defined:
1. PstD95% < 1.0 Acceptable flicker levels.
2. 1.0 < PstD95% < 2.0 Precarious flicker levels that require system-dependent
evaluation. These sites may be acceptable with existing flicker levels if the attenuation factors
combined with local flicker sources at the MV levels are resulting in MV flicker levels that are
acceptable for customers. The cost of resolving the flicker problem should also be taken into
account.
3. PstD95% > 2.0 Critical flicker levels that are unacceptable.
The system-dependent evaluation would consider whether or not there are actual complaints,
system topology (different transfer functions), the costs of reducing the flicker levels,
allowance for local flicker generation, and the potential impacts.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo - Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
Issues
Are the flicker levels proposed acceptable?
The existing goals establish a limit for Pst95% at the actual PCC in the range of 1.0 to 2.0.
The requirements of a specific system will depend on transfer ratios to lower voltages and
other characteristics of the system.
What about rapid voltage (step) changes? Are they a different type of evaluation?
Rapid voltage changes occur during the connection or disconnection of loads or other
devices (e.g. capacitors or reactors) to the power system. They are a different type of
problem than an arc furnace or other time-varying load. Typical rapid voltage changes do
not exceed a magnitude of + 5 % or - 5 % of the nominal or declared voltage at LV or MV
levels. Lower limits on individual step changes are required for switching events on the
transmission system. A reasonable limit for a single step change caused by a switching
event at the HV level would be 3%. This limit is used by some transmission companies as
a criteria for sizing capacitor bank steps on the transmission system.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo - Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
Issues
What are the power quality concerns of flicker? If everyone uses compact florescent lights,
will it be a concern?
The only power quality phenomena that has been associated with flicker is the affect on lamp
voltage. Severe flicker levels have also caused operation of UPS systems, resulting in
depleting the UPS batteries. However, lamp flicker has always been the limiting criteria for
flicker. Flicker then is the effect produced on the visual human perception by a changing
emission of light by lamps subjected to fluctuations of their supply voltage.
Usually on the basic grid the flicker evaluation will be dominated by one load. Cases
with mulitiple loads will require fairly advanced studies. The literature gives a method of
evaluating how flicker sources combine is given by the following relationship:
It will usually be sufficient to limit individual contributions to PstS99% to less than 0.8.
Exceptions can be made when there is only one large source of flicker on the system. In
these cases, individual contribution of PstS99% of 1.0 can be acceptable.
Waveform information in combination with extended rms vs. time recording for voltage
sags and interruptions.
08:30 - 10:10 Distrbios na Tenso
-Breve Introduo - Definies (Sags, Swells, Flutuaes de Tenso, etc)
Summarize of Actions
1. Maintain a fault history database.
2. Benchmark the system fault performance.
3. Develop a methodology in order to evaluate the expected voltage sag
profiles for various system locations.
4. Develop monitoring projects with new instruments for key sites to
establish confidence with the monitoring process.
5. Develop a standard reporting format for presenting voltage sag
information.
10:15 - 10:40 - Coffee Break
10:45 - 12:15 - Distrbios na Tenso
Normas / Recomendaes
Other topics
18 de junho (Quarta-feira)
Stability consideration, continuity, and frequency control are goals important to power
delivery and power quality. These aspects have traditionally been managed actively by
the transmission operators. The utility has the required frequency monitoring systems,
load shedding schemes, oscillography, and SCADA systems to deal with these
concerns. The PQ program does not change what is already being done with respect to
these systems.
08:30 - 10:10 Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Flicker, harmonics, and unbalance are concerns that only show up in regions of the
network with heavy concentration of certain industries and load types. These problems
are largely dealt with by engineering the particular situation. The PQ program should
help assess system conditions in these areas and identify possible problem conditions
before they cause system disruptions and customer equipment problems (proactive
approach).
08:30 - 10:10 Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Concerns for disturbances such as voltage sags, transient switching events, and even
dynamic frequency excursions are more recent. The PQ program should consist of new
systems to monitor these events, and to provide better communications and reporting of
these events. Analytical tools for use in conjunction with the monitoring can assist in
tracking system performance and identifying expected performance levels. It suggests
that the transmission system operator continue to investigate the causes of faults on the
system, and identify circuits or types of equipment where a higher level of maintenance
activity is necessary.
10:15 - 10:40 - Coffee Break
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
- Programas de Qualidade de Energia
- Aspectos Econmicos / Custos
- Contratos / Seguros de Qualidade
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Utility Competitiveness
Monitoring projects enable utilities to offer special power quality contracts.
Monitoring at customer sites adds an important service for the customer,
differentiating the utility from its competition.
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Cost-of-Ownership Survey
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
One of the most significant findings of the survey was the impact of poor
facility power quality on production yields and costs. Power quality is
expected to become a major issue for the industry in the United States with
the growing deregulation of the utility industry.
PQ Program
Establishing benchmarks for expected system performance in all
categories of power quality
Documentation of detailed power quality characteristics at
individual locations
Identifying problems that need to be resolved
Evaluation of solutions for resolving problems
Economic analysis of options for resolving problems
Convenient web-based access to power quality performance
information
Educational tools for describing power quality performance
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Benefits of a PQ Program
Table 2.
What Unfavorable Effect Would a "Brown-Out" Have on Production?
Major effect Moderate effect Little effect No effect No answer
(%) (%) (%) (%) (%)
Throughput of product 33.7 33.7 18.8 7.9 5.9
Yield of product 36.6 22.8 17.8 13.9 8.9
Maintenance of 33.7 27.7 24.8 5.0 8.9
equipment
Consumables used in 17.8 25.7 30.7 17.8 7.9
process
Cost of production 38.6 28.7 19.8 5.0 7.9
Table 3.
What Unfavorable Effect Would Power Voltage Spikes, Surges or Noise Have on Production?
Major effect Moderate effect Little effect No effect No
Throughput of product (%)
30.7 (%)
32.7 (%)
20.8 (%)
7.9 answer
7.9
Yield of product 31.7 31.7 16.8 10.9 8.9
Maintenance of 34.7 23.8 27.7 5.9 7.9
equipment
Consumables used in 18.8 20.8 35.6 16.8 7.9
process
Cost of production 27.7 36.6 17.8 5.9 11.9
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Cost
Microeconomics Framework for Assessing PQ Benefit Cost
Step 1 - Assessment of power Disturbance Cost. This should be done based on the type of
industry/process, etc. and type of disturbance. Boundary conditions should be specified to
determine the actual effect of power disturbance. Direct and indirect costs, varying from
production loss to reduced efficiency, should then be calculated.
Step 2 - Assessment of the Cost of Mitigation. This step should compute the total cost of
mitigation varying from initial monitoring and analysis to final testing of performance.
Alternative options should be suggested.
Step 3 - Assessment of Benefit due to Mitigation. This step should compute the direct/indirect
benefits plus energy savings due to mitigation.
Step 4 - Financial Computation of the Benefit-Cost - With the input from steps 1 to 3, the final
assessment of the benefit-cost and payback period should be determined for the different
options.
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Contratos e Seguros
Power Quality Contracts in a Restructured Competitive Electricity Industry, Barry W. Kennedy Bonneville Power, Administration, Portland,
OR 97209, Mark McGranaghan Electrotek Concepts, Knoxville, TN 37923 - http://www.dranetz-bmi.com/pdf/contracts.pdf
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Switching capacitor banks creates transient voltages that can impact distribution systems and
end use customers due to magnification or sensitive loads. This problem was encountered in
England after deregulation and there was no definition of responsibility for controlling the
transient voltages. The transmission company declared that the transient voltages were not
excessive and the distribution companies that served the customers declared that the transients
causing the problem were being created on the transmission system. With integrated utilities
in the United States, these problems are usually solved with switching control in the
transmission capacitor banks (synchronous closing or closing resistors). Transients from
capacitor switching should be limited to very low levels (e.g. less than 1.1 pu) at this point
due to their potential for causing problems at lower voltages.
Voltage Sags and Interruptions
Expected voltage sag and interruption performance at the point of common coupling should
be defined. It is important to recognize that voltage sags can be caused by faults on the
transmission system or distribution system. Contracts that include voltage sag limits between
utilities and large customers supplied from the transmission system have already been
implemented by Detroit Edison, etc, with the large automotive manufacturing companies.
Payments or rate structures that provide compensation for voltage sag and interruption
performance outside of the specified levels should be defined.
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Contracts between DISTCO and End Users (or End User Representative)
The power quality requirements at the point of common coupling between the distribution
system and end use customers must be defined. In some cases, the end user may be a
customer of the distribution company. In other cases, the end user may be represented by a
retail marketer or an energy service company. The basic power quality requirements at this
interface will probably be defined by regulations. However, opportunities for performance-
based rates or enhanced power quality service from the distribution system will create the
need for more creative contracts.
Contracts between DISTCO and End Users (or End User Representative)
Transient Voltages.
Capacitor switching transients could be important due to their impact on sensitive loads.
The distribution system supplier should control the capacitor switching transient
magnitudes but the customer should be responsible for avoiding magnification problems
created by power factor correction capacitors within the facility. Basic requirements and
responsibilities for surge suppression should also be defined to avoid problems with high
frequency transients associated with lightning.
Voltage Sags and Interruptions
The contract should define expected voltage sag and interruption performance. This is an
area where enhanced performance options may be offered in cases where it may be more
economical to improve performance through modifications or power conditioning
equipment applied at the distribution system level.
10:45 - 12:40 - Gerenciamento da Qualidade de Energia Eltrica
Conclusions
The electric sector needs to monitor closely the PQ levels and maintain investment
to keep compatible power quality over the entire grid.
12:50 - 14:10 Almoo