Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1. Background
2. Study Components and research findings
I. Prevalence and Causative Factors for CKDu in
Sri Lanka
II. Socioeconomic and productivity impact of
CKDu
III. Nephrotoxic herbal remedies used in Sri Lanka
IV. Randomized Clinical trial to examine the renal
effects of an Angiotensin Converting enzyme
Inhibitor (Enalapril) in adults with CKDu
3. Recommendations
4. Future Studies
Background
Western
Uva until very advanced
Sabaragamuwa
High economical cost for patient, family &
Southern
state
Global Situation
Nicar agua
CKDu am ong loca l
gr oup of e x-sugar
cane w or ker s.
El S alva dor
CKDu par ti cularl y
am ong younger m en
Definition of CKDu to be
established and used as a standard
screening tool
Representativeness and nature of
populations screened unclear
Geographical mapping piece meal
Little coordination of
epidemiological, analytical &
environmental studies
ORGANISATIONAL STRUCTURE OF THE COLLABBORATIVE RESEARCH EFFORT
STRENGTHS OF THE STUDY
Thissapura
Ambagaswewa
#
CD-SDMC Hebarawa
Thalakolawewa
DH-Girandurukotte
")
6 Divisional
CD-Batalayaya
#
# CD-Dambana
#
Hatharaskottuwa CD Medirigiriya BH
# F
G Wijepura CD
#
BH-Mahiyangana
F
G
3 Districts
Divulankadawala CD CD-Uva Tissapura
# #
Secretariat
RH-Ekkiriyankumbura
!>
Galamuna PU
2
%
Singhapura CD
Higurakgoda DH #
Pulasthigama RH
") DH-Uraniya
!> ")
Jayanthipura RH
!> DH-Kandeketiya
")
Areas
Aselapura CD
#
DH-Meegahakiula
Welikanda RH ") RH-Roeberry
Polonnaruwa GH
!> !>
Diyabeduma CD !C
# Sevenapitiya CD
#
CD-Taldena
Mannampitiya PU
2
% CD-Tennepanguwa #
# DH-Metigahatenna
Parakrama Samudra CD
")
Attanakadawela RH
#
!>
PU-Galauda
2
% DH-Lunugala
")
RH-Kahataruppa
RH-Kandegedara !>
RH-Wewegama !>
!> RH-Kandagolla
PU-Badulla
!>
!C%
2
GH-Badulla
RH-Hopton
!>
CD-Haliela
Nuwaragala CD Aralaganwila PU CD Lunuwatta #
# 2
% # RH-Ury CD-Meedumpitiya
Ellewewa CD
Bakamuna PU
2
% # DH-Uvaparanagama
RH-Ettampitiya CD-Medagama !> DH-Passara
#
") # !>
!> RH-Springvelley ")
Weheragala CD CD-Sylmiapura
DH-Welimada
# Daminna CD
# ") BH-Damodara
Siripura CD # CD-Hewankumbura #
CD-Keppetipola
F
G
CD-Halpe #
CD-Namunukula
# # #
RH-Nadungamuwa
!> !> RH-Mirahawatta
RH-Bogahakumbura CD-Ballaketuwa
Padavi Parakramapura CD
!> #
# DH-Bandarawela
RH-Boralanda
")
!>
CD-Liyangahawela
Padaviya DH PADAVIYA DH
") BH-Diyatalawa #
F
G
RH-Glananore DH-Haputale
!> ")
Wahalkada PU
DH-Haldummulla
2
% ")
DH-Koslanda
")
Thiththagonawa CD
#
Kapugollagama RH
!>
Kabathigollawa RH
!>
Punawa RH Ethakada CD
!> #
Gonumeru Wewa
Thanthirimale RH
!>
Madawachchiya DH 2
%
") Rathmalgahawewa RH Kokmaduwa
!>
22 Gramaniladhari
Maha Willachchiya RH
!> Gambirigaswewa GH
#
Kendawa CD
^_
Kallanchiya RH
Parasangaswewa RH Rambewa RH
!> # Wahagahapuwewa CD
!> !> ") Kahatagasdilliya DH
^_ Puliyankulama CD #
# Thammannawa RH
Ranorawa RH !>
!> #
Secred City CD
2
%
Mihinthale PU
Mee - Kumbukwewa
Devanumpiyathissapura CD
# Anuradapura GH
Prison Hospital
!C Pura CD
# Pubudu
Divisions
# Wijepura CD
Galenbidunuwewa PU
Nelubawe RH # 2
% Ellawewa
!> Galkulama CD
")
Nochchiagama DH # Pairamadu RH
Nachchiyaduwa RH !>
Thalawa PU !>
Galadevulwewa CD 2
%
# Huruluwewa GH
2
% Gatalawa
Rajanganaya-Track 11 GH
!C
Rajanganaya-Track 5 RH
!> Thambuttegama BH
F
G 2
%
Eppawala PU Hurulunikawewa Track 03 - 04
Maradankadawala RH
Maha Illuppallama CD !>
Kattiyawa RH #
!> Senapura RH
!> # Kunchikulam CD Hurulumeegahapattiya
Kekirawa DH
Galnawa PU Habarana RH
")
2
% !>
Negampaha RH Kalawewa RH
!> !>
Madawathugama CD
Galkiriyagama RH #
!>
Adiyagala RH
!>
2200 Households
(100 Houses from each GN)
Response
Rate
6,698 total eligible 74%
6,132 responded to questionnaire
4,941 sampled (15-70 years)
Ia Population Prevalence Study (Cont..)
Participant Selection
Methodology: 6,698
Informed Consent
Detailed Questionnaire
6,132
Physical Examination
Non
Endemic Area Endemic
Characteristic Area
CKDu cases Controls Controls
Total Number 733 4044 250
Males, % 37.1 42.5 56
Age (years), mean (SD) 39.1 (14.2) 43.7 (13.9) 35.5 (14.0)
Farmer,% 38 43.9 18.3
BMI,kg/m2, mean (SD) 22.3 (4.6) 21.1 (4.1) 21.7 (4.4)
ACR > 30 mg/g 733 0 0
Mean 45.447 92.443 56.572 1.039 0.646 0.345 1.153 1.254 2.099
Median 26.3 6.99 42.025 0.695 0.18 0.265 0.95 0.793 1.434
Range 0.4 - 0.2 - 5.38- 0.005- 0.005- 0.005- 0.04- 1.21- 0.277-
616.6 966.29 350.28 8.93 5.13 2.079 8.53 6.64 20.9
The sensitivity & specificity for concentrations of Cadmium in urine were 80% and 53.6% (AUC=0.682, 95% CI=0.61 to
0.75, cut off value > 0.23)
At a cut-off value of 0.397 g/g, sensitivity was 70% and specificity 68.3%.
The sensitivity and specificity for the concentration of arsenic in urine were 90% and 23.2% respectively (AUC = 0.64, 95%
CI = 0.58 to 0.71, cut-off value 88.57 g/g).
The concentration of lead in urine was a poor predictor of CKDu (AUC = 0.53, 95% CI 0.38 to 0.67)
RESULTS OF URINE
4
3 The sensitivity and Dose-response analysis
specificity for Urine showed that Cadmium
Cadmium were 80% exposure is a risk factor
and 53.6% for the development of
respectively* CKDu* *
6
5 The sensitivity and The mean urine
specificity for concentration of Arsenic
concentration of in CKDu cases was above
Arsenic in urine was levels known to cause
90% and 23.2% oxidative injury to
respectively* kidneys
7
There was no significant dose-
effect relationship between
the concentration of Arsenic,
Lead or Selenium in Urine
and the stage of CKDu
2
About two-thirds
1 Serum (63%) of CKDu
Aluminium and subjects had
Chromium levels Selenium levels
were within normal below 90g/l.*
levels
3
Serum Strontium *Serum Selenium levels in CKDu subjects ranged
levels were above from 50.0 g/l to 121.8 g/l(reference range = 54 g/l
to 163 g/l).
normal limits** A serum selenium concentration of 90 g/l is required
to reach the maximum level of glutathione peroxidise
Water
Fertillisers Food
Environmental
Weedicides Samples Tobacco,
Beetle &
& Pesticides
Beedi
Soil Weeds
SPECIMEN HANDLING AND ANALYSIS
Lead Uranium
End canal = endemic area canal; End drink = endemic area drinking water; End reser = endemic area reservoir; End spring =
endemic area spring;nonend drink = non-endemic area drinking water. Horizontal lines within the boxes represent the median
values. The ends of the solid lines extending on either side of the boxes represent the minimum and the maximum. The dark
dots are outliers; defined as being more than 1.5 interquartile ranges away from the box. The interquartile range is the distance
between the upper part of the box and the lower part of the box.
RESULTS OF WATER ANALYSIS
2
1 Arsenic was borderline or
Levels of Cadmium, Lead raised in four samples* of
and Uranium in sources drinking water used by
of drinking water used by individuals with CKDu
individuals with CKDu repeat analysis from the
were within normal four sources showed
limits. normal Arsenic levels.
Reference limits: Arsenic <10 g /l, Cadmium <3 g/l, Lead <10 g/l, Uranium <2 g/l
4
3
In water samples from other All other samples from
sources in Endemic area, the wells, tube wells, irrigation
Arsenic concentration was canals, pipe-borne water,
22.2 g/l and 9.8 g/l in two reservoirs and natural
samples taken from a canal springs from endemic and
and a reservoir, non-endemic area, had
The Cadmium normal Arsenic,
concentration was 3.46 g/l in Cadmium and Lead
one sample from a reservoir levels.
The Lead concentration was
12.3 g/l in one sample from a
reservoir in the endemic area.
Reference limits: Arsenic <10 g /l, Cadmium <3 g/l, Lead <10 g/l, Uranium <2 g/l
DINKING
KEY MESSAGES WATER
Cadmium (mg/kg)
Levels of Cadmium in Source Endemic Area Non Endemic
certain vegetables such as lotus (EA) Area (NEA)
root, and in tobacco, were high. Lotus Mean 0.413 0.023
Levels of Cadmium in lotus Median 0.066 0.023
and tobacco were higher in Maximum 1.50 0.03
endemic than in non-endemic Tobacco Mean 0.351 0.316
areas Median 0.351 0.316
Maximum 0.44 0.351
FOOD
KEY MESSAGES TOBACCO
Since the Cadmium content of certain food items in the endemic area
is above stipulated levels, the total weekly intake of cadmium in
people living in the endemic area could exceed these safe limits, with
detrimental effects on the kidneys, particularly in vulnerable people
and those with predisposing factors.
RESULTS OF SOIL ANALYSIS
The mean Cd
Concentration of soil
from the endemic
area was 0.4g/g.
Endemic Area Non Endemic Endemic Area Non Endemic Endemic Area Non Endemic
(EA) Area (NEA) (EA) Area (NEA) (EA) Area (NEA)
n=26 n=8 n=26 n=8 n=26 n=8
A total of 26
samples analyzed
from endemic
areas
RESULTS OF PHOSPHATE FERTILIZERS
Endemic Area Non Endemic Endemic Area Non Endemic Endemic Area Non Endemic
(EA) Area (NEA) (EA) Area (NEA) (EA) Area (NEA)
n=13 n=6 n=13 n=6 n=13 n=6
Mean 2.98 0.49 94.23 20.29 0.06 0.43
Median 0.04 0.03 1.42 0.65 0.04 0.19
Minimum 0.01 0.01 0.17 0.09 0.00 0.00
Maximum 30.79 1.28 823.41 98.52 0.19 1.22
Pesticide residues
were detected in the
urine from individuals
Pesticide Residue Frequency of
with CKDu
detection
2,4-D 33%
3,5,6-trichloropyridinol 70%
P-nitrophenol 58%
1-naphthol 100%
2-naphthol 100%
Glyphosate 65%
Aminomethyl phosphonic acid (AMPA) 28%
Ib Analytical & Environmental Studies
Completed.
Ic Hospital Based CKD registry
Main objectives:
To characterize CKD / CKDu population
attending renal clinics in :
Medawachchiya DH
Medirigiriya BH
Anuradhapura GH
Polonnaruwa GH
Medawachchiya DH
13% Medirigiriya BH
25%
Polonnaruwa GH
14%
Female
28% Male
72%
Anuradhapura GH
48%
Cases Registered in the hospital registry - 1997
Household
Maps Sample
Survey Maps
2200 Households
mapped upto GN level
Water
Fertillisers Food
Environmental
Weedicides Samples Tobacco,
& Beetle &
Pesticides Beedi
Soil Weeds
Approximately 450
sampling sites mapped
Capacity of 50 field volunteers built from the area
IeId Establishment of a literature repository for CKD
Water analysis
Heavy Metals Flouride
Biochemistry
Risk Factors Epidemiological Histology
Toxins
Trace elements
Miscellaneous
Radionuclides
Other related
literature
Presentations
(International
Publications
MAIN SUB PROJECTS OF THE CKDu RESEARCH
Cadmium (mg/kg)
Levels of Cadmium in Source Endemic Area Non Endemic
certain vegetables such as lotus (EA) Area (NEA)
root, and in tobacco, were high. Lotus Mean 0.413 0.023
Levels of Cadmium in lotus Median 0.066 0.023
and tobacco were higher in Maximum 1.50 0.03
endemic than in non-endemic Tobacco Mean 0.351 0.316
areas Median 0.351 0.316
Maximum 0.44 0.351
MAIN SUB PROJECTS OF THE CKDu RESEARCH
22
200 Case studies
questionnaires (with regard
& in depth to death of
interviews CKDu
person)
16 23
Key
Focus Group
informant
discussions
Interviews
RESULTS OF COMMUNITY BASED STUDY
Community Fear with regard to the illness, and social & emotional
Discourse cost due to stigma
98% Sinhalese
98% Buddhists
50% were skilled agriculture and fishery workers
whilst 40% were unemployed
54% monthly family income was Rs5000-20000
RESULTS OF HOSPITAL BASED STUDY- COST TO
PATIENTS
Clinic
74% used the bus to attend clinic patients
Direct cost of the last clinic visit of the participant Direct
1000 Costs
Cost Median (LKR)
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Cost Item
RESULTS OF HOSPITAL BASED STUDY-COST TO
PATIENTS
Clinic
patients
Median time spent on the clinic visit by a participant was 8
hours
Indirect
Indirect Cost of patients seeking clinical care Costs
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
Lost income by patients (n=11) Payment for covering work (n=43) Lost income by family members (n=35)
RESULTS OF HOSPITAL BASED STUDY-COST TO
PATIENTS
Inpatients
Total No of inpatients 132 (Including those
on dialysis)
Mean duration of hospitalisation 1 day
Key demographic features of the hospitalised patients were:
71% Males
93% Sinhalese
92% Buddhists
39% were skilled agriculture and fishery workers
whilst 63% were unemployed
54% monthly family income was Rs5000-20000
RESULTS OF HOSPITAL BASED STUDY COST
TO PATIENTS
Inpatients
56% used a hired three wheeler to reach (Including those
hospital on dialysis)
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
Cost Item
RESULTS OF HOSPITAL BASED STUDY COST
TO PATIENTS
Inpatients
(Including those
Indirect cost of the hospitalisation on dialysis)
1200 Indirect
Costs
1000
Cost median (LKR)
800
600
400
200
0
Lost income by Payment for covering Lost income by
patient (n=3) work (n=7) family members
(n=29)
Cost Item
RESULTS OF HOSPITAL BASED STUDY COST
TO HEALTH SYSTEM
Cost of
Based on clinic services at Anuradhapura Renal Unit
clinic care
Telecommunication 1,046
Utilities
Paramedical 58,747
Nursing 897,913
Medical 260,178
RESULTS OF HOSPITAL BASED STUDY COST
TO HEALTH SYSTEM
Inpatient
Based on Renal Unit at Anuradhapura TH care
Telecommunication 10,024.47
Utilities
Electricity 660,886.30
Water 145253.08
Average Number of
Fuel 130446.34
patients hospitalized per
Meals 230830.84 month is 1182
Overheads
Nursing 1346870.09
Medical 390,266.75
0.00 200,000.00 400,000.00 600,000.00 800,000.00 1,000,000.001,200,000.001,400,000.001,600,000.00
Haemodiaysis
Rs 4,900
RESULTS OF HOSPITAL BASED STUDY COST
TO ILLNESS TO COMMUNITY
A sample of 200 patients chosen from Padaviya and
Madawachchiya
Patient
To be provided at an earlier stage of the illness
Allowance
MAIN SUB PROJECTS OF THE CKDu RESEARCH
Aristalochia labiosa
Aristalochia littoralis
Aristalochia bracteolata
RESULTS OF NEPHROTOXIC HERBAL REMEDY
STUDY
Usage of of Aristolochoia Species
May 2013 Minister (Senior) for Rural Affairs & Chairman of the
Committee to look into Indiscriminate use of fertilizer & Agrochemicals
INDISCRIMINATE USAGE IF CHEMICAL FERTILIZER AND
AGROCHEMICALS
The Ministerial
committee
1st Meeting on
The Officials November
Committee 2012
Research findings on
Pesticides (Including
the effect of soil
Weedicides,
Fertlliser use in Sri agriculture, water,
herbicides and Organic Agriculture
Lanka with Special fertiliser and
fungicides) used in in Sri Lanka
reference to CKDu pesticide use on
Sri Lanka with
CKDu & any other
special reference to
links such as food &
CKDu
drinking water
Ministry of Health - Cabinet Memorandum
1
Water purification schemes to be scaled up
2
Strengthen the regulatory framework to improve quality control of imported
agrochemicals
3
Implement and monitor comprehensive public health measures to reduce the
exposure of farmers to harmful health effects of agrochemicals
4 Improve service provision for early detection of CKDu, hypertension and
diabetes and appropriate treamtment
5
Increase the financial assistance provided to farmer families affected by CKDu
Banned importation of 4
Updated Fertilizer pesticides
Recommendations for paddy Carbaryl, Chloropyrifos,
Carbofuran, Propanil
Ministry of Agriculture - Cabinet Memorandum
15 Recommendations
1
Establishment of Statutory Technical Council to promote environmentally friendly
agriculture
2
Establishment of new Sri Lankan Standards (SLS) on pesticides and agrochemicals
3
To make orders under the Pesticide Control Act to retain heavy metals and
impurities to a minimum possible level
15
4 Establishing methodology for controlling under-growth
Re (weeds) of paddy
cultivation & encouraging farmers to cultivate alternate crops for minimizing the
use of pesticide
12 Prohibit pesticide and agro-chemical fertilliser advertising over electronic & print
media
Ministry of Agriculture - Cabinet Memorandum (Cont..)
13
Establishment of a safety method for recycling/disposal of empty pesticide
containers/bottles and fertillizer bags
14
Providing people in Kidney disease prone areas with drinking water free of
insipid water
15
Impose a 10% health safety cess on all imported pesticide varieties and the levied
amount to be used for welfare of the kidney patients and research activities
Minister (Senior) for Rural Affairs & Chairman of
the Committee to look into the indiscriminate
usage of chemical fertilizer & Agrochemicals
1
Launch an islandwide program to identify CKDu patients with special attention
to NCP & take action to declare CKDu as a notifiable disease
2
Carry out surveys using GIS to identify all CKDu hotspots upto Grama Niladhari
Division
3
Declare CKDu hotspots and take all initiatives, to establish casual factors and to
mitigate CKDu in the prevalent areas
4 Establish a high powered policy implementation body to carry out further
research on establishing the exact causal factors of CKDu and to control CKDu
and CKD under an appropriate ministry and to coordinate and implement the
recommendations
Minister (Senior) for Rural Affairs & Chairman of the
Committee to look into the indiscriminate usage of
chemical fertilizer & Agrochemicals (Cont)
5
Launch a multidisciplinary further research program to cover all spectrum of
CKDu and to strongly establish the causal factor for CKDu
6 Further analyze the fertilizer recommendation scheme while paying specail
attention to the environmental consequence of the scheme
Facilities of the traditional medical practitioners to carry out their treatments for
the affected people based on the patient interest & demand
19
Expedite the establishment of proposed chemical fertilliser manufacturing plant
to produce fertilliser with minimum/standard limits of heavy metals using
Eppawella rock phosphate
Minister (Senior) for Rural Affairs & Chairman of
the Committee to look into the indiscriminate
usage of chemical fertilizer & Agrochemicals
20
Establish procedures for examination of quality of agrochemicals at boarder poits,
Factory outlets, wholesale & retail shops in the districts
21 Establish long term water quality monitoring system by an accredited agency
under direct supervision of a government institution.
27
Introduce programmes for organic and sustainable certification to receive
premium prices for farm products
28
Establish appropriate CSR avenues through Banks, Insurance companies, NGOs,
local institutions for possible subsidy or incentives for proposed curative and
corrective measures
29
Conduct extended cost benefit analysis for the use of agrochemicals in
consideration of their impact on environmental & social effects
Ministry of Water Supply and Drainage
National Water Supply & Drainage Board
1
Parliamentary Sub committee appointed to coordinate mitigation measures
2 Concept paper and action plans have been prepared for supplying safe drinking
water to all affected areas
3 District wise action items/sub projects have been identified
4 Implementation Plans
SHORT TERM:
Water for drinking and cooking using small RO (Reverse Osmosis) plants
Rain water harvesting
MEDIUM TERM:
Medium sized water supplies based on surface water
Water Supply extensions
LONG TERM:
Major Integrated Water Supply projets
Ministry of Social Services
2 To pay monthly assistance of Rs 1500 each for kidney patients who do not
require dialysis (Stated in Grade 2/3)
3 To pay monthly assistance of Rs 3000 each for kidney patients who require
dialysis (Stated in Grade 3/4)
Sri Lanka has done work in the area of CKDu over many years.
With a coordinated research initiative over a period of 27
months funded by NSF and WHO has yielded evidence to
initiate policy dialogue which has resulted in the highest political
commitment translated into action by different stakeholders
and ministries.
Thank You