Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Transformer Paralleling
Technical Presentation Tuesday April 21: 4:45-6:00 p.m.
Jim Graham
* Reasons for paralleling transformers * Examples of users concerns & needs
User Issues
Voltage / Ratio Mismatch Impedance Mismatch Unbalanced Loads Volt/Current Sensors Connected in phase Incompatible Controllers Tap Changer Locations Increased Fault Currents Do I need Paralleling Controls?
Jin Sim
* Manufacturer Concerns * Specification needs
Manufacturers Request
Existing units with Load Tap Changers Serial Numbers of existing units Test report LTC Wiring and Schematic Drawings Method Circulating Current Master Follower Other Manual
ZA, ZB = per Unit Impedance of Transformers A & B IA, IB = per Unit Load Current of Transformers A & B IL = per Unit load current of Transformers A & B in parallel Assuming the voltage drop thru both transformer is equal Then: IA x ZA = IB x ZB and IL = IA + IB
And
IA = ZB/(ZA+ZB)
& IB = ZA/(ZA+ZB)
Paralleling Issues Constant Flux Voltage Variation vs Variable Flux Voltage Variation
Tom Jauch
Transformer Paralleling Application
LTC Control basics Paralleling basics Control paralleling techniques System variables configuration Transformer Differences
BASICS
VARIABLES
Paralleling self-correction
CONCLUSIONS
Control Basics
Control Basics
"Paralleled Transformers:
Two or more transformers connected in such a manner that they share in the supply of a common load bus." Note: Any system operation that removes the supply source from a paralleled transformer(s) or separates a transformer load winding from a common load bus ends the parallel operation of the transformer(s).
LINES
The transformers must continue their basic function of controlling the regulated bus voltage as prescribed by the basic settings on the control (band center, bandwidth and line drop compensation).
The tap changers must operate to maintain tap position so as to minimize the current that circulates between them. Depending upon the designs of the transformers, the appropriate tap positions on the paralleled transformers are not necessarily on the same tap to achieve this.
These functions must operate correctly and automatically regardless of system configuration changes or breaker operations.
Need for paralleling equipment Example 1: TIMING ERROR: One tapchanger faster than other (tolerances) causes one transformer to do all voltage regulation
Setpoints
V1,2
SP
SP
There are three basic control Techniques for controlling paralleled transformers.
a)Direct operation technique (from one control) (Master / Follower) b) Blocking technique which blocks controls from operating in an inappropriate direction (Power Factor) c) Biasing technique for adjusting control set points (Negative Reactance, Circulating Current, Circulating reactive current or vars)
LOADS
LOADS
LOADS
LOADS
TRANSFORMER VARIABLES
Transformer Impedance - Z%
(Matched: Equal Z% @ max rating)
Transformer Rating MVA Tap Size tap size Number of taps #taps Number of windings - # windings Winding configuration Dynamic Z% CT Ratios ct ratios Voltage Ratings V Rating Voltage Ratio V ratio = Primary Voltage
Master/Follower Method
(Direct operation technique)
Master/Follower Method
(Direct operation technique)
Requires:
Feedback
Feedback of follower unit(s) action to master Usually by external relays or communication channel(s)
Master/Follower Method
(Direct operation technique)
OR
Master/Follower Method
(Direct operation technique)
Application:
Z% Matched Transformers Solid HS bus Different CT ratios OK
OR
Limitations:
Not applicable for: Unmatched Z% Different Tap Sizes Different # of Taps Separated HS bus Dynamic Z% # windings (tertiary)
V1, V2
I1A, I2A
V1, V2 I2A
I1A
Application:
Z% Matched Transformers Solid HS bus Different tap sizes OK Different # of taps OK Different CT ratios OK
V1, V2 I2A I1A
Limitations:
Not applicable for: Unmatched Z% Separated HS bus Dynamic Z% # windings (tertiary)
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
SP
SP
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
SP
SP
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
Importance of SENSITIVITY
SP V SP
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
Importance of SENSITIVITY
SP V SP
-1
SP
SP
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
Importance of SENSITIVITY
SP V SP
-1
SP
SP
SP
SP
OVERSENSITIVE HUNTING !!
SP
SP
SP
SP
Application:
Z% Matched Transformers Solid HS bus Different tap sizes OK Different # of taps OK Different CT ratios OK
Limitations:
Not applicable for: Unmatched Z% Separated HS bus Dynamic Z% # windings (tertiary) Significant load changes
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
Typical Systems
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
SP
SP
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
Setting the Sensitivity Set both PBMs sensitivities on neutral Find tap combination that minimizes circulating current & produces voltage closest to setpoint Raise one transformer one tap and lower on transformer one tap 4) Adjust sensitivities (together) to the level where both transformers return to original tap positions Reduce both sensitivity levels by one
3)
Common Error
(STOPPING HERE)
5)
METHODS Master/Follower Power Factor Neg Reactance Circ current Circ reac current
Typical Backup
Application:
Z% Matched Transformers Solid HS bus Different tap sizes Different # of taps
Limitations:
Not applicable for: Unmatched Z% (Comped) Different MVA rating Separated HS bus Dynamic Z% # windings (tertiary)
180A
100MVA,8% IZ
ct = 100/1A
180A
50 MVA,10%IZ
ct = 50/1A
Ic=2 2/1
1A
50MVA
Ic=2 1/1
2A
VT1
OPEN
VT2
OPEN
VT2
* Same connections as circulating current Control reacts ONLY to circulating reactive current Equalizes transformer var flows * CT ratios equivalent to rating sizes (not %Z)
Application:
OPEN/CLOSED HS bus
VT1
OPEN
Different HS voltages Different Z% Dynamic Z% # windings (tertiary) Different tap sizes Different # of taps
VT2
Limitations:
Requires: MVA matched ct ratios (Equalizes var flows by rating)
5% Z
SP
+
SP
5% Z
IN FACT: Could cause OVERSENSITIVE Operation (hunting) if used with Paralleling control !
SP
+
SP
"Paralleled Transformers: Two or more transformers connected in such a manner that they share in the supply to a common load bus." Suggestion: Two questions must be asked to determine if this Guide (paralleling control) is applicable. #1 Is there any system condition that will cause this transformer to be paralleled (in parallel) with another? (IF YES) #2 Will all system conditions cause paralleling self correction? (IF NO)
LTC Control basics Paralleling basics Control paralleling techniques System variables configuration Transformer Differences
BASICS
VARIABLES
Paralleling self-correction
CONCLUSIONS
Conclusions
Several methods of paralleling to choose from depending on needs of the application In choosing consider: all possible configurations* all future possibilities
(PC57.153) I. Definition & Purpose of a Paralleling Guide: II. General Overview of Paralleling Requirements: III. Basic Tapchanger Control: IV. Basic Paralleling Method Descriptions/Applications: V. Special Transformer Application Considerations: VI. Special System Application Considerations: VII. Backup protection: VIII. Typical problems: IX. Field commissioning / troubleshooting: X. Conclusions
Transformer Paralleling
Questions , Answers & Comments
Jim Graham Electrical Engineer Alliant Energy, Cedar Rapids, Iowa Tom Jauch Application Consultant Beckwith Electric Co. Largo, FL Jin Sim VP, Chief Technology Officer Waukesha Electric Systems.