Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
67
Innovative Marketing, Volume 3, Issue 4, 2007
(Parasuraman et al., 2005). Only discusses auto- service? What ways and means to be followed for
mated service quality within the service that is de- increasing the usage of Internet banking in India?
livered through web sites. In addition to internet
3. Research problem and objectives
banking, service quality, telephone banking and
ATM service quality need to be addressed in par- Changes in banks’ external environment, including
ticular service environment. Black et al. (2001) per- globalization and deregulation, have made the bank-
formed a qualitative study on the adoption of inter- ing sector highly competitive. Banks find it hard to
net services and found out that those with the high- compete on price, and need to look at other ways to
est income with a greatest use of information tech- retain customers. As customers become more so-
nology were most likely to purchase financial ser- phisticated, it becomes imperative for banks to con-
vices using internet channel. Education and gender sider the use of technology to respond to their con-
were not studied in this study. Earlier studies tinuously changing requirements.
(Barczak et al., 1997; Danniel & Strong, 1997; Lia
But current scenario in India shows that pace at
et al., 1999; Polatoglu & Ekin, 2001; Devlin & Ye-
which technology in Internet banking proceeds
ung, 2003) report factors such as convenience,
doesn’t march with the customers’ usage rate. Even
flexibility, security concern, complexity, and re-
though banks are more interested in adopting new
sponsiveness being associated with a higher propen-
technology to differentiate themselves in competi-
sity to use internet banking. In the context of the
tive market, they are not getting expected ROI. So is
above perspective, the paper will make an attempt to
this the fault at the end of the technology or con-
analyze the evolving sphere of Internet banking and
sumers’ perception? If any, then why? If both, then
the innovations both technological and conceptual
why? Is it due to lack of skills or will? Update on
which are sweeping the financial services industry
technical skills through customer’s education on net
in India in the context of the changes that are taking
with simple software can create an interest in the
place in this sector across the world. The regulatory
customer’s mind. However, interest and desire to a
and taxation issues of Internet banking present for-
great extent will depend upon his education level,
midable problems and the paper attempts to get an
culture religion and gender. This may affect his
insight into these two important issues.
perception on Internet banking.
2. Problem definition
4. Conceptual model
The basic understanding of Internet banking has Update skill through
Enhances will to use the Internet
shown the presence of a number of desired features. simple software
banking
Such features are broadly aimed at satisfying one or
the other of the following immediate user objectives Affected by:
ease of access, up-to-date content, layout, design, i
i
Trust
Gender
consistent themes, easy navigation, higher interac- i Education
i Culture
Usage of Internet banking
tivity, access through multiple media, higher use of i Religion
i Security
non-textual information, multiple languages and
lower cost of transaction, and thrust. Fig. 1. The conceptual model
The Internet banking project now wants to integrate This research is focused on what is the consumer’s
an ethnographic approach with flexible systems perception about Internet banking. What are the
methodology to focus on the communication design drivers that drive consumer towards better percep-
issues for web-portals specifically devoted to con- tion? Bank can evaluate its Internet banking system
sumers. The specific research questions are: What with respect to the drivers and customers’ response
are the major information design features for India? to these drivers.
What are the major communication media tools to
be used for banking websites in India? What are the 5. Research methodology
modes employed to transcend communication and Qualitative research method was used in the first
cost barriers for specific user groups? What local phase. Pilot testing of questionnaire helps to get in-
language solutions are to be provided and through depth response of target group. Based on this we
which media? What non-textual solutions can be have used exploratory research methodology in the
provided for the under-educated, untrained user? second phase. The working of the research was
What makes Internet banking relevant for the non- started with the questionnaire. In this we have used
served communities? What is customers’ perception screening criteria to identify the target group for our
about Internet banking? What are the factors that research. Screening was done on the basis of three
result in the perception of the I-banking? How can questions:
these factors be evaluated for current banking
69
Innovative Marketing, Volume 3, Issue 4, 2007
i Does their bank provide Internet banking facil- mize the errors in our survey, as we were taking the
ity? sample of population for the purpose of research.
i Does customer know how to use Internet? Questionnaire used Likert’s five point scale to
i Does he have access to Internet? measure the opinion of different customers on dif-
ferent parameters. It took six months to complete
The study went through the perception of the target the project.
group about the manual banking also. Opinion about
manual banking by the target group helped to meas- 6. Sampling
ure impact of manual banking transactions. Then, 6.1. Target population. The first criterion to get the
our study was divided into two streams: the cus- targeted sample was the bank customer; whose bank
tomer, who uses Internet banking and who doesn’t provides Internet banking service, who has access to
use it. The reason behind bifurcation of the study Internet and who knows how to use Internet. The
was to gather the parameters that can help to under- sample for conducting the survey containts custom-
stand the customers’ perception. These parameters ers from Mumbai. The study covered bank custom-
helped to correlate the information between both ers from different regions of Mumbai. Mumbai
kinds of customers. This also helped to evaluate the represents mini India and is the economic capital.
current satisfaction level of the customers who were While doing the survey we have taken suggestion
using Internet banking. Evaluation of different pa- from the bank employees, of ICICI & SBI to get
rameters ended up with the landscape scrutiny of the more insights about the Internet banking. The sur-
areas, which are needed to be urbanized by banks. vey also focused on covering all the demographic
Earlier studies have mentioned that reliability, ease factors in the sample itself.
of use, personality, accessibility accuracy, security
and efficiency could influence the Internet banking 6.2. Sample size. Bank customers were our sample
(Joseph et. al., 1999; Meuter et al., 2000; Yang & for study. We have surveyed 665 bank customers
Jun, 2002; Zeithaml, 2002; Joseph & Sone, 2003; from different banks and from different locality.
Long & McMellon, 2004). While doing the survey From these 665 we got 500 replies, which fitted in
we focused on all the possible different demograph- our criteria of target population. Our analysis is based
ics, e.g. age, sex, financial status, etc. The aim be- on these 500 bank customers. The respondent profile
hind covering different demographics was to mini- who participated in the study is given in Table 1.
6.3. Results and discussion. A survey of 665 re- the usage of internet banking. This research pointed
spondents of different age groups and with different out that there is a significant difference between
educational qualifications was conducted; out of educated users and educated non users. Academic
these 665 respondents we had received only 500 people use more internet banking (x2 = 0.037) as
targeted responses. This study was aimed to find out pointed out in Table 1. This factor was not studied
what is the consumers’ perception about Internet by earlier researchers. This becomes important in a
banking. From the selected sample of 600, it was country where the level of education is not very
found that 57% don’t use Internet banking services. high. Gender also does play an important role in
The rate at which investments of banks in providing acceptance of internet banking. This study revealed
such facility is growing, mere 43% users signifies a that males are more internet banking users compared
wide gap between the investment and its returns. to females (X2 = 0.0021) as pointed out in Table 1.
Education does play an important role in improving Again small research was done on the internet bank-
70
Innovative Marketing, Volume 3, Issue 4, 2007
ing usage and the role of gender. Similarly, this Internet banking for all the transactions as given in
study also revealed that people of higher income Tables 3, 4, 5.
group are more Internet banking users (x2 =2.244).
Table 4. Never created any security problems for
However, religion and choices of internet banking
users, N=215
by user are independent (x2 – 15.28) of each other.
Answers Counts Percentages
This study corroborates earlier finding of Back et
al. (2001) concerning those people who do not use
Strongly 10 4.55
Internet banking and believe that manual banking is disagree 15%
more convenient. This age old habit has become so Disagree 25 11.36
strong that even such quick and efficient mode as Neutral 55 25.00
Internet banking has not been able to change it. The
Agree 85 40.91
reasons are that manual banking offers human inter-
Strongly agree 40 18.18
action and more flexibility. There is no motivation
Total 215 100
which would push them to use Internet banking
services as they have a strong belief that manual Table 5. Trust in this service for all the transactions
banking is easy and convenient to use. among users, N = 215
Table 2. Convenience to use the manual banking Answers Counts Percentages
among non-users, N = 285 Strongly disagree 10 4.55
Answers Counts Percentages Disagree 40 18.18
Strongly disagree 25 8.62 Neutral 55 25.00
Disagree 30 10.34 Agree 90 43.18
Neutral 90 30.03 Strongly agree 20 9.09
Agree 100 36.21 Total 215 100
50%
Strongly agree 40 13.79
T-test among the user and non-user was t = 0.533.
Total 285 100
Security is the major inhibiting factor for not using
Table 2 shows 50% of total respondents are happy Internet banking. This corroborates the conceptual
with the manual banking operation, so this comes out model which says that security could be an impor-
to be one of the strongest points for the consumers, tant factor for its acceptance. Trust is the major
which influences the consumers mind not to use the factor which helps to use internet banking. Users are
Internet banking. 30% were neutral. It means that this convinced about the usage of the internet. This con-
segment may opt for Internet banking if motivated to fidence on t test comes to t = 0.2567. Thus, trust is
do so. The higher number of non users could be due the motivating factor for usage of internet banking.
to better service quality at manual banking. As per Thus, this further confirms the hypothetical model
Santos (2003), service quality can lead to acceptance on trust as mentioned in Conceptual Model.
and failure of electronic commerce. Customers’ evaluation of automated service options
Table 3. Security factor among non-users, N = 285 as per earlier study and their intension to use a par-
ticular option are directly affected by their percep-
Answers Counts Percentages
tion to words they attribute associated with the op-
Strongly 30 10.34 tion (Dabholkar, 2002). At the same time price has
disagree
been incorporated as an additional factor that could
Disagree 35 12.07
influence the customers’ overall perception of
Neutral 50 17.24
automated service quality (Al-Hawari, 2005).
Agree 105 37.93 60%
Strongly agree 65 22.41 Non-user friendliness software is another crucial
Total 285 100
issue which holds people back from using the facil-
ity. Around 32% of non-users are agreeing with the
As found in numerous other studies conducted (Po- fact that the technology used in Internet banking is
latoglu & Kin, 2001; Devlin & Young, 2003) ours complicated for them. Among users, 9% believe that
also revealed that security forms a major concern for these services aren’t easy to use while 7% say they
using Internet banking facility. As high as 60% of are difficult to access. This is given in Table 6. This
non-users prefer manual banking due to high level result confirms our critical concept on acceptability
of cyber crimes like phishing, hacking, etc., while of internet banking as mentioned earlier.
15% of the users have faced such problems. This
can be the reason why 23% of users do not prefer
71
Innovative Marketing, Volume 3, Issue 4, 2007
Table 6. User-friendliness perceptions among proper security, and the best response to the services
non-users, N = 285 offered.
Users Factors Counts Percentages
The study also provides the kind of correlation be-
Non-users Complicated 90 32
technology tween different factors. As per our basic assump-
Not easy 25 9
tions we consider only those consumers who know
how to use Internet and have an access to Internet,
Difficult 20 7
accessibility and our study considered only the situation wherein
Rigidity 15 5 banks provide Internet banking services. By group-
Don’t get 35 12
ing the variables less than one relevant question may
required result in proper implication for the bankers.
response
Poor feedback 40 14
In case of the consumers who don’t use Internet
banking services, having all facilities at their dis-
Can not say 60 21
posal, technology was not the biggest issue. The
Total 285 100
first thing that all bankers should concern about is
Fees charged for using Internet banking facility also the requirement of awareness. Even though these
make consumers reluctant in exploiting such services. people are inclined towards the manual banking,
Almost 23% of consumers who don’t use Internet these can be turned to potential customers, it is well
banking feel that the charges are not reasonable. In proven thing, which says the surrounding influences
fact 14% of users also share the same view. This the individual’s behavior or in India only environment
shows that a little cut in these charges may induce that surrounds the public determines the behavior and
them to use this service as given in Table 6. decisions of the individuals. So if consumer sees most
of their colleagues or friends who surround him using
In our theoretical concept we have suggested that Internet banking then it may influence his decision to
training of consumer will help to improve the usage follow Internet banking option.
of internet banking. Our study confirmed that one
way to shift people from non-users segment to the Limitations
users segment can be educating them about the ser- There are limitations that need to be acknowledged
vices provided. When asked, 74% of non-users re- and addressed regarding the present study. Impact of
sponded in “yes” that they would use Internet bank- religion can play an important role but could not be
ing services if provided with personal training and considered due to samples size of minorities. Focus
information as given in Table 7. is placed more on non-users as they can provide
Table 7. Service charges aren’t fair correct perception about the subject. Another limita-
tion could be due to a limited number of financial
User Count Total
banks covered, and people who participated in this
Non-user 65 (23%) 285 study represented a city like Mumbai which is the
User 30 (14%) 215 financial capital of India but it can not represent a B
This tool can increase the usage of the service but class people’s behavior though they belong to the
can also help in erasing various myths prevailing same country. We made an attempt to get the reply
among consumers regarding Internet banking like from the bank employees but we were not allowed
security related factors, its efficiency, etc. Users to do this. Because of this we loosed one aspect of
agreed (69.7%) that given a training users were able the study.
to use internet banking. Thus the will and skill will Managerial implication
determine the usage of internet banking. The skill
will enhance the will to use internet banking. The data provided could be useful to improve the
internet banking in the world. Results through this
Conclusion study will help to understand customer’s perception
When investigating all the variables and the re- and activities can be initiated to improve the usage of
sponse by consumers, this study reveals that the internet banking. This data if used can lead to reduc-
perception of the consumers can be changed by tion in cost of operation for banks as manual banking
awareness program, friendly usage, less charges, is more costly compared to internet banking.
References
1. Barczak G.E, Scholder P. & Piling B.K.T. (1997), Developing typologies of consumer motivation for use of tech-
nologically based banking services, Journal of Business Research 38 (2), 131-40.
2. Black N.J. Lockett A., Ennew C. & Winklhofer H. (2001), Adoption of Internet banking, a qualitative study, In-
ternational Journal of Retail & Distribution Management 29 (8), 390-8.
72
Innovative Marketing, Volume 3, Issue 4, 2007
3. Corrocher, N. (2002), Does Internet banking substitute traditional banking? Empirical evidence from Italy,
Working Paper, CESPRI, No. 134, November.
4. Dabholkar P. & Bagozzi R. (2002), An attitudinal model of Technology based self service: Moderating effect of
consumer traits & situational factors, Journal of Academy of Marketing Science 30 (3), 184-201.
5. Danniel E. & Storey C. (1997), Online banking Strategies & Management Challenges, Long Range Planning 30
(6), 890-8.
6. Devlin J. F. & Young Matthew (2003), Insight in to customer motivation for switching to Internet Banking, Int.
Rev. of Retail, Distribution & Consumer Research, 13-4, Oct, 375-392.
7. European commission (2003), Report on Public perception on Bank September
8. Joseph M. & Stone G. (2003), An empirical evaluation of US bank customer perceptions of the impact of technology
on service delivery in banking sector, International Journal of Retail and Distribution Management 4, 190-202.
9. Joseph M. McClure C. & Joseph B. (1999), Service quality in the banking sector: The impact of technology on
service delivery, International Journal of Bank Marketing 17 (4), 182-191.
10. Journal of Internet Banking and Commerce (2006), Impact of demographics on the consumption of different ser-
vice online in India, vol. 11, No. 3, 353-355.
11. Journal of Service Research (2007), Profiling of internet banking users in India, vol. 6, No. 2, March, 77-125.
12. Liao S. S.Y., Yuan P. S., Wang H. and Chen A. (1999), The adoption of virtual banking: an empirical Study, In-
ternational Journal of Information Management 19, 63-74.
13. Long M. & McMellon C. (2004), Exploring determinants of retail service quality on the internet, Journal of ser-
vice marketing 16 (1), 78-90.
14. Long M. & McMellon C. (2004), Exploring determinants of retail service quality on he internet, Journal of Service
Marketing 18 (1), 78-90.
15. Meuter M. Ostrom A., Rountree R. & Bitner M. (2000), Self service technology: Understand Customer satisfac-
tion with technology based service encounters, Journal Marketing 64 (3), 50-64.
16. Mohammed Al-Hawari, Nicole Harley and Tony Ward (2005), Measuring banks’ automated Service Quality, a
confirmatory factor analysis approach, Marketing Bulletin, 16, 1-19.
17. Parasuraman A., Zeithami V. & Malhotra A. (2005), A multiple Item Scale for assessing Electronic Service qual-
ity, Journal of Service Research 7 (3), 213-234.
18. Polatoglu, V. N. & Ekin S. (2001), An Imperial investigation of Turkish consumer acceptance of internet banking
service, International Journal of Bank Marketing 19 (4), 156-65.
19. Rao, G. R. and Prathima, K. (2003), Internet Banking in India, Mondaq Business Briefing, April 11.
20. Reil A. L., Liljander V. and Jurriens P. (2001), Exploring consumer evaluation of e-service: portal site, Interna-
tional Journal of Service Industry Management 12 (4), 359-377.
21. Santos J. (2003), E-Service quality: a model of virtual service quality dimension, Managing Service Quality
13 (3), 233-246.
22. Suganthi, Balachander and Balachandran (2001), Internet Banking Patronage: An Empirical Investigation of Ma-
laysia, Journal of Internet Banking and Commerce, Vol. 6, No. 1, May.
23. Yang Z. & June M. (2002), Consumer perception of e-service quality: from internet purchase and non purchase
perspectives, Journal business strategies 19 (1), 19-41.
24. Zeithml V. (2002), Service excellence in electronic channels, Managing Service Quality 12 (3), 135-138.
25. http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article.cfm?articleid
26. www.search.epnet.com
27. www.financialexpress.com/fe/daily/19980714/19555264.html
73