Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Technical report
PII: S0261-3069(10)00388-2
DOI: 10.1016/j.matdes.2010.06.013
Reference: JMAD 3182
Please cite this article as: Rahman, M.M., Nor, S.S.M., Rahman, H.Y., Investigation on the Effect of Lubrication
and Forming Parameters to the Green Compact Generated from Iron Powder through Warm Forming Route,
Materials and Design (2010), doi: 10.1016/j.matdes.2010.06.013
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers
we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Investigation on the Effect of Lubrication and Forming Parameters to the Green Compact
e-mail: mujibur@uniten.edu.my
Abstract
In order to generate green compacts of iron ASC 100.29 powder at above ambient temperature and
below its recrystallization temperature, a warm compaction rig is designed and fabricated which
can be operated at various temperature and load. The aim of this paper is to present the outcomes
of an investigation on the effect of lubrication and forming parameters, i.e, load and temperature
to the green compacts generated through warm compaction route. The feedstock was prepared by
mechanically mixing the main powder constituent, i.e, iron ASC 100.29 powder with different
weight percent of zinc stearate at different mixing time. Compaction load was varied from
105 kN to 125 kN using simultaneous compaction mechanism. The microstructures of the green
compacts were analyzed by Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), and the mechanical properties
are measured through density measurement, hardness test and electrical conductivity test. The
study found that increase in compaction load as well as forming temperature give improved
microstructure and mechanical properties. It is also found that effects of lubrication to the
mechanical properties of green compacts are strongly dependant on the lubricant content as well
*
Corresponding author. Tel: +6 03 89287269; Fax: +6 03 89212116
1
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
1. Introduction
Nowadays, the number of engineering components and automotive parts manufactured from
shaped and sintered metal powders has been increasing. In the last three decades, a wide range of
structural components especially for the use as automotive parts has been developed for production
using this method [1]. Most of them are manufactured by a process called die compaction method
through warm forming route or conventional cold forming route. The production of solid
components from powders by compaction and sintering is known as powder metallurgy, which has
been existence since the early nineteen hundreds as a new generation of manufacturing process [2].
container to a desired shape. The compacted powder mass is called a green compact, which only
has sufficient strength to be handled for further treatment [3]. Powder compaction is an attractive
main objective in powder forming process is to obtain green compacts with relatively high density
and uniform density distribution in the component [4]. Metal powder may be compacted either at
which is warm compaction, which was introduced in the market in 1994 [5].
Compaction process involves the transfer of pressure to each particle contained in the
powder. Generally, the compaction mechanism relates directly to the density and the pressure [6].
When a powder is being compacted in a rigid cylindrical die, the axial pressure exerted upon the
powder by the compaction punch is only partly transformed to radial pressure upon the die wall.
This radial pressure can be quite substantial but it does not reach the level of the axial pressure
because the powder is not a liquid and does not have any hydraulic properties [7]. Aggregates of
metallic particles are considered as frictional, nearly non-cohesive and granular [8]. When the load
acts upon the powder in the die cavity, the powder deforms plastically. Each of the particles fills
the gap among them. This results in reduction of pores. This means, density increases inside the
2
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
compacted powder. During compaction, powder exhibits strain or work hardening, the volume
Previous study on the effect of temperature to the deformation of powder has been
conducted by Wechsler [10]. The study found that, the strength of the product is less dependent on
forming temperature and pressure, but is strongly influenced by density, particle size and shape.
However, an experimental work on microscopic aspect has been conducted by Gagne [11] in
classifying the behavior of metal powder under compaction at 23°C and 150°C using Scanning
Electron Microscope (SEM). This work showed that there is influence of temperature to the
particle arrangement in powder compact. It also found that there are interaction forces among
powder particles where this phenomenon lead to the enhancement of the strength of the green
compacts.
The influence of temperature to yield point of green compact has been presented by
Höganäs [12] and stated that at higher temperature, the green compact experiences lower value of
yield point. This principle of a temperature-dependant yield point emerges from the theoretical
hysteresis curves. The curves clarified that maximum radial pressure increases but the residual
pressure, after complete release of the axial pressure, decreases when the yield point is lowered at
elevated temperatures. Therefore, it can be stated that the deformation of metal can be looked upon
as thermally activated process [13]. Warm compaction experiments at forming temperature from
100°C to 150°C are conducted and reported in [14], also found to obtain a green densification level
of greater than 98%. Furthermore, Rahman [15] has presented the experimental work on a full
cycle of warm powder compaction process that shows a decreasing trend of friction with the
The optimum forming temperature in generating crack-free green compacts is important for
obtaining the most effective production system. Rutz et al. [16] has found that the optimum
temperature for ferrous powder during the warm compaction is 145°C. However, no further
3
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
evidence from other researches is found to support this finding. In powder compaction process, a
considerable friction is generated which is the major cause of density variation throughout the
powder compact and also affects the component deformation [17]. Inter-particle and particle to die
wall friction also hinders pressure transmission and therefore produces density gradients inside the
compact [14]. The friction also generates some amount of heat that affects the compaction process
Previous researchers such as Rahman [15], Tabata et al. [18], Tran et al. [19], Ariffin [20],
Aidah [21], and Khoei & Lewis [22] worked on powder compaction including the study of friction.
The understanding of friction phenomenon in warm powder compaction enhances the capability in
solving the compaction problem numerically. They showed that friction is caused largely by
powder-die wall interaction and inter-particle friction among the powder particles. Therefore, there
is a need to use the lubricant as friction reduction agent. Two types of lubrication method that have
been studied by previous researchers, i.e., admixed and die wall lubrication method. However, this
study concentrates only on the admixed lubrication method, since die wall lubrication method
needs to manufacture high technology die that incurs extra manufacturing cost.
The use of an admixed lubricant may create problems in compaction, and it is therefore
important that the lubricant is well suited to the type of compaction carried out. In order to
generate defect-free green compacts, the lubricant should be forced out from the pore structure of
the powder composition during the compaction operation. Another reason to remove the lubricant
from the compact is that it would otherwise create pores in the compact after sintering. It is well-
known that large pores have an adverse effect on the dynamic strength properties of the product
[23]. Another problem in using the lubricant is that most of the lubricants used in cold compaction
cannot be used for the compaction at elevated temperature, since they seem to be effective within a
4
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Interesting findings reported by Zhornyak & Oliker [24] on the optimization of zinc stearate
content in ensuring the greatest compressibility of a powder. The higher the density of a compact
and the smaller the pore size, the smaller is the amount of zinc stearate it can hold. The weakening
action of zinc stearate, which manifests itself in stress relief at inter-particle contacts during
pressing, substantially increases the density of compacts and at the same time decreases their
strength. This phenomenon is particularly pronounced with compacts from poor compactibility
powders. After pressing at any given pressure, the strength of a compact with zinc stearate is
higher than the strength of a compact without lubricant. This is due to the decrease of the contact
surface brought about by the elastic aftereffect in the zinc stearate which is counterbalanced by the
increase of this surface resulting from better compressibility of the powder. They found that the
addition of an optimum amount of zinc stearate to the iron powder is always more effective than
Previous researches have given significant knowledge on powder compaction involving its
parametric analysis. However, all reported research works have been conducted at the maximum
researchers considered just only involving the weight percent of lubricant without considering the
importance of mixing time. Therefore, this study concentrates in expanding the scope of warm
compaction parameters by considering different loading, lubricant content, mixing time as well as
forming temperature.
2. Experimental Works
A lab-scale warm compaction tool was designed and manufactured (Figure 1) which enabled the
generation of cylindrical shape green compacts. Iron powder ASC 100.29 was used during the
experiment because this type of powder is normally used in most of the powder compaction
industries [29, 30]. The as received powder has the particle size range of 20-180 µm. The powder
5
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
manufactured by Höganäs AB Company has the composition of 1.5% Cu, 0.5% Mo, and 4% Ni
multi axial compaction mechanism. Four point heaters (50 Watt each) are attached to the
cylindrical shape die. The forming temperature is ranged from 30°C to 180°C while the
compaction load is ranged from 105 kN to 125 kN. However, the lubrication study is conducted at
constant compaction load of 80 kN in order to focus only on the effect of lubricant content and the
mixing time.
The generated green compacts are tested for their microstructure and mechanical
properties in order to evaluate the influences of the parameter applied. Scanning Electron
Microscopy (Quanta 400, Serial Number 4022 262 32071, Manufactured by Fei Company) is used
for observing only the iron powder particle arrangements. Mechanical properties are analyzed
through density measurement, Rockwell hardness (HRF) test, tensile test, and electrical resistivity
test. Fill density was obtained by dividing the mass of the powder required to fully fill the die
cavity by the volume of the die cavity. Green density was measured by dividing the mass of the
green compact by the volume of the green compact. The hardness of the compact was measured
by digital Rockwell hardness tester. Steel ball of diameter 1/16 inch was used as indenter with the
load of 60 kg. The compact was placed on the platform which was moved upward by the rotating
wheel. Upon contact with the ball indenter on the top of the sample, a reading appeared at the
The bending strength of each compact was measured through the Instron Universal Testing
machine. The compact was hold tightly at both ends when a transverse force is applied at the
middle of the compact. All data such as elongation, maximum stress and maximum strength were
collected through the data acquisition system in the computer until the compact fractured or broke
down. Electrical resistivity is obtained by measuring the electrical resistance of the green compact
6
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
by a multimeter. The red and black pointers of the multimeter were placed at both ends of the
green compact and the reading was recorded once it was stable.
Figure 2 presents the micrograph of green compacts formed at different load and temperature. It
shows that lower compaction pressure gives poor particle adhesion, and even some macropores are
found in the sample formed by 105 kN at 30°C forming temperature (Figure 2b, d). Calcination
caused fusion among particles, and it can be found in the sample formed by 125 kN at
170°C (Figure 2a) which showed almost perfect particle fusion by leaving no particle boundaries.
An increasing trend of relative density with respect to compaction pressure is obtained for
the compaction at every forming temperature (Figure 3). At elevated temperature, the green
compact requires less pressure to achieve higher relative density. This phenomenon shows that
temperature is an important factor in reducing applied pressure in obtaining higher relative density.
This finding strengthens the established theory which stated that the deformation of metals can be
looked upon as a thermally activated process where both the elastic and inelastic deformations are
affected [25].
Figure 4 shows that higher weight percent of zinc stearate in powder mass contributes to
lower load needed for the same deformation. Zinc stearate is fused during the compaction
pressure, penetrated between particles of the iron powder by capillary force, and is uniformly
dispersed in the particles so as to decrease the contact resistance between the particles, accelerating
the rearrangement of the particles, and accelerating the increase in density of the compact [26].
Density is the ratio between the mass of a compact and its volume whereas relative density is the
ratio between the instantaneous density and the true density of a compact produced from the same
material. Higher relative density means the lower volume. Therefore, higher weight percent of zinc
stearate requires lower load in obtaining the maximum displacement means lower volume hence
7
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
It is also found that a longer mixing time improved the density of the green compact. The
mixing time of 60 minutes has been found to be more effective compared to 30 minutes (Figure 4).
The reason is that longer mixing time gives more space and chances to the lubricant to fully
assimilate with the powder. The more uniform zinc stearate dispersion inside powder mass, the
more iron particles have the chance to slide between each other during compaction, thus increases
the density of green compact. As the function of lubricant to the powder mass is to increase the
flowability of iron particles and promoting free spaces to be filled, it is important that the lubricant
to be forced out from the powder mass [23]. In order to achieve this purpose, longer mixing time
has been tested in this research referring to the studies reported in [31-35].
Figure 4 also illustrates the effect of mixing time to the densification of powder mass
mixing time during the preparation of powder mass is due to the tendency of flowing granular
material mixture to segregate [31]. Because of the difference in density and particle size,
segregation occurs [32] where lower density particles, in this case, zinc stearate concentrates at the
periphery of the powder mass [31]. During die filling, assuming all the powder particles at its final
mixing position, significant amount of zinc state is located at the inter phase between powder mass
and die wall. Therefore, this amount of zinc state contributes to the lower friction between die wall
and the powder mass. This shows that, study on mixing time has expanded the function of zinc
Figures 5 and 6 show the hardness variation of green compacts formed at different forming
temperatures and lubricant contents. It clearly shows that 0.6wt% zinc stearate produced harder
green compacts both at 30 and 60 mixing time. The graphs also show that green compacts
generated at higher temperature are harder than formed at lower temperature. The improvement of
hardness is due to the increase in density obtained by warm compaction. As the temperature
increases, the particles are brought into close proximity and are moved relative to each other, thus
8
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
promoting adhesion between them. Hence, the bond strength of particles inside the green compact
increases [27]. However, at elevated forming temperature i.e., 180°C, the hardness decreases. This
is due to the function of lubricant that might exceed its effective limit [28].
The study also found that the best formulation is 0.6wt% lubricant and 30 minutes mixing
time in terms of hardness and relative density (Figures 5 and 6). Due to higher amount of zinc
stearate, less time needed to distribute the lubricant uniformly throughout the iron powder. It can
be observed in Figures 7 and 8 that improved hardness and tensile strength is obtained by suggested
0.6wt% lubricant content and 30 minutes mixing time compared to green compacts without
lubricant. Although the production time increases, the mechanical properties of produced green
compacts are greatly improved. Based on the above results (Figure 4 - Figure 6), improved
properties of green compacts, i.e., higher relative density and hardness can be obtained either by
mixing 0.6wt% zinc stearate for 30 minutes or 0.3wt% of zinc stearate for 60 minutes.
It is also evident from Figure 5 and 6 that shorter mixing time produced harder green
compacts. This can be explained referring to the study conducted by Sommer [33] on the variance
of ideal disorder of a multi-component mixture where the research suggested that mixing efficiency
is time dependant and there is a limit where the mixing process is completed. Further mixing time
does not improve the mixing quality. This may be a reason for no further increase in hardness as
longer mixing time applied. This argument is also in line with the results reported in [36] where 60
minutes mixing time is found to be better in generating T-shape green compacts from iron powder.
lubricant contents are presented in Figures 9 and 10. The decreasing trend of resistance due to
increase in forming temperature is observed. This phenomenon implies that electrical conductivity
is increased across the green compact. As the mixing time increases, more uniform zinc stearate is
distributed, hence decreases the chance of zinc stearate to accumulate at certain section that can
reduce the electrical conductivity. The formulation of 0.3wt% lubricant content and 30 minutes
9
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
mixing time is found to be good formulation compared to 0.6wt% lubricant content and 60 minutes
mixing time. Figure 11 shows that the addition of lubricant to the iron powder mass improves the
electrical conductivity of the green compacts. Although pure iron powder should conduct electrical
current better, it would not achieve the desired higher density at same amount of pressure compared
to powder mass with lubricant [28]. Increase in density means increase in particle packing order
and good particle rearrangement as discussed in Figures 2 and 3. This leads to better electrical
conductivity in the present of lubricant. However, higher lubricant content may give adverse effect
due to pore generation, mainly at elevated temperature during sintering at later stage.
4. Conclusions
The study concludes that compaction at higher pressure as well as elevated temperature can
improve microstructure and mechanical properties of green compacts. No defects are observed for
the sample formed by 125 kN compaction load at 170˚C. The suitable lubrication formulation also
improves the mechanical properties of green compact where mixing time can minimize the adverse
effect that usually found in higher weight percent of lubricant content. It also can be highlighted
Acknowledgment
The authors want to thank Ministry of Science and Technology and Innovation (MOSTI) Malaysia
for funding this research project under 03-02-03-SF0146. Thanks to Universiti Tenaga Nasional for
References
[2] A.K. Ariffin, A. Jumahat and M.M. Rahman, The simulation of die movement in designing
P/M parts, National Design Seminar 2001, Johor Bahru - Malaysia, 15th January, 2001.
10
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[3] A.K. Ariffin, M.M. Rahman and A. Jumahat, An Experimental investigation of warm
[4] D.C. Zenger and Chai, Common causes of cracks in P/M compacts, Int. Journal of Powder
[5] P. Seung-Jun, N.H. Heung, H.O. Kyu and N.L. Dong, Model for compaction of metal
powder, International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, vol. 41, pp. 121-141, 1999.
sinter_pressure/more.html, 2005.
[7] A.K. Ariffin and M.M. Rahman, Warm metal powder compaction process, Advances in
[8] A. Bejarano, M.D. Riera and J.M. Prado, Simulation of the compaction process of a two-
level powder metallurgical part, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, vol. 143-
[9] M.M. Rahman, Themomechanical modelling of powder compaction process, M.Sc. Thesis,
[10] A.E. Wechsler, Thermal and mechanical properties of evacuated powders, Powder
[11] M. Gagne, Behaviour of powder mix constituents during cold and warm compactions,
Advances in Powder metallurgy and Particulate materials, vol. 1(3), pp. 19-33,1997.
[12] A.B. Höganäs, Iron and steel powders for sintered components, USA: North American
Höganäs, 1998.
[13] B. Johanse, Experience with warm compaction of densmix powder in the production of
11
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[14] G.F. Bocchini, G. Cricri and R. Esposito, Friction effects in metal powder compacting part
two: experimental result, Advances in Powder and Particulate Materials, vol. 1(2),
pp. 141-151,1996.
[15] M.M. Rahman, Finite element modeling of warm powder compaction process. Ph.D.
[16] H.G. Rutz, A.J. Rawlings and T.M. Cimino, Advanced properties of high density ferrous
[17] M. Hehenberger and J.E. Crawford, A predictor method for finite element analysis of
sliding friction, Scandinavia Journal of Metallurgy, vol. 12, pp. 285-288, 1983.
[18] T. Tabata, S. Masaki and K. Kamata, Determination of the coefficient of friction between
metal powder and die-wall friction in compaction, Journal of Plasticity, vol. 21(236),
[19] D.V. Tran, R.W. D.T. Gethin and A.K. Ariffin, Numerical modeling of powder
[20] A.K. Ariffin, Powder compaction, finite element modeling and experimental validation,
[21] A. Jumahat, Analisis kelakuan termo-mekanik bagi proses padatan hangat, M.sc. Thesis,
[22] A.R. Khoei and R.W. Lewis, Finite element simulation for dinamyc large elastoplastic
[23] S. Deepak and A. Diran, Control strategy for de-lubrication of P/M compacts,
12
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[24] A.F. Zhornyak and V.E. Oliker, Pressing behavior of atomized iron powders III: Effect of
zinc stearate on compressibility and particle cohesion, Powder Metallurgy and Metal
[25] A.B. Höganäs, Handbook for warm compaction, Sweden: Höganäs AB, 1998.
http://www.freepatentsonline.com/6605251.html, 1997.
[27] G.T. Murray, Introduction to engineering material; behaviour, properties and selection,
[28] S.S.M. Nor, M.M. Rahman, F. Tarlochan, B. Shahida and A.K. Ariffin, The effect of
[29] E. Pavier & P. Doremus, Triaxial characterisation of iron powder behaviour, Powder
[30] O. Coube, A.C.F. Cocks & C.-Y. Wu, Experimental and numerical study of die filling,
powder transfer and die compaction, Powder Metallurgy, 48: 68-76, 2005.
[31] D.V. Khakhar, A.V. Orpe and S.K. Hajra, Segregation of granular materials in rotating
[32] B. Daumann and H. Nirschl, Assessment of the mixing efficiency of solid mixtures by
means of image analysis, Powder Technology, vol. 182, pp. 415-423, 2008.
[33] K. Sommer, Sampling of Powders and Bulk Materials, New Yorko: Springer Verlag,1986.
[34] J.J. McCarthy, D.V. Khakhar and J.M. Ottino, Computational studies of granular mixing
[35] S.B. Savage and C.K.K. Lun, Particle size segregation in inclined chute flow of dry
cohensionless granular solids, Journal of Fluid Mechanics, vol. 189, pp.311-335, 1988.
13
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[36] M.M. Rahman and S.S.M. Nor, An experimental investigation of metal powder
compaction at elevated temperature, Mechanics of Materials, vol. 41, pp. 553-560, 2009.
14
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Figure Captions
Figure 2. SEM micrographs of green compacts of iron powder formed at different compaction
load and temperature (a) 125 kN at 170°C, (b) 105 kN at 170°C, (c) 125 kN at 30°C,
Figure 4. Relative density variation at different forming temperature and lubricant contents
Figure 8. The effect of lubricant formulation to the tensile strength of green compact
Figure 10. Electrical resistivity of green compact (60 minutes mixing time)
Figure 11. The effect of lubricant to the electrical resistivity of green compact
15
Figure 1
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Figure 2
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
(a)
(b)
(c)
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
(d)
Figure 3
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
0.85
0.84
0.83
Relative Density, rr
0.82
0.81
30ºC
0.80 170ºC
0.79
0.78
100 105 110 115 120 125 130
Load (kN)
Figure 4
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
0.77
0.3 wt% - 30 minutes
0.76
0.3 wt% - 60 minutes
0.75
0.6 wt% - 30 minutes
0.74 0.6 wt% - 60 minutes
Relative Density, rr
0.73
0.72
0.71
0.70
0.69
0.68
0 50 100 150 200
Temperature (ºC)
Figure 5
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
106
104
Rockwell Hardness (HRF)
102
100
98
96
0.3 wt%
94 0.6 wt%
92
90
0 50 100 150 200
Temperature (ºC)
Figure 6
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
105
100
Rockwell Hardness (HRF)
95
90
0.3 wt%
0.6 wt%
85
80
0 50 100 150 200
Temperature (ºC)
Figure 7
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
120
100
Rockwell Hardness (HRF)
80
60
20
0
0 50 100 150 200
Temperature (ºC)
Figure 8
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
1.20
1.00
Tensile strength (GPa)
0.80
0.60
0.00
0 50 100 150 200
Temperature (ºC)
Figure 9
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
0.14
0.12
0.1
Resistivity (Ω.m)
0.08
0.3 wt%
0.04 0.6 wt%
0.02
0
0 50 100 150 200
Temperature (ºC)
Figure 10
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
0.4
0.35
0.3
Resistivity (Ω.m)
0.25
0.2
60 minutes mixing time
0.15 0.3 wt%
0.6 wt%
0.1
0.05
0
0 50 100 150 200
Temperature (ºC)
Figure 11
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
0.045
0.040
0.035
0.030
Resistivity (Ω.m)
0.025
0.020
0.015
0.010
0.000
0 50 100 150 200
Temperature (ºC)