Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
RESEARCH ARTICLE
To determine the end point of wet granulation by measuring powder energies and thermal properties
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Apotex Inc on 03/13/12 For personal use only.
Arnold and Marie Schwartz College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences, Division of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Long Island University, Brooklyn, NY, USA and 2Covidien Research & Development Center, Webster Groves, MO, USA
Abstract Wet granulation has been widely used in pharmaceutical industry as a tablet manufacturing process. However, endpoint determination of wet granulation process has always remained a challenge. Many traditional methods are available for end-point determination, yet accuracy and reproducibility still remain a challenge. Microcrystalline cellulose, widely used as an excipient in pharmaceutical industry, was granulated using water. Wet mass was passed through sieve # 12 and dried till constant percentage loss on drying was obtained and dried granules were obtained. Wet and dried granules collected were subjected to basic flow energy, specific energy, bulk density, pressure drop, differential scanning calorimetry and effusivity measurements. Analysis of data revealed various stages of granule growth from initial seed formation by adding 200400 g of water, granule growth was observed by adding 600800 g of water and over wetting was observed at 1155 g of water. In this work, we have justified our work to properly identify and utilize this technique for practical purpose to correctly identify the end-point determination of microcrystalline cellulose and explain various principles underlying energies associated with powder and thermal measurements. Keywords: Wet granulation, microcrystalline cellulose, end point, effusivity, powder rheology, granules, differential scanning calorimetry, granulation, permeability, dry granulation
Introduction
Pharmaceutical industry runs under a number of regulations, which are imposed, by Food and Drug Administration and other regulatory authorities. So, it is very important to achieve and maintain quality required in the pharmaceutical field. Therefore manufacturing of consistent quality product requires an effective manufacturing and optimization of process. Tablets and capsules are most common and convenient solid oral dosage form. Wet granulation is commonly used technique in tablets and capsules. Wet granulation is a process of collecting particles together by creating bonds between them. When homogenous mix of components cannot be obtained by simply mixing the ingredients, it should be granulated prior to compression to assure an even distribution of the active compound in the final tablet. Though direct compression is cheaper method, it is not applicable to all formulations. End-point determination of wet granulation process has been a challenge for decades1,2.
It is very important to determine the quantity of water or binder solution required, as many of the tablet properties such as hardness, friability, disintegration time3, dissolution time4, compressibility and unit dose accuracy5 are affected by the granule properties68. End point in wet granulation is defined as a point at which formulator gets target particle size mean or distribution and at this point, granules follow the principle of Equifinality9. At this point, granules approach a state of dynamic equilibrium, while continuous addition would result in the collapse of liquid bridges and formation of wet mass. Microcrystalline cellulose (MCC) is widely used as an excipient in pharmaceuticals owing to its different characteristics based on different grades. Charges based on grades in terms of pre-formulation and formulation characteristics have noted previously10,11. Microcrystalline cellulose is a partially depolymerized cellulose containing many hydroxyl groups which form hydrogen bonds with neighboring chain12. Due to its
Address for Correspondence: Dr. Rutesh H. Dave, Ph.D., Division of Pharmaceutical Sciences, Long Island University, 75 Dekalb Avenue, Brooklyn, 11201, NY, USA. Tel: 718-488-1660. E-mail: rutesh.dave@liu.edu (Received 24 March 2011; revised 23 July 2011; accepted 25 July 2011)
439
440
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Apotex Inc on 03/13/12 For personal use only.
structure, MCC can absorb large amount of water and it enables to produce wet mass with different amounts of water. There are many methods reported in literature to characterize wet granulation end point using power consumption13, torque rheometer7, acoustic emission14, reaction torque7, application of artificial neural network15, near infra red spectroscopy16,17, focus beam reflectance measurements17, surface responses18 etc. These methods have their own limitations including reproducibility. Application of torque and force measurement for powder flowability has been reported in literature1921. These measurements provide important insight into the formation of granules. Effusivity measurements have been reported in literature as a process analytical technology (PAT) tool for determination of blend uniformity, for monitoring roller compaction process etc22,23. Thermal effusivity and power consumption have also been used as a PAT tool to determine the formation of wet granules24 and to optimize, monitor and control the fluid bed drying process25. The purpose of this study is to analyse energies associated in pharmaceutical powders with thermal properties and to establish an end-point determination using microcrystalline cellulose.
BFE measurement
A cylindrical vessel with a dimension of 50 160 mL was filled with respective materials and set on platform of the rheometer. To measure BFE, particular flow pattern was generated by downward anti-clock wise motion of 48-mm diameter twisted-blade at 100 mm/s tip speed and 5 helix angle, which resulted into relatively high stress flow mode in the powder and energy was calculated by work done during this downward traverse. The force-distance profile of the powder bed between 10 and 100 mm of the distance blade traveled was integrated for BFE calculation.
Energy consumed: dE = (T/(R tan ) + F ) dH
(1)
Where, R = Blade radius dH = Increment or decrement of vertical displacement = Helical path angle F = Axial force on the blade in Newtons (N) T = Torque acting on blade (Nm)
End-point determination 441 supplied at 10 mm/s constant velocity. PD across the powder bed was measured for applied normal stress and is represented by following equation. k = q m L/P where, = Permeability (cm2) = Air viscosity (Pas) (1.74 105 Pas) q = Air flow rate (cm/s) L = Length of powder bed (cm) P = Pressure drop across the powder bed (mbar) (2)
DSC analysis was performed using Q100 (TA Instruments, New Castle, DE) instruments with nitrogen (50 mL/min) as purge gas. The experiments were performed in hermetically sealed aluminum pans and the weight of each sample was 12 3 mg. Heating rate was 10C/min from 40200C. DSC was calibrated using Indium before start of experiments.
Effusivity measurements
Effusivity measurements were conducted using the thermal conductivity (TC) Probe (Mathis Instruments, Canada). Samples were placed in direct contact with probe and were as flat as possible to ensure maximum contact with the probe. The instrument detects interfacial heat flow from materials based on its heat capacity, density and thermal conductivity. Effusivity is also a function of thermal conductivity, density and heat capacity of a material, which is calculated using Equation (3). Effusivity = krCp Where, = Thermal conductivity (W/mK) = Density (kg/m3) Cp = Heat capacity (J/kgK) Apart from the above-mentioned samples in preparation of wet and dried granules, two additional experiments were performed to see the impact of water on wet granulation and were performed using 700 g of MCC 101 and adding 1691.6 2 g (70.76% w/w, 70 rpm) and 2376.5 g (77.25% w/w, 70 rpm) of water. After each experiment, approximately 23 g of total sample weight were collected from different locations and subjected to effusivity measurements. This data were not subjected to rheological measurements due to formation of over-wet mass, which hinders the movement of blades. After addition of water, wet masses were dried as mentioned above and further effusivity measurements were performed using dried granules. As was the case before, dried granules obtained by addition of 1155g or higher amounts of water, resulted in formation of heavy lumps which could not be used for effusivity measurements. Feasibility experiments were initially performed using 3 g of MCC 101 and adding equivalent %w/w of water only for effusivity measurements.
2012 Informa Healthcare USA, Inc.
(3)
Figure 1. Comparison of basic flow energy for wet and dried granules vs. addition of water.
442
R.H. Dave et al. after addition of 1155 g of water resulted into large mass of cohesive powder, which resulted in over-load to continue further measurements. BFE values are much less compared to the wet mass due to above-mentioned phenomena except when 200 g of water is added. This is due to the fact that 200 g addition of water is not sufficient to initiate granule formation and so after drying, the energy required to move the blade will be similar for wet and dried granules.
(Figure 3). These void spaces will act as a cushion to blade movement resulting in decrease of BFE values. Further, for dried granules we can see that initially from 200400 g of dried powder the formation of granules have not taken place due to more fines in the powder blends (Figure 4). For dried granules obtained after addition of 600800 g of water, increase in BFE values were observed, this is due to do formation of more granular particles and decrease in fines in powder. Dried granules obtained
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Apotex Inc on 03/13/12 For personal use only.
Figure 2. (A) Blade movement in non-cohesive particle; (B) Blade movement in cohesive particle.
Figure 3. Images of wet granules containing 200, 400, 600, 700, 800 and 1155 g of water.
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy
End-point determination 443 SE takes into consideration the energies and forces involved in formation of cohesive and adhesive attraction between particles. SE is measured during upward movement of blades in clock-wise direction and provides understanding between confined and nonconfined materials in which gravity also plays an important role. In Figure 5, for wet granules, we can see that as the addition of water increases, the material becomes cohesive and try to resist the movement of blade while the blade is moving in upward direction. A slight discrepancy is observed after addition of 600 g of water, after which further addition resulted in formation of wet mass giving rise to increase in SE. This is due to m1g < fcoh12 + fcoh13 (Figure 6) where fcoh denotes cohesion forces between like particles and mg is a gravitational force acting on a particle in which if the mass of the particle and gravity is less than the combined forces acting on a particle, it will tend to stick with other materials; however in opposite case, the particle is free to fall, as the forces acting on the particles are less than the combined mass and gravitational forces resulting in free flowing of material. In case of dried granules (Figure 5), we can see that due to formation of initial granules, less amount of material is on the blade resulting in similar values of SE from 600 g to 800 g points. However, in the beginning the SE decreases slightly due to uneven formation of granules resulting in weight variation to further produce decrease in SE. lower volumes. After initial granules formation, granules achieve more definite shape resulting in less voids and increase in BD.
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Apotex Inc on 03/13/12 For personal use only.
Figure 5. Comparison of specific energy of wet and dried granules vs. addition of water.
Figure 6. Forces between particles. fcoh, cohesion forces between like particles; mg, gravitational force acting on a particle.
Figure 7. Bulk density of wet and dried granules at various amount of water.
444
PD studies
As shown in Figure 8, for wet granules, the PD linearly declines after 200 g addition of water suggesting formation of granules. This suggests that formation of granules have started and with subsequent addition of water, they attain more granular form allowing the air to pass without resistance resulting in decreased PD. After 800 g addition of water, there is sudden increase in PD as over-wetting occurs. This erratic behavior at 1155 g of wet granules is due to the fact that material is highly over-wetted and as the air is trying to pass in-between the over-wetted mass, the pressure generated is highly variable. Another explanation is air, which is passing through bottom-up will have to change direction/or pass through more hindrance depending on the formation of lumps as the piston generates the pressure from top, which results in variation in location and amount of mass. In case of dried granules, PD decreases with the formation of better granules and offering least resistance at 700 g (0.04 mbar) and 800 g (0.05 mbar), suggesting that better granules are formed at this stage and least resistance is offered to the air passing through the powder bed.
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Apotex Inc on 03/13/12 For personal use only.
Figure 8. Pressure drop of wet and dried granules at various amount of water.
DSC
MCC 101 shows a typical polymer relaxation, which shifts towards right due to addition of water. As the amount of water increases, DSC showed an increasing trend in enthalpy30 and relaxation phenomenon decreases leading to formation of broader peak as shown in Figure 9. As mentioned previously, once MCC absorbs water to a certain point, it will start resisting intake of water and water will be present on the surface. This is clearly seen that at 1155 g of water, we see surface phenomena with as light bend in peak around 125C representing water on the surface.
Figure 9. DSC measurements of wet granules with addition of different amount of water.
Effusivity measurements
This measurement is critical in determining the end-point region for wet granulation. As effusivity is proportional to thermal conductivity, density and heat capacity, small increment in water content will generate change in effusivity values. Water has highest effusivity (~1600 Ws1/2/ m2K). Particle size also affects the density. Heat capacity also changes depending on water absorbed. A schematic representation is shown in Figure 10 (Chart type). As seen in Figure 11, as the amount of water increases, effusivity starts to increase in initial stage (0400 g), further addition of water (400800 g, optimum granule growth stage 700800) results in better granule growth after which any further addition (11551691.62 g) creates marked increase in effusivity which resulted in over-wetting of granules, after which it turns into slurry form (2376.5 g water). Critical step here is to identify the formation of proper granules by supporting data from rheometer; we see that, addition of 700 and 800 g of water results in ideal granule formation. Further increase in water (1155 g) content results in increased effusivity values. Once MCC 101 has absorbed enough water, further addition of water
(1691.92 and 2376.5 g) will result in water being on the surface of particle resulting in higher and constant effusivity, this value also corresponds to water effusivity, suggesting presence of water on surface of powder, analogous to the granulation optimization, utilizing torque measurement technique31. Another important consideration is similarity between feasibility studies and lab scale experiments. Due to equipments ability to be used as online PAT tool, it can be used to detect end point for granulation. In case of dried granules as seen in Figure 12, effusivity also decreases almost in linear fashion in initial stage (0400 g); this sudden decrease becomes smaller as granules have attained proper shape (600800 g). Effusivity at 700 and 800 g addition of water remains same, suggesting formation of ideal particles.
Conclusion
End-point determination for wet granulation always remains a challenge. There are many traditional methods are available for end-point determination, but they have their own limitation of reproducibility and accuracy.
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Apotex Inc on 03/13/12 For personal use only.
Figure 10. Schematic diagram explaining the effect of effusivity on granule formation.
In this study, we have attempted to develop a simple and practical approach to determine end point for wet granulation using MCC 101, characterized and differentiated between formations of various stages of granules. Incorporating effusivity measurements together with fundamental energies involved in powder can be a powerful, yet simple technique to measure the end point of wet granulation. Authors understand that further work is needed in terms of using different materials and binders.
Declarations of interest
The authors report no conflicts of interest.
References
Figure 11. Effusivity measurements of wet granules performed at feasibility scale and lab scale.
1. Miwa A, Yajima T, Itai S. (2000). Prediction of suitable amount of water addition for wet granulation. Int J Pharm, 195:8192. 2. Chirkot T. (2002). Scale-up and endpoint issues of pharmaceutical wet granulation in a V-type low shear granulator. Drug Dev Ind Pharm, 28:871888. 3. Zhao N, Augsburger LL. (2006). The influence of granulation on super disintegrant performance. Pharm Dev Technol, 11:4753. 4. Unvala H, Schwartz J, Schnaare R. (1988). The effect of the wet granulation process on drug dissolution. Drug Dev Ind Pharm, 14:13271349. 5. Mehrotra A, Chaudhuri B, Faqih A, Tomassone M, Muzzio F. (2009). A modeling approach for understanding effects of powder flow properties on tablet weight variability. Powder Technol, 188:295300. 6. Leuenberger H, Puchkov M, Krausbauer E, Betz G. (2009). Manufacturing pharmaceutical granules: Is the granulation end point a myth? Powder Technol, 189:141148. 7. Achanta AS. (1997). End point determination and its relevance to physicochemical characteristics of solid dosage forms. Drug Dev Ind Pharm, 23:539546. 8. Shiakura O, Yamada M, Hashimoto M, Ishimaru S, Takayama K, Nagai T. (1992). Effect of amount and composition of granulating solution on physical characteristics of tablets. Drug Dev Ind Pharm, 18:10991110.
446
Drug Development and Industrial Pharmacy Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Apotex Inc on 03/13/12 For personal use only.
9. Levin M. (1992). Wet granulation: End-point determination and scale-up. In: Swarbrick J, Ed. Encyclopedia of pharmaceutical technology. New York (USA): Marcel dekker Inc, 40784098. 10. Javadzadeh Y, Shariati H, Movahhed-Danesh E, Nokhodchi A. (2009). Effect of some commercial grades of microcrystalline cellulose on flowability, compressibility, and dissolution profile of piroxicam liquisolid compacts. Drug Dev Ind Pharm, 35:243251. 11. Aljaberi A, Chatterji A, Shah NH, Sandhu HK. (2009). Functional performance of silicified microcrystalline cellulose versus microcrystalline cellulose: A case study. Drug Dev Ind Pharm, 35:10661071. 12. Mihranyan A, Llagostera AP, Karmhag R, Strmme M, Ek R. (2004). Moisture sorption by cellulose powders of varying crystallinity. Int J Pharm, 269:433442. 13. Pepin X, Blanchon S, Couarraze G. (2001). Power consumption profiles in high-shear wet granulation. I: Liquid distribution in relation to powder and binder properties. J Pharm Sci, 90:322331. 14. Gamble JF, Dennis AB, Tobyn M. (2009). Monitoring and end-point prediction of a small scale wet granulation process using acoustic emission. Pharm Dev Technol, 14:299304. 15. Kachrimanis K, Karamyan V, Malamataris S. (2003). Artificial neural networks (ANNs) and modeling of powder flow. Int J Pharm, 250:1323. 16. Otsuka M, Mouri Y, Matsuda Y. (2003). Chemometric evaluation of pharmaceutical properties of antipyrine granules by near-infrared spectroscopy. AAPS PharmSciTech, 4:E47. 17. Frake P, Grierson SM, Hempenstall JM, Rudd DR. (1997). Process control and end point determination of a fluid bed granulation by application of near infra red spectroscopy. Int J Pharm, 151:7580. 18. Navaneethan CV, Missaghi S, Fassihi R. (2005). Application of powder rheometer to determine powder flow properties and lubrication efficiency of pharmaceutical particulate systems. AAPS PharmSciTech, 6:E398E404. 19. Freeman RE. (2004). Predicting flowability and characterizing powders. Pharm Technol Eur, 16:4143. 20. Staniforth JN, Baichwal AR, Hart JP, Heng WS. (1988). Effect of addition of water on the rheological and mechanical properties of microcrystalline cellulose. Int J Pharm, 41:231236.