Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
U The authors describe the use of a bifrontal basal interhemispheric approach with or without division of the anteri-
or communicating artery (ACoA) for removal of large craniopharyngiomas. This approach is a more basal modifica-
tion of the anterior interhemispheric approach, allowing preservation of most bridging veins. Since 1988, 22 patients
underwent operations using this approach to achieve total or near-total excision of large craniopharyngiomas. Division
of the ACoA was performed in 11 of 17 patients with retrochiasmatic tumors with no early or late complications relat-
ed to division of the artery. There were no operative mortalities. Visual improvement (59%) and preservation of the
pituitary stalk (64%) were achieved in a high percentage of patients. Preservation of the pituitary stalk correlated well
with postoperative pituitary function. The bifrontal basal interhemispheric approach allowed a bilateral, wider opera-
tive field with better orientation and views of important neural structures and perforating arteries without requiring
combination with other approaches. When the ACoA limited operative exposure, the artery could be divided safely.
The authors discuss indications for, and advantages of, the bifrontal basal interhemispheric approach with or without
division of the ACoA in the removal of large craniopharyngiomas.
LTHOUGH controversy still exists regarding the opti- vides additional space. In the present report we discuss
TABLE 1 The olfactory nerves are dissected from the basal sur-
Characteristics and outcomes of 22 patients who underwent a face of the frontal lobes bilaterally all the way to the ol-
bifrontal basal interhemispheric approach with or factory trigone. This maneuver minimizes the risk of in-
without division of the ACoA* advertent damage to the nerves during retraction of the
frontal lobes. Both frontal lobes are retracted together
Characteristics Preserved ACoA Divided ACoA Total
& Outcomes (11 patients) (11 patients) (22 patients) with the superior sagittal sinus, and dissection of the inter-
hemispheric fissure is performed only from the basal side,
characteristics not from the convexity surface (Fig. 1 right). Therefore,
age (yrs) the extent of dissection in the area of the fissure is less
,18 4 5 9 (41%)
$18 7 6 13 (59%) than that caused by the conventional anterior approach
follow-up period (mos)† 35 6 23 31 6 15 33 6 19 and most of the bridging veins that drain into the superior
tumor size (mm)† 42 6 14 40 6 11 41 6 12 sagittal sinus are preserved. The arachnoid dissection is
tumor location directed toward the pre- and suprachiasmal region, expos-
prechiasmatic 5 0 5 (23%) ing the A2 segment bilaterally, the genu of the corpus cal-
retrochiasmatic 6 11 17 (77%)
losum, the ACoA, and the chiasm. Usually, the brain be-
outcomes comes sufficiently slack after removal of cerebrospinal
tumor recurrence 2 1 3 (14%)
visual acuity
fluid from the basal cisterns. In cases of prechiasmatic
improved 7 6 13 (59%) tumors, the ACoA is compressed and displaced supero-
unchanged 4 3 7 (32%) posteriorly and the artery usually does not affect the oper-
deteriorated 0 2 2 (9%) ative approach. On the other hand, in cases of retrochias-
mental problems matic tumors, the ACoA is located anterior to the tumor
preop 1 2 3 (14%)
postop 2 3 5 (23%)
and often limits operative exposure. Division of the
pituitary stalk ACoAs may be necessary for the removal of the latter type
preserved 8 6 14 (64%) of tumor.
severed 1 3 4 (18%) The lamina terminalis is opened in the midline. Internal
undetected 2 2 4 (18%) decompression is the next step toward removal of the tu-
* ACoA = anterior communicating artery. mor. The cyst is punctured and intracapsular removal of
† Values expressed are the mean 6 standard deviation. the tumor is done using a smooth or serrated suction tube
to extract the solid part of the tumor.13 The two-suction
method is useful for this purpose. Chemical meningitis is
prevented by avoiding spillage of cyst fluid into the sub-
be divided safely. The indication for division of the ACoA arachnoid space; this is accomplished using cottonoid
was determined in patients with retrochiasmatic tumors by coverage of the surrounding operative field as well as con-
weighing the importance of a wider exposure for total tinuous suction drainage through a small silastic tube
removal of the tumor with the disadvantage of sacrificing placed in the bottom of the operative field. Sufficient
the ACoA. internal decompression facilitates the following step of
Endocrine studies included preoperative and postopera- capsular dissection from adjacent vital structures such as
tive measurement of basal serum levels of adrenocorti- the hypothalamus.
cotropic hormone (ACTH), growth hormone (GH), and At this stage the surgeon must decide whether the
thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH). Provocation testing ACoA should be divided. The artery is one of the main
was only performed in limited cases. Insulin (0.1 U/kg) structures limiting operative exposure of retrochiasmatic
and thyroid-releasing hormone (TRH; 500 U) were craniopharyngiomas in the anterior interhemispherical
administered intravenously for provocation testing of approach (Fig. 2 left). Although we always try to preserve
ACTH, GH, and TSH. The provocation test results were the artery, dividing it often provides a much wider operat-
judged as normal when the ACTH level increased to more ing space, which subsequently makes the operation easier
than twice the basal value, the GH level increased to and safer (Fig. 2 right). When the artery is left intact, it
more than 10 ng/ml, and the TSH level increased to more may inadvertently be damaged during retraction of the
than 10 mU/ml. hemispheres, especially in pediatric cases in which one
encounters thin-walled arteries. The ACoA is occluded
Operative Technique with small vascular clips and incised between the clips.
The patient is placed supine with the neck slightly The hypothalamic arteries must always be preserved, even
extended. A bicoronal skin incision is made behind the if they look small. The cut edges of the artery and the vas-
hairline and subperiosteal dissection of the skin flap is cular clips are covered with Biobond (glue)-soaked oxycel
extended to the glabella and the orbital ridges. The supra- to prevent slippage of the clips. Clipping and dividing of
orbital nerves are preserved. A bifrontal craniotomy is the ACoA may be difficult when it is too short and many
performed, which includes removal of the nasal part of the perforating arteries branch off from the artery. When one
frontal bone in a single continuous bone flap or separate side of the A1 segment is hypoplastic, it may be divided
flaps (Fig. 1 left). The frontal sinus is almost always instead of the short ACoA, although we have not had such
opened, the mucosa is pushed downward, and the inner a case.
table of the sinus and the crista galli are removed with The tumor usually adheres most tightly to the chiasm,
rongeurs or air drills. The falx and the superior sagittal pituitary stalk, or hypothalamus, whereas it usually sepa-
sinus are divided after double ligation. rates easily from the upper wall of the third ventricle. The
FIG. 1. Drawings displaying the bifrontal basal interhemispheric approach. Left: Skin incision and craniotomy. A
bifrontal craniotomy is performed, which includes removal of the nasal part of the frontal bone in separate bone flaps.
Right: The extent of dissection of the interhemispheric fissure. The dissection area of the fissure in this approach (A) is
much less than that created in the conventional anterior interhemispheric approach (B). Most of the bridging veins drain-
ing into the superior sagittal sinus are preserved in the bifrontal basal interhemispheric approach.
bilateral, wider exposure obtained by this approach en- obtained when the ACoA was cut between two Weck
ables the surgeon to view the lesion from many different clips. Additional parts of the tumor were removed by
angles and to locate the dissection plane between the means of scissors, bipolar cutting, and suction. The por-
tumor capsule and the important neural structures or per- tion of tumor that tightly adhered behind the optic chiasm
forating arteries on both sides. Consequently, there is a was dissected using a silver dissector under direct vision,
good chance of preserving the hypothalamus, pituitary which was obtained by changing the angle of the micro-
stalk, and perforating arteries using this approach. More- scope. Fortunately, there was a membrane separating the
over, the wider operative field reduces blind operative tumor from the perforating arteries, and the tumor could
procedures and facilitates complete tumor resection. be totally removed without disturbing these vessels (Fig.
3 right). The pituitary stalk was left intact.
Postoperative Course. Postoperatively, the patient ex-
Illustrative Case hibited diabetes insipidus and required hormone replace-
Examination. This 51-year-old man was referred to ment for a few months. By 6 months after the operation
our hospital for visual disturbance. His visual acuity was he was able to do well without hormone replacement.
20/100 on both sides. Goldmann’s perimetry showed a His vision improved markedly postoperatively (right eye,
binasal lower quadrantanopsia with central scotoma in the 20/40, left eye, 20/20) and his visual fields widened. He
lower half of both eyes. Gadolinium-enhanced MR imag- still has central scotoma in the lower halves of both eyes.
ing showed a well-enhanced multilobular suprasellar solid Although his olfaction decreased slightly postoperatively,
mass, 40 mm in diameter, in the third ventricle (Fig. 3 he experiences no difficulties in daily life.
left). The pituitary stalk was clearly shown in the midline
on the coronal image (Fig. 3 center).
Operation. The operation was performed using the bi-
frontal basal interhemispheric approach. When the inter-
hemispheric fissure was dissected, as described previous-
ly, the pituitary stalk could be clearly seen below the
chiasm. The lamina terminalis was bulging and was
opened in the midline, avoiding damage to the hypotha-
lamic arteries. A yellowish, granulomatous, solid tumor
appeared in the third ventricle. The tumor was tough and
could not be removed by suction using the usual smooth
tip. However, a serrated suction tip was effective in cut-
ting and removing the tumor. Fortunately, the tumor did
not adhere tightly to the wall of the third ventricle except
behind the optic chiasm and thus could be retracted infe-
riorly as it was removed little by little. Initially, the ACoA FIG. 2. Drawings depicting the operative view in a patient with
a retrochiasmatic craniopharyngioma before (left) and after (right)
was preserved; however, total removal of the tumor ap- division of the anterior communicating artery. The broken line
peared to be impossible without sacrificing the artery. The shows the extent of the tumor. Division of the artery provides a
ACoA was fenestrated with a median artery of the corpus much wider operating space, subsequently making the operation
callosum arising from it. A wide operative field was easier and safer.
FIG. 3. Gadolinium-enhanced magnetic resonance images showing a retrochiasmatic craniopharyngioma in our illus-
trative case (left). The pituitary stalk is clearly shown in the midline on the coronal image (center). Postoperatively, total
removal of the tumor is shown (right).
TABLE 2 TABLE 3
Correlation between preservation of the pituitary stalk and Correlation between preservation of the pituitary stalk and
normal levels of basal serum ACTH and TSH* postoperative hormonal replacement
Pituitary Stalk (no. of patients) Pituitary Stalk (no. of patients)
the stalk. Administration of GH had to be stopped in both for craniopharyngioma.] No Shinkei Geka 17:799–812, 1989
patients after recurrence of the tumors was confirmed. (Jpn)
Whether use of GH induces tumor recurrence is an unset- 4. Baskin DS, Wilson CB: Surgical management of craniopharyn-
tled question;2,5 however, it is not recommended for pa- giomas. A review of 74 cases. J Neurosurg 65:22–27, 1986
tients with residual tumors. 5. Clayton PE, Shalet SM, Gattamaneni HR, et al: Does growth
hormone cause relapse of brain tumours? Lancet 1:711–713,
Postoperative improvement in visual function was ob- 1987
tained in more than half of the patients in our series (13 6. Day JD, Giannotta SL, Fukushima T: Extradural temporopolar
cases) and deterioration was observed in only two pa- approach to lesions of the upper basilar artery and infrachias-
tients. These results seem to be better than those reported matic region. J Neurosurg 81:230–235, 1994
in recent series, in which unilateral approaches were pri- 7. Fischer EG, Welch K, Shillito J Jr, et al: Craniopharyngiomas
marily used.9,16 The bifrontal basal interhemispheric ap- in children. Long-term effects of conservative surgical pro-
proach enables the surgeon to identify both sides of the cedures combined with radiation therapy. J Neurosurg 73:
optic nerves, chiasm, and the optic tracts, possibly allow- 534–540, 1990
ing more chance for postoperative visual improvement. 8. Fujitsu K, Sekino T, Sakata K, et al: Basal interfalcine approach
Anatomical preservation of the pituitary stalk was ob- through a frontal sinusotomy with vein and nerve preservation.
tained in 64% of our cases. This value is much higher than Technical note. J Neurosurg 80:575–579, 1994
that reported by Yasargil, et al.16 (36.5%). When the pitu- 9. Hoffman HJ, Silva MD, Humphreys RP, et al: Aggressive sur-
gical management of craniopharyngiomas in children. J Neu-
itary stalk was anatomically preserved during the op- rosurg 76:47–52, 1992
eration, postoperative hormone replacement was none or 10. Kanno T, Kasama A, Shoda M, et al: A pitfall in the interhemi-
mild in more than half of the cases, whereas it had to spheric translamina terminalis approach for the removal of a
be strict in all but one case in which the pituitary stalk craniopharyngioma. Significance of preserving draining veins.
was severed or undetected. Although anatomical preser- Part I. Clinical study. Surg Neurol 32:111–115, 1989
vation does not necessarily mean preservation of function, 11. Samii M, Samii A: Surgical management of craniopharyn-
patients have a greater chance of remaining free from giomas, in Schmidek HH, Sweet WH (eds): Operative Neuro-
strict postoperative hormone replacement therapy. More- surgical Techniques, ed 3. Philadelphia: WB Saunders, 1995,
over, severe endocrine dysfunction might be related to one pp 357–370
late death in our series, in which the patient’s pituitary 12. Serizawa T, Saeki N, Fukuda K, et al: [Microsurgical anatomy
stalk was severed during the operation. Preservation of the of the anterior communicating artery and its perforating arteries
stalk does not seem to increase the recurrence rate. important for interhemispheric trans-lamina terminalis ap-
proach: analysis based on cadaver brains.] No Shinkei Geka
22:447–454, 1994 (Jpn)
Conclusions 13. Shibuya M, Suzuki Y, Nakane T: A serrated suction tip for tu-
mor removal. Technical note. J Neurosurg 69:140–141, 1988
The present results suggest that the bifrontal basal in- 14. Suzuki J, Katakura R, Mori T: Interhemispheric approach
terhemispheric approach with or without division of the through the lamina terminalis to tumors of the anterior parts of
ACoA is a useful and safe procedure for removal of large the third ventricle. Surg Neurol 22:157–163, 1984
craniopharyngiomas. When the ACoA limits operative 15. Symon L, Sprich W: Radical excision of craniopharyngioma.
exposure, division of the artery can be accomplished safe- Results in 20 patients. J Neurosurg 62:174–181, 1985
ly without significant early or late complications. 16. Yasargil MG, Curcic M, Kis M, et al: Total removal of cranio-
pharyngiomas. Approaches and long-term results in 144 pa-
tients. J Neurosurg 73:3–11, 1990
References
17. Yasui N, Nathal E, Fujiwara H, et al: The basal interhemispher-
1. Al-Mefty O, Hassounah M, Weaver P, et al: Microsurgery ic approach for acute anterior communicating aneurysms. Acta
for giant craniopharyngiomas in children. Neurosurgery 17: Neurochir 118:91–97, 1992
585–594, 1985
2. Arslanian SA, Becker DJ, Lee PA, et al: Growth hormone ther- Manuscript received September 21, 1995.
apy and tumor recurrence. Findings in children with brain neo- Accepted in final form January 17, 1996.
plasms and hypopituitarism. Am J Dis Child 139:347–350, Address reprint requests to: Masato Shibuya, M.D., Depart-
1985 ment of Neurosurgery, Nagoya University School of Medicine, 65
3. Asano T: [Interhemispheric, trans-lamina terminalis approach Tsurumai-cho, Showa-ku, Nagoya 466, Japan.