Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
In this
ISSUE
From the Desk
CEOs Viewpoint BUDGET - From Consumer
Mortgages
Auction - the solution
Research
Halal Claims must be substantiated
Misleading Advertisements
02 03 06 08 12 13
BUDGET 2012
Cigarettes and alcohol. Imported exercise books. Blank DVDs and CDs. Palm Oil. Chinese salt. Nails. Nylon Ropes. Departure Tax. A 1% levy is imposed on all voice call charges such as landline calls, mobile phone post pay, mobile phone top up cards or prepay. Luxury cars exceeding 2500cc but not exceeding 3000cc. Luxury cars such as four wheel drives with cylinder capacity exceeding 3000cc. A 2% levy is imposed on credit card balance. As a consumer, one needs to analyze, understand and grasp the information in order to fully utilize the benets made available through the 2012 Budget. Signicantly, the budget should also remind consumers to control their spending in other areas where prices have gone up. The purchasing power always lies in consumers hands and the decisions they make are therefore important. Proper planning, budgeting and savings will put consumers in a stable position looking forward to a more secure future.
The announcement of any national budget affects a consumer in many ways. The 2012 Budget announcement has certainly made our consumers happier. For instance, the reduction in income tax (PAYE) and pay rise for civil servants are welcoming news. For consumers in general, life has been made a little easier with benets in a number of areas. This can be seen as a relief, especially in these hard, trying times with the rising cost of living. The 2012 budget also allows a lot of room for consumers to save that will ultimately put them in a better nancial position. For this, you need to make the right choices and know what areas to spend on. It is important for consumers to be fully informed about the available benets and to realize the impact of their spending. Consumers can expect to pay less for the following items: Imported fruits such as apples, grapes and oranges. Imported vegetables such as broccoli and celery. Musical instruments such as piano. Sports equipment such as table tennis sets. Knitted fabrics. Every coin has two sides, hence the benets come with critical and cautious side. This is where consumers need to be smart, responsible and more careful with their spending. Consumers can expect to pay more for the following items/services: Imported canned sh.
Complaints
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down
Consumer Advice
Christmas Shopping Tips Buy Fiji made
Distribution CCoF
seasons greetings
Point
CEOs View
Once again we have come to the end of the year when everyone is in festive mood. Its a time when consumers get tempted to spend more and many take a break to relax with family and friends.
However, this is the time when consumers need to be most cautious and practical about their needs and wants. Many in the excitement of getting bonus or back pay may spend unwisely and without thinking. This should be avoided at all times as impulse buying will definitely affect your financial status in the weeks to come. There will be massive sales advertised in every shopping outlet luring consumers to spend but as a smart and responsible consumer, you need to ask yourself what you really need and if you are getting the real bargain for your hard earned money. Look around for the best available prices rather than being comfortable with one place. Examine the quality of goods you are buying and keep all receipts should you require a redress later. Make a budget for yourself and specify what you really need. This should give you a clearer picture and stop you from unnecessary spending. If there is a surplus than save it for better use in future. Consumers need to be vigilant and better organized with their spending. This has been a tough year for many with the increasing price of goods and services. Not to mention the latest increase in taxi fares - a service that majority of consumers rely heavily upon, especially during busy shopping periods. Consumers are urged to look for alternative and cheaper modes of transport. You need to be prepared for the challenges in the New Year. On behalf of the Council, I wish all consumers a Merry Christmas and a very happy New Year.
this of course is expected to become a thing of the past. 98% of the passengers, drivers and taxi operators interviewed by the Council are against the new taxi fare increase. This is also evident from the daily newspaper articles and letters to the editors column. People have also been expressing their concerns through radio talkback shows and media at large. The Consumer Council had a significant number of complaints including taxi owners who were unhappy with the exorbitant fare increase.
Advice to Consumers Weigh your travelling options- consumers should make wise decisions to choose the cheapest mode of transportation. One should analyze whether they really need taxi for travel and if it can be replaced by bus or mini vans. Walking home- this would be another healthy option. Walking, if home is close by, for those without the burden of carrying groceries or other luggage would be a wise option. Daylight savings-consumers to make the right use of daylight savings by walking home. Use your alarm to get up in the morning to avoid using taxis should you miss your regular transport. Car pooling- consumers are encouraged to practise car pooling, ie, catching a ride to and from work in a friends or neighbours vehicle if travelling from the same area (sharing a ride with friends or neighbours). Taxi pooling-consumers can team up and share a taxi when the need arises. This will not only save consumers some cash but is environmentally friendly as well.
Mistri Trisameta Solomon Islands As a private student at USP, it affects me because we dont work. If the taxi fare can go back to its normal rate, then it would really be good for us private regional students. Eroni Kotoiwasawasa Cunningham The way I see it the taxi fare increase is not a good initiative because our wages remains stagnant while everything else is increasing, like food etc. And these days its very hard to take our shopping home, even under rainy conditions because we fear what we have to pay and the longer the distance, the higher the fare. I think the taxi fare should go back to its normal rate.
How to calculate your new fare: Old fare multiply by 2 then subtract $1.50 For example, if your old fare was $3 than the new fare would be: $3x2= $6-$1.50= $4.50
MONEY TALKS
FINANCIAL LITERACY:
Why the Need?
Financial literacy can be defined as the ability to make the right decisions when it comes to managing your personal finances. Financial literacy is all about how the decisions you make affect your future financial stability. An assessment of the complaints received by the Council shows that majority of the financial and credit problems which are faced by consumers is due to the lack of basic understanding of rights and responsibilities when it comes to borrowing money or purchasing goods and services on credit. As a result, many consumers tend to over commit to credit, are not able to make payments on time and are not aware of protection mechanisms under the Consumer Credit Act. In these hard economic times when prices of goods and services are rising is a harsh reminder of how important understanding financial matters are. Everyday transactions and financial decisions pave the way for the consumer to make bigger decisions like being able to buy a house or to invest in a car. Through information and objective advice, consumers are able to develop the skills and confidence to become well informed of the financial risks and opportunities. They need to make informed choices to improve the status of their finances. For Consumers to have access to just, fair and competitive financial services, it is essential that information is available through education. This will allow consumers to make informed choices in the market place. Once consumers are empowered with the right skills a n d knowledge, credit providers and financial institutions will be forced to re-look at their contracts and market practices. This empowerment will manifest itself when consumers are able to read and question the fine print clauses that deny them the remedy and right to redress. Consumer financial literacy is an economic and social empowerment tool. It provides consumers with a better understanding of the mechanics of financial institutions. Consumers become more aware and vigilant when they enter into credit agreements to ensure that their rights are protected and put an end to consumer exploitation. Therefore, all consumers need to be financially literate in order to protect their rights and also make informed decisions when it comes to their finances.
Case Study
Mr. Daniel was facing financial difficulties in making repayment for his loan taken from a credit provider. He requested changes in time period but the Institution failed to consider his request. They even threatened him with phone calls every day to either fully clear the account or the Institution will repossess his item which he took on Hire Purchase. Frustrated and nowhere else to go, Mr. Daniel lodged the complaint with the Council. Councils Action Upon Councils intervention, the respondent was willing to have a meeting with Mr. Daniel and made arrangement to extend the payment period. Daniel was very happy with the outcome of his case. TIP OF THE DAY You have the right to apply for changes in repayments period on the grounds of hardship provided that you discuss your hardship issues with your credit provider. It should however be noted that interest will continue to accumulate until you have paid off the arrears.
the couple then decided to go through the agreement which they had signed. They were shocked and stunned to find out that the interest rate for their loan was 24% and that a purchase Agreement was made instead of a Bill of Sale. On the same weekend, the Council had made comments on hire purchase sale in one of the newspapers which the couple came across. Without further delay, they lodged their complaint with the Council on the high interest rate charged by the institution. Councils Action Upon Councils intervention, the institution disclosed some of the vital information which should have been done before signing the contract. It was revealed that the interest rate was 13.5% and 24% was the default rate. The institution stated that if the interest rate was 24%, they would then be making much higher repayments than what they were currently paying. It was also explained that the institution does not prepare a Bill of Sale to save additional costs for the consumer. In addition, Mr. and Mrs. Benaab were advised that the Institution can also restructure their loan repayment upon request. TIP OF THE DAY Before entering into a credit contract, consumers are to demand for pre-disclosure and to check the interest rate.
Case Study 2
Mr. and Mrs. Benaab took a loan to purchase a vehicle. With all the excitement and exhilaration, the couple signed the agreement and paid a deposit. After making their first monthly installment,
es a provid ers ers. It e consum sum Cons e con it to ensur ns before Is for th cred io What f decis guard l safe provision o informed ices. lega rv make ct is a or the or se The A mework f allowed to for goods redit t fra hen c legal tected and it contrac ents w disclose ed ro uirem fully are p g into a cr . It e req o plianc e drafted t formation terin om en um c ation ar ent in erests. minim inform pertin wn int other down o er It sets ts and oth ditions and otect their to pr ntrac and con rs co sume rms the te es the con at motiv
Cre umer
dit A
ct?
cts) ontra itten c r es (w s) ry not ff loan misso and it e (Sta d pro n ye policy ents a emplo rance u estm edit to life ins policy. Inv ing cr ainst dit ag alue of the yer giv plo d cre der v Em rovide en ops/ who p ed the surr ies ibilit orksh urer ing w nsumers spons s hire Ins not exce hold nd re uch a does ble co sently hts a Act? s t is pre he vulnera r the for rig providers tions. It se ole f Fiji cate t ls R vide ed fo u o ci Act. n pro A Ne credit gh under l instit uncil to edu Coun Why throu er the gulatio as well as er financia adhere to er Co d Re nsum ampaigns ibilities und th round ns and o s o ct an nd o ave t s umer the g mpaig The C rs and c The A the cons s, banks a orrowers h espon le on ca ss on and r b mina nder th nie peop s, media u se arene e hts of bo se compa nders and r ig h t s ilities. eir rig te aw ing th hool visit a t e a le on th targe ts, sc to cre d h a v esponsib purch es which n ions cil is lso r ay an n are a Coun engageme ial institut e a s hts and uideli , s. g av The rig banks y focu ls o h w. inanc nity ils ke e r s a ave equal s such as the la mmu lks with f nc edit co h p r o v id ta tion nd cr e Cou c r e d it th parties cial institu it Act. ins th olding ent a . This is aware a h n The d o n agem dvice t rem are u ce, it ct. ct. B r fina er Cre a they t man the dit Ac the A the A and othe e Consum ause them. Hen f the e deb ho require o educate er Cre fre bec um s Cons vides umers w nization t s. rader d under th loited ailable to e aware o T p The r w pro cons b et ex ies av ga cte sume e rs to cil no he or still g d prote eds Coun vices to th iatives of t ted as con mers and reme r consume rk ne The r c onsu y init hts rote nt fo re wo f such ly, c ry se o man hts are p Sad al rig ly importa at mo nce o advis ir leg of the rig ws th te s of the es extreme st one how their d sho ut the exis good ju he roun ecom tence. own t lic on the g mers abo b n pub ent to to: ct in exis eck o ith int consu able Acts edit A m ch pplic redit w e.g er Cr ando e to inform c A r Ar ct is es on ample: onsum ee (fo don arant servic x The A is a C to be ed gu s and ents, for e here uva, elat . that t f good llm s of S t or r a law Sale o g in insta aware ntrac street un e yin dit co on th mazed le are by pa er cre rewed Peop e und tervie y were a o ask for p t in . ag place eople w. The Mortg an) ht t abou of p la lo tor e a rig w much he ajority f this uaran ged o home y hav ere t The m naware o ld that the id not kn fees char and G ts wh s) d tees u d ntrac entitie o co aran were hey were t ures; they harges an Gu d sale ferent c t s e (relate are two dif rchas when tual disclo s, hidden d a ers e Pu ey ha ntrac anty work Hir Provid financier co dit at th hem to h re the warr are t ows t ked C r and how creditors. tracts unaw all Lin s provide their e Con he were t, which cture nc d by t good Ac restru Insura s) stione e m to lated in the ct ter ity qu tions dit Re ontra Major ion clause cial institu hips. Cre ses (c t t s n c s and uc er Lea prote t their fina faced hard Cond uation onsum y ral sit le state of lated sehold es e e u C d Re requ s if th d sev lnerab for ho shop) ing an ment ntere u nal or e to: e repay dvertis encou epict the v icabl perso your coffe pl A tic, has ot Ap omes nder for uncil t clearly d N d o ct is e not g a ble The C ints tha ich ar The A ts wh mple buyin ompla ers. n c xa estme m Inv oses (for e consu p pur ities activ ercial Comm
ER SUM ON C
CT IT A RED C
MORTGAGEE
SALE
Real estate law change
The Consumer Council of Fiji welcomes Governments latest initiative to strengthen laws and regulations governing the real estate sector. The amendments to the Real Estate Agents Act bring about and ensure the much needed transparency in the system. The amended law governing the real estate business has been effective since November 15th this year. This will now prohibit the involvement of lawyers acting on behalf of financial institutions to dispose of properties by mortgagee sale. The Council hopes, with the elimination of lawyers from engaging directly into the actual process of mortgagee sales, home owners will be allowed to be part of the tender opening and tender awarding process. This will allow the property to be sold at actual market value and do justice to the home owner in getting the best deal.
The Real Estate Licensing Board has a very critical role to play now as they are empowered to take action to enforce the Real Estate Agents Act 2006 given reasonable cause that provisions of the decree are being contravened. The feedback from the Real Estate Licensing Board has been positive and encouraging as a number of fraud practices are under investigation and the Board welcomes consumers to lodge complaints on unfair practices existing in the market place. The Council believes the changes will not only protect home owners but empower the board to effectively carry out its mandate. The Council hopes that strengthening of the regulations will bring about fairness and more transparency, particularly in mortgagee sales. The Council also hopes to see the rights and interests of home owners protected with the amendment made to Real Estate Agents Act.
Problems Sale
with
Mortgagee
The Council has been receiving a number of complaints from consumers when it comes to mortgage sale. Some cases are unbelievable where the behavior of the financial institutions and their lawyers are shocking. Below are some of the main problems associated with mortgage sale. Some unscrupulous lawyers represent all three parties i.e. financial institution, seller and the buyer and this information is not disclosed to the parties. The pre-disclosure (full information prior to any confirmed deal) is not given to the buyer.
Auctions ca n be guided by the regu the bidding pr lations ocess so that everyone know to control and obligatio ns. This wou s their rights ld avoid disc system. repancies in the Unlike mortg agee sales, auctions can market value reveal the tr of a property ue open forum and are cond where all bids ucted in an are known an are given imm d participants ediate feedba ck on the prop ertys value. Auctions el iminate long negotiation interests keep periods whe on accumul re ating. Buyer they are com s peting fairly and on the sa would know other buyers me terms as and receive all comprehensi property via ve informatio due diligence n on packet. Any consum er taking pa rt in an au and quickly ction can ea make marke sily t comparison biddings at th s when they e same plac see e and at the same time.
e Solution Public auctio ns would be a fairer and way of selling more transp mortgaged pr arent operties. This would gi ve the buyer a good barg debt free as ain and be well.
Auction-Th
The consumer pays for the legal fees and yet is not allowed to choose his/her own lawyer. Home owners are not informed by the financial institution or lawyers on how much fees he/ she is expected to pay. The information on the amount owed by the homeowner is leaked by solicitors and bank officers to other bank staff or their acquaintances. Neither the financial institutions nor the lawyers provides a final statement to the home owner giving details such as what was owed to the financial institution, how much the property was sold for, any reimbursement of insurance, other fees and charges, what is the accrued interest etc.
The surplus from the sale of the house is not given to the homeowner and yet the shortfall is expected to be accommodated by the home owner. Most borrowers receive very little information on financial hardship from
The buyer is never informed that there are two types of insurance and one is not compulsory. The buyer, not knowing this, ends up paying for both. The lack of transparency, whereby a home owner is left in the dark without having a say in disposing his or her property. 6 | Consumer WATCH December 2011
lenders. Many of the standard letters sent to defaulting borrowers are not clear. Home owners are excluded from the tender opening and awarding process.
FRESH INITIATIVE
noqu DINAU
DEBT MANAGEMENT AND CONSUMER ADVISORY SERVICES
How often do we find ourselves caught up in debt? Borrowing as low as $2 from a friend or workmate for bus fare puts you in debt unless the money is returned. Debt simply means when you owe somebody money. It gets bigger every week if you are charged interest. Interest is an extra charge on the original debt. The Consumer Council of Fiji, under the AusAID project titled Consumer Financial Protection and Building Credit Competency for Vulnerable Groups launched its first ever pilot program on Debt Management and Consumer Credit Advisory Services in September 2011 in Suva. The overall objective of the service is to provide assistance to consumers who are in debt by giving them advice on their current financial problems and help them reorganize their finances so that they are in a better position to pay it off without sinking deeper into the vicious cycle. The Council aims to promote and encourage holistic changes in the way consumers use and manage their money (income) with smart spending habits combined with debt management skills. This new service offered by the Council anticipates empowering consumers to borrow and manage debt wisely. We all need money to survive but how to use the money is the real issue. The Council has produced brochures and posters on Debt Management and Consumer Credit Advisory Services mainly to educate the consumers on the free Debt Management and Consumer Credit Advisory Services in Suva. You can find this informative brochure on our website www.consumersfiji.org Through this service, the Council intends to assist the repayment of the consumers debt by helping them to create a payment plan to get their debts under control, better understand their rights and responsibilities in relation to their payments and establish a budget. Whilst the initiative has been taken by the Council to assist the consumers in managing their debts, it will not: lend money to consumers to pay off their debts, or be a guarantor for any loans or mortgages which consumers undertake, or take responsibility to ensure consumers debts are paid on time. Since it is a pilot project, this service will only be available to the consumers residing in the central division.
Proudly supported by Ausaid The Debt Management and Consumer Credit Advisory Services is proudly supported and funded by the AusAid. AusAid First Secretary for Development and Cooperation Mr Timothy Gill, at the launch of the project, urged Consumers towards becoming financially literate so as to become better informed of their rights and obligations when entering into Credit Contracts. Australia is a major supporter of financial inclusion in Fiji and is committed to improving access to financial services to break down the barriers to economic participation by the poor, said Mr Gill. CASE STUDY (Below is a real case study that the Council is handling at the moment) A worried and depressed Mrs Singh came to the Council with a huge debt she had no idea how to control, let alone clear. She was in great need of advice on how to manage her debts. Mrs Singh had a personal loan with the bank, a mortgage to pay off, unpaid utility bills and debts she owed to money lenders. The Council has advised Mrs Singh that while her loan with the bank is directly deducted at source, she needs to find additional work to supplement her income. The Council strongly advised
Mr Gill stated that the new Consumer Credit Advisory Services that will be offered by the Council will allow people in the Suva Nausori corridor to get the assistance they need to better manage their debt and the Financial Literacy workshop will provide a platform where consumers will be able to better understand their rights as borrowers. According to Mr Gill, this situation illustrates the level of indebtedness of many Fijian households, especially the poor as they often do not qualify for cheaper sources of finance. It further strengthens the need for a debt management and credit advisory service to help poor consumers find their way out of this debt trap, he said.
her not to take loans anymore from either money lenders, friends or family. Mrs Singh and her husband are now looking at buying a brush cutter to start their own grass cutting business to supplement their existing income and help them start paying off their debts. The Council will continue to assist and guide consumers to effectively manage their debts and grow out of it. We welcome members of the public to take advantage of this free service. Remember out-of-control debt can have a long term effect on your future. You could lose your home, your family, and your entire life savings.
RESEARCH
CASE STUDY
CASE STUDY
IN August this year, Foods Pacific Limited (FPL), producers of Golden Country canned meat was forced to remove the term halal on one of their corned mutton products after they failed to substantiate this claim. This followed concerns raised by the Fiji Muslim League (FML) FPL had provided halal certification, but these were for their New Zealand supplier on the raw lamb products that they imported. The FML clarified that halal approval and certification for a food product is done for the entire processing of the product and not in parts. That is, the whole process from the slaughtering of the animal right up to the final product, in this case corned mutton, had to be fully halal compliant. After nearly 5 months of correspondence between the Council and FPL, the company finally removed the word halal from its product. In mid-August FPL began removing the product from its wholesalers and retailers. It also stopped using halal on its label and would only do so through proper certification. Consumers who come across the term halal on food labels, in restaurants, and other food establishments are urged to check with the Fiji Muslim League or the Consumer Council. The Council found that the certificate was actually issued by the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils (AFIC) to Edlyn Foods, one of Nandos main suppliers in Australia. AFIC informed the Council that the certificate was applicable only to the organisation they issued it to, that is Edlyn Foods, and not Nandos. AFIC added that Nandos should obtain a certificate from the Fiji Muslim League. Furthermore, the Australian organisation highlighted that having ingredients certified halal does not make the final product halal. Nandos ended up removing the certificate from its restaurants. In fact they had violated the Food Safety Regulations 2009 requirements for substantiation. Fortunately for them they were not penalised as they took quick action in removing the hala certificate being displayed in their restaurants.
specify that only particular meals were applicable. The ad said customers can purchase the 50c glass if they purchased any meal. However, after a complaint was lodged with the Council, McDonalds clarified that the promotion was applicable only for purchases of its McValue meals. The complainant was provided compensation by McDonalds. The Council is concerned that some businesses allow promotional posters to remain on shop windows and in public places after the promotion has ended. While the concerned businesses tended to blame the retailers, the Council reminded them that they were the promoters and thus also had the responsibility to remove these posters. December 2011 Consumer WATCH | 9
The Consumer Council of Fiji received a total of 1911 complaints for the first 10 months of this year (January to October). These are registered complaints
From January to October, the Council received 1,911 complaints. These complaints had a monetary value of close to $3.3m. The Council assisted 1202 consumers saving them close to $2m. This was resolved through mediation with the parties concerned. Complaints on Landlord/Tenancy, Electronic Goods and FEA are the top three respectively. The most popular complaint in the second half of the year was on the much talked about FEA security deposit. Consumers failed to understand why they had to meet with a sudden demand on the security deposit when their bills were up to date. For some, this sudden increase had a huge impact on their budget. The latest statistics from our Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Division showed that the Council received a total of 141 complaints on FEA Security Deposit let alone the numerous enquiries and advice sought on this issue. The second highest complaint was on electronic goods with a total of 144 complaints. Traders continue to dupe consumers by selling faulty and damaged electronic goods. We urge consumers to be vigilant in this area. The Council is deeply concerned with the high number of complaints in the landlord and tenancy area as it received the highest number of complaints at 203 and continues to lead the complaints table for the past 3 years. The next on the list of complaints is on mobile products as 136 complaints on faulty and damaged mobile phones were lodged with the Council. Majority of the omplaints were lodged against Dickson International in Suva. Other complaints that made the top 10 of the list are WAF water, banks & other financial institutions, hire purchase/lay-by, spare parts and grocery. The Council will continue to protect and fight for consumers to ensure there is a level playing field in the marketplace. The Councils ultimate aim is to have confident and empowered consumers in society who are able to choose the best deals, demand better products or services and resolve problems when things go wrong. This will bring about innovation, competition and growth for the country as a whole.
Case Study 1: Small Claims Tribunal (SCT) Mr Singh had entered into a deal with his brother-in-law over the sale of a vehicle which was not transferred to him as both parties had agreed to have it done after he had made his final. There was a dispute later over the transfer so Mr. Singh sought help from the Small Claims Tribunal. But the Tribunal dismissed Mr. Singhs claim, saying there was no documentary evidence. Mr. Singh was aggrieved. He contacted the Consumer Council for assistance. He believed his case was not properly heard and upon our advice, the Small Claims Tribunal re-opened his case. Our Advice: It is your duty as consumers to ensure your rights are upheld. If you believe you have not received justice over a credit deal that you have entered into, you have the right to reopen the case. Also, consumers are expected to demand for and keep all the documents safely so they can produce them in any hearing when required. Your Right: When your case is referred to the SCT, you have a right to be heard fairly. The primary function of a Tribunal is to attempt to bring the disputed parties to an agreed settlement. The Tribunal shall determine the dispute according to the substantial 10 | Consumer WATCH December 2011
merit and justice of the case and in doing so shall have regard to the law but shall not be bound to give effect to strict legal rights or obligations or to actual forms or technicalities. If you are aggrieved with the outcome of the Tribunal in that you feel that it maybe unfair, you should seek for the hearing of your case. Case Study 2: Accepting Payment without being able to Supply as Ordered The complainant had placed a special order with a car company for the purchase of a vehicle to be manufactured with the special features. The initial quote was for $115,000.00 inclusive of all the special features that the complainant wanted and the respondent agreed that they would provide. The complainant had made a deposit of $38,400.00 before the order was made to the manufacturer and had further arranged for a loan from the bank to pay the balance of $76,000.00. Before the arrival of the vehicle into the country, the car company had then advised the complainant that he was to pay an extra $5000.00, bumping up the initial cost of the vehicle from $115,000.00 to $120,000.00. The complainant was not too happy with what the car company demanded and lodged a complaint with the Council.
Top 10 Reoccurring Complaints for Jan - Oct 2011 Types of Complaint Landlord/Tenant Electronic goods (computers etc) FEA Electricity Mobile products WAF Water Banks & other Financial Institutions Hire Purchase/Lay-By Groceries Spare parts Monetary Value for Complaints received by Council for Jan-Oct Complaints Registered Resolved Cases Cases referred to Small Claims Tribunal Total Dollar Value $3,391,913.86 $1,931,657.93 $109,760.70 Total Received 203 144 141 136 110 62 55 48 44
280 240 200 160 120 80 40 0 WAF - Water Hire Purchase / Lay-By Groceries Landlord/Tenant Mobile products FEA = Electricity Banks & other Financial Institutions Electronic Goods (Computers etc) Spare parts 144 141 136 110 62 55 48 44 203 Series 1
Total Received
Consumer Complaints Jan - Oct 2011 Types of Complaint Registered Resolved Small Claims Tribunal SCT Other Total 1911 1202 139 330
17.26% Resolved 62.89% Small Claims Tribunal (SCT) 7.27% Resolved 17.26%
Percentage of Complaint
Percentage of Complaint
7.27%
62.89%
Upon the Councils intervention, the car company was advised that they were in breach of Section 88 of the Commerce Commission Decree accepting payment without being able to supply as ordered. It then agreed to supply the car to the complainant without the extra $5000.00. Our advice: Consumers should be aware and only pay for what was agreed to at the beginning. Ensure this is given in writing. Suppliers must supply what they had accepted payment for. If there shall be any fluctuations in price due to unforeseen circumstances, it should be stated in their quotations and or invoices. Your right: You have a right to demand what you have rightfully paid for. If there are any changes to the agreed price, it has to be agreed to between the parties and adequate reasons should also be given.
Case Study 3: Misleading Advertisement Mr. Yiu saw an advertisement Early Bird Offer in the dailies, in which he had to spend more than $300 in order to qualify to enjoy the offer. The next morning he went to the store at 8.30am, shopped for $663 and cashed in at 8.31am. As he asked to purchase the item under the early bird offer, he was advised that item was not available. Frustrated he lodged a complaint with the Council. The Council asked the store to explain how the items under the Early Bird Offer could be sold in just one minute. The store accepted the Councils justification, obtained the item from another branch and provided it to Mr. Yiu. Our Advice: Consumers should retain their receipts each time they purchase anything. It is important in cases like this especially when consumers want redress. Receipts and dockets are necessary as they act as a proof of purchase. Your Right: You have a right to raise concerns should you feel you have been cheated and misled by any advertisement.
THUMBS UP
1. Vodafone Fiji Ltd Consolation Prize from Vodafone 888 Texting Promotion The complainant had won a consolation prize through entering the above texting promotion during the Hibiscus festival. She went to a Vodafone shop to collect her gift voucher and was also advised that she needed to redeem her prize at the store that sponsored her. Upon going to that store, she was advised that the time frame for which she was supposed to redeem her prize was over and that she could no longer claim it. She had then gone back to the Vodafone store and was also advised the same. Upon the Councils intervention, Vodafone delivered the consolation prize to her doorstep along with $25 cash to compensate her for all the hassle and travelling around she did to redeem her prize. Vodafone will also be looking into the possibility of going without all the consolation prizes in next years texting promotion. 2. Courts Fiji Ltd (providing replacement) Courts gave a new replacement bed for the return of a faulty mobile phone that was purchased from them. The complainants account was also credited with $199 from the mobile phone account and the payment term was extended for another year. 3. Melbourne Building Works (Satisfactory Refund) Complainant paid for a double bed to be tailor made as per the catalogue. However, this was not provided to the complainant on time. Upon the Councils intervention, Complainant was provided with a bed while his order was still being made. Respondent could not finish the order on time, therefore, provided full refund as promised upon the customers request. 4. DIGICEL (For practicing conditional selling) The Council received complaints against Digicel selling mobile phones under the condition that unless $10 recharge card was purchased the mobile phone couldnt be purchased. The displayed price of a $35 mobile phone was actually purchased at $45 due to the recharge card. Upon the Councils intervention, Digicel made amendments and cancelled all conditional selling. 5. WATER AUTHORITY OF FIJI (For rechecking the water meter) The complainant was disappointed with his water bill of $81.65 when all his previous bills ranged from $6.00-$9.00. He was informed by the respondent that the bill was correct. The Council intervened and had the complainants meter was rechecked by the respondent to find that the reading was incorrect. The complainant was then issued a new and accurate bill of $10.95. 6. McDonalds RADIO ADVERTISEMENT A radio Advertisement stated that for every purchase of a meal from Mc Donalds consumers could purchase the Coca Cola glass for $0.50, however this was only applicable, when purchasing Mc Value meals. Through the Councils intervention, McDonalds made amendments to the advertisement and offered a free Mc Value meal to the complainant on the same day.
THUMBS DOWN
1. Fiji Care Insurance (Unfair Terms & Conditions) The complainant had an insurance policy, which stated a payout of the damages sustained in the event of theft. The complainants vehicle was stolen and involved in an accident but Fiji Care refused to pay out stating that the vehicles wheel tax was not valid at the time of the accident. The policy was silent on this. The case has been further referred to the Reserve Bank of Fiji. 2. Annan Motors (deferring payout of vehicle parts) The complainant gave his vehicle which was involved in an accident for repairs to the respondent. However, the complainant found out that LTA would not pass that vehicle, therefore he sought a refund. The respondent agreed to provide partial refund and the rest to be refunded later. Therefore respondent also agreed to buy the vehicle and sell it as spare parts; however he kept on extending the date for the payment. The case has further been referred to the Small Claims Tribunal, as the respondent did not commit to his payment deadline. 3. Dickson International Ltd (faulty products being sold) Numerous complaints have been lodged with the Council concerning the quality of electronic goods purchased from this store, mostly mobile phones. Products sold at this store are mostly China-made and develop problems within a week or two from the time of purchase. When consumers try to rectify the problems with the store, they are usually given the run around or shown warranty conditions that werent disclosed to the consumer at the time of purchase; or given replacement items which are second hand again not to the knowledge of the consumer. 4. Telecom Fiji Limited (Non availability of battery) The complainant had purchased an Alcatel Dual Sim from TFL. When the battery was faulty; the complainant had approached TFL and was advised that the battery was out of stock and an order had been placed for but was yet to arrive. After a few months the complainant still had not received the battery. 5. SKY Pacific (For Unsatisfactory Services in the Northern Division) Customers of Sky Pacific in the North have lodged complaints and grievances against the company for providing unsatisfactory services. Complainants are paying a monthly fee and are then required to call Sky Pacific Office in Suva to inform that the monthly bill has been paid since there is no office in Labasa. Most of the time when consumers call Suva Sky Pacific office they are placed on hold or are transferred from one line to another which is time consuming and increases phone bill at the same time. The Council has tried to contact Sky Pacific however no response from Sky Pacific has been received regarding this. 6. MORRIS HEDSTROM (MISLEADING ADVERTISEMENTS) Misleading price tags on the shelves. Price display for lettuce is $18.99/kg but they charged $24.99. Misleading advertisement; advertised 13kg Fiji Gas in the news papers but only 12kg Fiji Gas is available.
Christmas is celebrated with much enthusiasm and joy. It is a time for giving and togetherness. Flush with the extra cash available in the form of bonus and back pay, consumers are eager to splurge on festive shopping. However during this festive season, consumers should consider the following: The consumers must practice comparative shopping where they need to check different stores for the best available prices in the market Make a shopping list and buy only what you need. Avoid impulse buying as this leads to regrets later Consider buying Fiji made products to promote growth locally Do not buy items from street hawkers as there is no guarantee for the product and a redress is impossible since no receipt is issued Do not get trapped into zero deposit or three months interest free promotions by hire purchase companies. Dont purchase for the sake of a hyped up advertised sale Demand for a pre-disclosure and find out all details including the warranty conditions and the annual interest rate Be careful of Buy One and Get One Free promotions. Sometimes such promotions are used to get rid of inferior quality products or products that are not fast moving. It is not necessary to buy expensive gifts. Home-made art and craft gifts are much more admirable than an expensive
one sitting in the store. A cheaper option is to stick to exchange of Christmas goodies such as juice and cakes with friends and families as a gift token to uphold Christmas spirit. Home baked cakes and biscuits are an option to consider rather than buying imported, expensive cakes. Always check the expiry date of any product you are purchasing and keep all the receipts Be alert and ensure you are paying the advertised price. Do your own calculation. Carry a calculator. Dont fall for bait advertising where traders advertise few items that are not in stock to lure you in your stores. Avoid doing last minute shopping as this makes one spend more
You can help provide for our Fijian families! 2 Every time you buy Fijian made products you are helping to provide for our Fijian families. A very substantial number of Fijians are employed by Fijian manufacturers. When you buy products made by these manufacturers you are helping every worker provide stability for their family. It means our Fijian families can continue to afford a decent life. You can help secure our childrens future! 3 Every time you buy Fijian made products you ensure that our children have a secure future. Our local manufacturing companies will grow and this will mean more jobs for us and our children. It means our jobs can be protected by us, with the buying decisions we make. The economy can grow because of your buying! 4 The more Fijian made products you buy the more our Fijian companies will grow. When these companies grow, they hire more people, contribute more tax dollars and even export more products which in turn bring in more income into the country. It means we have a strong economy and a stable financial environment for all of us.
SUBMISSIONS
FIJI NATIONAL PROVIDENT FUND Proposed changes to pension policy In this submission the Council objected to the downward review of the FNPF pension rate as it is unfair and breaches the contract between members and the fund. Pensioners make their pension optional with the FNPF on the explicit understanding that there would be no changes to the pension nor would it be revoked. MINISTRY OF FINANCE 2012 National Budget The Councils annual submission on the National Budget requested the Government to consider measures to relieve consumer hardships for its upcoming 2012 Budget. The Council highlighted the rising cost of living based on its regular supermarket price survey, changes in fuel prices, increase in electricity tariffs and so forth. MINISTRY OF HEALTH Draft Restaurant Grading Regulations 2011 Submission on Food Establishment (Grading) Regulations 2011 requested consideration by the Ministry of Health on issues raised by the Council to strengthen the regulations. The Council made its submission on the draft regulation calling for the strengthening of the enforcement and penalties provisions, in the regulations.
INTERNATIONAL NEWS
THE Consumer Council of Fiji is participating in a new campaign led by Consumers International (CI) on consumer issues surrounding broadband Internet services. CI has commenced the campaign of research-based advocacy titled Holding Broadband Service Providers to Account. The research and campaign will end in early 2012. It involves research and advocacy to bring to the fore pressing consumer issues around broadband Internet. Holding Broadband Services Providers to account is part of the global consumer movements bigger campaign titled Access to Knowledge (A2K). The campaign aims to empower consumer organisations around the world to demand more equitable and accessible broadband service offerings, respecting consumers rights and broader human rights, as a necessary condition of achieving a socially-inclusive information society. Internet access has become fundamental to the lives of todays consumers, and will only continue to become more important in developed and developing countries alike. The Consumer Councils participation in the campaign comes at a crucial time when consumers in Fiji are facing a multitude issues in the provision of Internet services. Apart from complaints on connectivity, consumers in Fiji also face problems in regards to misleading advertisements, lack
Your 8 cons
The right to safety
umer rights
The right to The right to consumer education The right to a healthy envi ro The right to redress
nment
service