Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
SEC Findings
November 10, 2016
Objective
Objective:
► To improve knowledge on the financial statement
preparation
Page 2
Agenda
Page 3
SRC Rule 68- Background and Covered
Entities
Page 4
SRC Rule 68 - Background
Page 6
SRC Rule 68, Part II, 1. - Covered Entities
(Issuers of Securities to the Public)
Page 7
Rule 68, Part I - Basic Reporting
Requirements
Page 8
Basic Reporting Requirements
(SRC Rule 68, Part I)
Page 9
Basic Financial Statements
(PAS 1, par. 8)
► Statement of Financial Position (Balance Sheet)
► Statement of Profit or Loss and Other Comprehensive
Income
► Statement of Changes in Equity
► Statement of Cash Flows
► Notes, comprising a summary of significant accounting
policies and other explanatory information (Additional
SEC disclosure requirements from applicable PFRS for
“issuers of securities to the Public [Annex 68-D] (Part II,6)
and for those filing consolidated FS, additional disclosure
requirements for subsidiaries not consolidated and 50% or
less owned persons (Part II,9,A)
Page 10
Additional requirements under Annex 68-D
for issuers of securities (Part II)
► Inventories
► Capital Stock
Page 11
Additional requirements under Annex 68-D
for issuers of securities (Part II)
► Costs
► Finance costs
► Other income
► Other expenses
Page 12
Basic Financial Statements
Requirement for Comparative Presentation
Page 13
Common SEC Findings
Components of Basic FS
Account Comment
Statement of ► The Statement of Financial Position failed to present the
Financial Position current and non-current classifications of assets and
liabilities
Page 14
Rule 68 – Acceptable Financial Reporting
Framework
Page 15
Acceptable Reporting Frameworks
(SRC Rule 68, Part I,2,A)
Page 16
Large or Publicly Accountable entities
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 2,A (i))
Page 17
Common SEC Findings
Basis of Preparation
Page 18
Common SEC Findings
Basis of Preparation
Page 19
Responsibility for the Company’s Financial
Statements
Page 20
Responsibility for Financial Statements
(SRC Rule 68, Part I,2,B,(i))
► The financial statements filed with the Commission are primarily the
responsibility of the management of the reporting company and
accordingly, the fairness of the representations made therein is an
implicit and integral part of the management’s responsibility.
Page 21
Statement of Management Responsibility
(SMR) Template
Par. 1
“The management of (reporting entity) is responsible for the
preparation and presentation of the financial statements for
the year(s) ended (date), in accordance with the prescribed
financial reporting framework stated therein. This
responsibility includes designing and implementing internal
controls relevant to the preparation and fair presentation of
financial statements that are free from material
misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, selecting and
applying appropriate accounting policies, and making
accounting estimates that are reasonable in the
circumstances.”
Page 22
Statement of Management Responsibility
(Template)
Par. 2
“The Board of Directors or Trustees reviews and approves
the financial statements and submit the same to the
stockholders or members.”
Par.3
“(Auditors), the independent auditors, appointed by the
stockholders, has examined the financial statements of the
company in accordance with Philippine Standards of
Auditing, and in its report to the stockholders or members,
has expressed its opinion on the fairness of the presentation
upon completion of such examination.”
Page 23
SMR for FS
(SRC Rule 68,Part I,2,B (iii))
► Signatories of SMR
► Chairman of the Board
Page 24
SMR for FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I,2,B (iv)
Page 25
Common SEC Findings
Statement of Management’s Responsibility
Account Comment
Statement of ► The SMR is not in accordance with the prescribed
Management’s wordings
Responsibility ► The SMR is not signed by the prescribed signatories
(SMR) under SRC Rule 68, as amended
► The signatories indicated in the SMRs are not consistent
with those stated in General Information Sheets
► The basis of preparation of the financial statements as
stated in SMR is not consistent with that indicated in the
FS
► The SMR failed to cover comparative year
► The SMR is not notarized
Page 26
Proposed amendments – responsibility for
related party transactions
Page 27
SMR for FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I,2,B (v))
Page 28
Classification of Reporting Entities for
Accreditation of Auditors
Page 29
Group B Entities (other than issuers of
timeshares and membership shares)
► Investment houses
► Brokers and dealers of securities
► Investment companies
► Government securities eligible dealers
► Universal banks registered as underwriters of securities
► Investment company advisers
► Clearing agency and clearing agency as depository
► Stock and securities exchange
► Special purpose vehicles under SPV act of 2002
► Special purpose corporation under Securitization act of
2004
Page 30
Common SEC Findings - Auditor’s Report
and Supplemental Written Statement of Auditor
► The external auditor of the Company is not accredited by the
Commission under Group C Category
► The Auditor's Report failed to indicate the control number and the
expiration dates of the SEC accreditation of the auditing firm and
signing external auditor
► The BIR Accreditation Number and its validity period are not
indicated
► The auditor’s report was dated prior to the date for approval for
issuance by the Management
► There is no legal matter paragraph in the auditor's report to cover
the information required by Revenue Regulation 15-2010
► The Supplemental Written Statement of Auditor failed to indicate the
external auditor's SEC Certificate of Accreditation number and its
expiration date
► There is no Supplemental Written Statement of External Auditor
Page 31
Other Documents to be filed with the
Financial Statements
Page 32
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(A) Non-stock, non-profit corporations
(as amended by SEC MC No. 4, series of 2013)
► Sworn Statement of the President and Treasurer on the accuracy
and completeness of the following schedules
► Schedule of Receipts or Income Other than Contributions and Donations
► Schedule of Contributions and Donations (Prescribed format in “Annex A”
of SEC MC No. 4)
► Schedule of Disbursements
Page 33
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(B) Foundations
(as amended by SEC MC No.4, series of 2013)
► Sworn statement of the President and Treasurer on accuracy and
completeness of the following schedules (SS)
(Prescribed format under SEC Notice April 18, 2013 required to be
notarized)
► Schedule of Sources of Funds Other than Contributions and Donations
► Schedule of Contributions and Donations
(prescribed format in “Annex A” of SEC MC No. 4)
► Schedule of Disbursements
► Schedule of Application of Funds
► Certifications from Office of the Mayor, or Head of DSWD or DOH for
existence of Program (COEP) (SEC Notice April 18, 2013 clarified that
the COEP may be provided by Heads/Officers of private institutions
provided these are notarized.)
Page 34
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(C) Issuers of securities to the public, and stock corporations with
unrestricted retained earnings in excess of 100% of paid-in capital
stock
► A Reconciliation of Retained Earnings Available for Dividend
Declaration (Annex 68-C of this SRC Rule 68)
► FRB 1 requires that the reconciliation be covered by a legal matter
paragraph in the Auditor’s report or a separate report of auditor
► FRB 14 clarified that:
► the amount of retained earnings should be based on the stand-alone
(parent) fs, and
► the reconciliation should be submitted with the consolidated FS
Page 35
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(D) All secondary licensees of the Commission (financing
companies, broker dealer of securities and underwriters) and
public companies
► A schedule showing financial soundness indicators in two
comparative periods, as follows:
► current/liquidity ratios;
► solvency ratios, debt-to-equity ratios;
► asset-to-equity ratios;
► interest rate coverage ratios;
► profitability ratios;
► other relevant ratios as the Commission may consider necessary.
Page 36
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(E) Financing companies
► A schedule showing the following information in two comparative
periods:
► ratio or percentage of total real estate investments to total assets;
► total receivables to total assets;
► total DOSRI receivables to net worth;
► amount of receivables from a single corporation to total receivables.
Page 37
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(F) Mutual funds
► A schedule showing the following information in two comparative
periods:
► percentage of investment in a single enterprise to net asset value;
► total investment of the fund to the outstanding securities of an investee
company;
► total investments in liquid or semi-liquid assets to total assets;
► total operating expenses to total net worth;
► total asset to total borrowings.
Page 38
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(G) Investment houses
► Schedules showing the following information:
Details (per issue) of underwriting activities for the year
► Name of the issuer-client;
► Nature of commitment;
► Amount of issue;
► Description of transaction;
Page 39
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(H) Listed companies and investment houses that are part of a
conglomerate or group of companies
► A map showing the relationships between and among
► the company
► ultimate parent company
► middle parent
► subsidiaries or co-subsidiaries
► associates
Page 40
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(I) Listed companies that recently offered securities to the public
(either as initial or additional offering)
► A schedule showing the following amounts:
► Gross and net proceeds as disclosed in the final prospectus;
► Actual gross and net proceeds;
► Each expenditure item where the proceeds was used; and
► Balance of the proceeds as of end of reporting period.
Page 41
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part I, 4)
(J) Large and/or publicly-accountable entities
► A schedule, in table format, showing in the first column a list of all
the effective standards and interpretations under the PFRS as of
year-end, and an indication opposite each in the second column on
whether it is “Adopted”, “Not adopted” or “Not applicable”.
Page 42
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part II, 6, D)
By Issuers of Securities to the Public
Page 43
Schedules Required under Annex 68-E
Page 44
Schedules Required under Annex 68-E
Page 45
Other Documents to be filed with the FS
(SRC Rule 68, Part II, 9)
By Issuers of Securities to the Public
Page 46
Common SEC Findings
Components of FS
Account Comment
Schedules ► The Schedules required under the SRC Rule 68, as
Required Under amended are not submitted
SRC Rule 68, as ► The following Schedules are not attached to the AFS:
amended ► Reconciliation of Retained Earnings Available for
dividend (Part I,4,C)
► Tabular schedule of standards (Part I,4,J)
► Conglomerate map (Part I,4,H)
► Financial soundness indicators(Part I,4,D)
Page 47
Common SEC Findings
Components of FS
Account Comment
Page 48
Material Violations of Rule 68
Page 49
Violations of SRC Rule 68 Warranting
Imposition of Penalties (Part II,10,A (ii))
Page 50
Violations of SRC Rule 68 Warranting
Imposition of Penalties (Part II,10,A (ii))
Page 51
SEC Memo 8-2009
Considered as Material Deficiency (III,A,(i))
► Any of the following is not submitted with the FS:
► Balance Sheet
► Income Statement or Statement of Receipts and
Disbursements
► Cash Flow Statement
► Statement of Changes in Equity or Fund Balance
► Notes to Financial Statements
► Statement of Management’s Responsibility
► Auditor’s Report
Page 52
SEC Memo 8-2009
Considered as Material Deficiency (III,A (ii))
► If a listed company, public company, mutual fund or issuer of
securities to the public, the auditor’s opinion is qualified due to a
deviation from the applicable financial reporting framework.
However, for listed banks, a qualified opinion of the external auditor
shall not be considered a non-compliance with SRC Rule 68 if the
qualification pertains to a deviation adopted by the Bangko Sentral
ng Pilipinas as part of its prudential reporting requirements;
► The auditor’s report is substantially not compliant with the wordings
prescribed by the Philippine Standards on Auditing (PSA) No. 700,
as revised and other applicable auditing standards and practices.
Page 53
SEC Memo 8-2009
Considered as a Material Deficiency (III,A(iii))
► The SMR is not signed by the prescribed signatories and/or not
notarized in the case of listed or public companies
Page 54
SEC Memo 8-2009
Considered as a Material Deficiency (III,A (iv))
► There is no accounting policy for a significant account:
For listed companies, public companies, mutual funds, other issuers of
securities to the public of which is equivalent, and pre-need companies
► 5% or more of Total Current assets, if it is one of the current asset items;
Page 56
SEC Memo 8-2009
Considered as Material Deficiency (III,A(v))
► Five (5) or more of the following minor deficiencies are noted:
► The financial statements are not presented in the prescribed
comparative format
► There is no distinction between the current and non-current portion of
assets or liabilities except in cases where PAS 1 allows non-
classification
► There are no cross-references to the notes to financial statements
► The number of disclosure items that are not provided for a significant
account does not exceed two
► The Statement of Management’s Responsibility is not in full conformity
with the prescribed wordings of SRC Rule 68 or 68.1
► Such other deficiencies as the Commission may consider minor
Page 57
SEC Memo 8-2009
Considered as Material Misstatement (III,B)
► An accounting policy for a significant account is not consistent with PFRS or
GAAP
► An accounting policy for a significant account is not consistently applied
between periods or to similar transactions and events
► The estimate or assumption used on a significant account is unreasonable
and resulted to material misstatement of the FS
► There is more than one (1) minor misstatement and the aggregate amount
involved for the said misstatements meets the test of materiality
► The financial statements of a corporation with a subsidiary or subsidiaries
are not presented on a consolidated basis in violation of PAS 27
► Such other misstatements in the financial statements, i.e., overstatement or
understatement of income, asset, liability or equity, that the Commission may
consider material
Page 58
SEC Memo 1-2011
Reckoning Date of Computation of Penalty
► The daily penalty shall be computed from the date of receipt of the
letter informing the company of its non-compliance with the reporting
requirements of Section 141 of the Corporation Code of the
Philippines, Section 68 of the Securities Regulation Code, the
Investment Company Act, Financing Company Act, the Lending
Company Act, and the Investments Houses Law, up to the time that
the company has submitted the following documents:
a) a sufficient explanation for the non-compliance;
b) an audit committee or a board resolution taking cognizance of the non
compliance;
c) corrective measures the company shall undertake to prevent future
violations of SEC Memorandum Circular No. 8, Series of 2009.
► The Commission may, in addition, require the company to submit
the revised financial statements or an addendum to the financial
statements.
Page 59
Financial Reporting Bulletin
(FRB)
Page 60
List of Financial Reporting Bulletin (FRB)
► FRB # 1 - Additional components of financial statements
► FRB # 2 - Emphasis of Matter paragraph for companies with capital deficiency - Part I, 3.B(iv)
► FRB # 3 - Disclosures of receivables/ payables with related parties eliminated during
consolidation (Annex 68-D)
► FRB # 4 - Companies not covered Under SRC Rule 68
► FRB # 5 - Companies with no operation but are covered under SRC Rule 68
► FRB # 6 - Deposits for Future Subscriptions
► FRB # 7 - Statement of Management’s Responsibility (SMR)
► FRB # 8 - Small and Medium-sized Entities (SMEs)
► FRB # 9 - Micro Entities
► FRB # 10 - Entities in the process of filing their financial statements for the purpose of issuing any
class of instruments (whether shares of stock or bonds) in a public market
► FRB # 11 - Non-stock and non-profit organizations
► FRB # 12 - Annex 68-E – Schedule A. Financial Assets (Issuers of Securities to the Public)
► FRB # 13 - Presentation of Related Party Disclosures
► FRB # 14 - Presentation Reconciliation of Retained Earnings
► FRB # 15 - Appropriation of Retained Earnings for Business Expansion
► FRB # 16 - List of Effective Standards and Interpretations (as of December 31, 2012)
► FRB # 17 - Newly-registered Corporations
► FRB # 18 - Age Requirement for Financial Statements
► FRB # 19 - Expectations of an Effective Audit Function
Page 61
FRB # 1 (Feb. 16, 2012)
Page 62
FRB # 1 (Feb. 16, 2012)
Page 63
FRB # 2 (Feb. 16, 2012)
Page 64
FRB # 2 (Feb. 16, 2012)
Page 65
Common SEC Findings – Emphasis of a
Matter regarding going concern
Subject Matter SEC Finding
SRC Rule 68, ►There is no discussion of the Company’s concrete plan to
Part I,3,E (v) address its recognized capital deficiency
► There is no “emphasis of a matter” paragraph discussing
Emphasis of the going concern issue due to the capital deficiency of
Matter paragraph the Company
for companies with ► There is no “emphasis of a matter” paragraph discussing
capital deficiency the following:
a) The fact that the company has incurred a capital
deficiency
b) A brief discussion of a concrete plan of the company
to address the capital deficiency and reference to
the note to FS that provide a complete disclosure of
the said plan
c) A statement that the auditor conducted sufficient
audit procedures to verify the validity of the
aforementioned plan.
Page 66
FRB # 3 (Feb. 16, 2012)
Page 67
FRB # 4 (Feb. 16, 2012)
Page 68
FRB # 5 (Feb. 16, 2012)
Page 69
FRB # 6 (amended) – Jan. 24, 2013
Page 70
FRB # 7 (April 3, 2012)
Page 71
FRB # 8 (April 3, 2012)
Page 72
FRB # 9 (April 3, 2012)
Page 74
FRB # 10 (April 3, 2012)
Page 75
FRB # 11 (April 3, 2012)
Page 76
FRB # 12 (April 3, 2012)
Page 77
FRB # 13 (Jan. 24, 2013)
Page 78
FRB # 13 (Jan. 24, 2013)
Page 79
FRB # 14 (Jan. 24, 2013)
Page 80
FRB # 15 (Jan. 24, 2013)
Page 81
FRB # 16 (Jan. 24, 2013)
Page 82
FRB # 17 (March 7, 2013)
Page 83
FRB # 17 (March 7, 2013)
(cont…)
Subject Matter Clarification / Details
Newly-registered ► If the paid-up capital of the corporation is less than
Corporations P50,000.00 the financial statements may be certified
under oath by the treasurer or any responsible officer of
the corporation.
► Except for the above limitation on the coverage of
entities whose financial report must be audited, the
provisions of the Corporation Code do not grant any
exemption from the required submission of annual
financial statements (AFS). The filing requirement is
applicable to all corporations and organizations
registered with the Commission as of the fiscal year end
including those newly incorporated during the said year.
Page 84
FRB # 18 (Dec. 22, 2015)
Page 85
FRB # 19 (May 3, 2016)
Page 86
SEC Memorandum Circular
Page 87
List of SEC Memorandum issued in 2016
Page 90
SEC Memorandum 3-2016 (April 5, 2016)
Page 91
SEC Memorandum 4-2016 (May 5, 2016)
Page 92
SEC Memorandum 5-2016 (June 9, 2016)
Page 93
SEC Memorandum 6-2016 (June 9, 2016)
► This Circular was signed last June 9, 2016 and shall take effect
immediately after its publication in a newspaper of general
circulation.
Page 94
SEC Memorandum 7-2016 (June 21, 2016)
Page 95
SEC Memorandum 8-2016 (June 30, 2016)
Page 96
SEC Memorandum 9-2016 (July 18, 2016)
Page 97
SEC Memorandum 10-2016 (July 28, 2016)
Page 98
SEC Memorandum 11-2016 (August 5, 2016)
Subscriptions Contracts
Page 99
SEC Memorandum 12-2016 (August 11, 2016)
► Other Fees
Page 100
SEC Memorandum 13-2016 (August 18, 2016)
Page 102
SEC Memorandum 15-2016 (Sept. 9, 2016)
► Foundations not receiving funds within the threshold are required to submit a
Certification stating they have not received government funds nor received
donations/grants/contributions for their operations. The Certification shall also
include a statement that there is no action or proceeding which has been filed or
pending before any Court.
Page 103
SEC Memorandum 16-2016 (Sept. 28, 2016)
Page 104
SEC Memorandum 17-2016 (Oct. 13, 2016)
Page 105
SEC Announcements and Notices
► SEC Advisory
► Submission of ACGR together with Annual Report
► SEC Announcement
► SEC Express Nationwide Express (SENS)
► SEC Notice
► Transactions of Corporate Governance and Finance Department (CGFD)
► Adoption of Standards and Interpretations
Page 106
SEC Advisory (March 16, 2016)
Page 107
SEC Announcement (March 21, 2016)
Page 108
SEC Notice (August 24, 2016)
Page 109
SEC Notice (August 24, 2016)
Page 110
Other Common SEC Findings
Notes to Financial Statements
Page 111
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Corporate ► There is no disclosure of the date when the Board of
Information directors authorized the issuance of the financial
statements
► There is no discussion on the company’s concrete plan
to address its recognized capital deficiency
► Incomplete disclosure on the description of the nature of
the company's operation and principal activity
► The address of the company’s registered office is not
indicated
► There is no discussion on the parent company
► Note 2 states that the financial statements prepared are
consolidated financial statements. There is however, no
disclosure of any subsidiary company
Page 112
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Significant ► There is no discussion on significant accounting
Accounting judgments and estimates used by the Company's
Estimates and management in the preparation of the financial
Judgments statements
► There are no discussions on estimates used on
impairment of financial assets, determination of net
realizable value of inventories, measurement of
revenue, cost and estimated liabilities from construction
contracts
Page 113
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Capital ► There is no accounting policies and disclosures on
Management capital management
► There is no or incomplete discussion in the notes to FS
of the externally-imposed capital requirement and how it
is incorporated into the Company’s management of
capital
► A note disclosure incorrectly stated that "The Company
is not subject to externally-imposed capital
requirements". As a lending company, it is subject to the
minimum capital requirement under the Lending
Company Act and its IRR (Lending Company)
► The Company failed to comply with the minimum paid-
up capital of P1 million (Lending Company)
Page 114
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Financial Risk ► There are no or incomplete discussion of accounting
Management policy and disclosures on financial risk management
► There are no qualitative and quantitative disclosures on
managing each financial risk
► Incomplete disclosures on liquidity risk, i.e., specific
management plans to address the company’s negative
liquidity
► There is no discussion on sensitivity analysis on equity
risk
► Considering the adopted financial framework, the
disclosure in Note 4 on financial risk management is not
necessary
► There are no qualitative and quantitative analysis on
each financial risk
Page 115
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Related Party ► There is no accounting policy on related party
Transactions transactions
► The nature of relationship between related parties was
not disclosed
► There are no or incomplete disclosures on related party
transactions, i.e., key management personnel
compensation, terms and conditions including the
collateral or security given, nature of the consideration
provided for settlement, details of any guarantees given
or received, provision for doubtful debts and the
expense recognized during the period
► Incomplete disclosures on related party transactions,
i.e., required disclosures on company’s retirement fund
Page 116
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Related Party ► Incomplete disclosures on related party transactions,
Transactions i.e., volume of transactions, mode of settlement, assets
used as collaterals and its carrying amount, key
management personnel compensation
► There is no explanatory note on “Advances from
stockholders of a subsidiary” under Note 17 on “Other
Non-current Assets” despite materiality of amount
► Note 6.3 indicates “Due from related parties” amounting
to P19.7 Million. Note 18 however, only shows an
outstanding balance of P18.8 Million or a difference of
P0.9 Million
Page 117
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Revenue ► There is no specific revenue recognition policy on
interest income, dividend income, financing income,
rental income, commissions, currency trading income,
service fees, miscellaneous/other income and charges
► There is no breakdown of the amount and nature of
each item of revenue sources
► There is no disclosure of the nature and amount of each
item comprising "sale of goods-net"
► There are no disclosures on “Gain on Sale of Property”
despite materiality of amount
► The Company's underwriting income is below 25%.
This is not in accordance with Section 12 of the
Omnibus Rules and Regulations for Investment Houses
and Universal Banks registered as underwriters which
requires that income from underwriting activities shall be
at least 25% of annual gross income (Investment House)
Page 118
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Cost and ► There is no accounting policy on recognition of cost and
expenses expenses
► The amount of Administrative Expenses on Statement of
Comprehensive Income is inconsistent with that stated
in the Notes to FS
► There is no disclosure of the nature and amount of each
item comprising “Cost of Real Estate Sales”
► There are no disclosures on "Direct Cost" despite
materiality of the amount
► There is no explanatory note on “Others – Operating
Expenses/Miscellaneous Expense”
► There is no breakdown of the nature and amount of
each item comprising Cost of Sales
► The recognition of pre-operating expenses in not in
accordance with Section 4 of PFRS for SMEs
Page 119
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Leases ► There are no specific accounting policy and disclosures
on leases
► Incomplete disclosures on leases, i.e., general leasing
agreements, minimum lease payments
► There is no general description of the lessor’s significant
leasing arrangement, including information about
contingent rent, renewal or purchase options and
escalation clauses and restrictions imposed by the lease
arrangements
► The Company's accounting policy on leases is not in
accordance with PAS 17
Page 120
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Employee Benefits ► There are no accounting policy and disclosures on
employee benefits
► AFS states that the Company has yet to provide for the
estimated benefits required to be paid under Republic
Act 7641. There is neither a disclosure if the Company
is exempted from the said Act or an assessment impact
on the said non-adoption
► Page 7 on “Employee Benefits” (b) states that “the
corporation does not have funded employee’s retirement
benefit plan. It has not recognized liability for service
and annual cost of earned retirement benefits due to its
employees, a departure from PAS 19.
► Based on Note 18, the company recognized a
retirement benefit cost. This is however not supported in
the Statement of Financial Position which do not show
any recognized retirement benefit liability.
Page 121
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Financial Assets / ► There is no explanatory note on the agreements
Liabilities covering the Corporate Notes restrictions and
requirements. There should have been a disclosure on
the information that is not presented elsewhere in the
financial statements, but is relevant to an understanding
to any of them. The disclosure should have included
details of the financial ratios that the company is
required to maintain.
► Note to the AFS indicates that the loan agreements
provide certain restrictions and requirements principally
with respect to maintenance of required financial ratios
and material change in ownership and controls. The
said restrictions and financial ratios requirements are
not disclosed.
► There is no explanatory note on “Due to Shang Grand
Tower Corp.” despite materiality of the amount
Page 122
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Financial Assets / ► There is no breakdown of the nature/description and
Liabilities amount of each item comprising “Accrued expenses”
► There are no or incomplete disclosure on loans and
receivables, i.e., accounting policy on impairment and
derecognition, initial measurement, subsequent
measurement, terms and condition, interest rate, nature of
assets held as collateral and its terms and conditions
relative to its use, repayment schedule and restrictions.
► Note 2 states that “Trade receivables are carried at original
invoice price less any allowance for doubtful accounts”.
This is not in accordance with Sec.11.14 which requires
debt instruments to be measured at amortized cost using
the effective interest method.
► Note 2.3, Trade receivables are stated initially at nominal
value. This is not in accordance with PAS 39, which
requires that loans and receivables shall be measured at its
fair value plus transaction cost except for financial assets
classified at fair value through profit or loss
Page 123
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Financial Assets / ► There is no aging analysis on receivables
Liabilities ► There is no disclosure showing that the following
conditions were considered in the provisioning for
probable losses as required (Financing Company):
a. Clean loans and advances past due for a period of more than six (6)
months;
b. Past due loans secured by collateral such as inventories,
receivables, equipment and other chattels that have declined in
value by more than 50% without the borrower offering additional
collateral for the loans;
c. Past due loans secured by real estate mortgage title to which is
subject to an adverse claim rendering settlement through foreclosure
doubtful;
d. When the borrower, and his co-maker or guarantor, is insolvent or
where their whereabouts is unknown, or their earning power is
permanently impaired;
e. Accrued interest receivable that remain uncollected after six
(6) months from maturity date of such loans to which it accrues; and
f. Accounts receivable past due for 361 days and more.
Page 124
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Available-for-Sale ► There is no accounting policy on the initial measurement
(AFS) financial of available-for-sale financial assets
Assets ► The following relevant disclosures were not provided:
► Description and terms and conditions of government
securities
► The facts that would establish the “rare circumstances” that
warranted the reclassification
► A Note indicates that “unquoted equity shares are
carried at cost less impairment”. This is not consistent
with the fair value hierarchy which indicates that the AFS
financial assets are fair valued at Level 2.
► Page 13 of the notes to financial statements, available-
for-sale financial assets are carried at fair value. Note 8
however, shows that the company's available-for-sale
financial assets include “Club share securities” that are
not traded in a formal exchange, thus, said securities
should have been carried at cost less impairment.
Page 125
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Cash and Cash ► There is no accounting policy on cash
Equivalents ► The cash beginning balance is not in conformity with the
cash ending balance per 2010 AFS
► There is no breakdown of items comprising the "Cash
and Cash Equivalents"
► There is no or incomplete disclosures on cash and cash
equivalents, i.e., amount, nature terms and conditions of
cash in bank
► There is no disclosure of any legal restriction which may
hinder its availability of "Cash in banks"
► There is no explanatory note on marketable securities
Page 126
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Inventories ► There are no accounting policy and disclosures on
“inventories”
► The accounting policy on measurement of inventories,
i.e., cost, is not in accordance with the prescribed
measurement basis of “lower of cost and NRV”
► There are no disclosure and recognition of the
inventories’ impairment loss which is the difference
between cost and net realizable value
► There is no disclosure of the amount of inventories
recognized as expense or reversed in profit or loss
► There is no disclosure on the total carrying amount of
inventories pledged as security for liabilities
► Note 17 indicates “other inventory adjustments” on raw
materials and finished goods amounting to P151,780
and P1,348,120, respectively, however, there is no
explanatory note on such adjustments
Page 127
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Business ► Incomplete disclosures on business combination, i.e.,
combination and the acquisition-date fair value of each major class of
disposal of consideration and the acquisition-date fair value of the
Subsidiary total consideration transferred, the amounts recognized
as of the acquisition date for each major class of assets
acquired and liabilities assumed.
► The basis and regulatory approval of the share-for-share
transaction are not disclosed
► The basis of determining the values of identified assets
was not disclosed, i.e., valuation technique used,
whether conducted by a qualified and accredited
appraiser
Page 128
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Investment in ► The entity's accounting in subsidiaries in separate
Subsidiaries financial statements is not disclosed
► Incomplete disclosures on Investment in subsidiaries,
i.e., date of approval of the Commission on the deposit
for future stock subscription; and basis for the allowance
on impairment losses
Page 129
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Investments in ► There is no disclosure of the company’s basis for
Associates classifying as investments with equity ownership of the
less than the threshold of 20% or equity ownership of
more than 50% as Investment in Associates
► A verification of the separate financial statements of
associates show that there are no disclosures on any
proposed increase in capital stock, i.e., Board and
stockholders approval, amount of increase on said
capital stock whether an application for said increase is
to be filed or already filed with SEC, and reason for the
delay of approval of the said increase with SEC (PAS 1,
as revised). The said disclosures should have justified
the recognition of the "Deposits for future stock
subscriptions" as additional investments in associates
instead of "Advances to associates“
Page 130
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Property and ► There is no accounting policies of initial recognition,
equipment subsequent measurement, derecognition and
impairment of property and equipment
► There are no disclosures on useful lives of property and
equipment
► The following disclosures are not provided:
► Description of the project
► Timeline of completion of the project; and
► Percentage of completion of the project
► There is no disclosure of the existence of restrictions on
title and carrying amounts of property and equipment
used as collateral for liabilities
► There are no or incomplete disclosures on ROPOA, i.e.,
nature, the description methods used, the useful lives or
the depreciation rate used, reconciling schedule for
2010 figures (Financing Company)
Page 131
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Property and ► Based in Note 8, major repairs were capitalized which is
equipment in contrary to the accounting policy adopted per Note 2
which states that expenditures for repairs and
maintenance are charged to expense as incurred.
► Based on page 6, PPE are subsequently measured at
“cost less accumulated depreciation, amortization and
any impairment in value”. This is inconsistent with the
recognition of “Revaluation surplus” which shows that
the company used the revaluation model (PAS 16).
► Note 15 (c) indicates that revaluation surplus of land
was based on bank’s appraisal and increases of values
by the Assessor’s Office. While that of the building was
revalued in 2005 in the amount of P60.092 Million due to
the increases in the value of construction materials.
Both methods are not acceptable basis of fair value
pursuant to PAS 16.
Page 132
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Property and ► Incomplete disclosures on the following with regards to
equipment the revaluation of PPE:
a. The methods and significant assumptions applied in estimating the
items’ fair value;
b. The extent to which the items’ fair values were determined directly
by reference to observable prices in an active market or recent
market transactions on arm’s length terms or were estimated using
other valuation techniques;
c. For each revalued class of PPE, the carrying amount that would
have been recognized had the assets been carried under the cost
model; and
d. The revaluation surplus, indicating the change for the period and any
restrictions on the distribution of the balance to shareholders“
► Note 10 states that “the amount of the land and building
approximately their fair value based on the recent
comparative price index level of similar properties within
the same area of location”. This is inconsistent with the
PPE schedule on the same Note which do not include
such properties
Page 133
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Investment ► There are no accounting policies and disclosures in
Property Investment Property
► Incomplete disclosures on "Investment Properties" i.e.,
depreciation methods used and useful lives or the
depreciation rate used; the basis of fair value of the
appraisal report; and reconciliation of carrying amounts
of investment property at the beginning and end of the
period
► Incomplete disclosures, i.e., methods and significant
assumptions applied in determining the fair value of
investment property, direct operating expenses arising
from investment property that did not generate rental
income during the period
► The Company incorrectly used the zonal value of its
investment properties as its basis of fair value
Page 134
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Other Non-Current ► There are no specific disclosures on “Advances” that
Assets would provide information that is not presented
elsewhere in the financial statements, but is relevant to
an understanding of any of them.
► A Note on accounting policy indicates that “Other
assets, if any, are carried at cost, and may include
current portion of non-trade receivables, such as loans
receivables, VAT input, accrued investment income,
prepayments and refundable/creditable income tax, if
any.” Said accounting policy however, incorrectly
includes “loans receivables” which should have been
measured at “amortized cost
It further indicates that "Non-current portion of loans
receivables are carried at cost or amortized cost using
effective interest method." There is, however, no
disclosure on the receivables that are being measured
using “cost” and those at amortised cost
Page 135
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Income Taxes ► There is no disclosure of the numerical reconciliation of
beginning and ending balance of deferred tax liability in
Note 12
Page 136
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Equity ► There are no disclosure and accounting policy on equity
► There are no disclosures on number of shares
authorized, issued and fully paid. Par value per share;
reconciliation of number of shares outstanding at the
beginning and at the end of the period
► There are no disclosures on "Subscription receivable"
which has been recorded as such for the last three
years
Page 137
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Equity ► Incomplete disclosures on Deposit for future
subscription, i.e., date of approval of increase in
capitalization by the Board of Directors and
Stockholders, date of filing with the Commission and the
status thereof
► The recognition of "Deposit for Future Stock
Subscription" under Equity section is not supported by
the following disclosures:
► Corporate's BOD and stockholders approvals for a
proposed increase in capital stock
► An application for the approval of the increase in
capital stock has been presented for filing or filed
with the Commission; and
► There is lack or insufficiency of authorized unissued
shares of stock to cover the deposit
Page 138
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Equity ► The Company’s Retained Earnings exceeds its paid-in
capital by 100%. There is however, no disclosure of any
appropriation of retained earnings to comply with
Section 43 of the Corporation Code.
► Incomplete disclosures on Reserves/Appropriated
Retained Earnings, i.e., date of approval of Board of
Directors and Stockholders, details of appropriation and
timeline of implementation/usage.
► The Statement of Income and Retained Earnings show
that the company declared a cash dividend in 2012
amounting to P2.7 million. There are however, no
disclosures whether said dividend declaration has been
approved by the Board of Directors.
Page 139
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Equity ► There is no summary discussion of the company's track
record of registration of securities that indicates the
number of shares registered, issue/offer price, date of
approval of registration statement and the number of
holders as of year end (Issuers of Unlisted Securities)
► The discussion of the Company’s plan to address capital
deficiency is incomplete and does not appear to be
concrete. There should be a disclosure on the
additional projects in which the management is planning
to enter into and the source of funding for such projects
Page 140
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
Deposit for Future ► The recognition of "Deposit for Future Stock
Stock Subscription Subscription" as a separate line item under Equity
section is not correct considering that the Company has
enough unissued shares to cover the amount of deposit
Page 141
Common SEC Findings
Notes to the FS
Account Comment
RA No. 8556 (The ► The Company’s net worth is less than the required
Financing minimum paid up capital of P10M
Company Act of ► Investment in real estate and in shares of stocks in a
1998 and its real estate development corporation and other real
Implementing estate based projects exceeded 25% limit of the
Rules and Company’s net worth.
Regulations) ► The Company failed to use or invest more than 50% of
(Financing its fund in financing activities
Company)
► Total credit extended to the Company’s directors,
officers and stockholders exceeded the fifteen (15%)
limit of its net worth
Page 142
Thank you
SGV & Co. | Assurance | Tax | Transactions | Advisory
Ernst & Young refers to the global organization of member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate legal entity. Ernst &
Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, does not provide services to clients.
This publication contains information in summary form and is therefore intended for general guidance only. It is not intended to be a substitute for detailed research or the exercise of professional
judgment. Neither SGV & Co. nor any other member of the global Ernst & Young organization can accept any responsibility for loss occasioned to any person acting or refraining from action as a result
of any material in this publication. On any specific matter, reference should be made to the appropriate advisor.
ey.com/ph