Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
HATEM EL-GOHARY
Bradford University School of Management
School address : EMM Lane, Bradford, West Yorkshire BD9 4JL, UK.
Mailing address : 24 Laisteridge Lane, Bradford, BD7 1QT, West Yorkshire, UK.
Telephone : +44 (0)7878470306
Fax : +44 (0)1274 546866
Email : h.o.a.elgohary@bradford.ac.uk
elgohary70@yahoo.com
Supervisor name : Dr. Myfanwy Trueman
Supervisor e-mail : M.Trueman@Bradford.ac.uk
Soreze, France
July 2007
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
Abstract:-
Small Business Enterprises (SBE's) play a major role in the world economy, and
their contribution to economic and employment growth is widely recognized. Based on
the SBE role as an economic engine to drive global development, this research seeks to
understand the practices and activities of these enterprises in terms of electronic
marketing (Achieving marketing objectives and functions through the use of electronic
communication technology), marketing performance and the effectiveness of industrial
and trade SBE’s. In order to do this a comparative study is made between SBE’s in Egypt
(developing) and the UK (developed).
The main aim of this work is to identify links between the conceptual framework
and empirical analysis in this field because they appear to be highly integrated, and if
reviewed separately may present distorted results.
A triangulation approach will be used in which quantitative and qualitative data
will be collected through structured mailed questionnaires and semi-structured
interviews to address different levels of investigation, test the hypotheses and address the
central research questions.
1. Introduction:-
Small Business Enterprises (SBE's) do play a major role in the world economy,
and they are recognized as one of the main contributors to economic, development and
employment growth. According to Mulhern (1995) 99% of all European companies are
small and medium sized (SME) and from 1985-1995 it provided 66% of the employment
in Europe. That is also true in Less Developing Countries (LDC’s) since small businesses
do represent a high percentage of the total number of enterprises.
On the other hand, the revolution in information technology (IT) and
communications changed the way people conduct business today. In recent years,
increasing numbers of businesses have been using the Internet and other electronic media
in their marketing efforts, giving the chance for Electronic marketing (as a new marketing
phenomenon and philosophy) to grow in a very dramatic and dynamic way.
From the researcher point of view, implementing E-marketing by small business
enterprise can change the shape and nature of SBE’s business all over the world. Because
the rapid proliferation of the Internet, the World Wide Web (WWW) and electronic
communication has created a fast growing new electronic channels for marketing. For
that, the internet and other electronic media are playing now a very important role in
conducting marketing activities due to its unique characteristics as a market and as a
medium.
Depending on that the researcher is seeking to add to the body of knowledge by
investigating and understanding the practices and activities of small business enterprises
2
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
Despite of the powerful position held by small businesses, defining it has always
been difficult and there is a little agreement on what defines a small business because the
term covers a variety of firms. As a result small businesses have been defined in a
perplexing number of different ways in different parts of the world according to national
and local needs (Theng and Boon 1996; Watson and Everrett 1996). Table 1 summarizes
the official or most common definitions of SBE's used in some countries around the
world.
Table 1: Criteria of defining SBE’s adapted by some countries
Country No. of employees Other criteria
USA Under 100 Less than $ 5 million annual sales
European Under 50 Annual turnover or global balance less than 10 million
Union euros
+
Independence
Australia Under 20 None
Canada Under 500 in mfg Less than $ 5 million annual sales
and 50 in services
India None Total investment(not exceeding 10 million Indian
Rupees in industrial enterprises and 1 million in
service enterprises)
Mexico Under 50 None
Thailand Under 200 in None
labour intensive
Turkey 10 to 49 None
Source: El-Gohary (2006)
From table 1 it is noticed that the number of employees is the most often used
element in determining the category of SBE's in most countries. Furthermore,. It also
noticed that there is a lack of agreement on what defines a small business, for that a
standard definition for Small Business Enterprises is needed. Accordingly and due to the
absence of an Egyptian official definition for SBE’s, the researcher will depend on the
following definition for SBE’s for the purpose of conducting the research study: “a small
business enterprise is that enterprise that employs from ten to forty-nine employees”.
1.1.2 E-Marketing:-
3
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
Internet and other electronic means. A review of relevant literature revealed that
definitions of electronic marketing vary according to each author's point of view,
background and specialization. While Smith and Chaffey (2005) defines it as: “Achieving
marketing objectives through applying digital technologies”, Strauss and Frost (2001)
define it as: “The use of electronic data and applications for planning and executing the
conception, distribution and pricing of ideas, goods and services to create exchanges that
satisfy individual and organizational objectives”.
The researcher will depend on Strauss and Frost definition in conducting the
current research because: it takes into consideration all the element of E-marketing, all
types of products, it illustrate the main objective of E-marking which is creating the
exchanges that satisfy individual and organizational needs. Moreover it is the official
definition for E-marketing adopted by the E-Marketing Association.
The researcher had identified a wide range of the literature review (in its wider
broad sense which include: Journals, Academic Books, theses and dissertations, short
articles, E-databases, conference papers,…). The literature time period starts from 1990
to presence. The research studies investigated and covered a wide rang of E-marketing
areas, such as: Internet-marketing / E-mail marketing / Intranet marketing / SMS
4
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
marketing / Extranet marketing. On the other hand, it is noticed that the literature in
Internet-marketing (IM) covers five main areas which are: Internet marketing (IM)
environment, IM functions, IM applications and IM research. Regarding the literature of
E-marketing in SBE’s, it was found that it covers the following areas illustrated in figure
1.
E-Business
adoption by The literature of e- Virtual
SBE’s marketing in SBE’s Market
3. Research Problem:-
5
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
4. Research Objectives:-
The main objectives of this research is to: develop a theoretical model to
understand and interpret the use of the E-marketing by small business enterprises in the
UK and Egypt, explore and analyze the level and form of e-marketing used by the
Egyptian and British SBE’s and its contribution to marketing performance as measured
by financial and operational performance measures.
To achieve these objectives a series of hypotheses have been constructed to be
tested during the research process.
5. Research Hypotheses:
Topic Selection
Process and the literature review, the following
In the light of the previous discussion
hypotheses have been constructed. Both the conceptual framework and empirical study
Electronic
are linked to test these hypotheses:-
Marketing Identification of the:-
Hypothesis (1): The level of e-marketing used by SBE’s is significantly related to the
- Research Problem
firm’s marketing performance.
- Research objectives
Hypothesis (2): The form of e-marketing used by SBE’s is not significantly related to the
Small Business -Research Importance
Enterprisesfirm’s marketing performance.
Hypotheses (3): Implementing E-marketing by the SBE’s is dependent on the SBE
internal related factors.
The Research
6. Contribution To The Current Knowledge:-
Questions, Model and
Hypotheses
“We make a living by what we get, but we make a life by what we give”
Research Strategy Sir Winston Churchill
The primary benefit of this study is as a contribution to knowledge in the areas of
small business
Research enterprises and E-marketing.
Methods Research
The research will contributesData,
to theMethod
limitedand
number of empirical researches on marketing goods, services, ideas and information
Methodology Methodological
Researchon
depending Design
the Internet and other electronic marketing means. Moreover,triangulation
it contributes
to the limited number of empirical evidences to explore the effect of E-marketing on the
marketing performance of small business enterprises. Many researchers (Sheth, J. N.,
Measures
Sharma, A., 2005; Sandeep K., Singh, N., 2005; Adam, S., et al., 2002; Teo, T., Tan, J.
S.,Sampling
2002; Darby, R., Jones, J., Al Madani, G., 2003 and Goldsmith, R., Lafferty, B.,
Process
2002) had suggested the need for such kind of research. Those authors agree that a
serious marketing practitioners and academic researchers are now aware that more survey
Questionnaire Design Data Collection
systematic research is required to reveal the true nature of E-marketing.
and Administration
case study
7. Researchpilot
Reliability/ Process:-
study
Descriptive Statistics,
Correlation, Chi
Entering
The Data toprocess
research SPSS will be conducted through five basic stages (as illustrated in
Figure2) these stages are:
Data Analysis Square, Independent
Identification of the research problem and objectives, The
samples t-test
Purification Process
development of the research framework, Research methodology, Quantitative and
qualitative data analysis, and Discussion and conclusion. Content Analysis
6
Conclusion and
Recommendations
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
7
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
Quantitative
Quantitative
8.6% 1.5%
33.3% Theoretical
Conceptual
Qualitative
Qualitative
Triangulation
Triangulation
Literature review
Literature review
27.6%
29% Table 2
Classification for some of the literature according to the methodology employed
MethodologyLiteratureQuantitativeFlavián
Figure 3: Research Methodologies used in andE-marketing
Guinalíu (2006), Lin et. al. (2006), Kuhlmeier and
Knight (2005), Wong (2005),
Source: El-Gohary (2006). Flavián et al.(2005), Lymperopoulos and Chaniotakis (2005), McCole
and Ramsey (2004),Kim and Kim (2004), Lee-Kelley et al.(2004), Merisavo and Raulas
(2004).QualitativeTaylor and England (2006), Hackney et al. (2006), Park (2005), Lagrosen (2005),
Ryan and Valverde (2005), Warnaby and Yip (2005), Rowley (2004 a), Smith, C. (2004), Darby et
al. (2003), Martin and Matlay (2003), Siddiqui et. al. (2003).TriangulationWeischedel et al (2005),
Christodoulides and Chernatony (2004), Fillis et al (2004), Yang et al. (2003), Chaston and
Mangles (2003), Adam et al (2002), Kapoulas (2002).Conceptual and theoretical studiesDe
Kervenoael et al (2006), Sheth and Sharma (2005), Sandeep and Singh (2005), McCole (2004),
Smith and Manna (2004), Smith, A (2004 a, b ), Kulviwat, et al (2004),Rowley (2004 b), Lindgreen
et al (2004).Source: El-Gohary (2006).
8
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
Experiment
Conceptual
3% Literature
6%
18.8% review
Figure 4: Research strategies used in E-Marketing
Source: El-Gohary (2006).
4%
6%
Questionnaire
Interviews
Observation
Focus groups
29.6% 60.4%
9
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
10
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
information and answer the 'HOW' and ‘WHY’ questions (for example: why the
relationship is taking one direction instead of anther direction).
Why triangulation?
The logic of triangulation is based on the premise that: “no single method ever
adequately solves the problem” (Denzin, 1978: 28) and using only one method is more
vulnerable to error linked to that particular method (Patton, 1990: 188); for that the use of
different methods in studying the same phenomenon should lead to a greater validity and
reliability than a single methodological approach, because any bias inherent in a
particular method would be neutralised when in conjunction with other methods. Beside
that, each technique has its advantages and disadvantages, strengthens and weaknesses,
for that combining the methods will be helpful and useful to benefit from the advantages
and strengthens and avoid the disadvantages and weaknesses.
A combined research strategy based on survey and case study strategies will be
carried out in the research by using structured mailed questionnaires and interviews as a
primary data collection methods.Then, many statistical analysis techniques will be used
to analyse the data and test the research hypotheses.
Bibliography:-
ADAM, S., MULYE, R., DEANS, K. & PALIHAWADANA, D. (2002) E-marketing in
perspective: A three country comparison of business use of the Internet. Marketing
Intelligence & Planning, 20 (4): 243 - 251.
BUI, T. X., LE, T. and JONES, W. D. (2006). An Exploratory Case Study E-Marketing in Ho Chi
Minh City, Thunderbird International Business Review, 48(3) 369–388..
11
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
JUTLA, D., BODORIK, P. & DHALIWAL, J. (2002) Supporting the e-business readiness of
small and medium-sized enterprises: approaches and metrics. Internet Research, 12 (2):
139 - 164
KOKKINAKI, F. and AMBLER, T. (1999), “Marketing performance assessment: an exploratory
investigation into current practice and the role of firm orientation”, working paper No.
99-114, Marketing Science Institute, Cambridge, MA.
LIANG, T. and HUNG, J. (1998). An empirical study on consumer acceptance of products in
electronic markets: A transaction cost model, Decision Support Systems, 24: 63 – 74.
MALONE, T.W., YATES, J., BENJAMIN, R.I. (1987), "Electronic markets and electronic
hierarchies", Communication of the ACM, 30 (6):484-97.
MALONE, T.W., YATES, J., BENJAMIN, R.I. (1989), "The logic of electronic markets",
Harvard Business Review, 67 (3):166-72.
MARTIN, L. & MATLAY, H. (2003) Innovative use of the Internet in established small firms:
the impact of knowledge management and organisational learning in accessing new
opportunities. Qualitative Market Research: An International Journal, 6 (1): 18 - 26.
12
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
SIDDIQUI, N., OMALLEY, A., MCCOLL, J. & BIRTWISTLE, G. (2003) Retailer and
consumer perceptions of online fashion retailers: Web site design issues. Journal of
Fashion Marketing and Management, 7 (4): 345 - 355
SMITH, A. (2004a) Cybercriminal impacts on online business and consumer confidence. Online
Information Review, 28 (3): 224 - 234.
SMITH, A. (2004b) E-security issues and policy development in an information-sharing and
networked environment. Aslib Proceedings, 56 (5): 272 - 285
SMITH, A. & RUPP, W. (2003) Strategic online customer decision making: leveraging the
transformational power of the Internet. Online Information Review, 27 (6): 418 - 432
SMITH, P.R. and CHAFFEY, D. (2005) e-Marketing excellence: at the heart of e-Business.
Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, UK. 2nd edition
STRAUSS, J. and FROST, R. (2001) E-marketing. NJ: Prentice Hall.
TAYLOR, M. & ENGLAND, D. (2006) Internet marketing: web site navigational design issues.
Marketing Intelligence &, 24. (1): 77 - 85
TEO, T. & TAN, J. (2002) Senior executives perceptions of business-to-consumer (B2C) online
marketing strategies: the case of Singapore. Internet Research, 12 (3): 258 - 275
THENG, L. G. and BOON, J. L. W. (1996) An Exploratory Study Of The Factors Affecting The
Failure Of Local Small And Medium Enterprises. Asia Pacific Journal of Management
.13(2): 47-61
WATSON, J. and EVERRET, J. (1996) "Do Small Businesses Have High Failure Rates,
Evidence From Australian Retailers." Journal of Small Business Management
.34(4): 45-62
13
Hatem El-Gohary 16th EDAMBA Summer Academy 2007
WIENTZEN, H.R. (2000), "What is the Internet’s impact on direct marketing today and
tomorrow?", Journal of Interactive Marketing, 14 (3):74-8.
WHITE, G.K. (1997) "International online marketing of foods to US consumers", International
Marketing Review, 14 (5):376-84.
14