Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Automated Palletizing
By
Michael A. Hernan I
Copyright: April 21, 2000
Published By:
Anderson Technical Services, Inc.
850 Morrison Road
Chillicothe, Ohio 45601
740-775-1962
www.atsi.cc
An Introduction to Palletizing
“Choosing the Right System”
by
Michael A. Hernan I
Abstract
Machines that automatically place cartons onto pallets, called “Palletizers”, vary greatly
in design and functionality. Selection and comparisons can be difficult if the user does
not know some of the basic design and functional parameters of the different equipment
offerings.
This paper reviews the different types of Palletizers and how they are best applied.
Palletizers are not stand alone machines; they work best within an integrated system or in
a “cell “ concept. This paper looks at Palletizers in systems and in a cells plus reviews
the before (in- feed) and after (out-feed) design requirements. It lists the throughputs and
flexibility of each machine type listed and provides application comparisons.
This paper endeavors to inform the reader about the general capabilities and
specifications of different types of palletizer. It will help the reader identify many of the
necessary considerations to determine the best machine type for their specific application.
Introduction
This paper will focus on palletizing, which is a form of unitizing. Palletizing refers to a
uniform load stacked on a wooden pallet, using a pre-determined case pattern sequence
and given number of layers. Unitizing refers to any load forming or unit load building
process. Loads can be formed using the same stacking procedure as palletizing, without
necessarily using a pallet, or loads may be stacked on slip sheets or on the floor.
The process of palletizing typically involves the stacking of cases, trays, bundles, bags,
pails or drums in a predetermined pattern configuration with a predetermined number of
layers. This paper will focus on the use of cases only, as they make up the vast majority
of palletizing applications.
No matter what type of palletizing equipment is used, several factors are constant. Cases,
case patterns, pallets, along with slip, pull pack and tie sheets are things every palletizer
must contend with. Before we look at the different equipment types, we will review what
they have to handle.
Cases & Case Patterns
The palletizers we will review can handle products from a small as 5” to 6” square boxes
with as many as 64 cartons per layer, up to a single carton size of 50” x 40” stacked one
to a layer. The product weight per carton can vary from 2 pounds up to 250 pounds with
a full pallet loads ranging up to 6,000 pounds.
An ideal case for building a formed load, is one that is rectangular and has a height that
approximates the width of the case. A case with a height that is 1-1/2 times the width of
the case or greater is termed a “high center of gravity case”. In some applications special
attention is required in order to avoid tipping over “high center of gravity cases” during
pattern forming. Rectangular cases enable stacking configurations that create a load that
has each layer rotated 180-degrees for interlocking purposes. In this way a very stable
load is built.
Square cases are less desirable in pallet forming than rectangular cases. Loads built using
square cases can only be column stacked and no interlocking of the cases can occur.
Some case sizes do not allow the patterns to be configured without gaps in the pattern
either side to side or front to back. However, the palletizer has the ability to create the
pattern with these gaps in both directions.
The terms “slip sheets” and “pull sheets” are synonymous. (Please reference Exhibit I).
They refer to a sheet on which the load is stacked, in place of or on top of a pallet. This
sheet is generally made from heavy corrugated and requires a special lift truck
attachment, which enables the load to be moved by the lift truck. Conventional fork
trucks do not have this attachment and cannot be used.
Tie sheets refer to sheets that are placed between the layers of a load to obtain load
stabilization. These are used predominantly when the cases to be stacked are square
and/or no interlocking case pattern sequence can be employed. Tie sheets can be thin
“butcher” paper, corrugated or fiberboard.
For most applications, the machines must handle the most common pallets used in
palletizing, conventional 2-way and 4-way wooden pallets together with solid plywood
pallets (slave pallets), that are often used in AS/RS (Automated Storage & Retrieval
Systems) or AGV (Automatic Guided Vehicle) systems. (Please reference Exhibit I)
Recently more companies are using plastic reusable pallets. These actually help
palletizing effectiveness as they are offer more consistency between individual pallets
and are less prone to damage than wood pallets.
Defining Speed
The assumption that the higher the price of the machine, the faster the
speed, is inaccurate. One of the basic fundamentals of palletizing is
that the more cases per layer, the faster the speed. Larger cartons
fill the pallet faster, thus making the palletizer appear faster. Smaller
cartons and intricate stacking patterns require more time.
The palletizer’s method of building a layer directly affects its speed. In-Line Palletizers
pick-up and move an entire layer, as opposed to a robotic–style machine that moves a
single case or two with each movement. Robotic Palletizers can build a load with a line
of waiting, accumulated, cartons faster than building with an intermittent flow of cartons
coming directly from production. Thus the infeed of cartons to the palletizer directly
affect its throughput speed. The same is true for the outfeed of cartons. If completed
pallets are not taken away fast enough the line becomes full and the palletizer has to stop.
The infeed and outfeed conditions directly affect all types of palletizers.
When considering speed requirements for a palletizing system, the rule of thumb is that
the palletizer- machine must be able to handle 25% more than the incoming packaging
line(s) can produce. Carton size, carton mix and the case pattern configuration must be
considered to calculate the palletizer speed with the aforementioned safety factor. This
“speed” must be based on round-the-clock operation and are sustainable speeds, not surge
rates.
Generally, when the manufacturer for a given model quotes speeds, they are based on an
8 to 10 case per layer configuration. A fully automatic low speed palletizer will operate
A Systems Approach
Regardless of the type of palletizer you select the interfaces both upstream and
downstream must match the rated operating speed of the palletizer or palletizing cell or
you new solution will cause more problems than it solves. After reviewing the
characteristics of each type of palletizer we will look at some typical systems layouts to
illustrate how they are used in everyday operations.
Palletizers
Types of Palletizers
The many different types of palletizing machines can
be categorized into two groups: In-Line and Robotic. In-Line Palletizers
Row Stripping
In-Line Palletizers offer speed while Robotic Palletizers
High Level
offer flexibility. Low Level
Vacuum Head
The approach to layout is different for In-Line &
Robotic Palletizers. Exhibit II illustrates the difference Robotic
Articulated Arm
and other examples are provided in this paper. (SCARA) Arm
Gantry (Cartesian)
In-Line Palletizers
These machines are dedicated to a line or lines to handle limited product/carton types.
The style you choose depends on your flow of cases at the end of the line and the type of
product you are handling.
Row-Stripping Palletizer
These are the most common machines. They are what most people envision when they
think of automated palletizing. These machines are designed for high speeds at
continuous duty.
This machine gets its name by the method it palletizes product. It first forms a row of
cartons. Once a row is completed, a pusher mechanism moves the row to the palletizer’s
make-up area. Several rows are combined to build a layer of products. To form the load,
the completed layers are stacked on a pallet or other unit load platform.
Row stripers can produce very high throughput speeds; speeds that can reach 160 cartons
per minute. This type of palletizer can also palletize products of different shapes and
sizes, provided that they are not intermixed. This type of machine has two basic types of
infeed configurations: high level and low level.
Low level units have an entry elevation of approximately 30”. This makes it ideal for
close coupling to case packers and case sealers, which have discharge elevations of
anywhere from 20” to 36”. If you have abundant floor space, this type of arrangement
offers several advantages over high level machines.
Biggest difference between low level and high level machines is that on low level
machines during the load building process, the elevator lifts one layer at a tine and the
load is built on a heavy-duty discharge conveyor, while the high level machine requires
an elevator to support the full load as it is being built. The added mechanical complexity
of a high level machine elevator results in more maintenance concerns compared to a low
level machine.
Top operating speed for this type of palletizer is typically about 25 cartons per minute.
An ideal application for a vacuum- head palletizer is one in which it handles rigid
products with a sturdy, flat tops. It is also an excellent choice for bags, drums and pails.
A single conveyor feeds the majority of palletizers from a packaging or production line.
This is why they are referred to as a dedicated machine. It is also common to have
several packaging lines feeding into one higher speed palletizer thereby reducing the
number of palletizers required. This arrangement is not unlike a funnel, pouring goods
quickly into a smaller opening. However, if the opening (palletizing operation) is too
slow or gets jammed, everything else upstream gets messy—quickly.
The need to accumulate product before and after palletizing is essential to smooth and
effective operations. When a single line is fed to a single dedicated palletizer, only the
product on that line is delivered to the palletizer. If the palletizer cannot keep- up or
pauses, the line backs-up, and eventually production on that line stops. When feeding
multiple product lines into a single high-speed palletizer back-up or pause in palletizing
can cause your operations to halt. That is why careful considerations must be given to
the accumulation. Please refer to Exhibits IV, V &VI for sample layouts that illustrate
this point.
The rule of thumb is to accumulate at least 1.5 times a full pallet load of each product
prior to feeding them to the palletizer. In the case of multiple product (conveyor) lines
being fed into a single high-speed palletizer, the palletizer must be capable of running at a
speed of approximately 10-20% greater than the total accumulated rates of each of the
conveyor lines feeding it. Thus, if three packaging lines, running at an accumulated rate
of 10 cases per minute per line were feeding into one palletizer, the palletizer must run at
10-20% faster than the 30 cases per minute being accumulated. In othe r words, the
palletizer must handle 33 to 36 cases per minute. This does not include the 25% safety
factor mentioned before.
Thus, if one packaging line is producing 16” long cartons and requires 80 cases to
complete a full load, this equates to a full load length of 107’ (1280” times 1.5, which
give a total accumulation conveyor length of 160’. This equation is repeated for each
additional line feeding the palletizer.
Robotic Palletizers
A robot’s strength is the ability to rapidly arrange mixed pallets while serving several
lines at the same time. These palletizers, depending on end-effector (end-of-arm-
tooling) can better handle thinner-walled corrugated and more fragile case. Robotic
Palletizers run at low to medium rates and are best used in applications that require a high
degree of flexibility, and intermixed product with different shapes and sizes. Speeds of 10
to 30 cases per minute are common.
If your operation requires different pallet patterns or uses different size cartons, the
controls and software programs for robotic palletizers give you the highest degree of
flexibility and quick reprogrammability you require.
Ø SCARA Arm
Ø Articulated Arm
Ø Gantry
All three types use end-effectors that are custom designed to handle the customer’s
product. Most often the design includes pneumatic cups, like the ones used by vacuum-
head palletizers; or they may use various types of mechanical grabs.
The layout configurations of these two “arm” type robots are very similar. (Please
review Exhibit II). In many cases they can be used interchangeably. Articulated arms
are better at building difficult intermixed loads on pallets, while SCARA arms are a bit
faster at building multiple pallet loads and usually cost less than articulated arm units.
The need to accumulate product before and after palletizing is still just as essential for
smooth and effective operations. The rule of thumb is to accumulate at least 1-1/2 full
pallet loads of product on the infeed line prior to feeding them to the palletizer. In the
case of multiple product (conveyor) lines being fed into a single robot palletizer, the
palletizer must be capable of running at a speed of approximately 10-20% greater than
the total accumulated rates of each of the conveyor lines feeding it. Thus, if three
packaging lines, running at an accumulated rate of 5 cases per minute per line were
Accumulation Length
The length of each line of accumulation conveyors from production into the
packaging/palletizing cell should be 1.5, minimum to 2 times a full pallet load of product.
Robots offer flexibility over speed. The infeed configurations are usually simpler than
In-Line Palletizers, however, the design of the palletizing cell is more critical. The
placement of the pallet(s), feeding pallets into and out of the system, all directly affect
throughput and systems’ functionality.
Other Considerations
An automated palletizer is usually part of a total packaging system. The palletizer may
have to interface or integrate with some of the following items:
Ø Case sealers
Ø Slip or tie sheet feeders
Ø Packaging machine
Ø Stretch wrappers
Ø Checkweighers
Ø Bar code labelers and applicators
Ø Pallet collector/dispensers
Ø Depalletizing
Often after installation as your system grows, demands for increased speed, flexibility
and capability happen. Often increases in speed are affected more by efficient system
configurations and changes in the inbound or outbound lines, than palletizer machine
speed.
Other challenges come with a specific stacking pattern for each type of product.
Sophisticated Palletizer Controllers can help to meet many of these challenges.
The number of case patterns that can be programmed into a fully automatic palletizer is
virtually limitless. However, when a pattern is programmed into a palletizer, it is not
simply a software change in the controller itself. One of the biggest challenges
manufactures must meet is building loads to customer’s specifications. More vendors
are requiring manufactures to build the pallet load so the bar code labels are readable on
all cases after stacking. Programmable controllers, systems’ controls, and software must
work together to fulfill this requirement.
There are several ways to solve the problem. If your application requires cases and you
are not using Robotic Palletizing, the turning function can be achieved with turning posts
or more elaborate things like side flaps, rotators, or lifting rotators.
For In-Line Palletizers mechanical stops are required in the machine, in order to separate
the cases during pattern forming. The hardware involves more than the case stops
themselves, it also includes cylinders to operate the stops, pneumatic valves to operate
the cylinders, and the software program to control them. All of which means additional
cost when the numbers of case pattern sequences are determined.
For Robotic Palletizers, the considerations and costs are somewhat less. Additional axes
of rotations (extra joints) are added to the end-of-arm tooling or end effector. With
robotic palletizers, the label is read up stream of the palletizer, the data is collected, and
then information to turn the carton is transmitted to the robot’s operating software. The
robot then uses its rotors to stack the carton properly on the pallet
When reviewing the justification of an automated palletizer, more than just direct labor
savings should be considered. The benefits produced by implementing an automated
palletizing operation are impressive:
All of these factors should be calculated into your return on investment (ROI) formula
when considering automating your palletizing/packaging operations.
To make the correct palletizer purchase, it is essential to understand how your business
will change in years to come. The higher throughput capacity your system requires, the
more elaborate the palletizing scheme becomes. Plan ahead for accessories such as
turning devices, pre-forming zones, slip sheet feeders, pallet dispensers, or parallel line
feeds.
Table 1 is a chart that summarizes the speed and flexibility of the types of palletizers we
have reviewed. The best machine is dependant on ones requirements and future needs.
Like all major capital decisions, proper research and thought should be given to
operations requirements and overall goals of the project before sending out bid requests
or settling on a machine to purchase.
Operating
Stacking
Speed Degree of
Palletizer Type Capacity Height Comments
(cartons/ Flexibility
(ft)
minute)
In-Line
Row Stripping 250 lb/ctn FAST! Many manufactures
40-160 800 lb/layer 5.5 -10 Low offer both low level & high
6,000 lb/load level designs.
Vacuum-Head Typically used with
10-25 100 lb/ctn 6-7.5 Medium products that have flat, rigid
tops; or delicate product.
Robotic
SCARA Arm Excellent degree of
10-30 200 lb/ctn Up to 9 High
flexibility.
Articulated Arm Excellent for building
10-30 400 lb/ctn Up to 6 High intermixed loads on one
pallet.
Gantry Up to Excellent for building up to
10-30 400 lb/ctn High
12 60 pallet simultaneously
Slave Pallet;
often used in AS/RS &
AGV applications 4-Way Pallet 2-Way Pallet
Exhibit II
In Line Vs. Robotic Arm
Palletizers
To have an effective palletizing operation Row Strippers need long accumulation lines to feed the machine. They can palletize different products,
but are limited to one product or pattern per pallet. Thus long accumulation lines for each product is required.
The layout above illustrates a typical arrangement for a high level row stripping machine. The infeed lines enter the machine at a high elevation
(10’-12’), thus saving valuable floor space.
The oufeed is equally important. This layout uses a shuttle transfer (T-Car) to take full loads from the palletizers to a stretch wrapper. After
stretch wrapping they accumulate on an a staging conveyor and await removal by lift truck.
Exhibit V
Row Stripper Palletizer
Low Level
The layout above illustrates a typical arrangement for a low level row stripping machine. The infeed lines enter the machine at a low elevation
(24”-36”), making it easier for maintenance and jam detection.
Like all row stripping machines, to have an effective operation they need long accumulation lines to feed the machine. They can palletize
different products, but are limited to one product or pattern per pallet. Thus long accumulation lines for each product is required.
The oufeed is equally important. This layout uses a shuttle transfer (T-Car) to take full loads from the palletizers to a stretch wrapper. After
stretch wrapping they accumulate on an a staging conveyor and await removal by lift truck.
Exhibit VI
Vacuum Head
The oufeed is less critical in this machine because the rates are
not as fast. This layout shows a small length of staging
conveyor at the exit end of the palletizer where full pallets
await removal by lift truck.
Exhibit VII
SCARA Arm
Palletizer Layouts
This illustration details a SCARA Robot palletizing cell. This cell accounts for future the
growth of the operations. This is an excellent example of palletizing in a “cell concept”.
The robot has the capability of handling an additional production line. Semi-automated at
present, the addition of pallet dispensers, exit conveyors and a lift table will make this
palletizing operation fully automated.
Exhibit VIII
Articulated Arm Robot
Palletizer Layouts
From
Production
The layout above illustrates a typical arrangement for a Articulated Arm Robot.
The robot can palletized multiple pallets at one time handling different loads.
A single end effector can be designed to handle cartons, slip sheets and pallets.
Good end effector design adds greatly to the versatility of these machines.
Exhibit IX
Articulated Arm Robot
Palletizer Layouts
The layout above illustrates the robot building intermixed loads by depalletizing
existing-built pallets on the floor and palletizing a new pallet on a production
conveyor.
The picture shows a palletizing cell that palletizes product from three
production lines. The line drawing shows a unit that builds intermixed loads
from a single main production line.
Exhibit X
2& 3-Axis Gantry
Palletizer Layouts
A gantry can come in 2, 3 or 4-axis configurations. The one shown to the right
has an x,z, and r axis. Different end effectors shown above-right allow for robot
style palletizers to handle almost any type of product and allows for superior
operations flexibility.
The layout above shows a 2-axis gantry palletizing cylinders. The advantage of a
gantry is the ability to stack loads high and to build many pallets at a time. The
layout approach to gantries is somewhat different than arm robots, but the overall
design philosophy is the same.
Exhibit XI
4-Axis Gantry
Palletizer Layouts
The fish-eye picture to the right shows reusable totes filled with production parts
being palletized. The loaded pallets move to the end of the line where they
accumulated and await pickup by a forklift.
Exhibit XII
4-Axis Gantry
Palletizer Layouts
Programmable controllers and software allow palletizers to handle limitless case and forming
patters. The flexibility and capability of palletizers is greatly enhanced by their use.
User friendly graphics and touch screen interfaces make palletizers easy to change pallet
configurations or handle different products. However, it must be remembered the machine must
also have the physical capabilities to execute the controllers commands.