Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
CHAPTER 9
Barriers to Entry
A monopoly is the sole supplier of a product with no close substitutes The most important characteristic of a monopolized market is barriers to entry new firms cannot profitably enter the market
Barriers to entry are restrictions on the entry of new firms into an industry
Legal restrictions Economies of scale Control of an essential resource
2
Legal Restrictions
One way to prevent new firms from entering a market is to make entry illegal
Patents, licenses, and other legal restrictions imposed by the government provide some producers with legal protection against competition
Economies of Scale
A monopoly sometimes emerges naturally when a firm experiences economies of scale as reflected by the downward-sloping, long-run average cost curve In these situations, a single firm can sometimes supply market demand at a lower average cost per unit than could two or more firms at smaller rates of output
6
Put another way, market demand is not great enough to permit more than one firm to achieve sufficient economies of scale a single firm will emerge from the competitive process as the sole seller in the market.
Natural Monopoly
Because such a monopoly emerges from the nature of costs, it is called a natural
monopoly
A new entrant cannot sell enough output to experience the economies of scale enjoyed by an established natural monopolist entry into the market is naturally blocked
Local Monopolies
Local monopolies are more common that national or international monopolies Numerous natural monopolies for products sold in local markets However, as a rule long-lasting monopolies are rare because, as we will see, a profitable monopoly attracts competitors
10
Total revenue divided by quantity is the average revenue per diamond which is also $7,000
Thus, the monopolists price equals the
12
LOSS
6,750
G A I N
By selling another diamond, De Beers gains the revenue from that sale, $6,750 from the 4th diamond as shown by the blue-shaded vertical rectangle marked gain. However, to sell that 4th unit, De Beers must sell all four diamonds for $6,750 each it must sacrifice $250 on each of the first three diamonds which could have sold for $7,000 each. The loss in revenue from the first three units, $750, is shown by the red shaded horizontal rectangle marked Loss. The net change in total revenue from selling the 4th diamond equals the gain minus the loss $6,750 - $750 = $6,000.
14
The first two columns contain the pertinent price and quantity information. Total revenue (quantity times price) is provided in the third column. As De Beers expands output, total revenue increases until quantity reaches 15 diamonds when total revenue tops out.
Marginal revenue (the change in total revenue from selling one more diamond) appears in the fourth column. Note that for all units of output except the first, marginal revenue is less than the price, and the gap between the two widens as the price declines because the loss from selling all diamonds at this lower price increases.
Exhibit 4 depicts this information graphically.
15
0 16
Total revenue
16
32
16
More generally, any firm that has some control over what price to charge is a price maker
17
Profit Maximization
Exhibits 5 and 6 repeat the revenue data from the previous exhibits and also include short-run cost data The cost data are similar to those already introduced in the preceding chapters The key issue is which price-quantity combination should De Beers select to maximize profits
18
The profitmaximizing monopolist employs the same decision rule as the competitive firm the monopolist produces that quantity where total revenue exceeds total cost by the greatest amount $12,500 per day when output is 10 units per day. Total revenue is $52,500 and total cost is $40,000
19
Applying the marginal rule would imply that the monopolist increases output as long as selling additional diamonds adds more to total revenue than to total cost. Again profit is maximized at $12,500 when output is 10 diamonds per day, per unit costs are $4,000 and the price is $5,250. Exhibit 6 provides a graphical illustration of this process. 20
$5,250 4,000
Profit
a b e MR D = Average revenue
32 Diamonds per day
10
16
(b) Total Cost and Revenue Maximum profit $52,500 40,000 Total cost
Total revenue
15,000
10
16
21
In the short run, the loss-minimizing monopolist must decide whether to produce or to shut down
If the price covers average variable cost, the firm will produce If not, the firm will shut down, at least in the short run
22
a Loss p b
Notice that at point b, the firm is covering its average variable cost it is making some contribution to its fixed costs. However, it is not covering all of its costs. The average loss per unit, measured by ab, is identified by the yellow 0 shaded area.
24
26
p' m
p c
Sc = MC = ATC D = AR
The monopolist maximizes profit by equating marginal revenue with marginal cost point b equilibrium price pm and output Qm.
MRm 0
Q'm Q'c Quantity per period The price shows the consumers marginal benefit at that output rate, point m, which exceeds the marginal cost, point b. Because the marginal benefit consumers attach to additional units exceeds the marginal cost of producing those additional units, society would be better off if output were expanded beyond Qm the monopolist restricts output below the level that maximizes social welfare consumer surplus is shown by the yellow triangle ampm 28
p c
Sc = MC = ATC D = AR
MRm 0
Q'm Q'c Quantity per period Notice that consumer surplus has been reduced by more than the profit triangle. Consumers have also lost the triangle mcb which was part of the consumer surplus under perfect competition the deadweight loss of monopoly because it is a loss to consumers but a gain to nobody. This loss results from the allocative inefficiency arising from the higher price and reduced output.
29
30
31
32
33
35
Finally, monopolists have also been criticized for being slow to adopt the latest production techniques, to develop new products, and generally lacking innovativeness
36
Price Discrimination
A monopolist can sometimes increase economic profit by charging higher prices to customers who value the product more
The practice of charging difference prices to different customers when the price differences are not justified by differences in cost is called price
discrimination
37
39
D o lla rs p e r u nit
$3.00
1.00 MR D
LRAC, MC
400
At a given price, the price elasticity of demand in panel b(elastic) is greater than in panel a (inelastic). For simplicity, assume the firm produces at a constant long-run average and marginal cost of $1. This firm maximizes profits by finding the price in each market that equates marginal revenue with marginal cost consumers with the lower price elasticity pay $3 and those with the higher price elasticity pay $1.50 in markets with elastic demand the price will be lower than in markets where demand is inelastic. 40
41
D o l la r s p e r u n i t
A perfectly discriminating monopolist would maximize profits at point e where marginal revenue equals marginal cost price set at point e
Profit
c
D = Marginal revenue
45