Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
in Dhaka
Presented by:
A.B.M. Morshedul Hassan (760) 10 th batch Session-2007-2008 Department of Urban and Regional Planning Jahangirnagr University Thesis Supervisor : Sabkat Kamal
Introduction:
Migration to urban areas is a regular phenomenon but disaster induced displacement forced to migrate to cities over the recent years is a matter of concern. Increased frequency and severity of natural disasters over the past recent years are not only displacing people but also exposing to enhanced unplanned urbanization. These natural calamities give influence the disaster affected people to migrate urban areas for shelter and work. Different regions of Bangladesh are under different risks of disaster. Like- the southern part (Barisal, Khulna, Patuakhali, Bhola, Barguna etc.) of Bangladesh is in more risk of cyclone, Sea level rise, and salinity problem. Eastern part (Rangpur, Sirajganj, Bogra etc.) is more vulnerable for drought, flood and riverbank erosion. Sylhet is more vulnerable for flash flood. Potential displacement every year due to some natural disasters like erosion (coastal and riverbank erosion), salinity, storm surge and water logging is estimated at 60,000 people, 10,000-15,000 people, 100000-120000 people and 30,000 people respectively (Ahmed and Neelormi, 2008). Bangladesh is expected to have massive environmental displacement, which is calculated to be about 49 million, 63 million and 78 million in 2010, 2015 and 2020 respectively. (Akter, T. 2010) Growing number of natural disaster affected people rush to citys areas creates urban crisis. Most of the displaced people living in urban slums are in search of better and secure life. According to International Organization for Migration (IOM), about 70% of slum dwellers in Dhaka experienced some kind of environmental shocks. This migration enhancing unplanned urbanization
Objectives:
1. To identify natural disaster and their effects on human displacement and migration in Bangladesh.
2. To develop maps for natural disasters, human displacement and migration in Bangladesh
3. To explore the present scenario of the migrated people and their spatial distribution of settlements in Dhaka.
Data Source
Collection Method
To identify natural disaster and their effects on human displacement and migration in Bangladesh.
Secondary
Displacement
Primary
To develop maps for natural disasters, human displacement and migration in Bangladesh.
Spatial Mapping
Disaster mapping
Catchment area
Number of people
Primary
Calculated from population data of Population Census 2001 and 2011 (Preliminary) of BBS Questionnaire survey
Primary
Flood
Floods occur most commonly when water from heavy rainfall, from melting ice and snow, or from a combination of these exceeds the carrying capacity of the river system, lake or ocean into which it runs. Annual monsoon flooding results in the loss of human life, damage to property and communication systems, and a shortage of drinking water. Floods of 1955, 1974, 1987, 1988, 1998, 2004 and 2008 were extensive and devastating. (Banglapedia, 2011)
Table-2: Number of people displaced and areas affected by floods in different time period
Event
1987 flood
Impact
Inundated over 50, 000 sq. km, estimated damage US$ 1 billion, 2,055 deaths Inundated 61% of the country more than 45 million homeless, loss US$ 1.2 billion Inundated 100,000 sq. km., 30 million people homeless, damaged 500,000 homes Inundation 38%, damage US$ 2 billion, affected nearly 3.8 million people Inundated 32,000 sq. km, over 85,000 houses destroyed and damage $1 billion
1988 flood
1998 flood
2004 flood
2007 flood
Riverbank Erosion
Riverbank Erosion is an endemic and recurrent natural hazard in Bangladesh. Every year millions of people of Bangladesh are affected by erosion that destroys standing crops, farmland and homestead land. It is estimated that about 5% or the total floodplain of Bangladesh Is directly affected by erosion. Some researchers have reported that bank erosion is taking place in about 94 out at 489 upazilas of the country. A few other researchers have identified 56 upazilas with incidence of erosion. At present, bank erosion and flood hazards are nearly 100 upazilas have become almost a regular feature. Of these 35 are severely affected. (Source: BBS, 2008)
Table 3 Riverbank Erosion/accretion along the different rivers for the period, 1984-1994
Jamuna Left Bank Erosion Right Rate (m/yr) *100 *84 Ganges -20 56 665 2240 1010 Padma 38 121 620 1800 233 Upper Meghna 7 -9 NA 48 49 Lower Meghna 66 182 824 1172 402
Maximum Bank Erosion *784 Rate (m/yr) Bank Erosion (ha/yr) Bank accretion (ha/yr) *5020 *890
(Source: SVRS, 2008) *Rates derived for the period of 1984-1992 (Source: Database of CCC, DoE and modified by the author, 2011)
Table 4 Regions Based on Drought Severity Impact Type Very Severe Arial Description About 0.58 million ha in Rajshahi and Nawabganj districts Severe More than 1.7 million ha in Dinjpur, Jessore, Tangail, Bogra, Kushtia and Dhaka districts Moderate About 2.18 million ha in Barisal, Rangpur, Dinjpur, Jessore, Kushtia and Bogra districts (Source: SVRS, 2008)
Flood
Floodplains of the Brahmaputra- Jamuna, the Ganges-Padma and the Meghna river system
Loss of agricultural production, disruption of communication and livelihood system, injury, damage and destruction of immobile infrastructure, disruption to essential services, national economic loss, evacuation, and loss of human lives and biodiversity, displacement and sufferings of human population and biodiversity. Loss of agricultural production, disruption of communication and livelihood system, damage and destruction of immobile infrastructure, injury, national economic loss, loss of biodiversity and human lives, need for evacuation and temporary shelter. Loss of land, displacement of human population and livestock, disruption of production, evacuation and loss of property. Major cause of disaster induced migration.
Banks of the Brahmaputra -Jamuna, the Ganges-Padma and the Meghna river systems
Drought
Loss of agricultural production, stress on national economy and disruption in life style. This is a cause of seasonal migration.
(Source: Bangladesh: state of the environment report, 2001 and modified by the author, 2011)
Pushing
1. Landless & homeless 2. Loan Pressure
3. Lack of work opportunities to maintain livelihood 4. Frequency of affecting by disasters Migration Decision Slum Settlements of big Cities 1. Good work opportunities in city
Flood
Riverbank Erosion
Natural Disaster
Drought
Cyclone
Pulling
(Source: Prepared by the author, 2011)
Settlements
Shrimp Ground
Calculation of Internal Migration in Bangladesh: Detail Calculation for Dhaka Division (Same process has been followed for other divisions)
District Population, **Population, Population, **Population, Census Population 2001 (All ages) 2001 (>75 2011 (All ages) 2011 ( 10+ survival (CSR) 2001 (<75 Ages) Ages) ages by multiplying with CSR) Net Internal Migration, 2001-2011 Per day Migration
(IV)
(V) = IV*0.7537
8950187.5 2512082.1 1039352.3 1070254 2183468.9 1781466.2 1407157.9 866001.3 866001.3 783848.1 863740.2 1707130.5 1005435.8 2150306.1 3800155.4 1663415.9 2691462.7 35341466.2
(VI)
(VII) = VI*III
7464542.984 1752318.939 1127558.508 1116472.596 1880049.432 1647158.67 1509346.926 997558.8673 978626.2081 824757.2132 935962.7684 1824013.611 1098146.197 2214792.011 3862851.411 1707265.099 2824828.965 33766250.41
(VIII) = V-VII
1485644.516 759763.1611 -88206.2078 -46218.59575 303419.4682 134307.53 -102189.0258 -131557.5673 -112624.9081 -40909.21316 -72222.56843 -116883.1107 -92710.39739 -64485.91052 -62696.01088 -43849.19941 -133366.2646 1575215.695
(IX)
0.879722579
407.0258947 208.1542907 -24.1660843 -12.662629 83.12862143 36.79658356 -27.9969934 -36.0431691 -30.8561392 -11.2080036 -19.7870051 -32.0227701 -25.4001089 -17.6673727 -17.1769893 -12.0134793 -36.5387026 431.5659439
**1.55 % Population is in the 75+ age group, in 2001 (Population census, 2001) and 75.37% population is in 10+ age group, in 2008 (SVRS, 2008)
Calculation of Natural Disaster Induced Internal Migration in Bangladesh: Dhaka Division Analysis
District Name Net Internal Migration, 2001-2011 Natural Disaster Induced Net Migration, 2001-2011 *(36.82% of net internal migration) 547014.31 279744.80 -32477.53 -17017.69 111719.05 49452.03 -37626.00 -48439.50 -41468.49 -15062.77 -26592.35 -43036.36 -34135.97 -23743.71 -23084.67 -16145.28 -49105.46 567899.05 Migration Per Year Migration Per Day
Dhaka Gazipur Manikganj Munshiganj Narayanganj Norsingdi Faridpur Gopalganj Madaripur Rajbari Shariatpur Jamalpur Sherpur Kishorganj Mymensingh Netrakona Tangail Dhaka Division
1485644.52 759763.16 -88206.21 -46218.60 303419.47 134307.53 -102189.03 -131557.57 -112624.91 -40909.21 -72222.57 -116883.11 -92710.40 -64485.91 -62696.01 -43849.20 -133366.26 1542365.70
54701.43 27974.48 -3247.75 -1701.77 11171.90 4945.20 -3762.60 -4843.95 -4146.85 -1506.28 -2659.23 -4303.64 -3413.60 -2374.37 -2308.47 -1614.53 -4910.55 56789.90
149.87 76.64 -8.90 -4.66 30.61 13.54 -10.31 -13.27 -11.36 -4.13 -7.29 -11.79 -9.35 -6.51 -6.32 -4.42 -13.45 158.90
*Bangladesh is expected to have massive environmental displacement, which is calculated to be about 49 million, 63 million and 78 million in 2010, 2015 and 2020 respectively. (Akter, T. 2010) Data Source: Calculated by the author
Calculation of Natural Disaster Induced Internal Migration in Bangladesh: Barisal Division Analysis
District Name Net Internal Migration, 20012011 Natural Disaster Induced Net Migration, 20012011 *(36.82% of net internal migration) -113120.7494 -55272.18467 -55493.57965 -44616.24103 -24717.99504 -46128.52311 -339349.2729 Migration Per Year Migration Per Day
*Bangladesh is expected to have massive environmental displacement, which is calculated to be about 49 million, 63 million and 78 million in 2010, 2015 and 2020 respectively. (Akter, T. 2010)
Calculation of Natural Disaster Induced Internal Migration in Bangladesh: Rangpur Division Analysis
District Name Net Internal Migration, 2001-2011 Natural Disaster Induced Net Migration, 20012011 *(36.82% of net internal migration) -17966.13 -27270.34 6717.12 -5559.97 6910.27 5013.49 -4379.77 -10511.86 -47047.18 Migration Per Year Migration Per Day
Dinajpur Gaibandha Kurigram Lalmonirhat Nilphamari Panchagar Thakurgoan Rangpur Rangpur Division
*Bangladesh is expected to have massive environmental displacement, which is calculated to be about 49 million, 63 million and 78 million in 2010, 2015 and 2020 respectively. (Akter, T. 2010)
Calculation of Natural Disaster Induced Internal Migration in Bangladesh: Sylhet Division Analysis
District Name Net Internal Migration, 2001-2011 36060.37 40124.86 117464.42 359394.37 553044.02 Natural Disaster Migration Induced Net Migration, Per Year 2001-2011 *(36.82% of net internal migration) 13277.43 1327.74 14773.97 1477.40 43250.40 4325.04 132329.01 13232.90 203630.81 20363.08 Migration Per Day
*Bangladesh is expected to have massive environmental displacement, which is calculated to be about 49 million, 63 million and 78 million in 2010, 2015 and 2020 respectively. (Akter, T. 2010)
Calculation of Natural Disaster Induced Internal Migration in Bangladesh: Khulna Division Analysis
District Name Net Internal Migration, 2001-2011 Natural Disaster Induced Net Migration, 20012011 *(36.82% of net internal migration) -115317.70 -26625.29 -12853.16 -8710.41 -23177.55 -78258.04 -40864.35 -8898.70 -17600.92 -6449.97 -338756.10 Migration Per Year Migration Per Day
Khulna Jessore Jhenaidha Magura Narail Bagerhat Satkhira Chuadanga Khushtia Meherpur Khulna Division
-313193.10 -72312.04 -34908.10 -23656.74 -62948.27 -212542.20 -110984.12 -24168.11 -47802.60 -17517.57 -920032.86
-11531.77 -2662.53 -1285.32 -871.04 -2317.76 -7825.80 -4086.44 -889.87 -1760.09 -645.00 -33875.61
-31.59 -7.29 -3.52 -2.39 -6.35 -21.44 -11.20 -2.44 -4.82 -1.77 -92.81
*Bangladesh is expected to have massive environmental displacement, which is calculated to be about 49 million, 63 million and 78 million in 2010, 2015 and 2020 respectively. (Akter, T. 2010)
Calculation of Natural Disaster Induced Internal Migration in Bangladesh: Chittagong Division Analysis
District Name Net Internal Migration, 2001-2011 Natural Disaster Induced Net Migration, 2001-2011 *(36.82% of net internal migration) 10383.29 -2952.22 70228.87 20933.03 -50558.98 7778.40 3891.61 9488.71 776.13 -27382.59 -2053.46 35157.07 Migration Per Year Migration Per Day
Bandarban Chittagong Cox's Bazar B. Baria Chandpur Comilla Khagrachri Feni Lakshmipur Noakhali Rangamati Chittagong Division
28200.13 -8017.98 190735.67 56852.32 -137313.92 21125.47 10569.29 25770.55 2107.91 -74368.80 -5577.02 95483.62
1038.33 -295.22 7022.89 2093.30 -5055.90 777.84 389.16 948.87 77.61 -2738.25 -205.35 3515.71
2.84 -0.81 19.24 5.74 -13.85 2.13 1.07 2.60 0.21 -7.50 -0.56 11.10
*Bangladesh is expected to have massive environmental displacement, which is calculated to be about 49 million, 63 million and 78 million in 2010, 2015 and 2020 respectively. (Akter, T. 2010)
Calculation of Natural Disaster Induced Internal Migration in Bangladesh: Rajshahi Division Analysis
District Name Net Internal Migration, 2001-2011 Natural Disaster Induced Net Migration, 20012011 *(36.82% of net internal migration) 2557.31 97.28 -45975.47 -13100.04 349.47 -11232.28 -20892.43 -26096.42 -114292.58 Migration Per Year Migration Per Day
Pabna Sirajganj Naogaon Natore Chapai Nawabganj Rajshahi Joypurhat Bogra Rajshahi Division
*Bangladesh is expected to have massive environmental displacement, which is calculated to be about 49 million, 63 million and 78 million in 2010, 2015 and 2020 respectively. (Akter, T. 2010)
Narayanganj 30.61
(Source: Maps are Prepared by the author, 2011) (Source: Map Prepared by the author, 2011)
Graphs
Graphs
Questionnaire surveys show that, maximum respondents are in the 51+ age group and this is about 31respondents and this percentage is 55.4%. A second highest respondent age group is 41-50 and this percentage is 25%.
Marital Status
Questionnaire surveys show that, maximum respondents are in the 51+ age group and this is about 24 respondents and this percentage is 41.4%. A second highest respondent age group is 41-50 and this percentage is 29.3%.
Marital Status
Almost 89.3% migrants were married at the time of the survey and this number is 50 persons. 3 migrants or about 5.4% were single and other 5.4% were widow.
About 77.6% migrants were married at the time of the survey and this number is 45 persons. 12.1% widow and another 10.3% single.
Gender
In this survey most of the respondents are male and this is about 47 persons. 83.9% respondents are male and other 16.1% respondents are female.
Gender
In this survey most of the respondents are male. 74.1% respondents are male and other 25.9% respondents are female.
District Name
Bhola Sherpur Patuakhali Barisal Mymensingh Gaibandha Jhalakathi Bagerhat Khulna Barguna Rangpur Sirajganj Jamalpur
No. of Respondents
11 5 5 6 5 5 4 2 2 3 5 1 2
Percentage
19.64% 8.93% 8.93% 10.71% 8.93% 8.93% 7.14% 3.57% 3.57% 5.36% 8.93% 1.79% 3.57%
District Name
Bhola Lalmonirhat Rajshahi Barisal Mymensingh Gaibandha Faridpur Chadpur Noakhali Rangpur Sirajganj Jamalpur
No. of Respondents
2 4 3 6 6 7 6 3 3 6 5 7
Percentage
3.45% 6.90% 5.17% 10.34% 10.34% 12.07% 10.34% 5.17% 5.17% 10.34% 8.62% 12.07%
No. of Respondents
41 15
Percentage
73.21% 26.79%
No. of Respondents
45 13
Percentage
77.58% 22.42%
Number of big natural disasters events experienced by the Migrants of korail slum
Number of big natural disasters events experienced by the Migrants of Ershadnagar Slum.
Area more Vulnerable to which Disaster (Korail slum) : Name of Disaster (one respondent give multiple answer at a time)
Flood Riverbank Erosion Cyclone Drought
Area more Vulnerable to which Disaster (Ershadnagar slum) : Name of Disaster (one respondent give multiple answer at a time)
Flood Riverbank Erosion Cyclone Drought
No. of Respondents
Percentage
No. of Respondents
Percentage
48 45 31 3
49 45 14 6
No. of Respondents
23 2 31
Number of displacement
1-3 4-6 7-9 10+ No
No. of Respondents
17 1 40
Percentage
29.31% 1.72% 68.97%
Weighted value
8*4+11*3+5*2+1*1 14*4+6*3+5*2+0*1 6*4+6*3+11*2+2*1 3*4+10*3+8*2+4*1
Score
76 84 66 62
Priority Level
Medium High Minimum Minimum
Weighted value
6*4+7*3+3*2+2*1 11*4+3*3+4*2+0*1 6*4+5*3+2*2+5*1 3*4+3*3+5*2+7*1
Score
53 61 48 38
Priority Level
Medium High Minimum Minimum
No. of Respondents
7 49
Percentage
12.5% 87.5%
No. of Respondents
4 54
Percentage
6.89% 93.11%
Some positive image of Dhaka Most accessible City from any region
Weighted value
41*4+7*3+8*2+0*1 23*4+10*3+10*2+13*1 40*4+10*3+6*2+0*1 36*4+12*3+4*2+4*1
Priority Level
High Minimum High Medium
Reason
Good work opportunity For secure livelihood High wage rate
Weighted value
39*4+12*3+6*2+1*1 23*4+10*3+10*2+15*1 41*4+9*3+8*2+0*1
Score
205 157 207
Priority Level
High Minimum High
Near to relatives
17*4+23*3+12*2+6*1
167
Medium
No. of Respondents
53 3
Migration Type
Permanent Temporary
No. of Respondents
50 8
Percentage
86.20% 13.80%
Option
Yes No
No. of Respondents
13 43
Percentage
23.21% 76.785
Option
Yes No
No. of Respondents
8 50
Percentage
13.80% 86.20%
2.
Natural Disaster
Migration
Slum
Evection
District
Percentage %
Dhaka Gazipur
149.87 76.64
Narayanganj 30.61
Recommendations:
1. Disaster mapping can be a very important tool for disaster management. By proper management after any disaster event, disaster mapping can put negative impact on human migration.
Disaster mapping makes it easy to monitoring different hazard and disaster. When it is difficult to collect information about damage of disaster , affected population and most affected areas during any disaster event, disaster mapping by satellite image makes it possible for the estimation of damage, affected population and area. Emergency relief work is very important after any disaster event, by disaster mapping, it is possible to provide relief within very short time to the most affected area.
2. Migration mapping can be used as a very important tool for urban planning and urban management in both smaller and larger aspects. Migration mapping, makes it possible to monitor the migration movement of population from one region to another.
Recommendations:
Makes it easy to take proper steps, to restrict excessive internal population migration
Migration mapping indicate, which regions need more importance for development. It makes it easy to take development activities. 3. Information about the spatial distribution of settlements of the migrants can be used in the process of resettlement of them to their own region. Spatial distribution of the disaster migrants also include information about their habit, occupation, work preference, living condition, income which will be needed in the case of preparing a resettlement plan for the disaster migrants. Spatial distribution is needed to know about the attraction factors, which are involved to choose any place for migration by the people of different regions. By considering those factors, and providing these facilities to different regions, it is possible to give a check in excessive disaster induced migration to Dhaka and other big cities.
Conclusion:
Increased frequency and severity of natural disasters over the past recent years are not only displacing people but also exposing to enhanced unplanned urbanization. There is lack of proper policy guidelines to monitor and restrict excessive migration to Dhaka. But, day by day much migration by the disaster induced people are making the city more unfit for living. Excessive migration is disturbing the planned growth of Dhaka. But it is also necessary to take proper development and resettlement measures to reduce migration. And disaster mapping, migration mapping and spatial distribution of disaster migrants can be used as a tool in urban planning and management to reduced migration and to ensure better development of both the migrants and the people of Dhaka city.
References:
Ahmed, A. U. and Neelormi, S. 2008. Climate change, loss of livelihoods and forced displacements in Bangladesh: whither facilitated international migration Akter, T. 2010. Migration and living conditions in urban slums: implications for food security Website link: http://www.unnayan.org/reports/Migration.and.living.conditions.in.urban.slums.pdf, accessed date on, 19.04.2011 Akter, T. 2009, Climate Change and Flow of Environmental Displacement in Bangladesh Website link: http://www.unnayan.org/reports/Climate_Change_and_Flow_of_Environmental_displace ment.pdf, accessed date on 25.05.2011 Bangladesh: state of the environment report, 2001, Website link: http://www.rrcap.unep.org/pub/soe/bangladesh_disasters.pdf, accessed date on 26.05.2011 IOM (International Organization for Migration), 2007, Discussion note: migration and the environment. International Organization for Migration Website link: http://www.iom.int/jahia/jsp/index.jsp, accessed date on 25.05.2011 BBS, 2001 and 2011 (Population Census) SVRS, 2008 (Sample Vital Registration Survey)
Thanks to all