Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Institutionen fr
Signaler, Sensorer & System
10044 STOCKHOLM
ROYAL INSTITUTE
OF TECHNOLOGY
Instrumentation Laboratory Elektrisk mtteknik
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field Sensors
Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
by
Hans Sohlstrm
TRITA-ILA 93.01
S-10044 STOCKHOLM
Department of
Signals, Sensors & Systems
Fi bre Opti c Magneti c Fi eld Sensors
Uti li zi ng Iron Garnet Materi als
Thesis by
Hans Sohlst r m
Submit t ed t o t he School of Elect r ical Engineer ing,
Royal Inst it ut e of Technology
in par t ial fulfilment of t he r equir ement s for t he degr ee of
Doct or of Philosophy
TRITA-ILA 93.01
Second cor r ect ed pr int ing, Apr il 1993
Depar t ment of Signals, Sensor s & Syst ems
Inst r ument at ion Labor at or y
Royal Inst it ut e of Technology
S-10044 St ockholm
Sweden
V
Descriptors
YIG, ir on gar net s, r ar e ear t h gar net s, magnet o-opt ics, opt ical waveguide,
fibr e opt ic sensor s, magnet ic field measur ement , cur r ent measur ement .
Abst r act
This t hesis deals wit h t he subject of fibr e opt ic magnet ic field sensor s
ut ilizing ir on gar net mat er ials. Such mat er ials exhibit a lar ge Far aday
r ot at ion which make t hem advant ageous for applicat ion in compact mag-
net ic field sensor s.
Aft er an int r oduct ion, in which fibr e opt ic sensor s and opt ical met hods t o
mea sur e elect r ic cur r ent a r e r eviewed, t he or igina l r esea r ch wor k is
summar ized.
A syst em for t he measur ement of t he magnet o-opt ic pr oper t ies of t r ans-
par ent mat er ials is descr ibed. Measur ement r esult s, showing t he influence
of t emper at ur e, magnet ic field dir ect ion and sample t r eat ment on t he
magnet o-opt ical pr oper t ies of YIG-cr yst als, ar e pr esent ed. The pr oper t ies of
t hin ma gnet o-opt ica l wa veguiding films ha ve a lso been st udied using
differ ent light coupling met hods. Measur ement r esult s obt ained for holo-
gr a phic gr a t ing, pr ism a nd edge (end-fir e) light coupling t o differ ent
subst it ut ed YIG films ar e pr esent ed. It is shown t hat t he launching met hod
may affect t he pr oper t ies t o be measur ed.
The design and per for mance of sever al ver sions of ext r insic guided wave
fibr e opt ic magnet ic field sensor s ar e t hen r epor t ed. The sensor s employ
subst it ut ed YIG (Yt t r ium Ir on Gar net , Y
3
Fe
5
O
12
) t hin film waveguides as
sensing element s. Polar izat ion maint aining fibr es wer e used as feed and
r et ur n t o pr ovide t wo signal channels. The signals wer e combined in a
balanced measur ement syst em, pr oviding insensit ivit y t o bot h fluct uat ions
in opt ical power and loss. Sensor s have been made bot h wit h separ at e fibr es
t o guide t he light t o and fr om t he sensing element and wit h a single fibr e for
bot h funct ions. The t wo fibr e ver sion, alt hough less elegant , is found t o
have a bet t er per for mance. This ver sion also makes it possible t o det er mine
bot h t he magnit ude and sign of t he magnet ic field. Measur ement r esult s
indicat e a usable measur ement r ange of at least sever al mT wit h a noise
equivalent magnet ic field level of less t han 8nT/
Hz.
The design and per for mance of mult imode fibr e opt ic magnet ic field
sensor s ut ilizing t he Fa r a da y effect in a n epit a xia lly gr own t hick
(YbTbBi)IG film is also descr ibed. This t ype of sensor is found t o be linear
over a r ange fr om 27mT t o less t han 270nT. Sensor pr ot ot ypes suit able for
cur r ent monit or ing in high volt a ge t r a nsmission lines ha ve a lso been
developed.
VI
VII
List of publicat ions
This t hesis is based on t he wor k cont ained in t he following paper s:
A: U. Holm, H. Sohlst r m and T. Br ogr dh, Measur ement syst em for
magnet o-opt ic sensor mat er ials, J . Phys. E: S ci. Inst rum., vol. 17,
p. 885889, 1984.
B: U. Holm, H. Sohlst r m and T. Br ogr dh, YIG-sensor design for fibr e
opt ical magnet ic field measur ement , OFS 84, R. Th. Ker st en and
R. Kist , p. 333336, VDE-Ver lag, Ber lin, 1984.
C: U. Holm and H. Sohlst r m, Measurement of YIG crystal characteristics
for the design of optical magnetic field sensors, TR84.01, Inst r ument a -
t ion Labor at or y; Royal Inst it ut e of Technology, St ockholm, 1984.
D: H. Sohlst r m, U. Holm and K. Svant esson, A Polar izat ion Based Fibr e
Opt ical Sensor Syst em Using a YIG Opt ical Waveguide for Magnet ic
Field Sensing, S pringer proceedings in Physics 44: Opt ical Fiber
S ensors, H. J . Ar dit t y, J . P. Dakin, and R. Th. Ker st en, p. 273278,
Spr inger -Ver lag, Ber lin, 1989.
E: H. Sohlst r m, U. Holm and K. G. Svant esson, Char act er izat ion of
Magnet oopt ical Thin Films for Sensor Use, S PIE Proc Elect ro-Opt ic
and Magneto-Optic Materials and Applications, J . P. Cast er a, vol. 1126,
p. 7784, 1989.
F: K. Svant esson, H. Sohlst r m and U. Holm, Magnet o-opt ical gar net
mat er ials in fibr e opt ic sensor syst ems for magnet ic field sensing, S PIE
Proc Elect ro-Opt ic and Magnet o-Opt ic Mat erials and Applicat ions II,
H. Dammann, vol. 1274, p.260269, 1990.
G: H. Sohlst r m a nd K. Sva nt esson, A wa veguide ba sed fibr e opt ic
magnet ic field sensor wit h dir ect ional sensit ivit y, S PIE Proc Fiber
Opt ic S ensors: Engineering and Applicat ions, A. J . Br uinsma and
B. Culshaw, vol. 1511, p. 142148, 1991.
H: H. Sohlst r m and K. Svant esson, The per for mance of a fibr e opt ic
magnet ic field sensor ut ilizing a magnet o-opt ical gar net , Fiber and
Integrated Optics, vol. 11, p.137141, 1992, also pr esent ed at t he OFS8
confer ence in Mont er ey, J an. 92.
VIII
IX
Cont ent s
Abst r act ............................................................................................................. V
List of publicat ions ......................................................................................... VII
Cont ent s ........................................................................................................... IX
1. The aim and or ganizat ion of t he t hesis ........................................................ 1
2. Int r oduct ion ................................................................................................... 3
Fibr e opt ic sensor s .................................................................................. 3
Magnet ic field measur ement .................................................................. 7
Measur ement of elect r ic cur r ent ............................................................ 9
Opt ical met hods for magnet ic field and ................................................. 9
YIG ........................................................................................................ 18
3. St ar t ing point s for t he sensor development wor k ..................................... 22
4. Mat er ial char act er izat ion measur ement s .................................................. 24
Bulk mat er ials ...................................................................................... 24
Waveguides ........................................................................................... 30
5. Sensor s. ........................................................................................................ 35
Single-mode syst ems ............................................................................. 35
Mult imode syst ems ............................................................................... 41
6. Conclusions .................................................................................................. 45
7. Acknowledgement s ...................................................................................... 46
Refer ences ........................................................................................................ 47
Comment s on t he aut hor ship of t he paper s ................................................... 55
Paper abst r act s ................................................................................................ 56
Paper r epr int s .................................................................................................. 59
Paper A
Paper B
Paper C
Paper D
Paper E
Paper F
Paper G
Paper H
X
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
1
1. The aim and or ganizat ion of t he t hesis
The indust r ial development has cr eat ed a gr owing demand for new t ypes of
measur ement and t her efor e new t ypes of sensor s, t o enhance t he qualit y of
differ ent pr ocesses. The physical envir onment for t he sensor s has, at t he
same t ime, become t ougher and mor e elect r omagnet ically pollut ed.
To over come t he elect r omagnet ic pollut ion and also t o achieve ot her
a dva nt a ges, t her e ha s, st a r t ing in t he mid sevent ies, been a st ea dily
gr owing int er est in fibr e opt ic sensor s. Opt ical met hods have long been used
for measur ement pur poses, but t he t echnological base developed for fibr e
opt ic communicat ion applicat ions has widened t he scope consider ably. Fibr e
opt ic r emot e sensing syst ems, pr oviding immunit y t o elect r omagnet ic int er -
fer ence, elect r ical isolat ion and a number of ot her advant ages, could now be
developed.
The measur ement of magnet ic field or cur r ent in elect r ical power syst ems
ar e applicat ions in which t hese advant ages ar e ver y significant .
This t hesis is t o a lar ge ext ent based on wor k made as par t of t he Single
Mode Sensor Pr oject t hat was st ar t ed in 1981 as a co-oper at ive effor t by t he
I nst rument at ion Laborat ory of t he Royal I nst it ut e of Technology, t he
Institute of Microelectronics (IM) and t he Institute of Optical Research (IOF).
The pr oject was financed by t he Nat ional S wedish Board for Technical
Development (S TU).
The aim of t he pr oject was t o st udy t he applicabilit y of single mode
opt ical fibr e t echnology for sensor use. AS EA AB (now ABB), one of t he
pr oponent s of t he pr oject , ha d a t t ha t t ime developed a number of
mult imode fibr e opt ic sensor s. Par t ly because of t heir int er est t he develop-
ment of a magnet ic field or elect r ic cur r ent sensor was chosen as t he
wor king goal.
Most of t he elect r ic cur r ent sensor s developed at t hat t ime ut ilized t he
Far aday effect in long lengt hs of fibr e, coiled ar ound t he conduct or . The
difficult ies encount er ed wit h such sensor s led us t o st udy sensor s based on
localized sensing element s made fr om mat er ials having a lar ge Far aday
r ot at ion, e.g. YIG (Y
3
Fe
5
O
12
).
Dur ing t he ear ly st ages of t he pr oject wor k, polar izat ion maint aining
fibr es became available. We t hen r ecognized t he possibilit y of a syst em in
which polar isat ion maint aining fibr es wer e used t o car r y t he light t o and
fr om a sensing element in t he for m of a YIG waveguide.
St udies of mult imode sensor s using bulk YIG or t hick films of subst it ut ed
YIG , wer e also car r ied out . A number of such sensor s wer e developed for
differ ent applicat ions.
The aim of t his t hesis is t o st udy t he feasibilit y of magnet ic field sensor s
based on ir on gar net mat er ials. As bot h single-mode and mult imode sensor s
Hans S ohlstrm
2
Fig.1. A magnetic field sensor in the form of a waveguiding chip the idea
as envisioned during the initial stages of the project.
ar e t r eat ed, t he t hesis can also be said t o for m a compar ison of t he t wo
t ypes.
Measur ement t echnology is an applicat ion or ient ed r esear ch ar ea, and
t he st r ess in t his t hesis is on t he sensor development and t he mat er ial
char act er izat ion. The paper s on which t he t hesis is based descr ibe differ ent
aspect s of t he sensor development wor k, fr om t he init ial ideas t o wor king
sensor pr ot ot ypes. In t his summar y I will pr imar ily mot ivat e and discuss
t he wor k in or der t o give a cont ext t o t he differ ent paper s. For t his pur pose
t he summar y includes an int r oduct ion in which t he t heor y is out lined and
also some illust r at ive r esult s, t hat wer e omit t ed in t he paper s due t o t he
limit at ions of t he confer ence cont r ibut ion for mat . The int r oduct ion also
cont ains an over view of fibr e opt ic sensor s and cur r ent measur ement in
gener al. In sect ion 3, I t hen out line t he sensor development and t he r ole of
t he mat er ial char act er izat ion. The summar y of my wor k is given in sect ions
4 and 5. At t he end of each of t hese t wo sect ions r efer ences ar e given t o t he
differ ent paper s. Finally, in t he conclusion, I summar ize and speculat e
somewhat about t he implicat ions of t he r esult s.
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
3
2. Int r oduct ion
Fi bre opti c sensors
Defi ni t i ons
A fibre optic sensor consist s of an opt ical sensing element which under t he
influence of t he quant it y t o be measur ed modulat es light , and opt ical fibr es
t o guide t he light t o and fr om t he sensing element . When also t he sensing
element consist s of opt ical fibr es, t he sensor is intrinsic, and when t he fibr es
ar e only ut ilized t o guide t he light t o and fr om t he sensing element , which is
it self ext er nal t o t he fibr e, t he sensor is extrinsic. In lit er at ur e, t he t er m
fibr e opt ic sensor is somet imes r eser ved for t he int r insic sensor s only.
This definit ion does not include pyr omet er s t hat use an opt ical fibr e
bet ween t he collect ing opt ics and t he det ect or . For mally it also excludes t he
pyr omet r ic devices t hat measur e t he t emper at ur e of a met allic film on t he
fibr e end and similar devices wher e t he sensing element emit s light ,
alt hough t hey ar e oft en consider ed t o be fibr e opt ic sensor s.
Anot her class of sensor s t hat should be ment ioned in t his cont ext ar e t he
opt ically power ed elect r onic sensor s or hybrid sensor s. As all t heir connec-
t ions wit h t he out side wor ld ar e opt ical, t hey shar e many of t he advant ages
of t he fibr e opt ic sensor s, while at t he same t ime t hey allow t he use of est ab-
lished elect r onic sensing pr inciples. They ma y a lso pr ovide a wa y for
convent ional sensor s t o be int egr at ed int o opt ical sensor net wor ks.
Hi st or i ca l not es
Opt ical measur ement met hods have long been used: opt ical t elephone
t r ansmission was pat ent ed in 1880, and pat ent s fr om 1927 (Mar coni Co.)
and 1934 (Amer ican Telephone & Telegr aph Co.)
1
show t he pr inciples of
opt ical fibr es, wavelengt h mult iplexing, et c. Wit hout usable opt ical fibr es
and laser light sour ces, however , lit t le pr ogr ess was made. In t he 1960s t he
laser was invent ed and opt ical fibr es became available, figur e2. The r apid
development in t he opt ical communicat ions field has since t hen made
opt ical and elect r o-opt ical component s available at r easonable pr ices also for
measur ement applicat ions.
In t he fir st fibr e opt ic sensor s t hat wer e developed, bundles of opt ical
fibr es wer e used
2
, but similar sensor s wit h single fibr es soon appear ed
3
.
Dur ing t he ear ly 70s many of t he commonly used sensing pr inciples wher e
developed
4,5,6,7,8
. Since t hen, t he t echnological advances of t he fibr e opt ic
communicat ions r esear ch and development have immediat ely been t aken
advant age of in t he sensor communit y.
Hans S ohlstrm
4
Limit for the
silica fibre
1968 1970 1972 1974 1976 1978 1980 1982 1984
10
4
10
3
10
2
10
1
10
0
10
1
10
2
10
3
Year
F
i
b
r
e
l
o
s
s
[
d
B
/
k
m
]
Fig.2. The minimum losses of fibres developed for optical communications.
The t r uly unique feat ur es of t he fibr e opt ic sensor s, t heir immunit y t o
elect r omagnet ic int er fer ence and t heir elect r ical isolat ion, wer e r ecognized
fr om t he ver y st ar t , and scenar ios fr om t he sevent ies indicat ed a complet e
swit ch t o opt ica l mea sur ement t echnologies. Wha t wa s not , however ,
t hor oughly r ecognized was t hat indust r y r eally needed r eliable st andar dized
equipment wit h pr oven per for mance, not labor at or y pr ot ot ypes. Aft er a
gener al disappoint ment at t he end of t he 80s, t her e is now in t he 90s a
r enewed opt imism, t hough on a mor e r ealist ic scale, as t he fir st indust r ial
pr ot ot ypes of fibr e opt ic sensor s ar e being int r oduced. One of t he leading
applicat ion ar eas for t his is t he elect r ical power indust r y, one of t he ar eas
wher e t he or iginal int er est fir st st ir r ed, indicat ing t he impor t ant r ole of
t ime and a pioneer ing applicat ion in t he accept ance of new t echnologies.
Pr i nci pl es
J ust as wit h t he convent ional elect r ic sensor s t he number of combinat ions of
measur ement quant it y, sensing pr inciple and out put par amet er is lar ge.
The out put par amet er , t he t ype of modulat ion t hat car r ies t he infor mat ion
fr om t he sensing element is a possible pr inciple of classificat ion.
The opt ical power or t he intensity of t he r et ur ned light is a fundament al
par amet er . In fact , int ensit y is t he only quant it y we can measur e. All ot her
quant it ies must in some way be conver t ed t o int ensit ies at one or mor e
det ect or s and possibly wit h a var iat ion wit h t ime.
The use of t he t er m intensity her e is somewhat unclear . I n t en si t y or
radiant intensity is, accor ding t o int er nat ional st andar ds, defined as power
per solid angle. Alt hough t his quant it y is modulat ed when t he t ot al power is
modulat ed, it would in pr inciple be mor e cor r ect t o speak of optical power
and power modulation. The use of t he t er m int ensit y as a r elat ive measur e
of power is, however , est ablished in lit er at ur e and will also be followed in
t his t ext .
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
5
In an ext r insic int ensit y sensor t he modulat ion can t ake place in an
opt ical syst em wit h moving par t s
9
, a piece of mat er ial wit h an envir on-
ment ally dependent opt ical loss
10
, et c. In an int r insic sensor t he modula-
t ion is caused by a var iat ion in t he opt ical pr oper t ies of t he fibr e it self.
Sever al loss mechanisms can be exploit ed, micr obending
11,12
, r eflect ions
fr om gr at ings in t he fibr e
13
, t emper at ur e dependent scat t er ing in t he
fibr e
14
, losses caused by dopant s in t he fibr e and light decoupling fr om t he
fibr e
15
ar e some examples.
Sever al of t hese ar e loss mechanisms t hat ar e always pr esent in a fibr e
opt ic syst em. This indicat es a major weakness of an int ensit y based sensor :
t her e is in pr inciple always a loss var iat ion in t he opt ical syst em and t his
could not dir ect ly be discr iminat ed fr om var iat ions in t he measur and. Oft en
however , some known pr oper t ies of t he measur and signal can be used t o
separ at e it fr om t he loss var iat ion.
To complet ely r emove t he uncer t aint y t hat is cr eat ed by t he loss var ia -
t ion, a syst em wit h a r efer ence channel can be used. In such a syst em t wo
light int ensit ies ar e measur ed. If t he r elat ion bet ween t he influence of t he
loss and t he influence of t he measur and is differ ent for t he t wo channels,
t he influence of t he loss can be r emoved. One r ealizat ion of t his is t he
balanced syst em in which t he sum of t he t wo det ect ed int ensit ies is affect ed
by t he syst em loss a nd t he dist r ibut ion bet ween t hem only by t he
measur and. A similar appr oach is t o use t he int ensit y var iat ions wit h t ime
t o achieve a syst em t hat is independent of t he absolut e int ensit y. The use of
fluor escence decay for t emper at ur e sensing has been st udied
16
.
The wavelengt h of t he light can be used t o car r y infor mat ion in sever al
ways. The sensing element can cause a wavelengt h dependent loss and
t r ansmit only cer t ain wavelengt hs of t hose emit t ed fr om a br oadband light
sour ce
17
. The sensing element can also r eceive light wit h one wavelengt h
and emit light wit h anot her . The infor mat ion can t hen lie in t he spect r al
cont ent of t he emit t ed light
18
, in which case it is a t r ue wavelengt h modu-
lat ion, or in t he int ensit y of t he conver t ed light , in which case it is bet t er
descr ibed as an int ensit y based syst em, per haps wit h a r efer ence channel.
The ph ase of t he light is used in t he ver y sensit ive int er fer omet r ic
sensor s
19
. In such a sensor t he fr ee-pat h ar ms of a convent ional int er -
fer omet er ar e r eplaced by opt ical fibr es t hat make t he int er fer omet er much
mor e r ugged and at t he same t ime ver y sensit ive t o any change in t he
effect ive r efr act ive indices or lengt hs of t he fibr es. The changes can for
example be caused by an absolut e r ot at ion, making t he device a r ot at ion
sensor ; t he envir onment al pr essur e, making it a ver y sensit ive hydr ophone
or a magnet ost r ict ive per t ur bat ion, making it a ver y sensit ive magnet o-
met er .
The polarizat ion st at e of t he light can also be ut ilized in t he sensing
element . The most usual examples of t his ar e sensor s using t he Far aday
effect , as will be fur t her discussed below, but ext r insic elect r o-opt ic elect r ic
field sensor s
20
and pr essur e sensor s based on phot oelast ic effect s in ext r in-
sic sensor s
21
or in fibr es
22,2 3
ca n a lso be found in lit er a t ur e. The
Hans S ohlstrm
6
polar izat ion st at e can, however , not be used as t he infor mat ion car r ying
par amet er in t he fibr e.
Most of t he sensor s t hat use polar izat ion modulat ion in t he sensing
element int er nally conver t it t o an int ensit y modulat ion. Alt er nat ively, it
could be conver t ed t o t wo differ ent int ensit ies cr eat ing a balanced syst em,
cf. above. The use of a polar izat ion maint aining opt ical fibr e makes it
possible t o t r ansmit t hese t wo channels in one fibr e cor e.
Si ngl e-mod e or mul t i mod e
Out of t he above ment ioned par amet er s, only t he wavelengt h and t he int en-
sit y can be maint ained when t he light pr opagat es along a multimode fibr e.
The opt ical loss var iat ion always pr esent in a pr act ical syst em, however ,
limit s t he applicabilit y of int ensit y as t he infor mat ion car r ier . The many
differ ent pr opagat ion modes allowed in t he mult imode fibr e, give r ise t o a
disper sion t hat dest r oys t he phase infor mat ion and causes a bandwidt h
limit at ion for t he int ensit y infor mat ion.
The cor e of a single-mode fibr e is so t hin, nor mally 510m, t hat only
one mode is allowed. For monochr omat ic light it has no disper sion. The
small disper sion associat ed wit h t he spect r al widt h of t he light can, in many
inst ances, be ignor ed. The phase infor mat ion is r et ained in t he single-mode
fibr e. The phase dr ift associat ed wit h changes of t he opt ical lengt h of t he
fibr e must , however , be t aken int o account . The polar isat ion st at e cannot be
maint ained for any longer lengt hs of fibr e because t he almost per fect
cir cular symmet r y of t he fibr e makes t he t wo or t hogonal polar izat ion modes
degener at e, allowing t he polar izat ion st at e t o change under t he influence of
t he fibr e bir efr ingence.
The polarizat ion maint aining (p. preserving) fibr e is a special t ype of
single-mode fibr e wit h a cor e t hat is ellipt ical or has an anisot r opic index of
r efr act ion. This r emoves t he degener acy of t he fibr e polar izat ion modes,
allowing t hem t o exist independent ly of each ot her . Polar ized light coupled
int o t he fibr e will, t hus, be dist r ibut ed int o t he t wo polar izat ion modes and
will t hen t r avel along t he fibr e wit hout mode coupling. The polar izat ion
st at e is in fact not gener ally maint ained as t he phase r elat ion bet ween t he
t wo or t hogonal component s pr esent at t he input is lost due t o t he differ ence
in pr opagat ion const ant for t he t wo modes. The int ensit y r at io bet ween t he
light in t he t wo modes is however maint ained. Only for t he special case
wher e only one polar izat ion mode is excit ed t he fibr e is r eally polar izat ion
maint aining.
Pl a na r wa vegui d es
J ust as light can be guided in an opt ical fibr e which is a cir cular waveguide,
it can be guided in a planar waveguide. The simplest st r uct ur e is t he planar
slab guide, figur e3, wher e a planar film of r efr act ive index n
f
is sandwiched
bet ween a subst rat e and a cov er mat er ial wit h lower r efr act ive indices
(n
f
>n
s
, n
c
). Oft en t he cover mat er ial is air (n
c
=1). In t he slab guide t her e is
no confinement of t he light in t he plane of t he film.
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
7
Subst r at e, n
s
Cover, n
c
Film, n
f
h
Fig.3. The planar slab waveguide.
The light is guided in t he same way as in an opt ical fibr e, t hough con-
fined only in one dimension. J ust as wit h t he fibr e, t her e ar e single-mode
and mult imode guides. Some of t he mat er ial combinat ions used for planar
guides have much lar ger index differ ences t han nor mally used in fibr es.
Beca use of t his, wa veguide t hicknesses, h, of 1m or less a r e oft en
necessar y t o achieve st r ict single-mode guiding.
In analyzing t he guide one has t o t r eat t he case of TE (Elect ric field
transverse to the propagation direction) and TM (Magnetic field transverse to
t he propagat ion direct ion) st at e of polar izat ion separ at ely. Due t o t he
differ ent phase shift s on t ot al r eflect ion, t he pr opagat ion const ant s will be
differ ent for t he t wo cases. For small index differ ences and wit h t hick
guides, t he differ ence in pr opagat ion const ant bet ween t he TE and t he TM
mode, , is small,
=
TE
TM
In many pr act ical cases however , t he magnit ude of is not iceable.
Below, I will descr ibe how t he Far aday effect in a planar waveguide can
be t r eat ed as a coupling bet ween t he TE and TM modes of t he same or der .
This coupling cannot effect ively t ake place if t he t wo modes do not r un in
synchr onism, i. e. if is far fr om zer o.
As in a slab waveguide t her e is no confinement of t he light in t he plane of
t he waveguide, one must use t he planar equivalent of convent ional bulk
opt ica l met hods t o cont r ol t he light in t he t r a nsver se dir ect ion. The
a lt er na t ive is t o confine t he light in bot h dimensions wit h a channel
waveguide.
Magneti c fi eld measurement
Befor e dealing wit h t he opt ical magnet ic field measur ement met hods, a
shor t descr ipt ion of magnet ic field measur ement in gener al is r elevant .
Magnet ic field measur ement s ar e not only made t o measur e t he magnet ic
field it self, but also t o pr ovide indir ect infor mat ion about ot her quant it ies.
Measur ement of elect r ic cur r ent , r ot at ion speed measur ement using a
per manent magnet and a pick-up coil, acoust ic pr essur e sensing using
Hans S ohlstrm
8
Sear ch-Coil Magnet omet er
Flux-Gat e Magnet omet er
Opt ically Pumped Magnet omet er
Nuclear Pr ecession Magnet omet er
SQUID Magnet omet er
Hall-Effect Sensor
Magnet or esist ive Magnet omet er
Magnet odiode
Magnet ot r ansist or
Fibr e-Opt ic Magnet omet er
Magnet o-Opt ical Sensor
Magnet ic Sensor Technology
10
12
10
9
10
6
10
3
1 10
+3
Det ect able Field [T]
Fr om Lenz Fr om t his t hesis
Fig.4. Magnetic field sensor comparison, adapted from
26
. In addition to the
data taken from the reference, the magnetic field range for the sensors
demonstrated in this thesis is given.
dyn a mi c mi cr oph on es , a n d s u bma r i n e det ect i on u s i n g SQUI D:s
(Super conduct ing Quant um Int er fer ence Device) t o det ect per t ur bat ions of
t he ear t hs magnet ic field ar e some examples. In addit ion t o t he lar ge
pr act ical differ ences, t he r anges of magnet ic field encount er ed ar e ver y
differ ent . The measur ement of elect r ic cur r ent may involve fields exceeding
1T, while submar ine det ect ion demands a noise level ar ound 10
-11
T
24,25
.
The r equir ed bandwidt hs r ange fr om about 1Hz for submar ine det ect ion t o
GHz for EMC measur ement s.
An over view of some differ ent measur ement t echnologies is given in
figur e4. The magnet ic field r ange for t he fibr e opt ic sensor s demonst r at ed
in t his t hesis is indicat ed in addit ion t o t he dat a fr om t he r efer ence.
Evident ly, sensor s ut ilizing magnet o-opt ical effect s cover a lar ge field r ange.
Toget her wit h t he Fibr e-Opt ic Magnet omet er , t hey cover t he ent ir e r ange
given in figur e4 except t he ver y low fields t hat can only be det ect ed by
SQUID Magnet omet er s.
Measur ement of elect r ic cur r ent has been t he main applicat ion con-
sider ed in t his wor k. It is, t her efor e, appr opr iat e t o widen t he view and also
have a br ief look at cur r ent measur ement in gener al.
Measurement of electri c current
Cur r ent and per haps volt age ar e t he only quant it ies t hat can r eally be
measur ed wit h convent ional elect r ical met hods. All ot her quant it ies ar e
conver t ed t o a cur r ent or a volt age t hat can in t ur n be measur ed, e.g., by an
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
9
indicat ing inst r ument . It may t her efor e seem somewhat sur pr ising t o find
t hat t her e is a consider able int er est in unconvent ional met hods t o measur e
cur r ent in high volt age power syst ems. A cause for t his is t hat even t hough
t he measur ement is in pr inciple a simple one, it is in pr act ice complicat ed
for t wo r easons: t he power dissipat ion in t he measur ement cir cuit and t he
need t o keep t he display unit at gr ound pot ent ial.
The convent ional way t o solve t his is t o use a current t ransformer t hat
t r ansfor ms t he cur r ent down t o a r easonable level and pr ovides an isolat ion
bar r ier bet ween t he pr imar y winding at line pot ent ial and t he secondar y
winding at gr ound pot ent ial. The size and cost of such a cur r ent t r ans-
for mer , however , incr ease wit h t he line volt age. Also, cur r ent t r ansfor mer s
can only be used for AC measur ement s. For DC measur ement s, mor e
complex devices wit h Hall element s ar e oft en used.
The incr easingly complex cont r ol syst ems used in t he power t r ansmission
net wor ks also cr eat es a need for mor e point s of measur ement and a wider
r ange of measur ement sit uat ions. Cur r ent met er ing for billing pur poses is
usually done wit h equipment having an accur acy in t he or der of 0.2% and
wit h a r elat ively low bandwidt h, t ypically less t han 1 kHz. For cont r ol and
pr ot ect ion pur poses, however , er r or s of 1% or even mor e a r e usua lly
accept ed. Ther e is even a need for on/off devices t hat indicat e t he pr esence
of cur r ent over a cer t ain level.
Cur r ent t r ansfor mer s wit h opt ical downlinks as well as syst ems using
t he Far aday effect at micr owave fr equencies have been invest igat ed
27
. In
r ecent year s t he int er est has, however , been focused on fibr e opt ic syst ems.
Opti cal methods for magneti c fi eld and
electri c current measurement
Two ma i n met hod s
Most of t he wor k t hat has been published on opt ical met hods t o measur e
ma gnet ic fields concer n eit her t he Faraday ef f ect or m agn et ost ri ct i ve
perturbation of optical fibres. The Far aday effect , which is a change of t he
polar izat ion st at e of pr opagat ing light under t he influence of a magnet ic
field, is t he phenomenon ut ilized in t his wor k.
Befor e we fur t her descr ibe t he Far aday effect , a shor t descr ipt ion of t he
ot her pr inciple is appr opr iat e. In cont r ast t o t he Far aday effect , which can
be ut ilized in bot h bulk opt ical element s, planar waveguides and in fibr es,
t he magnet ost r ict ive pr inciple r equir es t he use of fibr es. The magnet ost r ic-
t ive pr inciple was fir st suggest ed in 1980
28
. It uses a magnet ost r ict ive
mat er ial which is mechanically linked t o t he fibr e, for example in t he for m
of a magnet ost r ict ive jacket on t he fibr e or a bulk magnet ost r ict ive element
ont o which t he fibr e is wound. When subject ed t o a magnet ic field t he
magnet ost r ict ive element will change it s for m, t her eby causing a st r ain and
a change of t he lengt h of t he fibr e. This change of t he opt ical lengt h can be
det ect ed if t he fibr e is placed in one ar m of a Mach-Zehnder int er fer omet er .
Hans S ohlstrm
10
The fibr e can be long and as t he phase sensit ivit y of t he int er fer omet er is
high, t his device can pot ent ially be ver y sensit ive
29
. However , it is unfor t u-
nat ely also sensit ive t o all ot her par amet er s t hat influence t he opt ical
lengt h of t he fibr e, e.g. t emper at ur e
30
. Alt hough t he measur ement of
elect r ic cur r ent was ment ioned as a possible applicat ion
31
, t he dr iving for ce
of t he development was t he pot ent ial possibilit y of det ect ing t he small
changes in t he ear t hs magnet ic field caused by passing submar ines. At fir st
nickel wa s used for t he ma gnet ost r ict ive element , a nd la t er m et al l i c
glasses
32,33
. Differ ent biasing
34
and feedback
35,36
ar r angement s have been
invest igat ed.
Many of t he pr oblems wit h t emper at ur e and vibr at ion sensit ivit y have
been over come wit h pr oper jacket ing of t he fibr e and wit h t he use of all fibr e
opt ical syst ems. This t ype of sensor offer s ext r emely high sensit ivit y, wit h
noise levels down t o 10
15
T/
Hz
37
, but it is not suit ed for elect r ic cur r ent
measur ement and ot her lar ge-signal applicat ions.
Ot her sensing pr inciples t hat have been st udied ar e: int er fer omet r ic
det ect ion of t he movement of a met al coat ed fibr e in a magnet ic field when a
cur r ent is sent t hr ough t he coat ing
38,39,40
, sur face plasmon r esonance
41
,
liquid cr yst als
42
and r esist or heat ing
43
. The use of a cur r ent t r ansfor mer
t hat is in t ur n int er r ogat ed by a fibr e opt ic int er fer omet er has also been
t r ied
44
.
In t his cont ext , t he possibilit ies t o use convent ional cur r ent t r ansfor mer s
t oget her wit h an opt ical dat a link for cur r ent measur ement s in high volt age
syst ems should be ment ioned. The equipment at high pot ent ial could t hen
be power ed by pick-off fr om t he power line
45
, or be a hybr id sensor ,
opt ically power ed t hr ough t he fibr e
46
.
The Fa r a d a y effect
When a mat er ial exhibit ing t he Faraday effect is placed in a magnet ic field
and a beam of linear ly polar ized light is sent t hr ough it in t he dir ect ion of
t he field, a r ot at ion of t he plane of polar izat ion of t he light will occur ,
figur e5.
The phenomenon was discover ed in 1845 by Michael Far aday. Ot her
names for t he same effect ar e t he magneto-optical rotation (MOR), magnetic
circular birefringence (MCB) or t he magneto-optical effect. The last t er m is,
however , mor e gener al and may also include ot her effect s.
The effect is non-r ecipr ocal in nat ur e. This means t hat when t he dir ec-
t ion of light pr opagat ion is r ever sed, t he dir ect ion of r ot at ion as seen fr om a
fixed r efer ence syst em, is not r ever sed. A light beam t hat passes t wice
t hr ough t he medium in opposit e dir ect ions will t hus acquir e a net r ot at ion
which is t wice t hat of a single pass.
The Fa r a da y r ot a t ion is pr opor t iona l t o t he ma gnet iza t ion of t he
mat er ial,
=
L
kM
.
dl
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
11
E
H
l
L
V
.
H
.
dl=
{ }
accor dingt ot hegeomet r yoffigur e5 = V
.
H
.
l
wher e H is t he component of t he magnet ic field st r engt h par allel t o t he light
pr opagat ion dir ect ion. (The Ver det const ant is somet imes expr essed in
t er ms of t he magnet ic flux densit y, B, which for t hese mat er ials is linear ly
r elat ed t o t he magnet ic field st r engt h, B=H.)
In fer r i- and fer r o-magnet ic mat er ials t he magnet izat ion is not linear ly
r elat ed t o t he magnet ic field st r engt h, and a Ver det const ant cannot be
used.
In addit ion t o t he magnet ic cir cular bir efr ingence, a linear bir efr ingence
can be induced by a magnet izat ion per pendicular t o t he light pr opagat ion
dir ect ion. This is called MLB (magnet ic linear birefringence), Voi gt or
Cotton-Mouton effect , t hough t he last name or iginally denot ed a similar
effect in fluids due t o molecule or ient at ion in t he magnet ic field. Ther e may
also be a magnet ic field dependent differ ence in opt ical absor pt ion bet ween
t he linear or t he cir cular polar izat ion st at es, MLD (magnetic linear dichro-
ism) and MCD (magnet ic circular dichroism)
47,48
. One should, however ,
keep in mind t hat t her e seems t o be a consider able confusion concer ning t he
names for t hese effect s in lit er at ur e.
Besides magnet ic field sensing, t he main applicat ion of t he Far aday effect
is in isolat or s and cir culat or s for micr owave or opt ical fr equencies t hough in
t hese a pplica t ions, t he effect is used in a st a t ic r a t her t ha n dyna mic
manner .
The isolat or is a device t hat allows power t o flow in one dir ect ion, while
t he ot her dir ect ion is blocked. The basic design consist s of a polar izer
followed by a 45 Far aday r ot at or and a second polar izer wit h it s polar iza -
t ion dir ect ion 45 fr om t hat of t he fir st one. The 45 angle, however , makes
Hans S ohlstrm
12
High-fr equency field h
x
Pr ecession
m
x
m
y
St eady magnet ic field
Fig.6. Electron precession: The high-frequency field h
x
creates magnetiza-
tion both in the x- and the y-direction. After
50
.
t he basic isolat or design unsuit able for opt ical waveguide implement at ion,
and a number of var iat ions of t he pr inciple have been t r ied
49
.
A cir culat or is a similar device but wit h t hr ee por t s, in which power
incident on one por t will emer ge at t he next por t .
The or i gi n of t he Fa r a d a y effect
The Far aday effect ar ises fr om t he int er act ion of t he elect r on or bit and spin
wit h a magnet ic field. The elect r on or bit for ms a magnet ic dipole t hat t ends
t o align in an applied const ant field. As it , fr om a classical viewpoint , is a
spinning par t icle, it will r eact t o a per t ur bing moment um at r ight angles t o
t he spin axis by precessing about t he or iginal spin axis, just as a spinning
t op would do. The elect r on spin behaves similar ly, t hough t his is not obvious
fr om a classical viewpoint . The per t ur bing moment um can be caused by an
elect r omagnet ic wave of opt ical or micr owave fr equency. The closer t his
fr equency is t o t he pr ecessiona l fr equency t he mor e ma r ked is t he
int er act ion. If t hey coincide t her e is a r esonance, called par amagnet ic
r esonance or fer r omagnet ic r esonance, depending on t he act ual mat er ial
pr oper t ies.
Macr oscopically, t he pr ecession has t he effect of cr eat ing a magnet izat ion
at r ight angles t o bot h t he applied const ant magnet ic field and t o t he per t ur -
bat ion, cf. figur e6.
The magnet ic suscept ibilit y of t he mat er ial will, under t he influence of
t he st eady magnet ic field (in t he z-dir ect ion), become a t ensor wit h off-
diagonal component s of t he for m,
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
13
yx
=i
2
0
xy
=+i
2
0
R
=
L
=
0
+
R
=
0
_
1+
L
=
0
_
1+
0
+
In t hese expr essions we r ecognize t he r esonances discussed above. If loss
t er ms ar e included, t he r esonances will be damped and t he per meabilit ies
will have imaginar y par t s, causing loss and dichr oism.
The st r ong int er act ion bet ween neighbour ing at oms in fer r i- and fer r o-
magnet ic mat er ials causes t hese mat er ials t o have sever al r esonances at
differ ent fr equencies and wit h differ ent st r engt hs, cr eat ing r at her compli-
cat ed fr equency (wavelengt h) dependencies for bot h t he r eal and t he imagi-
nar y t er ms.
Li ght pr opa ga t i on i n ma gnet o-opt i ca l ma t er i a l s
To under st and how t he Far aday effect influences t he light pr opagat ion, t he
wave equat ion is a suit able st ar t ing point . For an infinit e medium wit h no
ext er nal elect r ical polar izat ion, t he wave equat ion can be wr it t en,
2
E(r, t )=
2
E(r,t )
t
2
The solut ion t o t his is a plane wave wit h t he phase velocit y given by,
u=
1
Waves wit h differ ent cir cular polar izat ion st at es will have differ ent :s,
and t hus t r avel wit h differ ent speeds.
A linear ly polar ized wave can be seen as t he sum of t wo cir cular ly
polar ized waves wit h equal amplit ude but opposit e dir ect ions of r ot at ion. As
t hese t wo waves pr opagat e wit h differ ent speeds, t hey will acquir e a phase
differ ence pr opor t ional t o t he t r avelled dist ance. In t er ms of t heir sum, t he
Hans S ohlstrm
14
phase differ ence has t he effect of r ot at ing t he linear st at e of polar izat ion by
an angle which is equal t o half t he phase change.
If we want t o st udy t he influence of t he Far aday effect on t he light
pr opagat ion in a waveguide wit h differ ent pr opagat ion const ant s for t he TE
and TM modes, t his simple r easoning is not applicable. Inst ead one can use
t he coupled-mode formalism
51
. In t his for malism one st udies how a small
per t ur bat ion causes a coupling bet ween t he or t hogonal eigenmodes of t he
unper t ur bed medium. In t he lit er at ur e t his per t ur bat ion is nor mally in t he
elect r ical per mit t ivit y , causing an elect r ic polar izat ion P . As only t he
pr oduct of and appear in t he wave equat ion, t he Far aday effect can be
t r eat ed as a per t ur bat ion in of t he following for m,
=
]
1
1
1
1 0 i 0
i 0 0
0 0 0
.
0
=
2
0
Wit h t his appr oach, one finds for t he case wit h only one of t he modes
exit ed, t hat t he power in t he ot her mode can be r epr esent ed by,
F=
1
_
1+
2
2
sin
2
]
1
1
1
2
+
2
2
.
z
wher e is t he differ ence bet ween t he pr opagat ion const ant s of t he t wo
modes, is t he polar izat ion r ot at ion per unit lengt h in a homogeneous
medium, and z is t he dist ance along t he pr opagat ion dir ect ion. If =0 t his
simplifies t o,
F= sin
2
(
.
z)
Fr om t he above, it is evident t hat should be smaller t han if any
appr eciable amount of power is t o be coupled bet ween t he modes.
El ect r i c cur r ent sensi ng usi ng t he Fa r a d a y effect
Glass sensing elements
The fir st opt ical cur r ent t r ansducer s ut ilizing t he Far aday effect used bulk
opt ical glass element s int er r ogat ed by an open pat h light beam, figur e7.
Using t wo det ect or s, and a polar izat ion separ at ing pr ism, a syst em which
is not affect ed by var iat ions in t he opt ical loss, can be achieved, figur e8
52
.
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
15
I
B
E
Polar izer
Polar izer
P
0
P=P
0
cos
2
(/4)
Fig.7. The simplest form of an optical current sensor utilizing the Faraday
effect.
Polar izer
Det .
Det .
Laser
I
B
Polar izat ion
split t er
Fig.8. A bulk optic current measurement system with polarization state
detection. As the Faraday effect is non-reciprocal the two-way pass through
the sensing element effectively doubles the rotation.
The sensor is sensit ive t o t he t ot al magnet ic field, t hus, also t o t he
cont r ibut ions fr om ot her conduct or s near by. Also, t he dist ance bet ween t he
conduct or and t he sensing element will influence t he scale fact or . Wit h t wo
sensing element s, one on each side of t he conduct or , a differ ent ial syst em is
achieved, r educing t he influence fr om conduct or s at lar ge dist ances.
53
An iron core r educes t he posit ion dependence and t he influence of ext er -
nal fields, but as t he ir on cor e must have a r elat ively lar ge gap t o accommo-
dat e t he glass sensing element , some sensit ivit y t o t he conduct or posit ion
and t o ext er nal fields will r emain.
A mor e fundament al appr oach is t o use a basic pr oper t y of t he magnet ic
field encir cling t he conduct or ,
O
L
H
.
dl =
S
i
.
ds = I
wher e i is t he cur r ent densit y t hr ough t he sur face S, wit h t he cont our L,
and I is t he t ot al cur r ent t hr ough S.
This means t hat if t he sensing light pat h complet ely encir cles t he con-
duct or , fig 9, t he sensor becomes insensit ive t o ext er nal fields and indepen-
dent of t he conduct or posit ion in t he sensing element . This can be appr oxi-
mat ed wit h a bulk sensing element wit h a cent r al hole for t he conduct or or
sensing element assembled fr om sever al pieces of glass. The r eflect ions at
t he cor ner s must be suit ably ar r anged not t o influence t he polar izat ion st at e
of t he light .
54
Hans S ohlstrm
16
Conduct or
Polar izer
In
Polar izer
Out
Far aday
r ot at or
element
Fig. 9. A glass sensing element that encircles the conductor, after
55
The ear ly exper iment s wer e made wit h glass sensing element s having
r elat ively small Ver det const ant s, t ypically about 10
5
r ad/A, r equir ing long
sensing element s for good sensit ivit y. Alt hough YIG (Y
3
Fe
5
O
12
) and ot her
mat er ials wit h much lar ger polar izat ion r ot at ion wer e st udied
56
, no t r ans-
ducer s using such mat er ials wer e pr esent ed. Mult iple r eflect ions wer e,
however , t r ied t o r educe t he physical size of t he sensing element wit hout
sacr ificing opt ical pat h lengt h
57,58
.
Devices t o measur e bot h t he cur r ent and t he volt age simult aneously wer e
also pr esent ed.
59,60
Wit h opt ical fibr es many of t he pr oblems associat ed wit h t he open opt ical
pat h could be eliminat ed
61
. The possibilit ies wit h opt ical fibr es, however , go
fur t her t han t hat . The sensing element can be made fr om an opt ical fibr e.
Alt hough t he Ver det const ant of t he fibr e mat er ial is not high, about
4
.
10
-6
r ad/A, a measur able r ot at ion can be achieved wit h a long fibr e, and
wit h t he fibr e wound r ound t he conduct or , a good appr oximat ion of t he
closed line int egr al of t he field is achieved.
Ther e was a consider able int er est in t his t ype of device at t he end of t he
70s and t he r esult s wer e pr omising
62
. The bending of t he fibr e in t he coil,
however , ca uses a t emper a t ur e dependent linea r bir efr ingence t ha t
quenches t he cir cular bir efr ingence caused by t he Far aday effect . Sever al
met hods have been t r ied t o over come t his pr oblem.
If t he fibr e is t wist ed, a cir cular bir efr ingence bias is int r oduced, which
is magnet ic field independent and lar ge enough t o quench t he linear bir e-
fr ingence. This bias bir efr ingence is, however , t emper at ur e dependent
63
.
Wit h t he sensing fibr e divided int o sect ions wit h opposit e t wist s, t he bias
r ot at ion and t he t emper at ur e dependence can be cancelled and wit h t he use
of polar izat ion maint aining fibr e for t he downlead, t he vibr at ion sensit ivit y
is r educed
64
. A similar appr oach is t o use a fibr e wit h a st r ong bir efr ingence
which is a lmost cir cula r
6 5
. This cir cula r bir efr ingence is st r ongly
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
17
t emper at ur e dependent . Techniques t o compensat e for t his have, however ,
been st udied
66
.
The fibr e can be wound int o a coil in such a way t hat t he beat lengt h (t he
fibr e lengt h t hat causes a phase differ ence of 2 bet ween t he t wo or t hogonal
linear polar izat ion modes) is equal t o t he cir cumfer ence of t he fibr e coil.
When an ext er nal field is t hen applied t o t he fibr e coil, t he per iodic mag-
net ic field t hat is in t his way applied t o t he fibr e will cause a net polar iza -
t ion r ot at ion.
67,68,69
. A pr incipally similar scheme is t o use a polar izat ion
maint aining fibr e wit h a ver y shor t beat lengt h and ar r ange a per iodic
magnet ic field wit h t he same per iod
70
.
A mor e fundament al appr oach is t o anneal t he coiled fibr e t o r emove t he
t emper at ur e dependent linear bir efr ingence
71
.
Also, t he Far aday effect is t emper at ur e dependent . The use of a t emper a -
t ur e dependent linear ly bir efr ingent opt ical element has been suggest ed as
a way t o int r oduce a t emper at ur e dependent par t ial quenching of t he
Far aday effect , t her eby r educing t he effect ive t emper at ur e dependence
72
.
In addit ion t o t he simple polar izat ion det ect ion syst em descr ibed above, a
number of int er fer omet r ic syst ems t o det ect t he polar izat ion r ot at ion has
been pr esent ed
73
. Closed-loop syst ems
74
a nd het er odyne det ect ion
syst ems
75
have been st udied. A syst em for simult aneous measur ement of
t wo cur r ent s has also been pr esent ed
76
. To eliminat e t he influence of
r ecipr ocal effect s in t he fibr e, some of t hese syst ems ut ilize S agnac int er -
fer omet er s
77,78
. The non-r ecipr ocit y of t he Far aday effect also makes it
possible t o use a Fabry-Perot r esonat or t o incr ease t he effect ive polar izat ion
r ot at ion
79
.
Exper iment s wit h t echniques t o make t he sensor out put independent of
var iat ions in t he Ver det const ant
80
, or t o conver t t he polar izat ion r ot at ion
t o a spect r al modulat ion
81
, have been made.
The measurement bandwidth of Far aday sensor s wit h bulk glass or fibr e
coil sensing element s is limit ed by t he t r ansit t ime of t he light in t he
sensing element
82
,
B
3dB
=
0.44
=0.44
.
c
n
1
2r
1
N
wher e c/n is t he speed of light in t he fibr e, N t he number of t ur ns in t he
fibr e coil and r is t he r adius of t he fibr e coil. Wit h N=100, r =0.1 and n=1.5 a
bandwidt h of 1.4MHz is achieved. Obviously, t her e is a t r ade-off bet ween
sensit ivit y and bandwidt h. Wit h high pulsed cur r ent s t he sensing element
can be made shor t , giving ver y lar ge bandwidt hs. A number of syst ems wit h
bulk glass
83
or fibr e sensing element s
84,85
for measur ement of t r ansient
cur r ent s in t he 10
6
A r a nge ha ve been pr esent ed. Ot her specia lized
applicat ions such as aer ospace
86
cur r ent measur ing and space plasma
cur r ent measur ement s
87
have been st udied. Ther e is also a pot ent ial for
dist r ibut ed magnet ic field sensing
88
.
Alt hough t he use of an opt ical fibr e coil for cur r ent measur ement s may in
pr inciple seem st r aight for war d, t he pr act ical applicat ion of t he t echnology
Hans S ohlstrm
18
is, however , complicat ed by t he linear bir efr ingence of t he fibr e and many
opt ical cur r ent met er ing devices t hat ar e inst alled in t he high volt age power
lines ar e of t he bulk opt ical t ype
89,90
.
Other materials
Opt ical fibr es wit h high Ver det const ant s may incr ease t he applicabilit y of
cur r ent sensing using fibr e sensing element s. Ter bium doped silica fibr e
91
,
wit h a Ver det const ant of 1.2
.
10
5
r ad/A, and doped plast ic fibr e
92
, wit h a
Ver det const ant of 2
.
10
5
r ad/A, have been developed.
The alt er nat ive solut ion is t o use a compact sensing element made fr om a
mat er ial wit h a Far aday r ot at ion lar ger t han t hat of t he glasses. A small
sensor hea d is a n a dva nt a ge in ma ny a pplica t ions, including cur r ent
measur ement using an ir on cor e.
BGO (Bi
12
GeO
20
)
93
, BSO(Bi
12
SiO
20
)
94,95
and ZnSe
96
offer Ver det
const ant s of about 7
.
10
5
r ad/A, which is about an or der of magnit ude
higher t han t hat of t he silica fibr e mat er ial. Cer t ain glasses also have
Ver det const ant s t hat ar e almost as high. A consider ably higher Ver det con-
st ant , about 2
.
10
3
r ad/A, is achieved wit h Cd
1x
Mn
x
Te
97,98,99,100,101,102
.
YIG and subst it ut ed YIG offer polar izat ion r ot at ions which, for many
applicat ions, is lar ger t han t hat of Cd
1x
Mn
x
Te by a bout a n or der of
magnit ude. As YIG is a fer r imagnet ic mat er ial, it can, however , not be
dir ect ly compa r ed t o t he pa r a ma gnet ic a nd dia ma gnet ic ma t er ia ls
ment ioned. Since YIG is t he mat er ial chosen in t his wor k, it will be fur t her
descr ibed below.
YIG
YIG, Yttrium iron garnet is a ferrimagnetic gar net cr yst al wit h t he composi-
t ion Y
3
Fe
5
O
12
. It is t r anspar ent for light wit h a wavelengt h longer t han
about 1.1m. At 1.3m and 1.5m, wavelengt hs at which r eliable light
sour ces and det ect or s ar e r eadily available, t he opt ical loss is ver y low. YIG
ha s a subst a nt ia l Fa r a da y r ot a t ion in la r ge pa r t s of t he opt ica l a nd
micr owave spect r um. Cr yst als of opt ical qualit y can be gr own fr om flux
melt s or gr own epit axially on subst r at es. Epit axially gr own films can be
used as high qualit y opt ical waveguides exhibit ing t he Far aday effect
103
.
YIG cr yst al mat er ial, oft en in t he for m of polished spher es, ar e used in
micr owave component s.
The cr yst al lat t ice of YIG is r hombohedr al, almost cubic, wit h t he ir on
at oms occupying t wo differ ent kinds of sit es in t he lat t ice, figur e10. For t his
r eason t he for mula is somet imes wr it t en Y
3+
3
Fe
3+
2
Fe
3+
3
O
2
12
.
The magnet ic pr oper t ies of t he cr yst al ar e mainly det er mined by t he ir on
at oms. The ir on at oms in t he t wo kinds of sit es int er act ant ifer r omagnet i-
cally wit h each ot her , giving a net magnet ic moment equal t o t hat of one
at om. The Yt t r ium is magnet ically polar ized by t he field fr om t he ir on
at oms, but it has lit t le influence on t he st r engt h of t he magnet ic int er act ion.
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
19
Y
3+
, et c.
O
2
Fe
3+
, et c.
Tet r ahedr al sit e
Oct ahedr al sit e
Dodecahedr al sit e
Fig.10. The different kinds of atomic sites in YIG, after
106
.
Fig.11. Qualitative behaviour of the different contributions to the net
magnetization of rare earth garnets having a compensation point. From
107
.
This is evident fr om t he fact t hat all rare-earth iron garnets (RIG, R
3
Fe
5
O
12
wher e R is a r ar e ear t h) have a Cur ie t emper at ur e of about 550K
104
. The
Cur ie t emper at ur e is t he t emper at ur e at which t he t her mal agit at ion
br eaks down t he magnet ic or der ing of t he at oms and t he mat er ial ceases t o
be fer r oma gnet ic. The Cur ie t emper a t ur e ca n t her efor e be used a s a
measur e of t he st r engt h of t he magnet ic int er act ion. The Cur ie t emper at ur e
for pur e YIG is 559K
105
. The net magnet ic moment for t he r ar e ear t h
gar net s is, however , influenced by t he r ar e ear t h, in sever al cases giving
compensation points, wher e t he t emper a t ur e dependent magnet ic moment s
of t he differ ent kinds of at oms cancel each ot her at a specific t emper at ur e,
figur e11. YIG, however , does not have any compensat ion point .
It is possible t o subst it ut e par t of t he yt t r ium wit h ot her r ar e ear t hs,
giving mixed r ar e ear t h gar net s. Also, ot her subst it ut ions can be made, but
t his nor mally has lit t le effect on t he magnet ic int er act ion. Bismut h subst i-
t ut ion is an except ion as it incr eases t he st r engt h of t he magnet ic int er -
act ion, t her eby incr easing t he Cur ie t emper at ur e.
If t he ir on is subst it ut ed, t he magnet ic int er act ion is weakened, giving a
lower Cur ie t emper at ur e.
Hans S ohlstrm
20
Fig.12. Two-dimensional domain pattern in thin sample with an out of
plane anisotropy.
The lattice constant of pur e YIG is such t hat it can be epit axially gr own
on subst r a t es of GGG, Ga dolinium ga llium ga r net (Gd
3
Ga
5
O
12
). Such
subst r at es of high qualit y ar e r eadily available. For subst it ut ed films, t he
subst it ut ions of t he film and subst r at e must be combined t o give t he pr oper
lat t ice const ant s.
The magnetic anisotropy in pur e YIG is mainly cubic and not so st r ong.
St r ain, however , st r ongly affect s t he magnet ic anisot r opy
108
. Epit axially
gr own YIG films can, t her efor e, have easy dir ect ions of magnet izat ion in t he
plane of t he film, or per pendicular ly t o it , depending on t he film st r ain
caused by t he lat t ice mismat ch. In addit ion t o t he st r ain anisot r opy, t her e
can also be a gr owt h-induced anisot r opy, ar ising fr om a cer t ain or der ing of
t he magnet ic ions in t he gr owt h pr ocess.
Because of t he fer r imagnet ic pr oper t ies of t he mat er ial, volumes of equal
dir ect ion of magnet izat ion, so called magnet i c domai ns will for m. The
doma ins a r e sepa r a t ed by t hin Bloch walls wher e t he ma gnet iza t ion
dir ect ion is changed. The domain size is det er mined by a magnet ost at ic
ener gy balance t hat depends on t he mat er ial pr oper t ies and t he sample
geomet r y.
Wit h t hin bulk sa mples a nd epit a xia lly gr own films wit h suit a ble
anisot r opy, t he domains can for m t wo-dimensional pat t er ns ext ending
t hr ough t he ent ir e t hickness of t he film, figur e12. Under cer t ain condit ions
t his pat t er n degener at es t o small cir cular domains, bubbles. These bubbles
can be moved ar ound in t he film, cr eat ed and annihilat ed by small per t ur -
bat ions in t he field. This is t he phenomenon t hat was used in t he bubble
memor ies, in which mor e t han 1Mbit of infor mat ion could be st or ed in t he
for m of a bubble pat t er n in 1cm
2
of ir on gar net film
109
.
For a lar ge sample wit h many domains, t he act ual for m of t he individual
domains and t heir movement when an ext er nal field is applied seems t o be
st ochast ic. For t he ent ir e sample or a lar ge par t of t he sample t he behaviour
of t he domains, however , aver ages out and t he net magnet izat ion r eflect s
t he var iat ions in t he applied magnet ic field. Ther e is however a t endency for
t he domain walls t o st ick t o imper fect ions in t he mat er ial, such as lat t ice
dislocat ions, causing discont inuit ies in t he magnet izat ion change.
The dir ect ion of magnet izat ion of t he individual domains will also change
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
21
under t he influence of an applied field. The magnet ic anisot r opy will,
however , keep t he magnet izat ion appr oximat ely along t he easy dir ect ions.
When t he net magnet izat ion of t he sample cannot be adjust ed t o t he
ext er nal field t hr ough r edist r ibut ion of t he domains bet ween t he easy
dir ect ions only, a r ot at ion of t he magnet izat ion dir ect ion wit hin t he domains
will occur . For a ver y st r ong a pplied field, t he ma gnet iza t ion will be
complet ely aligned wit h t he field.
The r a pidit y wit h which t he ma gnet iza t ion of t he ma t er ia l ca n be
changed is limit ed by t he dynamic pr oper t ies of t he domain wall move-
ment s. This gives an upper fr equency limit somewher e in t he 10MHz t o
GHz r ange
110
. Ver y lit t le wor k has however been done in measur ing t he
fr equency r esponse of YIG mat er ial based devices
111
.
The cont r ibut ion t o t he magnet o-opt ical r ot at ion per unit lengt h fr om t he
differ ent at oms can be descr ibed by a for mula fr om
112
,
= (A
m
+A
e
)M
o
Fe
+(B
m
+B
e
)M
t
Fe
+(C
m
+C
e
)M
R
The indices m and e indicat e cont r ibut ions fr om differ ent kinds of
r esona nces a nd t he super scr ipt s o a nd t indica t e oct a hedr ic a nd
t et r ahedr ic posit ions for t he ir on at oms. Appar ent ly, t he cont r ibut ions fr om
t he ir on at oms in t he t wo kinds of sit es ar e differ ent . In t he r efer ence,
A
e
/B
e
=1.72 is given.
The magnet o-opt ical r ot at ion incr eases wit h decr easing wavelengt h fr om
3m t o 0.5m
113
. At 1.15m, t he sat ur at ion r ot at ion is about 200/cm
(3.5
.
10
2
r ad/m) for pur e YIG. Bismut h subst it ut ion can incr ease t his value
by a fa ct or of mor e t ha n 10 depending on t he composit ion; 7400/cm
(13
.
10
3
r a d/m) ha s been r epor t ed a t 1.15m
114
. The ma gnet o-opt ica l
r ot at ion is t emper at ur e dependent , but it has been shown t hat subst it ut ions
can r educe t his dependence subst ant ially
115,116
.
It is impor t ant t o r emember t hat t he magnet o-opt ical r ot at ion of fer r i-
magnet ic mat er ials, just as t he magnet izat ion, micr oscopically always has
t he sat ur at ion value. When measur ement s show ot her values, it is eit her
because t he magnet izat ion is not par allel t o t he measur ing light beam or
beca use t he light pa t h goes t hr ough sever a l doma ins wit h differ ent
magnet izat ion dir ect ions.
The r ar e ear t h gar net s also possess a magnet ic linear bir efr ingence in t he
or der of 100/cm (1.7
.
10
2
r ad/m)
117,118
. For bismut h subst it ut ed YIG,
lit er at ur e dat a also indicat e a magnit ude which is about half t hat of t he
magnet o-opt ical r ot at ion
119
.
The index of r efr act ion for pur e YIG is 2.15. As t he index for GGG is 1.95,
a YIG film on a GGG subst r at e can for m a high qualit y opt ical waveguide.
Using ion beam et ching, or wet et ching and mult ilayer gr owt h, it is
possible t o make strip or channel waveguides in YIG film
120
. The t echnolo-
gies used t o define t he channel ar e, however , not so well developed. Fur -
t her mor e, all changes made in t he magnet o-opt ical film will change not only
t he opt ica l pr oper t ies, but a lso t he ma gnet ic pr oper t ies such a s t he
anisot r opy, et c.
Hans S ohlstrm
22
3. St ar t ing point s for t he sensor development wor k
A conclusion fr om t he above descr ipt ion of YIG and ot her r ar e ear t h gar net s
is t hat t hey, compar ed t o ot her magnet o-opt ical mat er ials, have many
favour able feat ur es such as a lar ge magnet o-opt ic r ot at ion, well-defined
magnet ic pr oper t ies and good opt ical qualit y in t he near IR. Fur t her mor e,
par t icular ly wit h t he epit axially gr own films, many of t hese pr oper t ies can
be a lt er ed a t will t hr ough a number of subst it ut ions. Unfor t una t ely
however , some of t he pr oper t ies a r e int er linked, ma inly t hr ough t he
mechanical st r ain, in such a way t hat t hey cannot easily be independent ly
opt imized. We have, t her efor e, not consider ed it fr uit ful t o design any
devices based on a per fect magnet o-opt ical mat er ial t hat has not yet been
developed. Inst ead, our appr oach has been t o find device st r uct ur es t hat ar e
useful for a demonstration wit h exist ing mat er ials or wit h r elat ively simple
modificat ions of known composit ions. For similar r easons, no exper iment s
have specifically been made t o measur e t he bandwidt hs of t he exper iment al
sensor s. No evidence of bandwidt h limit at ions has, however , been found in
measur ement s of magnet ic fields at fr equencies up t o about 1MHz.
The most st r iking feat ur e of t his t ype of mat er ial for sensor s, is t he lar ge
Far aday r ot at ion. To achieve a polar izat ion r ot at ion of 90 (or a complet e TE
t o TM conver sion in t he waveguide case) at 1.3m, fr om less t han 1 mm t o
about 6 mm of opt ical pat h lengt h is needed, depending on t he mat er ial in
quest ion. The volume of t he sensing element can, t hus, be made ver y small,
in t he or der of 1mm
3
. Wit h a sensing volume of t his size, t he spat ial
var iat ions of t he magnet ic field can be r esolved. This is in cont r ast t o t he
sensor s using glass sensing element s. They oft en r equir e a lar ge sensing
element and/or a closed measur ement pat h.
In t he design of a measur ement syst em t hat ut ilizes a YIG or subst it ut ed
YIG sensing element eit her in t he for m of a bulk cr yst al or a waveguide,
t her e ar e a number of syst em design opt ions. To be able t o choose bet ween
t hese, we had t o acquir e a t hor ough knowledge of t he pr oper t ies of t he
mat er ial. As t he available lit er at ur e dat a, r elevant for t his applicat ion, wer e
insufficient , t his knowledge had t o be gained t hr ough measur ement s.
For t he single mode sensor s we ha ve, in or der t o a void a lignment
pr oblems, decided t o wor k wit h waveguiding sensing element s only. The
r elat ively lar ge index differ ence bet ween GGG and YIG, however , poses
some pr oblems. Guides t hat ar e single mode in t he near infr ar ed r egion ar e
ver y t hin, less t han 1m. A slab guide of t his kind will have a lar ge linear
bir efr ingence t hat pr event s t he TMTE conver sion.
A number of t echniques have been used t o solve t his pr oblem. Mult ilayer
st r uct ur es wit h a layer bet ween t he GGG and t he ir on gar net film have
been invest igat ed
121
. A magnet ic field t hat shift s it s dir ect ion wit h a per iod
t hat is equal t o t he beat lengt h bet ween t he TE and TM modes can also be
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
23
used. In t his way, a net conver sion can be obt ained even wit h a r elat ively
lar ge
122
.
At an ear ly st age of our pr oject a per iodic cover st r uct ur e in GGG on t op
of t he YIG waveguide was suggest ed as a means t o achieve a net conver sion
wit h a single mode YIG waveguide
123
.
We have, however , used anot her appr oach. Because of t he high opt ical
qualit y of t he YIG waveguides, t he coupling bet ween t he differ ent modes in
a mult imode guide is negligible for t he pr opagat ion dist ances in quest ion.
As it is also possible t o achieve a fibr e t o waveguide coupling t hat only
excit es t he fundament al mode of t he waveguide, a r elat ively t hick guide can
effect ively be used for single mode use
124
. For t he fundament al mode, t his
kind of guide has a r elat ively small t hat can be cancelled by a moder at e
st r ain-induced int r oduced dur ing t he film gr owt h
125
. The magnet ic
pr oper t ies of t he film ar e also influenced by t he st r ain necessar y t o achieve
a small net but it is possible t o achieve a usable device wit h t his
appr oach.
Some of t he cr it ical design decisions t hen wer e:
To use or not t o use a magnet ic bias field.
One fibr e for sending light t o t he sensing element and for r eceiving t he
signal, or separ at e fibr es for t he t wo funct ions.
The select ion of a suit able opt ical configur at ion t hat allows a measur able
pola r iza t ion modula t ion a nd a n a ccept a ble opt ica l loss. A cha nnel
waveguide st r uct ur e or a slab guide combined wit h some ot her means of
cont r olling t he light pr opagat ion ar e t wo of t he opt ions for t his pur pose.
The available select ion of film t ypes for waveguiding sensor s was quit e
small. The YIG films wer e or iginally developed for bubble memor y use and
have lat er been modified for use in display unit s, pr int er s
126,127
, wave-
guiding opt ical isolat or s
128
and sensor s.
For t he mult imode sensor s, which ar e of a mor e immediat e int er est fr om
t he applicat ion point of view, a design which is suit able for pr oduct ion must
be select ed.
I n t he mult imode ca se a la r ger select ion of useful ma t er ia ls wa s
available. The bulk YIG mat er ial t hat we init ially used for t he mult imode
sensor s was or iginally pr oduced for micr owave applicat ions and had t o be
cut and polished t o opt ical qualit y. Lat er when t he t hick (100m) epit axi-
ally gr own films wit h lar ge magnet o-opt ical r ot at ion wer e developed, mainly
for opt ical isolat or use, we could use t his t ype of mat er ial for t he mult imode
sensor s.
As t he mat er ial char act er izat ion measur ement s went on, we wer e gr adu-
ally able t o t r ansfor m t he or iginal sensor ideas envisioned at t he st ar t of t he
pr oject , int o pr act ical sensor designs. In r ealit y, of cour se, t he influence also
went t he ot her way: The sensor design ideas made fur t her measur ement s
necessar y. Below, however , t he mat er ial char act er izat ion measur ement s
and t he sensor pr ot ot ype exper iment s ar e pr esent ed in separ at e sect ions.
Hans S ohlstrm
24
4. Mat er ial char act er izat ion measur ement s
Bulk materi als
Mea sur ement opt i ons
The magnet ic and magnet o-opt ical measur ement s t hat can be made on bulk
YIG cr yst als can be divided int o t wo cat egor ies, t hose made on homoge-
neously magnetically saturated samples and t hose made on non-sat urat ed
samples. Micr oscopically, t he sat ur at ed st at e is t he only one t hat exist s and
macr oscopically, it is t he only well-defined st at e. Examples of phenomena
t hat ar e st udied ar e t he influence of mat er ial composit ion, t emper at ur e,
wavelengt h, et c. on t he sat ur at ion r ot at ion. Such measur ement s ar e of
int er est not only fr om an applicat ion point of view, but also for mat er ial
science, as t hey pr ovide infor mat ion about t he nat ur e of t he magnet ic int er -
act ions. Result s fr om t hese t ypes of measur ement s ar e, however , r elat ively
well cover ed in lit er at ur e, and will not be fur t her descr ibed her e.
For sensor applicat ions, t he pr oper t ies of YIG also at low applied fields
ar e of int er est . These include t he domain st r uct ur e and how it is influenced
by t he cr yst a l or ient a t ion, sa mple geomet r y, sa mple t r ea t ment a nd
t emper at ur e.
Some measur ement s such as t he measur ement of t he net magnet izat ion
of t he sample and it s dependence on ext er nal fact or s, can be made using
magnet ic met hods
129
. Most of t hese r esult s can, however , also be indir ect ly
obt ained fr om magnet o-opt ical measur ement s and as our main int er est is in
t he magnet o-opt ical pr oper t ies, t his is t he appr oach we have t aken. The
opt ical met hods also facilit at e changes of t he measur ement volume, which is
a key measur ement par amet er .
If t he sample is t hin and t he domains ar e lar ge enough, a focused light
beam, figur e13a, allows t he behaviour of a single domain or domain wall t o
be st udied. Ideally, wit h a beam passing t hr ough only one domain, one
should obt ain t he same r esult s as t hose obt ained for a homogeneously
sat ur at ed mat er ial. One can t hen st udy changes in t he domain magnet i-
zat ion dir ect ion and t he effect on t he magnet izat ion and magnet o-opt ical
r ot at ion caused by, for example, t emper a t ur e.
Wit h a large diamet er beam, figur e13 b, t he cont r ibut ions fr om t he
differ ent domains will be aver aged. The exact nat ur e of t he aver aging
pr ocess is r at her complicat ed as t he pat t er n of t he domains will act as a
phase gr at ing. For a t hin sample wit h a t wo-dimensional domain pat t er n as
in figur e13, t he r esult ing polar izat ion r ot at ion can oft en be appr oximat ed
using t he ar ea r at io bet ween t he t wo kinds of domains.
Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
25
E
B
Hz.
H: The performance of a fi bre opti c magneti c fi eld sensor
uti li zi ng a magneto-opti cal garnet
Hans Sohlst r m, Kjell Svant esson
The design and per for mance of a mult imode fibr e opt ic magnet ic field
sensor ut ilizing t he Far aday effect in an epit axially gr own t hick (YbTbBi)IG
film is r epor t ed. The sensor is found t o be linear over a r ange of mor e t han
100dB.
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
59
Paper r epr int s
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
Paper A
U Holm, H Sohlst r m and T Br ogr dh
Measur ement syst em for magnet o-opt ic sensor mat er ials
J . Phys. E: S ci. Instrum., vol. 17, p. 885889, 1984.
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
Paper B
U. Holm, H. Sohlst r m and T. Br ogr dh
YIG-sensor design for fibr e opt ical magnet ic field measur ement
OFS 84, R. Th. Ker st en and R. Kist , p. 333336, VDE-Ver lag, Ber lin, 1984.
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
Paper C
U. Holm and H. Sohlst r m
Measurement of YIG crystal characteristics
for the design of optical magnetic field sensors
TR84.01, Inst r ument at ion Labor at or y;
Royal Inst it ut e of Technology, St ockholm, 1984.
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
Paper D
H. Sohlst r m, U. Holm and K. Svant esson
A Polar izat ion Based Fibr e Opt ical Sensor Syst em
Using a YIG Opt ical Waveguide for Magnet ic Field Sensing
S pringer proceedings in Physics 44: Optical Fiber S ensors, H. J . Ar dit t y,
J . P. Dakin, and R. Th. Ker st en, p. 273278, Spr inger -Ver lag, Ber lin, 1989.
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
Paper E
H. Sohlst r m, U. Holm and K. G. Svant esson
Char act er izat ion of Magnet oopt ical Thin Films for Sensor Use
S PIE Proc Electro-Optic and Magneto-Optic Materials and Applications,
J . P. Cast er a, vol. 1126, p. 7784, 1989.
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
Paper F
K. Svant esson, H. Sohlst r m and U. Holm
Magnet o-opt ical gar net mat er ials in fibr e opt ic
sensor syst ems for magnet ic field sensing
S PIE Proc Electro-Optic and Magneto-Optic Materials and Applications II,
H. Dammann, vol. 1274, p.260269, 1990.
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
Paper G
H. Sohlst r m and K. Svant esson
A waveguide based fibr e opt ic magnet ic field sensor
wit h dir ect ional sensit ivit y
S PIE Proc Fiber Optic S ensors: Engineering and Applications,
A. J . Br uinsma and B. Culshaw, vol. 1511, p. 142148, 1991.
Hans S ohlstrm: Fibre Optic Magnetic Field S ensors Utilizing Iron Garnet Materials
Paper H
H. Sohlst r m and K. Svant esson
The per for mance of a fibr e opt ic magnet ic field sensor
ut ilizing a magnet o-opt ical gar net
Fiber and Integrated Optics, vol. 11, p.135139, 1992.
Also pr esent ed at t he OFS 8 confer ence in Mont er ey, J an. 92.