Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Ion exchange
Ion exchange reaction in soil:
According to Lambert Wiklander, ‘ion exchange is the
reversible process by which cation and anion are exchanged between solid
and liquid phases and between solid phases if in close contact with each
other’.0
Ion exchange in soils occurs on surfaces of clay minerals,
inorganic compounds, organic matter, and roots. The specific ion associates
with these surfaces depend on the kinds of minerals present and the solution
composition. In this ion exchange process a cation or anion in the solid
phase is exchanged with another cation or anion in the liquid phase. For
example,
K +NH4+ NH4+ + K+
Colloid solution colloid solution
If two solid phases are in contact, exchange of ions may
also take place between their surfaces. Ion exchange reactions in soils are
very important to plant nutrient availability. Therefore, it is essential that we
can understand the nature of the solid constituents and the origin of their
surface charge.
Based on counter ion, the ion exchange phenomenon can
further be divided into
i. Cation exchange; and
ii. Anion exchange.
Processes of ion exchange:
Ion exchange may takes place in the following ways:
i. Ion exchange between solid and liquid phase.
ii. Ion exchange between solid and solid phase
iii. Ion exchange between solid phase and root surface.
The processes are described below:
i. Ion exchange between solid and liquid phase:
Ions are strongly adsorbed on the colloidal surfaces.
Hence, the colloidal refers to solid particles. When the colloidal surfaces
come in contact with solution, ion from solution replace or exchange the
equivalent amount of ion from colloidal surface. This ion exchange
process/reaction obeys the law of chemical reaction, i.e. the law of mass
action.
K + NH4+ NH4+ + K+
Colloid Solution Colloid Solution
2
Clay-1
Clay-1
K
Na
Na
K
Clay-2
Clay-2
3. Speed:
Exchange reactions are rapid. The exchange step itself is
virtually instantaneous, if the ions are in close contact. The rate-limiting step
often is ion diffusion to or from the colloid surface. This is particularly true
under field conditions, where ions may have to move through tortuous pores
or through relatively thick, stagnant water films on soil colloid surfaces to
reach an exchange site. [The need for diffusion can produce hysteresis
(reaction-direction dependence) for some ion exchange reactions.]
Under laboratory conditions, samples normally are shaken
during exchange reactions, to speed ion movement and to minimize the
thickness of stagnant water layers on soil particle surfaces.
4. Mass action:
Because of their reversibility, cation exchange reactions can be
driven in either the forward or inverse direction by manipulating the relative
concentrations of reactants and products. [In the laboratory, common
techniques for driving the reactions toward competition include use of high
(e.g.1N) concentrations of exchange cations, and maintaining low
concentration of product cations by leaching or repeated washings.
For example,
V2 = K2[X-K] [Na+]
Where, K2= velocity co-efficient (another constant).
At equilibrium, the rate of forward reaction is equal to the rate of reverse
reaction, so,
V1=V2
K1 [X-Na][K+] =K2[X-K] [Na+]
[X-K] [Na+] = K1 = K
[X-Na] [K+] K2
Here, K is the equilibrium constant, for the above
reaction at a given temperature, which is equal to the ratio of the velocity
constant for the forward reaction & backward reaction.
• Why the CEC of agricultural soils are greater than AEC?
The CEC of a soil is the capacity of clays to adsorb and
exchange cations. The AEC is the capacity of clay to adsorb & exchange
anions.
Cation exchange capacity of a soil is generally more than
anion exchange capacity. It is dependent on the charges in electrolyte levels
& on soil pH. It is also limited to special types of clays.
The clay must be positively charged to be able to adsorb
negatively charged ions (anions). But, positive charges on clays occur clay
in acid conditions; (i.e. under moderate to extreme acid soil conditions, some
silicate clays & iron and aluminum hydrous oxides may exhibit positive net
charges; > Al-OH + H+ > Al-OH2+)
But, in agricultural soils, pH ranges between 5.0-8.5.
There is no constituent at this pH range which can develop positive charge.
Only minute quantities of charges develop in certain amino acids. At this pH
range, negative charges are dominant in soil colloidal surfaces, which are
originated from isomorphous unequivalent ionic substitution and pH related
hydroxy groups on the edges & surfaces of the inorganic & organic colloids.
Since, normally extreme acid conditions does not prevail
in soil, CEC of a soil is generally more than AEC.
• Why does CEC vary from soil to soil?
Cation exchange capacity is the sum total of the exchangeable
cations that a soil (or other substance) can adsorb.
13
2. Type of clay:
CEC of soils also vary with the type of clay they contain. A soil
dominated by 1:1- type silicate clay & Fe-Al-oxides with have lower CEC
than the soil that contain 2:1- type clays, because expanding type minerals
show higher CEC than non-expanding type clay.
3. Organic matter content:
The higher is the organic matter content in soil, the higher is the
CEC of that soil. CEC also depends on the stage of decomposition of
organic matter. A soil containing completely decomposed organic matter, has
higher CEC than a soil containing partially decomposed or undecomposed
organic matter.
4. Soil pH:
At high pH values, negative charges develop and hence the
CEC increases. On the other hand, at low pH values, positive charges
develop & the CEC is lower.
5. Temperature:
The temperature has been found to increase slightly the rate of
the rapid ion exchange for the slower exchange. For this reason, in a
temperate zone, the soil has high CEC because temperature governs the
amount of CEC.
6. Soil Texture:
In general, the more the clay in a soil, the more is the CEC of
that soil. Finer texture soils tend to have higher CEC than sandy or coarser
textured soils.
• Factors controlling the CEC of soils:
The factors that influence/ control the CEC of soil are as
follows:
1. Clay minerals ( amount & type of clay)
2. Soil organic matter (nature & amount of organic matter)
3. Soil pH
4. Size of particles
5. Temperature
6. Soil Texture
Clay minerals:
14
CEC of the soil varies with the amount & type of clay minerals
present in soil.
Amount of clay:
Soils that contain high amount of clay minerals have more CEC
than soils that contain less clay minerals. For example a soil that has 20%
kaolinite has higher CEC than a soil having 10% kaolinite.
Type of clay:
CEC of soils also vary with the type of clay it contains. A clay
soil dominated by 1:1 type silicate clays & Fe-Al-oxides will have lower
CEC than the soil containing 2:1 type clays, because expanding type
minerals show higher CEC than non expanding type clay. For example, a
soil containing 20% montmorillonite has more CEC (80-150 meq/100 g soil)
than the soil that contains 20% kaolinite (CEC 3-15 meq/100 g soil), though
the amount of clay minerals in the two soils are same.
Soil organic matter:
CEC depends on the amount & nature of organic matter in soil
& on the presence of functional groups in the organic matter.
Amount of organic matter:
CEC depends on the amount of organic matter present in soil.
The higher the organic matter content in soil, the higher is the CEC. For
example, soil containing 5% organic matter has higher CEC than a soil
containing 2% organic matter. There was a fairly definite increase in the
exchange capacity of sandy Florida soils of 2 meq for each 1% increase in
organic matter.
Nature of organic matter:
CEC also depends on the stage of decomposition of organic
matter. A soil containing completely decomposed organic matter has higher
CEC than a soil containing partially decomposed or undecomposed organic
matter.
The product of completely decomposed organic matter is
humus & its CEC is higher (150-300 meq/100 g soil). The CEC of partially
decomposed organic matter is near zero. As a result, CEC of a soil varies
with the different stage of decomposition.
Presence of functional groups on humus:
The reason for the higher CEC of humus is the functional
groups on humus particles. These functional groups are –OH, -NH2, -COOH,
etc. when the pH of soil solution increases, these functional groups
dissociate & form negative charges.
15
OH + OHˉ Oˉ + H2O
Soil pH:
pH also influences the CEC of soils, at very low pH values, the
CEC is generally low. Under low pH conditions, only the permanent charges
of the 2:1 type clay & a small portion of the pH-dependent charges of
organic colloids, allophane, and some 1:1 clays hold exchangeable ions.
At high pH, the negative charges on some 1:1 type silicate
clays, humus, allophane and even Fe, Al oxides increases; thereby increasing
the CEC.
At natural or slightly alkaline pH, the CEC reflects most of the
pH-dependent charges as well as permanent charge.
To obtain a measure of the maximum retentive capacity, the
CEC is usually determined at a pH of 7.0 or above.
Size of particles:
The finer the size of the particles the higher is the specific
surface area, and so the higher is the CEC of the soil, and vice-versa. CEC is
a surface phenomenon. As a result, CEC increases with the increase in
surface area. Clay is a colloidal particle, so its CEC is higher than coarser
soil particle.
Soil texture:
The more clay in a soil, the more CEC is in that soil. Fine-
textured soils tend to have higher CEC than sandy or coarser textured soils.
Different CEC of different textured soils:
Sandy soil 0-5 meq/100g soil
Fine sandy loam 5-10 meq/100g soil
Clay loam 15-20 meq/100g soil
Clay 30 meq/100g soil
16
5. Microbial activity:
The predominance of desirable cations such as Ca++ in the
exchange complex favorably influences the microbial activity,
ammonification & nitrification.
6. Irrigation:
CEC of a soil helps to measure irrigation water efficiency
of a field. If the CEC of a soil is low, irrigation is needed for several
times with small amount of water, because water holding capacity of
this soil is low & vice-versa.
7. Efficient use of fertilizer:
A soil which has low CEC will hold small amount of
fertilizer nutrients than a soil with high CEC, because nutrient ions of
the fertilizer are adsorbed by soil colloid by the process of ion
exchange. So, the soluble inorganic fertilizers are not washed away
from the soil when added to the soil. Thus, the CEC of soil increases
the efficient use of fertilizer.
8. Reclaimation of acid soil:
Strongly acidic soils are not produce for most crops.
When lime is added to neutralize the acidic soils, most of
exchangeable H+ & Al³+ ions are neutralized after the pH.
H
Micelle + Ca (HCO3) Micelle Ca+ 2CO2 +2H2O
H
Micelle
Na Micelle
H
+ H2SO4 + Na2SO4
Na H
05-20 m²/g. This accounts for its low capacity to adsorb cations as well as
low CEC. The CEC of kaolinite is 03-15 meq/100 g soil.
For the above reasons, the CEC of montmorillonite > that of
kaolinite.
• CEC of montmorillonite> CEC of illite :
The CEC of montmorillonite is greater/higher than that of
illite, because montmorillonite is a 2:1 type expanding clay mineral. The
total surface area per unit mass of montmorillonite is 700-800 m²/g, which
accounts for its high capacity to adsorb cations as well as its CEC.
Again, isomorphous substitution takes place in
montmorillonite; viz. Al³+ for Si4+, Mg²+, Fe++, Ni²+, Li+ for Al³+.
Isomorphous substitution of Mg²+ for some of the Al³+ ions in the
dioctahedral sheet accounts for most of the negative charges for
montmorillonites, although some substitution of Al³+ for Si4+ has occurred
in tetrahedral sheets. Thus isomorphous substitution causes high CEC of this
clay mineral. The CEC of montmorillonite is 80-150 meq/100g soil.
On the other hand, through the illite is a 2:1 type mineral, it
is non-expanding mineral. Therefore, its surface area is as low as only 70-
100 m²/g, which accounts for its low capacity to adsorb cation as well as low
CEC.
Again, isomorphous substitution takes place in illite. The
major source of negative charges of illite is in the tetrahedral sheet where
about 20% of the Si-sites are occupied by Al-atoms. This results in a high
net negative charge in the tetrahedral sheet. But, to satisfy this charge, K+
ions are strongly attracted in the interlayer space. Thus, K+ ions act as
binding agents preventing expansion of the mineral. For this reason, cation
adsorption is much less intense in illite (fine-grained mica) than in
montmorillonite. The CEC of illite is 10-40 meq/100 g soil.
For the above reasons, CEC of montmorillonite> CEC of illite.
Kaolinite Non-expanding mineral
Montmorillonite fully expanding mineral
Vermiculite limited expanding mineral
Illite Non-expanding mineral
[Origin of positive & negative charges on soil clays/ permanent & pH
dependent charges------------ from 2nd year note].
• Origin of negative clays in humus:
Negative charges are originated in humus due to
dissociation of the following groups:
21
Humus Humus
NH2 NHˉ+H+
reactions. That is, there are two steps of mechanisms for anion retention in
soils:
1. Nonspecific Anion Reactions; and
2. Specific Anion Reactions.
Nonspecific Anion Reactions:
In this case, adsorption (or retention) is not specific for
any anion. An anion, which is more powerful, takes the place first.
An anion (approaching a charged surface/ soil solid) is
subjected to
i. attraction by positively charged sites on the
surface, or
ii. Repulsion by negative charges.
Anion repulsion (negative adsorption):
Layer silicates in the clay fraction of soils are
normally negatively charged; so, anions tend to repel from the mineral
surfaces.
Factors affecting anion repulsion include:
a. Anion charge & concentration;
b. Species of exchangeable cation;
c. pH;
d. Presence of other anions; and
e. Nature & charge of the colloidal surface.
Ions commonly exhibiting anion repulsion include Clˉ, NO3ˉ and
SO4²ˉ.
Anion repulsion expressed in units of milliequivalents repelled per
square centimeter of solid surface (me/cm²), increases with anion charge
(valence).
If the negative charge on a soil colloidal surface remains constant,
anions of higher charge are repelled more than anions of lower charge. For
example, Mattson found anion repulsion in a Na- montmorillonite
suspension to increase in the order: Cl~ NO3ˉ< SO4²ˉ<Fe (CN)64ˉ.
Similarly, increasing of the anion concentration increases anion
repulsion.
In soils with pH dependent charge, lowering the pH decreases the
net negative charge of the system. Anion repulsion thus decreases as the soil
pH decreases.
Anion repulsion decreases when anions are adsorbed by positively
charged sites on soil colloids.
23
OHˉ½ OH (b)
+NO3ˉ =
OH+½….Cl OH+½…………..NO3 + Clˉ
OH2+0.5 +1 Fˉ0.5 0
O OH O O P O
OH
Fe + 2H2PO4ˉ Fe +2OH
OH
O OH O O P O
OH
Fe Fe
R-N-H………..O
R-C-H…………O
Layer silicate
O
R-C-OH………O
R-C-O………..O