TowardsaResultsBased CoreAgricultureSupportProgram

C.C.Yu ResultsManagementUnit 2526Oct2011

1

Agenda A d
BenefitsofaresultsbasedCASP Problem tree analysis Problemtreeanalysis Proposedresultsframeworkstructure p Needformonitoring Nextsteps

ManagingforDevelopmentResults Managing for Development Results

Decidebetter

Deliverresults

Demonstrate results

ResultsManagementCycle g y
Plan

Monitor & Evaluate

Development Outcomes

Budget

Implement p
4

ResultsBasedCASP:Benefits ResultsBased CASP: Benefits

Target right problems Targetrightproblems Allocateresourceswisely y Measureprogress&demonstrateresults Learnandimprove

ProblemTreeAnalysis(PTA) Problem Tree Analysis (PTA)

Serves as diagnostic tool Servesasdiagnostictool Identifiesacoredevelopmentproblem p p Analyzesrelatedproblems(effects)& constraints(causes) Visualizes the cause effect relationship in Visualizesthecauseeffectrelationshipin atreelikediagram
6

AnExampleofPTA

ApplyingPTAtoCASP:Effects
Ruralemployment andincome stagnant Exportofagro productshas Export of agroproducts has notrealizeditspotential Deforestation,loss ofbiodiversity,and contributionto contribution to climatechange Demandfordomestic energynotfullymet f ll

Domesticdemandfor livestocknotfullymet

Agriculturalproductionstagnant particularlyinremoteareas

AgroindustriesinGMSare underdevelopedandvulnerableto climatechangeandlanddegradation climate change and land degradation

ApplyingPTAtoCASP:Causes
Agro-industries in GMS are AgroindustriesinGMSare underdeveloped and vulnerable p underdevelopedandvulnerableto underdeveloped and vulnerable to to climate changes and land climatechangesandlanddegradation degradation

Pooraccessto export market exportmarket

Poorproducts qualitynotmeeting safetystandards

Lowyieldsand susceptibletonatural disasters

Tariff& iff & nontariff trade barriers

Transport constraints

Lowtechnology Low technology inputsandsmall scaleoperations

Heavyuseof H f waterand agrochemicals

Forestloss,poor Forest loss poor agriculturalpractices andovergrazing

TranslatingPTAtoResultsFramework Translating PTA to Results Framework

N t th t PTA i hi NotethatPTAisahierarchyofproblems, h f bl notimplicationsofsolutions Reversenegativestatementstoget resultsstatements lt t t t Include SMART indicators for each IncludeSMARTindicatorsforeach problem

10

GMSSectorOutcomes Sector S t Indicators I di Outcomes with Targetsand Baselines GMSagro industries aremore productive andresilient toenviron mental mental changes

GMSSectorOutputs Sector S t Outputs Indicators I di t with Incremental Targets g

CASPOperations Plannedand M i O t t Pl d d MainOutputs fromCASP OngoingCASP Interventions Interventions Planned: Planned:

Infrastructure andsystems supporting pp g GMSagro industries providedand improved i d

Ongoing

Ongoing

SectorResultsFramework

11

WhyMonitorResults? Why Monitor Results?

D id b Decidebetter Deliver results Deliverresults Demonstrateachievements

12

TooltoDecideBetter
Bangladesh,19732009
2.5

Energy

Improv vementin sectoroutcomes n

TransportandICT

1.5

Finance Health Industryandtrade Education Agricultureand nat resources

0.5 05

Watersupply& municipalinfra

0 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000

ADBcumulativeinvestment($ million)
13

NextSteps Next Steps

Bring key stakeholders together Bringkeystakeholderstogether inaworkshop C d t Conductproblemtreeanalysis bl t l i Developresultsframework p Agreeonmonitoring mechanisms h i

14