Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
the Brown
FYS-zle
weather
Go unhemmed
t o d ay tomorrow
news...................2-5
Saving Sarah
inside
Arts........................6
editorial.............10 Surge in first-year Student-run magazine lets Brown students play
Opinions.............11 seminars fizzles at 74 fashionistas shine into Palin’s hands
SPORTS..................12 Campus news, 3 arts & CULTURE, 6 opinions, 11 43 / 19 48 / 34
2 Campus News The Brown Daily Herald
Monday, March 14, 2011
Today
calendar
March 14 ToMORROW March 15
Financial aid remains Committee
7 P.m.
“Suite Dating!” Roommate Social,
7:30 p.m.
Sex-Ed Kink Romantic Comedy,
constant for transfers formed to
8 p.m.
Petteruti Lounge
8 p.m.
Rights and Reason Theatre continued from page 1 2004 Herald article.
But in 2005, the Corporation
oversee
and more students returned from earmarked $400,000 for financial
Sex and Chocolate in the Dark,
South Wayland Lounge
ADOCH Volunteering Info Session,
Wilson Hall, Room 102
leave than expected, according
to Dean of the College Katherine
aid for transfer and resumed under-
graduate education students. Those
fundraising
Bergeron. funds were designed to support in-
fall one short of U.’s goal the committee, which will also
include President Ruth Simmons,
Chancellor Thomas Tisch ’76 and
By Elaine Kuckertz 23 course offerings and about 250 three to five other Corporation
Contributing Writer enrollments. members.
“There was a desire to create a According to Vascellaro, the
The 2008 Plan for Academic En- program that would make it pos- Committee on Development will
richment set a goal of offering 75 sible for first-years to have a more oversee fundraising efforts and
first-year seminars by 2010. As meaningful intellectual encounter develop strategies for future fund-
of the 2011 spring semester, the with faculty members in their first raising. King added that the com-
registrar’s office lists 74 first-year year at Brown,” said Dean of the mittee will also review fundraising
seminars on record. Despite be- College Katherine Bergeron. progress and report its findings
ing one course short of the goal, From 2003 to 2007, offerings to the Corporation at least once
Kathleen McSharry, associate dean leveled around 60. After a slight per year.
for writing and issues of chemical drop in course offerings in the With the recent end of the
dependency, said she is satisfied 2007-08 academic year, Bergeron, campaign, Vascellaro said the
with the current number of of- with the help of Professor of Phys- committee intends to ensure “a
Crossword ferings.
At the beginning of the 2010-
ics James Valles, then the associate
dean of the College for curriculum,
continuation of the momentum
and fundraising results of the cam-
11 academic year, the University renewed University Hall’s focus on paign.” He added that before the
had 76 courses on record, but Mc- the seminars. Bergeron and Valles campaign began, the University
Sharry said courses tend to “melt” encouraged faculty to apply for raised about $80 million in gifts
as professors’ schedules change. grants through the Curricular De- and pledges each year, but during
“Seventy-five is a target,” said velopment Grant program, placing the campaign, that number rose to
McSharry. “If we can say that from an emphasis on proposals for first- $200 million per year.
2008 to 2013, that we offered on year seminars. Bergeron called this Vascellaro called the new com-
average 75 offerings a year, and the process a “small incentive system.” mittee “a natural evolution from
offerings never fell below 70, then The following school year, of- the campaign.”
we’ve met our goal.” ferings rose from 56 to 74, as many The Campaign for Academic
The first-year seminar program as there still are. Enrichment Executive Committee,
began in 2002 as a way to “expand The success of the program “is including the president, chancel-
opportunities for student interac- a testament to the departments’ lor and three campaign co-chairs,
tion with faculty,” according to the commitment to first-year stu- decided to create a development
Plan for Academic Enrichment. committee at the Corporation lev-
In 2002, the program began with continued on page 5 el that would be established when
the campaign was over, King said.
Daily Herald
the Brown The campaign “set a standard
of excellence,” he said.
King and Vascellaro both said
www.browndailyherald.com another important duty of the
195 Angell St., Providence, R.I. Committee on Development will
Ben Schreckinger, President Matthew Burrows, Treasurer be to discuss the University’s fun-
Sydney Ember, Vice President Isha Gulati, Secretary draising priorities. King said the
The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serving the committee will ensure the Univer-
Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday through Friday sity’s institutional priorities deter-
during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during Commencement, once dur- mine the committee’s fundraising
ing Orientation and once in July by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Single copy free for
each member of the community.
priorities.
POSTMASTER please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI 02906. Vascellaro said the committee
Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. will work closely with the admin-
Subscription prices: $280 one year daily, $140 one semester daily. istration to establish these fund-
Copyright 2011 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved.
raising priorities and will work to
editorial Business
match specific donors to specific
(401) 351-3372 (401) 351-3360
herald@browndailyherald.com gm@browndailyherald.com
initiatives. The new engineering
school and the financial aid pro-
gram are two possible areas of
focus for the committee, he said.
Got tips? “I feel good that we will have
the leadership and support of this
herald@browndailyherald.com group,” said King, adding that fun-
draising is crucial for the future of
the University.
The Brown Daily Herald
Monday, March 14, 2011 Campus News 3
Higher ed by emma wohl Conference addresses immigration
news roundup senior staff writer
By Kristina Klara Kai of the Ministers Alliance. He Nasser Zawia, dean of the
Staff Writer recounted his own experiences as graduate school at the University
Lafayette students to cross into N. Korea an immigrant and described how of Rhode Island, who is Yemeni,
Five days after University research- hurt he felt when called an “alien.” spoke from the perspective of a
Lafayette College in Pennsylvania may be the first American ers released a poll showing public “They said ‘illegal alien,’” Kai Muslim immigrant, saying Mus-
university to offer a for-credit study-abroad program in North Korea division over immigration issues, said. The term angered and con- lims in the United States were par-
this summer. academic and policy leaders met fused him at first, “but then I didn’t ticularly affected after the Sept.
The program is being organized through the P’yongyang Project, for a conference entitled “Policy feel so bad because we were all 11 attacks.
a non-profit based out of Beijing that has run trips to North Korea and Demographics in Rhode Is- aliens — some of us were legal and “What some crazy lunatic did
since 2009. land: A Symposium on Immigrants some were illegal.” somewhere, I suddenly am re-
The U.S. government has issued a warning for citizens traveling and Immigration in the State” Sat- Molly Soum from the Gen- sponsible for,” said Zawia, adding
abroad in North Korea. “U.S. citizens crossing into North Korea urday in MacMillan 117, adding esis Center in Providence, who that many innocent people were
without proper documentation, even accidentally, have been subject a human face to the hard data of is Cambodian, spoke from the “rounded up” and held after the
to arrest and long-term detention,” reads the warning. The U.S. does the poll. perspective of a Southeast Asian 2001 attacks.
not have diplomatic or consular relations with the North Korean “We invited community lead- immigrant. Overall, the panel encouraged
government. ers and public officials to come “It’s not that we chose to come more community involvement and
The Lafayette program would be a two-and-a-half-week trip to to Brown to have a discussion on here — it’s that we were brought aid for immigrants.
China, North Korea and South Korea to study cultural interactions immigration based on hard data — here,” Soum said. “We aren’t here State Sen. Juan Pichardo, D-
between the three countries. It was organized by Lafayette Assistant the poll,” said Marion Orr, director to squeak the wheel.” Providence, encouraged Rhode
Professor of Anthropology Allison Alexy, who will co-lead the trip. of the Taubman Center for Public Soum said she sees herself and Island residents to “help all im-
The students would be under a number of security measures Policy and American Institutions, others as giving a voice to immi- migrants, whether they’re here
from both the program and the North Korean government. which conducted the poll. grants. “I’m speaking for the un- undocumented or not.”
Restrictions would prevent them from taking photographs, President Ruth Simmons speakable, the people who can’t “It is in our best interest to be
publishing articles, leaving the group without permission and opened the conference with an speak for themselves,” she said. mentors,” he added.
traveling anywhere without a North Korean staff person. address to an audience of about
The trip is structured in such a way that the North Korean 60 students and community mem-
portion could be canceled if any risks arise, Alexy said. The program bers. Thomas Tobin, bishop of the
organizers have also made arrangements for emergency charter Roman Catholic diocese of Provi-
flights in case they need to evacuate, she added. dence, was the keynote speaker.
There have not been any security issues with the P’yongyang Afterward, the results of the
Project’s past trips, project director and co-founder Matthew Reichel survey were presented by Orr and
’09 told Inside Higher Ed. There should not be problems “as long as Alexandra Filindra, a postdoctoral
you go in legally,” he added. research associate in public policy.
“Everything that we do is sanctioned by the Koreans,” he said. The poll surveyed the views of 508
Rhode Island residents about im-
Penn State may close branch campuses migration. The results showed that
Rhode Islanders were divided on
Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett proposed cutting funding to issues of immigration and as-
higher education in half in a budget address last Tuesday. similation. But a majority favored
The plan, which would cut $211 million to the state-owned providing education to immigrant
institutions for next year, would be the largest one-time percentage children, whether documented or
decrease to higher education in history, according to the American not.
Association of State Colleges and Universities. The event was sponsored by
Corbett called the measure “a reality-based budget.” Pennsylvania the Taubman Center, the Bill and
has a $4 billion deficit for the 2011-12 fiscal year. Melinda Gates Foundation and the
John Cavanaugh, chancellor of the Pennsylvania State System of Rhode Island Foundation, among
Higher Education, told the Chronicle of Higher Education he plans to others.
make up for the decreased funding by trimming the system’s budget Two panels — one of com-
and looking for other sources of funding while at the same time munity leaders and another of
lobbying the General Assembly to restore some of the funds. academics — answered questions
The deficit will not simply be made up by increases to student regarding immigration.
tuition, Cavanaugh added. All of the community leaders
At Penn State, the budget cut would reduce the state’s had personal connections to im-
contribution to the school’s budget from 8 to 4 percent. With such migration issues.
a small input from the state, some have suggested privatizing the “Some people have given me
university. the title of troublemaker or com-
But Donald Heller, director of the Center for the Study of Higher munity organizer — same thing,”
Education at Penn State, said the state’s $165 million contribution for said immigration attorney Roberto
the next fiscal year would not be “insignificant.” Gonzalez, who has defended im-
Penn State currently has nearly two dozen campuses across the migrants facing deportation.
state. Campus closures are a “significant possibility” if the budget “Providence is 65 percent mi-
cuts persist, said Graham Spanier, the university’s president. nority,” said Reverend Matthew
Researchers present
Clerestory, which was named af- about the integration of disciplines,” Because there is no department for
ter a type of architectural window, is said MariaLisa Itzoe ’12, president South Asian studies concentrators,
the oldest literary journal on campus. of the Brown chapter. Each edition Awaaz, the South Asian Journal of
With each publication, the magazine
searches out a variety of aesthetics.
There is no thematic criteria for sub-
includes pieces written by Brown
students and those written by their
international peers. Recent editions
Arts, seeks to connect both concen-
trators and writers to those interested
in the field, said co-editor Manasa
new OCD treatment
By DAniel Jeon Because researchers are still re-
fining the techniques of deep brain
Ivy schools reinstate early action
Contributing Writer
stimulation, there have been mixed
A team of researchers presented feelings from the general public
an innovative method for treating regarding its safety and ethical im-
By Jamie Brew Number of early applicants to Brown by obsessive-compulsive disorder called plications. Ethicists have expressed
Contributing Writer deep brain stimulation at the annual concern that the research should not
class year meeting of the American Association have received a Humanitarian Device
Harvard and Princeton will al- for the Advancement of Science Feb. Exemption grant — which provides
low prospective students to apply 18. The team shared the technique approval to implant electrodes in a
through non-binding early action and results of their ongoing research, patient’s body — because they say the
programs beginning this fall, the which began more than 10 years ago. success rate is not high enough. Ras-
two schools announced Feb. 24. OCD “is a disorder characterized mussen said that the ethicists doubt
Both schools cancelled their early by intrusive thoughts,” said Nicole whether deep brain stimulation has
action and early decision programs McLaughlin, assistant professor of been studied well enough to be fully
in 2006 in favor of single rounds of psychiatry and human behavior implemented for patients suffering
admissions in the spring. and a member of the research team, from OCD. But, Rasmussen added,
The single-admission policy adding that these thoughts are often “if it was your family member who
was meant to give equal consider- caused by anxiety. An extreme case was suffering from this, wouldn’t
ation to “excellent students from a of the disorder — which can range you want the option of having the
broad array of backgrounds,” said from mild to severe — is defined as treatment?”
Princeton President Shirley Tilgh- “when something basically gets in Rasmussen and McLaughlin
man in a Feb. 24 press release. By the way of life,” she said. both said a national registry is vi-
eliminating the early action option, If medication and behavioral tal for the sake of the future of deep
the schools mitigated the advantage therapy have failed in these severe brain stimulation. A registry would
of students who were familiar with cases, deep brain stimulation can help to collect data from every-
the college application process or help. Originally used for movement one who performs these surgeries
who went to schools with strong disorders like Parkinson’s disease, across the country, and “hopefully
admissions advisory programs. deep brain stimulation can now be this could help inform us and also
Katie Wilson / Herald
“In eliminating our early pro- used to treat OCD. inform potentially other forms of
gram four years ago, we hoped oth- sider. Princeton and Yale will now be During deep brain stimulation, anxiety treatments and those kind
er colleges and universities would Because many factors influ- the only ones to offer non-binding doctors insert electrodes under the of things,” McLaughlin said. “If we
do the same, and they haven’t,” Til- ence trends in applications, it is early action programs. All others, skin that send impulses to correct understand how these kinds of sur-
ghman said in the release. “One hard to tell how strongly Harvard including Brown, have binding problems in the brain. These elec- geries can make OCD better, then
consequence is that some students and Princeton’s policies on early early-decision programs, which trodes stimulate specific parts of we may also be able to find other
who really want to make their col- admissions affect Brown’s admis- require applicants to attend if ac- the brain — for example, those that techniques we could use on a larger
lege decision as early as possible sions, wrote Dean of Admission cepted. play a role in obsessive thoughts. OCD population.”
in their senior year apply to other James Miller ’73 in an e-mail to Early decision programs “tend McLaughlin said the stimulation “The more systematic data we col-
schools early, even if their first The Herald. to provide more certainty for the helps to increase mood and decrease lect, the better off we are in knowing
choice is Princeton.” “We did not see an increase college in terms of constructing general anxiety. In combination with what’s going to help and what’s not
With the exception of the Uni- in our early decision pool when an incoming class, while giving medication and behavioral therapy, going to help,” Rasmussen said.
versity of Virginia, which adopted Harvard and Princeton dropped students the chance to declare the stimulation has been success- Both researchers expressed hope
a single admission system in 2007 their early programs, so it is hard to and commit themselves to a very ful in about 70 percent of cases, ac- for the future of deep brain stimula-
only to switch back last year, no predict that we will see a decrease clear first choice institution,” Miller cording to Steven Rasmussen P’13, tion and said they believe that, with
other schools followed Harvard as they reinstate their programs,” wrote. “At this time, we have no who led the research with Benjamin further research, the stimulation can
and Princeton’s lead, causing the Miller wrote. plans to move to a single choice Greenberg, both associate professors be used in more effective and system-
two Ivy League schools to recon- Of the eight Ivies, Harvard, early action program.” of psychiatry and human behavior. atic methods.
The Brown Daily Herald
Monday, March 14, 2011 Campus News 5
Students studying in Japan safe after earthquake Seminar
offerings
continued from page 1 four years and has also lived in the
northeastern Miyagi Prefecture
Accounts from abroad near the earthquake’s epicenter.
Nine students are planning to Smith is currently working on a
study abroad in Japan this semes-
ter, though only three students are
there now due to the start time of
book about the Kanto Earthquake
of 1923 that hit Tokyo.
This active earthquake pattern
fall short
their term, according to the press has contributed to the strict build- continued from page 2
release. ing codes in Japan that McClain
Alec Brownridge ’12, an East credited with dimishing the dam- dents,” McSharry said. “Depart-
Asian studies concentrator study- age inflicted by the earthquake. ments do their very best to provide
ing through the Kyoto Consortium “Japanese building codes, in re- first-year seminars.”
for Japanese Studies at Doshisha gards to anti-earthquake construc- Professor of Geological Sci-
University, said the natural disas- tion, are among the toughest in ences Reid Cooper said he began
ters did not affect students at the the world, if not the toughest,” he teaching GEOL 0160F: “Patterns:
university because Kyoto is an in- wrote. in Nature, in Society” in 2005, after
land region, though media cover- Kasindorf-Mantaring wrote feeling a “push” from the deans.
age of the disaster has been exten- that the 1995 Hanshin earthquake But, after teaching it for several
sive. Helen Diagama ’12 and Tyler spurred efforts to increase the in- years, Cooper found the courses
Kasindorf-Mantaring ’12 are also tegrity of Japanese homes. “I be- valuable to both him and his stu-
studying through the consortium. lieve Japan averted more deaths, es- dents. He said he enjoyed the semi-
U.S. Navy
Kasindorf-Mantaring wrote in pecially in the metropolitan Tokyo nar so much that he is interested
A professor teaching in Kyoto and three students studying abroad there are
an e-mail to The Herald that he all safe after Friday’s earthquake and tsunami. area, with its airtight infrastructure in creating another “field-trip in-
first heard about the earthquake and strict building codes,” he wrote. tensive” first-year seminar on the
when his parents called him Fri- Relief efforts largely turned away, according to “There’s no place that’s earth- natural history of Rhode Island.
day. Though Brownridge said his Brownridge said he hopes to get Smith. quake-proof,” Smith said, though David Caianiello ’14 took
area was not affected, he said his involved in relief efforts in the up- It is difficult to know how exten- he added that Japan has a “good CHEM 0080B: “Molecular Struc-
homestay family was concerned coming weeks, but noted that right sive the devastation will be when all sense of what to expect under pre- tures in Chemistry and Biology”
about their friend in Tokyo who now, relief is much more focused is said and done, McClain wrote, dictable conditions.” last semester. Caianiello said he
had to evacuate her seventh floor on immediate rescue missions and since the country is still in the “We’re used to experiencing benefited from the intimate class
apartment as aftershocks reached evacuations. midst of early relief efforts in the little earthquakes here or there,” setting, which helped first-years
the city. The Japanese Cultural Associa- hardest-hit regions where com- said Yamamoto, who is from an learn how to study in a college
James McClain, a professor of tion will organize a charity event munication has been essentially area near Tokyo. setting and allowed for produc-
history who is on leave this aca- set tentatively for March 21, Ya- severed. Because of the damage inflicted tive discussion. He called it a “re-
demic year to teach at the Kyoto mamoto said. They will also col- But he added that the dam- by the earthquake and tsunami, ally good eye-opener for being a
Consortium, wrote in an e-mail lect money in J. Walter Wilson age may be severe. “The Japanese several nuclear reactors located freshman.”
to The Herald that CNN coverage and attract other cultural groups prime minister, a person not given near Tokyo are in danger of leak- Additionally, Caianiello formed
of the earthquake and tsunami ap- to perform. to exaggeration, said that this is the ing radiation. McClain wrote that a strong relationship with Profes-
pears “needlessly alarming” thus Kerry Smith, chair of the East worst disaster to strike Japan since the Japanese rely on these power sor of Chemisty Paul Williard,
far. But Japanese media coverage Asian Studies Department and as- World War II,” he wrote. “Indeed, sources for one-third of their elec- who taught the class, which led
of the tsunami appears “dispassion- sociate professor of history, said to me, some of the scenes of the trical energy, and these reactors are him to pursue an Undergraduate
ately objective,” he wrote. he believes a comparison will be damaged cities bear an eerie re- mostly concentrated in areas at risk Teaching and Research Award with
Jack Boeglin ’12, who plans to drawn between national relief ef- semblance to the Japanese cities de- for earthquakes. Williard.
leave March 21 to study abroad at forts today and the response to the stroyed by American fire-bombing “The Japanese themselves have McSharry said she is optimistic
Keio University in Tokyo, said the 1995 Hanshin earthquake in Kobe, in WWII.” long debated the wisdom of fol- about the future of the program.
program has not contacted him to Japan. “The response appears to lowing such an energy policy,” he As of right now, 81 first-year semi-
suggest any changes to the plan. be much better organized,” Smith Historical perspective and wrote, adding that “many — re- nars have been proposed for the
While Tokyo was not the most said, adding that aid appears to be preparation membering that the Japanese are 2011-12 academic year. “I’d be sur-
severely affected, Boeglin said he moving at a “relatively quick pace.” The earthquake occurred in a the only persons who have experi- prised if we had 81,” McSharry
knows a host family who felt the Plans may also be in place to region known over the last 150 enced an atomic bombing — have said. “But it’s a solid number to
shocks from the quake. accept external aid if necessary, years for volatile seismic activity, been deeply apprehensive about the have at this point, so I’m confident
though in 1995, outside aid was said Smith, who lived in Tokyo for accidental release of radioactivity.” that we’ll have at least 75.”
6 Arts & Culture The Brown Daily Herald
Monday, March 14, 2011
League
trying to find a home. But thanks to since.
ongoing NFL labor disagreements, But of the four, the most un-
Sewall said he has received less in- conventional route to the NFL was
continued from page 12 terest than he hoped. Develin’s.
“With this (collective bargain- “I went through the (Arena
utes later, allowing the Tigers to ing agreement) issue comes com- Football League) and (United Foot-
maintain a commanding 10-goal plications for guys like me who ball League) and even changed my
lead. Hudgins and McGilloway don’t have a team because teams position to make it to the NFL,” said
struck again, but the Tigers qui- are reluctant to sign anybody in the defensive tackle-turned-full-
eted the Bears’ offensive surges. case there is a lockout,” Sewall said. back. “The process really humbled
“I don’t think anyone was hap- “The best thing I can do, though, me and showed me how much work
py with our performance,” Water- is keep working hard, keep staying it takes. It helped me appreciate
man said. “Everybody wanted to in shape and go out there and show Cincinnati’s offer more once I fi-
step up and make big plays, but the teams that are giving me tryouts nally got it.”
instead of staying as a cohesive what I’ve got to offer.” The day after Develin’s United
unit and doing the things we Still, Sewall said he remains op- Football League team, the Florida
normally do, we kind of got in timistic. Tuskers, lost in the championship
a stink.” If an agreement is reached, “I game in late November, Develin
Though the first loss in Ivy definitely think I can sign some- was called for a tryout with the
League play stung, the team where,” he said. “I’ve just got to keep Bengals.
Herald file photo
aims to take the same positive working my butt off.” Though Farnham was undrafted
Bobby Sewall ’10 (above) was on the Titans’ practice squad with David Howard
approach to Wednesday’s home Howard was in a similar posi- out of Brown, his path to the NFL
’09.5 this fall. Sewall was cut but is hoping to get re-signed for next season.
game at 5 p.m. against Holy Cross tion after he was cut by the Titans has been the simplest. After receiv-
(1-6). in September, despite being selected ing a tryout from his hometown practice squad player of the week “Buddy’s living the life,” Develin
“We had a great game plan go- by the team in the seventh round New England Patriots in the sum- leading up to New England’s Week said.
ing into (the Princeton game),” of the 2010 NFL Draft. But How- mer, Farnham was cut by the team 17 showdown against the Miami “He’s playing for the team he
Waterman said. “And we know ard then impressed coaches for the only to be resigned several weeks Dolphins. He remains on the team’s rooted for growing up after playing
that we need to stick to the game Oakland Raiders, a team that had later. He went on to make the Pa- active practice squad roster and said for the college he rooted for grow-
plan and do what we know how shown pre-draft interest in him. triots’ practice squad and was also he hopes to earn a spot on the game ing up,” Develin added. “He’s just
to do.” The team offered him a spot on its recognized by his coaches as the squad next year. living every kid’s dream.”
Teacher layoffs no
reason to villify Taveras
To the Editor: that teachers must be notified of any
change in their status by March 1. If
I read the opinion piece on not for that law, Brady claims, “no
teachers by Chris Norris-LeBlanc teacher would have received dis-
’13 (“Who needs teachers anyway?” missal notices” when they did. As
March 8) with dismay. By failing to for protecting teachers, would it have
make distinctions or provide con- been preferable to hastily cut loose
text for his comparison of Rhode a number of teachers simply on the Dot Comic | Eshan Mitra and Brendan Hainline
Island with Wisconsin and New basis of their standing, whether ra-
Jersey, Norris-LeBlanc could put tionalized by protecting those with
Mayor Angel Taveras and Scott seniority or by firing the most highly
Walker in the same union-busting paid, regardless of the specifics of
camp. Providence is in deep eco- training and performance? Where’s
nomic trouble, and Taveras, known the solidarity in that?
to be supportive of unions, has made The story of Providence’s teacher
public his intention to fire as many layoffs is much more complicated
highly paid city administrators as than Norris-LeBlanc’s ideological,
he can — he has taken a 10 percent rhetorically charged representa-
pay cut himself — so as to rehire as tion suggests. I support unions and
many teachers and shut down as few teachers. And there’s a world of
schools as possible. difference between the actions of
Taveras did not, as Norris-LeB- Taveras and those of Walker.
lanc contends, launch “a full-fledged
attack on teachers” or any other gov- Denise Davis
Got something to say?
ernment workers, nor is there any
evidence for the claim that he is “sit-
ting atop … stacks of money.” Super-
Visiting Instructor in Gender
and Sexuality Studies and
Managing Editor, Differences:
Leave a comment online!
intendent Tom Brady explained in A Journal of Feminist Cultural
an open letter that dismissing teach- Studies at the Pembroke Center
Visit www.browndailyherald.com to comment on
ers was a decision “of last resort” for Teaching and Research on opinion and editorial content.
necessitated by a state law stipulating Women
10 Editorial The Brown Daily Herald
Monday, March 14, 2011
Editorials are written by The Herald’s editorial page board. Send comments
to editorials@browndailyherald.com.
quote of the day
“Positive body image is about feeling sexy whoever
t h e b r ow n da i ly h e r a l d
Editors-in-Chief
Sydney Ember
Deputy Managing Editors
Brigitta Greene
Senior Editors
Dan Alexander
you are and at whatever stage you’re at in your life. ”
Ben Schreckinger Anne Speyer Nicole Friedman —Shanna Katz, sexuality educator
Julien Ouellet
editorial Business See sex on page 6.
Kristina Fazzalaro Arts & Culture Editor General Managers Office Manager
Luisa Robledo Arts & Culture Editor Matthew Burrows Shawn Reilly
Rebecca Ballhaus City & State Editor Isha Gulati
Claire Peracchio City & State Editor
Directors
Talia Kagan Features Editor
Aditi Bhatia Sales
Hannah Moser Features Editor
Danielle Marshak Finance
Alex Bell News Editor
Margot Grinberg Alumni Relations
Nicole Boucher News Editor
Lisa Berlin Special Projects
Tony Bakshi Sports Editor
Ashley McDonnell Sports Editor Managers
Ethan McCoy Asst. Sports Editor Hao Tran National Sales
Tyler Rosenbaum Editorial Page Editor Alec Kacew University Department Sales
Hunter Fast Opinions Editor Siena deLisser University Student Group Sales
Michael Fitzpatrick Opinions Editor Valery Scholem Recruiter Sales
C O R R E C T I O N S P olicy
Jared Davis Sales and Communications
Graphics & Photos Lauren Bosso Business Operations The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Corrections may be
Abe Pressman Graphics Editor Emily Zheng Business Analytics submitted up to seven calendar days after publication.
Alex Yuly Graphics Editor Nikita Khadloya Alumni Engagement C ommentary P O L I C Y
Stephanie London Photo Editor James Eng Special Projects
Hilary Rosenthal Photo Editor The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily reflect the views of
Arjun Vaidya Special Projects
Nick Sinnott-Armstrong Photo Editor The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only.
Webber Xu Special Projects
Jonathan Bateman Sports Photo Editor L etters to the E ditor P olicy
Post- magazine Send letters to letters@browndailyherald.com. Include a telephone number with all letters. The Herald reserves the right to edit all letters for length and clarity
Production
Kate Doyle Editor-in-Chief
Dan Towne Copy Desk Chief and cannot assure the publication of any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may request anonymity, but no letter will
Gili Kliger Design Editor BLOG DAILY HERALD be printed if the author’s identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements of events will not be printed.
Anna Migliaccio Design Editor David Winer Editor-in-Chief
advertising P olicy
Katie Wilson Design Editor Matt Klimerman Managing Editor
The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.
The Brown Daily Herald
Monday, March 14, 2011 Opinions 11
Sarah Palin: created at Brown
Standing up for the rights of neglected make any concessions to the military and Brown community is for the very forces
groups is admirable. What is not admira- instead demonize our armed forces. For that protect this freedom. This ungrate-
By Oliver Rosenbloom ble is Brown’s refusal to engage with other these critics, steadfastness in relation to fulness stems from our inability to engage
Americans who do not share Brown’s lib- narrow social concerns gives the impres- with those who do not share our socially
Opinions Columnist eral ideology. sion of an anti-military, anti-American liberal worldview.
In terms of cultural beliefs, our mili- worldview. I would never vote for Sarah Palin. But I
tary will never be the socially liberal in- Palin also argues that many elite lib- believe that her anti-intellectual populism
As the race for the Republican presidential stitution that Brown is. By eliminating any erals and intellectuals are ungrateful for carries an unfortunate amount of truth,
nomination begins in earnest, Sarah Palin military presence from campus, Brown the real sacrifices that previous genera- especially when applied to Brown. Elite
will receive even more publicity than she students show that issues of national se- tions of Americans have made to guaran- liberal institutions often are out of touch
normally does. Liberal intellectuals will curity and duty to country are of relative- tee our freedom. Again, this critique per- with the beliefs of the majority of Ameri-
continue to dismiss her as an ignorant ly little importance when compared to fectly applies to Brown’s ROTC debate. In cans. Instead of offering general support
country bumpkin. This anti-Palin rheto- Brown’s extreme form of social liberalism. the rush to identify discrimination in the to our country, they prioritize narrow so-
ric will be just as intense at Brown, where cial agendas and dismiss all of those who
Palin certainly is not a popular figure. Her do not share their form of social liberal-
nomination would be a disaster for many ism. Similarly, elite intellectuals neglect to
Brown students. show proper gratitude and support to the
It is therefore ironic that Sarah Palin
By deifying extreme social liberalism and neglecting armed forces who fight and die for their
was in fact created at Brown. More pre- duty to, and love of, country, Brown provides an easy academic freedom. In the debate over
cisely, her anti-elitist and anti-intellec- ROTC, Brown has shown all of these re-
tual rhetoric appeals to so many Ameri- target for Palin’s brand of conservative populism. grettable qualities of elite liberal opinion.
cans because elite liberal colleges, includ- I doubt that any Brown students will al-
ing Brown, play right into her hands. By ter their positions to appease Sarah Palin.
deifying extreme social liberalism and But they should be aware that their arro-
neglecting duty to, and love of, country, Neglecting to support the military fu- armed forces, ROTC critics conveniently gant and dismissive form of liberalism only
Brown provides an easy target for Palin’s els Sarah Palin’s anti-elitist and anti-in- overlook the fact that the U.S. Army is the makes Palin more popular. By disrespect-
brand of conservative populism. tellectual populism. A common theme of force most responsible for guaranteeing ing our armed forces and refusing to en-
The debate about the Reserve Officers’ Palin’s rhetoric is that some Americans are all of the freedoms we hold so dear. gage with those who do not share their so-
Training Corps serves as a perfect example ashamed of their country. These Ameri- Brown students enjoy unprecedented cial values, these critics have set themselves
of how the Brown community needlessly cans pursue a narrow agenda of grievance academic, sexual and personal freedom. apart from all but the most socially liber-
alienates conservative Americans. Even politics and overlook the strengths of our Historically, this freedom did not instant- al Americans. In doing so, they have im-
after the repeal of “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell,” country and the sacrifices of our armed ly appear at the request of socially liberal proved the electoral prospects of Sarah Pal-
the Brown community continues to search forces. reformers. It developed through the com- in and every other conservative populist.
for reasons to ban the military from cam- This description fits Brown perfectly bined work of politicians, private citizens
pus. These rationales for banning the mil- when applied to the ROTC debate. ROTC and our armed forces. Even today, we only
itary continue to move further left along critics refuse to consider the strengths of enjoy our freedom because brave young Oliver Rosenbloom ’13 is a history
the spectrum of social liberalism. our military and only dwell on its social men and women are willing to risk their concentrator from Mill Valley, Calif.
Brown students do not deserve criti- conservatism. In their quest to spread lives for it. Demonizing the army and He can be reached at
cism for their extreme social liberalism. their liberal worldview, they refuse to banning ROTC shows how ungrateful the oliver_rosenbloom@brown.edu.
M. Lacrosse