Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Ceniza
Green
Green
A and B constitute P.
A and B constitute P.
C1: A and B (where A and B are simple propositions) have the same structure as X and Y (where X and Y are states of affairs),
Q1. What makes P true? Q2. How do we know that P is true? Q2*: How does S (where S is the knower) know that A and B have the same structure as X and Y ?
Correspondence Theory of Truth (CPT): Q2*: How does S know that A and B have the same structure as X and Y ? Q2*: What makes Ss belief that A and B have the same structure as X and Y true?
Correspondence Theory of Truth (CPT): Q2*: How does S know that A and B have the same structure as X and Y ?
Correspondence Theory of Truth (CPT): Q2*: How does S know that A and B have the same structure as X and Y ?
X
The car is red A
X
The car is red A
X
The car is red A
X
The car is red A
X
The car is red A
Q2.
P is true only if P is part of Ss set of coherent beliefs.
P: I am sick.
P: I am sick. P is part of A.
P: I am dog.
P: I am dog. P is part of A.
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true.
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true.
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true.
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true.
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true.
X verifies P.
X
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true.
X verifies P.
X
= P is true.
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true. Does VT answer Q2?
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true. Does VT answer Q2? Q2**:
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true. Does VT answer Q2? Q2**: How does S know that X verifies P?
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true. Does VT answer Q2?
Q2**: How does S know that X verifies P? Problems:
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true. Does VT answer Q2? Q2**: How does S know that X verifies P? Problems: 1. The regress problem.
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true. Does VT answer Q2? Q2**: How does S know that X verifies P? Problems: 1. The regress problem. There is an X1 that verifies Ss belief that X verifies P.
VT: P is true only if: 1. There is an X (where X is a method of verification) that verifies P. 2. X verifies that P is true. Does VT answer Q2? Q2**: How does S know that X verifies P? Problems: 1. The regress problem. There is an X1 that verifies Ss belief that X verifies P. What justifies Ss belief that X1 justifies the belief that X verifies P?
Does VT answer Q2? Q2**: How does S know that X verifies P? Problems: 2. The problem of relativism.
Does VT answer Q2? Q2**: How does S know that X verifies P? Problems: 2. The problem of relativism. If X is merely created or imposed by S, then VT collapses into a form of relativism.
Does VT answer Q2? Q2**: How does S know that X verifies P? Problems: 2. The problem of relativism. If X is merely created or imposed by S, then VT collapses into a form of relativism. VT does not guarantee truth for S.