Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
http://about.jstor.org/terms
Economic and Political Weekly is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to Economic and Political Weekly
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
ANNA ZIMMER
1 Introduction
While unplanned colonies retain a negative image for
mo say that Delhi is a heterogeneous and rather divided
most city planners, pragmatic reasons favourtheir
city is not new. Indeed, the divide between formal and
regularisation. A large number of Delhi's residents live in
J. informal residential areas within the urban space has
such unauthorised colonies, most of which are now
been problematised in depth,1 as the informal production of
being regularised. But just how many people,urban
and what
space has increasingly been recognised as playing a
large role
changes forthem through regularisation? This process in the making of India's capital when compared to
formal development (Benjamin 2005b: 245; Dupont 2004:
does not come without preconditions, spelled out
311; Water Aid India 2005: 27-31). Consequently a large
through an emphasis on self-enumeration as number
well asof
the
Delhi's inhabitants face the label of informality, or
mandatory formation of resident welfare associations
even illegality.
The effects on the inhabitants of unauthorised colonies
during the application for legal status. Analysing these
(uacs) can be most importantly identified as different forms of
procedures, this article argues that greater inclusiveness
exclusion. There is a large literature on the negative impact of
is offered only to those who adhere to a new themeaning ofinfrastructure provision in informal housing
gap in public
citizenship, focusing on residents' active andarrangements
financial in Delhi, but equally in other Indian cities
(among others Ahmad and Choi 2011; Ali 2003; Batra 2005;
participation in development and governance.
Dupont 2005; gnctd 2006; Selbach 2009; Singh 2009; un
Habitat 2008; Zimmer 2011a). More importantly, residents of
informal areas (together with a large informal workforce) are
often marginalised in terms of decision-making processes, as
urban debates and participatory procedures are dominated by
powerful middle class resident welfare associations (rwas)
(Chakrabarti 2008; Harriss 2010; Kundu 2011; Tawa Lama
Rewal 2007; Zerah 2009; Zimmer 2011a). Moreover, the "right
.
Economic & Political weekly EEE3 july 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 89
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
90 July 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 0EE3 Economic & Political weekly
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
Figure 1: Map of Delhi's Unauthorised Colonies while the smallest is of only 40 residents,6 the largest
houses an impressive 1,50,000 people.7 On average, a
Delhi - Unauthorised Colonies
Built-up Area
total number of uacs, this would mean that an
Green Space
Not Built-up Area astonishing 8.1 million people, or about 49% of
Street
— Railway Line with Station Delhi's inhabitants live in uacs (gnctd Department
of Urban Development 2one).8
. .. Boundary of National Capital
Territory of Delhi
Obviously, these numbers have to be read with
caution. They constitute estimates, figures have
been noted down by residents themselves, and
there may be a certain interest in inflating num
bers. Also, in a number of cases it can be seen that
some uacs have applied twice for regularisation via
competing rwas, so that a number of residents
might have been counted twice. Furthermore, the
total figure is calculated on the basis of an average
as 57.5% of the colonies have not provided data on
population.9 Moreover, not all uacs have been able
to apply for regularisation: e g, south Delhi's afflu
ent farmhouses do not fall under the regularisation
drive, while others might not have been able to as
semble the required papers. The estimate might
therefore actually be still smaller than the real fig
ures. Nevertheless, these numbers represent the
best estimate available till date. They indicate that
Delhi is by and large an informal city - with jj clus
urban fringe (Jain 1990: 172). In 2008, the list of those uacs ters housing another estimated 2.1 million (dusib 2011)10 the
who had applied for regularisation indicated that at least 1,641total percentage of "informal" residents of the capital is as
such colonies existed in Delhi at this point of time.4 No mapsumed to be 64%. They thus constitute almost the absolute ma
has been published on the locations of uacs so far. With thejority of Delhiites. The figures clearly indicate that dreaming of
help of the aforementioned list and the Geographic Informaan orderly and planned capital city means deceiving oneself. It
tion System (gis) provided on the website of the Municipal is high time that political as well as administrative processes
Corporation of Delhi (no date), the majority of uacs whichacknowledge this fact.
have applied for regularisation has been identified and located
3 Unauthorised Colonies'
on the urban map (Figure 1). This process was fraught with
difficulties as spelling of colony names would differ between Perceived Role in the Urban Space
different lists and the gis application, and thus this map canUnauthorised colonies have been interpreted as a response to
only constitute a first attempt at visualising the informal the demand for housing by the lower-middle and working
urban landscape. classes that is not met on the formal market. Land develop
Despite shortcomings, the outcome of this exercise is advan ment policies in Delhi are restrictive and effectively exclude
tageous. It shows for the first time clearly the massive concen private development (Ahmad and Choi 2011: 80-81; Dupont
tration of uacs along the urbanised fringes, especially in 2005: 315-16). As a result, prices for land and housing are
Delhi's western parts. It is here that former agricultural land exorbitantly high in large parts of the capital. However, where
has been incorporated in a private manner into the urban area land is not classified as residential according to the master
- and the future of Delhi's remaining rural areas even furtherplan, land prices are much more accessible. This is the situa
west, south and north can be imagined. tion in which uacs have developed. In the investigated case
Until recently, however, not only the location, but also popuprices were less than 10% of those for plots in adjacent author
lation data on uacs were extremely vague. Estimates of the ised colonies. But this bargain comes at a price: First, the new
population of uacs in the literature vary therefore grossly owners are in fact only leasing their land, house or flat. Sec
between 0.5 and 3 million, or roughly 3-18%, of the population ond, without public infrastructure provision, residents of
of Delhi (Ali 2006: 435; Dupont 2005: 311; gnctd 2009:169; unauthorised colonies often have to invest in installing and
Water Aid India 2005:27).5 In early 2011, applications for uac's upgrading through private means. Only by acquiring voter
regularisation were uploaded on the department's website. identity cards, and thus a political identity as part of an elec
These included in a large number of cases an indication of the toral ward, will some form of public investment occur through
population of the particular residential area. The available the support of elected representatives. However, the use of
figures make it obvious that uacs are extremely heterogeneous:municipal councillors' and members of legislative assembly's
Economic & Political weekly [333 July 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 91
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
funds is restricted in uacs, so that upgrading often happens in clusters or other forms of settlement without lease or owner
a piecemeal, unequal, and rather haphazard manner through ship and settlements of the (extremely) poor (Ghertner 2008;
a variety of funds and channels. Sharan 2006; Zimmer 2011a). They may even represent
Yet, this uneven infrastructural development of uacs has spaces of opportunities in terms of political gains and practi
also a positive side to it: heterogeneous colonies offer today a calities of housing provision. First, uacs hide and compensate
variety of spaces with differential price levels in close proxi for the fact that public housing activities have failed at a grand
mity (Benjamin 2005b: 252). Residents moreover highlight the scale. If more than half of Delhi's residents live in informal
benefit of a differential offer in terms of plot sizes that allowed housing the government faces a major crisis of legitimacy with
people of different economic background to purchase land. regards to its ability to provide (roti, kapda and makan)'3 for
The often mixed land use allows for a reduced amount of time its citizens. In this context, informal housing arrangements
spent travelling between homes and workplaces, helping to cre which provide at least relative security of tenure have lowered
ate localised, sometimes highly specialised, and densely knitted the pressure on government significantly (Bahr and Mertins
economies, as well as encouraging a bust of diverse activities 2000: 23). Second, a number of political opportunities arise.
to maintain urban livelihoods (also found in other types of in Local politicians might build vote banks by arranging for
formal areas, see Benjamin 2005a; Jervis Read 2010: 46). infrastructure and other benefits through informal channels.
The "regularisation" of such informal settlements, Benjamin Also, the government can benefit from an ex post regularisa
(2005b: 245) succinctly states, "is the dominant way cities are tion process, as support for this move helps building up a
built". Yet, the result of this process - the "unintended city" political constituency amongst uac residents (Benjamin
(Nandy 1998: 3) - is not easily accepted, and efforts by the 2005b: 247; Gazdar and Bux Mallah 2012).14 Third, uacs
government to bring Delhi's urbanisation process under control present the unique opportunity for the government to claim
have intensified rather than attenuated in the last years. From development charges for the retrofitting of settlements with
a point of view of urban planning these areas are inherently infrastructure. While costs for these undertakings in formal
flawed for being unplanned, and even in contradiction with colonies are included in property prices, infrastructure provi
the larger plan for the city. sion is nevertheless considered a prime responsibility of the
The ideal of the rational, planned city is obviously not only a state. In uacs however, infrastructure development can be
modern one. Yet, it gained new verve in the context of a inserted into a discourse of responsibility, i e, of cost-sharing
modern governmentality (Foucault 2007:19-20; Scott 1998:4). between the state and its citizens, inculcating a new under
Planning was thus considered "an instrument to achieve standing of citizenship while at the same time penalising the
progress" by the nationalists of independent India (Prakash illegalised residents (a point discussed in more detail below).
2002:4). As early as in 1957, the image of the planned city was While being labelled as informal and thus officially unwanted,
therefore objectified and institutionalised in Delhi's first mas uacs - and the votes, initiatives, or investments of their resi
ter plan (Legg 2006: 201). This plan was based on an "ideology dents - are therefore nevertheless coveted by the administra
of zoning" (Jervis Read 2010: 84)," separating different uses of tion as well as politicians.
the urban space, namely, residential, industrial, and recrea
tional. Because mixed land-use, however, was widespread, 4 Regularisation: Procedural Steps and Political Struggle
this plan created a wide gap between the orderly planned This ambiguous relationship between the state and uacs has
imagined city "as it should be" and the reality, grown out of led to the fact that uacs have enjoyed quite widespread, albeit
the "quiet encroachment of the ordinary" (Bayat 1997:1). tacit tolerance (Lemanski and Tawa Lama-Rewal forthcom
In contradiction to the defined zones, unauthorised colonies ing: 11). Around 786 colonies were legalised in Delhi in the
are in fact the antithesis of the master plan city: they represent 1960s and 1970s (Dupont 2005: 319-20), receiving the odd tag
a constant reminder of planning "failure" - or the failure to of "unauthorised-regularised colonies" (housing yet another
implement the plan and thus the lack of (sovereign) control 12.7% of the city's population, if this figure is more reliable
over the urban territory. This tension, impossible to overlook, than the one on uacs, see gnctd 2009:169). Since 2007, after
produces a kind of master plan angst amongst urban authorities. a gap of more than 30 years, a new round of regularisation is
The Delhi Development Authority (2006: i), for instance, in the on its way promoting the inclusion of uacs into the urban so
introduction to the Delhi Master Plan 2021, states that "[t]he cial and material fabric. For this purpose a separate cell has
choice is between either taking a road to indiscriminate uncon been created within the gnctd Department of Urban Develop
trolled development and slide towards chaos or a movement to ment (The Gazette of India 2008). The bureaucracy's move to
wards making Delhi a world-class city". The dichotomy pre regularise the uacs is depicted as an act of largesse, as the col
sented is between a loss of control described in apocalyptic onies are compared to "an illegitimate child (which) doesn't
terms, and a planned, supposedly bright future. It underlies the stop being a citizen of Delhi", as an interviewee in the Delhi
policy approach to unauthorised colonies,12 where uacs appear Secretariat who wished to remain anonymous put it. While
as potentially "risky" to the urban order and state control. earlier rounds of regularisation highlighted the aim of total
Yet the relationship between the government and unauth state control over the urban territory, the recent drive is differ
orised colonies is not straightforward, uacs have for example been ent in that it is based very prominently on the notion of part
considered less "dangerous" when compared to jhuggi-jhompri nership with uac residents, which we will return to, below.
92 july 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 EH5E3 Economic & Political weekly
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
Economic & Political weekly nran july 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 93
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
"indulging in an illegal act" (Indian Express 2011). Only indepartments in 2010 show that where the forest department
February 2011, the cabinet of Delhi government, on the sughas objected to the regularisation, the Government of India
gestion of a group of ministers, finalised the developmentand the Empowered Committee constituted by the Supreme
charges to be Rs 200/m2, a relatively modest amount. Yet,Court of India have to give clearance. Where the Archaeo
more than 100 resident welfare associations announced their
logical Survey of India (asi) has objected to the regularisation
protest against the decision under the leadership of the bjp of colonies, "an amendment in the asi Act to empower a
(Times of India 2011b). Committee to consider regularisation of such colonies" is
Finally some 733 colonies were informed that they had sought (Lieutenant Governor of Delhi 2010). In these cases it is
received all the required no objection certificates from the difnot clear how long regularisation might take, or indeed, if it
ferent government agencies (gnctd Department of Urban will happen at all. Some actually existing, and built-up uacs
Development 2011b). Since then another list of 285 eligible will remain ineligible and will not benefit from investment.
colonies has been published in July 2011, and their layout plans More problematically, some of these colonies are in danger of
are under scrutiny by the chief town planner, mcd (gnctd demolition or sealing drives and thus housing arrangements
Department of Urban Development 2011a). In the meantime remain very insecure.
(as seen in Figure 2), financial resources have been allocated
and spent by the Delhi government to provide facilities in 5 The Politics of Enumeration: Engaging UAC Residents
uacs, and public works are under way in several areas after through Technologies of Citizenship
the administrative approval for development in 28 colonies The above sections have made it clear that in the process of
had been given to the mcd commissioner, Delhi Jal Board, the regularisation, enumeration, along with the creation of resi
Irrigation and Flood Control Department and the Delhi State dent welfare associations and the payment of certain penalties
Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation. Worksand duties are the most important contributions residents have
concern mainly the construction of roads, outfall drains, water to make. They have also shown that residents have had to in
supply as well as (in one case) sewer lines.18 vest a lot of time to apply for regularisation and that results of
At the same time, the scrutiny of layout plans revealed inthe drive are not yet clearly discernible. So how should we un
late 2011 that 127 colonies did not meet the criteria of beingderstand the political content of regularisation more precisely?
50% built up by 2007. The rwas of these colonies then received In my opinion, the process can be read as a coupling of three
a show-cause notice, to which 73 did not reply, raising serious different dynamics. First, as regularisation is inextricably linked
doubts about a land scam set up between the land mafia and with enumeration and location, it increases the visibility of uacs
local administrative staff and politicians. It was speculatedand aims undoubtedly at gathering data on this vast population.
that vacant land had been declared to be occupied by unau From a Foucauldian point of view, visibility is not a neutral,
thorised colonies in order to apply for regularisation and thus given feature. Rather, visibility or invisibility are produced
increase the land value (gnctd Department of Urban Develop (Dean 2010: 40). States for example seek to create visibility of
ment 2011c; Kumar 2011; Hindustan Times 2011). A report by citizens and spaces in order to attain control through fear of
Divisional Commissioner Vijay Dev was commissioned on the punishment and subsequent self-government of their subjects
issue of provision of provisional regularisation certificates (Foucault 1991). The enumeration of uacs can therefore be
(Financial Express 2012). As a result, and following heated disregarded as a form of surveillance authorities might want to
cussions between the Delhi government and the opposition, 40 establish for tighter control of the city and its inhabitants.
provisional regularisation certificates have been cancelled in Second, inhabitants are not only registered through a gov
February 2012 (gnctd Department of Urban Development 2012a). ernment-led census or registrar office, but also have to under
The landowning agencies were asked to reclaim the vacant take enumeration and data compilation themselves. These
lands and the report recommended criminal prosecution against self-enumerating practices have been associated in the past
the actors of the scam (Financial Express 2012; Times of India with liberating technologies of a "civic governmentality" (Roy
2012). Most recently, the Delhi Lokayukta has issued a show 2009) and a democratic upsurge from below (Appadurai
cause notice to the Delhi government to clarify the application 2001). They have been described as being able to "infiltrat(...)
of criteria for regularisation, and the procedure of distribution [e] the very categories through which rule is accomplished"
of provisional regularisation certificates (The Hindu 2012). (Menon 2010: 151). Certainly, there is an immense difference
Aside from possible criminal activities, other colonies didbetween a self-enumeration drive, in which informal residents
not meet the regularisation criteria because of their proximity have control over the data, and a government-initiated
to forestland, a right of way, or protected archaeological collection of data by residents. Yet, even in the former case,
monuments, as noted above. Development is not supposed toauthors have cautioned against the disciplinary effects of self
take place "where the agencies such as dda, asi, revenue or surveillance (Ley 2008), and the danger of co-option of
forest have objected (...) regarding regularisation" (gnctd gathered data by the state (Roy 2009: 165). Rather than
Department of Urban Development 2009), and special admin dwelling on the aspect of surveillance here, I propose to read
istrative provisions seem to have been agreed upon for these the self-enumeration in the context of the regularisation
cases. The minutes of a meeting of the lieutenant governor, theprocess as a "technology of citizenship" (Cruikshank 1994; Dean
minister of urban development, the dda, mcd, and other 2010: 199). These technologies of government aim to control
94 july 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 EH323 Economic & Political weekly
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
Economic & Political weekly EHZ3 july 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 95
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
NOTES 18 The full list of colonies in which administrative Cruikshank, B (1994): "The Will to Empower
approval has been given can be found at GNCTD Technologies of Citizenship and the War on
1 This dualistic representation of housing prac
Department of Urban Development (2012b). Poverty", Socialist Review, 23 (4): 29-55.
tices in cities has been criticised for being overly
19 Ghertner (2010a: 192) describes a similar strate Dean, M (2010): Governmentality: Power and Ru
rigid and missing out on the various hybrid
gy of the state, where JJC residents in the 1990s in Modern Society (London: Sage Publications)
practices of citizens (Etzold et al 2009, Leman
were "draw[n] (...) into the practice of govern Dupont, V (2004): "Socio-Spatial Differentiatio
ski and Tawa Lama-Rewal forthcoming). The
ment" by holding out the prospect of resettle and Residential Segregation in Delhi: A Ques
use of both labels is nevertheless widespread
ment in return for cooperation in slum surveys. tion of Scale?", Geoforum, 35157-75.
especially in policymaking and therefore they
reveal to have real impacts on citizens' lives - (2005): "Residential Practices, Creation and
which fall in one or the other category. REFERENCES Use of Urban Space: Unauthorised Colonies in
2 DUSIB (2011), "Our Objectives and Mission", Delhi" in E Hust and M Mann (ed.), Urbani
Ahmad, S and M J Choi (2011): "The Context of Governance in India (New Delhi:
sation and
http://delhishelter.nic.in/, viewed on 9 June.
Uncontrolled Urban Settlements in Delhi",CSH, South Asia Institute), 311-41.
Manohar,
This information is no longer available on the site.
Asien, 118, 75-90.
3 This research took place in the context of my PhD. DUSIB (2011): "List of JJ Clusters", http://delhish
Ahmad, Z (2011): "Urban Transformations andviewed on 9 June 2011.
ter.nic.in/,
4 This is the number of UACs that have applied
'Unclean' Occupations: An Ethnography of R
Delhi's
for regularisation. DDA (no date) - list of Dutta, and Peace Institute Charitable Trust (2009
Muslim Butchers", Presentation at the CSH-CPR
1,432 unauthorised colonies sent by GNCTD "Unquiet River: An Overview of Select Decisions
Urban Workshop Series, New Delhi, 26 April.
(unpublished). of the Courts on the River Yamuna", http://www.
Ali, S (2003): Environmental Situation peaceinst.0rg/publicati0n/b00k-let/The%20
of Slums in
5 When calculating on the basis of the 2011India
popu (New Delhi: Uppal Publishing House).
lation figure for Delhi.
Unquiet%2oRiver%2oAn%2oOverview%2o
- (2006): "Managing Slums in Delhi" in S Ali
of%2oSelect%2oDecisions%2oof%2othe%2o
6 Sad Nagar Left Out Pocket, Mangla (ed.),
Puri Managing Urban Poverty (New Delhi:
Courts%2oon%2othe%2oRiver%2oYamuna.pdf,
Chowk, and Palam Colony. Uppal Publishing House), 432-53. viewed on 10 January 2010.
7 Sangam Vihar, L-Block. Appadurai, A (2001): "Deep Democracy:
Etzold, B,Urban
H Bohle, M Keck and W Zingel (2009):
8 These documents are for 1641 UACs who have
Governmentality and the Horizon of"Informality
Politics", as Agency - Negotiating Food Se
applied for regularisation. The actual number
Environment and Urbanisation, 13 (2): 23-43.
curity in Dhaka", Die Erde, 140 (1): 3-24.
of UAC residents might therefore inBahr,
fact be
J and G Mertins (2000): "Marginalviertel in Financial Express (2012): "Reclaim Land in 43
even higher than that. GroBstadten der Dritten Welt", Geographische
Illegal Colonies, Government Tells DDA",
9 The documents vary, and not all UACs have
Rundschau, 52 (7-8): 19-26. http://www.financialexpress.com/news/
handed in the page entitled "Application forB (2005): "Entitlement to Services and
Batra, reclaim-land-in-43-illegal-colonies-govt-tells
Unauthorised Colonies to be Considered for
Amenities in JJ Clusters, JJ Relocation Colo
dda/910681/, viewed on 23 April.
Regularisation". It is not clear whether the nies and Other Non-planned Settlements in
Foucault, M (1991): Discipline and Punish: The Birth
ministry's regularisation documents have Delhi: An Overview", www.isst-india.org/PDF/
of Prison (London: Penguin Books).
changed in the course of the process, or certain Entitlement%2oto%2oServices.pdf, viewed on
- (2007): Security, Territory, Population: Lectures
RWAs have not handed this specific document 25 July 2010.
back. Also, the document might simply not at the College De France 1977-78 (Houndsmills:
Batra, L and D Mehra (2008): "Slum Demolitions
have been uploaded on the website. Palgrave Macmillan).
and Production of Neo-liberal Space. Delhi" in
Gazdar, H and H Bux Mallah (2012): "The Making
10 In the literature and documents of government D Mahadevia (ed.), Inside the Transforming Urban
of a 'Colony' in Karachi and the Politics of Reg
agencies, numbers of inhabitants are usually Asia: Processes, Policies and Public Actions (New
calculated by multiplying the number of dwell Delhi: Concept Publishing Company), 391-414. South Asia Multidisciplinary Aca
ularisation",
ings by five. Recent figures of Delhi Urban Shel demic Journal, (5): no pages.
Baud, I, M Kuffer, K Pfeffer, R Sliuzas and R Karup
Ghertner, A (2008): "Analysis of New Legal Dis
ter Improvement Board indicate that 4,18,282 pannan (2010): "Understanding Heterogeneity
jhuggis exist in Delhi to date. course Behind Delhi's Slum Demolitions",
in Metropolitan India: The Added Value of
11 For a more elaborate discussion on zoning in Remote Sensing Data for AnalysingEconomic Sub-stand
& Political Weekly, 34 (20): 57-66.
Delhi see Sharan (2006:4909). Ghertner,
ard Residential Areas", International Journal A (2010a):
of "Calculating Without Num
12 And more so, the approach to the even less Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation,bers: Aesthetic Governmentality in Delhi's
planned jhuggi-jhompri clusters. 12 (5): 359-74 Slums", Economy and Society, 39 (2): 185-217.
13 Bread, clothes, and housing. - (2010b):
Bayat, A (1997): Street Politics: Poor People's "Green Evictions: Environmental Dis
Movements
courses of a "Slum-Free" Delhi" in R Peet, P Rob
14 Benjamin (2005b: 247) also suggests that regu in Iran (New York: Columbia University Press).
Benjamin, S (2005a): 'Productive Slums'.
larisation is a way of expanding the autonomy bins The
and MCenWatts (ed.), Global Political Ecology
of the municipality vis-a-vis the state and trality of Urban Land in Shaping Employment (London and New York: Routledge) 145-65.
national government. However, the recent reg and City Politics (Cambridge (MA): GNCTDLincoln
(2006): "Delhi Human Development Report
ularisation drive in Delhi has been initiated by Institute of Land Policy). 2006" (New Delhi: Oxford University Press).
the state government. - (2009):
- (2005b): "Touts, Pirates and Ghosts" in Economic
Sarai, Survey 2008-09, http://
delhi.gov.in/wps/wcm/connect/DoIT_
15 Colonies are categorised in classes from A to H CSDS and Society for Old and New Media (ed.),
depending on the unit area value and pertain The Sarai Reader 2005: Bare Acts (New Planning/planning/economic+survey+of+
Delhi:
ing property tax (Municipal Corporation of Sarai & Society for Old and New Media), dehli/economic+survey+of+delhi+08+--1-09/
242-54.
Delhi 2011). Black, M and B Fawcett (2008): The economic+survey+of+delhi+2oo8++2oo9%
Last Taboo:
16 Despite extensive research, the original ruling Opening the Door on the Global Sanitation 28english%29, viewed on 29 August 2011.
was not accessible. Crisis (London: Earthscan). - (no date): "Bhagidari", http://www.delhigovt.
17 Resident welfare associations have a long his Chakrabarti, P (2008): "Inclusion or nic.in/bhagi.asp,
Exclusion? viewed on 20 January 2010.
tory in Delhi's colonies, including UACs. In the Emerging Effects of Middle-Class GNCTD
CitizenDepartment
Par of Urban Development
investigated case, the earliest RWA was formed ticipation on Delhi's Urban Poor", IDS(2009): "F No i-33/UC/UD/2007/Pt-III Order",
Bulletin,
in 1985. These early associations were engaged 38 (6): 96-104. http://delhi.gov.in/wps/wcm/connect/dan
in long struggles for the provision of a govern Chaturvedi, B ed. (2010): Finding Delhi: 6ooo4fe8b67eb399bbd9dib46642/order.PDF?
Loss and
ment primary school as well as street infra Renewal in the Megacity (New Delhi: MOD=AJPERES8tlmod=1282342378,
Penguin viewed on
structure (Zimmer 2011a: 203-05). Books India). 31 August 2011.
96 july 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 EEE3 Economic & Political weekly
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms
REVIEW OF URBAN AFFAIRS
- (2011a): "F No 530/UC/UD/2011/-7442 TentaAsia: A Macro Overview", Economic & Political Srivastava, S (2009): "Urban Spaces, Disney-Divinity
tive List of 285 Unauthorised Colonies for the Weekly, 44 (48): 48-58. and Moral Middle Classes in Delhi", Economic &
scrutiny of Layout Plans", http://delhi.gov.in/
Kundu, D (2011): "Elite Capture in Participatory Political Weekly, 44(26 & 27): 338-45.
wps/wcm/connect/96d3788o47ai797oa226a6 Urban Governance", Economic & Political Tawa Lama-Rewal, S (2007): "Neighbourhood
5e985ifb52/285listscanned.pdf?MOD=AJPER Weekly, 46 (10): 23-25. Associations and Local Democracy: Delhi
ES&lmod=ioi477i936, viewed on 31 August.Lefebvre, B (2009): Le droit a la ville (Paris: Municipal Elections 2007", Economic & Politi
- (2011b): "List of 733 Unauthorised] ColoniesAnthropos). cal Weekly, 42(47): 51-60.
for Scrutiny of Layout Plans", http://delhi.gov.
Legg, S (2006): "Post-Colonial Developmentalities: - (forthcoming): "Participation as a Support to
in/wps/wcm/connect/eidodfoo46e8cadba7a From the Delhi Improvement Trust to the Delhi Neo-populism? The Case of the Bhagidari
dff96nfe9500/733+list.pdf?M0D=AJPERES Development Authority" in S Raju, M S Kumar Scheme" in K Coelho, L Kamath and M Vijaya
&lmod=ni4i2i73&CACHEID=eidodfoo46e8c and S Corbridge (ed.), Colonial and Post-colonial baskar (ed.), Participolis, Consent and Conten
adba7adff96iife9500&lm0d=ni4i2i73&CAC Geographies of India (New Delhi: Sage Publica tion in Neo-liberal Urban Governance (Delhi:
HEID=eidodfoo46e8cadba7adff96nfe950o&l tions), 182-204. Routledge), 198-211.
mod=ni4i2i73&CACHEID=eidodfoo46e8cad
Lemanski, C and S Tawa Lama-Rewal (forthcom The Gazette of India (2008): "Extraordinary: Part II,
ba7adff96nfe9500, viewed on 12 July. Section 3, Sub-Section II", http://www.deM.
ing): "The 'Missing Middle': Class and Urban
- (2011c): "List of Colonies Who Have Been Governance in Delhi's Unauthorised Colonies", gov.n1/wps/wcm/connect/a925aeoo4fe8b
Issued, Show Cause Notice", http://delhi.gov. Transactions of the Institute of British Geogra io7b38fbbd9dib46642/published+by+ autho
in/wps/wcm/connect/DOIT_UDD/urban+ de phers, 1-15. rity.PDF?MOD=AJPERES&CACHEID=a925aeo
velopment/unauthorised+colonies+under+th 04fe8bi07b38fbbd9dib46642, viewed on 15
Ley, A (2008): "Moving Targets as a Coping Strate
e+jurisdiction+of+government+of+nct+of+ February 2011.
gy: Rethinking Emergent Patterns and Relations
delhi/127+list,viewed on 23 April 2012. The Hindu (2010): "MCD Seeks Power of Regulari
of Organised Urban Poor Groups", presentation
- (2ond): "Unauthorised Colonies Cell (UC)", at the 8th Berlin Roundtable on Transnationali sation of Unauthorised Colonies", http://www.
http://delhi.gov.in/wps/wcm/connect/DOIT_ ty: "Collective Identities, Governance and Em thehindu.c0m/news/cities/Delhi/article5900
UDD/urban+development/our+services/unau powerment in Megacities", Berlin, 11-16 June. 09.ece, viewed on 11 November.
thorised+colonies+cells+%28uc%29/introduLieutenant Governor of Delhi (2010): "Minutes of - (2011): "Regularisation of Illegal Colonies a
ction, viewed on 30 September 2009. Sham: BJP", http://www.thehindu.com/news/
the Meeting Regarding Regularisation of Un
- (2one): "Unauthorised Colonies under the authorised Colonies and Finalisation of Plan for cities/Delhi/articleio63284.ece?css=print,
Jurisdiction of GNCTD", http://delhi.gov.in/ the Special Area Held at Raj Niwas on 5 March viewed on 28 March.
wps/wcm/connect/doit_udd/Urban+ Develo 2010", http://lgdelhi.nic.in/min_meeting. html, - (2012): "Lokayukta Notice to Government over
pment/Our+Services/Unauthorized+Colonies viewed on 2 October 2011. Provisional Certificates for Illegal Colonies",
+Cells+%28UC%29/Unauthorised+Colonies Mehra, D (2011): "Politics and Protesting Publics in http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Delhi/
+under+the+Jurisdiction+of+GNCT+of+
Urban India: Reflections from the 2006 Sealing article30i5770.ece?css=print, viewed on 23 April.
Delhi, viewed on 29 March.
Drive and the World of New Delhi's Traders", The Hindustan Times (2011): "One Hundred Twenty
- (2012a): "Fourty Unauthorised Colonies Who presentation at the CSH-CPR Urban Workshop five Unauthorised Colonies Get One Week to
PRC Cancelled Out of 127", http://delhi.gov.
Series, New Delhi, 27 September. Reply to Government Notice", http://www.hin
in/wps/wcm/connect/DOIT_UDD/urban+ Menon, G (2010): "The Clandestine Politics ofPave dustantimes.com/StoryPage/PrinU776287.aspx,
development/unauthorised+colonies+under+ ment Dwellers in Mumbai" in McMichael, viewed on 23 April 2012.
the +jurisdiction+of+government+of+nct+ofP (ed.), Contesting Development, Critical Strug The Pioneer (2009): "Great Regularisation Hoax",
+delhi/prc+cancelled, viewed on 23 April. gles for Social Change (New York and Oxon: The Pioneer.
- (2012b): "Unauthorised Colonies Cell", http://
Routledge), 151-64. Times of India (2011a): "MCD Opposes Levying of
delhi.gov.in/wps/wcm/connect/doit_udd/ Municipal Corporation of Delhi (2011): "Online Prop Development Charges in Illegal Colonies",
Urban+ Development/Our+Services/Unauthoriz http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/
erty Tax", http://www.mcdpropertytax. in/de
ed+Colonies+Cells+%28UC%29/, viewed on 23tail.php?id=io#multifacti, viewed on 17 July. MCD-opposes-levying-of-development-charges
April.
- (2011): "MCD Citizens GIS Portal", http://app. in-illegal-colonies/articleshow/73i4775.cms,
GNCTD Planning Department (2011): "Plan mapmyindia.com/mcdApp/, viewed on 23 June.
viewed on 28 March.
Documents: Eleventh Five-Year Plan 2007-12", - (2011b): "RWAs of Unauthorised Colonies to
Nandy, A (1998): "Introduction: Indian Popular Cin
http://www.delhi.gov.in/wps/wcm/connect/ Protest against Development Fee", http://time
ema as a Slum's Eye View of Politics" in A Nandy
DoIT_Planning/planning/our+services/ sofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/RWAs-of
(ed.), The Secret Politics of Our Desires: Inno
plan+documents, viewed on 8 April. unauthorised-colonies-to-protest-against-deve
cence, Culpability and Indian Popular Cinema
Harriss, J (2007): "Antinomies of Empowerment", (New York: Palgrave Macmillan), 1-18. lopment-fee/articleshow/753552o.cms, viewed
Economic & Political Weekly, 42(26): 2716-24. on 28 March.
Prakash, G (2002): "The Urban Turn" in Sarai,
- (2010): 'Participation' and Contestation in the CSDS and Society for Old and New Media (ed.), - (2012): "Report on Scam Moots Action against
Governance of Indian Cities (Vancouver: School for Officials", http://articles.timesofindia. indiati
Sarai Reader 02: The Cities of Everyday Life
International Studies, Simon Fraser University). mes.com/2012-02-04/delhi/31024157_1_unau
(New Delhi and Amsterdam: Sarai 8t Society
Hazards Centre ed. (2005): Draft Delhi Master Plan for Old and New Media), 2-7. thorised-colonies-inquiry-report-rwas, viewed
2021: Blueprint for an Apartheid City, New Delhi. on 23 April.
Roy, A (2009): "Civic Governmentality: The Poli
Indian Express (2010): "Unauthorised Colonies: tics of Inclusion in Beirut and Mumbai", Anti UN Habitat (2008): State of the World's Cities 2010-11,
Civic Bodies to Make Layout Plans", http:// pode, 41 (1): 159~79 Bridging the Urban Divide (Nairobi: UN-Habitat).
www.indianexpress.com/news/unauthorised Scott, J (1998): Seeing Like a State: How Certain UNESCO and CSH (forthcoming): Urban Policies
colonies-civic-bodies-to-make-layout-plans/ Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have and the Right to the City in India: Rights, Re
569400/0, viewed on 6 June. sponsibilities and Citizenship, Research Policy
Failed (New Haven: Yale University Press).
- (2011): "Delhi's Unauthorised Colonies Turn Paper (New Delhi: UNESCO & CSH).
Selbach, V (2009): "Wasserversorgung und
Legal", http://www.indianexpress.com/story Verwundbarkeit in der Megastadt Delhi/ Unique Identification Authority of India (2011):
print/747157/, viewed on 3 March. Indien", thesis submitted to the Geographisches "Why Aadhaar Number?" http://uidai.gov.in/
Jain, A K (1990): The Making of a Metropolis (New Institut, Universitat zu Koln, http://kups.ub.uni index. php?option=com_content&view=article
Delhi: National Book Organisation). koeln.de/286o/i/Selbach_Diss_Publikation_ &id=58&Itemid=io6, viewed on 4 October.
Jervis Read, C (2010): "Making Delhi Like Paris: 3.pdf, 3 July 2011 Water Aid India (2005): "Profiling 'Informal City'
Space and the Politics of Development in an Sharan, A (2006): "In the City, Out of Place: Envi of Delhi: Policies, Norms, Institutions & Scope
East Delhi Resettlement Colony", thesis sub ronment and Modernity, Delhi 1860s to 1960s", of Intervention", http://www.wateraid.org/
mitted to the Department of Anthropology, Economic & Political Weekly, 41 (47): 4905-11. documents/plugin_ documents/ profiling_ of_
University of Sussex. Singh, R (2009): "Wastewater Problems and Social delhi_i.pdf, viewed on 7 February 2009.
Kabeer, N ed. (2005): Inclusive Citizenship: Mean Vulnerability in Megacity Delhi/India", thesis Zerah, M-H (2009): "Participatory Governance in
ings and Expressions, Claiming Citizenship, submitted to the Department of Geography, Urban Management and the Shifting Geometry
Rights, Participation and Accountability (Lon University of Cologne, http://kups.ub.uni of Power in Mumbai", Development and Change,
don and New York: Zed Books). koeln.de/2819/i/Thesisreenasingh.pdf, 40 (5): 853-77
Kumar, Rajesh (2011): "RWAs of 73 Non-Existent 13 July 2011. Zimmer, A (2011a): "Everyday Governance of the
Colonies Absconding'", The Pioneer, 22 Decem Srirangan, K (2000): "Public Land and Property Waste Waterscapes, A Foucauldian Analysis in
ber. http://www.dailypioneer.com/city/29685 Development and Cross-subsidisation for Low Delhi's Informal Settlements", thesis Submitted to
rwas-of-73-non-existent-colonies-absconding. income Housing in Delhi", http://www.dfid. the Department of Geography University of Bonn.
html, viewed on 23 April 2012. gov.uk/R4D//pdf/outputs/R686oI.pdf, viewed - (2011b): "Slums in Indien - ein Uberblick",
Kundu, A (2009): "Exclusionary Urbanisation in on 30 January 2008. Sildasien, 31(02): 31-34.
Economic & Political weekly E32Q july 28, 2012 vol xlvii no 30 97
This content downloaded from 128.122.230.132 on Sun, 20 May 2018 06:11:20 UTC
All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms