Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
AGING 9
ETHICS 19
EPISTEMOLOGY 21
Work in Progress
THE GENERALIZED SUCKER PROBLEM 22
1.
2.
You know you have influence when people start noticing your
absence more than the presence of others.
3.
4.
They will envy you for your success, for your wealth, for your
intelligence, for your looks, for your status --but rarely for your
wisdom
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 2
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
5. 10.
Most of what they call humility is successfully disguised You will get the most attention from those who hate you. No
arrogance. friend, no admirer, and no partner will flatter you with equal
curiosity.
6.
11.
12.
The mark of a mediocre mind is the subdued and passive
reaction in front of the truly exceptional.
Social media are antisocial, health foods are empirically
unhealthy, knowledge workers are ignorant, & social sciences aren't
8.
scientific.
The strangest thing about this love business is that the more
9.
intensely enthralled two being are with each other the harder they
will try to hurt each other later on.
I wonder whether a bitter enemy would be jealous if he They seem to care about the smallest wound now in the other
discovered that I hated someone else. but they will be inflicting the most scathing one later. Love is not for
philosophers.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 3
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
14. 18.
The characteristic feature of the loser is to bemoan, in general The most depressing aspect of the lives of the couples you watch
terms, mankind's flaws, biases, contradictions & irrationality -- surreptitiously arguing in restaurants is that they are almost always
without exploiting them for fun and profit. unaware of the true subject of argument.
19.
15.
17.
The most painful moments are not those we spend with
uninteresting people; it is those spent with uninteresting people
When someone starts a sentence with "simply", you should trying hard to be interesting.
expect to hear something very complicated.
22.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 4
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
23. 28.
The opposite of enemy is a dull life. The tragedy of virtue is that the more boring, unoriginal, and
sermonizing the proverb/tweet, the harder it is to implement.
24.
29.
Hatred is much harder to fake than love. You hear of fake love;
never of fake hate. It is the appearance of inconsistency, and not its absence, that
makes people attractive.
25.
30.
To value a person, consider the difference between how
impressive he (she) was at the first encounter and the most recent
one. This, I suspect, was the reason they put Socrates to death.
There is something terribly unattractive about thinking with too
much clarity. Nobody wants to his reasoning to become perfectly
26.
transparent --not to others, not to himself.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 5
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
33. 38.
For company, you tend to prefer those who find you interesting Half of what we call arrogant is arrogant; the other half is
over those you find interesting. conviction and beliefs.
34. 39.
Unrequited hate is vastly more diminishing for the self than When a woman says about a man that he is intelligent, she
unrequited love. You can't react by demonizing. means handsome; when a man says about a woman that she is dumb,
he means attractive.
35.
36.
37.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 6
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
40.
Success, Insuccess, Happiness, and
Stoicism
It is only by accident that what ordinary people say they will do
corresponds to what they will actually do.
41.
42.
43.
You are rich if, and only if, money you refuse tastes better than
money you accept.
44.
Success is when you switch from the camp of the hating to the
camp of the hated.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 7
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
49.
46. Ordinary men regret their words more than their silence; finer
men regret their silence more than their words.
A good foe is far more loyal, far more predictable, and, to the
47. clever, far more useful than any admirer
Money earned speculating against the crowd and the common 53.
man does not feel as sordid and vulgar as money coming from other
forms of commerce, and not as lowly as money coming from
employment. It is as if it came entirely from the purest philosophical You can tell how uninteresting a person is by asking him who he
insights. finds interesting.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 8
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
54. Aging
Most people are made for insuccess; they lose their charm and
become unbearable when they succeed.
55.
59.
If existence were about happiness, more would accept to be
"happy imbeciles".
Decline starts with the replacement of dreams with memories,
reverses with the replacement of dreams with other dreams, and
57. ends with the replacement of memories with other memories.
61.
Pomponius Atticus, severely ill, tried, the Stoic way, to take his
own life. Having chosen starvation, he was cured of his illness.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 9
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
I read nothing from the past 300 years; I drink nothing from the
past 4000 years (just wine and water); but I talk to no ordinary man
over 40. A man without a heroic bent starts dying at the age of 30.
65.
63.
64.
Most people write so they can remember things; I write to
forget.
Some pursuits are much duller from the inside than outside;
even piracy can be terribly uninteresting. Unless you are good at
detecting dullness you will be trapped for life. 67.
68.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 10
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
69. 74.
Writers are remembered for their best work, politicians for their The imagination of the genius vastly surpasses his intellect; the
worst mistakes; and businessmen are almost never remembered. intellect of the academic vastly surpasses his imagination
70. 75.
Charm lies in the unsaid, the unwritten, and the undisplayed. It A maxim allows me to have the last word without even starting a
takes mastery to control silence. conversation.
71. 76.
No author should be considered as having failed until he starts A good maxim should 1) surprise you, 2) be true (counter-
teaching others about writing. intuitively true), and 3) be either symmetric (one assertion, one
negation) or rhythmic.
72.
77.
73. 78.
An aphorism is the poetry of ideas. Giving business readers my book is like giving vintage Bordeaux
to drinkers of Diet Coke and listening to their comments about it.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 11
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
79.
81.
I aim to never answer critics, just plan to stay in print as long as
possible --insure that I will be on the shelves long after these critics
"Business books": a category invented by bookstores for writings are dead.
that have no depth, no style, no empirical rigor, and no linguistic
sophistication.
86.
82.
I can predict when someone is about to plagiarize me, and
poorly so, when they claim that Taleb "popularized" the theory of
I wish to say some day about someone "Voilà un homme!" as Black Swan events.
Napoleon said upon meeting Goethe: a mixture of passion, intellect,
and elegance.
87.
83.
Journalism is what disappears a day after it is printed;
electronic journalism is what dies even before it is posted; literature
Just like poets and artists, bureaucrats are born, not made; it aims to never go out of print.
takes normal humans extraordinary effort to keep attention on such
boring tasks.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 12
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
88.
The Universal and the Particular
You are as alive as the ratio of clichés in your writing.
89.
92.
Businessmen hire people to write books for them; I discovered
that they also hire people to read books for them (with abstracts)
There is nothing deemed harmful (in general) that cannot be
beneficial in some particular instances, and nothing deemed
beneficial that cannot harm you in some circumstances. Universals
are weaker under complexity.
93.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 13
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
98.
Fooled by Randomness
The sucker's trap is when you focus on what you know and what
others don't know, rather than the reverse.
99.
94.
95.
The role of the media is best seen in the journey from Cato the
elder to Sarah Palin. Do some extrapolation if you want to be scared.
Corollary to Moore's laws: every ten years, collective wisdom
degrades by half.
101.
96.
Using, as excuse, others' failure of common sense is in itself a
failure of common sense.
The tragedy of the information age is that the toxicity of data
increases much faster than its benefits.
102.
Before checking the news today, check how much the 400-700
97.
hours of nongossip media exposure in 2007 helped you make sense
of 2008, etc.
The fool views himself more unique, and others more generic;
the wise views himself more generic and others more unique
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 14
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
103.
(Re)Becoming Free
Mental clarity is the child of courage, not the other way around.
Comment: The biggest error since Socrates has been to believe
that lack of clarity is the source of all our ills, not the result of them.
105.
104.
107.
108.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 15
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
109. 114.
You have a real life if & only if you do not compete with anyone There is no intermediate state between ice and water but there
in any of your pursuits. one is between life and death: employment.
110. 115.
You will be civilized on the day when you can spend a long Only in recent history has "working hard" signaled pride rather
period doing nothing, learning nothing, and improving nothing, than shame for lack of talent, finesse and, mostly, sprezzatura.
without feeling the slightest amount of guilt.
116.
111.
Their idea of the sabbatical is to work six days and rest for one;
I never see the world with more clarity than when I misplace my my idea of the sabbatical is to work for (part of) a day and rest for six.
eyeglasses.
117.
112.
What they call play (gym, travel, sports) look like work; what I
You have a real life when most of what you fear has the call work (effortless daydreaming) looks like play. They lose freedom
titillating prospect of adventure. trying harder; the harder they try, the more captive they become.
118.
113.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 16
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
119. 124.
Technology's double punishment is to make us both age Competitive athletes are closer to animals than men; though
prematurely and live longer. never as fast as a cheetah or as strong as an ox.
120.
121.
122.
123.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 17
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
129.
Aesthetics
Wit seduces by signaling intelligence without nerdiness.
130.
125.
In classical renderings of prominent figures, males are lean &
females are plump; in modern photographs, the opposite.
The genius of Mandelbrot lies in showing that we can achieve
aesthetic clarity without the cost of smoothness.
126.
127.
128.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 18
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
135.
Ethics
Ethical man accords his profession to his beliefs, instead of
according his beliefs to his profession. Rarer and rarer since middle
ages.
131. 136.
You can only convince those persons who think they can benefit I trust everyone except those who tell me they are trustworthy.
from being convinced.
137.
132.
138.
133.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 19
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
139. 144.
I wonder if crooks can conceive that honest people can be The difference between magnificence & arrogance is in what one
shrewder than them. does when nobody is looking.
140.
Pure generosity is when you help the ingrate. Every other form
is self-serving ,
[Kantian ethics]
141.
142.
143.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 20
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
148.
Epistemology
Substractive epistemology: the sucker thinks Truth is search for
knowledge; the nonsucker knows Truth is search for ignorance.
149.
145. 150.
My problem of knowledge is that there are many more books on Happiness; we don't know what it means, nor how to reach it;
birds written by ornithologists than books on birds written by birds but we know extremely well how to avoid unhappiness.
and books on ornithologists written by birds.
151.
146.
152.
147.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 21
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
153.
154.
Education makes the wise slightly wiser; but it makes the fool
vastly more dangerous.
155.
156.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 22
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
157. 162.
There are two types of people; those who try to win and those Mathematics is to knowledge what an artificial hand is to the
who try to win arguments. They are never the same. real one. Some frauds, like Robert C. Merton, amputate to replace.
158. 163.
You are guaranteed a repetition when you hear the declaration Mediocre men tend to be outraged by small insults, but passive,
"never again". subdued, and silent in front of very large ones
160.
It is easier to disguise ignorance than knowledge.
161.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 23
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
169.
Robustness and Fragility
The best test of robustness to reputational damage is your
emotional state (fear, joy, boredom) when you get an email from a
journalist.
165. 170.
You are only secure if you can lose your fortune without the One should first pick a destination for which one has a good
additional worse insult of having to become humble. map, instead of travel first then use “the best” map, "because there is
(My great-great-great-grandfather's rule). nothing else".
166.
They have a hard time accepting my idea that the only robust
society is the imbecile proof society. I call it more politely
epistemocracy.
167.
168.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 24
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
175.
The Ludic Fallacy and Its Extensions
Compliance with the straightjacket of narrow (Aristotelian) logic
and avoidance of fatal inconsistencies are not the same thing.
176.
171.
177.
172.
174.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 25
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
182.
The Sacred and the Profane
I now take a hot bath after reading emails from businessmen or
journalists; I then feel purified from the profane until the next email.
183.
178.
179.
184.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 26
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
185.
Dealing with the Future
The economy, in brief: they are calmly waiting in line to be
slaughtered while thinking it is for a Broadway show.
186.
187.
You can replace lies with truth; but myth is only displaced with a
narrative. For the ancients, forecasting historical events was an insult to
the God(s); for me it is an insult to man --that is, for some, to science.
188.
189.
190.
For Seneca, the Stoic sage should withdraw from public efforts
when unheeded and the state is corrupt beyond repair. It is wiser to
wait for self-destruction.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 27
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
191.
192.
193.
194.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 28
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
195.
Politics, Economics, and Other Very
Conscious ignorance, if you can practice it, expands your world; Vulgar Subjects
it can make things infinite.
196.
199.
197.
200.
I threatened to walk out of a lecture hall under Seneca's dictum
that philosophers should avoid speaking like mountebanks.
The 20th C was the bankruptcy of the social utopia. The 21st will
be that of the technological one.
198.
From one Procrustean bed to another: efforts at building
social, political, and medical utopias have caused nightmares;
Academia is as close to sophistry today as the sophists were in many cures and techniques came from martial efforts.
Socrates' day; in fact ironically the academy was there to counter
sophistry. 2400 years and we've learned nothing.
201.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 29
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
206.
202. The worst damage has been caused by competent people trying
to do good; the best welfare has been brought by incompetent ones
trying to harm.
Economics cannot digest the idea that the collective (and the
aggregate) are disproportionately less predictable than individuals.
207.
205. The differences between Goldman Sachs and the mafia are as
follows: GS has a better legal-regulatory expertise; but the mafia
understands public opinion.
An individual has a conscience, feels shame and honor. The
collective (that is, institutions) does not aggregate them -despicable
bureaucrats. 210.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 30
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
211. 215.
"It is much easier to scam people for billions than for just CNBC journalists are imbeciles. "You need skills to get a BMW,
millions". (Some thoughts on the Madoff story). skills and monstrous luck to become a Warren Buffet" was turned
into "Taleb says Buffet has no skills". Imbeciles.
212.
216.
213. 217.
Dubai borrowed to put vanity buildings on postcards; America The curious mind embraces science; the gifted & sensitive, the
and Western Europe need to borrow to just survive. arts; the practical, business; the leftover becomes an economist.
218.
214.
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 31
POETIC & PHILOSOPHICAL APHORISMS
5/17/10 © Copyright 2009 by N. N. Taleb. This draft version cannot be disseminated or quoted. 32