Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Speaker name
plane definition
Forerunner of GEC,
and now AREVA
(Stafford, UK)
(1)
I1 = local current
I2 = remote current,
k = Constant (a bias slope)
10
10
11
11
12
12
13
13
14
14
15
15
16
16
TRIP
TRIP
NO
TRIP
TRIP
TRIP
18
TRIP
NO
TRIP
TRIP
TRIP
Reminder:
N = Local Current (xIn)
M = Remote/Local Ratio
K1 = Low Bias Slope
K2 = High Bias Slope
19
19
Reminder:
N = Local Current (xIn)
M = Remote/Local Ratio
K1 = Low Bias Slope
K2 = High Bias Slope
20
20
Scenario (1):
Error in compensating for Propagation Delay
Dual Slope Current differential relays measure the propagation
delay - the time taken for messages to traverse the end-end
channel
The propagation delay measurement is used to time shift current
vectors into time alignment, allowing a like for like comparison
relating to the same instant in real time
The most likely source of incorrect time alignment is on a
SONET/SDH system
The higher the relative difference in Tx and Rx (t), the greater the
error
This error does not affect magnitude, only phase - causing a rotation
at unity radius on an Alpha plane as we will see later
22
22
7.8ms
7.8ms
Standby
(protection)
path
TX
3.8ms
fault
RX
RX
TX
3.8ms
Worker (main) path
23
25
25
GPS
receiver
GPS
receiver
1sec
1sec
M iC O M
M iC O M
T R IP
T R IP
ALAR M
ALAR M
O U T O F S E R V IC E
O U T O F S E R V IC E
HEA LTHY
C LE A R
RE AD
EN TER
CG
Relay at End A
26
CLEA R
READ
ENTER
CG
E D IT
E D IT
H EA LTH Y
Relay at End B
26
Reminder:
N = Local Current (xIn)
M = Remote/Local Ratio
K1 = Low Bias Slope
K2 = High Bias Slope
27
Trip
Stable Region
3
2
t = 2 x (180-157)/360 cycles
Note: doubling is due to the
error in time alignment being
half of the real difference
1
0
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
28
29
0.6
2.3
0.9
3.3
1.2
4.5
1.5
5.9
139
120
99
74
29
NO
TRIP
Reminder:
N = Local Current (xIn)
M = Remote/Local Ratio
K1 = Low Bias Slope
K2 = High Bias Slope
30
30
Scenario (2):
Current Transformer Saturation
Conjunctive testing is always performed on differential
relays to check for fast operation for in-zone faults
32
32
33
Reminder:
N = Local Current (xIn)
M = Remote/Local Ratio
K1 = Low Bias Slope
K2 = High Bias Slope
34
34
TRIP
NO
TRIP
Reminder:
N = Local Current (xIn)
M = Remote/Local Ratio
K1 = Low Bias Slope
K2 = High Bias Slope
35
35
36
36
Saturation creates an
unbalance in the system
by changing the value of
M from its natural value of 1
to a higher value and to less than
180 instead of the natural value of 180. The relay
restrains for such deviations as restraint region is large because
during CT saturation the relay is in the high bias slope characteristic
37
37
38
38
39
40
41
41
42
43
43
44
45
OUTFEED
With the pre-fault voltage at fault point as reference ( i.e VFpf = 1 0 )
the terminal voltages VLpf and VRpf would lead and lag this voltage up
to 10-15 degrees , respectively ,depending on the load flow. We can
also assume the load current Iload to be in phase with VFpf.
If the resistive component of the fault current infeed from one of the
terminals, IL and IR, is less than the load current (which is also
resistive) the resulting angle between IL and IR may be around 180 as
shown here. This is called OUTFEED.
46
46
WEAK INFEED
As the fault resistance gets smaller and becomes comparable to other
circuit impedances, the total fault current as well as its components IL
and IR start lagging the pre-fault voltage, VFpf ,whilst their
amplitudes increase. Consequently, the angle will start to decrease
from 180 . If the load component of the current at one of the ends still
remains significant, the angle will remain in this area (that
corresponds to 90 to 270 in the plane)
47
47
48
NO
TRIP
Reminder:
N = Local Current (xIn)
M = Remote/Local Ratio
K1 = Low Bias Slope
K2 = High Bias Slope
49
50
51
NO
TRIP
Reminder:
N = Local Current (xIn)
M = Remote/Local Ratio
K1 = Low Bias Slope
K2 = High Bias Slope
52
52
53
53
Observations
54
Conclusions (1)
The operation of a dual slope bias current differential
relay can be represented in detail in the alpha plane; low,
transition and high bias have been shown in the alpha
plane. Analyzing the performance of the relay seen from
the alpha plane point of view, we can conclude:
Higher tolerated asymmetry in the transmission
delays could be achieved by increasing the low slope
bias setting but compromising the sensitivity of the
relay. Instead of that, solutions for permanent and
semi-permanent channel asymmetry can be done.
55
55
Conclusions (2)
The dual slope bias current differential relay adapts
perfectly for heavy external through faults as the
restrain region increases once we are in the high bias
slope. Additionally for the more onerous faults
(multiphase faults), the relay uses the highest bias
making it even more stable, with the restrain region
increasing.
The inherent adaptivity of the dual slope bias current
differential relay makes it appropriate for Weak infeed
and Outfeed conditions which are located in II and III
quadrants.
56
56
Conclusions (3)
And finally. by using the alpha plane mathematical
technique mentioned by A.R. van C. Warrington in
1962, we have shown that the well known Biased
Current Differential technique that has been widely
used for years to protect the most vital plant in power
systems such as lines, generators and transformers is
completely valid.
57
57