Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
REPORT
ON
COMPARE THE STANDING TATA MOTORS
vis-á-vis THE INDUSTRY
&
CUSTOMER
SATISFACTION
SURVEY
:- SUBMITTED TO
SUBMITTED
BY: -
DECLARATION
Signature :
Date :
Place : Jalandhar
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
In order to make my project I acknowledge a special thanks to all those people without
whose supports it would not be possible for me to complete for me to complete my report.
I would also thankful to the Satluj Motors (TATA MOTORS Dealership) for giving me
this opportunity to work on project in Mandi (H.P) . I convey my heart full thanks to the
Mr. Bhopal Singh Jamwal (Admin. Manager) and the staff members of Satluj Motors, with
their help and corporation.
Also I would like to express my inner feeling for all the people for co-operating and
helping me throughout the project.
Last but not the least I am thankful to my parents and friends who have provided me with
their constant support throughout this project.
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
PREFACE
The professional training is the internal part of a M.B.A program. It helps the student
understand practical aspects of Business Management in a better way as a part of my M.B.A.
program at Lovely Professional University, Jalandhar . I was supposed to work the
organization.
And I also conducted Customer Satisfaction Survey of TATA Motors in the Mandi
District of Himachal Pradesh. I used research questionnaires as the research and data collection
tools. The responses were collected from 100 respondents from various areas of Mandi.
I had learned lot during my project on compare the standing TATA Motors vis-á-vis the
industr y & customer satisfaction survey of TATA Motors; I hope this will be helpful to find out
financial standing of TATA Motors in automobile industry and satisfaction of consumer in Mandi
city.
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
INDEX
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
S.No. PARTICULAR Page No.
1. Declaration (i)
2.
Acknowled
gement
(ii)
3. Preface (iii)
4. Executive Summary 7
5. Introduction 10
6. Literature Review: 14
6.1 Tata Motors July Sales At 48,054 Nos. 15
6.2 First Quarter Stand-Alone Net Revenue
Rs.6405 Crores, Pat Grows 58% To Rs.514
Crores 16
6.3 Delivers First Tata Nano In The Country In
Mumbai 17
6.4 June 2009 Domestic Sales At 43,244 Nos 18
6.5 First Jaguar Land Rover Showroom Opens In
India 19
6.6 Tata Motors To Introduce Air Car 20
6.7 Consolidated Revenue In 2008-09 Rs. 70938.85
Crores, Loss After Tax Rs. 2505.25 Crores 21
6.8 Effect Of Inflation On Car
Market 24
7. Profile Of Tata Group: 27
7.1 TATA Group Companies 32
8. Profile Of Tata Motors Limited: 35
8.1 Industry Overview 37
8.2 History Of Tata Motors 39
8.3 Important Developments 39
8.4 Global Operations 48
8.5 Future Challenges 51
8.6 Milestones 52
8.7 Awards 57
9. Products Of Tata Motors: 58
9.1 Passenger cars and utility vehicles 58
9.2 Concept vehicles 59
9.3 Commercial vehicles 60
10. Marketing Strategies: 62
10.1 Launch Of Tata Nano 62
10.2 Modification In Tata Sumo 69
10.3 New Version Of Indigo ,Indigo Dicor 71
10.4 Tapping Of Rural Markets 72
11. SWOT Analysis - Tata Motors Limited 73
12. Financial Analysis: 76
12.1 Financial Overview 77
12.2 Capital Structure 78
12.3 Weighted Average Cost Of Capital 79
ARUN GULERIA
12.4 Balance Analysis 81
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100 12.5 Financial Analysis Of Tata Motors 84
13. Global Automobile Industry 87
14. Indian Automotive Players: Overview Of The Players In the Indian
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
COMPARE THE STANDING TATA MOTORS vis-á-vis THE The project on
INDUSTRY & CUSTOMER SATISFACTION SURVEY based on financial
perfor mance and on customer survey. The main objectives of the project are:
For this project Financial Statements was analysis and customer research was carried out at
various area of Mandi District of Himachal Pradesh. I learnt analysis financial statement in to
find different aspects for compare the standing vis-á-vis industry and customer ’s perception
about TATA Motors.
2. Company Profile:
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
This section gives the information about the company. It includes the company history
which depicts the company from the period of foundation. This section also products of
the company producing by the company.
3. Analysis of Financial:
Financial statements of the company over last few years are analysis in this section and
financial perfor mance is output.
4. Competitors of company:
The company’s competitors are finding and study the business during the financial years.
FINDINGS:
A detailed analysis of the company shows that the company has had a strong fundamental
as well as a strong market performance over the years. Given the economic and the industry
environment (improving outlook for the CV industry) TATA Motors would be a key beneficiary.
While a pick-up in its CV volumes is evident, operating leverage and cost saving initiatives will
improve margins.
On an average more than 73% people feel that the prices are affordable whereas 12% do
not agree, 74% believe that attractive discounts are offered whereas 26% are not satisfied with
the discounts offered. 20% said that the test drives are not offered and 15% said that post sales
follow ups are not done regularly whereas 85% said that they were done regularly but people feel
that it is the people’s car as it is satisfactor y on all other parameters: knowledgeable sales persons
, employees spent enough time before and during sales, display of merchandise is attractive,
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
availability of product, variety of mer chandize, vehicle in good condition, prices are affordable,
attractive discounts are offered, décor of the waiting area is pleasing, responds to complaints
quickly, service at TATA Motors service station is excellent, careful with personal information
and is value for money . The overall opinion about TATA Motors is very good.
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
INTRODUCTION
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
India is an emerging country with huge potential. The domestic economy is now growing
at around 9-10% per annum and India’s importance in global terms is being reinforced by
rapidly rising exports and domestic consumption. At a time when numbers of a slowdown and
overheating in the Indian economy have started gaining momentum, the Indian rupee sprang a
surprise by pushing the GDP figure past the trillion-dollar (42,00,000 crore) mark.
The automotive industr y is at the center of India’s new global dynamic. The domestic
market expanding rapidly as incomes rise and consumer credit becomes more widely available.
Manufacturer ’s product lines are being continually expanded, as is the local automotive
manufacturing base. Expectation are high that India can develop as a global hub for vehicle
manufacturers and as an outsourcing center that offers the global automotive industry solution
.
high up the automotive value chain
The automobile industry in India accounts for a business volume of $45 billion and has
the potential to grow much faster both through Indian as well as international manufacturers who
have established huge facilities in the country
With the world’s second largest and fastest-growing population, there is no denying India’s
potential in both economic and population terms and the effect it will have on the auto industry
in the years to come. The country is already off to a good start, with a well-developed
components industry and a production level of 1 million four-wheeled vehicles a year, plus a
further 5 million two- and three-wheelers.
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
The implications, market drivers and scope of a future massive Indian vehicle market
are covered in the India Strategic Market Profile, a brand-new forecast of Indian automotive and
related activity to 2020. Based on Max Pemberton's unique relational long-term forecasting
model, it forecasts car and CV sales, demographics, materials usage, auto industr y employment,
and explains their inter- year of healthy growth in auto industr y.
INDUSTRY GROWTH:
Future of the
Automobile in the Economy:
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
US based consultancy, keystone predicts that India will become world’s third largest
automobile market by 2030. Overall size expected to exceed 20 million with compounded
annual growth rate of over 12%.
1983
• Number of brands 2
• Number of models 2
2008
• Number of brands 30
• Number of models 70
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
LITERATURE
REVIEW
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
Released on: 3rd August, 2009
Tata Motors July sales at 48,054 nos., growth of 18%
M&HCV sales record year-on-year growth after almost a year
- Ashish Garg
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
Released on: 27th July, 2009
Tata Motors First Quarter Stand-alone net revenue Rs.6405 Crores,
PAT grows 58% to Rs.514 crores
- R. S. Sardha
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
in the industr y.
In passenger vehicles, the company has
The company continues to upgrade its completed the process of allotment of Tata
resources to leverage emerging Nanos, following the car ’s launch in March
opportunities. In commercial vehicles, the 2009. Deliveries to the allottees have since
company unveiled its new range of world begun. The company also opened the first
standard trucks in May 2009, comprising Jaguar Land Rover showroom in India at
multi- axle trucks, tractor-trailers, tippers, Mumbai. Along with the Fiat Linea, Fiat 500
mixers and special purpose vehicles which and the Palio, the company has commenced
are being gradually launched in India and the distribution of the Fiat Grande Punto in
also in select international markets over a June 2009.
period of time. An all-new Starbus range of
buses has also been introduced. A new The audited stand-alone financial results for
mileage enhancing automatic stop-start the quarter ended June 30, 2009, are
technology, developed in-house, has been enclosed. The consolidated financial results
introduced in the Ace mini truck. Tata for the 1st quarter of Financial Year would
Motors has received a majority of the orders be voluntarily disclosed separately in due
for buses released by different State course.
Governments under the JNNURM.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
Released on: 1st July, 2009
TATA Motors’s June 2009 DOMESTIC SALES at 43,244 nos.
- G. Lata Sure
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
The cumulative sales from exports for the fiscal at 5,220 nos. declined by 43% over
9,159 nos. in the same period last year.
Jaguar Land Rover has confirmed Tata Motors as its exclusive importer and the world-class
Ceejay House facility in Worli, Mumbai, will offer a wide range of both Jaguar and Land Rover
vehicles, with a dedicated showroom section for each brand. It aims to
establish a benchmark
experience in luxury car sales in India, with plans to
develop the dealer network throughout 2009 and 2010.
Mr. David Smith, CEO of Jaguar Land Rover, said: "Jaguar Land Rover is delighted to have
officially opened our first showroom in India. It is an exciting time to be entering the Indian
market, a country with increasing affluence and an economy which is still growing. We believe
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
that the Indian market holds significant growth potential in the long term, and we hope to tap the
demand for premium vehicles from discerning customers."
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
exhaust pipe is between 0-15 degrees below internal air conditioning system with no
zero, which makes it suitable for use by the need for gases or loss of power.
Telcon:
The company has launched several new
products, but was impacted by the credit
squeeze in the third quarter of the year. It
expects demand revival supported by
infrastructure spend in the country.
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
Released on: 29th May, 2009
Tata Motors Net Revenue in 2008-09 lower at Rs.25660.79 crores,
and Net Profit lower at Rs.1001.26 crores, due to market upheaval
T Ace and the Tata Magic, have continued to
ata Motors today reported gross revenue
improve penetration.
(stand- alone) of Rs.28599.27 crores (2007-
08: Rs.33093.93 crores) in 2008-09, a year Stimulus packages from the Government in
marked by severe demand contraction in the the last quarter of the year have to an extent
automobile industry. helped regenerate overall sales, as in the
automobile industry, but growth is yet to
Revenues (net of excise) for the year were revive to earlier levels.
Rs. 25660.79 crores compared to
Rs.28739.41 crores in 2007-08, a decline of The fall in volumes combined with peak
10.7%. The Profit before Tax was input prices and high interest rates brought
Rs.1013.76 crores compared to Rs.2576.47 margins under pressure. The company
crores in 2007-08, a decline of 60.7%. The accelerated cost reduction measures and
Profit after Tax for the year was Rs.1001.26 proactively managed working capital to
crores compared to Rs.2028.92 crores, a contain the impact as best as it could.
decline of 50.7%. The total 2008-09 sales volume (including
exports) is 506,421 units, compared to
The demand contraction was triggered by 585,649 units in the previous year. The
high interest rates and unavailability of company retained its domestic leadership
finance throughout the year; particularly in position in commercial vehicles, and
the October-December quarter post the continued to be amongst the top three in
global financial market upheavals. The passenger vehicles. Domestic commercial
impact on heavy commercial vehicles was vehicles sales amounted to 265,373 units
more severe, abetted by reduction in freight (2007-08: 312,935 units). The company
movement in different segments and increased market share in commercial
customer concerns on economic conditions. vehicles to 63.8% (2007-08: 62.2%), aided
Small commercial vehicles, like the Tata by its wide product offering. Domestic
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
passenger vehicles sales amounted to 2008, and the launch of the Tata Nano on
207,512 units (2007-08: 218,055 units).The March 23, 2009. Over 2.03 lakh fully paid
launch of the second generation Tata Indica bookings were received for the Tata Nano,
Vista and the continuing good run of the the deliveries of which will begin from July
Tata Indigo CS has helped recover market 2009. The Pantnagar plant began producing
share in passenger vehicles in the second the Tata Nano during the year, while the
half which stands at 13.1% for the year Sanand plant is rapidly progressing towards
(2007-08: 14%) and a March exit share of completion.
14.5%. Tata Motors’ exports were 33,536
numbers (2007-08: 54,659 numbers), DIVIDEND
impacted by the worldwide downturn in the The Board of Directors has recommended a
industr y. dividend of Rs.6/- per Ordinary share and
Rs.6.50 per ‘A’ Ordinary share of Rs.10/-
The launch of the Tata Indica Vista was each for the financial year 2008-09 (2007-
augmented by the distribution of the Fiat 08: Rs.15/- for Ordinary share). The
500 and Linea, both of which have been dividend is subject to approval of
received well. In commercial vehicles too, shareholders; tax on the dividend will be
new products, introduced during the year or borne by the Company.
the previous year, offering benefits like
higher fuel efficiency, grew at a faster rate The Audited Financial Results for the
and helped enhance market share. financial year ended March 31, 2009, are
The landmark events of the year were the enclosed.
acquisition of Jaguar Land Rover on June 2,
__________________________________________________________
EFFECT OF INFLATION ON CAR MARKET
- Hindustan Times
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
The effect of inflation has affected not only
the production and sales of Indian cars but
also has significantly affected the car dealer,
officials and car financers. Research and
observations have led to the conclusion that
in the year 2008, the car market and the car
industr y is expected to witness 8-9% fall.
ARUN GULERIA
arun_guleria@ymail.com
100
THEORETICAL RELEVANCE OF TATA MOTORS’S LONG TERM FINANCIAL BEHAVIOR
- Financial Institute
“As per the Trade off theory, the marginal cost and benefit of debt in determining the best financial
structure of a company is considered, at most considerate liability percentage, a companies market
value is brought up and the companies whose liability percentage diverge from the best possible can
increase their price by bringing their liability percentage towards the target”. (European Journal of
Economics)
“The pecking order theory is based on the idea of asymmetric information between managers and
investors. A company increases its debits by issuing new equities to finance new projects because if
not done the same way then and new investors are brought into consideration then the new Investors
will make most of the profit which is ”the net present value (NPV)” of that particular project which
will cause lose to the present share holders. To avoid this most of the firms tend to finance their new
projects using a security that is not undervalued in the market, which can be internal funds or some
other less dangerous debt securities. Therefore, this is what affects the choice between internal and
external financing. (European Journal of Economics).
“The M&M theor y is a theory of capital structure which explains that a company’s market price
is definite by its earning power and by the basic risk of its resources, the three most important
ways of funding, they are issuing shares, borrowing and retaining profits
“As opposed to dispersing them to shareholders in dividends” (Modigliani-Miller Theorem -
M&M)
This theory also says that if there are no taxes, bankruptcy costs, and asymmetric information, in
an efficient market then a company’s value becomes solid for finance by its sources. It makes no
difference how the company’s funds are increased either by issuing stock or by selling debt and
neither matters the dividend policy of the company”. (Modigliani-Miller Theorem - M&M)
Therefore, According to the above composed data the Tata motors raised funds from NYSE in
2004, and then from Bombay stock Exchange, Private Equity Funds, Sale of Stakes, Inter-Group
Sales and Bridge loans, so, this is in accordance to “the pecking order theory which says that a
company increases its debits by issuing new equities to finance new projects because if not done
the same way then and new investors are brought into consideration then the new Investors will
make most of the profit which is ”the net present value (NPV)” of that particular project which
will cause lose to the present share holders. To keep away from this situation most of the firms
tend to finance their new projects using a security that is not undervalued in the market, which
can be internal funds or some other less dangerous debt securities. Therefore, this is what affects
the choice between internal and external financing”.
Hence, the pecking order theory explains the need of the firms to rely on the internal sources of
the company for finances and also explains why the companies prefer debt to equity if external
financing is required.
COMPANY
PROFILE
TATA GROUP
Tata is a rapidly growing business group based in India with significant international
operations. Revenues in 2007-08 are estimated at $62.5 billion (around Rs251,543 crore), of
which 61 per cent is from business outside India. The Group employs around 350,000 people
worldwide. The Tata name has been respected in India for 140 years for its adherence to strong
values and business ethics.
The business operations of the Tata Group currently encompass seven business sectors:
communications and information technology, engineering, materials, services, energy, consumer
products and chemicals. The Group’s 27 publicly listed enterprises have a combined market
capitalization of some $60 billion, among the highest among Indian business houses, and a
shareholder base of 3.2 million. The major companies in the Group include Tata Steel, Tata
Motors, Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), Tata Power, Tata Chemicals, Tata Tea, Indian Hotels
and Tata Communications.
The Group’s major companies are beginning to be counted globally. Tata Steel became
the sixth largest steel maker in the world after it acquired Corus. Tata Motors is among the top
five commercial vehicle manufacturers in the world and has recently acquired Jaguar and Land
Rover. TCS is a leading global software company, with delivery centres in the US, UK, Hungar y,
Brazil, Uruguay and China, besides India. Tata Tea is the second largest branded tea company in
the world, through its UK-based subsidiary Tetley. Tata Chemicals is the world’s second largest
manufacturer of soda ash. Tata Communications is one of the world’s largest wholesale voice
carriers.
In tandem with the incr easing international footprint of its companies, the Group is also
gaining international recognition. Brand Finance, a UK-based consultancy firm, recently valued
the Tata brand at $11.4 billion and ranked it 57th amongst the Top 100 brands in the world.
Businessweek ranked the Group sixth amongst the World’s Most Innovative Companies. And the
Reputation Institute, USA, recently rated it as the World’s Sixth Most Reputed Firm.
Founded by Jamsetji Tata in 1868, the Tata Group’s early years were inspired by the spirit
of nationalism. The Group pioneered several industries of national importance in India: steel,
power, hospitality and airlines. In more recent times, the Tata Group’s pioneering spirit has been
showcased by companies like Tata Consultancy Services, India’s first software company, which
pioneered the international delivery model, and Tata Motors, which made India’s first
indigenously developed car, the Indica, in 1998 and recently unveiled the world’s lowest-cost
car, the Tata Nano, for commercial launch by end of 2008.
The Tata Group has always believed in returning wealth to the society it serves.
Twothirds of the equity of Tata Sons, the Tata Group.s promoter company, is held by
philanthropic trusts which have created national institutions in science and technology, medical
research, social studies and the performing arts. The trusts also provide aid and assistance to
NGOs in the areas of education, healthcare and livelihoods. Tata companies also extend social
welfare activities to communities around their industrial units. The combined development-
related expenditure of the Trusts and the companies amounts to around 4 per cent of the Group’s
net profits.
Going forward, the Group is focusing on new technologies and innovation to drive its
business in India and internationally. The Nano car is one example, as is the Eka supercomputer
(developed by another Tata company), which in 2008 is ranked the world’s fourth fastest. The
Group aims to build a series of world class, world scale businesses in select sectors. Anchored in
India and wedded to its traditional values and strong ethics, the Group is building a multinational
business which will achieve growth through excellence and innovation, while balancing the
interests of its shareholders, its employees and wider society.
CORE VALUES OF TATA
At the Tata Group our purpose is to improve the quality of life of the communities we
serve. We do this through leadership in sectors of national economic significance, to which the
Group brings a unique set of capabilities.
This heritage is being continuously enriched by the formalization of the high standards of
behavior expected from employees and companies. The Tata name is a unique asset representing
leadership with trust. Leveraging this asset to enhance Group synergy and becoming globally
competitive is the route to sustained growth and long-term success.
Integrity: We must conduct our business fairly, with honesty and transparency. Everything
we do must stand the test of public scrutiny.
Understanding: We must be caring, show respect, compassion and humanity for our
colleagues and customers around the world, and always work for
. the benefit of the communities we serve
Excellence: We must constantly strive to achieve the highest possible standards in our day-to-
day work and in the quality of the goods and services we provide.
Unity: We must work cohesively with our colleagues across the Group
and with our
customers and partners around the world, building strong relationships
based on tolerance, understanding and mutual cooperation.
• Tata Motors:
Subsidiaries /Associates/ Joint Ventures: Concorde Motors, HV Axels, HV
Transmissions, Nita Company, TAL Manufacturing Solutions, Tata Cummins, Tata
Daewoo Commercial Vehicles Company, Tata Engineering Services, Tata Precision
Industries, Tata Technologies, Telco construction Equipment.
• Engineering Services
Tata Projects, TCE Consulting Engineers, Voltas
• Engineering Products
TAL Manufacturing Solutions, Telco Construction Equipment Company, TRF
METALS:
• TATA STEEL
Subsidiaries /Associates/ Joint Ventures: Hooghly Met Coke and Power Company,
Jamshedpur Injection Powder (Jamipol), Jamshedpur Utility and Service Company
Limited (JUSCO), Lanka Special Steel, Mjunction Serves, NatSteel, Sila Eastern
Company, Tata Blue Scope Steel, Tata Metallic, Tata Pigments, Tata Refractories, Tata
Ryerson, Tata Sponge Iron, Tata steel (Thailand), Tata Steel KZN, Tayo Rolls, The
Dhamra Port Company, The Indian Steel and Wire Products, The Tinplate Company of
India, Tm International Logistics, TRF.
ENERGY:
• POWER
• Tata BP Solar India
• Tata Power
Subsidiaries /Associates/ Joint Ventures: Tata Ceramics, Tata Power Trading, North
Delhi Power Limited
CHEMICALS:
• Rallis India
• Tata Pigments
• Tata Pigments
• PHARMA
• Advinus Therapeutics
SERIVES:
• HOTELS AND REALTY
• Indian Hotels (Taj Group)
Subsidiaries /Associates/ Joint Ventures: Taj Air, Roots Corporation (Ginger Hotels)
• THDC
• Tata Realty and Infrastructure
• FINANCIAL SERVICES
• Tata AIG General Insurance, Tata AIG Life Insurance, Tata Asset Management, Tata
Capital, Tata Financial Services, Tata Investment Corporation
• OTHER SERVICES
• Tata Quality Management Services, Tata Services, Tata Strategic Management
Group
CONSUMER PRODUCTS:
• Infiniti Retail
• Tata Tea
Subsidiaries /Associates/ Joint Ventures: Tata Coffee, Tata Tetley, Tata Tea Inc
• Tata Ceramics
• Tata McGraw Hill Publishing Company
• Titan Industries
• Trent
COMMUNICATIONS
• Tata Sky
• Tata Teleservices
Subsidiaries /Associates/ Joint Ventures: Tata Teleservices (Maharashtra)
• Tata Communication
• Tata Net
INDUSTRIAL AUTOMATION
• Nelco
Subsidiaries /Associates/ Joint Ventures: Tatanet
TATA MOTORS LIMITED
The largest passenger automobile and commercial vehicle manufacturing company of
India Tata Motors Limited, was formerly called TELCO (TATA Engineering and Locomotive
Company), has its headquarters in Bombay, now Mumbai, India. Established in 1945, listed on
the New York Stock Exchange in 2004 has created Rs. 320 billion wealth and was one of the top
10 wealth creators in India, With manufacturing facilities in the towns of Jamshedpur, Lucknow,
and Pune. This company was founded by Jamshetji Tata and is run by Ratan Tata under the
flagship company known as Tata and sons group. He commands 22000 employees working in
three plants as well as other regional and zonal offices across the length and breadth of India.
Tata motor’s passenger cars still need to reach acceptable international requirements. The
company commands an imposing 65% share of the domestic commercial vehicle market and is
tr ying to modernize this segment. The financial business of Tata motors was separated into a
subsidiar y company in sep. 2006, where it recorded a strong financial performance during the
last 5 year period. From year 2003-2007, the profits of the company went up at a CAGR of
36.4%, to attain Rs. 331, 525 million in 2007 from Rs. 95, 731 Million in 2003. B y floating two
rights issues at the end of Sep 2008 Tata Motors Ltd expected to raise Rs 4, 150 crores. They are
offering one ordinary share valued at Rs. 340 every six shares expecting to net Rs. 2.90 Crores,
the so called “A” share would have different voting and dividend rights, for every such 6 shares
held at a face value of 305 would raise Rs. 1.960 Crores, these proceed would be utilized for an
early repayment of the short term funding of 2.3 Billion $ (Rs. 10,189 Crores) Borrowed for
Acquisition of jaguar and Land Rover from their principle “The Ford Motor Company’s”.
It is also in talks with private equity funds to offload 25% of stake in each of the
following 6 unlisted group units, they are Tata Daewoo commercial vehicle company, HV
transmissions, Tata motors finance, Tata technologies and TELCO construction equipment, the
sales of the stakes would possible conclude by June 2009, helping it to raise further funds for this
acquisition, earlier in July it sold 24% stake in an Auto component unit to a group firm and
booked a profit of Rs. 110 crores, it also sold 10 million shares or 1.36% of Tata steel for RS.
486 crores to Tata Sons, the holding company of whole Tata group firms.
"The Company aims to monetize a part of its funds through a phased divestment of
certain investments preferably as inter-group sales wherever possible at current market prices in
the coming six to eight months," the money that will be released from these investments will
become a part of the capital to be lifted for repayment of the bridging loan taken for the Jaguar-
Land Rover acquisition. Taken in March 2008" (Tata Motors Profile)
Since the rights issue was announced on 28 may its share value has fallen more than 30% and th
fell by 1.82% to Rs. 429.85 on BSE, even though the bench mark index gained 3.8% to end at
15, 049.86 points.
If the company will follow the above mentioned trends then possibly it can raise its finances in a
low liquidity and high interest rate set-up.
INDUSTRY OUTLOOK
The Indian Automobile Industry enjoys the advantage of low cost base, high skilled
labour, strong ancillary network coupled with Government’s support by way of concessional
excise duty of 16% for small cars, ban on overloading and also significant investments proposed
for removing infrastructure bottlenecks. The CV industry is directly related to the economic
growth and development. The growth in demand for CVs is directly related to the IIP index and
any upsurge in economic activities will call for more cargo movement in the economy.
The domestic CV market grew at a CAGR of 26.7% during the last 6 years. In FY07, the
CV segment registered a growth of 32.2% due to Supreme Court’s ban on over loading trucks.
However, we believe that this is a one-time demand and the CV segment may not witness such
kind of growth repeatedly. There is a regulation that restricts the movement of vehicles above
certain age (15 years in National Capital Region and 8 years in Mumbai). Though the rule is not
being followed strictly at present, in future if this rule is implemented strictly it will result in
huge replacement demand.
With the Indian economy expected to grow at 8.5% to 9% in coming years, we expect the
demand for CVs to be fairly decent except for the fact that the industry is currently experiencing
a correction due to sharp spurt in demand in the previous years.
The CV industry witnessed a change in demand dynamics in last few years. The demand
for LCVs in the <=3.5 tonnes segment is rising at the cost of demand in 5 to 7.5 tonnes category,
while demand in 7.5 to 12 tonnes segment and 16.2 to 25 tonnes segment is booming at the cost
of demand in 12 to 16.2 tonnes segment. Demand for trailers of >35.2 tonnes is witnessing a
surge while demand for semi-trailers in 26.4 to 35.2 tonnes segment is suffering. This structural
shift in demand dynamics is due to the evolution of Hub & Spoke model of distribution, which is
now adopted by transportation players because of improved road infrastructure and also the ban
on trucks in many cities by the authorities to tackle the traffic congestion issues. According to the
Hub & Spoke model, HCVs plying over the highways to transport goods to different states and
districts, while MCVs are used in distributing goods to different cities and the last leg of
distribution in intra city is done by using <=3.5 tonner vehicles.
History
History of TATA Motors
1.
Tata Motors is a part of the Tata and Sons Group, founded by Jamshedji Nussarwanji Tata and J.
Baker. The company was established in 1945 as a locomotive manufacturing unit and later
expanded its operations to commercial vehicle sector in 1954 after forming a joint venture with
Daimler-Benz AG of Ger many.
2. TATA Indica
3. TATA Brads
DAEWOO ACQUISITION
To expand the product portfolio Tata Motors recently introduced the 25MT GVW Tata
Novus from Daewoo’s (South Korea) (TDCV) platform. Tata plans to leverage on the
strong presence of TDCV in the heavy-tonnage range and introduce products in India at
an appropriate time. This was mainly to cater to the international market and also to cater
to the domestic market where a major improvement in the Road infrastructure was done
through the National Highway Development Project
Tata remains India's largest heavy commercial vehicle manufacturer and Tata Daewoo is
the 2nd largest heavy commercial vehicle manufacturer in South Korea. Tata Motors has
jointly worked with Tata Daewoo to develop trucks such as Novus and World Truck and
buses namely, GloBus and StarBus.
HISPANO CARROCERA
Hispano
Divo at
the 2008
FIAA in
Madrid
In 2005, sensing the huge opportunity in the fully built bus segment, Tata Motors became
acquired 21% stake in Hispano Carrocera SA, Aragonese bus manufacturing company giving it
controlling rights of the company.
JAGUAR CARS AND LAND ROVER
After the acquisition of British Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) business, which also includes the
Rover , Daimler and Lanchester brand names Tata Motors became a major player in the
international automobile market.
On 27 March 2008, Tata Motors reached an agreement with Ford to purchase their Jaguar and
Land Rover operations for US$ 2 billion. The sale was completed on 2 June 2008 Tata has gained
the rights to the Daimler , Lanchester , and Rover brand names.
In addition to the brands, Tata Motors has also gained access to 2 design centers and 3 plants in
UK. The key acquisition would be of the intellectual property rights related to the technologies.
JOINT VENTURES
Tata MarcoPolo released this low-floor bus in India and now it is widely used as public transport
• In 2005, sensing the huge opportunity in the fully built bus segment, Tata Motors
acquired 21% stake in Hispano Carrocera SA, Aragonese bus manufacturing company
and introduced its highend inter-city buses in the country.
• Tata Motors has also formed a 51:49 joint venture with Marcopolo S.A., a Brazil-based
global leader, lead by Brian Behrle, in bus body building. This joint venture is to
manufacture and assemble fully-built buses and coaches targeted at developing mass
rapid transportation systems.
• The joint venture will absorb technology and expertise in chassis and aggregates from
Tata Motors, and Marcopolo will provide know-how in processes and systems for
bodybuilding and bus body design.
IMPORTANT
DEVELOPMENTS
In 2005 & 06
In 2007
In 2007, Tata Motors launched several concept models and future designs of existing
models. It also formed joint ventures with various local companies in several countries to
assemble Tata cars. Tata Motors launched a re-designed version of Tata Xenon TL during Motor
Show Bologna which would be assembled in Thailand and Argentina. A pick-up variant of Tata
Sumo was also launched under the program 'Global Pick-Up'. The company plans to launch the
new pick- up model in India, Southeast Asia, Europe, South Africa, Turkey and Saudi Arabia.
Tata Motors also unveiled newer model of Tata Indigo and Tata Elegante concept-car during the
Geneva Auto Show.
Tata Motors also formed a joint venture with Fiat and gained access to Fiat’s diesel
engine technology. Tata Motors is looking to extend its relationship with Fiat and Iveco to other
segments like the 'Global Pick-Up' program. The launch of the 'Global Pick-Up' will mark the
entry of the company into developed markets like Europe and the United States. The project was
initially collaboration between Tata Motors and its subsidiary Tata Daewoo Commercial
Vehicles, but later Tata Motors decided to work with Iveco as Daewoo’s design was not in sync
with the needs of sophisticated European customers. The company has formed a joint venture
with Thailand’s Thonburi Company, an independent auto assembler, in which Tata Motors will
hold a 70% stake.
In 2008
COMPRESSED AIR CAR
Tata OneCAT
Motor Development International of Luxembourg has developed the world's first prototype of a
compressed air car , named OneCAT. In 2007, MDI owner Guy Negre was reported to have "the backing
of Tata".
It has air tanks that can be filled in 4 hours by plugging the car into a standard electrical
plug. In 2008 MDI planned to also design a gas station compressor, which would fill the tanks in
3 minutes. There are no gasoline costs and no fossil fuel emissions from the vehicle when run in
town, but "the compressed air driving the pistons can be boosted by a fuel burner".
OneCAT is a five seat vehicle with a 200-litre (7.1 cu ft) trunk. With full tanks it will run
at 100 km/h (62 mph) for 90 kilometers (56 mi) range in urban cycle. It is actually a dual fuel car
but it is more efficient than any present Hybrid cars.
Tata Motors' UK subsidiary, Tata Motors European Technical Centre , has bought a 50.3%
holding in electric vehicle technology firm Miljøbil Grenland/ Innovasjon of Norway for
US$1.93 M, which specialises in the development of innovative solutions for electric vehicles,
and plans to launch the electric Indica hatchback in Europe next year.
GLOBAL OPERATIONS
Tata Motors has been aggressively acquiring foreign brands to increase its global
presence. Tata Motors has operations in the UK, South Korea, Thailand and Spain. Among them
is Jaguar Land Rover, a business comprising the two iconic British brands that was acquired in
2008. Tata Motors has also acquired from Ford the rights to three other brand names: Daimler ,
Lanchester and Rover . In 2004, it acquired the Daewoo Commercial Vehicles Company, South
Korea’s second largest truck maker. The rechr istened Tata Daewoo Commercial Vehicles
Company has launched several new products in the Korean market, while also exporting these
products to several international markets. Today two-thirds of heavy commercial vehicle exports
out of South Korea are from Tata Daewoo.
In 2005, Tata Motors acquired a 21% stake in Hispano Carrocera, a reputed Spanish bus
and coach manufacturer, giving it controlling rights of the company. Hispano’s presence is being
expanded in other markets. On Tata's journey to make an international foot print, it continued its
expansion through the introduction of new products into the market range of buses (Starbus &
Globus) as well as trucks (Novus). These models were jointly developed with its subsidiaries
Tata Daewoo and Hispano Carrocera. In May, 2009 Tata unveiled the Tata World Truck range
jointly developed with Tata Daewoo. They will debut in South Korea, South Africa, the SAARC
countries and the Middle-East by the end of 2009. In 2006, it formed a joint venture with the
Brazil-based Marcopolo, a global leader in body-building for buses and coaches to manufacture
fully-built buses and coaches for India and select international markets. Tata Motors has
expanded its production and assembly operations to several other countries including South
Korea, Thailand, South Africa and Argentina and is planning to set up plants in Turkey ,
Indonesia and Eastern Europe . Tata also franchisee/joint venture assembly operations in Kenya,
Bangladesh, Ukraine, Russia and Senegal. Tata has dealerships in 26 countries across 4
continents. Though Tata is present in many counties it has only managed to create a large
consumer base in the Indian Subcontinent namely India, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Sri Lanka and
Nepal and has a growing consumer base in Italy, Spain and South Africa.
The Government of India announced an automobile policy in December 1997. The policy
required majority-owned subsidiaries of foreign car fir ms to invest at least US$50 million in
equity if they wished to set up manufacturing projects in India. It also forced them to take on
export obligations to fund their auto part imports and required them to submit to a schedule for
increasing the share of locally made parts in their cars. Mere car assembling operations were not
welcomed.
An Indian cabinet panel will soon consider a new automobile policy that aims to set fresh
investment guidelines for foreign firms wishing to manufacture vehicles in the country.
Investments in making auto parts by a foreign vehicle maker will also be considered a part of the
minimum foreign investment made by it in an auto-making subsidiar y in India. The move is
aimed at helping India emerge as a hub for global manufacturing and sourcing for auto parts. The
policy sets an export target of $1 billion by 2005 and US$2.7 billion by 2010.
Tata Prima
The Luxury Sedan was designed by Pininfrina and has marked the entry of Tata into the
international sedan market. The car is to be sold in India by 2013 and around the world by 2015
Tata Motors has expanded its production and assembly operations to several other countries
including South Korea, Thailand, South Africa and Argentina and is planning to set up plants in
Turkey, Indonesia and Eastern Europe.
FUTURE CHALLENGES
Mahindra and Mahindra: JV with ITEC, North American leader in heavy trucks. •
M&M has formed a 51:49 JV called Mahindra International with ITEC, USA (parent
Navistar International), to manufacture commercial vehicles and to bolster its position in
the CV business. ITEC is the leader in medium and heavy trucks and buses in North
America, and is the world's largest manufacturer of medium-duty diesel engines.
Mahindra International aims to have a presence across the CV market (6-35 tonnes
GVW) with variants of passenger transport, cargo and specialised load applications and is
likely to start producing medium/heavy commercial vehicles from FY09.
Force Motors Ltd: JV with MAN for manufacturing high-tonnage vehicles Force •
Motors has paired up with MAN in a 70:30 JV to manufacture high-tonnage and specialty
vehicles, such as long-haul trucks, tippers, tractor trailers and multi-axle vehicles in the
16-32 tonne range at its Pithampur plant, with an initial capacity of 24,000 units per
annum and at an investment of Rs7bn. The JV plans to sell nearly half of its production in
the domestic market, while the rest is to be exported to the Middle East, Turkey, Russia,
Asia and Africa. Further, the two companies have formed another JV to manufacture
buses in India from end-2007.
Suzuki : Suzuki through its subsidiary, Maruti Suzuki in the Indian market may also be •
alarming. Maruti has aggressively launched family cars to undermine the Tata models.
MILESTONES
1945 Tata Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. was established to manufacture •
locomotives and other engineering products.
1948 Steam road roller introduced in collaboration with Marshall Sons (UK). •
1954 Collaboration with Daimler Benz AG, West Germany, for manufacture of •
medium commercial vehicles. The first vehicle rolled out within 6 months of the
contract.
1959 Research and Development Centre set up at Jamshedpur. •
1986 Production of first light commercial vehicle, Tata 407, indigenously designed, •
followed by Tata 608.
1991 Launch of the 1st indigenous passenger car Tata Sierra . •
One millionth vehicle rolled out. •
1994 Launch of Tata Sumo - the multi utility vehicle. •
2004 Tata Motors and Daewoo Commercial Vehicle Co. Ltd. sign investment •
agreement and completes acquisition of Daewoo Commercial Vehicle Company
Tata Daewoo Commercial Vehicle Co. Ltd. (TDCV) launches the heavy duty •
truck 'NOVUS' , in Korea
Sumo Victa launched •
Indigo Marina launched •
Tata Motors lists on the NYSE •
2005 Tata Motors rolls out the 500,000th Passenger Car from its Car Plant Facility in •
Pune
The Tata Xover unveiled at the 75th Geneva Motor Show •
Branded buses and coaches - Starbus and Globus - launched •
Tata Ace , India's first mini truck launched •
The power packed Safari Dicor is launched •
Tata Motors launches Indica V2 Turbo Diesel . •
One millionth passenger car produced and sold •
Inauguration of new factory at Jamshedpur for Novus •
Launch of Tata Novus •
Launch of Novus range of medium trucks in Korea, by Tata Daewoo Commercial •
Mr. N. A. Soonawala
Dr. J.J. Irani
Mr. V.R. Mehta
Mr. Nusli N Wadia
Mr. S. M Palia
Dr. R. A. Mashelkar
Mr. Ravi Kant
Mr. P. M. Telang
Senior Management
Mr. Ravi Kant : Executive Director
Mr. P. M Telang : Executive Director
Mr. Rajive Dube : President (Passenger Cars)
Mr. C Ramkrishnan : Chief Financial Officer
Mr. P.Y. Gurv : Vice President (Corporate Finance- Accounts and Taxation)
Dr. S. J. Tambe : Vice President (Human Resource)
Mr. Zackria Sait : Vice President (Technical Services)
Mr. A. M Mankad : Head (Car Plant)
Mr. S. B. Borwankar : Head (Jamshedpur Plant)
Mr. S. Krishnan : Vice President (Commercial-PCBU)
Mr. Ravi Pisharody : Vice President (Sales & Marketing)
Mr. H. K. Sethna : Company Secretary
AWARDS
TATA
SUMO GRANDE
TATA SAFARI
Indica Vista
• Tata Sierra
• Tata Estate
• Tata Sumo/ Spacio
• Tata Indica
• Tata Indigo
• Tata Indigo Marina
• Tata Winger
• Tata Nano
• Tata Xenon XT
• Tata Xover
• Tata Ace
• Tata TL/ Telcoline /207 DI Pickup Truck
• Tata 407 Ex and Ex2
• Tata 709 Ex
• Tata 809 Ex and Ex2
• Tata 909 Ex and Ex2
• Tata 1109 (Intermediate truck)
• Tata 1510/1512 (Medium bus)
• Tata 1610/1616 (Heavy bus)
• Tata 1613/1615 (Medium truck)
• Tata 2515/2516 (Medium truck)
• Tata Globus (Low Floor Bus)
• Tata Marcopolo Bus (Low Floor Bus)
• Tata 3015 (Heavy truck)
• Tata 3118 (Heavy truck) (8X2)
• Tata 3516 (Heavy truck)
• Tata 4923 (Ultra-Heavy truck) (6X4)
• Tata Novus (Heavy truck designed by Tata Daewoo)
roads blocked.
TATA Nano will hit the roads and as it is a definite threat to Maruti 800. TATA stated that
the initial production of this car will be of 250,000 a year. After about four years of hard efforts
TATA Nano ( 1 lakh rupee car ) was on road now.
The introduction of the Nano received media attention due to its targeted low price. The car is
expected to boost the Indian economy , create entrepreneurial-opportunities across India , as well as
expand the Indian car market by 65%. The car was envisioned by Ratan Tata , Chairman of the Tata Group
and Tata Motors , who has described it as an eco-friendly "people's car". Nano has been greatly
appreciated by many sources and the media for its low-cost and eco-friendly initiatives which include
using compressed-air as fuel and an electric-version (E-Nano). Tata Group is expected to mass-
manufacture the Nano, particularly the electric-version, and, besides selling them in India , to also export
them worldwide.
Critics of the car have questioned its safety in India (where reportedly 90,000 people are
killed in road-accidents every year), and have also cr iticised the pollution that it would cause
(including criticism by Nobel Peace Prize winner Rajendra Pachauri ). However, Tata Motors has
promised that it would definitely release Nano's eco-friendly models alongside the gasoline -
model.
The Nano was originally to have been manufactured at a new factory in Singur , West
Bengal , but increasingly violent protests forced Tata to pull out October 2008. Currently, Tata
Motors is reportedly manufacturing Nano at its existing Pantnagar ( Uttarakhand ) plant and a
mother plant has been proposed for Sanand Gujarat . The company will bank on existing dealer
network for Nano initially. The new Nano Plant could have a capacity of 500,000 units,
compared to 300,000 for Singur. Gujarat has also agreed to match all the incentives offered by
West Bengal government.
The Tata Nano is a rear-engined , four-passenger city car built by Tata Motors , aimed
primarily at the Indian market . The car is very fuel efficient, achieving around 26.00 km/l on the
highway and around 22.00 km/l in the city. It was first presented at the 9th annual Auto Expo on
Januar y 10, 2008, at Pragati Maidan in New Delhi . Nano had a commercial launch on March 23,
2009 and a booking period from April 9 to April 25, generating more than 200,000 bookings for
the car. The sales of the car begin in July 2009, with a starting price of Rs 115,000 ( rupees ). This
is cheaper than the Maruti 800 , its main competitor and next cheapest Indian car priced at
184,641Rupees.
DESIGN
Contrary to speculation that the car might be a simple four-wheeled auto rickshaw , The Times of
India reported the vehicle is "a properly designed and built car". The Chairman is reported to
have said, "It is not a car with plastic curtains or no roof — it's a real car."
To achieve its design goals, Tata refined the manufacturing process, emphasized innovation and
sought new design approaches from suppliers. The car was designed at Italy's Institute of
Development in Automotive Engineering — with Ratan Tata requesting certain changes, such as
the elimination of one of two windscreen wipers. Some components of the Nano are made in
Germany by Bosch , such as Fuel Injection , brake system, Value Motronic ECU, ABS and other
technologies.
The Nano has 21% more interior space (albeit mostly as headroom, due to its tall stance) and an
8% smaller exterior compared to its closest rival, the Maruti 800 . Tata offered the car in three
versions: the basic Tata Nano Std; the Cx; and the Lx. The Cx and Lx versions each have air
conditioning, power windows, and central locking. Tata has set its initial production target at
250,000 units per year.
COST CUTTING FEATURES
The Nano's trunk does not open. Instead, the rear seats can be folded down to access the trunk •
space.
It has a single windscreen wiper instead of the usual pair. •
It has no power steering. •
Its door opening lever was simplified. •
It has three nuts on the wheels instead of the customary four. •
It only has one side view mirror. •
PRICE
Tata initially targeted the vehicle as "the least expensive production car in the world"— aiming
for a starting price of 100,000 rupees or approximately, despite rapidly rising material prices at
the time.
As of August 2009, material costs had risen from 19% to 29% over the car’s development, and
Tata faced the choice of:
introducing the car with an artificially low price through government subsidies and tax- •
breaks
forgoing profit on the car •
using vertical-integration to artificially boost profits on cars at the expense of their •
materials industries
partially using inexpensive polymers or biodegradable plastics instead of a full metal- •
body
raising the price of the car •
The base model will have fixed seats, except for the driver's, which will be adjustable, while the
deluxe and luxury models will get air conditioning and body coloured bumpers.
Technical specifications
According to Tata Group 's Chair man Ratan Tata , the Nano is a 33 PS (33 hp/24 kW) car
with a 623 cc rear engine and rear wheel drive , and has a fuel economy of 4.55 L/100 km
(21.97 km/L, 51.7 mpg (US), 62 mpg (UK)) under city road conditions, and 3.85 L/100 km on
highways ( 25.974 km/L, 61.1 mpg (US), 73.3 mpg (UK)). It is the first time a two-cylinder non-
opposed petrol engine will be used in a car with a single balance shaft . Tata Motors has
reportedly filed 34 patents related to the innovations in the design of Nano, with powertrain
accounting for over half of them. The project head, Girish Wagh has been credited with being
one of the brains behind Nano's design.
Much has been made of Tata's patents pending for the Nano. Yet during a news
conference at the New Delhi Auto Expo, Ratan Tata pointed out none of these is revolutionar y or
represents earth- shaking technology. He said most relate to rather mundane items such as the
two-cylinder engine’s balance shaft, and how the gears were cut in the transmission.
Though the car has been appreciated by many sources, including Reuters due to "the way
it has tweaked existing technologies to target an as-yet untapped segment of the market", yet it
has been stated by the same sources that Nano is not quite "revolutionary in its technology", just
low in price. Moreover, technologies which are expected of the new and yet-to-be-released car
include a revolutionary compressed-air fuel system and an eco-friendly electric-version,
technologies on which Tata is reportedly already working, though no official incorporation-date
for these technologies in the new car has been released.
According to Tata, the Nano complies with Bharat Stage-III and Euro-IV emission
standards. Ratan Tata also said, 'The car has passed the full-frontal crash and the side impact
crash'. Tata Nano passed the required 'homologation’ tests with Pune-based Automotive Research
Association of India (ARAI).This means that the car has met all the specified criteria for
roadworthiness laid out by the government including emissions or noise & vibration and can now
ply on Indian roads. Tata Nano managed to score around 24 km per litre during its
‘homologation’ tests with ARAI. This makes Tata Nano the most fuel efficient car in India. Nano
will be the first car in India to display the actual fuel mileage figures it recorded at ARAI’s tests
on its windshield. According to ARAI it conforms to Euro IV emission standards which will
come into effect in India in 2010.
The Tata Sumo has been enjoying its position in the MUV market since 1994. It had stiff
competition with new Sumo Victa has been portrayed as a family lifestyle vehicle, but in fact is a
carryover of the old Sumo, with some cosmetic changes. The Sumo comes in nine Victa variants:
CX 10/7 Str, DI CX 7/9/10 Str, DI EX 7/9 Str, DI GX 7/9 Str, DI LX 7/9 Str, EX 10/7Str, GX 7
Str, GX TC 7 Str, and LX 10/7 Str. All variants, except the Victa DI variants, are powered by a 2-
litre Inline-4 diesel engine. The GX and GX TC variants get a 2-litre turbocharged diesel engine
that generates 89 bhp. The Victa DI variants get a 3-litre turbocharged diesel engine. Refinement,
both internal and external, is evident across the variants. Tata's latest three variants under the
'Sumo Grande' category are LX, EX and GX available in 2-seater, 7- seater and 8-seater
configurations. Sumo Grande boasts of a powerful 2.2-L Direct Injection Common Rail
(DICOR) engine
SUMO SPACIO
A no-frills version called the Tata Spacio is also available. It is equipped with a 3000 cc
DI diesel engine sourced from the popular LCV Tata 407. The prominent visual difference was
the presence of round headlamps instead of the rectangular lamps. A soft top version of the
Spacio called the Spacio ST was also introduced for the rural markets. After the facelift, the
Spacio inherited the styling elements of the older Tata Sumo. In 2007, the Victa became available
with the Spacio's 3000 cc engine. And in terms of styling, the positioning of the spare wheel was
changed from the rear tailgate to the underbody of the vehicle. This model comes in 8 and 10
seater variants and is ver y much popular with private transporters & contract taxi vendors
because of its lower cost.
SUMO VICTA
The new Sumo Victa released in 2004 featur ed power windows , power steering , dual AC,
central locking , clear lens multi reflector head lamps, crystal finish tail lamp cluster, anti glare
ORVMS with electronic control, remote keyless entry , tachometers , LCD monitors, voice
warnings, multiple trip odometers are all either standard or available options.
TATA
SUMO
GRANDE
(More than meets the eye)
3. NEW VERSION OF INDIGO ,INDIGO DICOR
Dicor Variants
The DICOR (common rail diesel) version of Tata Indigo is available in two variants which has
already hit the bull's eyes. The beefy & bony structured sedan has the capacity to deliver
maximum torque of 140Nm @ 1800 - 3000 rpm. The Indigo Dicor from Tata Motors has been
made apt for Indian roads especially with its driver & co passengers oriented positive attributes
such as:
Anti- submarine front seats
New electronic instrument cluster with engine RPM meter
Rear Seat with double folding backrest
Video player with MP3: with headrest mounted LCD screens
1.4-litre as rail diesel engine
Indigo LX Dicor
Tata Indigo LX Dicor on the other hand features manually operated with chrome strip outer rear
view window, black dials with chrome rings & star check as the new pattern for its console &
AC fascia.
Indigo LS Dicor
Tata Indigo LS Dicor features manually operated outer rear view mirror, black dials, & Benz
silver as the new pattern for console & AC fascia. It has no mounted LCD screens.
Mileage (City) : 14.75 kmpl
Mileage (Highways) : 18.35 kmpl
ENGINES
Petrol 1396 cc MPFI Petrol Engine with 32-Bit Microprocessor
Max. Power - 85 PS @5500 rpm
Max. Torque - 12 Kgm @ 3500 rpm
Diesel Turbo-charged 1405 cc Indirect Injection Engine with Intercooler
Max. Power -70 PS @ 4500 rpm
Max. Torque - 13.5 Kgm @ 2500 rpm
Dicor 32-bit microprocessor based 1396 cc DICOR (Direct Injection Common
Rail) 16-valve engine with Dual Over Head Camshafts and a Variable
Geometry Turbocharger (VGT)
Max. Power-70 PS@4000 rpm
Max. Torque - 140Nm@1800-3000 rpm
According to the National Council for Applied Economic Research, or NCAER, rural
India accounts for 70% of India’s population, 56% of the national income, 64% of the total
expenditure and one-third of the total savings. So, the difficulties faced in cracking these markets
pale before the huge potential they offer a company. Of the total sales (of consumer goods),
around 55% come from rural India, and going ahead, the contribution is likely to grow. NCAER
data suggests that in real terms, at 1999 prices, the size of the rural economy will be about Rs16
trillion in 2012-13 compared with Rs12 tr illion in 2007-08. The share of non-farm income will
be about two-thirds of the rural economy by 2012-13.
Noticing this huge potential Tata motors now plans to tap the rural market, 60 per cent of
which runs on cash. Tata motors ltd. is working on strategies to make inroads into these markets.
SWOT Analysis - Tata Motors
Limited
SWOT – Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threat
STRENGTHS
• The internationalization strategy so far has been to keep local managers in new
acquisitions, and to only transplant a couple of senior managers from India into the new
market. The benefit is that Tata has been able to exchange expertise. For example after
the Daewoo acquisition the Indian company leaned work discipline and how to get the
final product 'right first time.'
• The company has a strategy in place for the next stage of its expansion. Not only is it
focusing upon new products and acquisitions, but it also has a programme of intensive
management development in place in order to establish its leaders for tomorrow.
• The company has had a successful alliance with Italian mass producer Fiat since 2006.
This has enhanced the product portfolio for Tata and Fiat in terms of production and
knowledge exchange. For example, the Fiat Palio Style was launched by Tata in 2007,
and the companies have an agreement to build a pick-up targeted at Central and South
America.
WEAKNESSES
The company's passenger car products are based upon 3rd and 4th generation platforms, which
put Tata Motors Limited at a disadvantage with competing car manufacturers.
• Despite buying the Jaguar and Land Rover brands (see opportunities below); Tat has not
got a foothold in the luxury car segment in its domestic, Indian market. Is the brand
associated with commercial vehicles and low-cost passenger cars to the extent that it has
isolated itself from lucrative segments in a more aspiring India?
• One weakness which is often not recognised is that in English the word 'tat' means
rubbish. Would the brand sensitive British consumer ever buy into such a brand? Maybe
not, but they would buy into Fiat, Jaguar and Land Rover.
OPPORTUNITIES
• In the summer of 2008 Tata Motor's announced that it had successfully purchased the
Land Rover and Jaguar brands from Ford Motors for UK £2.3 million. Two of the
Wor ld's luxury car brand have been added to its portfolio of brands, and will undoubtedly
off the company the chance to market vehicles in the luxury segments.
• Tata Motors Limited acquired Daewoo Motor's Commercial vehicle business in 2004 for
around USD $16 million.
• Nano is the cheapest car in the World - retailing at little more than a motorbike. Whilst
the World is getting ready for greener alternatives to gas-guzzlers, is the Nano the answer
in terms of concept or brand? Incidentally, the new Land Rover and Jaguar models will
cost up to 85 times more than a standard Nano!
• The new global track platform is about to be launched from its Korean (previously
Daewoo) plant. Again, at a time when the Wor ld is looking for environmentally friendly
transport alternatives, is now the right time to move into this segment? The answer to this
question (and the one above) is that new and emerging industrial nations such as India,
South Korea and China will have a thirst for low-cost passenger and commercial
vehicles. These are the opportunities. However the company has put in place a very
proactive Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) committee to address potential
strategies that will make is operations more sustainable.
• The range of Super Milo fuel efficient buses are powered by super-efficient, eco-friendly
engines. The bus has optional organic clutch with booster assist and better air intakes that
will reduce fuel consumption by up to 10%.
THREATS
• Other competing car manufacturers have been in the passenger car business for 40, 50 or
more years. Therefore Tata Motors Limited has to catch up in terms of quality and lean
production.
• Sustainability and environmentalism could mean extra costs for this low-cost producer.
This could impact its underpinning competitive advantage. Obviously, as Tata globalizes
and buys into other brands this problem could be alleviated.
• Since the company has focused upon the commercial and small vehicle segments, it has
left itself open to competition from overseas companies for the emerging Indian luxury
segments. For example ICICI bank and DaimlerChrysler have invested in a new Pune-
based plant which will build 5000 new Mercedes-Benz per annum. Other players
developing luxury cars targeted at the Indian market include Ford, Honda and Toyota. In
fact the entire Indian market has become a target for other global competitors including
Mahindra and Mahindra, Maruti Udyog, General Motors, Ford and others.
• Rising prices in the global economy could pose a threat to Tata Motors Limited on a
couple of fronts. The price of steel and aluminium is increasing putting pressure on the
costs of production. Many of Tata's products run on Diesel fuel which is becoming
expensive globally and within its traditional home market.
FINANCIAL
ANALYSIS
FINANCIAL OVERVIEW
Year 2008- 2007-03 2006-03 2005- 2004-03
03 03
Equity Paid Up 385.54 385.41 382.87 361.79 353
Network 7813.99 6843.8 5510.68 4111.39 3589.77
Capital Employed 14094.51 10852.94 8447.52 6606.81 4849.54
Gross Block 10805.32 8749.85 7945.16 6611.95 5985.4
Net Working Capital -1248.57 1997.22 1923.41 -19.92 -1477.22 (Incl Def.
Tax)
Current Assets 10781.23 10688.65 9638.56 7188.72 3830.76 (Incl Def. Tax)
Current Liabilities and 12029.80 8691.43 7715.15 7208.64 5307.98
Provision (Incl Def. Tax)
Total Assets/ Liabilities 26118.26 19534.28 16148.55 13797.29 10135.33
Gross Sales 32885.03 31611.21 23673.43 20152.03 15165.85
Net Sales 28529.40 27185.77 20293.30 17088.59 12895.55
Other Incomes 972.93 547.11 693.92 560.29 427.79
Value of Output 28488.92 27535.45 20550.21 17232.59 12753.57
Cost of Production 24611.49 23290.95 17447.80 14614.45 10511.53
Selling Cost 1179.48 1068.56 756.54 581.41 455.56
PBIDT 3654.39 3527.98 2867.81 2319.87 1877.42
PBDT 3228.78 3159.47 2574.32 2102.06 1674.94
PBIT 3002.08 2941.69 2346.87 1869.71 1494.82
PBT 2576.47 2573.18 2053.38 1651.90 1292.34
PAT 2028.92 1913.46 1528.88 1236.95 810.34
CP 2681.23 2499.75 2049.82 1687.11 1192.94
Revenue earnings in forex 2844.12 2714.68 2384.81 1497.85 1016.64
Revenue expenses in forex 1695.58 1504.74 1132.9 671.40 354.38
Capital earnings in forex 00000
Capital expenses in forex 1314.31 472.76 264.88 226.84 43.22
Book Value (Unit Curr) 202.68 177.57 143.93 113.64 101.69
Market Capitalisation 24037.11 28048.94 3507.39 14976.30 17331.23
CEPS 67.44 62.31 51.19 44.88 32.77 (annualised), (Unit Curr.)
EPS 50.52 47.10 37.59 32.44 21.93 (annualised), (Unit Curr.)
Dividend 150 150.00 130 125.00 80.00 (annualized %)
Payout 29.7 31.85 34.6 38.66 36.44 (%)
Year Dividend Per Share(DPS)
in Rs.
2003-04 8.00
2004-05 12.50
2005-06 13.00
2006-07 15.00
2007-08 15.00
FORMULAE AT GLANCE
Cost of Equity, K =
e
Cost of Debt K =
d
ROI =
CAPITAL STRUCTURE
(Rs in Cr.)
2 2 20 2 20
Year 008 007 06 005 04
DPS(Rs) 15 15 13 12.5 8
Book Value(Rs.) 202.68 177.57 143.93 113.64 101.69
Payout (%) 29.7 31.85 34.6 38.66 36.44
Retention Ratio 0.703 0.6815 0.654 0.6134 0.6356
PBT 2576.47 2573.18 2053.38 1651.9 1292.34
Tax 139.01 476 363.35 363.82 96
PAT 2437.46 2097.18 1690.03 1288.08 1196.34
Preference Dividend 0 0 19.94 0 0
Equity 385.54 385.41 382.87 361.79 353
Reserves 7453.96 6484.34 5154.2 3749.6 3236.77
P & L Account(Dr
Balance) 0 0 0 0 0
Equity Shareholder Fund 7839.5 6869.75 5537.07 4111.39 3589.77
ROE 0.31 0.31 0.30 0.31 0.33
Growth Rate (%) 21.86 20.80 19.73 19.22 21.18
Cost of Equity (%) 29.26 29.25 28.76 30.22 29.05
Interest 425.61 368.51 293.49 217.81 202.48
Total Debt 6280.52 4009.14 2936.84 2495.42 1259.77
Cost of Debt (%) 6.78 9.19 9.99 8.73 16.07
PBIT 3002.08 2941.69 2346.87 1869.71 1494.82
Capital Employed 14094.51 10852.94 8447.52 6606.81 4849.54
ROI (%) 21.30 27.11 27.78 28.30 30.82
WEIGHTED AVERAGE COST OF CAPITAL
Year 2008
Proportion Cost Weighted
Source Amount (%) (%) Cost (%)
29.2
Equity 385.41 9.61 5 2.81
9.1
Debt 4009.14 91.23 9 8.39
4394.55 100.84 11.20
Year 2006
Proporti
on Cost Weighted
Source Amount (%) (%) Cost (%)
REASONS
Fiscal 2008-09, the second year of 11 Five Year Plan saw a marginal fall in GDP growth rate of th
9%.
• The slowdown in economy.
• Increase in inflation.
• Poor credit availability.
• Hardening of interest rate
• Rise in price of input material
• Proposed increase in fuel price and volatility in foreign exchange rates.
• Manufacturing expenses, employee cost increase.
• Net raw material consumption inclusive of processing charges increased, with pressure
on volumes and margins.
BALANCE SHEET ANALYSIS
From the above statement it is seems that the company has become highly geared year
after year. To substantiate this, the net current asset which is a representation of their long term
debit is on the increase (Rs. 27,203.30 million In 2006, Rs. 40,235.10 million in 2007, and Rs.
58,792.80 million In 2008) this forms a lower percentage of the total debit (when short term
debit and capital cases are added) the company is perhaps aware of the results that may effect the
interest on the total equity and rather have a preference for short term loans as the environment
dictate, hence, increasing the total equity year by year.
During the year, the Company recorded its highest ever sale of 5, 85,649 vehicles and
grew its turnover to Rs. 33,094 crores to remain as India's largest automobile company by
revenue.
The Company's margins were under pressure during the year due to rising interest rates,
constraints in availability of vehicle financing from outside sources and unprecedented increase
in prices of raw materials.
For long term financial plan and expansion of the new product (Nano) Tata has decided to
raise funds from the stock market rather than going for a loan option (GEARING). This is
because in the past heavy amounts were gained as interest on loans which have a negative effect
on the profit and returns to the stake holders. To support my analysis in financial year 2006, Rs.
36,641 million loans was taken, and in the year 2007, Rs. 79,137 million loan was taken, And
also the companies net profit margins have gone down abruptly from 6.8% in 2005 to 5.6% in
2007, most probably because of the rising cost of the raw material used by the 5 company, but
still the profits of the Tata Motors remain highest than the other auto manufacturers.
The rate of interest on vehicles in India is running very high, because of which the sales
growth have gone a little down. Even then Tata Motors have increased there profits to 6.2% year
after year. And are still financing most of their sales, up to 31% in 2007 from 24% in 2006.
Hence, gross accounts receivable are greater than before by 35% every year and they also had to
make up the shortage of cash by borrowing. When combined with the other expenses to the
growth of fuel, it has augmented its short as well as it’s the long-term debt extensively.
The EBIDTA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization) margin at 10.8%
was lower than last year as increase in input costs could only be partially absorbed by the market.
Note: Amortization = non-cash expense of writing off intangible assets over their useful lives.
The Profit Before-Tax at Rs.2, 576 crores was 0.1 % higher than last year, The Profit after Tax at
Rs.2, 029 crores, was 6.1 % higher than last year.
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
With significant increase in the Company's capital expenditure program’s and the
growing business requirement, the overall borrowings of the Company stood at Rs.6, 280.52
crores at a Debt: Equity ratio of 0.80:1.
The Indian economy remained in high growth phase but witnessed moderation in GDP
growth to 90/ in FY 07-08 as compared to over 9% growth achieved in the previous two years.
The commercial vehicle industry which grew by over 33% in FY 06-07 was impacted by
moderation in economic growth as wet as substantial reduction in vehicle financing and posted a
8.1% growth this fiscal. The passenger vehicle industry also witnessed a slowdown but managed
to grow by 11.1 % by increasing discounts on mature products, launching new models and due to
reduction in excise duty announced by the government in Budget during February'08. Vehicle
exports also grew, albeit at a slightly lower rate of 11.9% as compared to 14.8% witnessed in the
previous year.
Amidst moderation in economic growth, a high interest rate regime and tightening of the
liquidity position, the domestic passenger vehicle industry was able to grow by 11.3% to an all
time high of over 1.5 million vehicles, albeit at a lower growth rate than 21% of the last fiscal.
The Industry's growth rate in fact fell to single digit in the last four months of the fiscal. Growth
was primarily driven by new launches and discounts on existing volume models. Along with two
wheelers, entr y level cars (price point below Rs 3 lacs) declined by 2%.The luxury segment
however doubled in size to over 5,000 vehicles and were immune to the slowing market
conditions. Of over 90 models in the industry the top 10 constitute 65% of the industry sales.
After six years of consecutive growth, the Company's passenger vehicle sales decreased
marginally by 4.5% to 2, 18,055 vehicles (including 3,297 Fiat branded vehicles) and the
Company had a 14.2% share in the passenger vehicle market between TATA and Fiat branded
vehicles.
Fiscal 2008-09, the second year of 11th Five Year Plan saw a marginal fall in GDP
growth rate of 9%. In view of the slow down in economy, increase in inflation, poor credit
availability, hardening of interest rates, rise in prices of input materials, proposed increase in fuel
prices and volatility in foreign exchange rates, the commercial and passenger vehicle industry
has a challenging year ahead, with pressure on volumes and margins.
• Expected to grow at 13% p.a over the next decade to reach around
USD $ 120 - 159 bn by 2016.
INDIAN AUTOMOTIVE PLAYERS:
OVERVIEW OF THE
PLAYERS IN THE INDIAN INDUSTRY
The Indian auto industry is highly competitive with a number of global and Indian auto companies
present. Hence, we have conducted an Inter company analysis of Tata with Mahindra and Mahindra and
Maruti Udyog, to get an idea of the company’s position (operation and profitability) vis a vis its
competitors.
INTER COMPANY ANALYSIS:
Key Pla yers in the Indian auto industry – Passenger Cars And CVs
The largest Player in the Indian industry. Plans to launch new and exciting products
in the Indian markets, including the ‘100,000’ cars.
TOYOTA has vision of capturing 10% share of Indian passenger car market by 2010.
The third largest passenger car manufacture in India and one of the largest
exporters of vehicles. Has establishes India as one of its manufacturing bases in the
world, is planning to invest heavily to boost exports from India.
Maruti Suzuki’s JV in India and the largest passenger car manufacturer in India.
Project involves:
Financial performance in automobile industry
Market performance
Cost saving initiatives
Introduction about TATA Motors
Procedure followed by TATA Motors for catering to the needs and queries of the
customers
Quantitative research
Awareness regarding the facilities provided by TATA Motors.
Overall opinion about TATA Motors.
• This study would be useful for companies to know what people perceive and thinking
about Tata Motors and its products.
• This study would be useful to other students as a secondar y data.
Research Methodology:
The purpose of methodology is to describe the process involved in research work. This
includes the overall research design, data collection method, the field survey and the analysis of
data.
• Books
• Newspaper
RESEARCH DESIGN:
Research Design is the arrangement for conditioned for data collection & analysis of data
in a manner that aims to combined relevance to research purpose with economy in procedure.
A research design is a master plan or model for the conduct of formal investigation. It is
blue print that is followed in completing study.
Type of study: For completing my study I have gone for sample study because looking at •
the size of population & the time limitation it was not convenient for me to cover entire
population. Hence, I have gone for sample study rather than census study.
Sampling Plan:
A sample design is a definite plan for obtaining a sample from a given population. It refers to the
technique or the procedure that researcher would adopt in selecting items to be inched in the
sample i.e. the size of sample. Sampling plan is determined before data are collected.
SAMPLING PROCEDURE:
The selection of respondents were accordingly to be in a right place at a right time and so
the sampling were quite easy to measure, evaluate and co-operative. It was a randomly area
sampling method that attempts to obtain the sample of convenient.
Analysis:
The important factors and data’s collected were sequentially analyzed and graphed.
Limitation of the study:
• I will have to rely upon the information get from secondary sources (Balance sheet, Profit
& Loss Account and Cash Flow ) and given by respondents, which may not be fully true.
• This study will be limited to only some areas of Mandi District of Himachal Pradesh.
• It is only for short period of time.
• Lack of professional approach since researcher is a student
• The sample size is only 100 so the sample may not be truly representative of the Delhi
population.
FIELD WORK:
I have collected the data through medium called questionnaire collecting the responses
from 100 people in all. I had done my field work in the following area.
LUNAPANI, JAIL ROAD, CHALCHOWK, NER CHOWK, REWALSER, SUNDER NAGAR,
PANDO
I started my project very first educating the respondents about my entire project, and ask
them to co–operate with me. Mostly all the respondent were aware of this type of surveys. So I
didn’t face any type of difficulty during my project in the process of explaining and taking there
responses on the questionnaire.
Comparison of
THE STANDING
TATA MOTORS vis-
á-vis THE
INDUSTRY
TO COMPARE THE STANDING TATA MOTORS vis - á - vis
THE INDUSTRY. I CONDUCTED A FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF
TWO OF ITS COMPETITORS – MAHINDRA & MAHINDRA
AND MARUTI UDYOG.
The comparison is based on the detailed analysis of the financial statement on the lines of
Liquidity, Solvency, Profitability and efficiency.
LIQUIDITY POSITION:
Purpose of the Liquidity Ratios: The liquidity ratios help to determine a company’s
ability to meet its short-term liabilities. It can be in the form of the current ratio, liquid ratio,
absolute ratio or the operating cycles. While the current ratio, liquid ratio and absolute cash ratio
provide information about the company’s ability to payoff the shot-term obligations, the
operating cycle provides qualitative information about how quickly the company can convert its
stock into cash.
Company Analysis:
• Current Ratio for TATA Motors is greater, which implies that it has comfortable liquidity
position, however as compared to its competitors it is least liquid since inventories form a
considerable portion of its current assets and cash i.e. the most liquid asset, the least.
• Further, it has a negative operation cycle, which is primarily due to the high credit period
provided to its creditors. While both TATA and M&M have similar inventory days M&M
has an even lower operating cycle due to an even higher credit period. Maruti on the
other hand has an operating cycle of 7 days, which is much higher as compared to the
other two.
LIQUIDITY POSITION GRAPHICAL:
SOLVENCY POSITION:
Purpose of the Solvency Ratios: The solvency ratios are used to measure a company’s ability to
meet its long term obligation. The commonly used ratios to ascertain the solvency position of a
company are Debt Equity Ratio and Interest Coverage Ratio.
Debt/Equity Ratio: The ratio gives the proportion of debt and equity in the total capital structure.
TATA Motors has a debt equity ratio of about 52% which means that one-third of its total assets
are financed through debt. Maruti on the other hand has a low Debt Equity Ratio only 9% i.e the
company primarily uses its profits and reserves to find its assets.
Interest Coverage Ratio: A ratio used to determine how easily a company can pay interest on
outstanding debt. The ratio is calculated by dividing a company’s earning before interest and
taxes (PBIT) of one period by the company’s interest expenses of the same period.
PBIT/Sale: The lower the ratio, the more the company is burdened by debt expense. When a
company’s interest coverage ratio is 1.5 or lower, its ability to meet interest expenses may be
questionable. An interest coverage ratio below 1 indicates the company is not generating
sufficient revenues to satisfy interest expenses. TATA Motors has an ICR of 9.22 which implies
that it can easily service its debt obligations. However, its ICR is much less as compared to its
competitors. This is primarily because it the proportion of debt financing employed by TATA
Motors is much higher as compared to M&M or Maruti Udyog. Consequently its debt obligation
is also higher than the other tow.
It is interesting to note here that while TATA Motors has a higher operating profit margin of 12%
as compared to M&M’s 9%, its Net Profit Margin (PBIT/Sales) of 10% is much lower than
M&M’s 15%. This implies that a large portion of TATA’s profit are from its operations while
M&M has a considerable amount of non operating income. Maruti has the highest profitability
among the three companies indicating that it has been most successful in controlling its costs.
Rate of Return Ratios
ROTA: ROTA is an indicator of how profitable a company is relative to its total assets.
ROTA given an idea as to how efficient management is at using its assets to generate
earnings.
ROCE: It indicated the efficiency and profitability of a company’s capital investments.
ROCE should always be higher than the rate at which the company borrows; otherwise
any increase in borrowing will reduce shareholders’ earnings
PROFITABILITY RATIO GRAPHICAL ANALYSIS:
Inferences about the companies:
ROTA and ROCE for TATA Motors
is the least among the three
companies. While TATA has an
ROCE of 25% Maruti’s ROCE is
nearly 30%. It implies that
there is potential in the industry that
is not being fully exploited by TATA
Motors. There is still
considerable scope for the company to increase its profits by effectively utilization its assets.
MARKET POSITION:
PE ratio and MV/BV is lowest among the three companies for TATA Motors, despite the
fact that its earnings and book value is higher than M&M. The reason as to why these ratios are
low is clearly its low market value as competitors. The MV/BV Ratio for M&M is 5.2 which is
much higher than TATA’s 3.73 despite the fact that M&M’s BV per share is Rs. 148.11 which is
lower than TATA Motors’s BV of
Rs. 198.66 per share.
RESULT/ CONCLUSION:
A detailed analysis of the
company shows that the
company has had a strong
fundamental
as well as a strong market
performance over the years. Given
the economic and the industry
environment (improving outlook for the CV industry) TATA Motors would be a key beneficiary.
While a pick-up in its CV volumes is evident, operating leverage and cost saving initiatives will
improve margins.
Current Ratio for TATA Motors is greater, which implies that it has comfortable liquidity
position, however as compared to its competitors it is least liquid since inventories form a
considerable portion of its current assets.
TATA Motors has a debt equity ratio of about 52% which means that one-third of its total
assets are financed through debt.
TATA Motors has an ICR of 9.22 which implies that it can easily service its debt
obligations.
However, its ICR is much less as compared to its competitors. This is primarily because it
the proportion of debt financing employed by TATA Motors is much higher as compared to
M&M or Maruti Udyog
TATA Motors has a higher operating profit margin of 12% as compared to M&M’s 9%,
its Net Profit Margin (PBIT/Sales) of 10% is much lower than M&M’s 15%.
ROTA and ROCE for TATA Motors is the least among the three companies. While TATA
has an ROCE of 25% Maruti’s ROCE is nearly 30%. It implies that there is potential in the
industr y that is not being fully exploited by TATA Motors.