Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract—This study was undertaken to obtain information on ments has been derived from early case reports 1-3 or from sur-
the prevalence of music-related upper-extremity problems peculiar veys of performers.4-9 These surveys generally consisted of
to a specific instrument or group of closely-related instruments, and
to help determine what problem types are most common or charac- reporting the performers’ subjective descriptions of physical
teristic for players of specific instruments. Music-related problems in symptoms and their locations, and did not include specific
167 performers from a hand surgical practice were reviewed retro- diagnoses made by health care professionals. Objective data
spectively. The musicians ranged in age from 9 to 83 years; 41.9% from an investigator’s clinical practice often have been
were males. Nearly 90% were professional performers, teachers, col- derived from specific study populations such as music stu-
legiate music students, or dedicated amateurs. More than 75%
played strings or keyboard instruments. Multiple diagnoses were dents, amateur players, and performers on specific instru-
found in 37.7% of musicians. Data from the six largest instrumen- ments5,10-13; other reports have focused on a single disease or
tal groups revealed that muscle–tendon strain diagnoses were most disorder and its instrument-specific prevalences.14-16 Addi-
common, occurring principally among pianists, violinists and vio- tional articles, also based on clinical experience or research,
lists, guitarists, and reed instrumentalists. Other common diagnoses have reported on instrument-specific symptoms but have not
included inflammatory disorders (tenosynovitis and the like), hyper-
mobility, masses, and arthritic problems. Of the pianists, 54.7% included specific diagnostic information.17 This relative lack
developed strains, 17.4% inflammatory conditions, and 12.8% of published instrument-specific diagnostic data served as the
nerve problems. Violinists and violists as a group had 64.4% strains impetus for undertaking the current investigation.
and 6.7% inflammatory conditions. Guitarists presented with This study attempted to provide some answers to two
37.5% strains, 21.9% inflammatory conditions, and 15.6% nerve questions: First, how common are upper extremity problems
problems. Flutists had 25% strains and 45% inflammatory condi-
tions. Other woodwind musicians developed 68.2% strains and that are peculiar or unique to a specific instrument or group
13.6% inflammatory conditions. Percussionists had 36.4% strains of closely-related instruments? Secondly, what music-related
and 36.4% inflammatory conditions. Only one musician developed upper-extremity problem types are most common or charac-
an upper-extremity problem that could be considered unique to teristic for players of specific instruments?
playing a specific instrument. Statistically significant occurrence
rates were found only in pianists under age 30 with strain diagnoses
and in those above age 30 with inflammatory problems. These cat- MATERIALS AND METHODS
egories seem to be related to repetitive and/or forceful upper-
extremity movements, and the resulting specific pathological Data were obtained from the author’s university-affiliated
processes. Med Probl Perform Art 17:135–140, 2002. hand and upper extremity practice for the period 1984 to
1996, during which time a database of prospectively obtained
Other diagnostic groups included hypermobility, which ilarity of instruments and playing techniques. A total of 32 dif-
was recognized as a secondary condition in seven of these ferent diagnoses were made, eight musicians initially present-
patients, a frequency equal to that for all other instruments ing with more than one. Twelve patients developed muscle
or instrumental groups. In the remainder of these patients, strains, all of which occurred in males and were located distal
two had ganglia or other masses, one had joint laxity, and to the elbow. Right-sided problems were diagnosed in two
three had joint stiffness or degenerative joint disease. men, left-sided in five, and bilateral in an additional five; three
Pianists less than age 30 were much more likely to present muscle strains were in the intrinsic muscles, four in the flexors,
with strain problems (21/25) than inflammatory ones (2/25), and five in the extensors. Seven guitarists (four of them males)
while those age 30 and older were less likely to do so (13/33 incurred tenosynovitis of the wrist or fingers, but no more
strain vs. 9/33 inflammatory). This difference between age than two had involvement of the same anatomical location.
groups is statistically significant at the p < 0.001 level, based Right and left sides were equally involved, with three patients
on chi-square testing. All seven pianists diagnosed as having in each category; one other had bilateral difficulties.
hypermobility syndrome were age 30 or less; four were in Five neurological diagnoses were made, including three
middle or secondary school and belonged to musician classes musicians with CTS and two with focal dystonia in the hand
D and E. The three youngest students also incurred strains of or fingers. Three additional guitarists developed wrist ganglia
their flexor or extensor groups about the wrist, while the that affected their playing (this number represented 60% of
oldest (age 16) had a right-sided CTS. all patients diagnosed as having ganglia), while the other five
presented with a miscellany of different playing-related diag-
Upper Strings—26 Patients noses. As was found with the upper bowed strings, there was
no significant age differential in the prevalence of either
Violinists and violists were combined in this subset, based strain or inflammatory diagnoses in this subset.
on the similarities of holding and playing their instruments.
The 26 ranged in age from 9 to 73 years, and 69.2% were Flute—13 Patients
female. Forty-five separate diagnoses were made, ten musi-
cians having more than one. Seventeen of the 26 patients These musicians’ ages ranged from 17 to 62 years; all but
had muscle strains, and showed a distal limb distribution (six one were female. They presented with a total of 20 diagnoses,
intrinsic, eight flexor, and seven extensor) and percentages seven performers having more than one at the initial visit.
similar to those of the pianists. Unlike the pianists, these This was the only instrument whose players’ inflammatory
musicians’ left hands were involved more commonly. Right- diagnoses outnumbered muscle strains (nine to five); three of
sided strains occurred in two men and one woman, left-sided the nine were de Quervain’s tenosynovitis at the wrist, two
strains in two men and five women, and bilateral strains in were trigger digits, and an additional three were located prox-
two men and five women. In addition, four musicians devel- imal to the forearm. Five of the nine inflammatory condi-
oped neck muscle strains and four strained their rotator cuff tions were left-sided, while four were on the right. Four of the
muscle complex about the shoulder; of this group, two were five patients with muscle strains had involvement of their
left-sided and two were bilateral. wrist and finger flexors or extensors, while the other devel-
Relatively few inflammatory and nerve problems were oped rotator cuff difficulties. Strains were left-sided in two
seen (only three patients in each category, and no more than cases, right-sided in one, and bilateral in two. Two of the four
one with any specific diagnosis), and only two musicians had nerve entrapments were CTS. Two flutists also were diag-
hypermobility syndrome. There was no significant age differ- nosed as having hypermobility syndrome. No difference in
ential in the prevalence of either strain or inflammatory diag- prevalence by age was noted in this subset, regarding the
noses in this subset. major diagnostic groups.
These patients had an age range from 12 to 77 years; 83.3% This cohort includes all players of single and double reed
were males. One bass guitarist was included, based on the sim- instruments, as well as recorder; all these instruments have