Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Shell nouns as
cohesive devices in
published and
ESL student writing
Discussion leader: Cedra B. Binalet
Abstract
Research questions
1. Is the use of the selected shell nouns as
frequent in the written production of published
authors as in students production?
2. Which lexico-grammatical patterns can be
identified in both corpora for the most
frequently used shell nouns in the published
corpus?
3. How do these shell nouns function in different
lexico-grammatical patterns as cohesive
devices? Are there any functional differences
between both groups of writers?
Terminology
Francis
(1986)
Ivanic
(1991)
Carrier nouns
Francis
Advance/retros
(1989, 1994) pective labels
Definition
Enumerative
nouns
Hinkel (2001,
2004)
Enumerative/
catch-all nouns
Flowerdew
(2003)
Signalling nouns
Pattern
Example
Cataphoric
Cataphoric
Anaphoric
Demonstrative adjective
(this,
that) + shell noun
Anaphoric
Demonstrative pronoun
as subject (this, that,) +
be + shell noun
Number
of texts
Number of
words
Academic disciplines
Published
authors
166
721,553
Student
writers
28
66,459
Published writing
corpus
Frequency in 100,000
words
effect
result
fact
system
process
problem
approach
reason
purpose
characteristics
form
Student corpus
Frequency in
100,000 words
Lexico-grammatical patterns:
identification and comparison across
corpora
Occurrences of the six shell nouns in the
published and student corpora.
Neither published writers nor student writers used
any of these shell nouns in the patterns N + be +
clause (shell noun+ be + complement clause
[that-/to-infinitive/wh- clause]) with cataphoric
function and th- + be + N(demonstrative
determiner [this, that] + be + shell noun with
anaphoric function.
Functional analysis
Characterization
Temporary conceptformation
Linking
Conclusion
study
Answer
quickly- who
has control
in the
following
conversation
s?
What is talk for?
Eg: a passenger buying
a ticket from a train
driver;
A teacher giving a class
instructions
Think of as many
rTeache
t?
studen
Shop
nt
a
t
s
i
s
as
me
o
t
s
u
c
r
Doctorpatient
Friend
friend