Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Contents
Section 1: Executive summary...............................................................................................................1
Section 4: Contacts...............................................................................................................................21
1
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 1
section
Executive summary
The COVID-19 crisis is As the impacts of COVID-19 continue to offset the downturn in economic
unfold and the crisis progresses, lessons activity and to stabilize market
an unprecedented global can be learned from the events of 9/11, confidence. In the US, this has led
pandemic event, which the global financial crisis of 2008–09 to financial institutions preparing
has had dramatic impact and several recent natural disasters. to manage their business in a low
However, there is no precedent for the and potentially negative interest
on daily lives and the international nature and widespread rate environment, which had been
broader economy. In effect on the global economy and prevalent in other economies prior to
the global markets, the the financial sector, specifically. The the pandemic.
functioning of the investment banking
pandemic has brought (IB) divisions of financial institutions
Market volatility, volume spikes and
demand for services alone would
significant dislocation with has also been significantly disrupted
be challenging for IBs to navigate.
volatility and spikes in with the displacement of staff to a
The introduction of remote work
work-from-home environment, driving
trading volumes, creating significant operating, cultural and
has complicated the environment
further. Most firms have the vast
challenges in the primary, business challenges.
majority of IB staff working from
secondary, funding and The economic environment has home, including, notably, substantial
derivatives markets. severely impacted clients of the IBs. portions of their sales and trading
Corporate clients have faced significant front-office workforce. With what has
revenue and cost challenges, requiring been essentially an overnight and a
access to credit lines to maximize prolonged shift to work from home
cash on hand, and reduced capital (WFH), IBs have faced challenges
expenditure. Institutional investors also in provisioning equipment at scale,
have been affected by large surges in supervising remote staff, enabling
redemptions and falling asset values. collaboration and establishing
National governments have introduced business as usual (BAU) in this
fiscal and monetary stimulus to extraordinary environment.
1
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 2
It should be acknowledged that IBs and the 5. Data enabled risk management: enhance
section broader market infrastructure (including financial financial and nonfinancial risk management
market utilities and third-party infrastructure with a focus on data enablement and real-time
providers) have demonstrated an impressive level monitoring of risk and exposure leveraging
of resiliency to date through the pandemic. The artificial intelligence (AI) to augment supervision
markets, overall, remain liquid, albeit volatile with and surveillance capabilities.
significant value fluctuations, and operational
6. Operations digital transformation: scale
processes have experienced a significant increase
operational functions through technology and
in volumes during this unprecedented time.
innovation, digital workflows and addressing
However, the pandemic has exposed certain
underlying root causes of inefficiency, considering
vulnerabilities and opportunities, which need
the end-to-end client management, process and
to be addressed to enable greater resiliency,
data journey.
sustainability and efficiency for the IB.
7. Enhanced elasticity of IT infrastructure:
With outlooks suggesting a prolonged impact to
implement flexible and secure technology
the markets and to daily life, the IB processes,
infrastructure that enables the digital and data
client proposition, technology and business mix
strategy of the enterprise.
across the front-to-back value chain may look
very different as we come through the pandemic The leaders of IBs must strengthen their
and emerge into what will be a new normal. Key organizations’ capabilities and resiliency by
factors that will shape this new normal include: learning from the challenges highlighted during
the pandemic and by focusing on the underlying
1. Preparing a return to work strategy: develop
root causes. Many of the challenges are not
and communicate a clear return to work strategy
new but have been further exposed through
covering triggers, timelines and precautions to
the pandemic. This provides organizations with
limit community spread in the workplace. The
an opportunity to reset and reprioritize their
plan should identify immediate actions required to
legacy transformation agenda, refocusing and
maintain the sustainability of remote working.
accelerating the digital transformation strategies
2. The need for a proactive postmortem that many firms have in play already today, with
assessment: proactive qualitative and added benefits of delivering cost efficiency and
quantitative review and assessment of enhanced client experience.
performance through the crisis to identify
vulnerabilities in business performance, resiliency
and control.
section
Prior to addressing the Firms should develop a multistage and 3. Population density in the offices
staggered return strategy with clearly and on trading floors, and the ability
strategic needs of the IB identifiable milestones and triggers. to appropriately distance staff,
arising from the pandemic, These plans need to include substantial including clear guidance on in-person
the transition from employee communication and broad meetings, travel and foot traffic flow
stakeholder awareness. through the office
response to recovery and
For most firms, the primary return to 4. Personal comfort levels of
the return strategy are key
work trigger will be government and employees and their respective
considerations. Return health authorities slowly reopening the vulnerability to infection
questions are focused economy. However, with the expectation
5. Provision of health screening and
of maintaining social distancing in
on timeline, triggers and other preventive health measures
the medium term, it is likely be a slow
precautions to limit the (i.e., personal protective equipment,
return to the office. When assessing the
sanitary supplies and strategic
risk of a second wave scheduling of the return, the IB should
cleaning cycles)
consider:
pandemic. 6. Opportunities to enhance the
1. Function criticality, risk and remote
connectivity and experience for
resiliency across the front, middle
the remaining remote workforce to
and back office, including remote
ensure sustainability and resiliency
working productivity and performance
of such an operating model
considerations
7. Updating the client management
2. Sustainability of heightened control
strategy to include an increased
and supervision framework in the
focus on remote and digital events
remote environment
and entertainment, as well as
relevant entertainment policy
updates
2
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 4
“
For most firms, the primary
return to work trigger will
be government and health
authorities slowly reopening
the economy. However, with
the expectation of maintained
section social distancing in the
medium term, it is likely be a
01
slow return to the office.
section
02
8. Review impacts to current regulatory and
strategic initiatives, including deliverable
timelines and risks, to identify where to
request relief and/or prioritize investments in a
coordinated manner
section
The IB workforce across all Albeit with initial challenges, the 1. Enable a virtual and digital
infrastructure is now broadly in place workforce. Firms should review
functions is traditionally and employees are set up for remote the tools offered to their teams to
office based, particularly working. While still too early to broadly facilitate a more flexible and remote
as it relates to front office assess, it has been a more seamless workforce. Traders will need to be
experience to date than many expected. digitally enabled with virtual turrets,
sales and trading. The collaboration tools and more flexible
Some of the key challenges that firms
COVID-19 crisis has connectivity to systems, potentially
had to overcome include the provision
triggered a significant of technology hardware to enable
creating mobile application solutions
for core platforms. Front to back
displacement of the remote working (particularly for sales
processes will need to be increasingly
and trading staff), the need to record
workforce requiring the embedded into digital workflow tools
client conversations, and the ability to
vast majority of personnel appropriately supervise and engage the
to facilitate monitoring and virtual
handoffs. Firms should also review
across the industry to work workforce in a remote environment.
second order business continuity
remotely. There are several broader plans such as a localized power or
considerations impacting the ability to Wi-Fi outages impacting remote
sustainably work from home. While we workers.
do not advocate a full work from home
2. Supervision considerations.
setup as a standard across the IB, given
Firms need to risk assess which
the broadly positive experience to date
functions they are willing to allow to
there is a potential opportunity for
be facilitated remotely, any risks this
greater flexibility for remote working.
may create, and how remote workers
and processes can be effectively
supervised. This is especially
important for high frequency, low
latency and high volatility products
2
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 8
and platforms. Supervision broadly will need to There will be additional benefits for firms that can
become more data driven and AI enabled and demonstrate the ability to adapt to a more flexible
less reliant on physical proximity; this will also operating model and sustain effective operations
strengthen the IB’s broader control environment. with a more remote workforce. Added flexibility
potentially opens the career path to previously
3. Cultural considerations. Firms will need to
unavailable high-quality labor, a potential
ensure they provide opportunities for the flexible
reduction in occupancy needs in high-cost campus
workforce to foster a team environment and
locations, and added resiliency to the firm from
ensure the firm’s culture of high performance
a more flexible and dispersed workforce. Firms
and collaboration is maintained and fostered.
should consider how they can build an advantage
Engagement with the workforce throughout will
from providing more flexible work arrangements
section also be critical to build trust and ensure its voice
in a controlled manner.
is heard in adjusting to the new normal.
03
2
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 9
section
and grow relationships and have had the least The current environment presents an opportunity
disruption to their client relationships. Firms to look at how data and analytics can be used
can also use such data to dynamically allocate to target and automate client interactions and
resources to meet clients’ needs for credit and coverage, helping firms provide enhanced service
liquidity across businesses, strengthening their and potentially achieve objectives of enhanced
relationships. cross-selling and revenue growth.
04
management’s ability to measure sales trading venues growing in all asset classes and
performance; track interactions; and better geographies. The crisis has highlighted challenges
understand, drive and forecast performance. with high-touch channels, such as voice and
To achieve this, firms should upgrade their data, e-messaging, in high-volume and high-volatility
analytics and client relationship management markets. We expect these frictions to accelerate
(CRM) capabilities to analyze client commentary, the adoption and product expansion of electronic
financials, transaction data, pricing requests, trading mechanisms, presenting opportunities
market data and operational service insights. and challenges to the IB.
Client coverage and prioritization. Appointing a Electronic pricing and risk management. Firms
cross-asset-class account executive can assist in need to enhance their infrastructure to support
the prioritization of resource allocation and brings electronic trading in broader and more complex
the power of the firm to the client. Data should be asset classes (credit, securitized, etc), with a
leveraged to identify gaps in coverage, segment less observable market price, and larger notional
underperformance, cross-selling opportunities where firms limit e-trading size today. To be
and pricing assessment. Firms adopting a competitive in pricing and dynamically manage
client-centric, solution-oriented sales approach risk exposure, firms need to enhance their data
will succeed. management capabilities and leverage algorithms
to price real-time risk. Such capabilities need to
Virtual events and digital content. This can
be resilient to highly volatile and high-volume
enable client interactions from business, cultural
markets; several firms’ tools struggled with this
and social perspectives. It is important that
through the pandemic. However, electronification
firms look at how to meet these needs from
can commoditize markets with dealer-agnostic
clients at a time of isolation for most. Longer
execution and lower barriers to provide market
term, this may become a more cost-effective and
liquidity.
environmentally sustainable approach, although
firms should personalize the approach so as not Algorithmic trading. Enabling electronic
to overwhelm clients with content. execution opens a broader marketplace for
buy-side and institutional investors for algorithmic
Hosting virtual meetings, conferences and
trading solutions and introduces index and
road shows makes events accessible to a wider
exchange-traded fund products across broader
investor base and can deepen client relationships.
asset classes. This presents opportunities to
Providing commentary, market insight and
provide digital toolkits for market access and risk
speaker series with business and cultural leaders
management. Such toolkits can create significant
will provide insight and stimulation for clients and
client demand and enable platform businesses to
broader stakeholders. We have also seen firms
attract greater flow, capturing more market data
hosting virtual happy hours with clients to sustain
and creating a virtuous circle for firms with the
relationships.
2
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 11
04
offer portfolio construction, risk analytics,
cross-asset margin compression, market data
and data-driven insights via a digital platform
distribution strategy, enabling stickier and deeper
client relationships.
section
IBs have long focused The crisis has exposed inefficiencies and trading activities in a remote
across risk and control processes, and environment through a volatile
on effectively managing while some processes have performed market across asset classes.
financial and nonfinancial well, others have required tactical Challenges have ranged from how
risks, with responsibilities, adjustments to enable more effective sales and trading staff communicate
risk management and reporting. internally and externally to a lack
capabilities and controls of surveillance capabilities off the
As firms settle into the current model of
sitting across both the trading floor, as well as resource
primarily remote working, sustainability
first and second lines and comprehensiveness for managing
capacity constraints due to a spike
in surveillance alerts triggered by
of defense. existing and emerging risks are factors
extreme market volatility. Firms
that need to be considered. As various
have tactically implemented ad hoc
fluid events unfold in the coming
solutions to best replicate their
months, firms need to be working on
BAU processes and maintain their
go-forward planning and adapting
capabilities:
their stressed operating models and
capabilities. 1. Technology needs to be
deployed rapidly to surveil WFH
sales and trading staff, including
Supervision, surveillance trading activity, voice and written
and related control communications, and personal
environment account activity, by deploying
computer hardware, enhanced
For nonfinancial risk management, network access technology, hardwire
supervision and surveillance have been phone lines and cell phone recording
at the forefront, given the challenges software, as examples.
of monitoring and reporting sales
2
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 13
05
notification to applicable stakeholders.
ability to nimbly manage and monitor risk. The
Firms generally have achieved a high level of cross-business impact of the current market
resiliency and continuity through the crisis, environment makes the ability to aggregate
navigating the initial surge of disruption. Now risk exposures to manage the institution-wide
firms need to pivot their attention to enhancing activity at geographic, sector and product specific
systemic controls, including: concentrations critical to operate within firms’ risk
1. Sustainability of tactical controls. Firms appetite limits.
should look to enhance their supervision and Organizations have developed tactical off-cycle
control programs to ensure they are able to analytics to accurately measure intraday exposure
sustain the heightened supervision standards metrics where enterprise analytics could not
more systemically for the expected ongoing capture the near-real-time picture, as firms
remote activity; this is likely to include agile balanced speed with accuracy of information used
technology development. in decision-making. While useful, firms should
2. Digital enablement of surveillance and consider strengthening these tactical fixes into
insight capabilities to leverage advanced longer-term, strategic solutions.
technologies. It is now clear that leading firms
will look to incorporate best practice resiliency
Enabling real-time counterparty
into ongoing business in an agile operating
model for people process, technology and exposure monitoring
location strategies. Leading firms will use this Counterparty exposure and concentration
opportunity as a catalytic moment to accelerate monitoring for many firms’ counterparties exist
the incorporation of better data and analytics into across asset classes and lines of business or fall
their surveillance programs. This will allow new under the same parent counterparty tree. It is
insights into their people, their risks, client and critical to have an accurate firmwide picture of
service provider behavior, and the market overall. counterparty risk and assess the need to quickly
Firms may not be able to predict every future adjust their limits based on dynamic market
event or scenario but can embed deeper learning events. Monitoring real-time consumption of
and continuous insights into ongoing operations limits intraday and identifying concentration of
to mitigate emerging risks. exposures for counterparties is a critical gap in
capabilities for many.
“
IBs with fragmented technology
and data architecture have
struggled to consolidate a global
view of intraday and end-of-
day risk in this volatile period,
undermining management’s
section ability to nimbly manage and
monitor risk.
05
have been exposed through the pandemic, and Accelerated credit approvals. Credit officers
we expect to see firms revisit their strategic are challenged with supporting ad hoc processes
capability in this space. More specifically, for accelerated credit approvals amid incomplete
counterparty watch list and default management data, drawdown of existing lines and a market
protocols need to be refreshed and automated to environment that has negatively impacted overall
further enhance monitoring capabilities. counterparty stability, ratings and downgrade
triggers in certain industry sectors, particularly
Proactive loan portfolio reviews. Firms have
hospitality, entertainment and transportation.
recognized the need to be more proactive in
reviewing their current loan portfolios to identify Overall, the market volatility has resulted in
troubled credits, particularly for more vulnerable breaches of existing market concentration and
industries and segments, and begin mitigation counterparty limits and has put a heightened
activities earlier in the cycle. The challenge focus on the need for a more granular and
has been that many loan review and credit frequent market and counterparty risk monitoring
functions are not staffed at levels necessary framework, including intraday risk monitoring
to undertake these reviews at scale. Firms are capabilities.
exploring alternative and more innovative ways of
performing such reviews that may be leveraged
into these functions on a go-forward basis.
2
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 15
section
IB operations have Teams have struggled to clear • Data visualization and optimization
backlogs, match capacity with demand, tools can be implemented to close
demonstrated a high level effectively interface with clients and gaps in current operational risk
of resiliency during the provide accurate point-in-time views of and performance management
reporting.
COVID-19 pandemic, operational risk.
though not without issues, The challenges arising from the • The adoption of industry-wide
pandemic are symptoms of underlying interoperability solutions can
as significant market accelerate exception resolutions
issues in processes and technology
volatility and volume that firms have not prioritized, due to between firms.
spikes have challenged complexity, business case or perceived We believe that in response to
potential for success. This is most COVID-19, firms need to accelerate
operations groups.
prevalent in the gap between the efforts to strategically break the
scalability of front-office technology linear relationship between market
and the lack of scale of operational and processing volumes, moving
processes. from processing to managing, and
While firms must address challenges eliminating exceptions. We expect
strategically, there are several near- to see a focus on the following four
term solutions that could be rapidly areas as firms begin to address the
deployed to provide immediate relief strategic challenges highlighted by
and close capability gaps until strategic COVID-19.
solutions are available. 1. Access to real-time operational
• Low-code/no-code technology allows data. Few firms have a trusted,
firms to rapidly workflow enable real-time repository of operational
volume-sensitive processes to data (volumes, events, fails, breaks,
enhance the monitoring, control and etc.) to leverage for point-in-time
process handoffs.
2
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 16
risk management, performance analysis and common processes and technology tools to
regulatory compliance. This gap has created manage streetwide interactions. Client access
a challenge responding to the crisis, where to standardized processing data sets should
regulators and management expect a real-time dramatically reduce the resources aligned to
view of operating risk. exception management. Traditional utilities
and FinTech providers should be pushed to
Strategically, this gap limits the ability to
close capability gaps, with a goal of minimizing
accurately assess operational performance across
duplicative processes across organizations. Firms
the trade life cycle, understand needed changes
can develop deeper relationships and potentially
to client and desk behavior, and forecast and
partnerships to collaborate across the industry
measure the impacts of process and technology
ecosystem to maximize the potential for success
section change. Firms should focus on developing an
driving efficiency.
operational data strategy, investing in technology
and training their teams in the methods needed to 4. Focus on process optimization and
06
manage data as a strategic asset. digitization. With the three prior areas as a
baseline, firms will be much better positioned to
2. Acceleration of moves to common processes,
determine where investment is needed in process
shared services and agile operations. The
optimization and digitization. Better data will
pandemic has impacted the ability to leverage
lead to stronger outcomes in digitization efforts
a global resource pool, creating imbalances of
and drive the shift from work management
demand and capacity across operations. Product,
to work elimination. Common internal and
technology and regional silos are unable to flex as
external operating models allow for solutions to
needed to respond to challenges like COVID-19.
be developed once to satisfy the needs across
Previous efforts to develop shared services
different products, regulations, geographies and
have often resulted in common management
clients.
of different processes running on disparate
technology in different regions. These challenges are not fundamentally new, and
firms have been able to work through the recent
Firms can leverage a true shared service
capacity and processing challenges. What the
strategy to addresses these challenges. This
COVID-19 response has exposed is the inability
allows firms to address performance variability
for firms to be able to meet these challenges
holistically, leverage best-of-breed technology and
strategically. A paradigm shift will be required
process, and support continual load balancing.
to scale processes through technology to meet
Agile operating models can further increase
expectations of clients, business partners and
organizational flexibility by breaking down
regulators, and will be a priority as firms return to
barriers between processing, subject matter and
what will become the new normal.
change resources.
section
07
latest methodologies to maximize flexibility
and ease adoption with emerging technology
tools and micro-service design embedded in
the architectural principles of the organization.
With increased remote working expected to
become the norm, firms should review their
change management methodologies to further
enable agile change management and review
the development operations toolkits enabling
streamlined quality assurance and control over
the code development, testing and deployment.
section
A final word
With significant and long- Firms have shown an encouraging 5. Integrate front-to-back risk
level of resilience and continuity at a analytics and limit monitoring,
lasting impacts expected time of high volume, volatility, demand connected in real time to trading
for the IB, it is critical and emotional strain on employees. platforms
that firms learn from the There are, however, several lessons
6. Promote a flexible and secure
learned and strategic initiatives that
COVID-19 crisis. should be accelerated or initiated to
technology infrastructure to
sustainably support volume and
further enhance operational efficiency
remote working
and client experience and remediate
vulnerabilities that were exposed. IBs broadly have demonstrated
resiliency and played a key role
1. Support prolonged, sustainable
in sustaining an orderly market,
remote working on scale, providing
supporting the economy, and
greater location flexibility and process
ensuring market liquidity and
efficiency through digital enablement
business continuity. However,
2. Transform the client value they should use this as a learning
proposition and experience through experience to further enhance
digital solutions and a data driven their capabilities and address the
personalized approach challenges observed to enhance
further their own and the market’s
3. Enhance digital, data and analytics
resilience.
capability for commercial and risk
management benefits Firms should take two immediate
actions. First, firms need to develop
4. Augment supervision and
a detailed multistage and staggered
surveillance capabilities with data driven
cross-functional return to work
and AI-enabled solutions
strategy playbook. Second, firms
should initiate the execution of a
holistic and proactive postmortem
review, developing prioritized
3
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 20
remediation action plans. We expect both to form to direct strategic investment. IBs with focused
a central part of audit and horizontal supervisory digital transformation strategies upgrading their
reviews over the coming months. data, technology and front-to-back infrastructure
will be far more strongly positioned for growth
From a strategic perspective, it is imperative
and profitability in the new normal.
section that firms refine their transformation objectives
considering lessons learned to date through the
pandemic and also review their broader strategic
agenda. We expect the most proactive firms in
assessing their vulnerabilities to be best placed
4
How COVID-19 will accelerate the investment bank transformation 21
section
Contacts
Brian Boyle Mark Nichols
US Capital Markets Advisory Leader US Capital Markets Advisory
Ernst & Young LLP Ernst & Young LLP
brian.boyle@ey.com mark.nichols@ey.com
About EY
EY is a global leader in assurance, tax, transaction and advisory
services. The insights and quality services we deliver help build trust and
confidence in the capital markets and in economies the world over. We
develop outstanding leaders who team to deliver on our promises to all
of our stakeholders. In so doing, we play a critical role in building a better
working world for our people, for our clients and for our communities.
Ernst & Young LLP are two separate client-serving member firms of
Ernst & Young Global Limited operating in the UK and US respectively.
This material has been prepared for general informational purposes only and is not intended to
be relied upon as accounting, tax, or other professional advice. Please refer to your advisors for
specific advice.
ey.com