Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
SCI Measurements
The SCI may be considered as a parameter that highlights
imperfect magnetic coupling between primary and secondary
windings. It contains resistive and inductive terms, the latter
being much more important than the former. The SCI (or leakage
inductance) can be represented as an additional inductance in
series with the transformer primary inductance, as shown in
Figure 1. A high SCI value leads to a high voltage drop across
the transformer terminals and thus affects network voltage
regulation, while a low value influences the network short-
circuit current.
The distances between the HV winding, the LV winding, and
the core of the transformer have considerable influence on the
SCI value (Figure 2). The SCI Ux is given by
Figure 1. Schematic model of primary, secondary, and leakage Figure 2. Schematic of transformer core and windings: (a) top
inductances of a transformer. view and (b) side cut view.
Results
In this study, a failed 400-MVA step-up transformer was used
to compare the effectiveness of FRA and SCI measurements for
fault detection. The principal parameters of the transformer are
given in Table 1.
SCI Measurements
The LV winding terminals were short-circuited, and SCI
measurements were made between the HV windings and the
neutral terminal. The measured impedances are presented in
Table 2.
The percentage change, defined as 100|Zfactory − Zmeasured|/Zfactory,
is smaller than the maximum permitted change (3%) suggested
in [15], for each of the three phases. Thus one standard [15]
indicates that winding deformation or displacement had not
occurred. (However, the change of 2.93% for phase B might
appear suspicious to an expert.) On the other hand, each of
the three changes exceeds the 1% figure suggested in [16] for
transformers with capacities above 100 MVA. Thus a second
standard [16] indicates that deformation or displacement had
occurred in each of the three windings. Clearly the two standards
yield conflicting indications.
FRA Measurements
Measurements of FRA were made by applying a 5.66-V
signal across each winding, at 801 frequencies in the range 20
Hz to 2 MHz. The characteristic impedance of the measurement
cables was 50 Ω. The measured FRA traces were compared with
fingerprint traces obtained during transformer overhaul (before
failure).
The results are shown in Figure 5. To avoid compression of
the higher frequency data, the frequency response magnitudes
are presented on a logarithmic frequency scale in Figures 5a, 5b,
and 5c. It will be seen that the measured traces for phases A and
C are very similar to their fingerprints. However, the same is not
true of phase B. Figure 5d shows the measured and fingerprint
impedances for phase B. The measured and fingerprint
impedances for phases A and C were very nearly identical.
A common method of interpreting FRA data is to use
statistical indices, particularly the correlation coefficient, the
standard deviation, and the relative factor.
The correlation coefficient (CC) is defined as [31]
N
CC(X ,Y ) =
∑ i =1 XiYi ,
N N (4)
∑ i =1 (Xi )2 ∑ i =1 (Yi )2
where Xi and Yi are the ith elements of the fingerprint and Figure 5. (a), (b), and (c) show the measured and fingerprint
measured FRA traces, respectively, and N is the number of frequency response magnitudes for phases A, B, and C, respec-
elements (or samples). CC is thus a number whose absolute tively, of the transformer HV side. (d) shows the measured and
value lies between 0 and 1. fingerprint impedances for phase B.
N i N they would not change any of the factors in (2). Bending and
i =1 i =1
PXY = (7) tilting of winding conductors are illustrated in Figures 7a and
DX DY 7b, respectively.
The results presented in this article suggest that FRA is
and DX and DY are given by capable of providing reliable information on the level of
CC SD
Low 10 1.2674 10
Conclusion
Off-line SCI and FRA measurements were conducted on Medium 10 1.0724 10
a transformer that had failed because of deformation of the
High 10 2.3831 10
B phase of the HV winding. Interpreted according to IEEE
Standard 62-1995 [15], the SCI values indicated that winding Low: 1 kHz to 100 kHz. Medium: 100 kHz to 600 kHz. High: 600 kHz to 1
1