Sei sulla pagina 1di 41

UMTS KPI-Optimisation and Tools

Sanjay Kumar/Hemal Doshi

Before we start: We will first look at the general optimisation process, RF aspects, call flow alongwith the KPIs. After that we will see the Optimisation techniques by means of Drill down analysis and all the UMTS Tools used for the optimisation for TNZ network.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

General Optimisation Process:

Pre-Optimization is an optional phase and might be required especially for new network deployment or network extensions. This phase might incorporate tasks such as hardware functionality checks (proper integration), coverage verification, adjustments for initial antenna tilts, creation of initial neighbour lists, and RF parameter declaration. Other optional tasks in this phase may include initial scanner drive test for coverage and neighbour list verifications. The objectives of the Service Measurement Based Optimization and the Drive Test Based Optimization are to assess and improve network performance and quality. Both optimization phases are independent of each other

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Primary RF Optimisation objectives: Minimize Call Setup Failures Minimize Drop Calls Maximize Voice Quality Maximize Data Throughput Ensure defined system service coverage Maximize reliability of IRAT handover

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Overview of RF Optimisation process:

Service Measurement based optimisation to be carried out based on report analysis. Pre-optimisation is mainly covered during the planning phase of the network .

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Importance of Scanner Measurement in Drive Test:


Scanner Measurement Tools measure the UMTS physical layer. The system performs absolute and relative channel power measurements of the Primary Synchronization Channel (PSCH), Secondary Synchronization Channel (SSCH) and the Primary Common

Pilot Channel (P-CPICH). These three channel measurements can be performed


simultaneously for multiple scrambling codes. Scanners are able to perform power measurements on the GSM DCS or PCS bands at the same time. The UMTS and/or GSM channel power measurements are executed without using a UMTS/GSM test terminal. Required key measurement capabilities are: Scrambling Code Power Ec and Ec/Io (CPICH) Scrambling Code Group and Scrambling Code Number RSSI (Io) Power measurements on GSM, DCS or PCS channels Scanner measurement tools are used for pilot coverage surveys to analyze pilot coverage, best server and pilot pollution, and to identify missing neighbors and nonUMTS interference.
All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Service Measurement Based Optimization:


Service measurement tools must be utilized during the Service Measurement Based Optimization. These tools are used primarily after network launch when live traffic exists. Network performance data are collected at the OMC level. Specific quality and performance criteria, within a UMTS network, are assessed by certain measures and events. These specific measures and events are performance metrics that are composed of a series of quality indicators. Since there is a large amount of quality indicators used for functional and performance tests, a subset of Key

Performance Indicators (KPIs) is chosen that best represent the quality and
performance of a UMTS network. The network performance is in general verified by the following factors: Call Availability (i.e. successful Set-up of the Call or Accessibility)

Call Reliability (i.e. Successful Maintenance of the Call as opposed to Dropped Call)
Call Quality Call Mobility A Call refers to both Circuit Switched Call and Packet Switched Call (Session).
All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Each of the classes listed above can be measured by specific KPIs as following: Call Availability: Successful Radio Resource Control (RRC) Connections Establishment

Rate, Dropped RRC Connections Rate and Total Radio Access Bearer (RAB)
Establishment Success Rate. Call Reliability: Total RAB Dropping Rate. Call Quality: Uplink and Downlink Block Error Rate (BLER). Call Mobility: Intra and Inter RNC Soft Handover Success Rate, Relocation Preparation (for UMTS to GSM HO) and UMTS to GSM Handover Success Rate, Location Area (LA) Update Success Rate, and Routing Area (RA) Update Success Rate.

Now we will see the basic RF UMTS optimisation/problem aspects, WCDMA call flow to
understand the performance counters in more detail.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

RF Optimisation Aspects:
The most common challenges of RF Optimization are Coverage, Pilot

Pollution/Interference, Around-the-Corner-Problem and Missing Neighbours. Additional aspects such as Cell Breathing, Inter/Intra System Handover, Near Far Problem and

HSxPA should also be checked for overall improvement.


1) Radio Coverage: Radio coverage is defined as an area where the Link Budget condition, in particular the limited traffic channel path loss (UL or DL) for a service type is met. Poor RF coverage is typically characterized as: Coverage Hole or Outer Coverage Area Area with insufficient pilot RSCP signal strength

No Dominant Pilot Area Area with sufficient pilot RSCP signal strength but no
dominant Ec/Io pilot. Usually the case when many equal strength pilots are measured that lower the overall signal-to-interference.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

2) Pilot Pollution: Multiple pilot receptions in the same area increase the overall level of interference. Pilots not used by the terminals cause interference to the ongoing communication, which in the worst case may cause a call failure. Typically the term

pilot pollution describes the existence of too many pilots in an area, which arent
required to sustain the call. Pilot pollution occurs when the following conditions take place: Number of present pilots are larger than the Active Set Size Present pilots have similar signal strengths Present pilots have poor Ec/Io ratios Polluted area shows usually good RSSI values

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

3) Near-Far problem: The Near-Far problem occurs when an UE transmits on high power near the cell site, thus creating excessive interference for another UE located far away from the cell site. The goal of the cell site is to receive all UEs at equal signal

strengths. Therefore fast closed loop power control is needed to direct mobiles to
power up/down very quickly.

The optimization goal is to ensure that all power control algorithms are working
properly. Power control parameters are tuned only when there are obvious power control failures.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

4) Cell Breathing: A spread spectrum system like UMTS has the characteristic of cell breathing, which is dependent on the network loading. An increase of the network load is associated with an increase of the network interference, which means more power is

transmitted by the network cells and users. High interference lowers the quality of
service at the initial cell coverage border and thus shrinks the effective coverage area. Inversely, low load leads to low network interference, which increases the effective cell coverage

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

5) Missing Neighbors: Missing Neighbours are pilots that are not defined in the neighbour list. These pilots are measured with an adequate receive level but cause interference because they cannot be added to the active set. It is important that all received UMTS sectors are either eliminated if not required to sustain the communication or declared in the neighbour list. An un-optimized neighbour list has a big impact to the quality and performance of connection. The practise shows that mostly missing neighbour relations are encountered around RNC

borders.
Neighbour list are pre-optimized during the radio network design stage. Scanner data can be used to automatically compute a neighbour list for an initial network rollout. Furthermore, root cause analysis of drive test failures will also provide information on

missing neighbour relations. In all cases extensive drive test are required. Another
possibility to optimise neighbour lists is to use the performance management counters (handover matrix) once commercial traffic is present.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

6) Intra System Handover: Unnecessary delays in intra system handovers (soft/softer handovers) may cause uplink/downlink interference. Quick intra system handovers are required for rapid changes in path loss between the UE and the sector due to fading.

Also, unnecessary handovers due to non-contiguous UMTS coverage or pilot pollution


require additional signalling resources, and increase downlink interference.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

7) Inter RAT Handover: The Inter Radio Access Technologies handover (Inter RAT or IRAT) covers the transfer of a connection from a UTRAN system to another system technology. The transition from UMTS to another technology should usually occur at

the UMTS coverage border. The optimization tasks cover:


Definition of sharp transition borders to avoid unnecessary handovers Underlying system should provide continuous stable coverage Idle mode parameters should also be considered and harmonized to avoid ping-pong

effects
The optimization of the IRAT handover may require the modification of the UMTS coverage to achieve sharp boarder and reliable radio conditions. This can be realized through antenna configuration changes (tilt, azimuth) and/or parameter settings. The performance of the IRAT handover depends mainly on the design of the IRAT neighbours. The practice shows that reliable IRAT handover is achieved through the RSCP threshold criteria for border cells, while core sites may find Ec/Io criteria in better defining the handover regions.
All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

8) HSDPA: High Speed Downlink Packet Access (HSDPA) is a major feature of the 3GPP Release 5 providing enhancements to the downlink transmission capacity (higher enduser data throughput). New physical channels such as HS-PDSCH (downlink), HS-SCCH

(downlink), and HS-DPCCH (uplink) are required to be traced and analyzed.


The End-to-End optimization strategy for HSDPA applies following considerations: Plan drive/indoor/walk-testing activities to cover HSDPA cells and collect HSDPA relevant data. Define all Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) according to a precise methodology, which makes KPIs comparable throughout the measurement campaigns. Definition of a methodology to correlate test results with relevant network performance counters. Monitoring capabilities on the interfaces to collect the relevant traces on UTRAN and

Core Network.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

The HSDPA performance depends, in general, on radio channel coverage condition,

traffic type (VoIP, Streaming, HTTP), user classes (different subscription levels), and
available downlink resources. time during cell change. The cell change procedure does not support soft/softer handover for the downlink HSDSCH. The hard handover constrains on the HS-DSCH require the following radio optimization aspects to be considered to maximize HSDPA performances (throughput) and avoid degradation, including eventual drops: HSDPA related metrics are round trip time (RTT), throughput per user, HS-DSCH cell change success rate, and HS-DSCH data interruption

Optimize soft/softer handover boundaries to avoid excessive sector coverage overlap


Create clear dominant pilot coverage through antenna configuration tuning (tilt, azimuth) to avoid unnecessary handovers Remove existing over shooters which create interference and possible instable radio conditions Minimize pilot pollution areas
All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Cell change should be performed not too late, when the UE has already moved into the area of the new best cell to avoid radio link quality as well as throughput degradation. On the other hand cell change should not be performed too early to avoid ping-pong

effects by switching back to the previous best cell if the radio conditions vary.
Local optimization is initially done through the tuning of the parameters hysteresis and time-to-trigger (e.g. in dense urban environment). 9) HSUPA: High Speed Uplink Packet Access (HSUPA) is aimed to improve throughput, reduce delay and enhance the capacity of a release 6 compliant 3GPP UTRAN. Unlike HSDPA, mobility is supported through soft handovers.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Call Flow WCDMA

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Metrics 1. Accessibility Voice = RRCSucConEst_Voice RABSucEst_Voice FRRCConReq_Voice RABAtt_Voice


RRCSucConEst_HSPA RABSucEstTrch_HSPA * 2. Accessibility HSPA = FRRCConreq_HSPA RABAttTrch_HSPA

AbRelReq_Voice_Cell 3. Retainability Voice = 1 RelComp_Voice_Cell

4. Retainability HSPA = 1-((AbnormalReleaseRequest_HSDPA) /


(IuAbnormalReleaseRequest_HSDPA + RadioBearerReleaseSuccess HSDPA +
HSDPAToDCHTransitionSuccess+ IF((AODownsizingStep1Success_AO012_C_HSDPA AOUpsizingSuccess_AO014_C_HSDPA > 0), AODownsizingStep1Success_AO012_C_HSDPA - AOUpsizingSuccess_AO014_C_HSDPA, 0.0))
All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Performance Analysis - Approach Adopt Top down analysis approach Filter out HW alarms before in depth analysis Monitor one/two week of busy hour data (busy hr defined on traffic). Identify sub metrics for drill down. Identify the counters impacting the performance metric. If parameter changes required implement in cluster, monitor the performance & backup with drive data, for any degradations before implementing global change.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Performance analysis - Monitoring Methodology

All Metrics Taken in Busy hour Average at busy hour over two weeks is compared with 1, ie the blocking exists if there is on average one blocking event per day

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Performance analysis - Call flow - RB allocation Counters

1 -> VS.RadioBearerSetupRequest - #1652 2/3 -> VS.RadioBearerEstablishmentUnsuccess - #1629

4 -> VS.RadioLinkReconfPrepReq - #56 5 -> VS.RadioLinkReconfigurationPrepareSuccess - #50 VS.RadioLinkReconfigurationPrepareUnsuccess - #40 Sub-Counter #0: RADIO_LINK_RECONFIGURATION_FAILURE Sub-Counter #1: Timeout nbap Sub-Counter #2: Rrm refusal Sub-Counter #3: Iub Layer Congestion Sub-Counter #4: NodeB (CEM) lack of L1 resources Sub-Counter #5: Lack of Transport Identifier (CID or 6 -> UDP Port) on the Iub VS.RadioBearerSetu Sub-Counter #6: Lack of bandwidth on the Iub pRequest - #1652 Sub-Counter #7: INode refusal Sub-Counter #8: NodeB out of order (No answer) 7 -> VS.RadioLinkReconfigurationCommit - #51 VS.RadioLinkReconfigurationCancel - #26 8 -> VS.RadioBearerSetupSuccess #1650 VS.RadioBearerSetupUnsuccess #602 Sub-Counter #0: timeout Sub-Counter #1: RADIO_BEARER_SETUP_FAILUR E Sub-Counter #2: Any other failure causing a RB setup procedure to be unsuccessful. See details under 'Triggering Event'. RAB.FailEstab.CS - #2629 2631 PS All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008 RAB.FailEstab.CS.ULLoad RAB.FailEstab.CS.DLPwr

Performance analysis Blocking phases, Bottlenecks


Blocking phases
Call admission Call reconfiguration Mobility

Bottlenecks:
Air interface power, codes, load Node B resources CEM, CCM, Licensing Backhaul Iub BW RNC CPU

Blocking Cause:
VS.RadioBearerEstablishmentUnsuccess - #1629 Sub-Counter #0: invalid RAB parameters value Sub-Counter #1: unavailable dl code resources Sub-Counter #2: unavailable dl power resources Sub-Counter #3: Unspecified Sub-Counter #4: RL failure or RLC error Sub-Counter #6: CAC RNC Processing resources Sub-Counter #7: NodeB (CEM) lack of L1 resources Sub-Counter #8: Lack of transport identifier on the Iu Sub-Counter #9: Lack of bandwidth on the Iu Sub-Counter #10: Lack of transport identifier on the Iur Sub-Counter #11: Lack of bandwidth on the Iur Sub-Counter #12: Lack of transport identifier on the Iub Sub-Counter #13: Lack of bandwidth on the Iub

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Performance analysis - RB allocation bottle neck Counters


1 -> VS.RadioBearerSetupRequest - #1652 2/3 -> VS.RadioBearerEstablishmentUnsuccess - #1629 4 -> VS.RadioLinkReconfPrepReq - #56 5 -> VS.RadioLinkReconfigurationPrepareSuccess - #50 VS.RadioLinkReconfigurationPrepareUnsuccess - #40 Sub-Counter #0: RADIO_LINK_RECONFIGURATION_FAILURE Sub-Counter #1: Timeout nbap Sub-Counter #2: Rrm refusal Sub-Counter #3: Iub Layer Congestion Sub-Counter #4: NodeB (CEM) lack of L1 resources Sub-Counter #5: Lack of Transport Identifier (CID or UDP Port) on the Iub Sub-Counter #6: Lack of bandwidth on the Iub Sub-Counter #7: INode refusal Sub-Counter #8: NodeB out of order (No answer) 6 -> VS.RadioBearerSetupRequest - #1652 7 -> VS.RadioLinkReconfigurationCommit - #51 VS.RadioLinkReconfigurationCancel - #26 8 -> VS.RadioBearerSetupSuccess - #1650 VS.RadioBearerSetupUnsuccess - #602 Sub-Counter #0: timeout Sub-Counter #1: RADIO_BEARER_SETUP_FAILURE Sub-Counter #2: Any other failure causing a RB setup procedure to be unsuccessful. See details under 'Triggering Event'. RAB.FailEstab.CS - #2629 2631 PS RAB.FailEstab.CS.ULLoad RAB.FailEstab.CS.DLPwr RAB.FailEstab.CS.CodeStarv RAB.FailEstab.CS.RLFailOther RAB.FailEstab.CS.RLFailNodeBErr RAB.FailEstab.CS.RLFailNodeBResource RAB.FailEstab.CS.RLReconfigExp RAB.FailEstab.CS.RBSetupFail RAB.FailEstab.CS.RBSetupExp

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Metric Classification
1. Performance metrics
Accessibility / Retainability

2. Mobility Metrics
Avg no of RL per user / Soft handoff success rate / Inter freq / Inter RNC

3. Traffic metrics
Erlangs / Traffic in Mbytes

4. Quality metrics
Throughput per sub / BLER

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Drill down Analysis - Accessibility


Accessibility

< target

Identify Top N cells

Identify Worst period

RRC Per-fRRC-RRC establishment success rate (UE perspective)

RAB Perf-RAB-RAB establishment success rate

SCCP Perf-CN-Iu SCCP Connection success rate CN

RF Conditions

RRC Congestion

SCCP RNC analysis

Alarm Correlation

High nb unspecified Ctg

Qual-Air-Uplink RSSI (dBm) Qual-Air-Ec/No Distribution Qual-Air-RSCP distribution

Cap-RRC-Congestion-DlCode rate Cap-RRC-Cogestion-DlPower rate Cap-RRC-Congestion-RSSI rate Cap-RRC-Congestion-Quality rate Cap-RRC-Congestion-Overload rate Cap-RRC-Congestion-Timeout Cap-RRC-Congestion-ALCAPfail Cap-RRC-Congestion-ManOvld Cap-RRC-Congestion-NodeBPrb Cap-RRC-Congestion DCH Cap-RRC-Congestion CRNTI Cap-RL-SF128 Code Channel Usage

RNC-Alarms Node B alarms CN Alarms

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Drill down Analysis - Retainability


Retainability

< target

Identify Top N cells

Identify Worst period

RL Analysis Qua-lRL-call drop RL

CORE

OAM

RF Conditions Qual-Air-Uplink RSSI (dBm) Qual-Air-Ec/No Distribution Qual-Air-RSCP distribution Qual-Air-BLER-AMR Qual-RL-SIR Qual-Nb-Thermal noise

CORE Network issues Outages Overload Forced releases

OAM Reasons

Alarm Correlation

Mobility

UE Prob

RNC-Alarms Node B alarms CN Alarms

Mobility Success rates

RFO Traces

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Drill down Analysis - Traffic


Traffic Throughput Total Calls Idle activity Call holding times Call duration Metrics

Identify Top N cells

Identify Worst period

RL Analysis

CORE

HW

RNC

RF Conditions

CORE Network issues Outages Overload Forced releases

OAM Reasons

Alarm Correlation

RNC/RAB resources

RNC-Alarms Node B alarms CN Alarms


All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Drill down Analysis - Quality


Quality Uplink Downlink BLER Noise rise Power used EcNo distribution

Metrics

Identify Top N cells

Identify Worst period

RL Analysis

CORE

HW

RF Conditions

CORE Network issues Outages Overload Forced releases

OAM Reasons

Alarm Correlation

UE Prob

RNC-Alarms Node B alarms CN Alarms


All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

RFO Traces

UMTS RF Parameters:
RF Optimization may require the adjustment of various RF parameters. Some of those have complex interactions with one another affecting the system in terms of coverage, capacity and call quality. Therefore, it is important to prioritize the parameters

depending on their ability to improve performance with minimal complexity and tradeoffs. Regarding their tuning occurrence the RF parameters can be classified into three classes: Primary, Secondary and Fixed parameters.

Primary Parameters
These parameters may require frequent adjustments, often from one cell site to another. These include: Neighbour Lists Antenna Parameter (antenna tilt, azimuth, height and type) Pilot Channel Power

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Secondary Parameters The secondary parameters can be used for further fine-tuning, especially in specific problem areas and include: Handover parameters (inter + intra RAT) Access parameters Cell Selection / Re-selection parameters

HSDPA parameters
HSUPA parameters

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Fixed Parameters The fixed parameters are not typically adjusted during the RF Optimization. Changing those parameters can create complex interactions in key system performance such as coverage, capacity, voice quality, data throughput, etc. The impact is not easily characterized or predictable, and can vary from network to network or within a network. These parameters should be adjusted only after consulting the subject matter experts, e.g. system engineering (SAE). These parameters include:

Power Control parameters


Load Control parameters Common Channel powers (e.g. AICH, P+SSCH, BCH) Access parameters which are not part of the secondary parameters Handover parameters that are not part of the secondary parameters

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Tools used:
1) CPV (Cell Performance Viewer): This tool is used for basic KPI monitoring & performance reporting tool. It has a client-server architecture:

CPV CLIENT: A user-friendly GUI to report on the RAN performance & capacity history
of the Telecom NZ CDMA network. CPV SERVER: A SQL database containing configuration and performance data based on regular Prospect CDMA reports

Sample reports available from CPV are as below:

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

2) RFO (RF Optimizer) is used for Call trace analysis.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

3) NPO: NPO (9359) offers a full range of tools for multi-standard QoS Monitoring and radio network optimization facilities for UMTS and GSM networks. NPO enables you to optimize using: QoS analysis Configuration Parameters tuning Availability and alarming.

4) WiPS (Alcatel Lucent 9352 Wireless Provisioning System): This tool is for making audit and changes in the network. This tool is similar to ALU PRC generator in GSM.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

5) SPAT3G (System Performance Analysis Tool): SPAT3G is a performance analysis tool used to quickly troubleshoot and improve

wireless network performance. The tool supports 2G/3G1X CDMA, 1xEV-DO, and UMTS
technologies. SPAT3G enables effective and efficient performance analysis by providing the user with intuitive analysis reports in the form of tables, trends, and geographical maps. It is used to troubleshoot and analyze the performance of a live network using data sources including Service Measurements, Per Call Measurement Data (PCMD), ROP,

Translations, Neighbour list data (Handoff Matrix, Undeclared Neighbour List).


6) Actix: This is the drive test Post-Processing Tool used here in TNZ.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

7) WQA (Wireless Quality Analyzer): This is a web based tool and is used for neighbour analysis. WQA (Wireless Quality Analyser-an ex Nortel product) is part of the UTRAN performance management portfolio(eg. NPO, RFO) for performance monitoring,

optimization and troubleshooting.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Key modules of WQA Neighbor Tuning Module (CTn)- Tune neighbor list based on 3G-2g handover,

softhandover, HSxPA, inter-frequency, ping-pong triggers, including handoff failure


analysis based on system wide call trace. Similar to UNL+Handoff Matrix in the SPO space with the addition in HSxPA, ping pong and advanced interfrequency analysis Call Failure Trace Module(CFT-based on Ctg) - call trace reporting based on call trace

snapshots. Filters, with the option of drilling down to per mobile(IMSI) analysis(daily
granularity). More than 100 causes in CFT vs. 20 at Counter level. Covers all types of failures in LCAP, NBAP, RANAP, RNSAP, RRC, RNC Internal Causes,etc. Call Trace Analysis Module(CTx=Ctb/Ctg) - This feature allows customers to optimize UTRAN sub system, mainly the radio aspects, without requirement of drive tests. RSCP,Ec/No behaviour(radio coverage analysis). Distance based analysis.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

8) A9155: (also known as 9155) It is Alcatel-Lucents re-branded version of ATOLL. The 9155 working environment provides a comprehensive and integrated set of tools and features that allow you to create and define your radio-planning project in a single

application.

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Thank You

All Rights Reserved Alcatel-Lucent 2008

Potrebbero piacerti anche