Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Macroeconomic Implications of Ecommerce The industry-level and economy-wide investments related to ecommerce? Implications for growth, employment, productivity, and inflation? How can these investments and their effects be untangled from the influence of other phenomena? How should we identify and measure the key drivers of the ecommerce? How should we account for intangible consumer benefits and burdens? How pervasive is ecommerce in the economy, between businesses and business and consumers? Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 What is ecommerce?
Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Ecommerce is any form of business transaction in which the parties interact electronically rather than by physical exchanges or direct physical contact It is one of those rare cases where changing needs and new technologies come together to revolutionize the way in which business is conducted European Commission (1997) http://www.ispo.cec/be/Ecommerce/whatis.htm Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 ECOMMERCE includes at least the following: The exchange of goods and services across an interactive digital network A computer-mediated and virtual market with new relationships among businesses and consumers A digital means of exchange (digital money, ecash, secure credit card transactions) The increasing importance of digital information as a commodity Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 More: New business processes and technologies to support digital transactions New business strategies and models to gain a competitive edge in the digital marketplace Technologies to ensure privacy and protect intellectual property A legislative and regulatory environment that supports ecommerce (domestic and international) Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 It enables companies To Be more efficient and flexible in their internal operations, Work more closely with their suppliers, Be more responsive to the needs and expectations of their customers, Select the best suppliers regardless of their geographical location, and Sell to a global market. Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Benefits of an ecommerce business:
reduces distribution costs or cost-of-sales shrink to near-zero. Examples include: publishing, information services or digital products categories
these can be delivered immediately- this may lead to massive disintermediation or even the eventual elimination of middleman
buyers and sellers can access and contact each other directly, potentially eliminating some costs and constraints of phone, letter, and fax Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 More selling- more of the selling function is in the hands of the customer, through online ordering and the use of fillout forms.This also allows the capture of customer information
firms can engage in dialog or communications with buyers
competitive intelligence- web technology allows the gathering market intelligence and monitoring of consumer choices through customers revealed preferences in browsing and buying Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Corporate ISP/VAN Dist Manufacturing Suppliers Government Banks Credit Card Companies Retail Consumers Internet Service Providers Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Ecommerce creates a marketplace for digital products, including: Software, text and image-based digitized objects Services that depend on information and data (electricity consumption etc) These can be produced and delivered over the net This changes traditional manufacturing and distribution processes Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Traditional commerce Physical product: a tangible, material object Physical process: interactions between buyers, sellers, producers Physical agent: People in a storefront Ecommerce Digital product: a digital object Digital process: interactions between buyers, sellers, producers online Digital agent: web storefront Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 components of a virtual economy Virtual players Virtual processes Virtual products The net Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Virtual players People, organizations, or automated agents with an online presence Virtual products Digitized objects/services: currency, text, multimedia, tickets, reservations, electric usage, pay-for-view, smart houses Virtual processes Participants interact digitally, interactively, and in real time (online ordering/payment; JIT inventory control; customized advertising) Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Virtual intermediaries Provide essential services: certification, authentication, quality assurance, copyright clearance, distribution Education brokers: bringing instructors and students together online Market organizers: establish meeting places for buyers and sellers (auctions...) Personalized service providers: shoppers, information filtering, travel agent, financial services Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 virtual firm Assumes that they exist in an environment where transaction costs are low They do not have to be based in a single geographic location Business processes can be distributed globally and take place on the net The value chain is digital Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 More: Products can be delivered through a digital web of business relationships with producers, financiers, distributors, consumers Producers, suppliers, warehouses, managers, administrator, subcontractors are all linked through an extranet Many functions can be easily outsourced (accounting, personnel management, training, public relations) Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Convergence in ecommerce Products, processes, and infrastructure all converge in the global digital marketplace Product: audio, video, still images, text all in the same digital format Process: multiple uses from a virtual process make other processes redundant Consumer feedback is used for product change, marketing, sales, pricing, and service Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Supplier opportunity Customer benefit
Global presence Global choice Improved competitiveness Quality of service Mass customizing and Personalized products targeting and services Shorten or eradicate Rapid response to supply chains needs Substantial cost savings Substantial price reductions New business opportunities New products and services http://www.ispo.cec.be/ecommerce/introduc.htm Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Ecommerce can: Reduce costs Shorten product cycle times Provide more rapid customer response Improve customer support and service Focus marketing efforts Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 E-commerce and economic efficiency: Costs
The cost of owning and operating a physical establishment
To carrying an inventory... ... to conducting a sale...
To placing an order
To customer support and after-sales service... To simple purchase orders and
Product distribution that is expected to fuel strong growth in the business-to-business segment of e-commerce Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Economic: business incentives for ecommerce Product promotion and customization through the direct connection to consumers Developing and exploiting new sales channels (products, information, advertising,transactions) Reduced costs of business transactions through a public shared infrastructure Reducing time to market for certain types of products Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 More: Improving customer relationships with intelligent systems for service and support Improving marketing and targeted advertising through the collection of detailed customer information New corporate branding and image creation Using the net for R&D and product development Developing of new business models based on characteristics of the new marketplace Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Current commercial uses of the net Commercial sites Storefronts, virtual communities, multiple user gaming Advertising: $150-200 million in 1996 Banner ads, targetted email (ads and product/service updates), customized web ads, spam Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 More: Commercial services Payment, product delivery, information collection, evaluation, and delivery Non-digital product transactions Books, cars, and other tangible goods Digital product transactions Publications, freeware, shareware, demo software, reservations, financial services Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Continued... Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Growth From $6.1 billion (1998) to $20 billion in sales by 2000 in the US Gartner Goup, 1998 6.8 million households and 16 million people will trade online (1998) - 15.2 million households and 33 million people by 2000 Jupiter Communication (1998) This is ~1% of the economy ($8.5 trillion) Business to business ecommerce: from $15.6 billion (1998) to $175 billion in 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 According to OECD: Total ecommerce is $26 billion for 1997 that is equivalent of 37% of US mail order shopping, 3% of US credit/debit cards purchases, and 0.5% of the retail sales of the seven OECD economies Predicted to reach $330 billion in 2001-02 (near term) and $1 trillion in 2003-05 (future) If realised, OECD-wide ecommerce will be equivalent of 15% of the total retail sales of seven OECD countries. http://www.oecd.org/subject/e_commerce/ebooks/part3e.pdf Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Source: Jupiter Communications. (1998) http://www.jup.com/digest/980116/stat.shtml Ecommerce in US households: 1996-2002 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Future Infrastructure: during the next few years, digital interactive services of all types are expected to converge Telephone, cable, microwave, satellite are all moving into the same arena and losing their monopolies Television, computers, radio, pagers, and cellular telephones are expected to share functionality and attributes You can watch WebTV and TV on your computer or your TV Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 In the global economy Competitive advantage to companies that are successful early adopters of ecommerce This will be true in nations with government economic and regulatory support for ecommerce Nations with highly trained labor forces will benefit from distributed value chain Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Challenges: Overcome the limitations and asymmetries of the infrastructure Implement hardware and software to fully exploit bandwidth, especially to the last mile Provide universal access at reasonable cost Provide secure frameworks for business- to- business and -to-consumer transactions Integrate electronic payment into the buying process Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Framework for Global Ecommerce
Organizational Change Ecommerce has the potential to change the structure and performance of organizations and human enterprise. Small Business Much of the innovative activity in the ecommercing appears to have come from small firms. Access The growth and success of the ecommercing depends on the ability of businesses and citizens to participate Market Structure and Competition Market demand for skilled and knowledgeable workers Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Present State in Developing Countries Technical: The infrastructure necessary to support ecommerce is not in place The hardware and software are becoming more powerful and dropping in price Beginning to understand the economics of networking and ecommerce Totally rely on developments and experiments underway abroad, particularly in business-to-consumer ecommerce Trying to build a consumer marketplace Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 To Develop Ecommerce in Third World
The private sector should lead. Governments should avoid undue restrictions on electronic commerce. The aim of governmental involvement should be to support and enforce a predictable, minimalist, consistent and simple legal environment for commerce. Governments should recognize the unique qualities of the Internet. Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 APEC Leaders Declaration Vancouver, Canada November 25, 1997 We agree that electronic commerce is one of the most important technological breakthroughs of this decade. We direct ministers to undertake a work program on electronic commerce in the region, taking into account relevant activities of other international fora, and to report to us in Kuala Lumpur. This initiative should recognize the leading role of the business sector and promote a predictable and consistent legal and regulatory environment that enables all APEC economies to reap the benefits of electronic commerce. Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 ISSUES Financial Issues customs and taxation electronic payments Legal Issues Uniform Commercial Code for electronic commerce intellectual property protection privacy security Market Access Issues telecommunications infrastructure and info. technology content technical standards Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Need of Standards Ensure growth of ecommerce standards needed: Electronic payments; Security (confidentiality, authentication, data integrity, access control, non-repudiation); Security services infrastructure (e.g., public key certificate authorities); Electronic copyright management systems; Video and data-conferencing; High-speed network technologies; And digital object and data interchange Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Macroeconomic Implications of Ecommerce
The industry-level and economy-wide investments related to ecommerce? Implications for growth, employment, productivity, and inflation? How can these investments and their effects be untangled from the influence of other phenomena? How should we identify and measure the key drivers of the ecommerce? How should we account for intangible consumer benefits and burdens? How pervasive is ecommerce in the economy, between businesses and business and consumers? Hussein Abdoh Tabrizi November 13, 2000 Economic drivers of e-commerce: Five broad themes The effect on the marketplace: Electronic commerce transforms the marketplace- far closer relationships will be created between business andconsumers. The catalytic role: Electronic commerce has a catalytic effect The impact on interactivity: E-commerce over the Internet vastly increases interactivity in the economy Openness: Openness is an underlying technical and philosophical tenet of the expansion of electronic commerce The relative importance of time is fundamental to understanding the economic and social impact of electronic commerce: Electronic commerce alters the relative importance of time.