Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Management
July 9, 2007
Agenda
ENTERPRISE
DISTRIBUTIVE
E
NETWORK
N
D
Engineering
C
O
Sourcing
Logistics
S
U
M
Operations
E
R
S
Energy
I - Basic
Beginnings
Quality/cost
teams
Longer -term
contracts
Volume
leveraging
Inventory
and transport
measurement
II - Moderate
Development
Ad hoc supplier/
customer
alliances
Crossfunctional
teams
Supplier/
Customer base
optimization
Cross-location
international
teams
III - Limited
Integration
Global sourcing /
distribution
Defined alliances
Supplier
development
Total cost of
ownership
Parts/service
standardization
Pull/demand flow
inventory systems
Global supply
chains with
external customer
focus
Comprehensive
information
visibility
Full service
suppliers
EPI / ESI
Insourcing/
outsourcing to
maximize core
competencies of
firms throughout
the supply chain
6
10
Agenda
11
ROA
Market Return
Circuit City
162%
4%
-33%
Best Buy
208%
8%
1025%
Kmart
109%
-2%
-62%
Wal-Mart
199%
8%
284%
Daimler Chrysler
172%
7%
-47%
Toyota Motor
228%
12%
26%
Motorola
432%
3%
-11%
Intel
2507%
22%
55%
GMROI =
12
13
Manufacturing
SC Organization
Disconnection of
External Market
Intelligence
Marketing & Sales
Disconnection of
Internal Business
Intelligence
Supplier
Copyright 2005 Baios, Inc.
14
Building Partnerships
A few wins:
15
Our Role
Plant perspective
16
Our Role
What we are trying to do
17
Challenges
Knowing what we have
Real differences among plants
18
Challenges (continued)
How to demonstrate savings
19
What information does the supply chain team need access to?
What are obstacles to getting it?
What do stakeholders need to do to support the SC team?
20
Agenda
21
Breakthrough
SupplyPeople
Management Performance
Model
Process
Collaboration
Results
and Integration
Continuous
Improvement
Power
Knowledge
Position
Supplier
Relationship
Management
+
Critical
Factors
Maturity
Score
Strategic
Sourcing
Performance
Management
Core Influence
Tactics
Consulting
Aligning
Personal
Effectiveness
Score
Enterprise
Perspective
& Team Spirit
Productive
Internal
Business
Discussions
SCM Business
Impact &
Performance
Reasoning
Supplier
Collaboration
&
Cooperation
Relationship
Capital
Trust
Process &
Performance
Enablers
Intimacy
Breadth of Network
Depth of Knowledge
Copyright 2005 Baios, Inc.
22
23
Focus
onselected
Value
Creation
and
Innovation
Suppliers
based
Suppliers selected
based on
on local
local criteria
criteria &
& often
often without
without formal
formal
Contract
Contract terms,
terms, conditions,
conditions, &
& risks
risks vary
vary greatly.
greatly.
Established
Critical
Processes
and
Supplier
performance
rated
on
inconsistent
local
criteria.
Supplier performance rated on inconsistent local criteria.
Systems
Relationships
Relationships managed
managed through
through casual
casual &
& informal
informal contact
contact
processes.
processes.
No
No organized
organized process
process for
for review
review &
& development
development of
of relationships
relationships or
or
agreements.
agreements.
Improvement
Improvement actions
actions are
are event
event &
& occurrence
occurrence driven.
driven.
24
5
4
3
2
1
Emerging
Awareness
Sustainable,
Intertwined
Businesses
Emerging Organizational
Organizational
Awareness
Established
Established local
local pool
pool of
of potential
potential suppliers
suppliers is
is identified
identified &
&
documented.
documented.
Focus
ondriven
Value
Creation
and Innovation
RFX
established.
Locally
Locally
driven
RFX processes
processes
established.
Local
Local contracts
contracts built
built on
on standardized
standardized T&Cs
T&Cs &
& usually
usually subject
subject to
to
central
central review.
review.
Established
Critical
Processes
and
metrics
established
at
site
level.
Performance
Performance metrics established at site level.
Systems
Market
Market intelligence
intelligence limited
limited to
to local
local businesss
businesss understanding.
understanding.
Relationships
Relationships are
are managed
managed through
through regular
regular though
though often
often informal
informal
Emerging
Organizational
Awareness
contact
contact between
between suppliers
suppliers &
& local
local leadership.
leadership.
Informal
Informal reviews
reviews of
of outcomes
outcomes on
on an
an annual
annual basis.
basis.
Business
Business cases
cases for
for key
key product
product &
& process
process improvements
improvements driven
driven
Ad Hoc
and
Offcasual
the&&Radar
by
informal
by local
local needs.ugh
needs.ugh casual
informal contact
contact
25
SRM Maturity
Levels: Level 3
Established Critical Processes/Systems
5
4
3
2
1
Sustainable,
Intertwined
Businesses
centrally,
strategies.
RFX
RFX processes
processes driven
driven
centrally, usually
usually by
by category
category
strategies.
Local
Local businesses
businesses select
select suppliers
suppliers already
already approved
approved through
through category
category management
management or
or
other
central
management
processes.
other central management processes.
Centralized
Centralized contracts
contracts driven
driven by
by aa central
central function.
function.
KPIs
KPIs established
established &
& tracked
tracked at
at both
both Corporate
Corporate (Big
(Big R)
R) &
& local
local (little
(little r)
r) levels
levels
Market
intelligence
is
driven
by
buyer
category
strategy
function.
Market intelligence is driven by buyer category strategy function.
Site
Site level
level relationships
relationships (little
(little r)
r) regularly
regularly reviewed
reviewed against
against enterprise-level
enterprise-level relationship
relationship
(Big
R)
strategies
&
objectives
(Big R) strategies & objectives
Customer/Supplier
Customer/Supplier contact
contact roles
roles are
are defined,
defined, including
including primary
primary &
& secondary
secondary contacts,
contacts,
little
r
business
sponsor
&
Big
R
executive
sponsor,
with
other
functional
&
team-based
little r business sponsor & Big R executive sponsor, with other functional & team-based
roles.
roles.
Relationship
Relationship mgt
mgt responsibility
responsibility is
is spread
spread across
across the
the organization
organization &
& relationship
relationship
managers
managers can
can have
have broad
broad portfolios
portfolios of
of relationships.
relationships.
Supplier/Customer
Supplier/Customer contacts,
contacts, business
business &
& executive
executive sponsors
sponsors are
are actively
actively engaged
engaged in
in
regular
regular reviews
reviews of
of business
business outcomes
outcomes &
& KPI.
KPI.
Performance
Performance information
information &
& project
project schedules
schedules are
are openly
openly shared
shared with
with suppliers
suppliers &
&
stakeholders.
stakeholders.
Centrally
Centrally managed
managed supplier
supplier development
development resources
resources ensure
ensure supplier
supplier quality.
quality.
Business
case
for
changes
&
relationship
management
is
clearly
defined
Business case for changes & relationship management is clearly defined &
& documented
documented
at
at Big
Big R
R&
& little
little rr levels
levels
Established
Critical Processes and
Systems
Emerging
Organizational Awareness
26
SRM Maturity
Levels: Level 4
Focus on Value Creation and Innovation
4
3
2
1
outcomes
outcomes than
than compliance
compliance with
with T&Cs.
T&Cs.
KPIs
KPIs &
& other
other performance
performance metrics
metrics are
are increasingly
increasingly qualitativeespecially
qualitativeespecially at
at the
the Big
Big R
R
level.
level.
Extensive,
Extensive, multifunctional
multifunctional contacts
contacts at
at local
local &
& corporate
corporate levels
levels with
with access
access to
to each
each
others
best
functional
expertise
&
resources.
others best functional expertise & resources.
Deep
Deep investments
investments in
in relationships
relationships &
& understanding
understanding each
each others
others organizational
organizational
capabilities.
capabilities.
Market
Market intelligence
intelligence developed
developed by
by pooling
pooling the
the knowledge
knowledge of
of both
both supplier
supplier &
& buyer
buyer
organizations.
organizations.
Defined
Defined process
process for
for inducting
inducting &
& educating
educating new
new team
team members.
members.
Explicit
Explicit investment
investment in
in dedicated
dedicated Relationship
Relationship management
management resources
resources who
who manage
manage
limited
number
(1-3)
suppliers
&
spend
25-30%
of
time
with
suppliers.
limited number (1-3) suppliers & spend 25-30% of time with suppliers.
Organization
Organization recognizes
recognizes the
the value
value of
of maintaining
maintaining continuity
continuity of
of relationships
relationships with
with team
team
members
&
acts
to
balance
career
progression
with
tenure
in
role.
members & acts to balance career progression with tenure in role.
Relationship
Relationship Managers
Managers have
have aa dedicated
dedicated manager
manager who
who reports
reports high
high in
in the
the organization
organization
&
follow
a
defined
management/coaching
processes.
& follow a defined management/coaching processes.
Continuous
Continuous improvement
improvement processes
processes are
are in
in place
place &
& anchored
anchored into
into the
the culture.
culture.
Mutual
Mutual investments
investments in
in process
process &
& capability
capability enhancements
enhancements that
that provide
provide differentiated
differentiated
efficiencies
or
innovation.
efficiencies or innovation.
Problems
Problems are
are fixed
fixed quickly
quickly without
without extensive
extensive approval
approval processes/documentation.
processes/documentation.
Copyright 2007 Supply Market Intelligence & Integration. All rights
Transparency
&
Transparency of
of business
business model
model
& profit
profit drivers
drivers in
in aa climate
climate of
of verifiable
verifiable trust.
trust.
reserved.
27
Either party is willing to make short term investments without parity or short term
Focus
on Value Creation and Innovation
Established
Critical Processes and
Systems
Emerging
Organizational Awareness
Sustainable,
Intertwined
Businesses
Sustainable, Intertwined Businesses
Focus
on Value
Creation
andKPIs
Innovation
organizations
for
organizations directly
directly &
& quickly
quickly influence
influence KPIs
for teams,
teams,
members
members &
& executive
executive sponsors.
sponsors.
Additional
Additional market
market intelligence
intelligence developed
developed through
through joint
joint investment
investment
in
in capabilities
capabilities &
& research.
research.
Business
Business strategies
strategies &
& models
models are
are adjusted
adjusted based
based on
on each
each others
others
plans
plans &
& capabilities.
capabilities.
The
The hard
hard issues
issues &
& areas
areas of
of conflict
conflict are
are addressed
addressed quickly
quickly &
&
objectively.
objectively.
Regular,
Regular, formal
formal &
& informal
informal contact
contact between
between both
both parties
parties
executives
executives in
in recognition
recognition of
of mutual
mutual dependence
dependence &
& in
in the
the spirit
spirit of
of
personal
personal &
& organizational
organizational intimacy.
intimacy.
Systems
Emerging
Organizational Awareness
28
29
Agenda
30
2. Enroll
stakeholders
3. Establish
Governance
4. Review business
needs &
strategies
5. Establish
vision ;Themes &
drivers
Understand
Scope & subcommodities
1. Define market
sector
commodity
structure
3. Define resource
requirements
demand
/demand
strategy for
& supply analysis interface & segment options implementation
1. Collate spend
2. Define business
need
Evaluate supply
market
dynamics &
trends and TCO
1. Segment &
identify
commodities &
sourcing
options
2. Evaluate
procurement
levers & cost
drivers
3. Develop
category & subcommodity
strategies
4. Confirm
procurement
approach
5. Back to ensure
alignment with
business (where
applicable)
1. Review and
finalise project
opportunities
with planning
3. Define enablers
to accommodate
strategic plan
4. Conduct
business review,
agreement &
signoff
5. Reassess and
confirm
6. Prioritise
projects against
sourcing criteria
31
E-Negotiate
6 Sigma
Leverage
HIGH
Large Consumption
Many alternative
Spend
Risk
Impact on
core business
initiatives
products / services
Readily Available
Important to business
Business
Impact
LOW
Strategic
Non-Standard
Common
Standard product
Many alternative
products / services
Low value items
Numerous suppliers
Readily Available
LOW
Operationally Critical
Support LOB Initiatives
Competitive Advantage
Few qualified suppliers
Unique Request
Complex Specifications
Important to business
Not Readily Available
Few alternative products /
services
Business
Relationship
6 Sigma
HIGH
32
33
Customers Environment
Suppliers Environment
Suppliers
Supplier
Supplier
andand
Market
Market
Intelligence
Intelligence
A GUESSING GAME
Company
Customer and
Market Intelligence
Customers
Business Intelligence
34
KNOWLEDGE
INFORMATION
Market Intelligence
Markets
Industries
Goods & Commodities
Finance
Suppliers
Competitors
Technologies
DATA
35
36
Push
MEETING &
REPORT
Spend Analysis
Pricing
Market Status
Political
Geographic
Demand
Supply
Step 2
Step 3
Customer
Needs
Assessment
Conduct
Market
Analysis
Pull
Requests for:
Specific queries
SME Interviews
Scenario plans
Supplier data
Step 4
Develop
Category
Strategy
Step 5
Negotiate and
Select
Suppliers
Push
MEETING
Updated info
Present results
Strategic thinking
Positioning
Scenario plans
Step 6
Develop
Implementation
Plan
Pull
Contracts
Terms
Indicators
Step 7
Manage
Supplier
Performance
Relationship
Manager
Push
Alerts
News Feeds
Price Trends
Statistics
37
Strategic
Cost
Modeling
Process to inform
management and
SBUs of trends
in cost and
supply
Market
Index
Planning &
Reporting
Commodit
y Price
Analysis
" CAMS
Supplie
r
Market
Analysi
s&
Reports
Identify/Communicate
trends in supply and
demand and provide
analysis
suppliers
Copyright of
2005
Baios, Inc.
Establish a market
price to compare BPs
price to identify
competitive
advantages
38
39
Discovered Customers
40
Discovered Suppliers
Only three with national capabilities
Additional Research
PPI Detailed Reports
41
42
Discovered Customers
43
Discovered Supplier
Industry challenges
44
Plant purchasing
Quary managers
Production managers
Used EZsupply
45
Hidden complexity
46
47
LOW RISK
Annual or quarterly
update using Risk
Survey Tool
48
GOAL:
Resilient
Supply Chain
With On-going
Knowledge and
Risk Mitigation
Copyright 2005 Baios, Inc.
3c. Invest in
Visibility
systems
49
50
Engages talent and skills of suppliers personnel in achieving Essrocs business goals
Integrates external organizations into Essrocs cross functional teams
Ensures relationship is mutually beneficial
Extends Essrocs quality and delivery expectations to tier-2 and tier-3 suppliers
51
People from the supplier (field application engineers) live in our Dell facilities,
and they are the feedback mechanisms to back to their company to deal with
supplier quality processes and failure analysis.
Daily, weekly, and quarterly performance reviews with the supplier and not
just about the product, but with people who are providing service technicians,
HR services, etc.
52
Areas
Areas of
of Improvement
Improvement
Expected
Expected Outcome
Outcome
Supplier Qualification
Supplier Development
Reduced Shortages
Quality Management
New Supplier
Supplier Collaboration
Source
Make
Deliver
Return
53
Sr.Sr.
management
management
Staff Business
Sr. management
Line of Business
Staff
Business
Leaders
Leaders
Line Business
Leaders
Line
Business
End Users
Leaders
End Users
SCM/
Procurement
Account
Owner
Specialists
R&D
Account Services
Geographic Sales
FACILITATE INTEGRATION!
The
The Customer
Customer
Organization
Organization
The
The Supplier
Supplier
Organization
Organization
Copyright 2005 Baios, Inc.
54
Sr. Management
Staff Business
SCM/
Procurement
Leaders
Line Business
Leaders
End Users
Sr. Management
Line of Business
Specialists
R&D
Account Services
Geographic Sales
The
The Customer
Customer
Organization
Organization
Account
Owner
The
The Supplier
Supplier
Organization
Organization
Copyright 2005 Baios, Inc.
55
Defined
Managed/Linked
Leveraged/Integrated
Optimized/Extended
Traditional Competencies
Integrity and ethical behavior
Cost-reduction focus
Sense of urgency and results orientation
Business process analysis
56
Defined
Managed/Linked
Traditional Competencies
Integrity and ethical behavior
Cost-reduction focus
Sense of urgency and results orientation
Business process analysis
Leveraged/Integrated
Optimized/Extended
Breakthrough Competencies
Enterprise-wide perspective and
customer-focused decision making
Business acumen and innovative thinking
Operational improvement through
collaboration and team leadership
Communications, influencing, and
facilitating change
57
Final Thought
If you insist on beginning only with
certainties
you shall end in doubts;
but if you will be content to begin with
doubts
you shall end in certainties.
(Francis Bacon)
58