Sei sulla pagina 1di 2

Breaking with Old Ideas is a product of Chinese Community Party chairman Mao Zedong's concept of a

new world in which all social relationships are transformed. Li Wen-Hua made the film during the last
years of the Cultural Revolution in the PRC, People's Republic of China. The film dramatizes the struggle
for proletarian control of education at an agricultural college during the Great Leap Forward and makes it
clear that the leading party members can still promote bourgeois ideas and only the masses can rectify these
leaders to ensure that education truly helps to build socialism. Breaking with Old Ideas shows an
introduction to the politics of the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution with concrete examples
of how class struggle continues under socialism and how communists can wage that struggle successfully
by mobilizing the masses to criticize those in positions of authority taking the capitalist road.
Mao launched the Cultural Revolution during his last decade in power to renew the spirit of the Chinese
revolution. "We must reform the arts faculties in the universities. The students must go down and engage
in industry, agriculture and commerce" (201, Reader), said Mao. Mao shut down China's schools, and
during the following months he encouraged Red Guards to attack all traditional values and "bourgeois"
things and to test party officials by publicly criticizing them. Mao believed that this measure would be
beneficial both for the young people and for the party cadres that they attacked. Breaking with Old Ideas
show how Mao's program works and encourages low class peasants to do the same.
"[Breaking with Old Idea is about] a teacher whose spectacles and manner suggest he is a backward
element undergoes a late but speedy conversion to the cause of educational popularization. Such changes,
however, were but sideshows to the main thrust of the plot" (139, Reader), said Clark. The film suggests
that Mao's idea of Cultural Revolution will make the country better for the poor peasants and will offer
everything they need to make a living including punishing the capitalist-minded bourgeois. For example,
the film starts with the main character smiling and laughing out loud. The late 1950s brought the forced
collectivization of agriculture and the campaign for the Great Leap Forward, which was to boost China's
industrial production. The happy, energetic, and idyllic scenes contrast with the grim reality of
mismanagement in industry and agriculture, which resulted in a horrible famine in which millions of people
starving to death.
In order to supply the people with food and consumer durables as well as the structure of a socialist society,
labor college was created. Students worked and studied at school to learn socialism and produce food for
their village. In the film, students face a struggle against bourgeois-minded teachers who do not care about
the village but trying to catch up to other colleges and countries. "We cannot follow the old paths of
technical development of every other country in the world, and crawl step by step behind the others" (195,
Reader), said Mao. To encourage people, film shows the victory of peasants against bourgeois-minded elite
by following what Mao have said.
Mao encouraged students to rebel against authority and inform on their politically incorrect seniors, and
join the Red Guard, the ideological militia that pushed the Cultural Revolution forward. At one point, Red
Guards were fighting pitched battles with government troops outside of the foreign ministry building.
Later on, Red Guard units ended up fighting each other for supremacy, not completing Mao's unity-
criticism-unity. Breaking with Old Ideas show how people can stand up to the authority and fix what is
wrong. A female student stands up for herself and what she believes in during the criticism meeting. By
doing so, people have agreed and helped her express her opinion to fix their authorities who were
controlled by capitalist minds. Not only that, others were able to gain confidence in what they believe in
and stood up for themselves as well. For example, a student who made money from castrating pigs
criticized himself in front of the whole town. A young girl, the daughter of the vice principle, also showed
the unfairness of her father by showing the letter of recommendation to a famous college in the city.
Breaking with Old Ideas worked as an advertisement film supporting Mao's new policy, Cultural
Revolution. By showing how the policy can work and give power to the people will help building a new
country gave the poor people hope and dreams to become more than what they currently are. People were
able to participate in the government by criticizing so called "closet capitalists" who were hiding in
government posts and within the CCP itself. In reality, the targets for Mao's wrath were those he saw as his
political enemies. Eventually, the campaign spread to include targeting members of the scientists and
influential professors of universities who were accused of putting technical expertise ahead of correct
political thinking. Unlike the film, the Cultural Revolution had a disastrous effect on the educational
system and the scientific community within China.

Potrebbero piacerti anche