Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
OF MAHARASHTRA LIMITED
Volume - II
Chapter - 1 – Introduction
Chapter - 2 – Analysis of Alternative Sites
Chapter - 3 – Project Description
June 2010
Volume - II
Chapter - 1 – Introduction
Chapter - 2 – Analysis of Alternative Sites
Chapter - 3 – Project Description
June 2010
CONTENTS
VOLUME - I
Executive Summary
VOLUME - II
Chapter 1 : Introduction Page
No.
1.1 : Background 1
1.11.2 : Water 36
1.11.4 : Energy 36
1.11.6 : CRZ 38
1.11.7 : Noise 39
1.13 : Scoping 45
2.3 : Rewas-Mandwa 2
2.3.2 : Accessibility 4
2.6 : Conclusion 20
3.1.1 : Location 1
3.1.4 : Linkages 3
3.5.1 : Runways 16
VOLUME - III
Chapter 4 : Description of Environment
4.1 : Introduction 1
4.3 : Hydrometeorology 3
4.4 : Physiography 5
4.5 : Geology 8
4.6 : Drainage 11
4.7.4 : Permeability 24
4.7.5 : Porosity 25
4.13.4 : Water Quality Status of Major aquatic Habitat in the Project Area 332
VOLUME-IV
Chapter 5 : Environmental Impacts & Mitigation Measures
5.0 : Background 1
6.2 : Scope 1
6.3 : Objectives 2
VOLUME-V
Chapter 8 : Additional Studies
8.0 : Introduction 1
8.2.1 : Background 22
8.3.1 : Background 31
8.5.1 : Methodology 40
: ANNEXURE-I
: ANNEXURE II
: ANNEXURE III
: ANNEXURE IV
: ANNEXURE V
: ANNEXURE VI
: ANNEXURE VII
List of Tables
VOLUME-II
Chapter 1
1.11 Current Fleet Mix – Scheduled Weekly Arrivals, CSIA ( January 2008) 25
1.12 Current Fleet Mix – Scheduled Weekly Arrivals, CSIA ( Summer 2004) 25
Chapter 2
Chapter 3
VOLUME-III
Chapter 4
4.10 Texture And Particle Size Distribution Of Soil In The Project Area 31
During Post Monsoon Season
4.11 Texture And Particle Size Distribution Of Soil In The Project Area 32
During Pre Monsoon Season
4.12 Texture And Particle Size Distribution Of Soil In The Project Area 33
During Monsoon Season
4.32 Nsf Water Quality Index (Wqi) Calculated For Creek Water For Post 98
Monsoon Season
4.33 NSF Water Quality Index (Wqi) Calculated For Creek Water For Pre 99
Monsoon Season
4.34 NSF Water Quality Index (Wqi) Calculated For Creek Water For 100
Monsoon Season
4.35 Results Of Water Quality Analysis Of Ground Water In The Project 102
Area During Post Monsoon Season
4.36 Results Of Water Quality Analysis Of Ground Water In The Project 103
Area During Pre Monsoon Season
4.38 Nsf Water Quality Index (Wqi) Calculated For Ground Water For Post 116
Monsoon Season
4.39 Nsf Water Quality Index (Wqi) Calculated For Ground Water For Pre 117
Monsoon Season
4.40 Nsf Water Quality Index (Wqi) Calculated For Water For Monsoon 118
Season
4.42 (a) Monthwise Measured Values Of Tsp (G/M3) In Air At Various 125
Stations Of The Project Area During The Post Monsoon Season
4.42 (c) Monthwise Measured Values Of Nox (G/M3) In Air At Various 127
Stations Of The Project Area During The Post Monsoon Season
4.42 (d) Monthwise Measured Values Of So2 (G/M3) In Air At Various 128
Stations Of The Project Area During The Post Monsoon Season
4.42 (e) Monthwise Measured Values Of Nh3 (G/M3) In Air At Various 129
Stations Of The Project Area During The Post Monsoon Season
4.42 (h) Monthwise Measured Values Of Tsp (G/M3) In Air At Various 131
Stations Of The Project Area During The Winter Season
4.42 (i) Monthwise Measured Values Of Pm10 (G/M3) In Air At Various 133
Stations Of The Project Area During The Winter Season
4.42 (k) Monthwise Measured Values Of So2 (G/M3) In Air At Various 135
Stations Of The Project Area During The Winter Season
4.42 (l) Monthwise Measured Values Of Nh3 (G/M3) In Air At Various 136
Stations Of The Project Area During The Winter Season
4.42 (o) Monthwise Measured Values Of Tsp (G/M3) In Air At Various 139
Stations Of The Project Area During The Pre Monsoon Season
4.42 (p) Monthwise Measured Values Of Pm10 (G/M3) In Air At Various 140
Stations Of The Project Area During The Pre Monsoon Season
4.42 (q) Monthwise Measured Values Of Nox (G/M3) In Air At Various 141
Stations Of The Project Area During The Pre Monsoon Season
4.42 (s) Monthwise Measured Values Of Nh3 (G/M3) In Air At Various 143
Stations Of The Project Area During The Pre Monsoon Season
4.42 (v) Monthwise Measured Values Of Tsp (G/M3) In Air At Various 146
Stations Of The Project Area During The Monsoon Season
4.42 (w) Monthwise Measured Values Of Pm10 (G/M3) In Air At Various 147
Stations Of The Project Area During The Monsoon Season
4.42 (x) Monthwise Measured Values Of Nox (G/M3) In Air At Various 148
Stations Of The Project Area During The Monsoon Season
4.42 (y) Monthwise Measured Values Of So2 (G/M3) In Air At Various 149
Stations Of The Project Area During The Monsoon Season
4.42 (z) Monthwise Measured Values Of Nh3 (G/M3) In Air At Various 150
Stations Of The Project Area During The Monsoon Season
4.42 (z’) Monthwise Measured Values Of Co (G/M3) In Air At Various Stations 151
Of The Project Area During The Monsoon Season
4.47 Air Quality Index (Aqi) And Air Quality Status At Various Station Of 163
The Project Area During Post Monsoon Season
4.48 Air Quality Index (AQI) And Air Quality Status At Various Station Of 164
The Project Area During Winter Season
4.49 Air Quality Index (Aqi) And Air Quality Status At Various Station Of 165
The Project Area During Pre Monsoon Season
4.50 Air Quality Index (Aqi) And Air Quality Status At Various Station Of 166
The Project Area During Monsoon Season
4.51 Average Air Quality Index (Aqi) And Overall Air Quality Status At 167
Various Station Of The Project Area During Post Monsoon, Pre
Monsoon, Monsoon Season
4.52 (a) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For November, 2007 172
4.52 (b) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For December, 2007 174
4.52 (c) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For January, 2008 175
4.52 (d) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For February, 2008 177
4.52 (e) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For March, 2008 178
4.52 (f) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For April, 2008 180
4.52 (g) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For May, 2008 182
4.52 (h) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For June, 2008 184
4.52 (i) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For July, 2008 185
4.52 (j) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For August, 2008 187
4.52 (k) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For September, 2008 188
4.52 (l) Meteorological Data Recorded At Panvel For October, 2008 190
4.57 Frequency Of Cloud Cover In Oktas Observed In The Project Area 211
During Post Monsoon Season
4.58 Frequency Of Cloud Cover In Oktas Observed In The Project Area 211
During Winter Season
4.59 Frequency Of Cloud Cover In Oktas Observed In The Project Area 212
4.60 Frequency Of Cloud Cover In Oktas Observed In The Project Area 212
During Monsoon Season
4.61 (a) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of November’ 213
2007
4.61 (b) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of December, 214
2007
4.61 (c) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of January, 2008 216
4.61 (d) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of February, 2008 217
4.61 (e) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of March, 2008 219
4.61 (f) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of April, 2008 220
4.61 (g) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of May, 2008 222
4.61 (h) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of June, 2008 223
4.61(i) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of July, 2008 225
4.61 (j) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of August, 2008 226
4.61 (k) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of September, 228
2008
4.61 (l) Type Of Cloud Cover Observed During The Month Of October, 2008 229
4.62 Visibility Observed Within Study Area During Post Monsoon Season 231
4.63 Visibility Observed Within Study Area During Winter Season 232
4.64 Visibility Observed Within Study Area During Pre Monsoon Season 233
4.65 Visibility Observed Within Study Area During Monsoon Season 234
4.66 Locations of Ambient Noise Quality Monitoring stations in and around 236
the project site
4.68 (a) Hourly Leq Values At Various Location Of The Project Area During 241
Post Monsoon Season
4.68 (b) Hourly Leq Values At Various Location Of The Project AreaDuring 243
Pre Monsoon season
4.68 (c) Hourly Leq Values At Various Locations Of The Project Area During 245
Monsoon Season
4.69 (a) Area wise Noise Characteristics In The Project Area During Post 251
Monsoon Season (January, 2008)
4.69 (b) Area wise Noise Characteristics In The Project Area During Pre 252
Monsoon Season (April, 2008)
4.69 (c) Area wise Noise Characteristics In The Project Area During Monsoon 253
Season (October, 2008)
4.71 (a) Ambient Noise Level At Various Location Of The Project Area During 255
Post Monsoon Season
4.71 (b) Ambient Noise Level At Various Location Of The Project Area During 256
Pre Monsoon Season
4.71 (c) Ambient Noise Level At Various Location Of The Project Area During 257
Monsoon Season
4.73 Monitoring Stations In The Project Area For Ecological Studies 260
4.76 Fish, Amphibians, Prawns & Crabs Encountered During The Site 268
Visits In Different Seasons
4.77 (a) Ecological Indices for the Flora of Terrestrial Habitats in Project Area 283
Surveyed During Pre Monsoon Season
4.77 (b) Ecological Indices for the Flora of Terrestrial Habitats in Project Area 288
Surveyed During Monsoon Season
4.77 (c) Ecological Indices for the Flora of Terrestrial Habitats in Project Area 295
Surveyed During Post Monsoon Season
4.80 (a) Phytoplankton Species Encountered in Marine Water of Gadhi River, 306
Ulwe River and Panvel Creek during Pre-Monsoon Season
4.80 (b) Phytoplankton species encountered at all collection stations from 307
Gadhi River, Ulwe River and Panvel Creek in Monsoon Season
4.80 (c) Phytoplankton species encountered at all collection stations from 308
Gadhi River, Ulwe River and Panvel Creek in Post Monsoon
4.81 (a) Primary Production of Water at Different Stations along Gadhi River, 311
Ulwe River and Panvel Creek in Pre Monsoon Season
4.81 (b) Primary Production of Water Collected From Different Stations along 312
Gadhi River, Ulwe River and Panvel Creek in Monsoon Season
4.81 (c) Primary Production of Water Collected From Different Stations along 313
Gadhi River, Ulwe River and Panvel Creek in Post Monsoon Season
4.82 (a) Species Composition of Zooplankton from Various Stations in Aquatic 315
Habitats in the Project Area during Pre- Monsoon Season
4.82 (b) Zooplankton Species encountered in waters collected from different 316
sites along Gadhi River, Ulwe River And Panvel Creek during
monsoon
4.82 (c) Species encountered in waters collected from different sites along 317
Gadhi River, Ulwe River And Panvel Creek during Post monsoon
4.83 (b) Ecological Indices for Zooplankton Species at Various Locations 319
Along Gadhi River, Panvel Creek And Ulwe River during Monsoon.
4.83 (c) Ecological Indices Calculated For The Zooplankton From Various 320
Locations Along Gadhi River, Panvel Creek And Ulwe River during
Post Monsoon.
4.84 (a) Dry Organic Weight of the Zooplankton Collected From Various 321
Stations along Gadhi River, Panvel Creek and Ulwe River During Pre
Monsoon Season
4.84 (b) Dry Organic Weight of the Zooplankton Collected From Various 323
Stations along Gadhi River, Panvel Creek and Ulwe River During
Monsoon Season
4.84 (c) Dry Organic Weight of the Zooplankton Collected From Various 324
Stations along Gadhi River, Panvel Creek and Ulwe River during Post
Monsoon Season
4.85 (b) Benthic Forms Encountered in the Sediments Collected at Various 327
Stations along Gadhi River, Panvel Creek and Ulwe River during
Monsoon Season.
4.86 (a ) Organic Matter Content of Sediments from Various Stations along 329
Gadhi River, Ulwe River and Panvel Creek during Pre Monsoon
Season
4.86 (b) Organic Matter Content of Sediments from Various Stations along 330
Gadhi River, Ulwe River and Panvel Creek during Monsoon Season
4.86 (c) Organic Matter Content of Sediments from Various Stations along 331
Gadhi River, Ulwe River and Panvel Creek during Post Monsoon
Season
4.87 (a) Results Of Water Quality Analysis Of Gadhi River During Post 333
Monsoon Season
4.87 (b) Results Of Water Quality Analysis Of Gadhi River During Pre 334
Monsoon Season
4.87 (c) Results Of Water Quality Analysis Of Gadhi River During Monsoon 335
Season
4.87 (d) Results Of Water Quality Analysis Of Ulve River During Post 336
Monsoon, Premonsoon And Monsoon
4.87 (e) Results Of Water Quality Analysis Of Panvel Creek During Post 337
Monsoon, Pre-Monsoon & Monsoon Season
4.88 Direct Connectivity To Catchment Area And The Rest Of The Country 341
4.116 Villages, Settlements Area & Population and Househols within 391
Airport
VOLUME-IV
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
Chapter 7
VOLUME V
Chapter 8
List of Figures
VOLUME II
Chapter 1
Chapter 2
2.1 Map showing location of Rewas Mandwa & Navi Mumbai airports 2
Chapter 3
VOLUME III
Chapter 4
4.11 Textural Triangle Showing The Percentage Of Sand, Silt And Clay 20
4.26 (a) Hourly Variation Of Average Wind Speed For The Month Of 197
November, 2007 And October 2008
4.26 (b) Hourly Variation Of Average Temperature For The Month Of 198
November, 2007 And October 2008
4.26 (c) Hourly Variation Of Average Relative Humidity For The Month Of 198
November, 2007 And October 2008
4.26 (d) Hourly Variation Of Average Solar Radiation For The Month Of 199
November, 2007 And October 2008
4.27 (a) Hourly Variation of Average Wind Speed for the Month of December, 199
2007, January, 2008 and February, 2008
4.27 (b) Hourly Variation of Average Temperature for the Month of December, 200
2007, January, 2008 and February, 2008
4.27 (c) Hourly Variation of Average Relative Humidity Speed for the Month of 200
December, 2007, January, 2008 and February, 2008
4.27 (d) Hourly Variation of Average Solar Radiation for the Month of 201
December, 2007,January, 2008 And February, 2008
4.28 (a) Hourly Variation of Average Wind Speed for the Month of March, 201
2008, April, 2008 and May, 2008
4.28 (b) Hourly Variation of Average Temperature for the Month of March, 202
2008, April, 2008 and May, 2008
4.28 (c) Hourly Variation of Average Relative Humidity Speed for the Month of 202
March, 2008, April, 2008 and May, 2008
4.28 (d) Hourly Variation of Average Solar Radiation for the Month of March, 203
2008, April, 2008 and May, 2008
4.29 (a) Hourly Variation of Average Wind Speed for the Month Of June, 203
2008, July, 2008, August, 2008 and September, 2008
4.29 (b) Hourly Variation of Average Temperature for the Month Of June, 204
2008, July, 2008, August, 2008 and September, 2008
4.29 (c) Hourly Variation Of Average Relative Humidity For The Month Of 204
June, 2008, July, 2008, August, 2008 And September, 2008
4.30 (a) Wind Rose For The Month Of November, 2007 205
4.30 (b) Wind Rose For The Month Of December, 2007 205
4.30 (c) Wind Rose For The Month Of January, 2008 206
4.30 (d) Wind Rose For The Month Of February, 2008 206
4.30 (e) Wind Rose For The Month Of March, 2008 207
4.30 (f) Wind Rose For The Month Of April, 2008 207
4.30 (g) Wind Rose For The Month Of May, 2008 208
4.30 (h) Wind Rose For The Month Of June, 2008 208
4.30 (i) Wind Rose For The Month Of July, 2008 209
4.30 (j) Wind Rose For The Month Of August, 2008 209
4.30 (k) Wind Rose For The Month Of September, 2008 210
4.30 (l) Wind Rose For The Month Of October, 2008 210
4.34 Location and Catchment area of the Proposed airport in Navi Mumbai 340
4.36 Land Access Modes Of Navi Mumbai Airport - The Important 346
Linkages
4.56 Approved Map Of Navi Mumbai Costal Zone Management Plan-1 410
4.57 Approved Map Of Navi Mumbai Costal Zone Management Plan-2 411
4.59 Navi Mumbai International Airport With The Training Of Gadhi And 413
Diversion Of Ulwe Rivers
VOLUME IV
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
VOLUME V
Chapter 8
8.4 Digitized shape of Vaghvli island & the coastal lines imagery 40
8.5 Digitized shape of Vaghvli island & the coastal lines imagery 1992 41
8.6 Digitized shape of Vaghvli island & the coastal lines imagery 1995 42
8.7 Digitized shape of Vaghvli island & the coastal lines on Iknos imagery 43
2001
8.8 Digitized shape of Vaghvli island & the coastal lines on imagery 2006 44
8.9 Digitized shape of Vaghvli island & the coastal lines on imagery 2009 45
Chapter-1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
The Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) is spread over an area of 4355 Sq. Km.
and comprises mainly of Greater Mumbai, Thane, Kalyan, Vasai-Virar and Navi
Mumbai. The population of MMR was 189.80 lakhs in 2001. The population of the
MMR is projected to grow substantially from the current 189.80 lakhs count to
approximately 235 lakhs by the year 2011 and over 300 lakhs beyond the year
2022.
To meet the expected demand for the above activities in the Region, there is
need to provide highest order of infrastructure. One of the major infrastructure
that need immediate attention is to increase the capacity of airports in the Region
since the existing airport in Mumbai is experiencing tremendous pressure in
meeting the air travel demand.
Considering the need of air travel of city population, City and Industrial
Development Corporation of Maharashtra (CIDCO) , as a part of Navi Mumbai
development, had proposed a domestic airport. With the initial site feasibility
study conducted by M/s.RITES, a location near Panvel was selected. Further, a
Realising the problems at other identified sites in MMR and at the behest of
Govt. of Maharashtra, the proposal of domestic airport was upgraded to
International airport and accordingly a ‘Technical Feasibility Report’ was
submitted to Govt. of India in 1998.
The Committee constituted in 1998 by the Ministry of Civil Aviation, Govt. of India
to identify suitable site for 2nd airport for Mumbai examined Navi Mumbai site
along with Rewas-Mandawa and Mhapan in Sindhudurg district and
recommended the Rewas-Mandwa site as most suitable site in 2000. The Navi
Mumbai site, while considered suitable for a domestic airport, was determined
unsuitable for international airport as no parallel runway had been proposed.
CIDCO then revised its original proposal incorporating the provision for a parallel
runway and made a presentation for development of Navi Mumbai International
Airport (NMIA) The proposal of CIDCO was considered financially viable,
environmentally less disturbing, supported by the local people. Thereafter
CIDCO, through Government of Maharashtra(GOM), submitted the proposal
enclosing a pre-feasibility report detailing air travel demand, project facilities,
phasing, costing and financial viability with dual runway to the Ministry of Civil
Aviation(MOCA), Government of India(GOI).
The Ministry of Civil Aviation, Government of India, in turn through the Airport
Authority of India, constituted a technical team to examine the pre-feasibility
report. The team concluded that the Navi Mumbai site is operationally feasible
for locating the second International Airport for Mumbai, and suggested to
conduct studies such as geological/geo-technical, hydrological, traffic and
environmental studies etc.
were reconciled and finally narrowed down to only two points i.e. the provision of
parallel independent runways with a spacing of 1035 mt. and carrying out the
Simulation study to establish the conflict free operation of Mumbai and Navi
Mumbai Airports. CIDCO carried out the exercise and accommodated parallel
independent runways with 1035 spacing between the centerline of two runways.
Upon the positive findings of the simulation study, the Union Cabinet in the
Ministry of Civil Aviation, Govt. of India, granted “In Principle” approval in July,
2007 for development of second airport at Navi Mumbai on public private
partnership basis based on the Project Feasibility & Business Plan report
submitted by Govt. of Maharashtra. The Govt. of Maharashtra also granted
approval in July 2008 for the development of Navi Mumbai International Airport
and appointed CIDCO as a Nodal Agency for implementation.
As stated above, Ministry of Civil Aviation, Govt. of India has granted “In
Principle” approval for setting-up a Greenfield airport through public-private
partnership (PPP) at Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra; to Govt. of Maharashtra. The
Govt. of Maharashtra, in turn appointed City & Industrial Development
Corporation Ltd. (CIDCO), a company incorporated under the Companies Act,
1956, wholly owned by Govt. of Maharashtra, as a “Nodal Agency” for
implementation of Navi Mumbai International airport project. A Special Purpose
Company (SPC) will be incorporated by CIDCO/AAI and project developer to be
selected through competitive bidding to take up the implementation of NMIA
project at Navi Mumbai.
These are divided into five main categories, as broken down in Table1.1;
with their respective share of total passenger traffic during the first 10
months of the 2008-09 fiscal year.
Table 1.1
National Airport System
Number Share Pax
Category
Airports 2008-09
Joint-Venture
International 5 59.4%
International 12 28.2%
Custom 8 5.1%
Domestic 21 6.2%
Other 80 1.2%
The four largest Indian airports (Mumbai, Delhi, Chennai, and Bangalore)
each handle more than 10 million annual passengers and accounted for
more than 60% of national passenger traffic during the fiscal year 2007-
08.
Fig 1.1
Map of Major Airports in India
increasing to almost 117 million upto end of fiscal year 2007-08. Most
growth has taken place since 2003/04, averaging 24.4% per year, with
particularly high growth in domestic traffic.
Air Freight has also increased substantially in recent years, though not
quite to the same extent as passengers (see Table 1.3). Total air freight
has grown from 1,068,445 tonnes in 2003-04 to 1,713,960 tonnes in
2007-08 at an average annual growth rate of 12.5%.
Table 1.2
Table 1.3
The driving forces behind this rapid growth in air traffic are:
The abolition of the Inland Air Travel Tax (IATT) in January 2004,
resulting in a reduction in domestic fares of 15%
It’s important to note that many of the factors that led to the recent boom
in traffic are still relevant and growth can be expected to resume once
economic conditions improve.
There are also several other major commercial airports in Western India
that can be considered to be in the same region as Mumbai, based on a
criteria of being within one day travel by land. These are:
Goa
Ahmedabad
Vadodara
Mumbai (CSIA)
Pune
Nagpur
Aurangabad
Table 1.4 presents a summary of recent air passenger traffic at each of the
primary regional airports in terms of total passengers.
Table 1.4
Regional and State Airports Passenger Data
The fastest growing airports during the current decade have been Pune,
Nagpur, Ahmedabad and Goa. But it is also these last two that have
suffered the sharpest downturns in traffic during 2008-09. In general, the
Maharashtra airports have all proved to be less affected by the current
crisis than those in the neighbouring states, with Pune and Aurangabad
performing particularly well in maintaining traffic levels.
Table 1.5 presents a summary of air freight data for these same airports.
Outside of CSIA, only Ahmedabad and Pune handle a significant amount of
cargo.
Table 1.5
Regional and State Airports Freight Data
(in tonnes)
Goa Airport: The Dabolim International Airport serves one of India’s most
important tourist destinations, located along the coast 600 km to the south
of Mumbai. The airport accounts for as much as 90% of India’s
international charter traffic. Dabolim's scheduled international flights are
sporadic; primarily short-haul flights operated by Air India/Indian and Sri
Lankan Airlines. On the other hand, scheduled domestic traffic has been
increasing rapidly, surpassing 2.1 million annual passengers in 2007-08,
having more than doubled over the previous three years. Airport facilities
are shared with the Navy which has resulted in some restrictions on hours
of operation.
The city also has the smaller Juhu Aerodrome, which is limited to private
and general aviation.
C h h a t r a p a t i S h i v a j i I n t e r n a t i o n a l Ai r p o r t ( C S I A)
Table 1.6 and Figure 1.2 show the historical trends for the CSIA in terms
of the number of international and domestic commercial passengers
between 1980-81 and 2007-08.
Table 1.6
GAGR
Though the overall trend during those two decades was generally
positive, there was significant year to year variation, with
temporary declines in traffic during the economic recession of the
early 1990’s and in the period immediately following the terrorist
attacks of September 11, 2001.
This growth trend has been interrupted during the current year
(2008- 09); initially by spiking fuel prices last summer, followed by
the impact of the worldwide financial crises.
Fig 1.2
Annual Commercial Passengers, CSIA
30
25 Internat.
Domestic
Annual Pax (millions)
20 Total
15
10
0
1980-81
1981-82
1982-83
1983-84
1984-85
1985-86
1986-87
1987-88
1988-89
1989-90
1990-91
1991-92
1992-93
1993-94
1994-95
1995-96
1996-97
1997-98
1998-99
1999-00
2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
This boom period seems to have recently come to an end as the industry
was hit hard by high fuel costs this past summer and the current
worldwide financial crisis. Traffic figures for the first six months of the
2008-09 fiscal year indicate that while international passengers have
continue to increase by 6.2% compared to those same six months during
2007, domestic passengers actually declined by -8.0%.
Table 1.7
GAGR
The overall trends for CSIA have followed a similar pattern as those at the
national level; though with somewhat lower growth rates in recent years
(see Figure 1.3).
Much of this difference in growth rates has been taken place over the past
four or five years, during which already consolidated airports like CSIA,
Delhi and Chennai have naturally grown at a somewhat lower rate than
many of the traditionally secondary airports that began the current decade
with very low traffic levels.
Fig 1.3
Comparison of Annual Passenger Growth Rates, CSIA & National
40%
CSIA
Annual Growth Rates - Total Passengers
30% India
20%
10%
0%
-10%
1996-97
1997-98
1998-99
1999-00
2000-01
2001-02
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2008-09
-20%
Figure 1.4 presents the monthly breakdown of passengers for the past
five complete fiscal years; indicating that December and January have
consistently been the peak months for both international and domestic
traffic, with a secondary peaks in March and May.
Fig 1.4
Monthly Distribution of Total Passengers in Recent Years, CSIA
2,500
2,000
Passengers (thousands)
1,500
1,000
500
Nov.
June
Jan.
July
March
April
Aug.
Sept.
Oct
Dec.
Feb.
May
In the specific case of 2007-08, December was the peak month for total
passengers. The 2.35 million total passengers recorded that month
represent 9.2% of the annual total. The month of December was followed
closely by January and November with 9.2% and 9.1% of the annual total,
respectively. The month with the smallest number of passengers was
September with 1.9 million passengers; representing 7.6% of the annual
total.
Fig 1.5
Monthly Passengers During 2007-08, CSIA
2,500
Passengers (thousands)
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
Nov.
June
Jan.
July
March
April
August
Sept.
Dec.
Feb.
Oct
May
Table 1.8
Peak Months for Commercial Passengers, CSIA
1 . 5 . 1 A n n u a l Ai r c r a f t M o v e m e n t s
Table 1.9 and . Figure 1.6 present the trend for annual commercial
aircraft movements at CSIA over the past 25 years.
Table 1.9
GAGR
Fig 1.6
250,000
Internat.
200,000 Domestic
Total
Aircraft Movements
150,000
100,000
50,000
0
1980-81
1982-83
1984-85
1986-87
1988-89
1990-91
1992-93
1994-95
1996-97
1998-99
2000-01
2002-03
2004-05
2006-07
2008-09
Table 1.10 presents a breakdown of total aircraft movements for 2006-
07, including cargo and non-commercial aircraft. Scheduled passenger
aircraft movements accounted for 90.1% of total ATMs during that year,
with freighters accounting for another 3.5%.
Table 1.10
ATM %
Total 213,277
Military and business aviation operations have not experienced the same
rapid growth experienced by commercial passenger and cargo ATM,
remaining relatively stable in recent years; though with considerable year
to year variation (see Figure 1.7). It would also be important to add that
most General Aviation activity in Mumbai is concentrated at the Juhu
Aerodrome, which in recent years has handled from 20,000 to 25,000
aircraft movements per year, representing approximately 10% of the
ATM’s for the Mumbai system.
Fig 1.7
Annual Other Aircraft Movements, CSIA
12,000
Annual Aircraft Movements
10,000
8,000
Military
6,000
G.A
4,000
2,000
0
2005-06 2006-07 2007-08
1
Flights arriving to CSIA’s international terminals from other airports in India are included
as international, as they either originated in another country or will continue on overseas
after departing Mumbai.
An estimate was made for the current fleet mix for regular passenger
operations based on the January 2008 flight schedule for CSIA (Table
1.11 ). This is compared to the fleet mix at the airport for August 2004 so
as to identify any recent trends (See Table 1.12 , Figure 1.8 and
Figure 1.9 ). This fleet mix was organized according to the aircraft
categories established by the ICAO and distributed between the
international and domestic terminals.1
Table 1.11
Current Fleet Mix – Scheduled Weekly Arrivals, CSIA (January 2008)
Table 1.12
Fig 1.8
Distribution of Total Arriving Aircraft by ICAO Code
Code D Code E
Code D
7% 14%
15%
Code E
Code B
13%
1%
Code B
Code C
3%
(turbo)
Code C 5%
(turbo)
6%
Code C Code C
(jet) (jet)
63% 73%
Fig 1.9
Distribution of International and Domestic Arriving Aircraft by ICAO Code
Code E
Code D 39%
1%
Code B
5%
Code C Code C
(jet) (turbo)
9% Code C
85%
(jet)
17%
Code D
44%
Code E
Code D 54%
1%
Code B
1%
Code C
(jet) Code C
91% (turbo)
7%
Code C
(jet)
23%
Code D
23%
Also, Air Sahara (now Jet Lite) has replaced its regional jets with
Boeing 737-800 aircraft on most routes into Mumbai, reducing the
domestic share of Code B aircraft down to less than 1% of total
arrivals compared to 4.5% in 2004.
1 . 5 . 2 P e a k P e r i o d Ai r c r a f t M o v e m e n t s
As was the case with passengers, the peak month for scheduled
ATMs in 2006-07 was January. However, there is little monthly
variation and this peak month only represents 9.2% of the annual
total (See Figure 1.10).
The hour with the most scheduled total weekly movements per day
was at 21:00-21:59, followed closely by 6:00-6:59 and 10:00-
10:59. The busiest hour for total arrivals was 22:00-22:59, while it
was 6:00-6:69 for total departures.
Fig 1.10
Monthly Commercial ATMs During 2006-07, CSIA
25,000
Commercial Aircraft Movements
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
Nov.
June
Jan.
July
Aug
March
April
Sept.
Dec.
Feb.
Oct
May
Fig 1.11
300
Domestic
International
250
Weekly ATMs (arrivals + departures)
200
150
100
50
0
000
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
1100
1200
1300
1400
1500
1600
1700
1800
1900
2000
2100
2200
2300
Hour
Breaking down this data for each day of the week allows the following
conclusions:
The peak hour for total passenger traffic was 21:00-21:59 on
Wednesdays, with 40 scheduled ATM’s.
The peak hour for scheduled domestic movements was 33, which
occurred on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, Fridays and Sundays at
10:00-10:59.
Table 1.13 presents historical data on the air cargo and mail handled at CSIA
over the past 27 years. As was the case with passengers and aircraft
movements, air cargo has also experienced very rapid growth rates over the past
few years, increasing from 307,600 tonnes in 2002-03 to an estimate of over
533,000 tonnes in 2007-08.
Mail, on the other hand, has actually decreased somewhat after reaching a high
of 18,146 tonnes in 2002-03.
Table 1.13
In 2007-08, 70% of the cargo handled by the airport was international, with the
remaining 30% domestic (see Figure 1.12 ). Though exports make up most of
the international cargo, imports have been growing at a much higher rate as a
result of the growth of the domestic market. The primary imports are consumer
items, as well as electronic, computer and machine parts, all of which are
increasingly in demand. Figure 1.1.13 presents the breakdown of international
air cargo by commodity at CSIA.
Partial data for 2008-09 would indicate that total air freight has increased by only
1.4% over the first 10 months of the year, a significant decline compared to the
growth rates of previous years that reflects the ongoing economic crisis.
Fig 1.12
Breakdown of Total Air Cargo in 2007-08, CSIA
Domestic Imports
30% 32%
Exports
38%
Fig 1.13
Breakdown of International Air Cargo by Commodity, CSIA
(April 2007 to January 2008)
Exports Imports
Auto/
Other Machine
48% Parts
Leather Luggage
16%
Goods 2%
1% Electricals
2%
Hazardous
2% Electronics/
Computer
Chemicals
Pharmaceuti 10%
3%
cals Perishable
Automobile 19%
Textiles 3%
9% Other
18% Hazardous 64%
3%
With the above air traffic, Mumbai is experiencing congestion. The congestion of
traffic particularly becomes excessive during the peak hours. Thus the airport has
reached its saturation level. With the proposed expansion after modernisation,
the capacity of this airport would be 40 mppa capable of meeting the air traffic
demand upto 2013-14. Thus there is a need to develop the second airport at
Navi Mumbai for which the sanction of MOCA and GOM is already obtained. The
step now is to obtain environmental clearance, for which Environmental Impact
Assessment study is to be carried out.
The proposed site falls in Panvel Taluka of Raigad Dist. of Maharashtra State
located west of Panvel City in the Geographical centre of Navi Mumbai and MMR
with a longitude of 73°.04’.18” and latitude of 18°.59’.33”. The following Table
gives the Environmental setting along with the topographical features of study
area within the 10 kms. stretch from the Airport Reference Point (ARP).
Table1.14
4. General Elevation Coastal (RL 1.5 mts.), Plain (RL 3.0 mts)
Hills (RL 82 mts.)
11. Nearest Rly. Station. Panvel 1.5 kms. on Central Rly./Konkan Rly.
13. Nearest Water Bodies. Panvel creek, Gadhi river, Taloja river and
Ulwe river running along and through the
boundary of the airport.
Source: IIT
10. Examine the details of the land use break-up for the proposed
project.
11. Soil investigation along the runway alignment has to be carried out
as the runway is to be constructed in a mud flat.
12. Physical model studies should cover both with and without
proposed development.
1.11.2 Water
2. Diversion of rivers flowing through the area, the work will involve
training of river, hydrology, erosion, flooding and cost implications.
1.11.4 Energy
1.11.6 CRZ
5. Examine the details of impact of sea level rise on the project in the
next 100 years.
10. Extent of tidal creeks whether alteration to the tidal creek allowed
under CRZ Notification and management measures.
12. Examine the impact of reclamation of the mangroves and the low
lying areas on the territorial/aquatic flora and fauna, hydrology of
the area.
13. Examine and submit details of the erosion of soil / coastal line in
the last 50 years.
16. Examine and submit the details of all the cases related to
destruction of mangroves related High Court rulings and the
clarifications which may be required from the Hon’ble High Court
and what are the measures to be taken.
1.11.7 Noise
5. A thick green belt should be planned all around the project site to
mitigate noise and vibrations to the nearby settlements. The
identification of species/plants should be made based on the
botanical studies.
a) The Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) undertook the site visit on 23rd
December, 2009 and given the following additional Terms of Reference.
Detailed studies should be carried out to examine the findings as confirmed
through satellite imagery regarding the site as below;
i) To study whether the island has merged with the land area due to
sedimentation as compared to the position in 2003.
ii) Would closing of inlets lead to greater tidal ingression.
iii) To study the adverse impact of quarrying the stones from nearby hillocks
particularly effecting the settlements.
iv) In case of the construction of the airport, there would be a necessity to
divert this rain water, so that it does not cause flooding the habitations
adjacent to the proposed site of the airport. Would there be necessity to
divert the rainwater presently flowing from hillocks to the coast to avoid
flooding.
v) Is diversion of the rivulet and the existing river courses is likely to cause
greater inundation of the existing habitations.
b) Examine whether the two runways proposed may be reoriented and /or shifted by
redefining the boundaries of the proposed project site so that(a) alignment of the
two rivers are not disturbed or minimum damage to the rivers take place (b)
mangroves present at the site are either not disturbed or minimum disturbance to
them take place.
d) Is there any other area identified for the purpose of airport which conforms better
to environmental parameters within acceptable limits.
e) Give a detailed drainage network for the area which will drain away the rain water
efficiently without affecting the region.
f) How the proposed transport systems to serve the airport would be effective in
reducing travel time to the main city and help in reducing air pollution and noise
levels besides providing comfort, convenience and safety to users.
Based on the above TOR, prescribed by MOEF, the scope of work in brief, study
area, scoping and structure of the environmental impact study have been worked
out and same is narrated below:
Figure 1.14 shows the study area around airport falling within the radius of
10Kms. The study area is further extended upto 20 km. as fringe area. The core
area covers the area within the radius of 10km, in which all the scoped
environmental parameters will be studied to understand the magnitude of impact.
In the remaining area i.e. fringe area places of historical importance, aesthetic,
cultural including environmentally sensitive area will be studied.
Figure 1.14
Study Area
1.13 Scoping
Based on the approved TOR, Screening and Scoping was carried out to identify
key environmental parameters that are likely to be affected due to the project in
the study area. The parameters that are considered are:
Atmosphere
Meteorology
Visibility
Air quality
Intensity
Duration
Frequency
Land
Surface Water
Shoreline
Bottom interface
Flow variation /ocean currents
Water quality
Drainage pattern/water logging
Water balance
Flooding
Existing and planned future use
Siltation
Ground water
Water table
Flow regime
Water quality
Recharge rate
Aquifer characteristics
Existing use and proposed plans
Terrestrial
Aquatic/marine/estuarine communities including spawning,
breeding and nesting grounds
Migratory birds’ route
Benthic flora and fauna
Ecologically sensitive areas
Socio Economic
Agriculture land
Employment /training
Housing
Education
Utilities
Amenities ( Water, sanitation, electricity, transportation)
Community health
Aesthetic/ Cultural
Landscape
Wilderness
Climate
Tranquility/sense of community
Community structure
Religious places and structures
Historic/archaeological place or structure
Physical
psychological
occupational
parasitic disease
Water born disease & communicable diseases
Disease vectors
The scoping is carried out in identifying the valued ecosystem and magnitude of
impact due to the project activities
Geology
Hydrology
Coastal Zone
Land-use
Atmosphere
Change in ambient levels and ground level concentration due to total emission
from point, line and area sources and their effects. Changes in air quality due to
increased vehicular traffic and aircraft operation including visibility and
meteorology.
Water quality
Socioeconomics
The environmental impact assessment has been designed and planned keeping
in view of the above scoped valued ecosystem components. Descriptive checklist
methodology as well as matrix methodology is followed for prediction of impacts
except for air and noise where computer aided models are used.
The purpose of the report is to carry out environmental studies, identify areas of
positive and negative impacts and evolve environmental management plan as
per the guidelines of decision-making authorities for environmental clearance.
The structure of the report is as follows:
Volume-I
Executive Summary
Volume-II
Chapter 1: Introduction
Volume-III
Volume-IV
Volume-V
Chapter-2
2.1 Introduction
Fig. 2.1
2.3 Rewas-Mandwa
Fig. 2. 2
Fig. 2. 3
2.3.2 Accessibility
The site in question does not have adequate power, water and tele-
communication facilities and the same are required to be tapped from the
nearest sources available in Navi Mumbai and directly taken to Rewas-
Mandwa for the airport. The power supply can be tapped from the
nearest grid of MSEB at Uran and a separate EHT line from Uran to the
airport site is required to be laid which will call additional investment. A
separate water supply line of 30 Km. is required to be laid from the
available Hetwane project at Pedghar to proposed site of international
airport. The cost on this account will also be an additional cost.
Similarly, the telecommunication network facility needs to be created for
airport.
i) Land Acquisition
The land of about 1500 Ha. needs to be acquired from the 14 villages
only for the operational needs of the airport. In addition to this about 500
Ha. of land would also be required for the development of township.
Thus, there is a need to acquire at least 2000 Ha. of land for the project.
Most of the lands are either salt pans, mud flats involving fishing
activities, agriculture land as well as newly developed farmhouses,
holiday homes, recreational areas & beautiful coastal line with huge
green belt. The acquisition of land under the present circumstances
would be an insurmountable task.
ii) Rehabilitation
About 14 villages fall within the operational area of airport which are to be
shifted to suitable locations. The population of these villages is in the
range of 20,000 to 30,000. Rehabilitation of such a large population by
shifting from their original villages appears to be a difficult task
considering the stiff opposition from the local population.
iii) Reclamation
More than 50% of the airport area falls in the deep mud abutting the sea
and entire land is required to be developed to a safe level as the site is
fronting the main sea subjected to swells, waves and roughness of the
sea requiring a strong sea wall for the purpose of protection.
The region harbours over 350 species of plants (of which over 150
species are utilized by the indigenous communities as medicines), about
150 species of resident birds (about 40 species of migratory birds are
known to visit this region), and over 125 species of fish most of which are
of commercial importance, are observed in this region
The areas in and around Mandwa show scrub vegetation (73), though in
the foot hills of some of the disturbed hillocks, such as Vitsaral hill, a
considerably good amount of secondary forest exists,
Hills near the coast (such as Mandwa-Rahatle) show man made plant
diversity while some of the xerophytic Euphorbia tirucalli along with the
other economically important plants help enrich the plant diversity of the
hills.
This plant and fish diversity also justifies the fact that there is enormous
amount of faunal diversity (both micro and macro faunal elements) which
is directly dependent on habitats rich in plant as well as animal diversity.
Efforts have also taken by local villagers as well as the forest department
to introduce some of the naturally occurring species of coastal areas to
check the invasion of coastal tidal water on potential agricultural lands.
The site of Navi Mumbai airport is selected near Panvel town in an area
admeasuring 1615 Ha. of land which is situated about 45 km away from
the CBD of Mumbai. The airport is planned with two runways of 3700 M
with parallel taxiways designed to suit the new generation large aircraft.
The other facilities include the domestic terminal, international terminal,
cargo terminal, airfield lighting, city side facilities etc. The phasewise
development approach has been adopted to suit the air travel demand.
Fig. 2. 4
Map Showing Navi Mumbai Site On Toposheet
Fig. 2. 5
Map Showing Navi Mumbai Site On Imagery
Supporting Infrastructure
The Navi Mumbai site has certain site constraints as detailed below
which can be overcome easily by taking an appropriate action:-
i) Rehabilitation
A portion of Gadhi river and Ulwe river flowing through the airport
site need to be trained and diverted along the boundary of airport
zone to make available the land for development of airport. A
detailed exercise by conducting the mathematical and physical
model study by CWPRS, Pune has revealed that the same is
feasible without having any adverse impact.
iv) Reclamation:
More than 50% of the airport area falls in the shallow mud abutting
the creek and the entire land is required to be developed to a safe
level. The northern side of the airport will be abutting the Panvel
Creek which is calm and shelter area.
The swot analysis brings the strength, weakness, opportunity and threat
of both the sites. It is a qualitative analysis which considers the various
features including technical and financial.
Table 2.1
SWOT TABLE
Navi Mumbai Rewas Mandwa
A. STRENGTHS
Land available with CIDCO Allows unconstrained growth
Site accessible by all modes of Obstruction free approach path
transport Possess Hub potential
Availability of all basic supporting
infrastructure
Availability of townships to house
airport working population
Support from local population
Provide alternative air-field in MMR
Less Capital Cost.
(Financially viable project)
Attractive for development through
Public and Private Partnership
CIDCO, in a unique position will fast
track the project.
Seismic Zone III
B) WEAKNESSES
Acquisition of 457 Ha. of land. Acquisition of 2000 Ha. of land.
Relocation of existing EHT line of Tata Rehabilitation of 14 villages
and MSEB. (30,000 Population)
Diversion of Ulwe river and training of Absence of basic infrastructure.
Gadhi river. Absence of commuter rail link
Falls in CRZ area. High capital cost.
Rehabilitation of Ten Settlements Requires development of
(15000 Population) township for 50,000 families
Destruction to scenic coastal
beauty
Falls in CRZ area.
Falls in sensitive zone.
Airport closure during Naval
practice.
Stiff opposition from local
population.
Table 2.1
SWOT TABLE
Navi Mumbai Rewas Mandwa
Project financially un-viable.
Unattractive for development
through public-private
partnership.
Seismic Zone IV
C) OPPORTUNITIES
Will boost the development of Navi Opportunity to expand – meeting
Mumbai and main land the demand beyond the year
Create healthy competition between the 2030
two airports Boost the development of Konkan
Relieve congestion at existing airport area in MMR
Better image of Mumbai in aviation field Create healthy competition
Increase business on State and National between the two airports
Level Relieve congestion at existing
airport
Better image of Mumbai in
aviation field
Increase business on State and
National level
D) THREATS
Trans harbour link with high
speed airport road towards main
land costing about Rs 8000
crores is essential
Difficult to fund huge capital
The above SWOT analysis clearly reveals that the Navi Mumbai site has many
positive aspects, compared to Rewas-Mandwa site.
The site sensitivity analysis brings the site sensitiveness of both the sites
considering various environmental parameters scoped earlier. The site
scoring minimum marks is considered as best environmentally selected
site.
Delphi technique is used to work out the site sensitivity index for both the
alternatives.
The development of new airport reflects basically air & noise pollution
and if the project is nearer to marine environment, the related issues
have to be taken into account i.e. effect on marine environment, land
development, effect on coastline, drainage pattern. The other important
parameters associated with any development project are also important
in respect of land acquisition, displacement of population, effect on social
and cultural activities. In view of above, these factors are considered and
allocated more marks.
The following tables give the score for each attribute separately for
Rewas Mandwa and Navi Mumbai.
Table 2.2
Attribution
I Accessibility
15
40
135
Table 2.2
60
5000
(Nos) 30000
(Acres) 5000
10
nil
VIII Loss of Environmental General Internal Land Creek line Coast line 30
Aesthetics
(Crores) √
X Marine Environment
(Nos.) 350
(Nos.) 150
(Nos.) 125
Table 2.2
(Nos.) 30000
2.5
15
XVIII Capital Project Cost (crores) 0-5000 5000-10000 10000- 15000 and 60
15000 above
Total 1000
Table 2.3
Attribution
I Accessibility
0.5
0.5
60
15
1140
(Nos.) 15000
(Acres) 3500
12.5
Aesthetics
(Crores)
Table 2.3
X Marine Environment
(Nos.) 139
(Nos.) 59
(Nos.) 80
(Nos.) 15000
0.6
2.5
0.5
2.5
Table 2.3
Total 1000
The overall score have been worked out on the basis of site sensitivity index for
these parameters and integration of total impact is worked out & categorized as
below-
Categorisation Criteria
Overall scale Level of Environmental Impact
750-1000 Very high
600-750 High
450-600 Moderate
300-450 Low
Having allocated the score for each attribute, the following Table 2.4 compares the
attributes score between two sites.
Table 2.4
Accessibility
Table 2.4
Structures (Nos.)
Table 2.4
After comparison the scores were added. The Rewas-Mandwa score is 773.95
and Navi Mumbai is 498.69.
Thus the comparison of Rewas-Mandwa & Navi Mumbai is worked out as below:
2.6 Conclusion:
From the categorisation criteria, the Navi Mumbai site has moderate impact in
terms of environment score whereas Rewas-Mandwa site has very high impact.
This exercise establishes that Navi Mumbai site is less sensitive to environment.
Considering the SWOT and Sensitivity Analysis Navi Mumbai site is technically
and environmentally preferred site when compared to Rewas Mandwa.
Chapter-3
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
3.1.1 Location:
Fig 3.1
Fig 3.2
Navi Mumbai Airport Zone
3.1.4 Linkages
The city is well connected to Mumbai and other parts of the country
through a well-established road network, consisting of National Highways
Fig 3.3
NMIA – Transportation Network & Linkages
The airport site is presently accessible by existing four lane road called
National Highway-4B from the east side, State Highway-54 which runs on
the southern boundary of airport as well as four lane concrete road called
Aamra marg from the west side. The airport will be made accessible by
constructing interchanges on the NH4B as well as on Aamra marg for
smooth and speedy entry and exit from the airport. The existing Mankurd-
Belapur-Panvel Commuter Railway line passes on the northeast of airport
area and the nearest station is Khandeshwar located at a distance of less
than 1 km. The airport zone is also proposed to be connected to Belapur,
Khandeshwar, Mansarowar located on the above commuter railway line.
The other commuter line called Nerul-Uran railway line is under
construction and the nearest station to approach the airport is Targhar
located at a distance of 1.5 km. from the airport boundary. Panvel Rly.
Station on Central/Kokan Rly. Is located at a distance of 1.5 km. from the
airport site which will provide the rail accessibility at the Regional, State
and National level.
A total area of about 2054 Ha. is earmarked for the development of Navi
Mumbai International Airport consisting of airport zone and the area
required for off site infrastructure such as; diversion and training of rivers,
construction of approach roads, railways, interchanges and laying of utility
lines. The airport zone is about 1615 Ha. consisting of on-airport area of
about 1200 Ha. for aeronautical and off-airport area of about 415 Ha for
non-aeronautical activities related to the airport, accommodating the
physical, social, institutional, residential and commercial supporting
infrastructure. The balance area of about 439 Ha. is required for diversion
and training of rivers, construction of approach roads & railway,
interchanges and utility services.
The project activities envisaged in the airport zone and its surrounding for the
Navi Mumbai International Airport which will be taken for implementation are
described below:
In accordance with the “ In principle” approval obtained from the Union Govt., the
project is proposed to be executed on the basis of public-private-partnership
(PPP). Accordingly, a Special Purpose Company (SPC) will be incorporated as
private company, under the Companies Act, 1956 in which 26% equity will be
held by CIDCO/AAI and the rest with the strategic partner to be selected through
the public bidding process. The SPC will raise the required resources, design,
build, market, manage and operate, maintain the airport during the concession
period. The project will be transferred back to the Govt. on expiry of the
concession period.
Table 3.1
The methodology used to prepare the forecast for air cargo is similar to
that used to passengers. A statistical regression was carried out for each
primary traffic segment to identify correlations between historical cargo
trends and combinations of the socio-economic variables for the last 15
years. The independent variable of State NDP and National Export are
used for arriving at the international cargo and State NDP for domestic
cargo. Table 3.2 below present the summary of Air Cargo Demand for
the Mumbai Metropolitan Region for the period of 2014-2032.
Table 3.2
Table 3.3
NMIA Air Traffic Forecast
(In ‘ 000 Passengers)
Table 3.4
NMIA Air Cargo Traffic
(Tonnes per Annum)
Based on the above forecast for passenger and cargo, the phasing of
development of airport in terms of design year, design passenger and
cargo has been worked out for detailing the master plan of Navi Mumbai
International Airport. Table 3.5 below gives the details of above :
Table 3.5
Airport Development Phasing
Based on the traffic forecast described above, the air traffic summary
indicating the aircraft operation for passenger and cargo, domestic and
international terminal commercial passenger, peak aircraft movement,
hourly departure and arrival of domestic and international aircraft, peak
passenger demand for domestic and international have been worked out
for detailing the various components of airport. Table 3.6 shows the
summary of traffic forecast in various phases spread-over in the entire
development period.
Table 3.6
Figure 3.4 presents the long-term development plan of the Navi Mumbai
International Airport.
Fig 3.4
NMIA Airport Layout Plan – Long-Term Phase
The Navi Mumbai Airport is a very significant and integral part of the national and
regional infrastructure. The immediate and long-term planning horizons of the
new air terminal development, in conjunction with the airfield facilities, are to be
planned to serve the growth as forecasted and to meet the region’s needs for an
airport complex. The overall plan shall demonstrate a commitment to the
development of a new Greenfield Airport that will be maintained, sequentially
developed, managed, and operated to internationally recognized standards.
Therefore, the planning process will have to be based on the design and
development of high quality facilities that will provide the users with a high level
of service, positive working environment, a safe environment, advanced
technologies (check-in and passport control procedures, etc.), long life cycles,
and excellent performance.
The overall airport complex shall introduce travel facilities, which will provide a
new and refreshed gateway to the region and specifically to Mumbai and its
surrounding region. Not simply a way of moving people and goods quickly and
efficiently, the new Airport Plan shall be a symbol of national and regional
manifest, which demonstrates the nation's status, its economic health, and sense
of welcome in the quest for excellence and competitiveness in air transportation.
The facilities planned include passenger and cargo terminal buildings, runway
system, aprons, taxiways, airfield lighting system, air traffic control tower with
ATS Complex, gate/aircraft parking position, contact gate position, NAVAIDs,
utilities and infrastructure including roads, car parking, power supply system,
water supply system, storm water drainage system, underground sewerage
system , sewage treatment plant, etc.
3.5.1 Runways
In the ultimate horizon, the airfield will consist of two parallel runways with
083º east northeast – 263º west southwest orientations at both the South
and the North of the site and designated as 08R/26L and 08L/26R,
respectively, with a take-off available distance of 3,700 metres and 60
metres of runway width to accommodate the Super-Jumbo A380 aircraft.
The runway will include shoulders 7.5 metres wide at each side of the
runways. Beyond the runway ends, blast pads of 60 x 60 metres at both
ends of the runway will be provided with the objective of protecting from
blast erosion. The terrain around the runway will be set up and graded as
required by ICAO standards to provide the adequate runway strip with a
longitudinal slope not exceeding 1.3% and downward transverse slope not
exceeding 2.5%. At both ends of the runway strip a rectangular area of
240 m long x 60 m wide will be prepared for the runway end safety area.
Runway Exits
A dual parallel taxiway system will be provided at the West and East sides
of the airfield connecting the main parallel taxiways to each runway with
the following characteristics:
Each taxiway is 1,473 metres long and 25 metres wide plus paved
shoulders of 17.5 metres wide at each side of the taxiway.
Both runways will be equipped with both elevated and inset lights for at-
all-time operations consisting of a CAT I approach system before each
runway threshold which comprises a row of lights, along the extension of
the runway centreline, to a distance of 900 m.
Also, runway threshold lights and runway end lights will be installed. Blue
elevated taxiway edge lights will be installed at each runway exit and
taxiways.
The airport shall be equipped with a DVOR/DME intended for the purpose
of en-route navigation including non-precision approach. The Airport
Surveillance Radar (ASR) shall be established for terminal control area
extending to distance of 60 NM from the airport. A PAPI approach slope
indicator system of a 4-element wing bar placed on the left side of each
runway will be installed.
The main aircraft parking aprons associated to the northern and southern
piers will consist of an approximated paved area of 555,925 m2 and
571,625 m2, respectively, consisting of contact aircraft position, vehicular
service road, ground handling zone and push back truck area.
The apron taxiway system will consist of one apron taxilane with aircraft
stand taxilane for Code D aircraft along with a partial aircraft stand
taxilane at the remote apron.
Aircraft long term parking area will be provided at the East side of the
airport and south side of the Eastern access road. Aircraft long-term
parking covers an area of 179,140 m2 making a rectangle of 676 m x 265
m with the long side parallel to the airport access road, consisting of
Aircraft stands at both sides, a service road running behind the aircraft at
the inner part of the apron, and apron stand taxilane from the vehicle
service roads at both sides. The aircraft long-term parking area will allow
parking for up to 50 aircraft at the same time. Blue elevated edge lights
will be installed at both the taxiway connecting to the long-term parking
aprons and the entire shoulder of the long-term parking aprons.
Two cargo aprons, located at the west side of the commercial apron and
at both sides of the airport Western access road, will be connected each
one from the Northern or Southern commercial aprons by a taxiway of 25
m wide plus shoulders of 17.5 m wide.
A number of terminal concepts were studied and this, the “H” concept,
was selected. This concept consists of a central processing terminal with
two concourses on either side, running parallel to the runways. One
important reason for the selection of the “H” concept is that it
accommodates terminal access both from the east and the west of the
airport property. Another important reason for the selection is that this
concept works well for a single runway (Phase 1) as well as for double
runways (later Phases).
Fig 3.5
Terminal Area Plan
Table 3.7
Number Passengers per Development Phase
Medium-
Year / Phase Opening Short-Term Term Long-Term
Total Annual Passengers 10,628,833 24,630,358 47,325,286 60,300,000
Peak Hour Passengers 2,869 5,958 10,667 13,323
Terminal Area sq.mt 86068 1,78,748 3,19,995 3,99,677
Source: LBG Consultant
The air cargo complex is located on the west side of the site. To satisfy
the projected demand, the air cargo building will grow in each
development phase from an area of 32,994 m2 on the opening phase to
103,463 m2 in the long-term development phase. In addition of the air
cargo building, the air cargo complex will consist of an apron and taxiway
as detailed earlier and vehicular parking space for cars and tucks.
The primary airport access roads will provide access to the airport from
the neighbouring community road system. There will be two main primary
access roads to the airport, from western and eastern fronts having
configuration of dual carriage way of 5 lane each with pedestrian walkway,
service corridor and a service road on either side to serve the ancillary
facility such as; cargo, hangers, jet fuel farm, electrical, mechanical,
telecommunication facilities, etc. A corridor of 12 mt. has been reserved
from western side for accommodating the metro rail line.
The terminal area access roads will serve airport passengers, visitors, and
employees and connect primary airport access roads with terminal
buildings and parking facilities. In Phase 4, six lanes of terminal area
access roads will be required.
The inside lane, sized at 8 feet (2.4 m), provides terminal curb frontage
and the 12 foot (3.6 m) outside lanes serves through traffic and
manoeuvring to the terminal curb frontage.
Service roads will be divided into two user categories: general and
restricted. General-use service roads are used for the delivery of goods,
services, air cargo, flight kitchen supplies, and the like. There are two
service roads on either side of the primary access roads providing access
to the ancillary facilities. One lane undivided road having road widths of
3.5 m will be provided until the ultimate phase.
Trucks carrying cargo goods will park in the parking dedicated for trucks
by the cargo terminal building. A total area of 3,600 m2 with 60 cargo truck
parking spaces will be provided in Phase 4. The parking lot will be
accessed using a service road running parallel to the primary access road.
and car parking lots. The Storage supply facility of airport will involve following
considerations
Two ARFF stations are required to serve the dual runway system. The level of
protection provided at the airport will be in compliance with airport category 9, at
least, if the A380 does not exceed the criterion of 700 annual movements in the
busiest consecutive three months.
A paved emergency access road of 5 metres wide will be provided from the
locations of the ARFF facilities to both runways. A communication and alerting
system will be provided linking the ARFF station with the control tower and ARFF
vehicles.
The catering facility will be located within the airport service area near the long
term aircraft parking apron, including truck parking, kitchens, food preparation
areas, refrigerated storage, storage, break rooms, locker facilities with showers
and restrooms, offices, delivery areas, and automobile parking. The overall size
of the facility area will be 24,218 m2.
The GSE maintenance area will include garages, workshops, restrooms, break
areas, mess facilities, storage rooms, paint booths, waste disposal, offices and
employee parking. The facility is located at the East side of the airport between
the East access road and the Northern long-term aircraft parking apron. The
proposed GSE maintenance compound will have an overall size of 24,500 m2,
approximately.
The area required for aircraft maintenance, including apron, hangars and car
parking, is expected to be 181,500 m2. The aircraft maintenance facilities are
estimated to provide space for 6 hangars. Blue elevated edge lights will be
installed at both the taxiway connecting to the hangar apron and the entire
shoulder of the hangar apron.
The airfield maintenance area will be located at the East side of the airport
adjacent to the long-term parking apron and will comprise of diverse maintenance-
related facilities, such as buildings / offices, workshops, parking, garages and
staging areas for runway sweepers (summer service), landscaping equipment
(excavator, mower, etc.), transport equipment such as flatbed trucks, and airfield
electrical services for servicing medium voltage switchgears, airfield lighting
systems and communication network within the airport. The proposed
maintenance compound will have an overall size of 96,500 m2, approximately.
An area of about 1200 Ha. out of 1615 Ha. of airport zone is earmarked for
aeronautical development, which will house the various activities described
above. This area would accommodate the parallel independent runway for
simultaneous and independent operation with a provision of full length taxi way on
one side of the runway along with the activities such as; terminal building, cargo
building, support area, surface/garage parking, public/semi-public area, hangers,
etc. A broad land use of aeronautical area is indicated in Fig.3.6 as well as in
the following table:
Table 3.8
Fig 3.6
Landuse plan of Aeronautical areaof Total Area
The daily water requirement for the proposed airport zone is estimated @ 30
Lit./Passenger per day, 70 Lit. per employee per day, 45 Lit./Capita/day
commercial land use and 180 Lit./Capita/day for residential and other uses. The
water requirement for A C mark up as 10% and 1 MLD per day has been
considered for landscaping and irrigation. 0.2 million litres per day (tank
availability) has been kept for fire fighting. Based on this, the water requirement
for airport zone consisting of aeronautical and non-aeronautical area is
estimated taking into consideration all requirement of passengers, visitors, staff,
commercial facilities, air and land side facilities, residential, conference facilities,
as well as AC Plant, irrigation for planted area, fire-fighting, etc. The total
requirement of water supply for the airport as worked out is given in Table 3.9
Table 3.9
Phase-wise Water Requirements
The above mentioned Water requirement shall be met from the water supply
system of Navi Mumbai being maintained by City & Industrial Development
Corporation (CIDCO), Navi Mumbai Municipal Corporation (NMMC),
CIDCO has developed its own source at Hetawane which is presently supplying
100 MLD water and with the sanctioned capacity of 185 MLD. Similarly, CIDCO is
in the process of developing a water source from the Balganga Dam with a
installed capacity of 350 MLD with the sanctioned capacity of 250 MLD for Navi
Mumbai. NMMC has already developed its own water source known as Morbe
Dam which has installed capacity of 450 MLD and presently supplying 350 MLD to
the city. The following Table 3.10 gives the details of sources of Water,
availability of water, daily water consumption and surplus water:
Table 3.10
Demand & Supply of Water
(in MLD)
Year MIDC MJP Hetawane Morbe Balganga Total Daily Surplus
Consumpti
on
Source: CIDCO
The above table clearly indicates that the demand of water supply for the airport
zone would be fulfilled from surplus water available from its own source as
described in the above table.
The potential for rain water harvesting within the project area is limited in view of
the absence of primary porosity to store the ground water in the underlying rocks,
except the secondly porosity weathering fracture stores ground water to some
extent. The rising trend of ground water table observed during the pre and post
monsoon further reinforces the limitation of rain water harvesting. However,
efforts would be made to make the water harvesting from the rain water being
discharged from the roof of various structures within the airport.
Electric energy will be supplied via 2 independent feeders from the national grid
to two power stations, one located at the East side of the airport near the catering
site and the second one at the West side between the West access road and the
airfield maintenance area.
ii) A second circuit without full redundancy that supplies those airport users
that can tolerate occasional outage without strong adverse impact on
terminal operations such as e.g. electric drives, compressors for air
conditioning and water heaters.
The power supply requirement has been determined based on the consumption
of various elements of airport as well as the land use proposed in the non-
aeronautical area of the airport zone and the same was checked with the ongoing
consumption at Delhi, Mumbai and Hyderabad airports. Accordingly, the power
requirement for the airport zone is given in Table 3.11 below:
Table 3.11
The above mentioned power requirement will be met from the Energy Distribution
Company of Govt. of Maharashtra from the nearest sub-station of 400/220/33 KV
sub-station located at Kharghar. A new sub-station for stepping down of power
to 132 KV and 33 KV shall be set-up in non-aeronautical area by the Distribution
Co. from where the power will be supplied to the airport. The following Table
3.12 gives the details of power supply stations, its capacity, load, consumption,
existing and planned for Navi Mumbai township.
Table 3.12
The demand and supply position planned for the Navi Mumbai township indicates
that the power requirement for the airport zone would be fulfilled from the surplus
available in the planned installed capacity.
Initially, the emergency power station shall consist of 5 X 500 KVA capable of
supplying power to the initial phase and subsequently augmentation of the same
will be carried out in accordance with the requirement of demand. All DG sets will
be synchronized through micro-processor based on PLC system with built-in
protection for electrical system and capable of restoring the power within 15 sec.
of disruption of power for air site consumer and maximum 60 sec. for other non-
critical areas.
• Roof, walls & fenestration products shall comply either the maximum U -
• Variable Frequency Drives (VFD) will be proposed for the HVAC chillers,
The spillages, sludge and 100% waste water discharged from the various airport
facilities shall be treated by installation of a sewerage treatment plant in an area
of 2 Ha. located near the diverted channel in the south-east corner of the airport
using SBR technology for installed capacity of 15 MLD. Similar treatment plant
will also be located for the non-aeronautical area of airport zone having 30 MLD
installed capacity in an area of 3 Ha. Thus, the airport zone will have two
sewerage treatment plants for treating the waste generated from the airport as
well as off-airport area.
Treated waste water so discharged from the sewerage plant would be utilized to
the extent possible for gardening, flushing and washing purpose. It is estimated
that 10% treated water would be made use for the above.
Solid Waste in the form of bio-degradable waste and non bio-degradable waste
generated from the various activities within the airport and outside in the non-
aeronautical area need to be treated and disposal at least away from the airport
by a distance of 10 kms. The solid waste generated from the airport zone has
been estimated, initially about 10 tones daily and it will go ultimately to 40 tones.
The bio-degradable waste will be treated at the treatment plant by the land fills
method, whereas the non-biodegradable waste in the form of incinerators will be
either installed or made use of existing municipal facility.
A solid waste treatment plant at Chal, Taloja (Map given in Fig 3.7) has been
installed by the Corporation, which is located more than 12 kms. away from the
airport boundary. The total area of about 15 Ha. has been earmarked consisting
of 7 Ha area of land fills having 7 land fills cells with an ultimate capacity of
treating a solid waste of 3,65,000 MT., with a compost capacity of 65 M.T. daily.
The method of treatment adopted for solid waste is of Aerobic composting by
windrow method. Since the solid waste treatment plant is located in north-east
corner of airport at a long distance away from the normal flight path of airport, the
question of bird hazard due to solid waste does not arise.
Fig. 3.7
An area of about 415 Ha. in airport zone has been earmarked for development of
airport related activities to facilitate the development, operation and functioning of
Navi Mumbai International Airport. The development of this area will be carried
out in close relation with the airport development. This area would mainly
accommodate airport related activities such as hotels, guest houses, transit
lodges, warehousing, bank, offices, housing, shopping, convention & exhibition
centre, leisure and entertainment, waterfront development, parking, garages,
inter-state bus terminal, etc. The broad land use of this area has been envisaged
as given in the following Table 3.13:
Table 3.13
Land Use Statement for Non-aeronautical Area
6. Entertainment 20.75 5%
The airport and airport related activities are expected to generate the employment
to the tune of above 90000 within the airport zone. The housing needs of this
employment would be partly met in this zone and partly in the various developing
towns of Navi Mumbai such as; Ulwe, Dronagiri, Kharghar, Kamothe, Panvel, etc.
The above area will be well integrated with airport as well as surrounding
townships of Navi Mumbai by means of connectivity i.e. road, rail, etc., as well as
other physical and social infrastructure.
Based upon the facilities shown on the airport layout plan on-airport site and the
various activities on off-airport site and the phasing of the airport development, the
block cost estimates of the aeronautical activities and non-aeronautical activities
have been worked out based on the current rates. The cost estimate is based
upon the airport zone layout plan developed without the detail site survey, soil
investigation or preliminary engineering analysis of any element. The cost so
worked out does not include the following items:
The basic cost estimate of Navi Mumbai International Airport is worked out and
same is shown under various head in following Table 3.14 up-dated to 2006-07
with escalation of 5% per annum.
Table 3.14
d) Off-site infrastructure
cost. 300.00 - - -
Project implementation programme not only helps in financial planning but also
helps us in identifying the various activities which are required to be carried out
for success of the project. The implementation programme is based on demand
and capacity analysis based on which the various facilities are required to be
created on air and landside. Accordingly, the following programme has been
devised to identify the various activities which will lead to the opening of airport
facilities keeping the target date of 2013-14.
The year 2009-10 has been kept for obtaining Environmental Clearance for
Airport project from Ministry of Environment and Forests, (MOEF), Govt of India.
Thereafter, process of Selection of Strategic Partner would commence and
selection of developer would be completed by August 2010. Actual construction
work would start in October 2010 and first phase of work will be completed by
September 2013. Another three months would be required to testing and
commissioning the various equipments and airport would be ready for operation
in December , 2013.
The implementation programme will continue for second phase in the year 2013-
17, third phase in 2017-21 and fourth phase in 2022–26. The Chart below shows
the various activities to be performed during planning, design and construction
phases.
There will be batching/ready mix plant within the airport. Major construction
activities will be land development and concreting for which bulk raw material is
available with the airport area. The following Table 3.15 gives quantities (approx)
of various materials required for the horizontal development:
Table 3.15
Quantities of Basic Materials (Approx.)
Material Approx. Quantity
In addition to above, these materials are also required for terminal building, cargo
buildings, and other ancillary buildings. Other materials required for construction
of buildings such as structural steel, aluminium frame works, glazing and other
finishing material are available in Mumbai/Navi Mumbai.
During the construction stage of the proposed facilities a large number of local
and migrating, (comprising of both skilled and unskilled) workers approx. average
500/day initially and peaking to the level of 3000/day will be involved. For the
migrating workers temporary hutments with adequate drinking water, proper
sanitation facilities along with provision of fuel (kerosene or fuel) will be provided.
As far as the safety and health of the construction workers is concerned, workers
will be provided with helmets, ear mufflers and other safety gadgets. First aid
arrangement with ambulance facility will be provided along with a Medical
Examination (ME) room to attend the accidental cases and cases with minor
injuries. Proper hygiene and sanitation will be maintained in and around the
worker’s colony to avoid spread of any epidemic. Provision will be made to have
regular health check-up of the workers with proper treatment facilities to prevent
spread of common endemic air and water borne diseases. Adequate clearance
and treatment of domestic waste and sewage will be done as per IS 2470.