Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Oxford Music
Online
Grove Music Online
Women in music, §III: World music
article url: http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com:80/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3
Women in music, §III: World music
A quick glance at the geographical range of the literature shows that not all the
world's musical cultures have been equally researched and that much more
information is needed on all aspects of women's musical behaviour, especially
among the traditional cultures of Central and South America, Africa and Asia.
In all the literature, however, one universal exists: nowhere do men and
women have equal access to all musical opportunities within a culture.
Gender-based restrictions of some sort exist everywhere, from the mildest and
most subtle (such as steering a young American boy away from playing the
harp in the school orchestra) to the most violent (threats of gang rape against
the Mundurucú women of central Brazil who catch sight of men's sacred
flutes).
One of the problems facing the study of women's music in world cultures, and
of gender issues in music in general, is that the analytical tools and models are
largely Western-orientated, concentrating on Western constructs (such as the
bi-polarity of the sexes) and a unitary Western conception of music. Although
all societies recognize two human biological categories (‘male’ and ‘female’)
and use them as a primary basis for the division of labour, gender categories
(‘man’ and ‘woman’) are social constructs seen within specific contexts. Each
society thus invents gender ideologies (often linked to religious, social,
economic and other systems within the culture), which act as models, or
templates, for gender-typical behaviours. Gender categories and ideologies
are thus fluid, and constantly changing across time and space. There are no
societies in which men and women have had total gender equality, that is,
equal access to all political, economic and expressive aspects of culture,
although there are many where men's and women's separate activities are, for
the most part, equally valued or necessary to cultural maintenance. Likewise,
although all societies select certain sounds to perform, and value such sounds
over others, not all would refer to them as ‘music’, a term associated in many
cultures with public, sexual or decadent (Western) values. Thus, it is crucial
that future research takes into account indigenous understandings of analytical
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 2 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
In many societies women take on the role of shaman and often practise
outside the sanctioned religious systems of their communities. Part-healer,
part-musician, spirit-guide and actor, the shaman is frequently called on to cure
individual, family and community illness. Women are often regarded as more
powerful than men in this role, as their fertility and perceived psychological
openness seem to make them better adapted to mediating between the spirit
and human worlds. Nowhere has this tradition been more fully documented
than in Korea, with major studies on mudang (female shamans) and the ritual
known as kut. Other studies have also appeared documenting female
shamans in Siberia, Haiti and the USA.
economic system proved advantageous for the arts, especially for music, as
court rituals and ceremonies required many elaborate performances and a
constant stream of musicians and composers. The patronage system that
developed in these areas disappeared with the rise of the urban middle class,
where musicians, especially in western Europe, often acted as free agents and
gained more control over their musical activities. But the legacy of the politico-
religious court system still lingers in many of the world's cultures.
Women were frequently drawn from surrounding villages and farming areas to
participate as courtesans in court life, as musicians, singers, dancers and
composers. Indeed, many of the world's classical music systems developed
and grew within court contexts, especially in Europe, India, China and
Indonesia. In most societies, however, courtesans (but not courtiers) were
viewed with some ambivalence. Contrary to the norm, these women were often
highly educated, professional musicians, singers and dancers, who were also
viewed as public women, that is, women who publicly performed not only their
music but also their sexuality, primarily for male patrons. Courtesan traditions
have been fairly well documented, especially in China, Korea, Japan,
Indonesia, Egypt, India, Nigeria, Tunisia, Cyprus, and within the medieval
Arabo-Islamic courts and the Christian courts of Europe (see COURTESAN ).
A tremendous amount of popular literature exists that chronicles the lives and
times of female singers, especially in the West; the scholarly literature,
however, is relatively small by comparison. Most work centres on black
American blues and jazz singers, especially in the first half of the 20th century
when women such as Ma Rainey and Bessie Smith were stars. Blues lyrics,
especially, provided a context for women to protest various gender issues,
such as infidelity, abandonment and other abuses. Other work on popular
female singers includes publications on women-identified (i.e. lesbian) music
in the USA, on popular singers in Mali, South Africa and Croatia, and on the
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 5 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
in the USA, on popular singers in Mali, South Africa and Croatia, and on the
great Egyptian singer Umm Kulthum, a powerful icon of Egyptian nationalism
and modernization in the first half of the 20th century. See also POPULAR MUSIC,
§II .
5. New research.
Since about 1985, new, postmodern studies addressing the issue of gender in
song lyrics and in musical structure itself have begun to appear, most
prominently within the literature on Western classical and popular musics.
These studies examine song texts, sound structures and actual performances
as materializations of gender relationships and, in openly political ways, try to
understand and address the power imbalances found between men and
women in virtually all world cultures. Some literature, such as that on the
popular performers Madonna, Annie Lennox and other contemporary Western
singers and songwriters, focusses on the strategies used by these powerful
women to subvert or overthrow male domination by questioning and playing
with the bi-polarized constructions of gender in Western culture. Similarly,
recent scholarship on rock, rap, blues and American balladry, and on women's
musical life stories, openly addresses questions of sexual identity politics
within music, the music industry, and within such contexts as the home and the
Internet. Outside the USA, scholars working on a number of areas – the Arab
Middle East, Jewish communities in Israel, female singers in Ethiopia and
Turkey, folksingers in north India, Australia and among the Maori – are
examining the ways in which culture-specific constructions of gender and
resulting inter-gender relations are actually performed through the musical and
sexual body.
Far more research and far more understanding of the wide variety of gendered
musical and social behaviours and contexts are needed. Women have always
been at least one half of the world's population, yet little of their music or
musical performance has been documented within the Western academy, itself
a male-dominated institution. This is changing as more women and men
become sensitive to the diversity and creativity of both gendered constructs
and the varied musical sounds the world offers, but much more research and
analysis is needed in order to balance the picture.
Bibliography
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 6 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
J. Riley: ‘Women and World Music: Straining our Ears to the Silence’, Heresies: A
Feminist Publication on Art and Politics, no.10 (New York, 1980)
J.L. Zaimont, ed.: The Musical Woman: an International Perspective (Westport, CT,
1983)
J. Shepherd: ‘Music and Male Hegemony’, Music and Society: the Politics of
Composition, Performance, and Reception, ed. R. Leppert and S. McClary
(Cambridge, 1987), 151–72
R. Keeling, ed.: Women in North American Indian Music: Six Essays (Bloomington,
IN, 1989)
E. Koskoff: ‘Both In and Between: Women's Musical Roles in Ritual Life’, Music
and the Experience of God, ed. M.V. Burnim, M. Collins and D. Power (Edinburgh,
1989), 82–93
C.E. Robertson: ‘Singing Social Boundaries into Place: the Dynamics of Gender
and Performance in Two Cultures’, Sonus, x (1989–90), no.1, pp. 59–71; no.2,
pp.1–13
M. Herndon and S. Ziegler, eds.: ‘Women in Music and Music Research’, World of
Music, xxxiii/2 (1991) [whole issue]
L.J. Jones: ‘Women in Non-Western Music’, Women and Music: a History, ed. K.
Pendle (Bloomington, IN, 1991), 314–30
B. Lincoln: Emerging from the Chrysalis: Rituals of Women's Initiation (New York,
1991)
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 7 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
P. Brett and E. Wood, eds.: Queering the Pitch: the New Gay and Lesbian
Musicology (New York, 1994)
S. Cook and J.S. Tsou: Cecilia Reclaimed: Feminist Perspectives on Gender and
Music (Urbana, IL, 1994)
E. Koskoff: ‘When Women Play: the Relationship between Musical Instruments and
Gender Style’, Canadian University Music Review, xvi/1 (1995), 114–27
W. Washabaugh, ed.: The Passion of Music and Dance: Body, Gender, Sexuality
(Oxford, 1998)
B. Diamond and P. Moisala, eds.: Music and Gender: Negotiating Shifting Worlds
(Urbana, IL, 2000) [incl. M. Herndon: ‘The Place of Gender within Complex
Dynamical Musical Systems’]
B: North America
F. Densmore: Chippewa Music (Washington, DC, 1910–13)
C.I. Frisbie: Kinaalda: a Study of the Navaho Girl's Puberty Ceremony (Middletown,
CT, 1965)
N.H. Saldaña: ‘La Malinche: her Representation in Dances of Mexico and the
United States’, EthM, x (1966), 289–309
B.L. Hawes: ‘Folksongs and Function: some Thoughts on the American Lullaby’,
Journal of American Folklore, lxxxvii (1974), 140–48
E. Alloy and M. Rogers: Working Women's Music: the Songs and Struggles of
Women in the Cotton Mills, Textile Plants, and Needle Trades (Somerville, MA,
1976)
S. Frith and A. McRobbie: ‘Rock and Sexuality’, Screen Education, xxix (1978),
371–89
G. Kurath: Tutelo Rituals on Six Nations Reserve, Ontario (Ann Arbor, 1981)
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 8 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
A.D. Shapiro and I. Talamantez: ‘The Mescalero Apache Girls' Puberty Ceremony:
the Role of Music in Structuring Ritual Time’, YIFMC, xviii (1986), 77–90
R. Keeling, ed.: Women in North American Indian Music (Bloomington, IN, 1989)
[incl. B.D. Cavanagh: ‘Music and Gender in the Sub-Arctic Algonkian Area’,
American Indian Music, 55–66; C. Frisbie: ‘ Gender and Navajo Music:
Unanswered Questions’, 22–38; O.T. Hatton: ‘ Gender and Musical Style in Gros
Ventre War Expedition songs’, 39–54; R. Keeling: ‘ Musical Evidence of Female
Spiritual Life among the Yurok’, 67–78; T. Vennum jr.: ‘ The Changing Role of
Women in Ojibway Music History’, 13–21]
G.D. Goode: Preachers of the Word and Singers of the Gospel: the Ministry of
Women among Nineteenth Century African-Americans (Philadelphia, 1990)
H. Carby: ‘In Body and Spirit: Representing Black Women Musicians’, Black Music
Research Journal, xi:2 (1992), 177–92
E. Koskoff: ‘Miriam Sings her Song: the Self and the Other in Anthropological
Discourse’, Musicology and Difference: Gender and Sexuality in Music
Scholarship, ed. R. Solie (Berkeley, 1993), 149–63
S.C. Cook and J.S. Tsou, eds.: Cecilia Reclaimed: Feminist Perspective on
Gender and Music (Urbana, IL, 1994) [incl. S.C. Cook: ‘“Cursed Was She”:
Gender and Power in American Balladry’, 202–24; J.C. Post: ‘ Erasing the
Boundaries between Public and Private in Women's Performance Traditions’, 35–
51]
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 9 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
J.A. Jones: ‘Nez Perce Women, Music, and Cultural Change’, Women of Note
Quarterly, iii/3 (1995), 6–19
E. Koskoff: ‘The Language of the Heart: Music in Lubavitcher Life’, New World
Hasidim: Ethnographic Studies of Hasidic Jews in America, ed. J.S. Belcove-
Shalin (Albany, NY, 1995), 87–106
B. Diamond and P. Moisala, eds.: Music and Gender: Negotiating Shifting Worlds
(Urbana, IL, 2000) [incl. J. Bowers: ‘Writing the Biography of a Black Woman
Blues Singer’; B. Diamond: ‘The Interpretation of Gender Issues in Musical Life
Stories’]
A. Seeger: ‘Sing for your Sister: the Structure and Performance of Suya Akia’, The
Ethnography of Musical Performance, ed. N. McLeod and M. Herndon (Norwood,
PA, 1980), 7–42; repr. in A Century of Ethnomusicological Thought, ed. K.K.
Shelemay (New York, 1990), 269–304
E.B. Basso: ‘Musical Expression and Gender Identity in the Myth and Ritual of the
Kalapalo of Central Brazil’, Women and Music in Cross-Cultural Perspective, ed.
E. Koskoff (Westport, CT, 1987), 163–76
F.R. Aparicio: Listening to Salsa: Gender, Latin Popular Music and Puerto Rican
Cultures (Middletown, CT, 1997)
D: Africa
GEWM, i (’Pop Music in Africa’, A. Impey)
M. Mackay: ‘The Shantu Music of the Harims of Nigeria’, AfM, i/2 (1955), 56–7
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 10 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
K.A. Gourlay: ‘Trees and Anthills: Songs of the Karimojong Women's Groups’, AfM,
iv/4 (1970), 114–21
J.C. DjeDje: Distribution of the One-String Fiddle in West Africa (Los Angeles,
1980)
C.A. Campbell and C.M. Eastman: ‘Ngoma: Swahili Adult Song Performance in
Context’, EthM, xxviii (1984), 467–93
J.C. DjeDje: ‘Women and Music in Sudanic Africa’, More than Drumming, ed. I.
Jackson (Westport, CT, 1985), 67–89
L. Monts: ‘Vai Women's Roles in Music, Masking, and Ritual Performance’, African
Musicology …: a Festschrift presented to J.H. Kwabena Nketia, i, ed. J.C. DjeDje
and W.G. Carter (Los Angeles, 1989), 219–36
R.C. Okafor: ‘Women in Igbo Musical Culture’, Nigerian Field, liv (1989), 3–4
C.E. Schmidt: ‘Womanhood, Work and Song among the Kpelle of Liberia’, African
Musicology …: a Festschrift presented to J.H. Kwabena Nketia, i, ed. J.C. DjeDje
and W.G. Carter (Los Angeles, 1989), 237–64
W. Bender: ‘Great Female Singers: Mali’, Sweet Mother: Modern African Music
(Chicago, 1991), 21–31 [Eng. trans. of Ger. orig., 1985]
N. McLeod and M. Herndon: ‘The bormliza: Maltese Folksong Style and Women’,
Women and Folklore, ed. C.B. Farrer (Austin, TX, 1975), 81–100
Y. Avishur: Women's Folk Songs in Judeao-Arabic from Jews in Iraq (Or Yehud,
Israel, 1987)
S.M. Sawa: ‘The Role of Women in Musical Life: the Medieval Arabo-Islamic
Courts’, Canadian Women's Studies, viii (1987)
V.L. Danielson: ‘Artists and Entrepreneurs: Female Singers in Cairo during the
1920s’, Women in Middle Eastern History: Shifting Boundaries in Sex and Gender,
ed. N.R. Keddie and B. Baron (New Haven, CT, 1991), 292–309
I. Heskes: ‘Miriam's Sisters: Jewish Women and Liturgical Music’, Notes, xlviii
(1991–2), 1193–1202
S. Gergis: ‘The Power of Women Musicians in the Ancient and Near East: the
Roots of the Prejudice’, British Journal of Music Education, x (1993), 189–96
K. Van Nieuwkerk: “A Trade Like Any Other”: Female Singers and Dancers in
Egypt (Austin, TX, 1995)
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 12 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
V.L. Danielson: The Voice of Egypt: Umm Kulthūm, Arabic Song, and Egyptian
Society in the Twentieth Century (Chicago, 1997)
S. Zuhur, ed.: Images of Enchantment: Visual and Performing Arts in the Middle
East (Cairo, 1998)
V. Doubleday: ‘The Frame Drum in the Middle East: Women, Musical Instruments,
and Power’, EthM, xliii/i (1999), 101–34
V.L. Danielson: ‘Moving into Public Space: Women and Musical Performance in
20th Century Egypt’, Hermeneutics and Honor: Negotiating Female ’Public’ Space
in Islamic Societies, ed. A. Afsaruddin (Cambridge, MA, 1999)
B. Diamond and P. Moisala, eds.: Music and Gender: Negotiating Shifting Worlds
(Urbana, IL, 2000) [incl. C.T. Kimberlin: ‘Women, Music and Chains of the Mind:
Eritrea and the Tigre Region of Ethiopia’; U. Reinhard: ‘The Image of Woman in
Turkish Ballad Poetry and Music’]
F: Europe
B. Bartók and A. Lord: Serbo-Croatian Folk Songs (New York, 1951)
J.C. Sugarman: ‘The Nightingale and the Partridge: Singing and Gender among
Prespa Albanians’, EthM, xxxiii (1989), 191–216
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 13 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
M.P. Coote: ‘On the Composition of Women's Songs [in the south Slavic oral
tradition]’, Oral Tradition, vii (1992), 332–48
B. Diamond and P. Moisala, eds.: Music and Gender: Negotiating Shifting Worlds
(Urbana, IL, 2000) [incl. N. Ceribasic: ‘Defining Women/Men in the Context of
War: Images in Croatian Popular Music in the 1990s’; H. Jarviluoma: ‘Local
Construction of Gender in a Rural Pelimaiuu Musicians' Group’; P. Moisala:
‘Gender Negotiation of Composer Kaija Saariaho in Finland: Woman Composer as
Nomadic Subject’; M. Meyers: ‘Searching for Data About European Ladies'
Orchestras, 1870–1950’; I. Runtel: ‘Past and Present Gender Roles in the
Traditional Community on Kihnu Island in Estonia’]
G: Asia
J.O. Becker: ‘Music of the Pwo Karen of Northern Thailand’, EthM, viii (1964),
137–53
U.H. Cadar: ‘The Role of Kulintang Music in Maranao Society’, EthM, xvii (1973),
243–49
M.J. Kartomi: ‘Music and Trance in Central Java’, EthM, xvii(2) (1973), 163–208
B.W. Lee: ‘Evolution of the Role and Status of Korean Professional Entertainers
(Kisaeng)’, World of Music, xxi/2 (1979), 75–84
R.B. Qureshi: ‘Islamic Music in an Indian Environment: the Shi‘a Majlis’, EthM, xxv
(1981), 41–71
A. Catlin: ‘Apsaras and other Goddesses in Khmer Music, Dance and Ritual’,
Apsara: the Feminine in Cambodian Arts (Los Angeles, 1987), 28–36
J. Becker: ‘Earth, Fire, “Sakti” [female power] and Javanese Gamelan’, EthM, xxxii
(1988), 385–91
L.G. Tewari: ‘Sohar: Childbirth Songs of Joy’, Asian Folklore Studies, xlvii (1988),
257–6
S. Addiss: ‘Text and Context in Vietnamese Sung Poetry: the Art of “Hát á Dào”’,
Selected Reports in Ethnomusicology, ix (1992), 203–34
I. Fritsch: ‘The Social Organization of the “Goze” in Japan: Blind Female Musicians
on the Road’, CHIME: Journal of the European Foundation for Chinese Music
Research, no.5 (1992), 58–64
A.K. Coaldrake: Women's Gidayu and the Japanese Theatre Tradition (New York,
1996)
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 15 de 16
Women in music, §III: World music in Oxford Music Online 1/12/08 16:15
C.J. Ellis and L. Barwick: ‘Antikirinja Women's Song Knowledge 1963–1972: its
Significance in Antikirinja Culture’, Women, Rites and Sites: Aboriginal Women's
Cultural Knowledge, ed. P. Brock (Sydney, 1990), 21–40
M. Orbell: ‘“My Summit where I Sit”: Form and Content in Maori Women's Love
Songs’, Oral Tradition, v (1990), 185–204
Ellen Koskoff
http://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/subscriber/article/grove/music/52554pg3?print=true Página 16 de 16