Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses
Late summer and fall have been very volatile and filled with disturbing economic news. Major global and economic events occurring around the world will have a major impact on the markets and our investments over the coming year. Where are we going from here? Should we be pessimistic or optimistic? Let's examine current events to try and understand what might shape future returns in the investment markets.
Stocks
As a citizen and as a father, I am disappointed and deeply concerned about the amount of money we're printing both here in the US and in other countries around the world. This out of control and
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 2 irresponsible running of the printing presses I believe will eventually cause a great deal of financial distress, and will burden my children and future generations to come.
However, viewed solely from the perspective of the stock market, I would suggest that money printing is potentially positive for higher stock prices. The reasons are not difficult to understand. When governments print a great deal of money, that money has to go somewhere and that somewhere is often the stock market. There is a very strong historical correlation between money printing and rising stock prices. Professors Christos Ioannidis and Alexandros Kontonikas of the University of Glasgow studied the impact of monetary policies in dozens of countries over four decades and concluded that,
monetary policy shifts significantly affect stock returns, thereby supporting the notion of monetary policy transmission via the stock market.
Ioannidis & Kontnikas, The Impact of Monetary Policy on Stock Prices We have discussed the Feds money printing activities like QE1 and QE2 in recent client letters. One need only skim headlines from just the last few weeks to see more evidence that this profligate monetary policy continues to be followed by governments around the world. For example: in September, the Federal Reserve announced Operation Twist, a new and untested form of quantitative easing involving the purchase of of a Trillion dollars of long dated US treasury bonds. Mr. Bernanke also
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 3 recently testified before Congress that he was ready and willing to provide more liquidity to the markets if situations dictated it. (central banker code words for "we'll print more money if we have to.") The Bank of England, the United Kingdom's central bank, announced a 150 billion Pound bond buy-back program, and the European Central Bank announced a 250 billion Euro bond buy-back program, both of which involve printing massive amounts of money to fund the purchase of those bonds. Unfortunately for our children, but perhaps good for our stocks, money printing continues unabated both here and around the world.
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke announced this week that the Federal funds rate will stay near zero for now. He reasoned that the low rates of resource utilization
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 4
and a subdued outlook for inflation over the medium run would likely warrant exceptionally low levels for the federal funds rate at least through mid-2013.
Bonds have been doing great for the last several years, and bond investors have had a huge smile on their face. I'm very happy for our clients as our bond fund positions have appreciated nicely over the last three to five years. However, the thing to remember about bonds is that bond values increase as interest rates decrease and one of the primary reasons that our bonds have done so well in recent years is because rates have dropped to almost unthinkably low levels, primarily due to the Feds manipulation of the bond market. Bonds also tend to decrease in value when rates go up. The bond party may be close to being over, and although I'm very happy for the wonderful gains we've enjoyed in our bonds, this may not be a great time to add more money to bonds because of the threat and worry of rising interest rates in the future. So where does that leave an investor today? If real estate is still considered toxic, banks are paying almost no interest and bonds face the spectre of a rising rate environment, then the only investment game in town is stocks. I'm not cheerleading a portfolio dedicated solely to stocks, just making an observation about the state of the investment market in today's environment. I've been investing professionally for about 20 years, and as a private investor since I was a teenager, and I have never seen an investment landscape where there was literally almost no competition to stocks for investor dollars. This is potentially very optimistic for stock prices. As long as interest rates remain low and real estate is unattractive, it creates a climate where investors may only have stocks as the single desirable alternative to choose from.
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 5
3. US Debt $15 Trillion and Counting Interest never sleeps nor sickens nor dies, it never goes to the hospital; it works on Sundays and holidays; it never takes a vacation; it never visits nor travels; it takes no pleasure; it is never laid off work nor discharged from employment; it never works on reduced hours. Once in debt, interest is your companion every minute of the day and night; you cannot shun it or slip away from it; you cannot dismiss it; it yields neither to entreaties, demands, or orders; and whenever you get in its way or cross its course or fail to meet its demands, it crushes you. J. Reuben Clark
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 6
A third area of concern is our country's continued descent into debt. The total US debt today stands at just under $15 Trillion, and we are scheduled to add another $1.5T this fiscal year and at least $1T or more per year for the next several years according to the CBO. US Government debt levels are rising exponentially causing a great deal of worry and fear about the future state of the US government and the crushing levels of debt that it carries. Warren Buffet made an interesting observation about this subject. When asked by an interviewer if he was worried about the US being able to pay its debt. Buffet replied, Think about it. The U.S., to my knowledge owes no money in currency other than the U.S. dollar, which it can print at will. Now if you're talking about inflation, that's a different question." The US government has their own printing press and they can print as many dollars as necessary to pay all their debts. Therefore the US will always be able to pay any debt they have no matter how large because of their ability to print money. More importantly since the US went off the gold standard in 1971 there has been no accountability as to how much money we can print, thus opening the doors for irresponsible politicians and central bankers to lead us deeper and deeper into debt.
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 7 The US can and is printing money to pay our debts and obligations, but history and common sense tell us that is an unsustainable course and one that has ended very poorly for other countries that have tried the same tactic.
4. PIIGS in Debt We all know what to do, but we dont know how to get reelected once weve done it.
Jean-Claude Juncker, Prime Minister of Luxembourg A fourth financial concern is the European debt crisis. The recent focus has been Greece, but the reality is that several other European countries are teetering on the edge of insolvency, most notably, Italy, but also Portugal and Spain and Ireland (hence the acronym PIIGS.) Greece (and the other PIIGS) have borrowed billions and billions of dollars from major European banks. Greece has reached the point of default in the sense that it will not be able to pay its obligations. In other words, not pay the principal and interest on the money they have borrowed. The crisis really has more to do with the banks than it has to do with Greece. If Greece defaults, it is widely believed that many of the major banks on the continent could be hurt badly. The European bailout is really about rescuing the banks not poor little Greece. Does that sound similar to 2008 here in the US? Europe is facing a financial crisis of the magnitude that the United States was in 2008 when Washington Mutual went under and other financial behemoths like Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, Bank of America, all required bailouts and rescue plans from the government just to survive. Large European banks in trouble include Societe Generale, the largest bank in France; UniCredit, the largest bank in Italy; and Deutsche Bank, the largest bank in Germany. You may have noticed there has
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 8 already been one major bank collapse in Europe. Dexia Bank became insolvent a few weeks ago and has been taken over by the countries of France and Belgium.
(GoogleFinance.com)
What might the impact of a default and resulting bank collapse be on the US? No one knows for sure. It might be quite dramatic, or it might just be inconsequential. There is a great deal of fear and uncertainty in the investment markets over this eventuality. There are perhaps two likely outcomes. The first is that Greece actually does default causing a great deal of distress in Europe and perhaps the collapse of one or more gigantic banks, and most likely some major problems here in the United States in both financial institutions and in the investment markets. If you think that a default by a country is unlikely, you might consider the historical record. Country after country has defaulted on their debts, most recently Russia defaulted on all their debts in 1998 leaving their creditors high and dry. Many other countries large and small have defaulted in recent decades, so it would not be a surprise if Greece did choose to default on its debts. The second outcome is that a bail out is successfully implemented. The European Central Bank, the International Monetary Fund, the US, the UK and the Chinese have all been working feverishly to enact a rescue plan. In fact, as of late October it was widely believed that a plan was in place to "rescue" Greece. The optimism associated with that plan is probably the primary reason that the stock markets did so well at the end of October and jumped in value.
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 9
Then, to everyone's great surprise and chagrin, Greece announced that they would not accept the bailout plan but rather, put it to a referendum of the people with a vote scheduled for January. This led to further drama as the government of Prime Minister Papandreou collapsed and he was forced to withdraw the referendum and resign. There is still a great deal of uncertainty and a likelihood that the plan may not work or might not be accepted by the Greek people which would lead us back to the first outcome - a possible default. Some other observations on the European crisis. First; I am enamored with economics, a little geekish in that regard, and often take economics books on vacation or for my bedtime reading. But viewing this European debt debacle in a simple minded way, it's not clear to me how you rescue someone or something that is deeply in debt by lending them more money. Some financial writers have called this the "extend and pretend" rescue and that this is not a permanent end to the problem, rather it just delays the inevitable damage to further down the road for Greece. Second - the other PIIGS are in trouble. Greece is a tiny country, but Italy is significant and is the worlds third largest borrower. And, Italy is having serious financial difficulties. What happens if Italy defaults?
"Italy has much more systemic implications than Greece, its debt is larger than the rest of the periphery put together, it is too big to fail, too big to save,
Thanos Vamvakidis BOA analyst
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 10
Third every proposed solution and rescue involves massive amounts of new money printing and creation, a phenomenon that may continue to have a profound impact on our investments and our diversification planning. The Greece/Bank crisis should be resolved relatively quickly and whichever of the two outcomes occurs will most likely have a dramatic impact on our investment portfolio and particularly our stocks. It's disconcerting to think that a group of Europeans making decisions in a smoke filled room in Brussels, might set the course for our investments for the next few months and even years. We'll all be watching this with a great deal of interest.
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 11
We can review this on a personal level in more detail at our next client review. And of course, always, please feel free to call if you would like to discuss this before we meet again.
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 12
(GoogleFinance.com)
A more typical rule of thumb between the stock price of gold-mining companies and the price of gold is 1.5 to 1 In other words, if the price of gold goes up 10%, you might expect the price of gold-mining stocks to be up 15%. That rule of thumb has not held true this year. There are two prevailing arguments as to why this might be the case. The first school of thought is that the price of gold is higher than it should be and so the stock market, through lower gold stock prices, is anticipating a drop in the price of gold. If the price of gold does drop, then the prices of these goldmining companies might be about where they should be. If that school of thought is correct, we may see the price of gold drop. The second school of thought (and the one that I learn towards) is that the price of gold is about where it should be today due to the excessive money printing by the US and other countries, and that if the financial crisis becomes worse and governments print more money, it might even be possible to see the price of gold continue to rise. If this argument is correct, then we might eventually see gold mining stocks rise and catch up to the higher price of gold. Gold mining stocks are an important part of our diversification plan against possible higher inflation and a weaker dollar, and this may be a good time to exercise patience with our holdings in this sector, and remember the wonderful gains we have enjoyed in this particular asset class over the last few years. We appreciate our relationship with you, and remain diligent to serve you and help you meet your financial goals.
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 13
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S4-AhcKKEEc
Happy Thanksgiving and blessings to you and your family. With Warm Regards,
William R. Gevers Financial Advisor PS: We have been repeatedly asked by clients if they could share these e-mail notes with their friends or neighbors. Please feel free to forward this with the stipulation that it may only be forwarded if done so in its entirety with no portions omitted. We would be delighted to share our comments and opinions with your friends, and welcome your comments and feedback. If you received this and would like to be included on our newsletter list, please email us at wgevers@geverswealth.com Copyright 2011 William R. Gevers. All rights reserved.
Gevers Wealth Management, LLC I-90 LakePlace Center 1605 NW Sammamish Road, Suite 250 Issaquah, WA 98027 Office: 425.657.2238 Fax: 425.657.2138 E-mail: wgevers@geverswealth.com
The views are those of William Gevers, Gevers Wealth Management, LLC, and should not be construed as individual investment advice. All information is believed to be from reliable sources; however, no representation is made as to its completeness or accuracy. All economic and performance information is historical and not indicative of future results. Investors can not invest directly in an index. Please consult your financial advisor for more information.
Four Good & Four Bad Presidents, PIIGS, and Printing Presses November 2011 Gevers Wealth Management, LLC Page 14
Securities and advisory services offered through Financial Network Investment Corporation, Member SIPC. Gevers Wealth Management and Financial Network are not affiliated.