Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
______________________________________________________________________________
THE GUIDE MUST BE READ IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE NURSE PRACTICE ACT (MD. CODE ANN., HEALTH
OCC., TITLE 8), BOARD REGULATIONS (COMAR 10.27.01 et. seq.), AND EMPLOYER POLICIES.
THE GUIDE IS NOT INTENDED TO REPLACE OR MODIFY THE ACT OR THE REGULATIONS, OR
EMPLOYER POLICIES. IN THE EVENT OF AMBIGUITY OR INCONSISTENCY, THE NURSE
PRACTICE ACT AND THE BOARD’S REGULATIONS TAKE PRECEDENCE.
Pain Management
Nursing Role/Core Competency
A Guide for Nurses
The purpose of this document is to assist the Pain management is only one aspect of the
licensed nurse in recognizing his/her complex process of providing palliative care.
accountability in effectively managing It is beyond the scope of this document to
patients’ pain through assessment, address other issues involved in palliative
intervention and advocacy. care.
BACKGROUND
Pain management encompasses various types response can provide maximum pain relief
of pain experiences throughout an individual’s without adversely affecting respiratory status.
life cycle from birth to the end of life. Pain expe- Therefore, it is unwarranted to under-utilize or
riences may include acute and chronic pain, pain withhold opioids from a patient who is
from a chronic deteriorating condition, or pain as experiencing pain based on fear of causing
one of many symptoms of the patient receiving respiratory depression.
palliative care. Pain is not exclusively physiologi - Due to multiple advances in the field of pain
cal but also includes spiritual, emotional and psy- management (i.e. pain assessment, pharmacolog-
chosocial dimensions. The goal of pain manage- ical and non-pharmacological interventions),
ment throughout the life cycle is the same - to licensed nurses may have incomplete or inaccu-
address the dimensions of pain and to provide rate information about the following variables
maximum pain relief with minimal side effects. which contribute to ineffective pain management:
Review of the literature, anecdotal reports and 1. What is pain and how do patients
dialogue with colleagues reveals that the majority demonstrate their pain?
of patients do not receive adequate pain manage- 2. How is pain assessed and managed?
ment. A wide variety of factors including inaccu- 3. Is there a difference between
rate information, myths, rumors, fear and cultural psychological dependence, addiction
issues contribute to inadequate pain management. and physical dependence?
For example, a prevailing rumor in the nursing 4. Does aggressive use of opioids cause
profession is that a nurse can lose his/her nursing addiction?
license for causing a patient’s respiratory depress- 5. How does the patient’s cultural back-
ion by frequent administration or by giving high ground effect pain expression and
doses of opioids, even though there is no documen- management?
ted evidence to substantiate this fear. The Myths and misinformation also contribute
literature shows that adequate assessment in to ineffective pain management. Some common
conjunction with opioid titration based on patient myths include:
2
Pain Management Nursing Role/Core Competency
1. Too much pain medication too frequently Populations identified by the literature as being at
constitutes substance abuse, causes greater risk include: infants and children, women,
addiction, will result in respiratory the elderly, patients with cognitive dysfunction,
depression or will hasten death; patients with emotional or mental illness, patients
2. Pain should be treated, not prevented; with chronic pain, patients with neuropathic pain,
3. People in pain always report their pain to substance abusers, minority populations, the
their health care provider; homeless, and patients with terminal illnesses.
4. People in pain demonstrate or show that In
they have pain - pain can be seen in the addition, patients who speak a different language
patient’s behavior; or who are from a cultural tradition different from
5. The level of pain is often exaggerated by that of the clinician pose a special challenge. In
the patient; effect, any patient, regard- less of age, is at risk of
6. Generally a patient cannot be relieved of all being under-treated for pain. All populations can
pain; be placed at greater risk because of the health care
7. Some pain is good so that the patient’s provider’s own belief system which may include
symptoms are not masked; the previously discussed myths and
8. Newborn infants do not have pain; and, misinformation.
9. It is expected that the elderly, especially the These factors and others have prompted the
frail elderly, always have some pain. Board to develop this educational guide for the
Maryland licensed nurse. The intent is to provide
Patient Populations at Risk of Under factual information and assist the licensed nurse in
Management developing core nursing competencies in pain
management. The licensed nurse must become
Because of multiple barriers to adequate pain familiar with standards, guidelines and definitions
management, all patients are at risk for under- regarding pain and its management, including but
treatment of pain. Since pain is identified and not limited to those listed in the definition of
reported primarily through patient self- reporting, terms and bibliography and to refer to these
difficulty in communicating increases the patient’s documents when advocating for the patient in
risk for under-treatment. pain.
3
Licensed Nurse Role:
Knowledge Based Practice
The licensed nurse is responsible and account- Pain is subjective. It is whatever the patient
able to ensure that a patient receives appropriate says it is. The nurse utilizes the nursing process in
evidence-based nursing assessment and interven- the management of pain. Adequate measurement
tion which effectively treats the patient’s pain and and management of pain includes knowledge in
meets the recognized standard of care. In order to the following areas:
advocate for the patient, the licensed nurse must 1. Pain assessment:
possess the following: a) The nurse utilizes a developmentally
appropriate, standardized pain assessment tool
A) Knowledge of Self which includes: a pain measurement tool
which has demonstrated reliability and validity
The practice of nursing includes the knowledge and patient participation, which is essential in
of one’s self through assessment of attitudes, the assessment process. For those incapable of
values, beliefs, and cultural background and influ- self-reporting, standardized pain assessment
ences that have formed each of us as individuals. tools should include behavioral observations
These factors affect the nurse when assessing, with or without physiologic measures.
evaluating, and interpreting the patient’s state- i. Physiologic signs such as tachy-
ments, behavior, physical response, and appear- cardia, hypertension, diaphoresis and pallor
ance. The greatest barrier to the patient achieving are non-specific to pain and may be an
effective pain management may be the nurse’s: indicator of another, unrelated physiologic
1. Individual experiences with pain; problem. For patients in pain, these
2. Personal use of medications or non- physiologic signs may be present for a
pharmacological methods to manage short period of time or not at all.
pain; and, ii. Sole reliance on these physiologic
3. Family’s or significant others’ history or signs to assess pain may be inappropriate.
experience with substances for pain control or b) The nurse is knowledgeable regarding the
mood altering effect. difference in categories of pain (i.e. acute,
chronic, breakthrough);
When the licensed nurse is influenced or con- c) The nurse is knowledgeable regarding the
strained by personal factors, the nurse may not most likely potential sources of pain (i.e.
assess, evaluate or communicate the patient’s pain neurological, muscular, skeletal, visceral);
level effectively or objectively. This can be further d)The nurse assesses the patient’s individual
compounded if the nurse does not have adequate pain pattern, including the individual patient’s
knowledge regarding pain management and, as a pain experiences, methods of expressing pain,
result, can not recognize the need to seek out cultural influences, and how the individual
additional information to assess and manage the manages their pain.
patient’s pain appropriately. For instance, a nurse 2. Pharmacologic and Non-Pharmacologic
who believes or states, “You can tell by looking at Intervention:
the patient if they are in pain” is demonstrating an a) The nurse is knowledgeable about the
inadequate knowledge base. pharmacological interventions of opioid,
non-opioid, and adjuvant drug therapies
B) Knowledge of Pain
4
Pain Management Nursing Role/Core Competency
5
PATIENT ADVOCACY
The nurse’s primary commitment is to the The nurse also has an obligation to advocate
health, welfare, comfort and safety of the for all patients in the aggregate. When an
patient. Self-awareness, knowledge of pain and organization’s policies, procedures and practices
pain assessment, and knowledge of the standard are insufficient to provide consistent effective
of care for pain management enhances the pain management, the nurse works through
nurse’s ability to advocate for and assure appropriate committees and channels to insure
effective pain management for each patient. that patients’ pain management needs are
When advocating for the patient, it is crucial addressed. This advocacy role is particularly
that the nurse utilize and reference current critical for populations known to be at risk for
evidence-based pain management standards and under-management of their pain.
guidelines.
As a patient advocate, the nurse takes all SUMMARY
reasonable means to alleviate the patient’s pain
and suffering. In addition, the nurse consults This educational guide is intended to assist
and collaborates with specially trained experts in the licensed nurse to act in an accountable
pain management, such as registered nurses, manner to effectively manage a patient’s pain.
licensed physicians, pharmacists, massage This document emphasizes that the licensed
therapists, acupuncturists and others to assure an nurse must continue to develop self-awareness
effective interdisciplinary treatment plan to and enhance his/her learning in order to remain
address each patient’s pain. When the patient’s current in nursing knowledge and skill relative
pain needs are not being adequately addressed, to attempt to pain management. The licensed
the nurse continues to advocate for the patient nurse is responsible and accountable to work
through other means, such as referral to the toward effectively managing the patient’s pain
organization’s joint practice committee, the through assessment, intervention and patient
ethics committee, and/or the organization’s advocacy.
chain of command.
6
DEFINITION OF TERMS
7
Pain Management Nursing Role/Core Competency
8
REFERENCES
Written Resources
1. Kaiser, Karen, RN, MS. “Personal Strate- 9. McCaffery, Margo, Ferrell, Betty R., and
gies to Overcome Barriers to Inadequate Turner, Martha. “Ethical Issues in the Use
Pain Manage-ment.” Presented to Nursing of Placebos in Cancer Pain Management.”
Practice Issues Committee, Maryland Board ONF (Ethical Issues). Vol. 23, No. 10.
of Nursing, September 1999. 1996. pp. 1587-1593.
2. Kaiser, Karen, RN, MS, Clyde, Chris, RN, 10. Fohr, Susan Anderson J.D., MA. “The
MS, Perrone, Margaret RN, BS, and Double Effect of Pain Medication:
Tarzian, Anita RN, Ph.D. “Overcoming Separating Myth from Reality.” Journal of
Barriers to Adequate Pain Management.” Palliative Medicine. Vol. 1, No. 4. 1998.
Presented to the Nursing Practice Issues pp. 315-328.
Committee, Maryland Board of Nursing, 11. Promotion of Comfort and Relief of Pain in
September, 1999. Dying. Position Statement - American
3. English, Nancy RN, Ph.D., Yocum, Cindy Nurses Association. Sept. 5, 1991.
RN, CRNH. “Guidelines for Curriculum 12. Forgoing Nutrition and Hydration. Position
Development on End-of-Life and Palliative Statement-American Nurses Association.
Care In Nursing.” Presented to National April 2, 1992.
Council of Hospice Professionals, National 13. Active Euthanasia. Position Statement-
Hospice Organizations, April 1997. American Nurses Association. December
4. Singer, Peter A., MD, MPH, FRCPC, 8, 1994.
Martin, Douglas K., and Merrijoy, Kelner, 14. Assisted Suicide. Position Statement-
Ph.D. “Quality End-of-Life Care: Patients’ American Nurses Association. December
Perspective.” JAMA. Vol. 281 No. 2. Jan. 8, 1994.
13, 1999. pp. 162-168. 15. Portnoy, Russell. “Morphine Infusions at
5. Conant, Loring and Lowney, Arlene. “The the End of Life: The Pitfalls in Reasoning
Role of Hospice Philosophy of Care in Non from Anecdote.” Journal of Palliative
Hospice Settings.” Journal of Law, Care. Vol. 12, No. 4. 1996. pp. 44-46.
Medicine and Ethics. Vol 24, #4. Winter 16. Mount Balfour. “Morphine Drips, Terminal
1996. pp 365-368. Sedation, and Slow Euthanasia: Definitions
6. Keay, Timothy, MD, M.A.-TH and and Facts, Not Anecdotes.” Journal of
Schonwetter, Ronald, MD. “Hospice Care Palliative Care. Vol. 112, No. 4 1996. pp.
in the Nursing Home.” American Family 31-37.
Physician. Vol. 57, No. 3. February 1, 17. “Peaceful Death: Recommended Compet-
1998. pp. 491-494. encies and Curricular Guidelines for End-
7. Cameron, Miriam E. “Completing Life and of-LifeNursing Care.” American
Dying Triumphantly.” Journal of Nursing Association of Colleges of Nursing, Robert
Law. Vol. 6, Issue 1. 1999. pp. 27-32. Wood Johnson Foundation, End-of-Life-
8. Arnstein, Paul, P.D., ARNP “Policy Care Roundtable. Nov. 11-12, 1997.
Statement: The Ordering and Administration 18. Joranson, David E. and Gilson, Aaron M.
of Placebos.” Distributed by the Mayday “Regulatory Barriers to Pain Management.”
Pain Resource Center. 1998. Seminars in Oncology Nursing. Vol. 14,
No 2. May 1998.
9
Pain Management Nursing Role/Core Competency
10
Pain Management Nursing Role/Core Competency
41. McPheeters, M., MPH and Lohr, K.N., l) Growth House News--www.growthouse
PhD., “Evidenced-Based Practice and org or www.pallcare.org/growth.htm
Nursing: Commentary.” Outcomes m) Wisconsin Educational Consortium on
Management for Nursing Practice. Vol. PainPolicy--www.medsch.wisc.edu/
13, No 2. July-September, 1999. p. 99. pain policy/ncjoint.htm.
42. Goode, Colleen J. “What Constitutes the 46. Standards and guidelines for pain
“Evidence in Evidence-Based Practice?”. management:
Applied Nursing Research. Vol. 13, No. 4. a)____, Management of Cancer Pain:
November 2000, p. 222-225. Adults. Clinical Practice Guidelines #9.
43. “Why Should Perioperative RNs Care About Quick Reference Guide for Clinicians.
Evidence-Based Practice?” (Research U.S. Department of Health and Human
Corner). AORN Journal. Vol. 72, No Services, Public Health Service, Agency
1. July 2000 pp. 109-111. for Health Care Policy and Research.
44. Stetler, Cheryl B. Ph.D, RN, FAAN, et al March, 1994.
“Evidence-Based Practice and the Role of b) ____, Principles of Analgesic Use in the
Nursing Leadership.” JONA. Vol 28, No. Treatment of Acute Pain and Cancer Pain,
7/8. July/August, 1998. pp. 45-53. 3rd Ed. American Pain Society. Skokie, Ill.
45. Web site addresses: c) ____, The Use of Opioids for the
a) National Guidelines Clearing House - Treatment of Chronic Pain. © 1997
www.mzch.gov AmericanAcademy of Pain Medicine and
b) Americans for Better Care of the Dying - American Pain Society. Glenview, Ill.
www.abcd-caring.com d) Ferrell, Betty Rolling P.d., FAAN and
c) American Pain Society- McCaffery, Margo, RN, MS, FAAN.
www.ampainsoc.org “Current Placebo Practice and Policy.”
d) American Society for Biothics and American Society of Pain Management
Humanities -www.asbh.org Nurses Pathways, Winter 1996. pp. 12-14.
e) Center for Ethics in Health Care - e) New JCAHO Standards: Intents,
www.ohsu.edu.ethics Examples, and Scoring Questions for Pain
f) Oncology Nursing Society - Assessment and Management in Hospitals.
www.ons.org May 1999.
g) Pain Link Home, A Pain Management f) ____, Acute Pain Management in Adults:
Resource - www.edc.org/painlink Operative Procedures. A Quick Reference
h) The American Alliance of Cancer Pain Guide for Clinicians. U.S. Department of
Initiative - Health and Human Services, Public Health
www.wisc.edu/trc/steony/steint/html Service, Agency for Health Care Policy and
i) Hospice Association of America- Research.
www.hospice.america.org g) ____, “The Management of Chronic Pain
j) Memorial Sloan - Kiltering Cancer in Older Adults.” American Geriatric
Center-www.mskcc.org Society’s Panel on Chronic Pain in Older
k) May Day Pain Link-City of Hope- Adults. Journal of The American Geriatric
www.city of hope.org/medinfo/ Society. Vol.46. 1998. pp. 635-651.
medresin.htm
11
Resources
Personal
1. Karen Kaiser, RN, MS, Clinical Practice 14. Bernadette Greene, RN, MS, Nursing
Coordinator, University of Maryland Medical Practice Issues Committee, Maryland
System, Baltimore, MD. Board of Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
2. Margaret Perrone, RN, CRNH, Program 15. Ann Triantafillos, RN, MSN, Nursing
Coordinator, Palliative Care Program, Practice Issues Committee, Maryland
University of Maryland Medical System, Board of Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
Baltimore, MD. 16. Sandra L. Dearholt, RN, MS, Nursing
3. Anita Tarzian, RN, PhD., Maryland Health Practice Issues Committee, Maryland
Care Ethics Committee Network, University Board of Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
of Maryland School of Law, Baltimore, MD. 17. Charlene A. Hall, LPN, Nursing Practice
4. Chris Clyde, RN, Nursing Coordinator, Issues Committee, Maryland Board of
University of Maryland Medical Systems Pain Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
Center, Baltimore, MD. 18. Carol F. Wynne, RN, MS, Nursing
5. Marilyn McCord, RN, Pulmonary Clinical Practice Issues Committee, Maryland
Specialist, Sinai Hospital, Baltimore, MD. Board of Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
6. Donna Hale, RN, MS, Consultant in 19. Marsha Hopkins, LPN, Nursing Practice
Perioperative/Pain Service/Sinai Joint Center, Issues Committee, Maryland Board of
Life Bridge Health Center, Baltimore, MD. Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
7. Veronica Noah, RN, IV Therapy-Pain 20. Laurie Miller, RN, BS, Nursing Practice
Management Team. Frederick Memorial Issues Committee, Maryland Board of
Hospital, Frederick, MD. Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
8. Mary Lou Perin, RN, MSN, Pain Management 21. Lou Williams, RN, Nursing Practice
Consultant. Pain Relief/USA. Middletown, Issues Committee, Maryland Board of
MD. Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
9. Lori KozlowskI, CRNP-P, Acute Pain 22. Susan Niewenhous, RN, MS, Nursing
Management Team. Johns Hopkins Hospital, Practice Issues Committee, Maryland
Baltimore, MD. Board of Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
10. Kathleen White, RN, PhD, Nursing Practice 23. Kathryn Offenbacher, RN, BSN,
Issues Committee, Maryland Board of Nursing Practice Issues Committee,
Nursing, Baltimore, MD. Maryland Board of Nursing, Baltimore,
11. Ann K. Sober, RN, BS, Nursing Practice MD.
Issues Committee, Maryland Board of 24. Chris Murphy, RN, BSN, Nursing
Nursing, Baltimore, MD. Practice Issues Committee, Maryland
12. Voncelia S. Brown RN, MS, Nursing Practice Board of Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
Issues Committee, Maryland Board of 25. Debbie Somerville, RN, MPH, Nursing
Nursing, Baltimore, MD. Practice Issues Committee, Maryland
13. Ralph Washington, RN, Nursing Practice Board of Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
Issues Committee, Maryland Board of
Nursing, Baltimore, MD.
12
13