JOHN WESLEY SCHOOL OF LAW AND GOVERNANCE

CIVIL PROCEDURE SYLLABUS 20201

ATTY. CARLOS P. GARCIA

STATUTES AND RULES:

A.M. No. 19-10-20-SC (2019 Amendments to the 1997 Rules of Civil Procedure)
Article VIII (Sections 1 and 5) of the 1987 Philippine Constitution
Batas Pambansa Bilang 129, as amended by Republic Act No. 7691
Republic Act No. 7902 (Expanding the Jurisdiction of the Court of Appeals)
Republic Act No. 7691 (Expanding the Jurisdiction of the Lower Courts)
Supreme Court Circular No. 09-94
Supreme Court Circular No. 21-99
Republic Act No. 8369
Supreme Court Circular No. 11-99, in relation to R.A. No. 8369
Republic Act No. 9285
Republic Act No. 8799 (Section , par.2, Chapter 2)
1991 Revised Rule on Summary Procedure
Rules of Procedure for Small Claims
Presidential Decree 1606, as amended
Presidential Decree 1083
Katarungang Pambarangay Law, Presidential Decree 1508,
Reublic Act No. 7160 (Section 399 to 422, Book III, Title I, Chapter 7)
A.M. No. 02-11-11-SC
A.M. No. 02-11-10-SC

CASES:

***Note: The Rules of Court have recently been amended via A.M. No. 19-10-20-SC. You are
expected to critically analyze the succeeding cases and determine whether their respective
doctrines apply at present.

Introduction and General Principles

Title Case No. Date

City of Manila v. Judge Grecia-Cuerdo, et al 175723 February 4, 2014
Medical Plaza Makati Condominium Corp v.
181416 November 11, 2013
Cullen
Spouses Rebamonte v. Spouses Lucero 237812 October 2, 2019
Sandoval v. Caneba 90503 September 27, 1990
Magpale v. Civil Service Commission 97381 November 5,1992
De Murga v. Chan L- 24680 October 7, 1968
Editha Padlan v. Dinglasan 180321 March 20, 2013
Quesada v. Department of Justice 150325 August 31, 2006
Lumbuan v. Ronquilo 155713 May 5, 2006
People v. Cawaling 117970 July 28, 1998
Zamora v. Heirs of Carmen 146195 November 18, 2004
Spouses Belvis, et al. v. Spouses Erola G.R. No. 239727 July 24, 2019
Re: Complaint-Affidavit of Elvira N. Enables, A.M. No. 18-11-09-SC January 22, 2019
Rebecca H. Angeles, and Estelita B. Ocampo
Gios-Samar, Inc. v. Department of 217158 March 12, 2019
Transportation and Communications, et al.
Kilusang Mayo Uno, et al. v. Aquino III, et al. 210500 April 2, 2019
Inmates of the New Bilibid Prison, Muntinlupa 212719 June 25, 2019
City v. De Lima, et al.

1 Based on the syllabus and professorial traditions of Dean Rico Paolo R. Quicho.
Victoria Manufacturing Corporation Employees 234446 July 24, 2019
Union v. Victoria Manufacturing Corporation
Republic of the Philippines, et al. v. Heirs of G.R. No. 201273 August 14, 2019
Paus, et al.
Metro Bottled Water Corporation v. Andrada 202430 March 6, 2019
Construction & Development Corporation, Inc.
Fruehauf Electronics Philippines Corporation v. 2014197 November 23, 2016
Techonology Electronics Assembly and
Management Pacific Corporation

I. ORDINARY CIVIL ACTIONS

Rule 1 - General Provisions

Title Case No. Date

Tamano v. Ortiz 126603 June 29, 1998
Domagas v. Jensen 158407 January 17,2005
Yu v. Pacleb 172172 February 24,2009
Cabutihan v. Landcenter 146594 June 10, 2002
Citizen Surety v. Melencio-Herrera L-32170 March 31,1971
Go v. UCPB 156187 November 11, 2004
Gochan v. Gochan 146089 December 13, 2001
Empire Insurance, Inc., et al. v. Bacalla, et al. 195215 March 6, 2019
Spouses Pozon, et al. v. Lopez 210607 March 25, 2019
Heirs of Ramiro, et al. v. Spouses Bacaron 196874 February 6, 2019
Manchester Dev’t Corp. v. Court of Appeal L-75919 May 7, 1987
Sun Insurance Ltd. v. Asuncion 79937-38 February 13, 1989
Tacay v. RTC of Tagum 88075-77 December 20, 1989
Ayala Corp. v. Madayag 88421 January 30, 1990
Negros Oriental Planters v. Hon. Presiding
179878 December 24, 2008
Judge of Negros
Heirs of Bertuldo Hinog v. Melicor 140954 April 12, 2005

Rule 2 - Cause of Action

Title Case No. Date

Juana Complex Homeowners v. Fil-Estate Land 152272 March 5, 2012
Del Rosario v. Far East Bank and Trust 150134 October 31, 2007
Company
Progressive Dev’t Corp. v. Court of Appeals 123555 January 22,1999
Joseph v. Bautista 41423 February 23,1989
Flores v. Mallare-Phillips L-66620 September 24, 1986
Central Visayas Finance Corporation v. Spouses 212674 March 25, 2019
Adlawan, et al.

Rule 3 - Parties to Civil Actions

Title Case No. Date

Rayo v. Metrobank 165142 December 10, 2007
Comm. Domingo v. Scheer 154745 January 29, 2004
Domingo v. Carague 161065 April 15, 2005
Pacana-Contreras v. Rovila Water Supply 168979 December 2, 2013
Juana Complex Homeowners v. Fil-Estate Land 152272 March 5, 2012
Mathay v. Consolidated Bank L-23136 August 26, 1974
Newsweek v. IAC L-63559 May 30, 1986
Oposa v. Factoran 101083 July 30, 1993

2
Heirs of Bertuldo Hinog v. Melicor 140954 April 12, 2005
Dela Cruz v. Joaquin 162788 July 28, 2005
Spouse Algura v. City of Naga 150135 October 30, 2006
White v. City of Manila 122846 January 20, 2009
Grandholdings Investments (SPV-AMC), Inc. v. 221271 June 19, 2019
Court of Appeals, et al.
Civil Service Commission v. Rasuman 239011 June 17, 2019
Heirs of Dinglasan v. Ayala Corporation, et al. 204378 August 5, 2019
Spouses Yu v. David Miranda, et al. 225752 March 27, 2019

Rule 4 - Venue of Actions

Title Case No. Date

Dacoycoy v. IAC 74854 April 2, 1991
Diaz v. Adiong 106847 March 5, 1993
Phil. Banking Corp. v. Tensuan 106920 December 10, 1993
Unimasters Conglomeration Inc. v. Court of 119657 February 7, 1997
Appeals
Anita Mangila v. Court of Appeals 125027 August 12, 2002
Hyatt Elevators v. Goldstar Elevators 161026 October 24, 2005
Nocum v. Tan 145022 September 23, 2005
Spouses Lantin v. Lantion 160053 August 26, 2006
Cabrera v. The Philippine Statistics Authority, et 241369 June 3, 2019
al.
Hygienic Packaging Corporation v. Nutri-Asia, 201302 January 23, 2019
Inc.
Pillars Property Corporation v. Century 201021 March 4, 2019
Communities Corporation

Rule 5 - Uniform Procedure in Trial Courts

Rule 6 - Kinds of Pleadings

Title Case No. Date

Financial Building Corp. v. Forbes Park 133119 August 17, 2000
De Lima v. Gatdula 204528 February 19, 2013
Dio v. SBMA 189532 June 11, 2014
Padilla v. Globe Asiatique 207376 August 6, 2014
Eliza Zuniga-Santos v. Santos-Gran 197380 October 8, 2014
Pili, Jr. v. Resurreccion 222798 June 19, 2019

Rule 7 - Parts and Contents of Pleadings

Title Case No. Date

Vallacar Transit Inc v. Jocelyn Catubig 175512 May 30,2011
Vda. De Formoso v. PNB 154707 June 1, 2011
Argallon-Jocson and Tusing v. Court of Appeals 162836 July 30, 2009
Maranaw Hotel and Resort Corp. v. Court of
149660 January 20, 2009
Appeals
Abiotiz v. Chiongbian 197530 July 9, 2014
Zarsona Medical v. PHIC 191225 October 13, 2014
Heirs of Dinglasan v. Ayala Corporation, et al. 204378 August 5, 2019
Goodland Company, Inc. v. Banco De Oro- 208543 February 11, 2019
Unibank, Inc., et al
Dizon v. Matti, Jr. 215614 March 27, 2019
FEMC v. Heirs of Llanes, et al. 194114 March 27, 2019

3
Good Earth Enterprises, Inc. v. Garcia, et al. 238761 January 22, 2020
Hirakawa v. Lopzcom Realty Corporation, et al. 213230 December 5, 2019

Rule 8 - Manner of Making Allegations in the Pleadings

Title Case No. Date

Canete vs Genuino Ice Co. 154080 January 22, 2008
Guevarra v. Eala 7136 August 1, 2007
Steelcase v. Design International 171995 April 18, 2012
Young Builders Corporation v. Benson 198998 June 19, 2019
Industries, Inc.
Lara’s Gifts and Decors, Inc. v. Midtown 225433 August 28, 2019
Industrial Sales, Inc.
Keihin-Everett Forwarding Co., Inc. 212107 January 28, 2019
Halimao v. Villanueva 3825 February 1, 1996
Tan v. Court of Appeals 125861 September 9, 1998
Asia Production Co. Inc v. Pano 51058 January 27, 1992
Sunville Timber Products Inc v. Abad 85502 February 24, 1992
Municipality of Binan v. Court of Appeals 94733 February 17, 1993
NPC v. Court of Appeals 84695 May 8, 1990
Pacsport Inc Phils v. Niccolo Sports 141602 November 22, 2001
Hacienda Bigaa Inc. v. Chavez 174160 April 20, 2010
Fels Energy Inc v. Province of Batangas 168557 February 19, 2007
Yuvienco v. Dacuycuy L-55048 May 27, 1981
Bank of America v. Court of Appeals 120135 March 31,2003
Associated Bank v. Spouses Montano 166383 October 16, 2009
Lu Ym v. Gertrudes Nabua 161309 February 23, 2005
Carniyan v. Home Guaranty Corporation 228516 August 14, 2019

Rule 9 - Effect of Failure to Plead

Rule 10 - Amended and Supplemental Pleadings
Rule 11 - When to File Responsive Pleadings

Title Case No. Date

Otero v. Tan 200134 August 15, 2012
Ponciano v. Parentela 133284 May 9, 2000
Heirs of Favis Sr. v. Gonzales 185922 January 15, 2014
Korea Technologies Co. Ltd. v. Lerma 143581 January 7,2008
Gajudo v. Traders Royal Bank 151098 March 21, 2006
De Guia v. De Guia 135384 April 4, 2001
Luna v. Mirafuente A.M. No. MTJ-05-1610 September 26, 2005
Carniyan v. Home Guaranty Corporation 228516 August 14, 2019

Rule 12 - Bill Of Particulars

Title Case No. Date

Salita v. Magtolis 106429 June 13, 1994
Guy v. Guy 189486 September 5, 2012

Rule 13 – Filing and Service of Pleadings

Title Case No. Date

Aberca, et al. v. Ver 166216 March 14, 2012
MMIC v. NAPOCOR 161219 October 6, 2008
Republic v. Caguioa 174385 February 20, 2013

4
Bracero v. Arcelo 212496 March 18, 2015
Aguilar v. Benlot, et al. 232806 January 21, 2019
Villalongha, et al. v. Court of Appeals, et al. 227222 August 20, 2019

Rule 14 - Summons

Title Case No. Date

Robinsons v. Millares 163584 December 12, 2006
Perkin Elmer Singapore Pte Ltd. v. Dakila 172242 August 14, 2007
Trading Corp.
NM Rothschild & Sons v. Lepanto Consolidated 175799 November 28, 2011
Mining Company
Orion Security Corp. v. Kaifam Enterprises Inc. 163287 April 27, 2007
Santos v. PNOC Exploration Corp. 170943 September 23, 2008
PCIB v. Spouses Wilson Dy Hong Pi, et. al 171137 June 5, 2009
Spouses Manuel v. Ong 205249 October 15, 2014
Greenstar v. Nissin 181517 July 6, 2015
Montefalcon v. Vasquez 165016 June 17, 2008
Reicon v. Diamond 204796 February 4, 2015
United Coconut Planters Bank v. Spouses Sy, et 204753 March 27, 2019
al.

Rule 15 - Motions

Title Case No. Date

Vlason Enterprises Corp. v. Court of Appeals 121662-64 July 6, 1999
Vette Industrial v. Cheng 170232-170301 December 5, 2006
Boiser v. Aguirre A.M. RTJ-04-1886 May 16, 2005
Sarmiento v. Zaratan 167471 February 5, 2007
Areza v. Express Savings Bank 176697 September 10, 2014
Microsoft Corp. v. Farajallah 205800 September 2014
Vlason Enterprises Corp. v. Court of Appeals 121662-64 July 6, 1999
Vette Industrial v. Cheng 170232-170301 December 5, 2006
Boiser v. Aguirre A.M. RTJ-04-1886 May 16, 2005
Sarmiento v. Zaratan 167471 February 5, 2007
Areza v. Express Savings Bank 176697 September 10, 2014

Rule 16 - Motion to Dismiss [provision deleted – relevant cases transferred to Rule 8]

Rule 17 - Dismissal of Actions

Title Case No. Date

O.B. Jovenir Construction Development Corp. v.
135803 March 26, 2006
Macamir Realty and Court of Appeals
Cruz v. Court of Appeals 164797 February 13, 2006
Ko v. PNB 169131-32 January 28, 2006
Ramnani v. Court of Appeals 101789 April 28, 1993
Martinez v. Republic 160895 October 30, 2006
Indiana Aerospace University v. CHED 139371 April 4, 2001

Rule 18 - Pre-Trial

Title Case No. Date

LCK Industries Inc v. Planters Development 170606 November 23, 2007

5
Bank
Calalang v. Court of Appeals 103185 January 22, 1993
Citibank N.A. v. Chua 102300 March 17, 1993
Paredes v. Verano 164375 October 12, 2006

Rule 19 - Intervention

Title Case No. Date

Mactan Cebu International v. Heirs of Minoza 186045 February 2, 2011
Looyuko v. Court of Appeals 102696 July 12, 2001
First Lepanto-Taisho Insurance Corporation v. 197219 October 1, 2019
Lavine Loungewear Manufacturing, Inc.

Rule 20 – Calendar of Cases

Rule 21 – Subpoena

Title Case No. Date

Collado v. Bravo A.M. No. P-99- April 10, 2001
1307
Roco v. Contreras G.R. No. 158275 June 28, 2005
People of the Philippines v. Montejo L-24154 October 31, 1967

Rule 22 – Computation of Time

Rule 23 - Depositions Pending Actions

Title Case No. Date

Fortune Corporation v. Court of Appeals 108119 January 19, 1994
BDO Strategic Holdings, Inc. v. Asia 217360 November 13, 2019
Amalgamated Holdings Corporation
People of the Philippines v. Sergio, et al. 240053 October 9, 2019

Rule 24 - Depositions Before Action or Pending Appeal

Title Case No. Date

Dasmarinas Garments Inc. v. Reyes 108229 August 24, 1993
Republic v. Sandiganbayan 90478 November 21, 1991
Caguiat v. Torres L-25481 October 31, 1969
Cariaga v. Court of Appeals 143561 June 6, 2001

Rule 25 - Interrogatories to Parties

Title Case No. Date

Marcelo v. Sandiganbayan 156605 August 28, 2007

Rule 26 - Admission by Adverse Party

Title Case No. Date

Development Bank of the Phil. v. Court of
153034 September 20, 2005
Appeals

Rule 27 - Production or Inspection of Documents or Things (Rule 27)

Title Case No. Date

Solid Bank Corp. v. Gateway Electronics Corp. 164805 April 30, 2008

6
Eagleridge Developmet Corp. v. Naval 204700 November 24, 2014
Air Philippines Corp. v. Pennswell Inc. 172835 December 13, 2007

Rule 28 - Physical and Mental Examinations of Persons

Rule 29 - Refusal to Comply with Modes of Discovery

Title Case No. Date

Raul Arellano v. CFI of Sorsogon L-34897 July 15, 1975
Spouses Zepeda v. China Bank Corp. 172175 October 9, 2006

Rule 30 - Trial

Title Case No. Date

People v. Mazo 136869 October 17, 2001
Sarmiento v. Juan L-56605 January 28, 1983

Rule 31 - Consolidation or Severance

Title Case No. Date

Superlines Trans. Co. v. Victor L-64250 September 30, 1983
Goodland Company, Inc. v. Banco De Oro- 208543 February 11, 2019
Unibank, Inc., et al.

Rule 32 - Trial by Commissioner

Title Case No. Date

Aljem’s Corp. v. Court of Appeals 122216 March 28, 2001
Cabuguas, et al. v. Nery, et al. 219915 April 3, 2019

Rule 33 - Demurrer to Evidence (Rule 33)

Title Case No. Date

Republic v. Sandiganbayan 152154 November 18, 2003
Radiowealth Finance Corp. v. Del Rosario 138739 July 6, 2000
David et. al. v. Rivera 139913 & 140159 January 16, 2004

Rule 34 - Judgment on the Pleadings

Rule 35 - Summary Judgment

Title Case No. Date

Meneses v. Sec. of Agrarian Reform 156304 October 23, 2006
Bitanga v. Pyramid Construction 173526 August 25, 2008
Bungcayao v. Fort Ilocandia 170483 April 19, 2010
Globe Asiatique Realty Holdings Corporation v. 229339 July 29, 2019
Union Bank of the Philippines
Dupasquier, et al. v. Ascendas (Philippines) 211044 July 24, 2019
Corporation
Trade and Investment Development 233850 July 1, 2019
Corporation of the Philippines v. Philippine
Veterans Bank

Rule 36 - Judgments, Final Orders and Entry Thereof

Title Case No. Date

Lacurom v. Tienzo A.M. No. RTJ-07- October 9, 2007

7
 2075|||
Pena v. GSIS 159520 September 19, 2006
Arroyo v. Court of Appeals 202860 April 10, 2019
National Power Corporation v. Delta P Inc. 221709 October 16, 2019

Rule 37 - New Trial or Reconsiderations

Rule 38 - Relief from Judgments, Orders or Other Proceedings

Title Case No. Date

Cansino v. Court of Appeals 125799 August 21, 2003
Uy v. First Metro Integrated Steel 167245 September 27, 2006
Purcon Jr. v. MRM Philippines Inc. et al, 182718 September 26, 2008
Yusuke Fukuzumi v. Sanritsu Great
140630 August 12, 2004
International Corp. et al.
Bernardo v. Soriano 200104 June 19, 2019
Valencia (Bukidnon) Farmers Cooperative 219984 April 3, 2019
Marketing Association, Inc., et al. v. Heirs of
Cabotaje, et al.
Bagaporo v. People of the Philippines 211829 January 30, 2019
Santos v. Santos 214593 July 17, 2019
People of the Philippines v. Mallari, et al. 197164 December 4, 2019
Rule 39 – Execution, Satisfaction and Effect of Judgments

Title Case No. Date

Premiere Development Bank vs Flores 175339 December 16, 2008
A.M. No. P-04-
Dagooc vs Erlina March 16, 2005
1857
Fiestan vs Court of Appeals 81552 May 28, 1990
Manila Remnant Co. Inc. vs Court of Appeals 107282 March 16, 1994
Malonzo vs Mariano 53998 May 31, 1989
City of Naga vs Asuncion 174042 July 9, 2008
Silverio et. al vs Filipino Business Consultants
143312 August 12, 2005
Inc.
Valencia (Bukidnon) Farmers Cooperative 219984 April 3, 2019
Marketing Association, Inc., et al. v. Heirs of
Cabotaje, et al.
Ariñola v. Almodiel, Jr. A.M. No. P-19- January 7, 2019
3925
Balmaceda-Tugano v.Marcelino A.M. No. P-14- October 14, 2019
3233
Diamond Drilling Corporation of the 201785 April 10, 2019
Philippines v. Crescent Mining and
Development Corporation
Monterona, et al. v. Coca-Cola Bottlers G.R. No. 209116 January 14, 2019
Philippines, Inc., et al.
Vda. de Atienza v. Aguilar A.M. No. P-19- August 14, 2019
3988
Republic of the Philippines v. Roguza 199705 April 3, 2019
Development Corporation, et al.
BDO Leasing & Finance, Inc. v. Great Domestic 205286 June 19, 2019
Insurance Company of the Philippines, Inc.
Far East Bank and Trust Company v. Union 196637 June 3, 2019
Bank of the Philippines
Villamor & Victolero Construction Company 218771 June 3, 2019
People of the Philippines v. Santiago 228819 July 24, 2019
Ang v. Spouses Bitanga, et al. 223046 November 28, 2019
Uematsu v. Balinon 234812 November 25, 2019
Perez v. Manotok Realty, Inc. 216157 October 14, 2019

8
Rule 40 – Appeal from Municipal Trial Courts to the Regional Trial Courts

Title Case No. Date

Encarnation v. Amigo 169793 September 15, 2006
Heirs of De La Rosa v. Calderon-Bargas 147939 July 6, 2007
Rodolfo Canlas v. Iluminada Tubil 184285 September 25, 2009

Rule 41 - Appeal from the Regional Trial Courts

Title Case No. Date

Neypes v. Court of Appeals 141524 September 14, 2005
Trans International v. Court of Appeals 128421 January 26, 1998
Ricardo Silverio, Jr. v. Court of Appeals 178933 September 16, 2009
Sps. Lebin v. Vilma S. Mirasol 164255 September 7, 2011
Tiong Bi, Inc. v. Philippine Health Insurance G.R. No. 229106, February 20, 2019
Corporation
Spouses Fernandez v. Smart Communications, G.R. No. 212885 July 17, 2019
Inc.
Yap, et al. v. Heirs of Pantalan, et al. G.R. No. 199783 April 10, 2019

Rule 42 – Petition for Review from the Regional Trial Courts to the Court of Appeals

Title Case No. Date

Ross Rica Sales Center Inc. vs Ong 132197 August 16, 2005
Macawiwili Gold Mining and Dev’t. Co. Inc. vs
115104 October 12, 1998
CA
Atty. Jesus F. Fernandez vs. Court of Appeals 131094 May 16, 2005

Rule 43 - Appeals From Quasi-Judicial Agencies to the Court of Appeals

Title Case No. Date

Fabian v. Desierto 129742 September 16, 1998
Santos v. Go 156081 October 19, 2005
Lapid v. Court of Appeals 142261 June 29, 2000
Phillips Seafood Corporation v. Board of 175787 February 4, 2009
Investments

Rule 44 - Ordinary Appealed Cases

Title Case No. Date

Mecado v. Sps. Espina 173987 February 25, 2013
Maricalum Mining corp. v. Remington 158332 February 11, 2008
Industrial Sales Corp.
Corazon Cruz v. MIAA 184732 September 9, 2013

Rule 45 - Appeal by Certiorari to the Supreme Court

Title Case No. Date

Nunez v. GSIS Family Bank 163988 November 17, 2005
China Road and Bridge Corp. v. Court of
137898 December 15, 2000
Appeals
Panganiban v. Tara Trading Shipmanagement, 187032 October 18, 2010
Inc.
DAR v. Berenguer 154094 March 9, 2010
Association of Non-Profit Clubs, Inc. v. BIR 228539 June 26, 2019

9
Interphil Laboratories, Inc. v. OEP Philippines, 203697 March 20, 2019
Inc.
People of the Philippines v. Sandiganbayan 219824-25 February 12, 2019
Ignacio et al. v. Ragasa et al. 227896 January 29, 2020
Magsaysay Maritime Corporation, et al. v. Buico 230901 December 5, 2019
BF Citiland Corporation v. Bangko Sentral ng 224912 October 16, 2019
Pilipinas

Rule 46 - Original Cases

Title Case No. Date

Guy vs Court of Appeals 165849 December 10, 2007
Molina vs Court of Appeals 143156 January 13, 2003
NYK International vs NLRC 146267 February 17, 2003
Cabuguas, et al. v. Nery, et al. 219915 April 3, 2019

Rule 47 - Annulment of Judgements, Final Orders and Resolutions

Title Case No. Date

Bulawan v. Aquende 182819 June 22, 2011
Lopez v. Esquivel 168734 April 24, 2009
Alaban v. CA 156021 September 23, 2005
Llamas v. CA 149588 September 29, 2009
Sps. Arcenas v. Queen City Development Bank 166819 June 16, 2010
Genato Investments, Inc. v. Barrientos 207443 July 23, 2014
Heirs of Collado v. Gutierrez G.R. No. 212938 July 30, 2019
Heirs of Ramirez v. Abon, et al. G.R. No. 222916 July 24, 2019

Rule 48 - Preliminary Conference

Rule 49 - Oral Argument
Rule 50 - Dismissal of Appeal

Rule 51 - Judgment

Title Case No. Date

Natalia Realty, Inc. v. CA 126462 Nov. 12, 2002
Philippine Hawk Corporation v. Lee 166869 Feb 16, 2010
Arroyo v. Court of Appeals, et al. G.R. No. 202860, April 10, 2019
Goodland Company, Inc. v. Banco De Oro- 208543 February 11, 2019
Unibank, Inc., et al

Rule 52 - Motion for Reconsideration

Rule 53 - New Trial

Title Case No. Date

Gonzales III v. Office of the President 196231-196232 Jan. 28, 2014
Rivera-Avante v. Rivera, et al. 224137 April 3, 2019
Spouses Sumndad, et al. v. Friday’s Holdings, 235586 January 22, 2020
Inc.

Rule 54 – Internal Business

Rule 55 – Publication of Judgments and Final Resolutions

Rule 56 – Original Cases

Title Case No. Date

Triumph International v. Apostol and 164423 June 16, 2009
Opulencia

10
Navarro v. Executive Secretary 180050 April 12, 2011
Heirs of Maura So v. Obliosca 147082 January 28, 2008

II. PROVISIONAL REMEDIES

Rule 57 - Preliminary Attachment

Title Case No. Date

Magaling v. Ong 173333 August 13, 2008
Davao Light & Power Co. v. CA 93262 December 29, 1991
Olib v. Pastoral 81120 August 20, 1990
Valmonte v. CA 108538 January 22, 1994
Trader Royal Bank v. IAC L-66321 October 31, 1984
Booklight, Inc. v. Tiu 213650 June 17, 2019

Rule 58 - Preliminary Injunction

Title Case No. Date

Strategic Alliance Development Corp. v. Star 187872 April 11, 2011
Infrastructure Development Corp.
Australian Professional Realty v. Municipality 183367 March 14, 2012
of Padre Garcia
Allgemeine-Bau-Chemie Phils v. Metropolitan 159296 February 10, 2006
Bank
Cabili v. Balindog A.M. No. RTJ- September 6, 2011
2225
Hernandez v. National Power Corporation 145328 March 23, 2006
Tiong Bi, Inc. v. Philippine Health Insurance 229106, February 20, 2019
Corporation
Empire Insurance, Inc., et al. v. Bacalla, et al. 195215 March 6, 2019
Lerias v. Court of Appeals, et al. 193548 April 10, 2019

Rule 59 - Receivership

Title Case No. Date

Normandy v. Duque L-25407 August 29, 1969
Vivares v. Reyes 155408 Feb. 13, 2008

Rule 60 - Replevin

Title Case No. Date

BA Finance Corp. v. CA 102998 July 5, 1996
Chiao Liong Tan v. CA 106251 November 19, 1993
Northern Motors v. Herrera L-32674 February 22, 1973
Smart Communications, Inc. v. Astorga 148132 January 28, 2008

Rule 61 - Support Pendente Lite

Title Case No. Date

Reyes v. Ines-Luciano L-48219 February 28, 1979
Lam v. Chua 131286 March 18, 2004
Calderon v. Roxas 185595 January 9, 2013

Provisional Deposit Order

11
 Title Case No. Date
Lorenzo Shipping Corporation v. Villarin, et al. 175727 & 178713 March 6, 2019

III. SPECIAL CIVIL ACTIONS

Rule 62 - Interpleader

Title Case No. Date

Ocampo Vs. Tirona 147812 April 6, 2005
WackWack Golf and Country Club Vs. Lee E. L-23851 March 26, 1976
Won

Rule 63 - Declaratory Relief and Similar Remedies

Title Case No. Date

DBM Vs. Manila’s Finest Retirees Association 169446 May 9, 2007
Martelino Vs. NHMF Corp. 160208 June 30, 2008
Monetary Board vs. Philippine Veterans Bank 189571 January 21, 2015
GSIS v. Daymiel, et al. 218097 March 11, 2019
Inmates of the New Bilibid Prison, Muntinlupa 212719 & 214637 June 25, 2019
City v. De Lima, et al.
Dupasquier, et al. v. Ascendas (Philippines) 211044 July 24, 2019
Corporation

Rule 64 – Review of Judgments and Final Orders or Resolutions of the Comission on

Elections and Commission on Audit

Title Case No. Date

Pates v. Commission on Elections, et al. 184915 June 30, 2009

Rule 65 - Certiorari, Prohibition, and Mandamus

Title Case No. Date

Day vs RTC of Zamboanga 79119 November 22, 1990
Romy’s Freight Services Inc. vs Castro 141637 June 8, 2006
Fajardo vs Bautista 102193-97 May 10, 1994
Spouses Dacudao vs. Sec. of Justice Raul
188056 Jan. 8, 2013
Gonzales
Bank of Commerce vs. Radio Philippines
195615 April 21, 2014
Network, Inc.
Spouses Yusay vs. CA 156684 April 6, 2011
Star Special Watchmen vs. Puerto Prinsesa City 181792 April 21, 2014
GSIS Family Bank Employees Union v. 210773 January 23, 2019
Villanueva, et al.
Callang v. Commission on Audit 210683 January 8, 2019
Jader v. Heir of Allones, et al. 209014 March 27, 2019
Ha Datu Tawahig v. Lapinid, et al. 221139 March 20, 2019
Go-Yu v. Yu 230443 April 3, 2019
Inmates of the New Bilibid Prison, Muntinlupa 212719 & 214637 June 25, 2019
City v. De Lima, et al.
Department of Education v. Rizal Teachers 202097 July 3, 2019
Kilusang Bayan for Credit, Inc.

Rule 66 – Quo Warranto

Title Case No. Date

Arroyo v. Court of Appeals 202860 April 10, 2019

12
Rule 67 – Expropriation

Title Case No. Date

Republic of the Philippines v. Holy Trinity
172410 April 14, 2008
Realty Development Corp.
National Transmission Corporation v. Bermuda
214782 April 3, 2019
Development Corporation

Rule 68 – Foreclosure of Real Estate Mortgage

Rule 69 – Partition

Title Case No. Date

Vda. de Daffon v. Court of Appeals, et al. 129017 August 20, 2002

Rule 70 – Forcible Entry and Unlawful Detainer

Rule 71 – Contempt

Title Case No. Date

Ang v. Spouses Bitanga, et al. 223046 November 28, 2019
Uematsu v. Balinon 234812 November 25, 2019

13