Sei sulla pagina 1di 5

CASES

CASE 13
HEINEKEN*
Dutch brewer Heineken was expanding its presence around At the same time, Heineken has maintained its leading
the globe in response to the merger of Anheuser-Busch InBev position across Europe. It had made a high-profile acquisi-
with SABMiller, which would give the combined firm a tion in 2008 of Scottish-based brewer Scottish & Newcastle,
commanding 30 percent of global beer sales. On March 19, the brewer of well-known brands such as Newcastle Brown
2019, it opened its first Mozambique brewery in the pres- Ale and Kronenbourg 1664. Although the purchase had
ence of His Excellency Filipe Nyusi, the President of the been made in partnership with Carlsberg, Heineken was
Republic of Mozambique. The new brewery, incorporating able to gain control of the Scottish & Newcastle’s opera-
the latest technologies, represents a $100 million invest- tions in several crucial European markets such as the
ment. Among its products will be Txilar, a local beer spe- United Kingdom, Ireland, Portugal, Finland, and Belgium.
cifically made with a maize that is grown in the region. These decisions to acquire brewers that operate in dif-
“The construction of Heineken’s first brewery is a major ferent parts of the world have been a part of a series of
step for the company’s presence in the country,” said Jean- changes that the Dutch brewer has been making to raise
Francois van Boxmeer, CEO of the firm.1 its stature in the various markets and respond to growing
The move comes on the heels of acquisitions and capac- consolidation within the industry and changes occurring
ity investments that Heineken has been making in other in the global market for beer. Even as sales of beer have
developing markets. In 2013, the firm had strengthened its stagnated in the United States and Europe, demand has
position as the world’s third largest brewer by taking full been growing in other developing countries. This has led
ownership of Asian Pacific Breweries, the owner of Tiger, the largest brewers to expand across the globe through ac-
Bintang, and other popular Asian beer brands. With this quisitions of smaller regional and national players (see
deal, Heineken added 30 breweries across several countries Exhibits 1 and 2).
in the Asia Pacific region. A few years earlier, the firm had The need for change was clearly reflected in the appoint-
acquired Mexican brewer FEMSA Cervesa, producer of ment in October 2005 of Jean-Francois van Boxmeer as
Dos Equis, Sol, and Tecate beers, to become a stronger, Heineken’s first non-Dutch CEO. He was brought in to re-
more competitive player in Latin America. place Anthony Ruys, who had decided to resign because of
his failure to improve performance. Prior to the appoint-
ment of Ruys in 2002, Heineken had been run by three gen-
* Case prepared by Jamal Shamsie, Michigan State University, with the
assistance of Professor Alan B. Eisner, Pace University. Material has been
erations of Heineken ancestors whose portraits still adorn
drawn from published sources to be used for purposes of class discussion. the dark paneled office of the CEO in its Amsterdam head-
Copyright © 2019 Jamal Shamsie and Alan B. Eisner. quarters. Like Ruys, van Boxmeer has tried to handle the

EXHIBIT 1
Income Statement 2018 2017 2016 2015
(millions of euros) Total Revenue 22,471 21,888 20,792 20,511
Operating Profit 3,062 3,276 2,709 2,664
Net Income 1,903 1,935 1,540 1,892

Source: Heineken.

EXHIBIT 2
Balance Sheet (millions 2018 2017 2016 2015
of euros) Assets 41,956 41,034 39,321 37,714
Liabilities 26,416 26,513 24,748 22,664
Equity 15,540 14,521 14,573 15,050

Source: Heineken.

C76 CASE 13 :: HEINEKEN

Strategic Management: Text and


Cases
challenge of preserving the firm’s family-driven traditions, evolved into one of the world’s largest brewers, operating
while addressing threats that have never been faced before. more than 190 breweries in over 70 countries in the world,
claiming about 10 percent of the global market for beer (see
Confronting a Globalizing Industry Exhibits 3 & 4).
Heineken was one of the pioneers of an international strat- In fact, the firm’s flagship Heineken brand ranked sec-
egy, using cross-border deals to expand its distribution of its ond only to Budweiser in a global brand survey jointly un-
Heineken, Amstel, or about 300 other beer brands in more dertaken by BusinessWeek and Interbrand several years
than 100 countries around the globe. For years, it has been ago. The premier brand has achieved worldwide recognition
picking up small brewers from several countries to add according to Kevin Baker, director of alcoholic beverages at
more brands and to obtain better access to new markets. British market researcher Canadean Ltd. A U.S. wholesaler
From its roots on the outskirts of Amsterdam, the firm has recently asked a group of marketing students to identify an

EXHIBIT 3
2018 2017 2016 2015
Geographical
Western Europe 10,348 9,990 10,112 10,227 Breakdown of Sales
(millions of euros)
Americas 6,781 6,312 5,203 5,159
Africa, Middle East, & Eastern Europe 3,051 3,028 3,203 3,263
Asia Pacific 2,919 2,922 2,894 2,483
Source: Heineken.

EXHIBIT 4
Markets Brands
Significant Heineken
United States Heineken, Amstel Light, Paulaner,1 Moretti, Lagunitas Brands In Various
Markets
Netherlands Heineken, Amstel, Lingen’s Blond, Murphy’s Irish Red
France Heineken, Amstel, Buckler,2 Desperados3
Italy Heineken, Amstel, Birra Moretti
Spain Heineken, Amstel, Cruzcampo, Buckler
Poland Heineken, Krolewskie, Kujawiak, Zywiec
China Heineken, Tiger, Reeb*
Singapore Heineken, Tiger, Anchor, Baron’s
India Heineken, Arlem, Kingfisher
Indonesia Heineken, Bintang, Guinness
Kazakhstan Heineken, Amstel, Tian Shan
Egypt Heineken, Birell, Meister, Fayrouz2
Israel Heineken, Maccabee, Gold Star*
Nigeria Heineken, Star, Maltina, Gulder
South Africa Heineken, Amstel, Windhoek. Strongbow
Panama Heineken, Soberana, Crystal, Panama
Chile Heineken, Cristal, Escudo, Royal

*Minority interest
1
Wheat beer
2
Nonalcoholic beer
3
Tequila-flavored beer

Source: Heineken.

CASE 13 :: HEINEKEN C77

Strategic Management: Text and


Cases
EXHIBIT 5
Brewers Market Share
Leading Global
Brewers (2016 market 1. Anheuser-Busch InBev (ABI), Leuven, Belgium (incl. SABMiller) 27.3
share percentage
based on annual sales, 2. Heineken, Amsterdam, Netherlands 9.7
millions of U.S. dollars)
3. China Resources Enterprise, China 6.1
4. Carlsberg, Copenhagen, Denmark 5.9
5. Molson Coors 4.9

Source: Statista.

assortment of beer bottles that had been stripped of their that would be difficult to change. Even with the appoint-
labels. The stubby green Heineken container was the only ment of non-family members to manage the firm, a little
one that incited instant recognition among the group. over half of the shares of Heineken are still owned by a
But the beer industry has been undergoing significant holding company that is controlled by the family. With the
change due to a furious wave of consolidation. Most of the death of Freddy Heineken in 2002, the last family member
bigger brewers have begun to acquire or merge with their to head the Dutch brewer, control has passed to his only
competitors in foreign markets in order to become global child and heir, Charlene de Carvalho, who has insisted on
players. This has given them ownership of local brands, pro- having a say in all of the major decisions.
pelling them into a dominant position in various markets But the family members were behind some of changes
around the world. In addition, acquisitions of foreign brew- that were announced at the time of van Boxmeer’s appoint-
ers can provide the firm with the manufacturing and distri- ment. These were intended to support Heineken’s next
bution capabilities they could use to develop a few global phase of growth as a global organization. As part of the
brands. “The era of global brands is coming,” Alan Clark, a plan, dubbed Fit 2 Fight, the Executive Board was cut down
Budapest-based managing director of SABMiller Europe from five members to CEO van Boxmeer and Chief Finan-
stated some years ago (see Exhibit 5).2 cial Officer Rene Hooft Graafland. The change was ex-
Since 2000, South African Breweries, Ltd, acquired U.S.- pected to centralize control at the top so that the firm can
based Miller Brewing to become a major global brewer. They formulate a strategy that it should follow to win over
subsequently acquired Fosters, the largest Australian brewer. younger customers across different markets whose tastes
U.S.-based Coors linked with Canadian-based Molson in are still developing.
2005, rising to a leading position among the world’s biggest Heineken has also created management positions that
brewers with their combined operations. In 2008, Belgium’s would be responsible for five different operating regions
Interbrew, Brazil’s AmBev, and U.S.-based Anheuser Busch and several different functional areas. These positions were
all merged to become the largest global brewer with opera- created to define more clearly different spheres of responsi-
tions across most of the continents. Finally, Anheuser-Busch bility. Van Boxmeer argued that the new structure also pro-
InBev made a move in 2016 to acquire SABMiller to become vides incentives for people to be accountable for their
an even more dominant player in the industry. performance: “There is more pressure for results, for
Since its acquisition of Anheuser Busch, InBev has in- achievement.”4 He claimed the new structure has already
cluded Budweiser along with Stella Artois, Brahma, and encouraged more risk taking and boosted the level of en-
Becks in its lineup of what it is promoting as its global flag- ergy within the firm.
ship brands. Each of these brands originated in different The Executive Committee of Heineken was also cut
locations, with Budweiser coming from the United States, down from 36 to 12 members in order to speed up the
Stella Artois coming from Belgium, Brahma from Brazil, decision-making process. Besides the two members of
and Becks from Germany. Similarly, SABMiller has been the Executive Board, this management group consists of
attempting to develop the Czech brand Pilsner Urquell into the managers who are responsible for the different operat-
a global brand. Exports of this pilsner doubled shortly after ing regions and several of the key functional areas. Van Box-
SAB acquired it in 1999, but sales have since plateaued. meer has hoped that the reduction in the size of this group
John Brock, the CEO of InBev, commented: “Global will allow the firm to combat the cumbersome consensus
brands sell at significantly higher prices, and the margins culture that has made it difficult for Heineken to respond
are much better than with local beers.”3 swiftly to various challenges even as its industry has been
experiencing considerable change.
Wrestling with Change Finally, all of the activities of Heineken have been over-
Although the management of Heineken has moved away seen by a Supervisory Board, which currently consists of
from the family for the first time, they have been well aware 10 members. Individuals that make up this board are drawn
of the longstanding and well-established family traditions from different countries and cover a wide range of expertise

C78 CASE 13 :: HEINEKEN

Strategic Management: Text and


Cases
and experience. They set up policies for the firm to use in Maintaining a Premium Position
making majors decisions in its overall operations. Members
For decades, Heineken has been able to rely upon the suc-
of the Supervisory Board are rotated on a regular basis.
cess of its flagship Heineken brand, which has enjoyed a
leading position among premium beers in many markets
Developing a Global Presence around the world. It had been the best-selling imported beer
Van Boxmeer has been well aware of the need for Heineken in the United States for several decades, giving it a steady
to use its brands to build upon its existing stature across source of revenues and profits from the world’s biggest mar-
global markets. In spite of its formidable presence in mar- ket. But by the late 1990s, Heineken had lost its 65-year-old
kets around the world with its flagship Heineken brand, the leadership among imported beers in the United States to
firm has been reluctant to match the recent moves of formi- Group Modelo’s Corona. The Mexican beer has been able
dable competitors such as Belgium’s InBev and the UK’s to reach out to the growing Hispanic Americans who repre-
SABMiller, which have grown significantly through mega- sent one of the fastest growing segments of beer drinkers.
acquisitions. In large part, it is assumed that the firm has Furthermore, the firm was also concerned that Heineken
been reluctant to make such acquisitions because of the di- was being perceived as an obsolete brand by many young
lution of family control. drinkers. John A. Quelch, a professor at Harvard Business
For many years, Heineken had limited itself to snapping School who has studied the beer industry said of Heineken:
up small national brewers such as Italy’s Moretti to Spain’s “It’s in danger of becoming a tired, reliable, but unexciting
Cruzcampo that have provided it with small, but profitable brand.”5 Therefore, the firm has been working hard to in-
avenues for growth. In 1996, for example, Heineken had ac- crease awareness of their flagship brand among younger
quired Fischer, a small French brewer, whose Desperados drinkers. Heineken also introduced a light beer, Heineken
brand had been quite successful in niche markets. Similarly, Premium Light, to target the growing market for such beers
Paulaner, a wheat beer that the firm picked up in Germany a in the United States. Through such efforts, the firm has
few years ago, has been making inroads into the U.S. market. managed to reduce the average age of the Heineken drinker
But as other brewers have been reaching out to make from about 40 years old to about 30 years old.
acquisitions from all over the globe, Heineken has been run- At the same time, Heineken has also been pushing other
ning the risk of falling behind its more aggressive rivals. To brands that would reduce its reliance on its core Heineken
deal with this growing challenge, the firm has broken out of brand. It has already achieved considerable success with
its play-it-safe corporate culture to make a few big deals. In Amstel Light, which has become the leading imported light
2003, Heineken spent $2.1 billion to acquire BBAG, a family- beer in the United States and has been selling well in many
owned company based in Linz, Austria. Because of BBAG’s other countries. But many of the other brands that it carries
extensive presence in Central Europe, Heineken has are strong local brands added through its string of acquisi-
become the biggest beer maker in seven countries across tions of smaller breweries around the globe. It has managed
Eastern Europe. The acquisition of Scottish & Newcastle in to develop a relatively small but loyal base of consumers
2008 similarly reinforced the firm’s dominance in Western by promoting some of these as specialty brands, such as
Europe. Murphy’s Irish Red and Moretti.
At the same time, Heineken has been making a string of Finally, Heineken has been stepping up its efforts to tar-
acquisitions in other parts of the world. Its recent acquisi- get Hispanics, who account for one-quarter of U.S. sales.
tions in Ethiopia, Singapore, and Mexico have allowed it to Besides developing specific marketing campaigns for them,
build its position in these growing markets. The firm has it added popular Mexican beers such as Tecate and Dos
also made an aggressive push into Russia with the acquisi- Equis to its line of offerings. For years, these had been mar-
tion of mid-sized brewing concerns. Through several acqui- keted and distributed by Heineken in the United States un-
sitions since 2002, Russia has become one of Heineken’s der a license from FEMSA Cervesa. In 2010, the firm
largest markets by volume. Heineken now ranks as the decided to acquire the firm, giving them full control over all
third-largest brewer in Russia, behind Sweden’s Baltic of their brands. Benj Steinman, publisher and editor of Beer
Beverages Holding and InBev. Marketer’s Insight newsletter, believed their relationship
Rene Hooft Graafland, the company’s Chief Financial with FEMSA had been quite beneficial: “This gives
Officer, has stated that Heineken will continue to partici- Heineken a commanding share of the U.S. import business
pate in the consolidation of the $460 billion global retail and . . . gives them a bigger presence in the Southwest . . .
beer industry, by targeting many different markets around and better access to Hispanic consumers,” he stated.6
the world. During the last decade, the firm has also added Above all, Heineken wants to maintain its leadership in
several labels to Heineken’s shelf, pouncing on brewers in the premium beer industry, which represents the most profit-
far flung places like Belarus, Panama, Egypt, and Kazakh- able segment of the beer business. In this category, the firm’s
stan. In Egypt, Ruys bought a majority stake in Al Ahram brands face competition in the United States from domestic
Beverages Co. and had been using the Cairo-based brewer’s beers such as Anheuser’s Budweiser Select and imported
fruit-flavored, nonalcoholic malts as an avenue into other beers such as InBev’s Stella Artois. Although premium brews
Muslim countries. often have slightly higher alcohol content than standard

CASE 13 :: HEINEKEN C79

Strategic Management: Text and


Cases
beers, they are developed through a more exclusive position- its existing culture. “Since 1952 history has proved it is the
ing of the brand. This allows the firm to charge a higher price right concept,” he stated about the Heineken’s ownership
for these brands. A six-pack of Heineken, for example, costs $9, structure. “The whole business about family restraint on us
versus around $6 for a six-pack of Budweiser. Furthermore, is absolutely untrue. Without its spirit and guidance, the
Just-drinks.com, a London-based online research service, esti- company would not have been able to build a world leader.”7
mates that the market for premium beer will continue to In fact, van Boxmeer’s devotion to the firm is quite evi-
expand over the next decade. dent. Since he took over, Heineken has shown steady
growth in revenues and profits, even with little growth in
Building on Its Past the global market for beer. Before he took over as Heineken’s
first non-Dutch CEO, van Boxmeer had spent 20 years
The recent acquisitions in different parts of the world—Asia,
working his way up within the firm. Even his cufflinks are
Africa, Latin America and Europe—represent an important
silver miniatures of a Heineken bottle top and opener. “We
step in Heineken’s quest to build upon its existing global
are in the logical flow of history,” he explained. “Every time
stature. Van Boxmeer and his team have made an effort to
you have a new leader you have a new kind of vision. It is
enter new markets and build upon the firm’s position in ex-
not radically different, because you are defined by what
isting markets. In November 2018, Heineken signed an
your company is and what your brands are.”8
agreement with China Resources Enterprise and China Re-
sources Beer to create a long-term strategic partnership for
mainland China, Hong Kong, and Macau. The partnership ENDNOTES
will give the firm a 40 percent share in the Chinese firm that 1. GlobeNewswire. 2019. Heineken opens up first brewery in
Mozambique, a US$100 million investment. March 13.
controls CR beer, the undisputed market leader in China,
2. Ewing, J. and G. Khermouch. 2003. Waking up Heineken.
which represents the world’s largest beer market. BusinessWeek, September 8, p. 68.
In order to accompany this global expansion, van Box- 3. Tomlinson, R. 2004. The new king of beers. Fortune, October 18,
meer has also been committed to working on the company’s p. 238.
culture in order to accelerate the speed of decision making. 4. Bickerton, I. and J. Wiggins. 2006. Accelerated change is brewing at
This led many people both inside and outside the firm to Heineken. Financial Times, May 8, p. 12.
5. Ewing, J. and G. Khermouch. 2003. Waking up Heineken.
expect the new management to try and break loose from the
BusinessWeek, September 8, p. 69.
conservative style that has resulted from the family’s tight 6. Kaplan, A. 2004. Border crossings. Beverage World, July 15, p. 6.
control. Instead, the affable 46-year-old Belgian indicated 7. Bickerton, I. and J. Wiggins. 2006. Accelerated change is brewing at
that he has been trying to focus on changes to the firm’s Heineken. Financial Times, May 8, p. 12.
decision-making process rather to make any drastic shifts in 8. Ibid.

C80 CASE 13 :: HEINEKEN

Strategic Management: Text and


Cases

Potrebbero piacerti anche