Sei sulla pagina 1di 5

MARCH/APRIL 2011

QL@=PA

The University of Puerto Rico:


A Testing Ground for the
Neoliberal State

-ÌÕ`i˜ÌÃÊ>ÌÊ̅iÊ1˜ˆÛiÀÈÌÞʜvÊ*ÕiÀ̜Ê,ˆVœ]Ê,‰œÊ*ˆi`À>ÃÊV>“«ÕÃ]ÊVœ˜vÀœ˜ÌÊ«œˆViʜ˜Ê>˜Õ>ÀÞÊÓx]Ê>vÌiÀʘi>ÀÞÊÌܜÊÜiiŽÃʜvÊ«ÀœÌiÃÌÃÊ>}>ˆ˜ÃÌʘiœˆLiÀ>Ê>ÕÃÌiÀˆÌÞÊ
ʓi>ÃÕÀiðÊ/…ˆÃÊÜ>ÃÊ̅iÊÃiVœ˜`ÊÜ>ÛiʜvÊ՘ˆÛiÀÈÌÞÊÃÌÕ`i˜ÌÊÕ«ÀˆÃˆ˜}Ãʈ˜ÊiÃÃÊ̅>˜Ê>ÊÞi>À°Ê

ÞÊ,ˆ“>Ê ÀÕȇˆÊ`iÊ>“>`Àˆ`

O
N MARCH 10, ACLU EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR injuries, and the application of pressure in the
Anthony Romero issued an open let- neck, eye and jaw of the protesters to provoke
ter to the Civil Rights Division of the pain and cause unconsciousness. At most events
U.S. Department of Justice on the question of po- young women are the first to be targeted for po-
lice brutality in Puerto Rico. In the letter Romero lice violence and have also been sexually ha-
called on the Civil Rights Division, which has been rassed, groped and touched by police.”1
investigating the Puerto Rican police since 2008, The police violence unleashed against the
RICARDO ALCARAZ/DIALOGO DIGITAL

to complete its investigation and take into account contemporary Puerto Rican student movement,
reports of widespread abuses committed against which emerged in spring 2010, has turned the
Rima Brusi-Gil
University of Puerto Rico student protesters. University of Puerto Rico (UPR) into a testing
de Lamadrid is a
“Students have been mercilessly beaten, ground for the neoliberal state. Beyond quelling cultural anthro-
maced with pepper spray, and shot at with rub- the students’ exercising their rights of free speech pologist and an
ber bullets,” Romero wrote. “Police have also and association to contest “austerity measures” Associate Professor of
applied torture techniques on immobilized imposed by the university administration un- Social Sciences at the
University of Puerto
student protesters, including the illegal use of der the cover of the island’s “financial crisis,” the
Rico–Mayagüez.
nightsticks to provoke serious and permanent state seems to be probing how much violence it

NACLA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS

QL@=PA

can get away when dealing with pro- which are granted on the basis of fi- Figueroa Sancha, chief of staff Marcos
tests that undermine its agenda. nancial need. This was touted as part Rodríguez, and UPR Board of Trustees
In a way that has become familiar of the solution to the university’s cri- president Ygrí Rivera—echoed the
around the world, state violence in sis; its budget was already depressed governor’s sentiments, portraying
Puerto Rico complements broad, fast- before the passing of Law 7, and the the students as selfish, privileged,
paced neoliberal reforms.2 This was additional cuts have spelled disaster: disorderly, and ideologically driven.
made evident soon after the 2008 elec- The university now faces an estimated Disparaging the students and their
tions, when governor-elect Luis Fortuño annual deficit of between $240 mil- cause, politicians and administrators
(of the pro-statehood New Progressive lion and $300 million.4 speaking to the media, especially ra-
Party of Puerto Rico, or NPP, and the Re- Students responded by launching dio, frequently described them as so-
publican National Committee) started a strike. Originally planned as a two- cialists, leftists, anarcolocos (anarchist
appointing the members of his cabinet. day stoppage, the strike ended up crazies), and even terrorists.7
For the island’s police superintendent, lasting almost 10 weeks. Although Yet by June, popular opinion seemed
he named a former assistant FBI direc- one would hardly know it from the to side with the students. Editorials in
tor, José Figueroa Sancha, who quickly U.S. media, the students’ massive major newspapers urged the univer-
announced his commitment to “zero protests repeatedly paralyzed Puerto sity administration to negotiate with
tolerance” policing (known in Puerto Rico’s 11-campus, 65,000-student the students, as did San Juan Superior
Rico as la mano dura, or, roughly, the public university system. They not Court judge José Negrón Fernández,
iron fist). After Fortuño took office in only organized large demonstrations who named a mediator. Sixty-nine
January 2009, the NPP-dominated but also developed new participa- days after the strike began, the stu-
Legislative Assembly passed Public tory forms of decision making and dents ended it and an agreement was
Law 7, which declared a state of fiscal created their own media—including signed by a majority of the trustees that
emergency and authorized the govern- some that are still going strong, for included some important victories: Tu-
ment to fast-track the dismissal of some example the online newspaper Rojo ition waivers would remain in place;
17,000 public employees, while ex- Gallito, websites like Estudiantes de the imposition of an $800 annual fee
panding private contracting (including la UPR Informan, and online radio was postponed, pending reexamina-
with companies hired to manage the stations like Radio Huelga.5 tion and discussion; and university
layoffs). Public Law 7 also cut funds to After the student strike began, employees and students who partici-
the public university system. Fortuño framed his administration’s pated in the strike would not be sub-
The following August, the govern- position toward the UPR strike. In a ject to administrative sanctions.8 The
ment of the capital city of San Juan speech, he called the student strikers agreement, however, was not signed
decided to strictly enforce existing “members of a tiny minority” driven by either Rivera or UPR president José
regulations against public drinking. In by selfish, “ideological” motives, as op- Ramón de la Torre.
an ominous precursor, large numbers posed to a “silent majority” that “really The government, meanwhile, did
of Puerto Rico and municipal police, wants to study.” He referred to public, not miss a beat. Aggressively pursuing
including riot police, were mobilized affordable higher education as a “privi- their agenda, Fortuño and the legis-
to target Avenida Universidad, directly lege” that Puerto Rico provides to its lature set about undermining demo-
in front of the UPR campus in Río students at no small cost to its citizens. cratic governance at UPR, both in the
Piedras, a subdivision of San Juan. In- “Tuition paid by students covers hardly administration and among students.
stead of simply fining violators up to 3% of the university’s budget; the rest On June 21, Fortuño signed a law that
$500, as the law stipulates, the officers is paid by us taxpayers,” he said, con- had been fast-tracked through the leg-
chased students down the street and trasting responsible citizens with the islature the same day, expanding UPR’s
tear-gassed them, in one case sending protesting students. “That is why our Board of Trustees from 13 to 17 mem-
a young woman to the hospital with a people—a just and noble people, but bers, and announced the names of the
badly wounded thigh.3 also respectful of law and order, and new members the very next day.9 (To
In April 2010 the UPR admin- believing in democracy—get upset put this in context, UPR, with fewer
istration announced that tuition when they see what we have all wit- than 60,000 students, now has almost
waivers, traditionally given to ath- nessed at the university.”6 as many trustees as the New York State
letes, band and choir members, and Officials and public figures— university system, with more than
honor students, would be eliminated including ex-governor Romero 400,000.) Attuned to the legislature’s
for students eligible for Pell Grants, Barceló, Police Superintendent activities, members of student media,

MARCH/APRIL 2011

QL@=PA

unions, and environmental groups at- million, to the university.14 All these the orderly exercise of free speech and
tempted on June 30 to observe a legis- proposals were ignored, however, and association within the university com-
lative session in which several key new the student fee simply implemented. munity.”16 Immediately after the Court’s
laws would be discussed—including These developments prompted ruling, the chancellor of the Río Piedras
one that would criminalize certain the students at the Río Piedras cam- campus circulated a letter announcing
protests and another that would ef- pus to mobilize for a second strike, that large gatherings and demonstra-
fectively abolish student assemblies beginning with a 48-hour stoppage tions on campus would not be per-
and replace them with an anonymous on December 7–8, with the option to mitted until January 12, when classes
electronic voting system.10 But the begin an indefinite strike December were to resume, in order to “preserve
Capitol that morning was closed to the 14. Then, in the early-morning hours safety.”17 The chancellor’s decision was
public and surrounded by riot police, of December 7, when the two-day later found unconstitutional.18
despite the fact that the legislature’s ses- strike was to commence, private secu- Despite the students’ efforts in defi-
sions are open to the public under the rity guards hired by the university de- ance of the crackdown on their right
Constitution. Numerous incidents of molished the gates to the Río Piedras to protest, the $800 fee has remained
police brutality against demonstrators, campus to prevent the students from in place. It is expected to bring in an
as well as members of the press, were barricading themselves in, as they had annual $40 million. Meanwhile, the
documented that day by both main- done earlier in the year.15 Many of the Board of Trustees in April decided to
stream and alternative media.11 private guards were young men from request a $75 million line of credit for
During the ensuing months the impoverished communities with little new construction projects that will be
new majority on the Board of Trust- training and education, hired—in a outsourced to private developers. One
ees installed chancellors on several surreal turn of events—by the ex- of the projected buildings will house
campuses who were openly rejected by wrestler Chicky Starr, well-known the Army ROTC, a program that will
faculty assemblies and search commit- years ago for his cheating ways in the serve only about 100 students and
tees. At the Mayagüez campus, the new ring and now a recruiter for the Capi- whose presence on campus has histori-
chancellor declared that any demon- tol Security company. cally been criticized and resisted.19
strations or protests were to take place By December 9, private guards,

A
in a new “public expression zone” lo- riot police, and Puerto Rican police LTHOUGH STUDENTS AND THEIR
cated in an old athletic track, far away had virtually occupied the campus. supporters have faced po-
from campus buildings—and potential They have, with few interruptions, lice violence since the first
audiences. The Puerto Rican satirical remained ever since. The police occu- strike began, it intensified in the win-
online newspaper El Ñame wondered pation of the UPR campus beginning ter, once the $800 fee was instituted
whether such a move was not, after all, in December marked the first time and students defied official limits on
equivalent to sending protesting stu- that the police had entered university their expression. Now there were
dents to the moon, to “freely” express grounds in the decades since the draft- incidents every day, and numerous
what nobody would hear.12 ing of the No-Confrontation Policy, students were arrested, with many of
Finally, in December, Fortuño signed created to promote non-violent ne- the women reporting being groped
the law that made student voting elec- gotiation between conflicting groups by the arresting officers.20 In January,
tronic, effectively eliminating open, at the university in the late 1980s, UPR professors joined the chorus of
public debate in student assemblies.13 following violent confrontations be- denunciations, condemning the tech-
Soon after, the trustees ratified the post- tween police and students. It required niques used by the police during the
poned $800 fee, to be implemented in that the police stay off campuses. arrests as torture.21 In February, riot
January, without so much as a glance at Further crimping students’ rights, police attacked demonstrators at a
student and faculty proposals—some the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico sit-in at the Capitol with rubber bul-
of which even agreed to allow students ruled on December 13 that university lets, arresting more than 150.
and employees to shoulder more of the students do not have a right to go on The same week, a “paint-in”—
university’s financial burden, as long as strike. Because students are not em- in which students gathered at the
the trustees agreed to demand that the ployees, the Court argued, what they university to paint slogans against
legislature undo the cuts to the univer- “call ‘strike’ is simply an organized the fee and the police presence on
sity budget mandated by Law 7, as well protest.” As a consequence of this de- campus—ended in chaos, after the
as to direct monies owed by other gov- cision, the UPR administration was police attacked the demonstration,
ernment agencies, estimated at $300 now legally empowered to “regulate and dozens of student activists, as

NACLA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS

QL@=PA

well as passersby, ended up wounded May 2010 videos and photos posted to use $30 million to “help” the UPR
or arrested.22 online supported allegations that budget. Instead of giving the money
University faculty and employees Assistant Police Superintendent José directly to the troubled institution so
joined the students’ protests against Rosa Carrasquillo had repeatedly that the fee could be reduced for ev-
the police violence and occupation of kicked a subdued student in the geni- eryone, it will be given away to indi-
the university, culminating in the res- tals, prompting the ACLU to demand vidual students, selected by a board,
ignation of UPR president De la Torre that he be dismissed and charged with as a “scholarship.” It would not be
on February 11. Following a massive assault.27 Nothing came of it. surprising for these “scholarships”
march of some 15,000 people on Although the use and abuse of po- to eventually morph into a sort of
February 12, Fortuño, who who had lice forces and the erosion of civil rights voucher system that students would
spent the weekend in Washington are the most visible, and the most vis- be able to use in the private colleges
at the Conservative Political Action ibly violent, tactics of neoliberalism that are proliferating on the island.29
Conference, returned to Puerto Rico being tested at UPR, they are not the Indeed, the deliberate shrinking of
and announced that the police would only ones. They have accompanied a the UPR system is equivalent, if not
be withdrawn from campus. By the concerted effort to shrink the institu- identical, to the privatization of higher
25th, however, they had returned.23 tion and funnel public funds away education. This would be consonant
from it. Although the administration with the broader neoliberal agenda of

I
F THE UNIVERSITY BECAME A TEST- has not explicitly stated plans to close Fortuño, who once served on the Board
ing ground for the violence of campuses or eliminate programs, it of Directors of one of the largest private
the neoliberal state, it has also publicly bases its revenue projec- education institutions in Puerto Rico,
become one for an exhausted stu- tions on an estimated student body the Ana G. Méndez university system.
dent movement that has come un- of 50,000 students, which is 15,000 The consequences of this agenda would
der increased criticism, including fewer than in 2008, and the lowest be devastating for the diversity of the
from within its own ranks, for tac- number since the early 1970s. student body. Because socioeconomic
tics such as wearing hoods, closing When the administration reported inequality translates into pre-college
down the campus, and throwing that about 54,000 students had educational inequality, students from
smoke bombs inside buildings.24 registered in late January and early poorer communities tend to have lower
This critique reached a high point February, it called this “a success.”28 admission, retention, and graduation
in March, when Ana Guadalupe, the The number of registered students rates. As the university gets smaller, the
Río Piedras chancellor, was assaulted has declined since 2010 for a variety students most likely to be affected are
by an angry mob of protesters.25 Pre- of reasons—some have been asked to precisely those with the most economic
dictably, the government and its sup- leave, as exchange students recently need. They will likely end up at pri-
porters immediately condemned the were, for “security reasons.” Some vate institutions in Puerto Rico, most
incident; some in the media who had have left because of the conflict, as of which have higher tuitions and
supported the students, like Mayra the administration is quick to point lower graduation rates than UPR.
Montero, a popular columnist for El out. And some have left because they This has implications for the student
Nuevo Día, now scolded them and simply can no longer afford it, though profile, for institutional diversity, but
called the strike “a failure.”26 their number remains unknown. even more critically, for the ability of
Others lamented the incident for Perhaps the most significant fac- Puerto Rico to face its current and fu-
its improvised and violent nature, so tor in the loss of students, however, ture social and economic challenges.
different from the nonviolent yet cre- has been the deliberate elimination Historically, the people of Puerto
ative and assertive expression people of course offerings, which prevents Rico have viewed their public uni-
had come to expect from the student students from being able to achieve versity not as a cost or as a burden
movement. Yet others have noted that full-time status. Low-income stu- but as an investment—the kind of
the state and the administration were dents are particularly vulnerable to investment most needed in times
quick to investigate, arrest, and pros- this, since to qualify for a Pell Grant of economic crisis. At stake in the
ecute students for pulling Guadalupe’s students must register for at least 12 students’ continuing struggle are the
hair and throwing water at her, but credits. These low-income students civil rights of Puerto Ricans and the
that the numerous abuses committed who leave will become particularly question of whether the public uni-
by police against the students never attractive as “customers” for private versity, and indeed the very notion
seem to be adequately investigated, if colleges, which may end up benefit- of public investment in the common
at all. To name just one example, in ting from how the legislature plans good, will survive.

NACLA REPORT ON THE AMERICAS

JKPAO

The University of Puerto Rico 2. Wendy Hunter and Timothy J. Power, “Rewarding Lula: Executive Power, Social
Policy, and the Brazilian Elections of 2006,” Latin American Politics and Society
1. Anthony D. Romero, ACLU Executive Director, to Mr. Thomas E. Perez Assistant 49, no. 1 (spring 2007): 19.
Attorney General, Civil Rights Division, United States Department of Justice, 3. Wendy Hunter, The Transformation of the Workers’ Party in Brazil, 1989–2009
Washington, DC, March 10, 2011. (Cambridge University Press, 2010), 170, 34.
2. Paul Treanor, “Neoliberalism: Origins, Theory, Definition,” December 2, 2005, 4. Benjamin Goldfrank and Brian Wampler, “From Petista Way to Brazilian Way:
web.inter.nl.net/users/Paul.Treanor/neoliberalism.html. How the PT Changes in the Road,” Revista Debates (Porto Alegre) 2, no. 2
3. Maribel Hernández Pérez, “Salpafuera en la avenida Universidad deja policías (July–December 2008): 248.
y civiles heridos,” Primera Hora (San Juan), August 21, 2009. 5. Uirá Machado, “ ‘PT mudou a ponto de ficar quase irreconhecível’, diz cientista
4. Tanishka Colon, “Propuesta para atajar la crisis fiscal de la UPR,” Diálogo política,” Folha do São Paulo, November 28, 2010.
Digital, June 22, 2010. 6. Pedro Ribeiro, “Thesis: Dos sindicatos ao governo: a organização nacional do PT
5. For a list of blogs, websites, and indie radio stations, see luchasrum.wordpress de 1980 a 2005,” Universidade de São Carlos, 2008, 8; Ibid., 271.
.com/2010/05/10/recursos-para-estar-al-da-con-la-huelga-de-la-upr. 7. Hunter, The Transformation of the Workers’ Party, 38.
6. Luis G. Fortuño, “Mensaje de Presupuesto,” speech, April 26, 2010. 8. David Julian Samuels, “Money, Elections, and Democracy in Brazil,” Latin
7. José Ramón de la Torre, “Vandalos(…) anarco/locos,” interview, Radio Isla, American Politics and Society (Miami) 43, no. 2 (summer 2001): 39.
December 8, 2010, radioisla1320.com/?p=1793. 9. Ruy Fausto, “Para além da gangrene,” Lua Nova (São Paulo) 65 (May–August
8. Maritza Díaz Alcaide, “Termina la huelga en la UPR,” Primera Hora, June 21, 2005): 11.
2010. 10. Goldfrank and Wampler, “From Petista Way to Brazilian Way,” 251.
9. Nydia Bauzá, “Fortuño firma ley y anuncia nuevos miembros de la Junta de 11. O Globo (Rio de Janeiro), “Gasto de Lula com cargos de confiança cresceu
Síndicos UPR,” Primera Hora, June 22, 2010. 119%,” February 22, 2010.
10. Érika Fontánez Torres, “Criminalizar la protesta: una forma de censura,”
80grados, September 28, 2010. Lula’s Political Economy
11. El Nuevo Día, “Calidad de vida,” blog, June 30, 2010.
12. Oscar Marrano, “UPR garantiza derechos de estudiantes: establece áreas de 1. Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, “Au-delà de la récession, nous sommes face à une
expresión pública en mona y caja de muertos,” El Ñame, December 10, 2010; crise de civilisation,” Le Monde (Paris), March 31, 2009.
Cangrimán, “De La Torre designa la zona fantasma como área de expresión 2. “Bolsa Família: Changing the Lives of Millions in Brazil,” The World Bank, ac-
pública del sistema UPR,” El Ñame, January 19, 2011. cessed April 22, 2011.
13. CyberNews, “Ya es ley el voto electrónico en la UPR,” Wapa.tv, December 3. Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Aplicada (IPEA), “PNAD 2009 – Primeiras Aná-
8, 2010. lises: Distribuição de Renda entre 1995 e 2009,” comunicado de IPEA, October
14. Leysa Caro González, “La cuota de $800 a los estudiantes de la UPR sí va 5, 2010.
en enero,” Primera Hora, December 15, 2010; 80grados, “La universidad: 4. Marcelo Cortes Neri, ed., “The New Middle Class,” Centro de Políticas Sociais,
sumando ganamos todos,” editorial, December 3, 2010; Comité Negociador Instituto Brasileiro de Economia, Fundação Getulio Vargas, August 2008.
Estudiantes UPR, “UPR: propuesta preliminar del comité negociador de los 5. Folha Online, “Entenda o chamado ‘caseirogate’ e a cronologia dos fatos que
estudiantes en huelga,” Indymedia Puerto Rico, April 19, 2010. derrubaram Palocci,” March 27, 2006.
15. Nydia Bauzá, “Capitol se agenció contrato millonario,” Primera Hora, De- 6. Paulo Kliass, “Mais uma vez, os incomensuráveis lucros dos bancos,” Carta
cember 8, 2010. Maior, February 5, 2011.
16. Juan A. Hernandez, “UPR Student Strike Starts Today at Río Piedras: De La 7. Câmara dos Deputados, “Lei Orçamentária Anual para 2011,” February 9,
Torre Says ‘No Way’ to Most Proposals,” Puerto Rico Daily Sun, December 2011.
14, 2010. 8. Clóvis Rossi, “Soros diz que EUA irão impor Serra e que Lula seria o caos,”
17. Wilmarie Hernández Vélez, “Un derecho protegido: las manifestaciones estu- Folha de São Paulo, June 8, 2002; Camilla Bustani, “The Challenges to Lula’s
diantiles,” Diálogo Digital, December 21, 2010. Revolution,” Open Democracy, January 16, 2003.
18. Ibid. 9. Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, “Carta ao povo brasileiro,” June 22, 2002.
19. Cynthia López, “Aprueban construir un edificio para el ROTC en la UPR,” El 10. Rosa Maria Marques and Paulo Nakatani, “A Política Econômica Do Governo
Nuevo Día, April 7, 2011. Lula: Como Mudar Para Ficar No Mesmo,” Forum des Alternatives, March
20. Maritza Stanchich, “Violence Against Student Strike in Puerto Rico Escalates 3, 2008.
With Police Brutality and Rubber Bullets,” The Huffington Post, February 2, 11. Agência Brasil, “Governo fará aperto fiscal para garantir superávit maior em
2011. 2003, diz Palocci,” Agência Brasil, January 13, 2003.
21. Maritza Díaz Alcaide, “Profesores de la UPR le achacan ‘abuso policial’ al 12. Banco Central do Brasil, “Economic Indicators; 1.2 Price Indices,” chart, April
Gobernador,” Primera Hora, January 29, 2011. 20, 2011.
22. CMI-Puerto Rico, “Policías convierten pintata estudiantil en jornada de violencia,” 13. Ministério do Desenvolvimento, Indústria e Comércio Exterior, “Panorama do
photo report, February 10, 2011. Comércio Exterior Brasileiro 2010,” report.
23. Leysa Caro González, “Regresa la Policía al Recinto de Río Piedras,” Primera 14. EFE, “Brasil paga dívida com FMI mas mantém política econômica austera,”
Hora, February 25, 2011. January 10, 2006.
24. See 80grados.net for a number of articles pertaining to these debates. 15. Banco Central do Brasil, “Daily International Reserves,” accessed April 2011,
25. Camila Espina, “Manifestación termina con empujones y cristales rotos,” bcb.gov.br/?DAILYRESERVES.
Diálogo Digital, March 7, 2011. 16. Paulo Kliass, “Nossas exportações: opção política ou vocação natural?,”
26. Mayra Montero, “Universidad,” Antes Que Llegue el Lunes (blog), El Nuevo Carta Maior, January 27, 2011.
Dia, March 13, 2011. 17. Repórter Brasil, “Especial: O avanço da cana-de-açúcar,” compilation of ar-
27. Eduardo Andrade, “ACLU pide destitución de Rosa Carrasquillo,” Diálogo ticles, accessed April 2011, reporterbrasil.org.br/conteudo.php?id=107.
Digital, May 25, 2010. 18. Gilberto Costa, “Estrutura fundiária brasileira continua inalterada,” Agência
28. Inter News Services, “CGE desmiente a De la Torre sobre matrícula,” January Brasil, February 22, 2011, mst.org.br/node/11286.
24, 2011. 19. Luciene Cruz and Stênio Ribeiro, “Governo anuncia corte de R$ 50 bilhões no
29. CyberNews, “Estudiantes recibirían doble ayuda,” January 14, 2011. Orçamento,” Agência Brasil, February 9, 2011.
20. Banco Central do Brasil, “Review Of COPOM Meetings and Short-Term Inter-
After Lula est Rates,” accessed April 2011, bcb.gov.br/?INTEREST.
21. Michael Hudson, “How Brazil Can Defend Against Financialization,” CDES
1. Verena Glass, “Movimentos discordam sobre posição frente a PT e governo,” conference paper, September 17, 2010.
Carta Maior, July 18, 2005.


Potrebbero piacerti anche