Mihai Mindra, Spring 2013 Contents with List San Francisco Renaissance Beat Poetry Confessionalism Allan Ginsberg (1926 1997) Robert Lowell (1917 1977) Background Harry S. Truman (Democrat, 1945 1953) Atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki: August 6 and 9, 1945 The Korean War (part of the Cold War: mid-1940s to the early 1990s): 1950 - 1953 McCarthyism (Republican senator Joseph Raymond McCarthy [1908-1957]): activities associated with the period in the United States known as the Second Red Scare (First Red Scare:shortly after the end of World War I and the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia; fear of anarchism: 1917 1920) roughly from the late 1940s to the late 1950s characterized by heightened fears of Communist influence on American institutions and espionage by Soviet agents. Background Term coined by Washington Post cartoonist Herbert Block. Block and others used the word as a synonym for demagoguery, baseless defamation, and mudslinging. Later, embraced by McCarthy and some of his supporters. "McCarthyism is Americanism with its sleeves rolled, (McCarthy, a 1952 speech; later that year he published a book titled McCarthyism: The Fight For America).
Background Dwight D. Eisenhower (Republican, 1953 1961) commanding general of the Allied forces in Europe during World War II truce in Korea moderate policies continued most of the New Deal and Fair Deal programs; balanced budget reinforced desegregation of schools "atoms for peace" program--the loan of American uranium to "have not" nations for peaceful purposes tried to ease Cold War tensions ordered the complete desegregation of the Armed Forces.
Background Postwar years: economic boom - started at the end of World War II and continued throughout the '50s, '60s, and early '70s military victory by Allied forces & the American move into spaces formerly dominated by European imperialism new developments in science and technology = sources of increased ease and comfort in the imminent future improvements in middle-class living conditions many people overlooked ongoing inequities in the distribution of wealth a sense of power and even invincibility among Americans. (Sterritt 20) Background Consumerism vs. Economic anxiety and Existential distress (materialism): growth of a credit-card economy the acquisition of debt and obligations as well as goods and services Explosion of road and highway systems rootlessness as well as mobility; suburban homes were comfortable but undistinguished and indistinguishable explosion of marriage, childbearing, and "togetherness" more household oriented living new worries about education, juvenile delinquency, health care, and other family- related issues; purchases of alcohol and tranquilizers boomed, indicating unease and insecurity despite the many signs of abundance that surrounded people in material fact and media representation. (Sterritt 20) Background media representation culture of consensus (IGNORING THE INDIVIDUAL; FOCUS ON SOCIAL AND ECONOMIC WELL-BEING; SELF-ALIENATION) : message of group-adjustment via self-manipulation social and economic advancement via thrift, hard work, and similar virtues inspirational literature of the Dale Carnegie or Norman Vincent Peale variety (pragmatc success oriented thinking), incl. periodicals with such titles as Journal of Living and Your Personality, which recommend "self-manipulative exercises for the sake not only of business success but of such vaguer, non- work goals as popularity" (Sterritt 28) BEAT POETRY Members of the original New York group : Allen Ginsberg, Jack Kerouac & Gregory Corso. Associated with a specific time frame and a particular state of mind. No shared formal aesthetic beyond their practice of experimental free-verse forms & interest in poetry as performance, frequently with jazz accompaniment Roots in the manifestos of the Black Mountain school of poetry: Group of poets at Black Mountain College (North Carolina), under the guidance of the rector, Charles Olson Charles Olson in his Projective Verse (1950) called for a unit of poetic expression based not on a more or less fixed metrical foot but on the poets breath and the rhythms of the body The poem should represent FEELING AT THE MOMENT OF COMPOSITION THE POEM WAS PROVISIONAL Contrary to New Critics claims. FILM BREAK
BEAT POETRY Earliest published writing by the New York Beat authors - autobiographical: John Clellon Holmess Go. (1952),William BurroughsJunky (1953) , Distinguishable feature: the poets rebellious questioning of conventional American cultural values during the Cold War. put the American dream of individual freedom to its ultimate test rebelled against what they saw as their countrys social conformity, political repression, prevailing materialism by championing unconventional sexual aesthetic & spiritual values. In the dissemination of this movement, LIFESTYLE was as important as literary values / principles; the Beats introduced new social forms and practices (bohemian) [M. Davidson, x]
BEAT POETRY They insisted that Americans could find an alternate life-style despite the prevailing conformism of their time like Emerson and Thoreau , they reaffirmed the essential sanctity of individual experience. Definition of the term : The Random House Dictionary credited Jack Kerouac for defining the term Beat Generation as members of the generation that came of age after Worl War II who, supposedly as a result of disillusionment stemming from the Cold War ,espouse mystical detachment and relaxation of social and sexual tensions. BEAT POETRY first heard by Ginsberg, Kerouac and Burroughs in New York City, Times Square,1944, from a hustler, Herbert Huncke, meaning exhausted, at the bottom of the world, looking up or out, sleepless, wide-eyed, perceptive, rejected by society, on your own, streetwise. According to Ginsberg they (the earliest Beat writers in New York) shared an awareness of the PAHNTOM NATURE of being, the transitoriness of existence.
BEAT POETRY Ginsberg wrote the poem Howl in August 1955. two months later he organized a poetry reading at the Six Gallery, San Francisco, with five other poets (Gary Snyder, Michael McClure, Philip Lamantia, Philip Whalen, Kenneth Rexroth) - October 7, 1955. A change of MEDIUM: poetry as VOICE not as printing (Rexroth) Michael McClure: all the poets participating at the event felt oppressed by the pressures of the war culture. We were locked in the Cold War and the first Asian debacle-the Korean War (1950-53)...As artists we were oppressed and indeed the people of the nation were oppressed
BEAT POETRY We had to speak out as poets. We saw that the art of poetry was essentially dead- killed by war, by academies, by neglect, by lack of love, and by disinterest. We knew we could bring it back to life. ...The audience [knew] at the deepest level that a barrier had been broken. The Beats: destruction of the barrier between popular & high art (poetry read at street corners, jazz clubs & Playboy) [M. Davidson, x] Return to the pre-Enlightment meaning and purpose of literature, i.e. not of civilizing but of enriching ones spiritual life BEAT POETRY Allen Ginsberg, Interview with Thomas Clark Recorded in 1965; published in Spring 1966 in Paris Review About 1945 I got interested in Supreme Reality with a capital S and R, and I wrote big long poems about a last voyage looking for the Supreme Reality. Which was like a Dostoevskian or Thomas Wolfeian idealization or like Rimbaud what was Rimbauds term, new vision, was that it? Object / Experience of poetry (ref. to Blake): that sense sublime of something more deeply interfused, whose dwelling is the light of setting suns, and the round ocean, and the living air (..). So I think this experience is characteristic of all high poetry. I mean thats the way I began seeing poetry as the communication of the particular experience not just any experience but THIS EXPERIENCE.
BEAT POETRY Associated to / outgrowth of Romanticism [M. Davidson, 2] As opposed to modernist doctrines of impersonality (e.g.: A. Ginsbergs relationship with W. C. Williams, for instance, as reflected in Ginsbergs first volume of poetry, Empty Mirror) & New Criticism principles (formalism: the author is not important, the text is all that matters). Romanticism & Beat common point: Perception of life in allegorical terms, each moment intersecting with the divine (M. Davidson, 2) Differences many, including among the members of the Beats / San Francisco Renaissance E.g. impulse toward orality and performance; popular / low culture; significance of the political / contingency; surrealist techniques etc.
BEAT POETRY Howl and Other Poems (1957) Lawrence Ferlinghetti: The great obscene wastes of Howl are the sad wastes of the mechanized world, lost among atom bombs and insane nationalisms. seized by the U.S.Customs in San Francisco on March 25, 1957, with the charge that Ginsbergs language describing homosexual acts was obscene.
BEAT POETRY Finally the judge ruled that Ginsberg had not written an obscene poem. His decision established judicial precedent by stating that if the printed material has social importance, it is protected by the First and Fourteenth Amendments of the United States Constitution. What had been the private cultural rebellion of an obscure literary group in New York was energized and given political focus by the contact of the East Coast Beats (New York beats) with the West Coast poets (the San Francisco Poetry Renaissance), who were sustained by a flourishing tradition of radical poetry . Not only an aesthetic revolt but also a radical assault on mainstream cultural values. ROOTS : Whitman & William Carlos Williams.
BEAT POETRY 1970s the Beat and the San Francisco Renaissance poets were recognized as a vital part of American culture The Beat and Beatnik labels were changed for hippie leading writers were gradually accepted into the literary establishment four of the poets, Ginsberg, Baraka\ Jones, Ferlinghetti, Snyder, entered the literary canon.
BEAT POETRY 1974 Ginsberg became a member of the National Institute of Arts and Letters and won a National Book Award for The Fall of America. In his acceptance speech he signaled the end of the Beat Generation as a literary movement In its place he hoped for the survival of what he called the sovereignty of the individual mind in post-Vietnam America. BEAT POETRY Nation, February 23, 1957: M.L. Rosenthals review of Howl: poetry of genuine suffering...the elementary need for freedom of sympathy...for the open response of man to man so long repressed by the smooth machinery of intellectual distortion. National Review ,November 18 ,1961, Ralph de Toledano: an overflow as accidental as a bathtub running over the Beat artistic revolt was as graceless and unproductive as the copulation of mules. defending the disciplined sensibility and reverence for tradition shown by T. S. Eliot, Wallace Stevens, and Marianne Moore, he concludes : the bumps and grinds of the Beat school may appeal to the blunted tastes and stunted sensibilities of our times, but they have as little connection with poetry as a strip act does with the sex act. 1960s - growing number of dissident writers and small press publishers became recognized as the development of an American counterculture.
The Beatnik Norman Mailer , essay The White Negro: the American existentialist: sees value in moods, feelings, actions as opposed to logical causality Society represents authority from without, he seeks authority within his ego. a pioneer, an explorer of inward reality ( see Puritanical roots ) the religious mystic has taken advantage of modern chemistry : drugs. like the existentialist the beatnik tries to maintain the significance of the individual personality in a world devoid of God, spiritual values. an attempt at re-humanizing themselves by a total re-examination of the meaning of life. The Beatnik Human personality is to be defended against the overwhelming pressures of conformity, competition and respectability- quantitative externals opposed by qualitative living. The continuous search for inner reality is a quest for authentic existence & moods are indices to his reality would not try, as the rationalist to overcome his fears, his dread, but he would exploit these feelings in order to reach new levels of truth about himself. the confessional character of Beat literature (celebration of intimate biographical detail ) which to the social conservative appears as exhibitionism. to the authentic beatnik nothing that is human or personal can be degrading. So, the alleged foolishness of the hip values turns out to be a criticism of the accepted American practices.
The Beatnik Paul ONeil ( The Only Rebellion Around , Life, November 30, 1959) : the Beats feel that the only way man can call his soul his own is by becoming an outcast . They are not reformers. Institutionalized reform would not change anything. So his solution : he disaffiliates, drops out of the entire scheme of traditional civilization and asks only to be left alone (e.g. that is why Thoreau is something of a Beat hero). Carl Michalson the Beatniks are similar to Existentialists: Social relations which are based upon existential individualism will be initiated in the creative force of personal volition. Which means when individuals come together, they will not lose their identity by social proximity. (Carl Michalson, What is Existentialism? Christianity and the Existentialists, ed. Carl Michalson (New York, 1956 ),p.13.
The Beatnik Modern society has mangled the concept of self by twisting interpersonal relationships into categories of competition, barter, argument, belligerence - covering it all with a glossy mantle of respectability. Howl (1956) biographical info: documentary screened at the course (The Source) Howl: 3 parts + a Footnote (another poem) program stated at the end of Part I - aestheticist: to recreate the syntax and measure of poor human prose and stand before you speechless and intelligent and shaking with shame, rejected yet confessing out the soul to conform to the rhythm of thought in his naked and endless head. Part II of Howl identifies the hostile universe with which the vulnerable sensibility cannot cope - American capitalism / devouring mechanical civilization
Howl (1956) Part III focuses on one person: Carl Solomon - Rockland State Hospital (New York State mental hospital) ends, like the other two parts on a note of lamentation combined with ambiguous affirmation. Footnote to Howl begins with a line that repeats the outcry Holy! fifteen times brings under the same sign of holiness the tragic, the comic, the ordinary, and the hallucinatory. Whitmanesque vitality and cosmic vision of mankind as an all comprising miracle.
Howl (1956) A. Ginsberg - Notes Written on Finally Recording Howl (1959) By 1955 I wrote poetry adapted from prose seeds, journals, scratchings, arranged by PHRASING or BREATH GROUPS into little short-line patterns according to ideas of measure of American speech Id picked up from W. C. Williamss imagist preoccupations. () I thought I wouldnt write a poem, but just write what I wanted to without fear, let my imagination go, open secrecy, and scribble magic lines from my real mind ().
Howl (1956) Composition: Ideally each line of Howl is a single breath unit My breath is long thats the Measure, one physical and mental inspiration of thought contained in the elastic of a breath. It probably bugs Williams now (SHORT SENTENCES), but its a natural consequence, my own heightened conversation, not cooler average daily talk short breath. Mystical process (started exploring Buddhism in 1954) union of body & mind Compare this statement with E. Pounds (and even W. C. Williams objectivist phase) imagist credo union of the intellectual & the emotional. The poem an experiment with Whitmans long line. Part I: depended on the word who to keep the beat, a base to keep measure, return to and take off again onto another streak of invention () I went on to what my imagination believed true to Eternity [] and what my memory could reconstitute of the data of celestial experience Howl (1956) Part II: the long line is used as a stanza form broken within into exclamatory units punctuated by a base repetition, Moloch. Part III: almost the same as Part I.
Thematically: Part I, a lament for the lamb in America with instances of remarkable lamblike youths; Part II names the monster of mental consciousness that preys on the lamb; Part III a litany of affirmation of the Lamb in its glory []
Listening Recording of Howl.
Howl (1956) rhetorical shock supported by the reiterated insistence that a generation of Americans had been betrayed & psychically crippled elemental language engulfed in deliberately intellectual phrasing (e.g. a vision of ultimate cunt eluding the last gyzym of consciousness , solipsisms of johns) or rhapsodic lyricism (sweetened the snatches of a million girls trembling in the sunset) compulsive search for love confronting external, automatic activity: I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness, starving hysterical naked... Howl (1956) revolutionary social and political criticism implied (Rosenthal p.93) rejection of the established order breakdown of respectable assumptions in the moral sphere involving generally the whole range of expectation of what will make a meaningful, self-regulated life normal masculine pride and adult personality are abandoned because of the terror created by a mad & brutal world some people adjusted so well that they can not see how irrelevant their lives are.
ALLEN GINSBERG & CONFESSIONAL POETRY Public recitation and rhetoric are at cross- purposes with the deeper aim of bringing very personal private concerns to the surface. Lowell and Plath: the latter aim embodies the issues of cultural crisis in the crisis of the poets own life Rhetorical extroverted poetry sharing with confessional writing its hatred or pain at the damage wreaked by Moloch. Piled - up details about his generation: many clues to Ginsbergs private experiences; he is groping toward a fuller release of his real, private demons (see Kaddish, 1961) ALLEN GINSBERG & CONFESSIONAL POETRY Kaddish and Other Poems 1958 - 1960 (1961), dated 1959 by the author. Full title is Kaddish for Naomi Ginsberg 1894-1956. formal elegy written as a tribute to his mother Naomi, who had been a communist sympathizer during his boyhood; had died in a mental hospital in 1956. The traditional kaddish is the Hebrew lament for the dead, which is at the same time a hymn of praise to God. Modeling his poem on the traditional form , Ginsberg divides it into a sequence of six parts called Proem, Narrative, Hymmnn (so spelled to suggest the wailing incantation of the Hebrew prayer.) , Lament, Litany, Fugue. The story of Naomi Ginsbergs paranoia, degeneration and death told in detail. ALLEN GINSBERG & CONFESSIONAL POETRY Through Naomis story politics becomes a matter of life, human predicament. At the same time it is a protest against the repression of radical thought and organization in the USA after the Second World War, associated with McCarthysm. The virtual sealing off of any legitimacy for revolutionary debate and organization, in the wake of a war that had already done immense damage to private personality throughout the Western world wrought even more psychic than political havoc. effort to establish the human validity of a retroactively outlawed type of experience violence done by modern existence to the most vulnerable.
ALLEN GINSBERG (1926 1997) The poets rebelliousness (homosexuality, use of drugs, rejection of squeamishness) is a familiar motif of his generation The barriers of fastidiousness once broken down, the sophisticated intelligence must learn (with Whitman) entirely new perspectives of human acceptance and value (see Rosenthal pp.105-106) STRUCTURE & STYLE: careless in diction, syntax, and rhythmic movement deliberately having the quality of a series of memories noted down in haste or snatched up out of the subconscious. The influence of Whitman - reiterative style, parallelism
ALLEN GINSBERG (1926 1997) this technique indicates a cumulative poetical movement suited to Ginsbergs expanding ego psychology which results in an enumerative style, the cataloging of a representative and symbolical succession of images, conveying the sensation of pantheistic unity and endless becoming.
This goes back to Hebraic roots, acknowledged by Ginsberg : repeating and balancing ideas and sentences instead of syllables or accents.
The reader is not supposed to look for a rational connection of ideas. There is richness of imagery and density & spontaneity.
A Supermarket in California (1956) Criticism of the prosperous Eisenhower era Criticism of capitalist America as opposed to romantic / individualist / inspired America of Walt Whitman; shopping for images In the store, Ginsberg sees whole families of consumers, emblematic of the capitalist societies that produced them: F. G. Lorca, Walt Whitman The theme of homosexuality openly asserted subverting middle class ideals & norms.
Confessional Poetry Robert Lowell Label first applied, disapprovingly, to Robert Lowellls Life Studies (1959) a collection of autobiographical prose and poetry confessional -violated the norms of decorum for subject matter (impresonality / indirectness), specific for WASP middle class postwar art Overall aim of his poetry: to locate personal experience, stray events, into epic history History & personal experience apocalyptic overtones Studied poetry with John Crowe Ransom came into contact with New Criticism and, briefly, the Fugitive movement (southern agrarians opposed to what they perceived as northern corrupting industrialism) Conversion to Roman Catholicism (he was a Protestant), 1940; opposition to American policies in World War II, and later on Vietnam Interested in psychoanalysis as a mode of address to postwar existential misery Note: Other New Critics in America - I. A. Richards, T. S. Eliot, R. P. Blackmur, Cleanth Brooks, Allen Tate.
Confessional Poetry Robert Lowell Robert Lowell's Life Studies (1959) - often cited as the most sustained attempt to develop a confessional mode and a 'turning point' in postwar poetry (Halliwell 72) Exploration of Lowell's family relationships Begins his 'Life Studies' sequence with the line: 'I won't go with you. I want to stay with Grandpa! E.g. Lowell recalls his Uncle Devereux Winslow dying of Hogdkin's disease at age twenty-nine. He provides direct expressions of his uncle's dress ('his trousers were solid cream from the top of the bottle') as a child would to hide his fears ( cowered in terror'), conflicting impulses which are brought together when the poem describes his hands: 'warm, then cool, on the piles / of earth and lime, a black pile and a white pile ' as his uncle blends 'to the one colour' in death. (Halliwell 73) Martin Halliwell, American Culture in the 1950s. Edinburgh : Edinburgh University Press, 2007.
Confessional Poetry Main New Criticism tenets: valid interpretations had to avoid the Intentional Fallacy (searching for presumed intentions of the author) and the Affective Fallacy (crediting emotional effects produced in the reader) In order to arrive at correct or universal meanings the reader has to approach the poem as an ahistorical, self-enclosed / - sufficient system, an object made of language : a vebal icon (W.C.Wimsatt ) late 1950s - 1960s: reaction against what was perceived as high modernist / new criticism formalism Search for ways to reintroduce both Intention and Affect in the discussion of poetic value.
Confessional Poetry Most outspoken the Beats Confessional poetry - not overtly political, but it participated in the protest against Impersonality as a poetical value by reinstating an insistently autobiographical first person.
Confessional Poetry Common features / conditions of the confessional poets: had developed close personal affiliations: Lowell - the teacher and mentor of Snodgrass, Sexton, and Plath; all these poets knew each others work. psychological breakdowns and treatment, following rather early marriages / conformity with middle class standards in force Interest in Freudian psychonalysis Their poetry - investigation into middle class social institutions (e.g. marriage / family dominated postwar American culture) Poetry in the first person: historical events & personal experiences. Common Stylistic Features Confessionalist characteristics: poems in the first-person voice with little apparent distance between the speaker and the poet; emotional in tone autobiographical in content narrative in structure. Personal reflections no longer took the form of the distanced idiom characteristic of both modernism and New Criticism. (Beach 174)
Skunk Hour -- Robert Lowell
(For Elizabeth Bishop) Nautilus Island's hermit heiress still lives through winter in her Spartan cottage; her sheep still graze above the sea. Her son's a bishop. Her farmer is first selectman in our village; she's in her dotage.
Thirsting for the hierarchic privacy of Queen Victoria's century, she buys up all the eyesores facing her shore, and lets them fall.
The season's ill-- we've lost our summer millionaire, who seemed to leap from an L. L. Bean catalogue. His nine-knot yawl was auctioned off to lobstermen. A red fox stain covers Blue Hill.
And now our fairy decorator brightens his shop for fall; his fishnet's filled with orange cork, orange, his cobbler's bench and awl; there is no money in his work, he'd rather marry.
One dark night, my Tudor Ford climbed the hill's skull; I watched for love-cars. Lights turned down, they lay together, hull to hull, where the graveyard shelves on the town. . . . My mind's not right.
A car radio bleats, "Love, O careless Love. . . ." I hear my ill-spirit sob in each blood cell, as if my hand were at its throat. . . . I myself am hell; nobody's here--
only skunks, that search in the moonlight for a bite to eat. They march on their soles up Main Street: white stripes, moonstruck eyes' red fire under the chalk-dry and spar spire of the Trinitarian Church.
I stand on top of our back steps and breathe the rich air-- a mother skunk with her column of kittens swills the garbage pail. She jabs her wedge-head in a cup of sour cream, drops her ostrich tail, and will not scare.
1959 Skunk Hour (1959) Often cited as the quintessential poem of the confessional movement Lowell began the poem in August 1957 while he was visiting the costal town of Castine, Maine; as he remembers it, Lowell was struck by having nothing to write, of having, at least, no language He abandoned his previous formalist style with this poem; the model Elizabeth Bishops The Armadillo He decided to write a poem in short stanzas with drafting description. (Beach 156) Skunk Hour (1959) The poem comprises eight six-line stanzas of variable meter and rhyme scheme The first four stanza: the decay of the town; the second four the poets personal ordeal, the dark night of the soul from which he is saved by the appearance of a family of skunks. The first half of the poem: Caricature of the town and its inhabitants: the lady who prefers to live in the Victorian age; the summer millionaire who seemed to leap out of an L. L. Bean / catalogue, a.o. The moral and social fabric of the town decayed: the seasons ill The town analogous for the poets state of mind.
Skunk Hour (1959) The second part of the poem: The illness of the season turns into the poets ill-spirit / My minds not right Comparison of his state of mind with the love cars (compared to boats sailing on the ocean): the love cars lie hull to hull The encounters of the lovers seemed perverted and morbid, particularly by the location of the car park in relation to the towns cemetery The city is transformed into a skull ; a popular love song is associated with Miltons Paradise Lost I myself am Hell The popular love song contains a reference to death also: Now you see what careless love will do Make you kill yourself and your sweetheart too The cemetery shelves on the town- ambiguous meaning: = sloping / inclining = building on the town interlocking fates of the living and the dead.
Skunk Hour (1959) The appearance of the skunks turn from despair to a humorous tone The poet makes the attempt at connecting with otherness, here embodied by prereflective natural order. The skunks a comical sight; not concerned with moral / religious / artistic existence A partial restitution of meaning: devoid of social / civic (symbolized by the Main Street) or religious implications (the view of the Trinitarian Church) As the identification of man & skunk = partial; no salvation in sight. (Beach 157)
(Anthologies of English Literature) Eric Homberger (Auth.) - American Writers and Radical Politics, 1900-39 - Equivocal Commitments-Palgrave Macmillan UK (1986)