Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Blowing:
The Ethical
Aspects
Introduction
Individual's association to morality and WB
WB=Function of degree of association that individual
creates between (act of) wrongdoing and (his/her
understanding of) morality)
Worldcom Case and Cynthia Cooper: Didnt accede to
her superiors instructions not to waste time and dug
into deeper moral recesses (Sherron Watkins and Enron
Case)
Coopers association with professional accounting
standards influenced her to WB and she later revealed
about the influence of Bible on her( treat other people
the way you want to be treated)
Is WB compatible with Employee Loyalty?
WB and Organizations
Highly negative impact
Weakening chain of command
Threat to effectiveness
Unsettle employees confidence and ability to use
discretion
Need for right of public to know needs to be weighed
against right of organization to maintain secrecy in
some areas
WB in India
WB in India...cont
The Narayana Murthy Report also suggested the
incorporation of whistle blowers policy within the
companies to enable the employees to approach the
audit committee when they observe unethical or
improper practice with informing their superiors and
also protect them from unfair termination and other
prejudicial practices
According to a study by ASSOCHAM and E&Y WB is used
in a limited manner by India Inc for fraud prevention
Drawbacks: Hierarchical set-ups with single nucleus of
power-Threats (monetary and non-monetary)
Making a Case: Benefits to stakeholders-attracting right
talent-Proper handling needed for sustained value
creation
The Insider
Should Jeffrey Wigand disclose his information?
Is it unethical to encourage another person to
break his promise for grater social good
Should 60 minutes have succumbed to
corporate interests and aired edited version
Case Analysis
Is nicotine boosting an ethical practice of tobacco
companies?
Is blowing the whistle justified in this case?
Pleasure
Pain
Utility
Impact on family
benefits and
confidentiality
agreement
Face lawsuit
Damage to
tobacco industry
and employees
High Utility
Not
Family Benefits
Disclose
Tobacco Industry
and people
protected
Low Utility
Exposure to
harm public
Public hurt as
tobacco cos will
continue to act
Possible
benefits to
public greater
than costs
Pleasure
Pain
Utility
To Encourage
Possible
benefits to
people
Uphold
integrity of
60 mnts
Impact on
Wigands
family
Lawsuit
against CBS
Damage to
tobacco
industry
Low to
medium
Benefits to
public
uncertain
Costs more
evident
60 mnts
and CBS to
lose credibility
Public will
never find out
truth
Medium to
high utility
Knows
pleasure but
not pain
Recap
Should Wigand Disclose
Information?
Should Bergman
encourage Brigand to
disclose information?
Utilitarian
Kantian
Not Encourage:
Encourage others to
break promises
unethical
Rawlsian
The Class
Stand?
Encourage: Right to
know truth
Pleasure
Pain
Utility
Dont
agree
Public welfare
Maintain professional
integrity
Lose jobs
Lose $5.3
million
Potential
lawsuit to
Westinghouse
Medium to high:
Lots of pain by
them but public
to benefit greatly
Agree
Keep jobs
Gain $5.3 million
Avoid lawsuit
Sale to Westinghouse
Guilt
Low Utility: Lots
Damage CBS
of pain to public
NEWS reputation as a whole
Lose credibility
Public oblivious of
information
Negotiate
Lose jobs
Lose $5.3
million
High Utility
Integrity and
professionalism
maintained and
more options