Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Submitted By:
Shounak Mondal 191055 FMG 19
FORE School of Management
Page
New Delhi
Page
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that Mr. Shounak Mondal , Roll No. 191055 has completed his summer internship at New Horizons India Limited and has submitted this project report entitled A detailed study of Marketing Strategies adopted by IIT Study Circle and recommending ways for their betterment towards part fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the Post Graduate Diploma in Management (FMG-19) 2010-2012.
This Report is the result of his/her own work and to the best of my knowledge no part of it has earlier comprised any other report, monograph, dissertation or book. This project was carried out under my overall supervision.
Page
Table of Contents
1. Table of Figures ..........................................................6 2. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT .........................................7 3. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................8 4. INTRODUCTION ......................................................9 4.1 INDIAN EDUCATION INDUSTRY ............................... 9
4.1.1 4.1.2 4.1.3 4.1.4 MARKET OVERVIEW AND SIZE ............................................................................... 10 FORMAL INDIAN EDUCATION SEGMENT ............................................................. 11 NON-FORMAL INDIAN EDUCATION SEGMENT ................................................... 13 E-LEARNING MARKET IN INDIAN EDUCATION INDUSTRY ............................ 15
4.3 SWOT ANALYSIS OF NHIL AS A COMPANY ......... 32 4.4 MARKETING TECHNIQUES FOLLOWED AT IIT STUDY CIRCLE VIKASPURI ............................................ 32 4.5 BRANDING .............................................................. 33 5. RESEARCH Methodolgy and Data Collection ......39
Page
5.1 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY......................... 39 5.2 NEED AND SCOPE OF THE STUDY ............... 39
5.3 LITERATURE REVIEW ........................................... 40 5.4 HYPOTHESIS ...................................................... 43 5.5 QUESTIONNAIRE DESIGN AND TESTING .. 43 5.6 DATA COLLECTION METHOD ...................... 44 5.7 RESEARCH DESIGN ......................................... 44 5.8 SAMPLING DESIGN AND SAMPLING SIZE . 45 5.9 TARGET POPULATION ................................... 45 6. DATA INTERPRETATION and Analysis .............46 6.1 DEMOGRAPHICS .............................................. 46 6.2 OTHER FACTORS ................................................... 49 6.3 STATISTICAL ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION .................................................... 52 7. Major Findings and Recommendations..................83 8. CONCLUSION ..........................................................85 8.1 LIMITATIONS ......................................................... 85 9. BIBLIOGRAPHY ......................................................86 10.APPENDIX ................................................................87 10.1 QUESTIONNAIRE .................................................. 87 10.2 ORGANIZATION PROFILE .................................... 89
Page
1. Table of Figures
Figure 1 ......................................................................................................................................... 11 Figure 2 ......................................................................................................................................... 12 Figure 3 ......................................................................................................................................... 14 Figure 4 ......................................................................................................................................... 21 Figure 5 ......................................................................................................................................... 34 Figure 6 ......................................................................................................................................... 36 Figure 7 ......................................................................................................................................... 46 Figure 8 ......................................................................................................................................... 47 Figure 9 ......................................................................................................................................... 48 Figure 10 ....................................................................................................................................... 49 Figure 11 ....................................................................................................................................... 50 Figure 12 ....................................................................................................................................... 51 Figure 13 ....................................................................................................................................... 80
Page
2. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
In pursuit of an MBA degree, summer internship plays a pivotal role in the overall grooming by providing real time industry experience. I have tried to apply the learning I have received from the various experienced professionals, who helped and guided me throughout the internship project tenure. I wish to express my true regards to individuals who have been a great support and motivated me to perform better.
My Sincere thanks to Mr. Praveen Sharma (Vice Chairman), for giving me an opportunity to work in the company and to learn from the practical challenges that a manager faces while on the job.
My Sincere thanks to Mr.Anu Kundlu(VP Marketing) and Mr. Samar Nayar (Zonal Head Marketing) for their support in solving my doubts related to the project. He has always encouraged me and appreciated my work by positively analyzing my findings and suggestions. He directed me how to make the data collected more valuable for me as well as the organization. I wish to place on record my gratitude to NHElite Education Services Ltd. for providing me an opportunity to work on a project of such importance. My stay in the organization has been a great learning experience. This exposure has enriched me with knowledge and has also introduced me to the attributes of a successful professional.
Page
3. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The objective of the Project is to identify and evaluate the existing strategies of Marketing for IIT Study Circle and then after proper research suggesting recommendations in these techniques and strategies.The questionnaire covered all the questions required to gain an insight into what factors influence the decision of schools and students to go for a school integrated coaching programs. Organization can understand the requirements of the students and the strategy can be made accordingly for the different marketing techniques. Finally attempt is made to suggest the different ways by which the company could improve its sales. Through this report we hope to make valuable contributions to the company. Several recommendations and suggestions are given from conclusions which were arrived after data analysis with the help of excel.
The data collected from students was entered into excel sheets and then analyzed using SPSS and Minitab to come up with the conclusion on general view of students and schools towards school integrated coaching programs and also coming up with the recommendations given at the end of the report.
Page
4. INTRODUCTION
The 86th constitutional amendment has also made elementary education a fundamental right for the children between the age group- 6 to 14. According to the 2001 census, the total literacy rate in India is 65.38%. The female literacy rate is only 54.16%. The gap between rural and urban literacy rate is also very significant in India. This is evident from the fact that only 59.4% of rural population are literate as against 80. 3% urban population according to the 2001 census.
In order to develop the higher education system, the government had established the University Grants Commission in 1953. The primary role of UGC has been to regulate the standard and spread of higher education in India. There has been a marked progress in the expansion of higher education if we look at the increase of higher educational institutes in India. The higher education system in India comprise of more than17000 colleges, 20 central universities, 217 State Universities, 106 Deemed to Universities and 13 institutes of Natioanl importance. This number will soon inflate as the setting up of 30 more central universities, 8 new IITs, 7 IIMs and 5 new Indian Institutes of Science are now proposed.
Page
With dramatic increase in demand for professionals in almost all spheres and good quality education becoming an avenue to success, A whole new education industry has grown alongwith the formal education system -- tutorials and coaching classes, distance education and online learning programmes, education consultancies for various courses and study programmes, skills' training centres and career counselling services. Massive investments are supporting this demand that range from pre-primary to research level. There are many institutions and coaching centres that prepare students for taking SAT, GRE and other examinations for studying abroad. Even big corporate houses have entered the field to meet rising aspirations of youngsters, reports from PTI bureaus across the country show."India has over 12 million students enrolled for higher education and the faculty for them is numbering less than 3.5 lakh which is just not adequate," said Sajjan Jindal, president of the Associated Chambers of Commerce and Industry of India (ASSOCHAM). 4.1.1 MARKET OVERVIEW AND SIZE The Indian education market has witnessed a series of developments and changes in the last few years, which resulted in a significant increase in market size of the education industry compared to previous years. The present Indian education industry is in its development stage. With increasing per capita income, national economic growth and enhanced technology it has become necessary to develop the structure of the Indian education sector. Private players have taken several initiatives for development of education infrastructure and quality. The emergence of new segments like e-learning and V-SAT training is slowly shifting the education market towards new heights. Indian education market consists of two segments formal and non-formal education system. K-12 segment has shown tremendous increase in terms of market growth and revenue from past years and is expected to grow at same pace. Private professional institutes are expanding with a strong growth rate which has opened the doors for foreign universities. There is tremendous opportunity in the test preparation market in India.
Page
enhanced teaching techniques. Increase in GDP and per capita Income has raised the
10
The growing IT industry in India is driving IT education and training market as well as
enrollment ratio in education sector. Growth in service sector revenues and collaborations with foreign universities have also driven the sector's growth. Presently the educational Industry is USD 50 billion strong and it expected to show an increase of 12% in 2010 and by 2012 it expected to touch USD 80 billion. Universities and colleges in India have grown at a CAGR (Compound Annual Growth Rate) of over 5% and 6% respectively, since independence. The statistics clearly shows that more number of private institutes is going to surface offering various courses. Not only full time educational institutions but various other training centers offering computer education, entrance coaching, career counseling etc.
Figure 1
4.1.2 FORMAL INDIAN EDUCATION SEGMENT The formal educational system in India broadly comprises schools (often classified as K12 kindergarten to 12th) and higher education (HE) level. All the levels, from school to higher education, fall under the purview of the Ministry of Human Resource Development (Department of School Education and Literacy & Department of Higher Education). Schools cater to the 3-17 years age group. With no central governing body
Page
11
for K12, they are ruled by state boards/ ICSE/ CBSE/ International Boards. Higher education institutes cater to the 18-22 years & above age group. With a single governing body (UGC), HE comprises graduate/ diploma/professional courses. This may be followed by post graduation courses.
While India has been proactive on liberalization, IES has remained largely untouched by the reforms process. A priority sector status does ensure fund flow to an extent, but the governments agenda of social inclusion has trapped IES in a regulatory maze. Archaic rules mandate all formal educational institutes in India to be run as not-for-profit centers under a society (registration under the Societies Registration Act 1860) or a public trust (Registration Act 1908). Any surplus funds generated in the process of running formal schools/ HEIs have to be ploughed back into the same school/ HEI and no dividends can be distributed.
50%
Figure 2
K12 Segment: At $20bn, schools (also popularly known as K12, i.e. from Kindergarten to 12th standard) form a core of the total market. A student can continue to be a part of the education system or his/ her 10th or 12th grade scores would be recognized only
Page
12
if he/ she passes out from a K12 institute affiliated to a board recognized by the system. Hence, all K12 institutes have to be affiliated to an education board either central boards like ICSE and CBSE or a state board. While a few states confer on schools the right to act as profit-generating entities,educational boards still demand strict adherence to the not-for-profit structure.Of late, a trend has emerged wherein some schools have been seeking affiliations with various international boards such as IGCSE (International General Certificate of Secondary Education) and IB (International Baccalaureate from Geneva); in terms of operating structure, while these schools can opt for either a not-forprofit trust or a for-profit company, they can do so only after evaluating the state laws (e.g. Haryana allows schools to be run for-profit while most states do not).
Higher Education Segment: At $6.5bn ($20bn including cash transactions of ~$1.5bn and the $13bn spend outside the country), HE is the second largest opportunity in IES. HEIs seeking recognition by the apex regulatory authority named UGC (University Grants Commission) also need to be run in the form of a trust/ society. Technical education institutes find themselves regulated under various professional councils as well e.g. AICTE (All India Council for Technical Education) is the regulating authority for engineering and MBA colleges.
4.1.3 NON-FORMAL INDIAN EDUCATION SEGMENT The non-formal education segments flanking the formal ones include preschools (1.5-3 years), coaching classes, multimedia/ IT to schools and colleges (catering to both private and public institutions), vocational training and the books market. The segments are free of any regulations (i.e. no governing/ regulatory bodies for this segment).While it is expected that the non-regulated $10bn non-formal market to witness 18% CAGR till 2012, the market broadly consists of segments that are inherently difficult to scale. In fact, scalability can be achieved only in less than 5% of the market while three of the largest segments (95% of the opportunity coaching class; ~64%, vocational training;
Page
13
Figure 3
Coaching Class Market: Indias already inadequate education system is being further stretched due to its increasing population. So much so that a $6.4bn segment (64% of the total nonformal IES; next only to K12 and HE) coaching classes has sprouted around formal IES. The market is rapidly growing as the Indian education system lays heavy emphasis on marks scored in an exam. A shortage of quality HEIs is further fuelling growth. This is evident in the fact that the number of seats in Indian IIMs (Indian Institutes of Management) has increased merely 3% (2003-2008) but the number of CAT aspirants has shown a CAGR of 19% in the same period.
Vocational Training Market: The imperative for students/ employees to draw on skill vocational training a parallel $1.5bn education system. Also, the increasing relevance of services sector in the Indian economy calls for enhanced technical/ soft skill sets.
Page
14
Corporates (across industries) too are gleaning from their global counterparts the culture of continuous upgradation in skill sets of employees at all levels. While the factors suggest rapid growth (25% 3-year CAGR) as new training areas (retail, aviation, hospitality, management, English language/ soft skills trainings, etc) emerge, the space remains highly fragmented. Also, nonsticky nature of corporate trainings implies low revenue visibility, thereby hampering scale. At this stage, only a few players like NIIT and Aptech (leaders in IT trainings) have managed to accumulate mass. Others players with the potential to scale include VETA (English training) and ICA (financials trainings).
4.1.4 E-LEARNING MARKET IN INDIAN EDUCATION INDUSTRY E-learning or electronic learning in India is gaining prominence slowly, but indeed steadily. This is due to the fact that more than half the population of India today is below 25 years of age and the number of Internet users are growing continuously. The tremendous growth of the economy in the recent past has also helped in the growth of online education in India. E-learning in India is specially popular with the young professionals who have joined the work force quite early but still would like to continue their education that may help them move up their career ladder quickly and safely. They find online education in India very convenient, as the nature of the course work does not require them to attend regular classes. Moreover reputed institutes like Indian Institute of Management, Indian Institute of Technology, Indian Institute of Foreign Trade are today offering e-learning courses.Thus e-learning in India makes it possible for the learners to pursue their education from reputed institutes without much hassle. Online Education Scope in India The scope of online education in India is actually much wider. Apart from proper course works, some E-learning portals in India are also conducting mock tests for various competitive examinations like engineering, medical, management etc. For example, the Indiatimes group has introduced the Mindscape test center where one can appear for mock IIT-JEE online for making self-assessment. The Gurukul online Solutions, apart
Page
15
from providing various courses, set up a Jobs and Careers Centre (JCC), which, not only provides job-oriented vocational education in a variety of domains, but also provides career enriching courses via eLearning. They also offer Live Virtual Classroom connectivity to over 175 cities across India. Some E-learning portals in India are also providing tutorials for school students. Thus the reach of E-learning in India has expanded from adults to teenagers. The future of E-learning industry seems to be very bright in India as number of Internet users is growing in the country
at quite a satisfactory pace and more and more reputed players are showing their interest in the e-learning business. In fact, if prices of computers become affordable and Internet speed becomes tolerable, e- learning can work wonders for the country. Therefore, on this page, we would be providing information about all the online courses in India and the key players that are providing e-learning solutions in India.
E learning industry in India is still in its infant stage. E learning is yet to penetrate Indian education system and hence there is ample opportunity for private players to invest in this industry. The major advantage in India is its large student base. E learning will enable students to earn degrees and certificates without leaving their hometown. This will also reduce the cost of education. This is more relevant in the Indian context, because here you can find the reputed universities and colleges only in the big cities. If you are from a rural area you have to come to a town or city to do your masters. E learning will bridge this gap. There is a huge disparity in the spread of educational institutes in India. Most of the reputed institutes tends to cluster in the big cities, while the rest of India still lags behind. As a result you will have to bear the extra cost of leaving your home town. E learning can defiantly capture these areas. Fortunately, the number of students using computer is increasing, as such more students have access to E learning. As such, this will make higher education more accessible to the students.
4.1.5 OPPORTUNITIES IN INDIAN EDUCATION INDUSTRY In India, Private professional institutes are expanding with a strong growth rate whichhas opened the doors for foreign universities. These days coaching classes are gaining
Page
16
popularity due to rising competition and heavy load of studies. Also there is an opportunity in the testpreparation market in India, though institutes are expanding with a continuous growth rate butstill there is high potential of growth. Private sector has a strong hold in education industry starting from pre-schools to universities,formal IES accounts for almost US$billion, non-formal IES US$billion and together almost US$billion in 2009 In terms of total education market revenue, K-12 contribution is the highest as the market size for K-12 school is the biggest in India as compared to other professional courses. By 2012 the overall pre-school market is expected to cross US$billion, the organized segment is expected to grow faster.Educomp is the industry leader in K-12 segment, also has an18-24 month lead in multimedia within schools, its K-12 programme.The Gross Enrollment Ratio (GER) in higher education in India (percent of relevant age group enrolled in higher education) is estimated at 11%. In comparison, enrollments levels are 60% in the US and 16% in China. 4.1.6 KEY PLAYERS
1) EDUCOMP SOLUTIONS
Founded in 1994, Educomp Solutions Ltd. is a globally diversified education solutions provider and the largest education company in India. Educomp currently serves more than 15 million learners and educators across India, USA and Singapore. Educomp works closely with schools implementing innovative models, creating and delivering content to enhance student learning. Educomp has maintained a long, undiluted focus in the K-12 curriculum design and teacher education space. Its innovative applications and products have revolutionized the way information technology and the Internet is used to deliver new age learning to people. Educomp is a publicly traded company on the Bombay Stock Exchange and National Stock Exchange, India. Educomp Products: Introduced smartclass, a teacher-led content delivery system that has dramatically improved learning effectiveness in class. Developed Indias richest 3 D K-12 content library with over 16,000 modules aligned to Indian and international learning standards. Developed Roots to WingsTM, Indias first structured Pre-School learning system.
Page
17
Developed Mathguru.com an online learning initiative. Pioneered Education Process Outsourcing in India through the Learning Hour platform, a benchmark for other similar initiatives.
Conducted Professional Development workshops, training more than a million teachers in technology integration, pedagogy, and best practices in teaching.
Educomps Research Team constantly evolves more effective methods to reach out to learners and educators.Educomp has a track record of implementing large scale PublicPrivate-Partnership projects. Educomp works intimately with various State and Central Government agencies, Ministries of IT and HRD, and Governments of other countries. The varied programs involve across-the-board education infrastructure implementation, teacher training and content development projects.
2) EVERONN SYSTEMS
One of the leading educational companies in India, Everonn is listed in both the NSE and BSE. With a firm belief that technology-enabled learning can truly nullify social and economic boundaries, Everonns achievements have helped millions of students achieve their dreams. From its pioneering VSAT-enabled virtual and interactive classrooms to its emphasis on offering only the highest-quality content to students, Everonns quest for excellence has enabled the company to repeatedly break new grounds in the Indian education industry. Everonns commitment to a better standard of education is the guiding principle behind all its activities, from making Pre-school toddlers school ready to enhancing the employability of college students and providing the best entrance exam guidance in the nation. Everonns diverse operations are testament to the companys firm focus and dedication. From offering the next-generation in school education through Internet and VSAT to providing content on the move via mobile phones, Everonn is on a constant look out for the next technological revolution in education. Be it elementary knowledge or the latest in animation and gaming, Everonn is the one-stop destination for educational excellence. A parallel focus on formal learning has also enabled the company to continue raising the bar in the Indian education scenario.
Page
18
An unrivalled reach constituting a network of leading schools, colleges and training Centres as well as the determination to face all challenges has made Everonn a brand to be reckoned with in the arena. With a firm foothold in the schools, colleges, web products, entrance examination guidance, retail, skill development, teachers training, education resources, e-governance, animation and gaming and formal education segments. Everonn today is the largest VSAT education network in the World.
3) NIIT
NIIT is a leading Global Talent Development Corporation, building skilled manpower pool for global industry requirements. The company which was set up in 1981, to help the nascent IT industry overcome its human resource challenges, has today grown to be amongst worlds leading talent development companies offering learning solutions to Individuals, Enterprises and Institutions across 40 countries. NIITs training solutions in IT, Business Process Outsourcing, Banking, Finance and Insurance, Executive Management Education, and Communication and Professional Life Skills, touch five million learners every year. NIITs expertise in learning content development, training delivery and education process management make it the most preferred training partner, worldwide. Research-based Innovation, a key driver at NIIT, has enabled the organization to develop programs and curricula that use cutting-edge instructional design methodologies and training delivery. NIITs Individual Learning Business offerings include industryendorsed programs for students seeking careers in IT - GNIIT, Edgeineers and Global Net Plus for IT professionals.
Page
19
Even big corporate houses have entered the coaching industry field to meet rising aspirations of youngsters. Industry experts say coaching institutions imparting only engineering ducation to make ways for Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) inlead metropolis collectively earn an annual turnover of Rs 10,000crore per annum from nearly six lakh aspirants that appear for these exams. Several coaching centres cater purely to the demand for the highly-competitive entrance exams, for medical, engineering and management courses. There are specialised coaching classes for the civil services and defence services exams too. Hundreds of institutions and coaching centres in cities across the country prepare students for taking Sat, Gre and other
preparing for the board exams have seen maximum growth in recent times. Coaching
Page
20
examinations for studying abroad. Tutorials and coaching classes for school students
classes are popular because they are cheaper and more affordable than private tuitions.
4.2.2 SEGMENTATION Market can be segmented in three broad categories: Subject/ concept-based tuitions catering to K12 and HE segments (estimated at $5.1bn) Graduation test preparation market ($1.1bn) Post Graduation test prep market (~$220m)
Players are also looking to provide coaching through online media a model quite popular in the global markets, especially developed ones. However, the model would take time to evolve in India given the negligible broadband connectivity (< 1%).
16.90% 3.40%
Grad test prep - Based on application of concept Post grad test prep - Aptitude based
Figure 4
TUTION MARKET: At $5.1bn, the tuitions market forms 80% of the coaching class opportunity and
is inherently difficult to scale. A highly fragmented market, the business is personcentric and individual
Page
21
teachers attached to schools/ colleges are much in demand. For exams held on a national level (10th, 12th and university exams at tertiary level), our interactions with industry players throw up instances of students moving enmasse to another coaching class, to follow the brand-teacher who has joined a particular institute. Thus, crowd-pulling ability in this segment rests with brandteachers (especially attached to schools/ colleges) and not brand-institutes. This, in turn, translates into lack of stability and scalability for coaching classes.
GRAD TEST PREP MARKET: The test prep market for entry into a graduation course is dominated
by the engineering segment (IIT-JEE, AIEEE and CET market together form 60% of the segment), followed by the next most-coveted profession of medical services (~23%).In the past, the eligibility criteria for a few HE professional courses have been seen to change with new political parties assuming office. For example, admissions to these courses could be based on the score/ marks secured in 12th grade exams or aspirants could have to take AIEEE and CET entrance tests depending on the preference of the incumbent state government. This presents a key risk to coaching class players operating within the segment as when admissions are based on the merit list of 12 grade, coaching for AIEEE and CET is
th
rendered redundant. On the other hand, IIT-JEE market players do not face this risk as entrance exams are always conducted on a national level.
POST GRAD TEST PREP MARKET: Apart from being held at a national level, the entrance tests of these courses are more aptitude-based. Thus, this category of coaching classes has relatively lower dependence on individuals, and higher focus on standardized content and study material (a key differentiator). With ~300,000 applicants every year, the market is dominated by CAT aspirants (market at $90m).
Page
22
4.2.3 COMPETITIORS
COMPANY
HISTORY
CURRENT NETWORK
65 Study Centres
Started in 1991
BUSINESS MODEL Strong focus on AIPMT , IIT-JEE/ AIEEE, NTSE and CBSE Strong focus on IIT-JEE/ AIEEE, NTSE and CBSE Strong focus on IIT-JEE, AIPMT and IAS Strong focus on AIPMT , IIT-JEE/ AIEEE Focus on IIT-JEE entrance test Strong focus on AIPMT , IIT-JEE/ AIEEE Strong focus on AIPMT , IIT-JEE/ AIEEE, BITSAT, NTSE, KVPY, CBSE
Started in 1992
54 Study Centres
Started in 1998
32 Study Centres
Started in 2000
17 Study Centres
Started in 1991
23 Study Centres
Started in 1998
8 Study Centres
Started in 2001
13 Cities
Page
23
4.2.4 COMPETITION ANALYSIS The education industry in Delhi/NCR region is flooded with various institutes and coaching centres. The major players in this industry are FIITJEE, BRILLIANT TUTORIALS, AKASH INSTITUTE, VIDYA MANDIR CLASSES AND NARAYANA CLASSES. The other small players are TOPPERS, GUIDENCE CLASSES, RESONANCE, VIDYA VIHAR CLASSES AND NEW HORIZON (IIT STUDY CIRCLE AND KH CLASSES). The following analysis focuses on the strengths and weaknesses of some of leading institutes.
FIITJEE: Fiitjee is the biggest institute in this industry that was established in the year 1992 by Mr. D.K. Goyal, a B.Tech from IIT Delhi and thereby professionalised this industry. Since its establishment it has opened its centres all over India in various cities and has produced excellent results over the years. Its first centre was opened at Kalu Sarai in Delhi. STRENGTHS First mover advantage: Fiitjee began at a time when there were no other established players in this industry. This helped it to easily attract a lot of students by doing aggressive marketing and advertising. Innovative strategies: Fiitjee always comes up with some or the other innovative programs that help it to differentiate it from others. Recently they launched Faculty training programs in which they recruit faculties and groom them according to their own standard procedures. This is done to maintain a certain level of standardisation for the faculty and coaching. Established Brand name: Fiitjees name has become almost synonymous with engineering entrance preparation. They were able to achieve this by making huge investments in advertising in their initial stages. This led to a change in the perception of the consumers about this company and a brand was formed.
Page
24
Pinnacle programs: Through its Pinnacle programs Fiitjee has made tie-ups with several
Corporate support: QInvest , Qatars largest investment bank has bought a stake a in Fiitjee. This move is support to fund Fiitjees expansion plans in the middle east market. IPO launch: Recently Fiitjee has planned to come with an IPO to fund its investments. The launch of IPO will further boost its brand image. National presence over a period: Fiitjee has its centre present in almost every major city in India. Developing a vertical: Fiitjee has also entered into different businesses apart from the education industry.
WEAKNESS High fees: Fiitjees biggest weakness is its fee structure. Its charges very high fees for its courses as compared to its competitors. Thus it fails to capture the consumers present at the middle and bottom level of the income range. Focuses only on engineering industry: Fiitjee can easily use its brand image, resources and wide spread network to enter into the medical and commerce industry as well but it focuses only on the engineering industry.
BRILLAINT TUTORIALS The other big institute of this industry is Brilliant Tutorials. Established in 2002, it also has a widespread network with its centres all over the country. It began in Chennai with its Classroom programs. STRENGTHS 40 yrs old correspondence: Brilliant Tutorials has one of the best correspondence structures. Its model for correspondence is followed by many other institutes. Nationally known brand: Its presence all over the country has helped it to establish an excellent Brand name. Excellent study material: Brilliants study material is considered to be one of the best in this industry.
research on how much actual time is required to effectively conduct these courses
Page
other classroom courses. The number of hours has been arrived at after specialized
25
More classroom hours per course: Brilliant's courses have more course hours than most
National level test series: It is renowned for its excellent quality of national level test series.
WEAKNESSES It has been very slow in expanding while its competitors who started late have developed more centres. Despite its excellent faculty, study material and infrastructure it has always failed to project itself a national leader.
AKASH INSTITUTE Akash Institute was started by Mr.J.C Chaudhury about 20 years ago. Today Aakash brand has become synonymous with quality coaching for Medical and Engineering entrance exams. It has got a country-wide network of over 45 centres across India, collective annual student base of more than 25,000 students every year and above all, trust of millions of parents, has made us a household name for focused and quality coaching.
STRENGTHS Market leader for medical in north India: It is market leader in the entire northern region with maximum number of branches. Its results have been the best for the past many years. Own branches and franchisees: It has its own branches and as well as franchisees all over the country unlike other institutes. Highly qualified and trained teachers:. We conduct campus recruitment for teachers from top Institutes/Universities like IIT Delhi, IIT-Roorkee, IIT-BHU, Delhi University & other state engineering colleges & Universities. Additionally, we hire top quality teachers from market. Each and every candidate for teaching is selected through a rigorous process, where we first take a written test, followed by demonstration lecture with HOD and then final personal interview with the Managing Director.
Page
26
Integrated approach of teaching, which not only prepares students for entrance exams but
Work culture, which creates a hub of entrepreneurs and not just bunch of employees. Everyone owns his/her job and produces best to his/her ability. Strategically located centres for convenience of students & parents. A network of 45 centres across India. Brilliant initiative like online tests, attendance reporting and test score reporting through SMS, email etc Excellent management team: It has an excellent professional team within its
organization. Its networking model is followed by many others and its follows an excellent hierarchy as well. Presence in both engineering and medical industry: Unlike Akash there are very few institutes that have a presence in both medical and engineering industry.
WEAKNESSES Initially it had started IITJEE courses but had to shut it down later as it was unable to match the industry standards. This created a negative impact on its brand image.
VIDYA MANDIR CLASSES (VMC) VMC is an established brand in the Delhi/NCR region. Over the years, the name of Vidyamandir Classes (VMC) has become synonymous with success in IIT JEE. Vidyamandir has over the years designed, delivered, perfected and innovated the art and science of teaching and guiding students for entrance exam for the IITs. The fact that more than 10,000 students appeared for the VMC Test for the limited seats on offer in 2010, is ample testimony to VMC's popularity and credence within the IIT JEE aspirants' community.
STRENGTHS Established brand name: VMC classes, established in 1990, with over 20 years of presence has created a brand image that is unmatched. VSAT Classroom: It conducts satellite classes across 18 centres all over India and is the
User friendly website: VMC offers a very user friendly website with a provision for live chat between the students and the faculty members.
Page
27
WEAKNESSES Trains only refined students: Out of 12000 students that take up its exam every year it enrols only 250 students. Thus it cannot be solely created for its results as it trains only the cream students in its classes. Low conversion rate: Even after selecting the cream layer of students for its various batches, its conversion rate i.e. selections to batch size ratio is only around 60%. Fixed set of faculty: With a fixed set of 3 faculties only, the teacher to student ratio is low. Only for IIT: Does not focus at all on other entrance exams like AIEEE etc. Also it does not provide coaching for medical or commerce streams.
NARAYANA The institute of Narayana Coaching Centre was established in the year 1979 as a coaching institute for aspirants of state level entrance exams. It was the visionary zeal of founder chairman Dr. P. Narayana, a gold medallist and renowned academician that led to the setting up of a coaching centre in Nellore, Andhra Pradesh, which was the precursor for the Narayana Group. In 2004 two centres for IIT-JEE training were opened at Kalu Sarai and Punjabi Bagh and two for PMT & AIEEE /DCE training at Janakpuri and South Extension. The following year, centres at Mayur Vihar for IIT-JEE & Rohini for PMT/AIEEE/DCE came up. In the next year Noida, Faridabad & Gurgaon centres followed.
STRENGHTS Maximum enrolments: Every year Narayana trains around 1,75,000 students all over the country. No other institutes has as many registered students. Hostel accommodation: There are PG accommodations available in the nearby areas, where Narayana IIT Academy centres are located and they provide separate
Page
28
accommodation for girls and boys. Thus, appropriate assistance may be provided in
Micro Level Analysis: This computerised, question-wise analysis will highlight the weak as well as the strong areas in the student's learning. It will point the way to effective preparation in the future and will tell the student which topic and subject requires greater attention. For every question in the objective-type test, the student will be informed the percentage of students appearing in the examination, those that attempted the question and what percentage of them solved it correctly
Macro Level Analysis: This will compare the student's performance with other students across the country. It will indicate his/her overall position as well as subject-wise position amongst all the students participating across India. We will give the students their subject-wise marks, total marks, subject-wise ranks, overall rank, subject-wise percentiles and overall percentile.
Online test series: Narayana is one of the very few institutes to provide inline test series to its students.
WEAKNESSES It started with a focus on engineering entrance coaching, but then diversified to medical exams as well, but has not been able to deliver the quality of coaching for medical exams as it provides for IIT and AIEEE.
4.2.5 CHALLENGES THE COACHING INDUSTRY FACES The challenges faced by coaching institutes now-a-days are A) INCREASING COMPETETION Because of increasing attractiveness in terms of money and market share in education industry of this sector many companies are entering into this market and many more are prospective entrants. For example Educomp has also entered in this market with its new various programmes like Smart classes and Edureach. B) CHANGE IN ENTRANCE TEST PATTERN Very frequent changes in test patterns and formats for various competitive exams also poses a great challenge to coaching industry. For example in 2006 pattern for IIT-JEE changed suddenly from 2 stage exam i.e Screening Phase and Second Phase to one time exam of 3 papers of 2 hours each in one day. This kind of sudden change requires
Page
29
immediate changes in teaching style which requires proper training and involves corresponding cost. Here time factor also comes into picture as time is also consumed in training the faculty again to teach according to the new pattern of exam.
C) PERSON CENTRIC APPROACH About 80% of the market is dominated by private tuitions which is highly dependent on reputed local teachers. So onus lies on the faculty only and their way of teaching so it is completely a person centric approach. And that is where challenge lies for the industry as faculties are the only drivers to the whole coaching industry and the success and results are dependent on the faculty only.
D) LACK OF GOVERNMENT AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTION SUPPORT When we talk about formal education system, It has got enough financial support from government as government has take many initiatives like Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan so as to provide children with required formal education free of cost. But when it comes to Nonformal education like coaching Institutes, it has got no financial support from government or any financial institution which poses a great challenge to coaching industry as a whole as all the costs have to be incurred by the company or coaching institute itself so risk involved is high. 4.2.6 KEY DRIVERS An analysis of drivers explain factors contributing to the growth of coaching class market based on high teacher-pupil ratio in schools, increase propensity to spend among parents on childs education, growth in double income nuclear families and favourable demographics, increasing competition at graduate and post graduate level and rising aspirants for foreign degrees. The key challenges identified include low scalability of private tuitions market, lack of government and financial aid, change in entrance test pattern and lack of faculty and funds for education. The key drivers for this industry are:
Poor quality institutions and a score-centric exam system fuelling growth of coaching class market
Page
30
Shortage of quality formal education institutes is increasing competition for admissions at graduate and post graduate level High propensity to spend on education and growth in double income families are further driving the industry High teacher pupil ratio in schools urges the students to look towards alternatives
4.2.7 TRENDS The key trends identified include increase in PE/VC investments, diversification of coaching institutes into mainstream education, increase in demand for online tutoring and correspondence coaching materials. Key trends of this industry are:
Coaching Institutes are entering mainstream education and opening pre-schools,K12 schools,B-schools and vocational training institutes.
PE/VC firms have started showing interest in the education sector including by Helix Investments ($12m for a 30% stake in Mahesh Tutorials), Gaja Capital ($8.3m in Career Launcher), Lightspeed Venture Partners and Sequioa Capital ($30m in Tutor Vista in three rounds).
Now there is increase in demand for online tutoring in domestic market. The phenomenon of online tutoring is very new in India. With ~3m broadband connections (less than 1% penetration), India is way behind the global average. In the coming few years, penetration is expected to double as the national Broadband and Wireless Policy targets to bring 25m subscribers to the broadband fold by 2012.Players like Tutor Vista that have a pure online model in the US are looking to follow a hybrid model in India to tap the potential in this segment.
Page
31
Page
32
School Seminars This is the predominant form of marketing followed at IITSC where the faculty conducts a workshop in schools for classes XI and XII Canopy Marketing Canopies are a major marketing technique for institutes in the coaching industry and IITSC too has its canopies strategically located at Vikaspuri and Punjabi Bagh along with a dedicated canopy team. Tele-Calling This is one of the major ways of creating brand awareness as prospective customers are made aware of IITSCs background and offerings over the telephone. It is a very cheap and effective system. Others There are several other indirect techniques such as Print Advertisements , Banners , Pamphlets etc.
IITSC faces stiff competition from the small players of the coaching industry as the follow the principle of aggressive pricing which sometimes becomes unviable for the organization.
When a brand in general gives the consumer more confidence in his choice this is even more important for services. Their quality and other features are more difficult to asses. Because of their intangibility and complexity it is harder for the customer to distinguish between the offers from the wide range of service companies operating in the market place.
Page
33
Figure 5
The mantra in question is the 4-M approach. This mantra breaks down the process of service brand management into managing of 4 specific attributes. This makes the planning, implementing and evaluation of any marketing scheme relatively simple and straightforward. The 4-M approach centers on the 4 basic elements that a service provider must manage for branding services effectively. In a nutshell the 4-M approach involves 1. Managing Egos- People always react negatively when they perceive a threat. Also, research has shown that more than the physical threat; it is threat to ones sense of selfones ego that elicits the most negative response. Thus managing egos is important in maintaining healthy and positive relationships with the companys customers-both internal as well as the external. Only if the internal customers (employees) feel safe and do not perceive any threat to their egos, will they provide superior service to the external customers. 2. Managing Perceptions- Brands are not static but are continuously evolving and changing with changing customer perceptions. Thus, a brand is not simply the promise of
Page
34
said quality but is in fact a manifestation of consumer perceptions of that promisewhether they see it as useful or not, truthful or not, consistent or not etc. Thus, managing perceptions of both internal and external customers is crucial in branding services. 3. Managing Attitudes- What people think about you matters! In any service, people are the walking billboards of the company. As primary service providers they interact with customers directly to deliver the service. What they think about the company is invariably reflected in the service they deliver. Thus, managing their opinions is critical in branding services. Also, each satisfied customer can direct another ten prospects towards your service. This word-of mouth publicity which is unique to the service industry can only be leveraged if your customers think highly of you as a service provider. 4. Managing Awareness- Goods have the advantage of ocular presence and physical existence. This tangibility helps consumers to first experience the product through the various senses, build a perception about the same and then decide to buy or not. However, in the case of services, the intangibility of the service causes the customer to buy the product and then decide whether it appealed to their senses or not. Branding services therefore becomes extremely tricky since there are very few ways of creating brand awareness and conveying the brand promise to the customers. Nevertheless, managing service awareness, though challenging can be achieved using physical evidence and media. Physical evidence refers to the material touch and feel factors that accompany the service and these are important in conveying the brand promise to the customers. Media on the other hand, is extremely useful in branding services by creating brand awareness.
that is depicted by the brand. It is up to the people to give the processes more reliability and thus to assure a higher homogeneity between the quality of the service and the personality and
Page
35
The careful selection and training of staff firstly assures a higher level of quality of the service,
message of the brand. Furthermore people have contact with the customer. They have to be aware of the brands objectives so that they can live them and communicate them to the customer. It is not enough to communicate the message of the brand externally to the customer; the first step has to be internal communication.
Figure 6
Here the principles of internal marketing play an important role. Staff is seen as the first customer of the brand. The theme here is that the customer not only receives the message from the companies external marketing activities, but also the message from the behaviour of the staff he has contact with. The impression the customer gets from the service, from the company and thus from the personality of the corporate brand is also influenced by the friendliness and responsiveness of staff, their perceived qualification and how the staff lives the philosophy of the corporate brand. The element of physical evidence is about the environment in which the service is offered and consumed, it is about the customers feelings. As for branding services, the physical evidence is closely related to the personality of the brand, which can be described as an emotional bond to the customer that grows out of the perceived characteristics of the brand. To give the service a
Page
can relate to the service provider. This can be achieved by the use of corporate brand signs,
36
corporate colours and several other themes that are common for all outlets, all employees everywhere the company presents itself to the public.
Processes are very important in services industries since in most cases the customer is directly involved in the processes. Aspects that are important are extremely high quality, confidentiality, timing/availability, consistency and the avoidance of the abuse of insider knowledge. On the other hand, even if necessary, there are dangers in relating a brand to closely to the quality of processes. Poor quality in only one single case can affect the whole brand. Many of the professional services firms have faced the problem that one of their major clients went into bankruptcy or was accused for some illegal activity. We can see that the processes that deliver the service closely relate to consistency as one of the issues customers value in brands.
Solution:
School Presentation
Presentation at schools is a major branding activity for an educational institute like IIT Study Circle where there is direct interaction with the customer and brand awareness is created. The pitching of the brand at schools via presentations is very effective since the customer can be engrossed with all the details of the several processes followed at the institute. A two way
Page
37
communication is possible and the customer i.e the student can clear all his doubts and have a clear idea of the brand. The type of schools one selects guides the institute in positioning the brand and creating the desired brand image. The methodology followed during presentations cannot be the same for all schools but should vary according to the target audience. There are a few very reputed schools which are already in partnership with existing coaching centres (competitors of IIT Study Circle). To invade such a market stress should be laid more on the differentiating factors .More focus should be made on the additional features we offer that will give the student a greater thrust towards success. Also different schools with students of different income levels should be targeted using different principles. Students coming from lower income level families generally look at the costeffectiveness of the deal we offer whereas students from higher income families look more at the differentiation in services which are visible clearly.
Internet Marketing
With the advent of social networking websites such as facebook and twitter it has become very important that each and every organization has an active presence on these sites. Internet marketing is considered to be broad in scope because it not only refers to marketing on the Internet, but also includes marketing done via e-mail and wireless media. Digital customer data and electronic customer relationship management (ECRM) systems are also often grouped together under internet marketing. Internet marketing ties together the creative and technical aspects of the Internet, including design, development, advertising, and sales. Internet marketing also refers to the placement of media along many different stages of the customer engagement cycle through search engine marketing (SEM), search engine optimization (SEO),banner ads on specific websites, email marketing, and Web 2.0 strategies. IIT Study Circle is currently active on facebook , has a presence on youtube and is also using email as a form of internet marketing
Page
38
Page
39
Page
40
2. Title : Entrance examinations for science and technology Author: K. P. Mohana Link : http://www.ias.ac.in/currsci/25nov2010/1321.pdf Source: CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 99, NO. 10, 25 NOVEMBER 2010 Abstract : The history of the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) and the current state of their joint entrance examinations have an important lesson for higher education in science and technology. The IITs were originally created to produce a skilled workforce of scientists and engineers to support the economy and society of the newly independent India, and to represent Indias urges, India's future in the making. IIT Kharagpur, the first of the IITs, was set up in 1950. Over the next decade came four more, and together, the five IITs played a pivotal role in the growth of science and technology in the country. An IIT degree became a brand name, and IIT graduates came to enjoy high prestige among both the top employers in India and admission committees in the best universities in the world. Admission to an IIT developed into a middle-class Indians dream. One consequence was that IITs soon had to deal with hundreds of thousands of aspiring students. The calibre of students who make it into the IITs by subjecting themselves to the killing rigours of coaching factories in places like Kota and Hyderabad. The alumni seemed to conclude that these products of coaching factories who now form, according to Wikipedia, 95 per cent of students at IITs had a blinkered approach to education, did not recognize new ideas and had lost the spirit of inquiry and innovation. In short, elements that had built Brand IIT over the decades had now gone missing. Teaching and coaching (as is practised by the JEE coaching schools) are two different kinds of things. Even the best of coaching does not attempt to clarify concepts. It does not inculcate the spirit of inquiry. It does not train persons in starting from the first principles. Instead, it relies on pattern recognition. Do enough problems so that when you see a problem in the exam, you can recall the special trick, the special integrating factor, substitution or whatever required to obtain the answer.
Page
41
3. Title : Limited usefulness and relevance of coaching for competitive examinations Author: Y.K Gupta Source : CURRENT SCIENCE, VOL. 83, NO. 11, 10 DECEMBER 2002 Abstract : A few competent teachers are now making money from the coaching
institutes/colleges/schools run for the coaching of students for the competitive examinations for the entrance to Medical/Engineering Colleges. Such coaching schools have mushroomed in the towns of Northern India and probably elsewhere too. Barring some known and established institutions which provide coaching on a planned scale, most of them are run just as class-room teaching where the number of students may vary from ten to some two hundred in a class. Some institutions provide coaching by post and also serve as examining bodies to let the candidates know where they stand. The fees for established institutes for any type of coaching may vary from Rs 30,000 to Rs 50,000. For most of the coaching schools (incidentally good!), the fees may vary from Rs 3000 to Rs 10,000 for a package teaching of a student in a group for three days in a week spread over about six months. Parents in their eagerness to see their wards become engineers/doctors somehow manage to pay the high fees, send them to these coaching schools and consider their job to be over. The wards too in a rat race not to lag behind go to these colleges/schools just to satisfy themselves that they have taken the coaching. The two professions, Engineering and Medicine, are highly specialized and those who do not have a temperament to serve them with devotion, cannot be made to acquire the required attitude even by study and training. Our science management in higher education must make scientific service more respectable, lucrative, challenging and self-satisfying so as to stop the drain of the cream of scientific talent to the two professions.
Page
42
5.4 HYPOTHESIS
H1: All the factors determining the selection of an institute by a student for a 1 year program have the same mean H2: Fees that a student wants to pay is independent of the income group he belongs to. H3: All the factors determining the selection of an institute by a student for a 2 year program have the same mean H4: All the factors determining the reputation of level of services provided by IIT Study Circle have the same mean (ie. all have the same importance H5: The factor distance from home is given different levels of importance by different gender. H6: To determine the importance of an institutes location in its marketing strategy H7: Dependency of Brand Image of a coaching institute on quality of faculty, study material and past records
Page
43
The method adopted for Questionnaire Design were 1. Brainstorming The Questionnaire was designed after rigorous discussions. The questions were designed in such a manner that they cover every aspect of the research objective. Twenty Five parameters to assess the customer satisfaction level were identified. 2. Focused Group Discussions The management of IITSC and NHElite were involved in focused group discussions with us to frame the correct questions so that it would not be derogatory in any situation and we would get the desired data through disguised questions.
Page
44
5.9
TARGET POPULATION
Our target population included :- Students who take coaching from IIT Study Circle
Page
45
Figure 7
Page
46
2) QUALITY DISTRIBUTION
19% 22%
48%
Figure 8
The student composition at IIT Study Circle is mostly in the range of 6080% and therefore most of the students who are attracted to the centre are average in nature. Thus the company should bring out new policies to attract students of better quality .The perception of the consumer needs to be changed.
Page
47
13%
36%
51%
Figure 9
It can be observed that most of the students are from the family income group of 4-8 lac followed by less than 4 lac which is also quite a high percentage proving that high family income is not necessary for a student to take admission in a coaching centre. Rather it is the aspirations of the customer that drives the market
Page
48
Figure 10
It can clearly be seen that counselling at the centres is a prime component of the several marketing techniques which influences a potential consumer. Therefore other factors related to counselling at the centres should also be kept in mind as physical evidence and the quality of staff. The customer perception varies a lot if the infrastructure of a centre is of excellent quality
Page
49
2)
25
Figure 11
These are the ratings of students who avail the current services provided by IITSC and these show that students are quite satisfied with the services. From the graphs we also see that Other Value Added Services and Test Series have a certain room for improvement.
Page
50
3)
43 72
Faculty Past Record Word of Mouth Physical evidence Course Structure Fees
49
Figure 12
Faculty is the most important factor that a student considers before selecting an institute, followed by word of mouth and physical evidence.
Page
51
Analysis of variance (ANOVA) is a collection of statistical models, and their associated procedures, in which the observed variance in a particular variable is partitioned into components attributable to different sources of variation. In its simplest form ANOVA provides a statistical test of whether or not the means of several groups are all equal, and therefore generalizes t-test to more than two groups. Here the categorical variable can have more than two groups only and the other variable(s) has to be continuous. There are various models of ANOVA:-
1. One way ANOVA Here comparison of means of three or more independent groups can be done 2. ANCOVA Any ANOVA model with a covariate. 3. MANOVA Any ANOVA model with multiple DVs. Provides omnibus F and separate Fs. We will be testing various Hypothesis using ANOVA so as to check for the significant difference b/w means of the more than two groups on the basis of Test variable(s) as follows:-
Page
52
Hypothesis 1: All the factors determining the selection of an institute by a student for a 1 year program have the same mean Null : The different factors considered by a student before selecting an institute have the same mean ( 1= 2 = 3 = = n) Alternate : The different factors considered by a student before selecting an institute have the different mean ( 1 = 2 = 3 = = n)
Oneway Anova
Descriptives VAR00002 95% Confidence Interval for Std. N 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 Total 28 28 28 28 26 28 28 28 28 250 Mean 4.0000 3.7500 3.6429 3.3929 3.2308 3.6786 3.4286 3.0714 3.6429 3.5400 Deviation 1.01835 1.14261 1.12922 .83174 .81524 1.05597 1.16837 .94000 1.12922 1.05301 Std. Error .19245 .21593 .21340 .15718 .15988 .19956 .22080 .17764 .21340 .06660 Mean Lower Bound 3.6051 3.3069 3.2050 3.0703 2.9015 3.2691 2.9755 2.7069 3.2050 3.4088 Upper Bound 4.3949 4.1931 4.0807 3.7154 3.5601 4.0880 3.8816 3.4359 4.0807 3.6712 Minimum 2.00 1.00 1.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Maximum 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
Page
53
ANOVA VAR00002 Sum of Squares Between Groups Within Groups Total 17.877 258.223 276.100 df 8 241 249 Mean Square 2.235 1.071 F 2.086 Sig. .038
VAR000 VAR000 Mean Difference (I01 LSD 1.00 01 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 J) .25000 .35714 .60714 .76923
*
Std. Error .27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665
Sig. .367 .198 .029 .007 .246 .040 .001 .198 .367 .699 .198 .067 .796 .246 .015 .699
Lower Bound -.2950 -.1878 .0622 .2139 -.2235 .0265 .3836 -.1878 -.7950 -.4378 -.1878 -.0361 -.4735 -.2235 .1336 -.4378
Upper Bound .7950 .9021 1.1521 1.3246 .8664 1.1164 1.4735 .9021 .2950 .6521 .9021 1.0746 .6164 .8664 1.2235 .6521
.10714
Page
54
3.00
.27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .28192 .28192 .28192 .28192 .28192 .28192 .28192 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .27665
.198 .699 .367 .145 .897 .439 .040 1.000 .029 .198 .367 .566 .303 .897 .246 .367 .007 .067 .145 .566 .114 .484 .572 .145 .246 .796 .897 .303 .114 .367
-.9021 -.6521 -.2950 -.1432 -.5807 -.3307 .0265 -.5450 -1.1521 -.9021 -.7950 -.3932 -.8307 -.5807 -.2235 -.7950 -1.3246 -1.0746 -.9674 -.7174 -1.0031 -.7531 -.3960 -.9674 -.8664 -.6164 -.5092 -.2592 -.1075 -.2950
.1878 .4378 .7950 .9674 .5092 .7592 1.1164 .5450 -.0622 .1878 .2950 .7174 .2592 .5092 .8664 .2950 -.2139 .0361 .1432 .3932 .1075 .3575 .7147 .1432 .2235 .4735 .5807 .8307 1.0031 .7950
.00000 -.60714
*
4.00
5.00
-.51923 -.41209 -.16209 -.44780 -.19780 .15934 -.41209 -.32143 -.07143 .03571 .28571 .44780 .25000
6.00
Page
55
8.00 9.00 7.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 8.00 9.00 8.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 9.00 9.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 Tamhane 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00
.60714
.27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .27665 .28192 .27665 .27665 .27665 .28925 .28736 .24848 .25020 .27724
.029 .897 .040 .246 .439 .897 .484 .367 .198 .439 .001 .015 .040 .246 .572 .029 .198 .040 .198 .699 1.000 .367 .145 .897 .439 .040 1.000 1.000 .480 .115 1.000
.0622 -.5092 -1.1164 -.8664 -.7592 -.5092 -.3575 -.7950 -.1878 -.7592 -1.4735 -1.2235 -1.1164 -.8664 -.7147 -1.1521 -.9021 -1.1164 -.9021 -.6521 -.5450 -.2950 -.1432 -.5807 -.3307 .0265 -.7234 -.6098 -.2303 -.0749 -.6110
1.1521 .5807 -.0265 .2235 .3307 .5807 .7531 .2950 .9021 .3307 -.3836 -.1336 -.0265 .2235 .3960 -.0622 .1878 -.0265 .1878 .4378 .5450 .7950 .9674 .5092 .7592 1.1164 1.2234 1.3241
.03571 -.57143
*
-.32143 -.21429 .03571 .19780 -.25000 .35714 -.21429 -.92857 -.67857 -.57143
*
-.35714 -.57143
*
1.2538
Page
1.6134
56
1.4446
7.00 8.00 9.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 3.00 1.00 2.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 4.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 5.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 6.00
.57143 .92857
*
.29290 .26190 .28736 .28925 .30359 .26708 .26868 .29403 .30884 .27961 .30359 .28736 .30359 .26504 .26665 .29217 .30707 .27766 .30180 .24848 .26708 .26504 .22421 .25403 .27103 .23720 .26504 .25020 .26868 .26665 .22421 .25571
.876 .029 1.000 1.000 1.000 .999 .888 1.000 1.000 .494 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 .993 1.000 1.000 .806 1.000 .480 .999 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 .999 1.000 .115 .888 .993 1.000 .961
-.4145 .0475 -.6098 -1.2234 -.9138 -.5456 -.3895 -.9177 -.7172 -.2636 -.9138 -1.3241 -1.1281 -.6456 -.4895 -1.0185 -.8184 -.3640 -1.0149 -1.4446 -1.2599 -1.1456 -.5936 -1.1425 -.9525 -.4769 -1.1456 -1.6134 -1.4279 -1.3136 -.9178 -1.3111
1.5574 1.8096 1.3241 .7234 1.1281 1.2599 1.4279 1.0605 1.3600 1.6208 1.1281 .6098 .9138 1.1456 1.3136 .9471 1.2470 1.5068 1.0149 .2303 .5456 .6456 .9178 .5711 .8810 1.1197 .6456 .0749 .3895
.35714 -.25000 .10714 .35714 .51923 .07143 .32143 .67857 .10714 -.35714 -.10714 .25000 .41209 -.03571 .21429 .57143 .00000 -.60714 -.35714 -.25000 .16209 -.28571 -.03571 .32143 -.25000 -.76923 -.51923 -.41209 -.16209 -.44780
.5936 .4155
Page
57
.4895
7.00 8.00 9.00 6.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 7.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 8.00 9.00 8.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 9.00 9.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00
-.19780 .15934 -.41209 -.32143 -.07143 .03571 .28571 .44780 .25000 .60714 .03571 -.57143 -.32143 -.21429 .03571 .19780 -.25000 .35714 -.21429 -.92857
*
.27261 .23900 .26665 .27724 .29403 .29217 .25403 .25571 .29762 .26717 .29217 .29290 .30884 .30707 .27103 .27261 .29762 .28339 .30707 .26190 .27961 .27766 .23720 .23900 .26717 .28339 .27766 .28736 .30359 .30180 .26504 .26665
1.000 1.000 .993 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 .961 1.000 .628 1.000 .876 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 .029 .494 .806 .999 1.000 .628 1.000 .806 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 .993
-1.1203 -.6462 -1.3136 -1.2538 -1.0605 -.9471 -.5711 -.4155 -.7514 -.2920 -.9471 -1.5574 -1.3600 -1.2470 -.8810 -.7247 -1.2514 -.5982 -1.2470 -1.8096 -1.6208 -1.5068 -1.1197 -.9649 -1.5063 -1.3125 -1.5068 -1.3241 -1.1281 -1.0149 -.6456 -.4895
.7247 .9649 .4895 .6110 .9177 1.0185 1.1425 1.3111 1.2514 1.5063 1.0185 .4145 .7172 .8184 .9525 1.1203 .7514 1.3125 .8184 -.0475 .2636 .3640 .4769 .6462 .2920 .5982 .3640 .6098 .9138
-.67857 -.57143 -.32143 -.15934 -.60714 -.35714 -.57143 -.35714 -.10714 .00000 .25000 .41209
1.1456
1.3136
Page
58
1.0149
Homogeneous Subsets
Subset for alpha = 0.05 N 28 26 28 28 28 28 28 28 28 1 3.0714 3.2308 3.3929 3.4286 3.6429 3.6429 3.6786 3.7500 3.3929 3.4286 3.6429 3.6429 3.6786 3.7500 4.0000 2
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 27.763. b. The group sizes are unequal. The harmonic mean of the group sizes is used. Type I error levels are not guaranteed. c. Type 1/Type 2 Error Seriousness Ratio = 100.
Page
59
Means Plots
Since p value = .038 is less than = .05 therefore we can clearly say that null hypothesis is rejected and thus all the different means of the different factors such as faculty , word of mouth etc vary independently while determining the choice of a student. Therefore while evaluating and modifying these factors all of them cannot be clubbed under any single head and needs to be dealt with independently. From the homogeneous subsets we see that except faculty all other factors can be clubbed together as their mean lies in the same range. We can also see that except Course Structure and Brand Image all other factors can also be clubbed into another group.
Page
60
Hypothesis 2: Fees that a student wants to pay is independent of the income group he belongs to. Null: Fees that a student is wanting to pay is independent of the income group Alternate: Fees that a student is wanting to pay is dependent on the income group
Oneway Anova
Descriptives VAR00002 95% Confidence Interval for Mean N 1.00 2.00 3.00 Total 34 49 12 95 Mean 3.7353 3.4490 3.1667 3.5158 Std. Deviation 1.02422 .91427 .71774 .94377 Std. Error .17565 .13061 .20719 .09683 Lower Bound 3.3779 3.1864 2.7106 3.3235 Upper Bound 4.0927 3.7116 3.6227 3.7080 Minimum 1.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 Maximum 5.00 5.00 4.00 5.00
ANOVA VAR00002 Sum of Squares Between Groups Within Groups Total 3.320 80.407 83.726 df 2 92 94 Mean Square 1.660 .874 F 1.899 Sig. .156
Page
61
VAR000 VAR000 Mean Difference (I01 LSD 1.00 01 2.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 3.00 1.00 2.00 Tamhane 1.00 2.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 3.00 1.00 2.00 J) .28631 .56863 -.28631 .28231 -.56863 -.28231 .28631 .56863 -.28631 .28231 -.56863 -.28231 Std. Error .20867 .31391 .20867 .30111 .31391 .30111 .21889 .27163 .21889 .24492 .27163 .24492 Sig. .173 .073 .173 .351 .073 .351 .479 .131 .479 .598 .131 .598 Lower Bound -.1281 -.0548 -.7007 -.3157 -1.1921 -.8803 -.2500 -.1215 -.8226 -.3536 -1.2588 -.9183 Upper Bound .7007 1.1921 .1281 .8803 .0548 .3157 .8226 1.2588 .2500 .9183 .1215 .3536
Homogeneous Subsets
N 34 49
Page
62
12
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 22.530. b. The group sizes are unequal. The harmonic mean of the group sizes is used. Type I error levels are not guaranteed. c. Type 1/Type 2 Error Seriousness Ratio = 100. d. There are no homogeneous subsets for alpha = 0.05.
Means Plots
Page
63
Since the p value = .156 is greater than = .05 therefore we accept the null hypothesis. Thus we cannot certainly determine that fees is independent of income group but nowadays the trend is that parents are willing to spend heavily on a students higher education which may be one of the reasons for fees to be not dependent on income group
Hypothesis 3: All the factors determining the selection of an institute by a student for a 2 year program have the same mean Null : The different factors considered by a student before selecting an institute have the same mean ( 1= 2 = 3 = = n) Alternate : The different factors considered by a student before selecting an institute have the different mean ( 1 = 2 = 3 = = n)
Oneway Anova
Descriptives VAR00002 95% Confidence Interval for Mean N 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 Total 67 67 67 67 67 67 67 67 53 589 Mean 4.1045 3.5522 3.4776 3.4328 3.8657 3.4478 3.3582 3.3582 3.2830 3.5484 Std. Deviation .98680 .90927 .95914 .80197 .91941 .89245 .82941 .94871 1.18285 .96351 Std. Error .12056 .11109 .11718 .09798 .11232 .10903 .10133 .11590 .16248 .03970 Lower Bound 3.8638 3.3304 3.2437 3.2372 3.6414 3.2301 3.1559 3.1268 2.9570 3.4704 Upper Bound 4.3452 3.7740 3.7116 3.6285 4.0899 3.6654 3.5605 3.5896 3.6091 3.6264 Minimum 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Maximum 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
ANOVA VAR00002 Sum of Squares Between Groups Within Groups Total 37.952 507.919 545.871 df 8 580 588 Mean Square 4.744 .876 F 5.417 Sig. .000
Page
64
VAR000 VAR000 Mean Difference 01 Tukey HSD 1.00 01 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 3.00 1.00 2.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 (I-J) .55224 .62687 .67164
*
Std. Error .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168
Sig. .019 .004 .001 .866 .002 .000 .000 .000 .019 1.000 .998 .587 .999 .956 .956 .823 .004 1.000 1.000 .286 1.000 .998 .998
Lower Bound .0488 .1235 .1682 -.2646 .1533 .2429 .2429 .2858 -1.0556 -.4288 -.3840 -.8168 -.3989 -.3094 -.3094 -.2664 -1.1303 -.5780 -.4586 -.8915 -.4736 -.3840 -.3840
Upper Bound 1.0556 1.1303 1.1750 .7422 1.1601 1.2497 1.2497 1.3571 -.0488 .5780 .6228 .1900 .6079 .6974 .6974 .8048 -.1235 .4288 .5482 .1153
.6228 .6228
Page
65
.5333
9.00 4.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 5.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 6.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 7.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00
.19459 -.67164
*
.17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168
.969 .001 .998 1.000 .158 1.000 1.000 1.000 .994 .866 .587 .286 .158 .195 .046 .046 .021 .002 .999 1.000 1.000 .195 1.000 1.000 .989 .000 .956 .998 1.000 .046
-.3410 -1.1750 -.6228 -.5482 -.9362 -.5183 -.4288 -.4288 -.3858 -.7422 -.1900 -.1153 -.0706 -.0855 .0041 .0041 .0470 -1.1601 -.6079 -.5333 -.4885 -.9213 -.4139 -.4139 -.3709 -1.2497 -.6974 -.6228 -.5780 -1.0109
.7302 -.1682 .3840 .4586 .0706 .4885 .5780 .5780 .6854 .2646 .8168 .8915 .9362 .9213 1.0109 1.0109 1.1183 -.1533 .3989 .4736 .5183 .0855 .5930 .5930 .7004 -.2429 .3094 .3840 .4288 -.0041
-.11940 -.04478 -.43284 -.01493 .07463 .07463 .14982 -.23881 .31343 .38806 .43284 .41791 .50746 .50746 .58265 -.65672
*
Page
66
6.00 8.00 9.00 8.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 9.00 9.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 LSD 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 4.00 5.00
.16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168
1.000 1.000 1.000 .000 .956 .998 1.000 .046 1.000 1.000 1.000 .000 .823 .969 .994 .021 .989 1.000 1.000 .001 .000 .000 .140 .000 .000 .000 .000 .001 .645 .461 .053
-.5930 -.5034 -.4604 -1.2497 -.6974 -.6228 -.5780 -1.0109 -.5930 -.5034 -.4604 -1.3571 -.8048 -.7302 -.6854 -1.1183 -.7004 -.6108 -.6108 .2347 .3093 .3541 -.0787 .3392 .4287 .4287 .4836 -.8698 -.2429 -.1981 -.6310
.4139 .5034 .6108 -.2429 .3094 .3840 .4288 -.0041 .4139 .5034 .6108 -.2858 .2664 .3410 .3858 -.0470 .3709 .4604 .4604 .8698 .9444 .9892 .5564 .9743 1.0638 1.0638 1.1593 -.2347 .3922 .4370 .0041
Page
67
6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 3.00 1.00 2.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 4.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 5.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 6.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00
.16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168
.518 .231 .231 .118 .000 .645 .782 .017 .854 .461 .461 .258 .000 .461 .782 .008 .926 .645 .645 .384 .140 .053 .017 .008 .010 .002 .002 .001 .000 .518 .854 .926
-.2131 -.1235 -.1235 -.0687 -.9444 -.3922 -.2728 -.7056 -.2877 -.1981 -.1981 -.1433 -.9892 -.4370 -.3623 -.7504 -.3325 -.2429 -.2429 -.1881 -.5564 -.0041 .0705 .1153 .1004 .1899 .1899 .2448 -.9743 -.4220 -.3474 -.3026
.4220 .5116 .5116 .6071 -.3093 .2429 .3623 -.0705 .3474 .4370 .4370 .5325 -.3541 .1981 .2728 -.1153 .3026 .3922 .3922 .4877 .0787 .6310 .7056 .7504 .7355 .8250 .8250 .9205 -.3392
-.01493 .07463 .07463 .14982 -.23881 .31343 .38806 .43284 .41791 .50746 .50746 .58265 -.65672
* * * * * * *
-.02985 .01493
.2877 .3325
Page
68
-.10448
.2131
5.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 7.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 8.00 9.00 8.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 9.00 9.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 Tamhane 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00
-.41791
.16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .16168 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .17203 .16393 .16812 .15535 .16477
.010 .580 .580 .339 .000 .231 .461 .645 .002 .580 1.000 .662 .000 .231 .461 .645 .002 .580 1.000 .662 .000 .118 .258 .384 .001 .339 .662 .662 .035 .010 .001 .997
-.7355 -.2280 -.2280 -.1731 -1.0638 -.5116 -.4370 -.3922 -.8250 -.4071 -.3176 -.2627 -1.0638 -.5116 -.4370 -.3922 -.8250 -.4071 -.3176 -.2627 -1.1593 -.6071 -.5325 -.4877 -.9205 -.5026 -.4131 -.4131 .0180 .0790 .1650 -.2982
-.1004 .4071 .4071 .5026 -.4287 .1235 .1981 .2429 -.1899 .2280 .3176 .4131 -.4287 .1235 .1981 .2429 -.1899 .2280 .3176 .4131 -.4836 .0687 .1433 .1881 -.2448 .1731 .2627 .2627 1.0865
1.1783 .7758
.23881
Page
69
1.1747
6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 3.00 1.00 2.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 4.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 5.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00
* * * * *
.16255 .15748 .16723 .20232 .16393 .16146 .14812 .15798 .15565 .15036 .16054 .19682 .16812 .16146 .15274 .16232 .16006 .15491 .16482 .20032 .15535 .14812 .15274 .14905 .14658 .14095 .15177 .18973 .16477 .15798 .16232 .14905
.003 .000 .001 .003 .035 1.000 1.000 .838 1.000 1.000 1.000 .999 .010 1.000 1.000 .484 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 .001 1.000 1.000 .145 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 .997 .838 .484 .145
.1269 .2328 .2013 .1578 -1.0865 -.4516 -.3634 -.8282 -.4027 -.2960 -.3291 -.3775 -1.1747 -.6008 -.4533 -.9170 -.4918 -.3856 -.4177 -.4629 -1.1783 -.6022 -.5428 -.9187 -.4927 -.3847 -.4202 -.4753 -.7758 -.2014 -.1409 -.0531
1.1865 1.2598 1.2912 1.4851 -.0180 .6008 .6022 .2014 .6117 .6841 .7172 .9159 -.0790 .4516 .5428 .1409 .5515 .6244 .6565 .8521 -.1650 .3634 .4533 .0531 .4629 .5339 .5695 .7749 .2982
-.11940 -.04478 -.43284 -.01493 .07463 .07463 .14982 -.23881 .31343 .38806 .43284
.9170 .9187
Page
70
.8282
6.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 6.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 7.00 8.00 9.00 7.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 8.00 9.00 8.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 7.00 9.00 9.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00
.41791 .50746
*
.15654 .15128 .16140 .19752 .16255 .15565 .16006 .14658 .15654 .14885 .15913 .19567 .15748 .15036 .15491 .14095 .15128 .14885 .15395 .19148 .16723 .16054 .16482 .15177 .16140 .15913 .15395 .19958 .20232 .19682 .20032 .18973
.266 .037 .071 .134 .003 1.000 1.000 1.000 .266 1.000 1.000 1.000 .000 1.000 1.000 1.000 .037 1.000 1.000 1.000 .001 1.000 1.000 1.000 .071 1.000 1.000 1.000 .003 .999 1.000 1.000
-.0922 .0144 -.0185 -.0662 -1.1865 -.6117 -.5515 -.4629 -.9280 -.3955 -.4290 -.4784 -1.2598 -.6841 -.6244 -.5339 -1.0005 -.5746 -.5019 -.5552 -1.2912 -.7172 -.6565 -.5695 -1.0334 -.6081 -.5019 -.5800 -1.4851 -.9159 -.8521 -.7749
.9280 1.0005 1.0334 1.2315 -.1269 .4027 .4918 .4927 .0922 .5746 .6081 .8079 -.2328 .2960 .3856 .3847 -.0144 .3955 .5019 .7056 -.2013 .3291 .4177 .4202 .0185 .4290 .5019 .7304 -.1578
-.19459 -.14982
.4629 .4753
Page
71
-.26922
.3775
Homogeneous Subsets
Subset for alpha = 0.05 N 53 67 67 67 67 67 67 67 67 .782 53 67 67 67 67 67 67 67 67 3.2830 3.3582 3.3582 3.4328 3.4478 3.4776 3.5522 3.4776 3.5522 .053 1 3.2830 3.3582 3.3582 3.4328 3.4478 3.4776 3.5522 3.3582 3.3582 3.4328 3.4478 3.4776 3.5522 3.8657 3.8657 4.1045 .875 2 3
9.00 7.00 8.00 4.00 6.00 3.00 2.00 5.00 1.00 Sig.
Waller-Duncan
a,,b,,c
Page
4.1045
72
3.8657
3.8657
a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 65.090. b. The group sizes are unequal. The harmonic mean of the group sizes is used. Type I error levels are not guaranteed. c. Type 1/Type 2 Error Seriousness Ratio = 100.
As the p value = 0.00 is less than = .05 therefore we reject the null hypothesis and we can say that all the factors that determine a students selection of any particular institute do not have the same mean.
Page
73
Hypothesis 4: All the factors determining the reputation of level of services provided by IIT Study Circle have the same mean (ie. all have the same importance) Null: The different factors determining the reputation level of IIT Study Circle have the same mean ( 1= 2 = 3 = = n) Alternate: : The different factors determining the reputation level of IIT Study Circle have different mean ( 1 = 2 = 3 = = n)
Oneway Anova
Descriptives VAR00002 95% Confidence Interval for Mean Lower N 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 Total 95 95 95 95 95 95 570 Mean 3.2842 3.3263 3.2105 3.4737 3.1368 3.0105 3.2404 Std. Deviation 1.00703 .99405 .98817 .99832 .94092 1.00525 .99566 Std. Error .10332 .10199 .10138 .10243 .09654 .10314 .04170 Bound 3.0791 3.1238 3.0092 3.2703 2.9452 2.8057 3.1584 Upper Bound 3.4894 3.5288 3.4118 3.6771 3.3285 3.2153 3.3223 Minimum 1.00 1.00 2.00 2.00 1.00 1.00 1.00 Maximum 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00 5.00
ANOVA VAR00002 Sum of Squares Between Groups Within Groups Total 12.177 551.895 564.072 df 5 564 569 Mean Square 2.435 .979 F 2.489 Sig. .030
Page
74
VAR000 VAR000 Mean Difference (I01 LSD 1.00 01 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 3.00 1.00 2.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 4.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 5.00 6.00 5.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 J) -.04211 .07368 -.18947 .14737 .27368 .04211 .11579 -.14737 .18947 .31579
*
Std. Error .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353
Sig. .769 .608 .187 .305 .057 .769 .420 .305 .187 .028 .608 .420 .067 .608 .164 .187 .305 .067 .019 .001 .305 .187 .608
Lower Bound -.3240 -.2082 -.4714 -.1345 -.0082 -.2398 -.1661 -.4293 -.0924 .0339 -.3556 -.3977 -.5451 -.2082 -.0819 -.0924 -.1345 -.0188 .0549 .1812 -.4293 -.4714 -.3556
Upper Bound .2398 .3556 .0924 .4293 .5556 .3240 .3977 .1345 .4714 .5977 .2082 .1661 .0188 .3556 .4819 .4714 .4293 .5451 .6188 .7451 .1345 .0924 .2082
-.07368 -.11579 -.26316 .07368 .20000 .18947 .14737 .26316 .33684 .46316
*
Page
75
4.00 6.00 6.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 Tamhane 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 2.00 1.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 3.00 1.00 2.00 4.00 5.00 6.00 4.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 5.00 6.00 5.00 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00
-.33684
.14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14353 .14518 .14475 .14548 .14140 .14599 .14518 .14381 .14454 .14043 .14505 .14475 .14381 .14412 .13999 .14462 .14548 .14454 .14412 .14075 .14535 .14140 .14043 .13999 .14075
.019 .379 .057 .028 .164 .001 .379 1.000 1.000 .961 .995 .619 1.000 1.000 .996 .948 .374 1.000 1.000 .660 1.000 .937 .961 .996 .660 .235 .025 .995 .948 1.000 .235
-.6188 -.1556 -.5556 -.5977 -.4819 -.7451 -.4082 -.4726 -.3556 -.6209 -.2720 -.1592 -.3884 -.3107 -.5760 -.2270 -.1143 -.5030 -.5422 -.6905 -.3415 -.2289 -.2420 -.2813 -.1642 -.0806 .0321 -.5667 -.6059 -.4888 -.7543
-.0549 .4082 .0082 -.0339 .0819 -.1812 .1556 .3884 .5030 .2420 .5667 .7066 .4726 .5422 .2813 .6059 .7459 .3556 .3107 .1642 .4888 .6289 .6209 .5760 .6905 .7543 .8942 .2720 .2270
-.20000 -.46316
*
-.12632 -.04211 .07368 -.18947 .14737 .27368 .04211 .11579 -.14737 .18947 .31579 -.07368 -.11579 -.26316 .07368 .20000 .18947 .14737 .26316 .33684 .46316
*
Page
.0806
76
.3415
-.12632
Homogeneous Subsets
Subset for alpha = 0.05 N 95 95 95 95 95 95 1 3.0105 3.1368 3.2105 3.2842 3.3263 3.1368 3.2105 3.2842 3.3263 3.4737 2
Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed. a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 95.000. b. Type 1/Type 2 Error Seriousness Ratio = 100.
Means Plots
Page
77
Since p value is less than alpha null hypothesis is rejected and All the factors determining the reputation of level of services provided by IIT Study Circle have different mean i.e they vary independently
T-TEST The t-test assesses whether the means of two groups are statistically different from each other. This analysis is appropriate whenever you want to compare the means of two groups, and especially appropriate as the analysis for the posttest-only two-group randomized experimental design. There are a number of different types of t-tests available in SPSS. The two that
Page
78
independent-samples t-test, used when you want to compare the mean scores of two different groups of people or conditions; and paired-samples t-test, used when you want to compare the mean scores for the same group of people on two different occasions, or when you have
Here the categorical variable can have two groups only and the other variable has to be continuous. We will be testing various Hypothesis using t-test so as to check for the significant difference b/w means of the two groups on the basis of Test variable as follows:-
Hypothesis 5 : The factor distance from home is given different levels of importance by different gender.
Null: Reaction to the Distance from home factor is same in case of male and female. Alternate: Reaction to the Distance from home factor is different in case of male and female.
Two-sample T for male vs female male female N 69 26 Mean 3.28 4.000 StDev 1.14 0.849 SE Mean 0.14 0.17
Difference = mu male - mu female Estimate for difference: -0.725 95% CI for difference: (-1.156, -0.294) T-Test of difference = 0 (vs not =): T-Value = -3.36 DF = 60
P-Value = 0.001
Page
79
As p value = .001 is less than = .05 therefore we reject the null hypothesis and accept the alternate hypothesis ie. there is a difference between the way male and female react to the distance from home factor which is also established from the following graph. Hence it can be concluded that female students always consider distance of the coaching centre as a very important criteria .
Percentage of male and female giving importance to "Distance from home" factor
120 100 80 60 40 20 0 45
66
55
Male
Figure 13
Page
80
Hypothesis 6: To determine the importance of an institutes location in its marketing strategy Null: Location is not an important factor while selecting an institute therefore mean () for
location factor is <= 3 Alternate: Location is an important factor while selecting an institute therefore mean () for location factor is > 3 One-Sample Z: Location
Test of mu = 3 vs mu > 3 The assumed sigma = 0.5 Variable Location Variable Location N 95 Mean 3.3789 StDev 0.9360 Z 7.39 SE Mean 0.0513 P 0.000
Since p = 0.00 is less than = .05 thus null hypothesis is rejected. Thus we can conclude that location for a particular coaching centre is considered to be of prime importance by a student. A good location also gives additional boost to the sales of a coaching centre.
Hypothesis 7: Dependency of Brand Image of a coaching institute on quality of faculty, study material and past records Null: Brand Image of a coaching institute is dependent upon quality of faculty, study material and past records Alternate: Brand Image of a coaching institute is not dependent upon quality of faculty, study material and past records
Model Summary
Model 1
R .852a
R Square .726
Page
81
As R Square is .726 so coefficient of determination is .726 which implies 72.6% variation is accounted in Brand image by parameters like Study material and Quality of faculty.
ANOVAb Model 1 Regression Residual Total Sum of Squares 9.776 3.691 13.467 df 4 25 29 Mean Square 2.444 .148 F 16.554 Sig. .000a
a. Predictors: (Constant), Past Result, Study Material, Quality of Faculty b. Dependent Variable: Brand Image
As significance value is less than .05 so it can be proved that these factors when taken collectively do affect the dependent variable i.e Brand Image.
Coefficientsa Standardized Unstandardized Coefficients Model 1 (Constant) Study Material Quality of Faculty Past Result a. Dependent Variable: Brand Image B 1.349 .097 .021 .199 Std. Error .630 .087 .148 .093 .159 .209 .242 Coefficients Beta t 2.140 1.122 -.145 2.138 Sig. .042 .272 .006 .043
As depicted by Table above significance value of Quality Of Faculty and Past Record is less than .05 so these factors do have a significant impact on Brand Image and here we reject the Null Hypothesis.
Page
82
Page
83
4. From the analysis it was concluded that location is a very important factor that a student considers before selecting any institute. IITSC Vikaspuri suffers from poor location problem. Though it is strategically located beside the Janakpuri East Metro Station it does not occupy a space near the hub of all other Vikaspuri institutes. Due to this the daily walk-in queries at IITSC Vikaspuri have dropped by a huge percentage and is limited to a daily query of one only. Thus it needs to have its office at a place within the hub where all other institutes are located and thereby increase its visibility. Automatically the number of walk-ins will increase and the conversion percentage will go up. 5. The analysis also concluded that girls give an addition weight age to the distance from home factor rather than boys and thus special attention must be given to this point to attract more female students. Strategic centre locations along with proper travel facilities for students should be arranged. Currently cab facilities are available at IITSC Vikaspuri but the system is outsourced and is not reliable in nature. Female students on an overall are also hindered from joining coaching institutes because of all such safety reasons as indicated by the graphical demographic analysis that the number of male students opting for coaching in the education sector is much more than the number of girls. 6. The statistical analysis shows that the fees factor is not dependant on family income, This may be because that parents are willing to spend much more nowadays on educating a student and providing him the best facilities possible. Thus there is a huge potential that awaits to be tapped. 7. The brand name Shriram group carries a lot of weight. But this has not been leveraged to its fullest potential. Among IIT Study Circle and Knowledge Horizon, the Shriram Group stands out as the most powerful name. Almost every principal that we approached was aware of the Shriram group and its presence in the education sector 8. The brand equity of an institute does depend significantly on its history and past records. Thus for an institute which is starting out and wishes to become a reputed one must focus on slowly but steadily building a good record in terms of successful student selections in various competitive exams for which it offers coaching.
Page
84
8. CONCLUSION
Due to the recent breakup of the IITSC and VMC partnership IITSC requires a high degree of marketing for its immediate sales to increase. For the long run brand building and creating brand awareness is very necessary. The breakup in the tie-up has not been taken in good stride by all and the company has had to travel through several phases of turmoil. These stages are bound to come as the company is facing a situation similar to a startup when brand awareness is very low. The company needs to establish the IITSC brand for the long term. Another problem that needs to be looked into immediately is the cannibalization of the market share of IITSC by Knowledge Horizon classes. The boundaries between these two brands has not been set properly by the parent brand NHElite and thus these two brands are always at a conflict with each other. The course structure of these brands needs to be redefined and in case of some centres these two brands can also be merged. Keeping all the findings and recommendations in view IITSC has a very good prospect to succeed if a few of the organizational problems are solved with the management using a strong hand as the coaching industry has a huge prospect.
8.1 Limitations
The recommendations are limited to IITSC Vikaspuri only as the study has only been concentrated on that centre and may not be true for other IITSC centres Sample size is limited to 95 which may not lead to correct results in some cases during statistical analysis
Page
85
9. BIBLIOGRAPHY
http://indiacurrentaffairs.org/coaching-fee-unaffordable-for-most-midclass-households-study/ http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/rise-of-coaching-centres-the-parallel-educationindustry/279402/ http://www.zeenews.com/news453521.html
http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=305554 Marketing Research by NK Malhotra Marketing Research by Naresh Nagundkar www.nhindia.com http://books.google.co.in/books?hl=en&lr=&id=SatjBnj6iNAC&oi=fnd&pg=PR7&dq=E +learning+pedagogy&ots=oSbbP2jl9E&sig=eVD_8TZcSYCWGJCJxZXu9jXjVhA http://deposit.fernuni-hagen.de/1922/1/ZP_121.pdf#page=14 http://www.jstor.org/pss/747625
Page
86
10. APPENDIX
10.1 Questionnaire
1. Which school are you from ? * ______________________________________
2. Which Program have you enrolled for ? * 2 Year Program 1 Year Program ( 12th Studying) 1 Year Program (12th Pass Out)
3. What was your percentage in the last declared results ? * Less than 50 50-59 60-69 70-79 80-89 90-100
4. How do you rate the following factors which you might consider while selecting an institute ? * 1-- Least Important 5-- Most Important
Faculty Past Record Word of Mouth ( Friend , Family Opinion, Feedback from Seniors etc )
Page
87
Course Structure Fees Location Brand Name (Reputation) Distance from home
Poor
Average
Good
Very Good
Excellent
Quality of Study Material Infrastructure ( Classroom , Air Conditioner etc) Test Series Faculty Discipline Other Value Added Services
6. What type of marketing do you think has affected you more in your selection ? * You can choose multiple options !!
School Seminars
Page
88
Word of Mouth
Canopy Marketing Counseling at the center Print Advertisements ( Newspaper , Magazines) Banners/Hoardings Pamphlet Distributions
Name
__________________________________________
Gender ::
Male
Female
Family Income *
4 - 8 Lakh
Above 8 Lakh
89
institutes in India, affiliated to the Delhi University), Lady Shriram College (LSR; rated as one of the premier women colleges in India) and Shriram Institute for Industrial Research (SRI; an independent, self sustaining, not-for-profit multidisciplinary contract research institute conducting research and development in the areas of special significance to industry, government agencies and other organizations which is committed to develop, innovate, analyze and apply technology for products and processes). It has shown exemplary leadership in the national context by introducing some of the leading fortune 500 companies in India. To name a few, Toyota of Japan, Daewoo of Korea who have over the years set-up automobile manufacturing facility in joint venture with shriram group. Benetton of Italy, a well know brand in fashion arena was introduced in India by this group to reach great heights of popularity.
Started its operation in the year 1982 and since then it has steadily grown to become the largest provider of IT Trainings. New Horizons India Ltd.-a tie-up between New Horizons World Wide Inc., USA & Shriram Group of India. World-class facilities, specialist faculty, widest range of courses covering entire IT
New Horizons has employee strength of over 6000 with 350 centres comprising of over 2800 class rooms spread over 60 countries
Page
90
Each year imparts more than 3 million days of training worldwide through a variety of flexible training programs. New Horizons India Ltd has trained more than 500K+ people as a part of its capacity building initiative over the last few years.
NHElite is a joint venture between two globally renowned organizations; the Shriram Group and New Horizons Worldwide Limited.
IIT Study Circle It focuses on preparing students for IITJEE/AIEEE and other state level engineering entrance examinations. It has a formidable faculty panel of some of the most well-known names in the IITJEE coaching industry and a presence in over 19 locations across India Knowledge Horizon It focuses on school-integrated supplementary test prep education programs targeted at CBSE VIII - XII, NTSE and various Olympiads, CA-CPT, BBA/BBS, HM, CLAT, etc. It has a
Page
91
presence in over 23 locations across India and has academic associations with some of the most prestigious schools of the country.
Knowledge Horizon Chiron The latest brand introduced by NHELITE, is dedicated to preparing students for pre-medical entrance examinations.in AIPMT Preparation
Page
92